arxiv:astro-ph/ v4 7 Jul 2006

Transcription

1 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy rxiv:stro-ph/ v4 7 Jul 2006 G. V. Vereshchgin nd G. Yegorin ICRANet P.le dell Repubblic 10 I65100 Pescr Itly nd ICRA Dip. Fisic Univ. L Spienz P.le A. Moro 5 I00185 Rome Itly Abstrct. The formul for drk energy density derived by Gurzdyn nd Xue is the only formul which provides without free prmeter) vlue for drk energy density in remrkble greement with current cosmologicl dtsets unlike numerous phenomenologicl scenrios where the corresponding vlue is postulted. This formul suggests the possibility of vrition of physicl constnts such s the speed of light nd the grvittionl constnt. Considering severl cosmologicl models bsed on tht formul nd deriving the cosmologicl equtions for ech cse we show tht in ll models source terms pper in the continuity eqution. So on the one hnd GX models mke up rich set covering lot of currently proposed models of drk energy on the other hnd they revel hidden symmetries with prticulr role of the seprtrix Ω m = 2/3 nd link with the issue of the content of physicl constnts. PACS numbers: 98.80Cq 06.20fn e-mil ddress: veresh@icr.it e-mil ddress: geghm@icr.it

2 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 2 1. Introduction With the estblishment of observtionl evidence fvoring drk energy domintion in the recent history of the cosmologicl expnsion numerous different models were suggested to ccount for it. For most of them the vlue of the corresponding density prmeter is chosen to fit the observtionl one. In contrst Gurzdyn nd Xue formul [1] for drk energy predicts the observed vlue for the density prmeter of the drk energy. The formul reds [1 2] ρ GX = π 8 hc L 2 p 1 2 = π 8 c 4 G 1 2 1) where h is the Plnck constnt the Plnck length is L p = hg )1 2 c is the speed of c 3 light G is the grvittionl constnt is the scle fctor of the Universe. Following the originl ide by Zeldovich [3] it corresponds to the cosmologicl term Λ GX = 8πGρ GX = 8πG π c 4 ) 1 c 2 c 2 c 2 8 G = 2 π2. 2) Therefore to keep it constnt the speed of light should vry with cosmologicl expnsion s c. One cn consider other possibilities s well ssuming the presence of some fundmentl physicl quntity nd dmitting vrition of bsic physicl constnts [4] in the spirit of Dirc pproch. Since the Plnck constnt does not pper in 1) these cn be the grvittionl constnt nd the speed of light. In the literture there is long-stnding discussion how to understnd possible vribility of physicl constnts linking this point to the mening of world constnts nd units in physics [5]. Clerly experimentlly only dimensionless constnts vrition cn be detected but the mening nd the content of the underlying physicl theory chnges depending on the issue which dimensionful quntity vries. In fct models with vrying physicl constnts re mong the currently discussed ones e.g. [6]). However models bsed on the formul 1) re very different from vrious phenomenologicl models of drk energy phntoms etc. becuse of the underlying empiricl bsis nmely greement between predictions for drk energy density prmeter nd the vlue following from the rry of recent observtions. The clssifiction of vrious cosmologicl models following from GX-formul is given in [4]. Furthermore it is shown [7] tht GX models provide indeed good fit to supernove nd rdio glxies dt. These models contin hidden invrince the seprtrix dividing cosmologicl solutions into two clsses: singulr Friedmnnin-type nd non-singulr with vnishing initil density [7][8]. In this pper we provide cosmologicl equtions for the simplest cses discussed in [4] nd generlize them including rdition field nd compre them to the stndrd cosmologicl model. In the section 2 cosmologicl frmework with vrying physicl constnts is formulted. In the section 3 we derive cosmologicl equtions for prticulr cses discussed in [4]. We provide nlyticl solutions for energy density in ll models nd lso in some models for the scle fctor. Conclusions follow in the lst section.

