Florida State University Libraries

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Florida State University Libraries"

Godfrey Bell
6 years ago
Views:

Phenomenological Approach Megan Fogle Follow this and additional works

1 Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2009 Understanding Electronic Music: A Phenomenological Approach Megan Fogle Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact lib-ir@fsu.edu

2 "#$%&'()*(*+,-&.+%)&*/ 0$##+1+$"2,)&0,-'+%)*(-'&-1+#+0*%$-&02,)&03(45+-$2+-$#$1&0(# (44%$( (-"$1#+ '>H<>;>G4D8E>9>ID7 ':F;::(K=;C:C3 )I;8?F):B:9<:;LMNNO

3 *D:B:BA:;9>G<D:0>BB8<<::=II;>P:<D:'899:;<=<8>?>G2:F=?">FE:>?2=;HDQRL MNNOS TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT +P=?U>?:9 4;>G:99>;'8;:H<8?F'899:;<=<8>? TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT U=?:48I:;0E:?C8??8?F 0>BB8<<::2:BA:; TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT 2=;VW8?F=<: 0>BB8<<::2:BA:; 88

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` RZZ 68AE8>F;=ID7 R[R 68>F;=ID8H=E)V:<HD R[Z 888

5 8P #&)*$"*(6#+) ZY ZO

6 #&)*$""&1,%+) :`H:;I<_>I:?8?F>Ga5:;.>8H:b [Q QSM#89<:?8?F9H>;:G>;7/&(#8'$3,'9".83(#8'"#5':;15,#:`H:;I< [[ QSQ#89<:?8?F9H>;:G>;<=,/(+"#'2/(*$&+3:`H:;I< YN YZ YY QS[#89<:?8?F9H>;:G>;23,'4(15'-.11:`H:;I< ON OY RNQ RRR RMR XSZ#89<:?8?F9H>;:G>;*;:P>;W89D=;<c9<=,/(+"#'2/(*$&+3 RQQ XS[#89<:?8?F9H>;:G>;%8HD=;C':P8?:c92,$/"5 RXZ P

7 (6)*%(0* @?C:;9<=?CD>K:E:H<;>?8HI8:H:9aK>;VSb*D89C899:;<=<8>?I;:9:?<9=ID:?>B:?>E>F8H=E I;8?H8IE:9S';=K8?F>?=ID:?>B:?>E>F8H=E=II;>=HD89P8=AE:G>;<D:=?=E7989>G H=9:K8<D<;=C8<8>?=EE7?><=<:CK>;V9S*D89=II;>=HD=8B9<>C:H8ID:;D>K9>?8H:P:?<9 D89<>;7>G<D:F:?;:L=?=E7<8H=EH>?98C:;=<8>?>G:E:H<;>?8HK>;V9L=?C=?=E79:9<D=< 8?H>;I>;=<:=ID:?>B:?>E>F8H=E=II;>=HDS*D:9:H>?CHD=I<:;C:9H;8A:9<D:H>?H:I<>G ID:?>B:?>E>F7=?C:`IE=8?9D>K<D:E89<:?:;H=?8?H>;I>;=<:<D89<7I:>G=?=E7<8H=E 8?<><K>B=8?H=<:F>;8:9_:P:?<9<D=<8?H>;I>;=<:<D:=9I:H<>G=.%(D.,'+;#+/E$,L P8