3 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 3 2. Cosmologicl equtions with vrying constnts In this section we re going to derive cosmologicl equtions ssuming vrying constnts such s the speed of light ct) the grvittionl constnt Gt) nd the cosmologicl term Λt) depending on the cosmic time t. Einstein equtions re postulted to be vlid in such cse. We strt from the FRW intervl [ dr ds 2 = ct) 2 dt t) 1 kr + ] 2 r2 dθ 2 + sin 2 θdϕ 2) 3) where r θ ϕ re sptil coordintes is the scle fctor. Using Einstein equtions R µν 1 2 Rg µν Λ c 2g µν = 8πG c 4 T µν nd the energy-momentum tensor T µ ν = dig ǫ p p p) with ρ being the energy density p being the pressure we rrive t the cosmologicl equtions H 2 + kc2 Λ 2 3 = 8πG ρ 4) 3c2 Ḣ + H 2 Λ 3 = 4πG ċ ρ + 3p) + H 3c2 c 5) where k is the sign of sptil curvture H d ln/dt is the Hubble prmeter dot denotes time derivtive. From 4) nd 5) or from 8πG T µν c 4 ;ν = 0) continuity eqution cn be written ρ + 3H ρ + p) = ρ Λ + ρ + ρ Λ ) 4ċ c Ġ ) 6) G where hve we introduced ρ Λ = Λc 2 /8πG). The sme equtions were derived e.g. in [9]. The difference with [9] is tht we consider the scling 1) not s phenomenologicl but s n empiricl reltion. It is esy to check tht 4) is the first integrl of 5) s it is within stndrd Friedmnn cosmology. Cosmologicl equtions for the cse when c nd G both depend on time cn be found in [10]. For the cse when insted Λ nd G depend on time these equtions re given in [11]. Our equtions reduce to equtions of [10] nd [11] with the corresponding ssumptions. There is little difference with [10] becuse we postulted only invrince of the Einstein equtions while uthors of [10] ssumed tht both Einstein nd Friedmnn equtions re still vlid. With these ssumptions the lst term in 5) disppers nd our equtions looks identicl to those of [10]. Note tht the former energy conservtion does not hold ny more: there re sources nd drins of energy e.g. from drk energy to the usul mtter from the vrition of the speed of light nd the grvittionl field strength) in 6). As we will see in the next section 6) cn be integrted to obtin energy density s explicit function of the scle

4 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 4 fctor. Further for some models Friedmnn eqution 4) cn be explicitly integrted to get the scle fctor s function of time. In [4] five different cses hve been discussed nmely: i) c=const G=const Λ const; ii) c G=const Λ =const; iii) c=const G 2 ρ Λ /c 2 =const Λ const cse 3.1); iv) c 1/2 G=const ρ Λ =const Λ const cse 4.2); v) c const G const Λ const. In wht follows we nlyze ech of the first four cses provide cosmologicl equtions nd corresponding solutions for them. 3. Cosmologicl models bsed on Gurzdyn-Xue formul In this section we present cosmologicl equtions for ech of the cses i-iv) nd discuss the corresponding cosmologicl scenrios providing nlyticl solutions where possible Models with drk energy nd pressureless mtter In this subsection we put the pressure in 5) nd 6) to zero nd introduce mss density µ = ρ/c 2. Ech solution cn be prmetrized by the usul mtter density Ω m µ 0 8πG 0 µ 0 7) µ c 3H 2 0 where µ c is the criticl density in usul Friedmnnin models subscript 0 denotes the vlue of ech quntity tody. In wht follows to define density prmeters we use normliztion condition Ω i = 1 8) i where i numbers components such s drk energy rdition usul mtter. In order to get density s function of the scle fctor we rewrite 6) s dµ d + 3µ = R 1 4πG dc dg 8πGµ + Λ) µ cd Gd 1 dλ 8πG d. 9) The crucil feture of these models is the presence of seprtrix in solutions for the density s function of the scle fctor see [7] nd [8]). This seprtrix divides solutions in two clsses: the one with Friedmnnin singulrity nd the one with vnishing density nd non-zero scle fctor in the beginning.

5 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 5 To see the difference from our models nd the corresponding Friedmnnin ones we compute for ech cse mss trnsfer rte nmely the rtio between R of 9) nd expnsion term 3µ/ i.e. M R 3µ. 10) If dimensionless M vnishes it mens the usul Friedmnnin solution µ 3 holds. When M = 1 mss trnsfer cncels the effect of expnsion nd the mss density does not chnge in course of expnsion. If it is lrge effect of expnsion cn be neglected. Model 1 vrying cosmologicl constnt). Neither the speed of light nor the grvittionl constnt vry with time but in this cse from 2) we find Λ 2. Cosmologicl equtions re H 2 + k c 2 2 = 8πG 3 µ µ + 3Hµ = π 4G c ) 2 H where k = k π2 3. It is cler tht k < 0 i.e. the effect of Λ vrition is to mke sptil geometry negtively curved even if the originl sign of k is +. The source term in the continuity eqution cn be interpreted s the energy trnsfer from the drk energy component into the mtter component see [11] nd references therein). Solution for the density is given by ) 0 3 π µ) = µ 0 + 4G c nd fter substitution of this solution to 4) we obtin where ±A t = A 1 A 1 + B 1 ) ) 11) 0 A 1 0 A 1 + B 1 )+ +B 1 log A 1 = c 2 π 2 k) B 1 = 2π 3 04Gµ πc 2 ). 0 A A 1 + B 1 A1 + A 1 + B 1 ) This solution reduces to simple form for seprtrix vlue with the condition B 1 = 0 nmely = 0 + A 1 t. 13) The seprtrix solution is given by the density prmeter Ω m 2/3 nd depends slightly on the sptil curvture. For high vlues of the density prmeter solutions prcticlly coincide with the corresponding Friedmnnin ones. In such cse one cn neglect the source term in the continuity eqution. This lso cn be done for lrge scle fctors since solutions pproch the seprtrix where they describe Friedmnn Universe with negtive curvture. 12)

6 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 6 The present scle fctor is well defined quntity even for k = 0 models 0 = k ) 1 c ) H 0 1 Ωm since this is the model with effective negtive curvture with Ω k = k c 2. With this 2 0 H2 0 definition 8) is stisfied long with with 7). Mss trnsfer rte 10) for this model in terms of density prmeter is given by ) M = 2π k Ω m nd it is cler tht M gets infinite with Ω m 0 i.e. vcuum mss trnsfer domintes expnsion nd in the opposite cse the model pproches Friedmnnin mtter dominted one with negtive curvture. Model 2 vrying speed of light). To keep interprettion of Λ s cosmologicl constnt we hve to require the vrying speed of light c = Λ π 2 ) 1/2. At the sme time the grvittionl constnt does not chnge G=const. Cosmologicl equtions reduce to the following system H 2 Λ 3 = 8πG 3 µ µ + 3Hµ = 3H 4πG H 2 + kλ π 2 ) = 3Hµ 1 + Λ ) 8πGµ where Λ = Λ ) 1 3k π. The source in the continuity eqution now comes from the 2 speed of light vribility. There is complete nlyticl solution for this model 0 µ) = µ 0 + Λ 1 ) 0 15) 4πG where t) = A 2 2B 2 + A B 2 2B 2 cosh t B 2 ) ± A 2 = πGµ 0 Λ) B 2 = Λ 1 kπ 2 ) 0 B 2 A B 2 ) sinh t B 2 ). In this model the seprtrix is given by Ω m = 2/3 independent on the curvture. If one neglects the source in the continuity eqution tht is gin possible for lrge or lrge Ω m ) which consists of two terms proportionl to H 3 nd HΛ respectively we come to the usul Friedmnn-Lemître cosmology with the cosmologicl constnt Λ. The density prmeter for Λ term is Ω Λ = Λ 3H k π 2 nd the scle fctor tody is rbitrry quntity in this model. ) Note tht the cosmologicl constnt ppers nturlly within McCre-Milne pproch [12].