8 &-*%$',0*&$ =?CK=9?><<:HD?>E>F8H=EE7=P=8E=AE:<><D:H>BI>9:;98?H:>P:;<D:I=9<98`<77:=;9>; R

9 =?=E7989A;:=VC>K?KD:?=?=<<:BI<89B=C:<>=IIE7<D:B<>=<>?=E=?C:E:H<;>?8H R G>;8?9<=?H:S*D:=?=E79<K>@EC@9:<K:EP:e<>?:=?=E7989<>=?=E7d:<D:B@98H>G H>BI>98<8>?H>@EC8?P>V:=EE<D:=?=E7<8H=EI;>H:C@;:9<D:7V?>K>;D=P:E:=;?:CLA@< :E:H<;>?8HB@98HL6;@?>6>99899<=<:93 C:P89:CS)@HD=B:<D>C>E>F7K>@ECE:=C<>=B>;:I;:H89:P898>?>G<D89H>;I@9 I;>I>98<8>?9LA@<=H:;<=8??@BA:;>G9I:H8G8H8<8:9D=P:D8?C:;:C<D89;:9:=;HDS M *D:D8?C;=?H:9<D=<6>9989E89<9=;:a<D:=A9:?H:>G=I:;H:8P:C8?9<;@B:?<=E<7I>E>F7b i8s:s=?8bb:?9:9>@?ci=e:<<:8?kd8hd<d:9>@;h:>g=9>@?cb=7a:@?v?>k?j=?ca<d: I;>AE:B>G;:I;:9:?<=<8>?bi8S:S?><=<8>?jS Q "@;<D:;B>;:LF8P:?<D:P=;8:<7>G9>?8H=?C 97?<=H<8H>I<8>?9=P=8E=AE:<><D:H>BI>9:;98?<D:<K:?<8:<DH:?<@;7L8<B=7?><A: >AP8>@9KD:<D:;>;?><<>=IIE78?D:;8<:C=?=E7<8H=EB:<D>C>E>F8:9<>:E:H<;>?8HB@98HS )>B:=?=E79:9>G9<=?C=;C;:I:;<>8;:G>H@9>?<D:I=;=B:<:;>GI8<HD?:=;E7<><D: :`HE@98>?>G=EE><D:;B@98H=EI=;=B:<:;9S(9>?:B8FD<9@9I:H<LH>?H:?<;=<8>?>?I8<HD R #=K;:?H:":;;=;=La4D:?>B:?>E>F7=9=*>>EG>;2@98H=E(?=E7989Lb23,'H.%(+"1'I."/$,/1&YNkQ i)@bb:;lro]xj3qz]s&?<d89=;<8he:":;;=;=9i:h8g8h=ee7=cc;:99:9=id:?>b:?>e>f8h=ei:;h:i<8>?>g.=;g9:c9?;e=,'f1,+$/;#(d.,s M 6;@?>6>9989La*D:(?=E7989>G+E:H<;>=H>@9<8H2@98H3G;>B)>@;H:9<>&?P=;8=?<9LbJ/8"#(%,5');.#56' <#'K#$,/#"$(;#"1'L;./#"1';0'H.%(+'2,+3#;1;8&RRkMiMNN[j3RNQS Q (@(5MLRNQS M