7 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 7 Mss trnsfer rte 10) is simply M = 1 Ω m so it precisely cncels expnsion with Ω m 1. Model 3 vrying grvittionl constnt). We introduce the fundmentl constnt µ GX = Λ =const the density of the vcuum. In this cse the grvittionl 8πG ) constnt chnges G = π c 2 8µ GX while the speed of light does not. The cosmologicl term lso cquires dependence on the scle fctor through G nd is given by 2). Cosmologicl equtions re H 2 + kc2 = π2 c ) µ ) 16) µ GX µ + 3Hµ = 2Hµ 1 + µ ) GX µ These re very different from the usul Friedmnn equtions. Even if could neglect the source terms in the continuity eqution tht obviously cnnot be done) the first cosmologicl eqution does not correspond to the first Friedmnn one. However phse portrit of solutions for this model on the plne {µ } looks similr to the one of model 2 [8]. Agin there is solution for density 0 µ = µ 0 + 2µ GX 1 ) 0. Notice similrity with 15). This is due to the fct tht Λ is constnt in the model 2 while µ GX is constnt in the model 3 so the dependence of mtter density on the scle fctor is the sme lthough the dependence of drk energy on the scle fctor is different. Solution for the scle fctor looks insted exctly the sme s the solution for model 1 12) with A 3 = A 1 B 3 = π2 3µ GX c 2 0 µ 0 2µ GX ). The seprtrix is the sme s in model 1 given by B 3 = 0. Mtter density prmeter for this model is Ω m = π2 3 c 2 H µ µ GX tht is the sme s 7). The scle fctor tody is the sme s in model 1 nd is given by 14) s this expression follows from the definition of density prmeter for curvture which is the sme s in model 1. Another equivlent expression follows from definitions of vcuum mss density nd criticl density nd it gives 2 0 = πc2 8G 0 µ GX.

8 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 8 Mss trnsfer rte 10) for this model is M = 2 3Ω m tht is nlogous to the model 2 but with Ω m 1 it corresponds to constnt frction of expnsion rte. Model 4 vrying speed of light constnt vcuum energy density). The constnt vcuum energy density is introduced s ρ GX = Λc2 =const requiring vrition 8πG of the speed of light c = ) 8Gρ 1/4 GX 1/2. Here G=const nd Λ = 2 2π 3/2 Gρ GX 1 = 3β 1 3k π 2 ) π where the constnt β ppers in the cosmologicl equtions H 2 = 8πG 3 µ + β 17) µ + 3Hµ = 3H H 2 + β π 2 ) + 3k 8πG π 2 3k with β = 2 2π 3/2 Gρ 3 GX ) 1/2 ) 1 3k π. 2 The source term in the continuity eqution cn be neglected for lrge but the first Friedmnn eqution contins the positive 1 term which is gin very different from the stndrd cosmology. There is complete solution for this model with nd where µ = µ 0 0 ) πρgx 2G 1 0 = 0 ± t A B 4 + B 4 4 t2 A 4 = 8πG 3 0 µ 0 0 πρgx 2G ) ) 2GρGX B 4 = 2 π 2 k). π This solution reduces to 13) for B 4 = 0 or in other words when Ω m 1. The seprtrix is given by Ω m = 2/3 like in model 2. Here new density prmeter for drk energy is defined s Ω β = β H nd the scle fctor vlue tody follows from this definition 0 = c 0 π H 0 31 Ω m ). Notice tht it is different from the scle fctor in models 1 nd 3 by the fctor 1 3k/π 2. Mss trnsfer rte 10) for this model is given by M = 1 3Ω m k π 2 ) 1 Ω m 1 )

9 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 9 from which we find tht with Ω m 0 the vccum gin domintes expnsion while in the opposite cse this is just constnt frction of expnsion rte. Therefore it cnnot be reduced to the usul Friedmnnin model. Finlly in the cse 5 of [4] cosmologicl equtions re given by the system 4)-6). Definitions 7) nd 8) cn be used in this generl cse s well Models with drk energy dust nd rdition So fr we considered cosmologicl models bsed in GX formul 1) contining only dust nd drk energy. In this subsection we turn to more generl clss of models including into considertion rdition. It is known e.g. [9]) tht there is mbiguity in definition of multicomponent models with drk energy nd/or vrition of constnts. There exist strong bounds on coupling between drk energy nd rdition [13][14] so we void this mbiguity ssuming decoupled rdition nmely ρ r = ρ r0 0 ) 4 pr = ρ r 3 18) where the subscript r refers to rdition. In stndrd cosmology ny reltivistic prticle in thermodynmic equilibrium cn be described by these equtions. However vrying speed of light implies vrition of dispersion reltion ǫ 2 = Πc 2 + m 0 c 4 where ǫ nd Π re prticle s energy nd momentum nd m 0 is its rest mss hence influences eqution of stte for ultrreltivistic fluid. In this pper we constrin ourselves with the cse of therml photons only. Rdition density prmeter in wht follows is defined by Ω r = 8πG 0 ρ 3H0c 2 2 r0. 19) 0 Then totl energy conservtion 6) implies dµ d + 3µ = Λ 2 dc 8πG cd dλ ) + [ Λd + µ + ρ ) ] r0 4 4 dc c 2 0 cd dg ) Gd 2µ dc cd. 20) It is cler from 20) tht in generl mtter couples to rdition lwys except for the cse c = G=const. In this section we provide solutions for the set of cosmologicl models described by 4)5)18) nd 20). Generlly speking these models do not reduce to the ones considered bove becuse of specil role of rdition given by 18). Model 1 with rdition. This is the unique cse when the rdition does not couple to mtter density becuse neither speed of light nor the grvittionl constnt vry.

10 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 10 Cosmologicl equtions for this model red H 2 + k c 2 = 8πG µ + ρ ) r0 4 21) 2 3 c 0) 2 µ + 3Hµ = π ) c 2 H 4G Solution for the mtter density is the sme 11) s it is in the bsence of rdition. Additionl peculirity of this cse is the presence of seprtrix plying the sme role s for models without rdition. The seprtrix is defined by Ω m = 2 1 Ω r 3 1 k π 2 tht gin gives Ω m 2/3 for ny curvture prmeter. Implicit solution for the scle fctor s function of cosmic time is t t 0 = 1 ) F) F 0 ) Ã1 log Ã1 + 2Ã2 + 2 Ã1 F) à 2 2Ã3 2 2 à à Ã1 F 0 ) where nd Fx) = Ã0 + Ã1x + Ã2x 2 à 0 = 8πG 3c ρ r à 1 = 8πG ) 3 0 µ πc2 4G à 2 = π 2 k ) c 2. The solution for seprtrix is explicit nd looks rther simple = c π2 k 1 + 2H 0 t + 1 Ω r )H H 0 1 Ω 0t 2 2. r This solution pproches 13) t lte times. Solution for density is represented t fig. 1) for selected vlues of Ω m. Like in models without rdition solutions with Ω m > 2/3 rech Friedmnnin singulrity in the pst while solutions with Ω m < 2/3 strt with vnishing density. Both density prmeter nd criticl density re defined by 7). Rdition density prmeter is s usul 19). Curvture density prmeters remins the sme s in model without rdition nd the scle fctor becomes little bigger due to the chnge 1 Ωm 1 Ω m Ω r in 14). Model 2 with rdition. Since the speed of light vries in this model mtter becomes coupled to rdition nd solution gets complicted.