10 K8<D8?<D:K>;VS(9*;:P>;W89D=;<?><:93 X (9=;:9@E<L<D:F:?;:>G:E:H<;>?8HB@98H=EE>K9<8BA;:=?C<D:@9:>G%;#(+',N,#$%<>?>K<=V:I;8>;8<7>P:;I8<HDS(9>?8H:P:?<89a=?79>@?C>;9>@?CeH>?G8F@;=<8>?KD8HD89 I:;H:8P:C=9=I;8B=;7B@98H=E@?8<m=98?F@E=;=@;=EF:9<=E<Sb Z ':H8ID:;8?F=?C 8C:?<8G78?F<D:9>?8H:P:?<9K8<D8?=H>BI>98<8>?=EE>K9<D:E89<:?:;<>H=<=E>F=?C C:<:;B8?:<D:9<;@H<@;=E;:E=<8>?9D8I>G<D:B@98H=EB=<:;8=E8?<D:B@98HS W8<D=?7?:KF:?;:>GB@98HH>B:9<D:8?D:;8<:C899@:>G@?C:;9<=?C8?F=?:K B@98H=EE=?F@=F:S$?:@9:G@EI;:H:C:?<89I;>P8C:CA7<D:K;8<8?F9>GU=B:9*:??:7S589 H,$"'nO;5;%9I:H8G8H=EE7=8B9<>HD=EE:?F:>@;K=7>G<D8?V8?F=A>@<=?CE89<:?8?F<> <K:?<8:<DeH:?<@;7B@98H8?F:?:;=ES*:??:79<=<:93 *D:8?H;:=9:C=@;=EH>BIE:`8<7>GB@HD>G<D:B@98H>G<D:<K:?<8:<DeH:?<@;789 9@HD=?:P8C:?<HD=;=H<:;89<8H<D=<8<9D>@EC?::C?>C:B>?9<;=<8>?S-:P:;<D:E:99L =?:`=B8?=<8>?>G<D:B=?7G=H<>;9KD8HDI;>C@H:<D89H>BIE:`8<7L=?C9>B:>G 8<9:GG:H<98?>@;I:;H:I<8>?>G<D:B@98HLK8EEA:?:H:99=;7A:G>;:K:H=?D>I:<> C:9H;8A:<D:B@98H=EB=<:;8=E98?=;:=EE7B:=?8?FG@EK=7S*D:H>BIE:`8<789?>< B:;:E7>G9<;@H<@;:LA@<=E9>>G%.@%$"#+,S*D=<89L8<89?><98BIE7<D:;:9@E<>G=?:K=;;=?F:B:?<>G<;=C8<8>?=EB=<:;8=E9>;:E:B:?<9S*D::E:B:?<9<D:B9:EP:9 3"N,'+3"#8,5L=?C<D:HD=?F:9=GG:H<?><>?E7<D:B@98H=E9<;@H<@;:LA@<>@;K=7 >GE89<:?8?F<><D:B@98H=9K:EES [ &<89HE:=;<D=<*:??:789I=;<8H@E=;E7H>?H:;?:CK8<DD>KE89<:?:;9=;:<>=<<:?C<>=B@98H <D=<H>?<=8?9=H:;<=8?=B>@?<>GH>BIE:`8<7S*D89H>BIE:`8<789;:GE:H<:C?><>?E78?<D: >;F=?8d=<8>?>GB@98H=E:E:B:?<9A@<=E9>8?>@;@?C:;9<=?C8?F>GKD=<H>BI;>B89:9= B@98H=E:E:B:?<8?<D:G8;9<IE=H:A:H=@9:<D:7D=P:HD=?F:CS">;8?9<=?H:L:=HDI8<HD X *;:P>;W89D=;<La)>?8H0>BI>98<8>?8?2;#8.,%';0'(/,GP7;=*.$,/'H.%(+'L;./#"1MXkMi)@BB:;L MNNNj3MQS Z U=B:9*:??:7LH,$"'Q'O;5;%6'<'?3,#;=,#;1;8&';0'2R,#$(,$3S7,#$./&'H.%(+"1'H"$,/("1%'"#5'"#' <**/;"+3'$;'$3,')$.5&';0';/=T'"#5'HU2<'H,$"'Q'O;5;%i5=?>P:;L-53";>F4:=V2@98HLROOMj3MQS [ (@(5MLXSi:BID=989B8?:j Q

11 Y <;=C8<8>?=EP>H=Ek8?9<;@B:?<=EG>;H:9LA@<<D:7H=?=E9>A:H;:=<:C:E:H<;>?8H=EE7HD=?F8?F *D::E:B:?<=EA@8EC8?FeB=<:;8=E9>Go<K:?<8:<DeH:?<@;7pB@98H=;:?>E>?F:; 9@A9<=?H:=?CB=<:;8=E>G<D89B@98H899>@?C_<D89C:G8?8<8>?898?:9H=I=AE:_=?C8< 89>G9:H>?C=;78BI>;<=?H:KD:<D:;<D89B=<:;8=E898?<D:G>;B>G=<>?:K8<D H7BA=ES(?79>@?CB8FD<>HH@;=<9>B:I>8?<8?=I8:H:>GB@98HLK8<D=G@?H<8>? 8<9:EGLA:8?FC:<:;B8?:C8?9<:=CA7<D:E=;F:;B@98H=EH>?<:?<8?KD8HD8<>HH@;9S ] &?9<:=C>GG>H@98?F>?=B:E>C8HE8?:L=B><8P:L>;=D=;B>?8HI;>F;:998>?L>@;=<<:?<8>? H=?H:?<:;>?8?C8P8C@=E9>?8H:P:?<9>G9<;@H<@;=E8BI>;<=?H:K8<D8?=H>BI>98<8>?S (II;>=HD8?FB@98H8?<D89B=??:;89I=;<8H@E=;E7A:?:G8H8=EG>;8?P:9<8F=<8?F:E:H<;>?8H B@98HL98?H:<D:9>@?CI=E:<<:=P=8E=AE:<><D:H>BI>9:;89P8;<@=EE7E8B8<E:99=?C:=HD 8?C8P8C@=EI8:H:K8EEH>?<=8?8<9>K?@?8J@:I;>F;:998>?>GB@98H=E:E:B:?<9S "@;<D:;B>;:L<D:H;8<:;8=A7KD8HDK:I:;H:8P:=9>?8H:P:?<8?>?:I8:H:>GB@98HLB8FD<?><A:<D:9=B:8?=?><D:;I8:H:L:P:?B@98HA7<D:9=B:H>BI>9:;S 2@98H8?KD8HD9>?8H:P:?<9L;=<D:;<D=?<D:<;=C8<8>?=E=9I:H<9>GI8<HD=?Ck>; ;D7<DBL=H<=9B@98H=EI=;=B:<:;9;:J@8;:99:FB:?<8?F=?C>;F=?8d8?F<D:9::P:?<9 I:;H:I<@=EE78?>;C:;<>:9<=AE89DC89H;:<::P:?<9K8<D8?<D:B@98H=E<:`<@;:S0>?9:J@:?<E7 <D:E89<:?:;?>K=9V9<D:J@:9<8>?9LaWD=<89=9>?8H:P:?<f5>KH=?&9:FB:?<<D:9: :P:?<9f(?CKD=<B=V:9=?:P:?<C8GG:;:?<G;>B=?><D:;fb$?H:<D:E89<:?:;D=9=G8;B F;=9I>G<D:9>?8H:P:?<9<D=<H>BI;89:<D:B=V:e@I>G=H>BI>98<8>?<D:?<D:E89<:?:; H=?9<=;<<>C;=KH>??:H<8>?9=9<>D>K<D>9:9>?8H:P:?<9G@?H<8>?K8<D8?<D:E=;F:; 9<;@H<@;:>G<D:K>;VS->?:<D:E:99L8<C:I:?C9>?KD=<B@98H=EI=;=B:<:;9L>;=9'=P8C)S #:GV>K8<d=?C^;89<8?*==P>E=H=EEa'>B=8?9LbH>BI;89:=H>BI>98<8>?S Y (HH>;C8?F<>*:??:7La*D:HE:=;:9<:`=BIE:9>G9@HDH>BIE:`9>@?Ce:E:B:?<9=;:<>?:eHE@9<:;9=?C><D:; D8FDE7C:?9:=?CC899>?=?<HD>;C9q9>@?Ce9<;@H<@;:9KD8HD9::B;:E=<8P:E7a>I=J@:b<><D::=;S)@HD HD>;C9H=??><@9@=EE7A:=?=E7d:CA7<D::=;8?<>H>?9<8<@:?<<>?:9L=?C&<D8?V<D:7=;:?><8?<:?C:C<>A: 9>=?=E7d:CS*D:7=;:9:EC>B9@A\:H<<>D=;B>?8H>;8:?<=<8>?LA:H=@9:>?:c9I:;H:I<8>?>GI8<HD8?<D:9: C:?9:9>@?CeH>BIE:`:989E8B8<:CL=<A:9<L<><D:I8<HD>G<D:8;D8FD:9<>;E>K:9<<>?:9L>;<>=B:=?I8<HDe E:P:ELKD:??>B>;:<D=?<D:=II;>`8B=<:;=?F:=?C;:F89<:;>G<D:HD>;C9H=?A:;:H>F?8d:CSb*:??:7L[S ] *:??:7LYe]S X