11 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy Μ Μ c Figure 1. Density of mtter in model 1 in terms of criticl density depending on the scle fctor in terms of present scle fctor with Ω m equl to 0.3 firm curve) thick curve) nd dotted curve). Cosmologicl equtions for this model re H 2 Λ 3 = 8πG µ + π2 3 Λ ρ 4 ) 0 r0 22) 6 µ + H µ Λ ) = 4π2 ρ r0 4 0 H 4πG Λ 6. Hence the solution for the density is µ) = 1 [ ) )] Λ 4πG 0) + µ π2 5 ρ r0 1. 5Λ 0 0 This model does not possess seprtrix in the sense discussed bove becuse the erly expnsion is dominted by the negtive definite term since the vcuum energy is positive definite). The solution for mtter density in this model is represented t fig. 2). Although there is no seprtrix with respect to initil singulrity the vlue Ω m = 2/3 gin plys importnt role dividing solutions in two clsses depending on the sign of time derivtive of the density: for Ω m > 2/3 the density decreses with time in mtter dominted epoch like in Friedmnnin models while for Ω m < 2/3 the density increses with time. This behvior is seen from eqution for the density since the condition Λ = 4πGµ leds to Ω m = 2/3. In contrst to simple GX model without rdition the scle fctor is no more rbitrry in this model nd is given by 14) with the chnge 1 Ω m 1 Ω m Ω r.

12 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy Μ 1 Μ c Figure 2. Density of mtter in model 2. Ω m equls to 0.3 firm curve) thick curve) nd dotted curve). Rdition density prmeter is ρ r0 Ω r = π2 Λ µ c 2 0 nd it coincides with 19). Model 3 with rdition. Cosmologicl equtions now reduce to [ H 2 + kc2 = 2π2 c ) 1 µ + ρ ) )] r0 4 23) µ GX c 2 0 µ + Hµ 2µ GX ) = 2H ρ r0 c 2 Solution for density in this model is 0 ) 4 µ) = 2µ GX + 0 µ 0 2µ GX ) + 2 ρ r0 0 3 c 2 1 ) ) 0 3 nd its dependence on the scle fctor is similr to the one shown t fig. 2). This is becuse gin with negligible contribution of rdition the time derivtive of the density is determined by the condition µ = 2µ GX which leds to the sme density prmeter Ω m = 2/3. The scle fctor is the sme s in the model 2 bove. Rdition density prmeter is ρ r0 Ω r = π2 3 µ GX 2 0H0 2 nd it coincides with 19) due to definition of µ GX.

13 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 13 Model 4 with rdition. For this cse cosmologicl equtions red H 2 = 8πG µ + 1 ) ) π 4 ρ r0 + β 3 8Gρ GX 0 24) µ + 2Hµ = H πρgx 1 + ρ ) ) r0 4 2G ρ GX 0 The solution for model 4 is ) 0 2 πρgx µ) = µ 0 + 2G nd it is represented t fig. 3). Μ Μ c ) + ρ r0 0 π Gρ GX 2 ) ) Figure 3. Density of mtter in model 4. Ω m equls to 0.3 firm curve) thick curve) nd dotted curve). There is no specil vlue of density prmeter in model 4. Solutions strt with zero density nd positive scle fctor then the density increses rpidly in rdition dominted stge but entering into mtter dominted stge it strts to decrese so for ech solution there is mximum in the density see fig. 3)). Here the density prmeter of rdition is defined by Ω r = 16π3/2 3H G ρ GX ρ r0 nd it is gin equivlent to 19).

14 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy Discussion nd conclusions In this pper we explored vrious cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy formul 1) ssuming lso vrition of physicl constnts such s the speed of light nd the grvittionl constnt. It is shown tht unlike stndrd Friedmnn models vrious interesting possibilities pper. In prticulr in the model 1 the continuity eqution is reduced to the energy trnsfer from drk energy component into the usul mtter. For some cses models 1 nd 4) the source term in the continuity eqution cn be neglected for sufficiently lrge scle fctors or sufficiently lrge present density of mtter) nd the discussion of the dynmics in this symptotic cses cn be given in terms of the stndrd cosmology. Solutions for the density in terms of the scle fctor for ll models with pressureless mtter nd drk energy contin seprtrix which divides solutions in two clsses. The first clss is nlogous to the stndrd Friedmnn solutions with singulrity in the beginning of expnsion. The second clss in contrst does not contin singulrity; solutions strt with vnishing density nd non-zero scle fctor. We lso considered generliztion of GX models including rdition ssuming tht dynmics of the ltter is not influenced by the vrition of constnts nd by drk energy. Interestingly for the model 1 we obtined the behvior qulittively similr to models without rdition. For the rest of models seprtrix in the sense discussed bove is bsent nd ll solutions belong to the second clss nmely non-friedmnnin solutions. The density in these solutions my be lrger in the pst but if so it hs mximum nd ll solutions strt with vnishing density in rdition-dominted epoch. However for models 2 nd 3 with rdition the sme vlue of density prmeter Ω m = 2/3 tht prmetrizes seprtrix in simple GX models corresponds to constnt mss density of pressureless mtter in mtter dominted epoch. For lrger density prmeter the mss density decreses with expnsion nd for smller density prmeter it increses. In fct not ll GX models with non-friedmnnin behvior Ω m < 2/3) pss ge constrint nd hve decelertion prmeter which fits the vlue followed from observtions. At the sme time model IV with Ω m 2/3 pss both constrints nd represent good cndidte for drk energy model [7] which in the limit of vnishing energy trnsfer from drk energy to the usul mtter hs 1 term in Friedmnn eqution. In the sme wy models I nd III fit these constrints for density prmeter slightly smller thn the seprtrix vlue. This circumstnce once more points out on specil role of the seprtrix in GX models. Notice nother interesting feture of GX models with rdition. It is well known tht Friedmnnin models with zero curvture hve rbitrry scle fctor. The sme holds lso for simple GX models model 2). However this degenercy breks down in GX models with rdition where the scle fctor cn lwys be computed in terms of present density prmeters nd present vlues of vrying) physicl constnts. We re thnkful to the referees for helpful comments.

15 Cosmologicl models with Gurzdyn-Xue drk energy 15 References [1] V. G. Gurzdyn S.-S. Xue in: From Integrble Models to Guge Theories; volume in honor of Sergei Mtinyn ed. V. G. Gurzdyn A. G. Sedrkin p.177 World Scientific 2002;Mod. Phys. Lett. A ) 561 [stro-ph/ ] [2] V. G. Gurzdyn S.-S. Xue stro-ph/ [3] Y. B. Zeldovich JETP Lett ) 883; Sov. Phys. - Uspekhi ) 209. [4] G.V. Vereshchgin Mod. Phys. Lett. A ) 729. [5] M. Duff L.B. Okun nd G. Venezino JHEP ) 023. [6] J. Mgueijo Rept.Prog.Phys ) 2025; J.D. Brrow D. Kimberly nd J. Mgueijo Clss.Qunt.Grv ) [7] G.V. Vereshchgin G. Yegorin stro-ph/ submitted for publiction to Phys. Lett. B. [8] G.V. Vereshchgin G. Yegorin Phys. Lett. B ) 150. [9] T. Hrko nd M. K. Mk Clss. Quntum Grv ) [10] A. Albrecht J. Mgueijo Phys.Rev. D ) [11] I.L. Shpiro J. Solà nd H. Štefnčić JCAP ) 012. [12] V.G. Gurzdyn The Observtory ) 42. [13] R. Opher A. Pelinson Phys. Rev. D ) [14] R. Opher A. Pelinson MNRAS ) 167.