12 O >GB@98H=E:E:B:?<9=;:8?P>EP:C8?@?C:;9<=?C8?F<D:I8:H:G;>B=9<;@H<@;=EI:;9I:H<8P:S H>BI>98<8>?8?>;C:;<>=?9K:;<D:G>;:F>8?FJ@:9<8>?9S(CC8<8>?=EE7LKD:?E89<:?8?F<> E=7:;9>G9>@?C<D=<>?:H=?I:;H:8P:C:I:?C8?F>?D>K<D:E89<:?:;c9=<<:?<8>?89 P=;8>@99>?8H:P:?<9=?CD>K<D:7G@?H<8>?8?\@`<=I>98<8>?K8<D8?=?:E:H<;>?8H B@98H8<9:EG<>F@8C:8?=?8?P:9<8F=<8>?>G9>?8H:P:?<9L98?H::=HDH>BI>98<8>?K8EED=P: >K?I:;H:I<8>?>G<D:H>BI>98<8>?8<9:EGL8?H>;I>;=<8?F=*3,#;=,#;1;8(+"1=II;>=HD<> 8?H>;I>;=<:9<D:E89<:?:;c9=@;=EH>BI;:D:?98>?>G<D:B@98H8?J@:9<8>?S(HH>;C8?F<> (lid:?>b:?>?c89<d:g>h@9>g9>b:>?:c9:`i:;8:?h:s*d:9<=<:b:?<ll&9::<d: HD=8;cB:=?9l&I:;H:8P:<D:HD=8;c>;l&=B:`I:;8:?H8?F<D:HD=8;c>;l&=B HD=8;C:I:?C9?><>?<D:H>F?8<8P:H=I=A8E8<8:9>G<D:9@A\:H<KD>D=9<D: =?C<D:K=7<D=<<D8?F89:`I:;8:?H:CA79>B:>?:S G8?C8?F9G>;:P:;7<7I:>GE89<:?:;LKD:<D:;7>@=;:=?=?=E79<LI:;G>;B:;LH>BI>9:;L O '=P8C)S#:GV>K8<d=?C^;89<8?*==P>E=La):FB:?<=<8>?8?2@98H31:?:;=E8d8?F=48:H:e):?98<8P: (II;>=HDLbL;./#"1';0'H.%(+'23,;/&XXkRi)I;8?FLMNNNj3RYMS RN U@C8<D#>HDD:=CLa)>B:2@98H=E(IIE8H=<8>?9>G4D:?>B:?>E>F7LbK#5("#"'23,;/&'V,N(,RQkQiROYOj3 ROS Z

13 =GG:H<<D:H>BI>98<8>?=EI;>H:99S28HD=:E#S^E:8?c9;:H:?<A>>V<8<E:CK#$,/$,>$."1($&'(#' 8?P:9<8F=<:CS RM RR RM 28HD=:E#S^E:8?LK#$,/$,>$."1($&'(#'4,%$,/#'</$'H.%(+i6E>>B8?F<>?3&?C8=?=,?8P:;98<74;:99LMNNZj3 RMS [

14 RQ RX &?=CC8<8>?L I;=FB=<8H=EE7L:B><8>?=EE7S(HH>;C8?FE7L<D:<7I:9>GI;:C8H<8>?<D=<H=?A:B=C: :?F=F:B:?<:E8H8<C8GG:;:?<V8?C9>GI;:C8H<8>?9S RZ ;=?F8?FG;>B:=;E7K>;V9<>B>9<;:H:?<L=?CK:K8EE=E9>I;>I>9:=?8?8<8=E=II;>=HD<> K:EH>B:C8GG:;:?<;:=C8?F9>G<D:9:K>;V9L=?C>GG:;B7>K?=9=I:;9>?=ED:=;8?FS*D: RQ RX RZ *:?C:?H8:9LbH.%(+'23,;/&')*,+$/.=MOkMi"=EELMNNYj3ROYS Y

15 I>998AE:K8<D8?=F8P:?I8:H:S(HH>;C8?F<>)8B>?+BB:;9>?La)H>;:9G>; R[ RY (E:F=?< R] R[ 4;:99L#<CS3#>?C>?LRO][j3MS RY H.%(+'23,;/&'?,5"8;8&MRiMNNYj3RXRS R] ]

16 *D:=?=E7<8H=E=II;>=HD=IIE8:C8?<D89I;>\:H<;:E8:9>?=?:`I:;8:?<8=E RO *D:=8B RO O

17 05(4*+%R $.+%.&+W$"+#+0*%$-&02,)&0 "#$%&'$()*#+*&),%-%.#% =9,1,W$/;#(%+3,'H.%(WL=?C4=;89L";=?H:LKD8HDK=9V?>K?G>;<D:=:9<D:<8H>G KD8HDK=9G8?89D:C8?RONR=?CK=9=E9>V?>K?=9<D:C&#"=;*3;#,S&<<;=?9B8<<:C =<<=HD:C<><:E:ID>?:;:H:8P:;9G8<<:CK8<D:9I:H8=EE7<D8?C8=ID;=FB9G>;A:<<:; A=99;:9I>?9:S R R U>:E0D=C=A:LU1,+$/(+');.#56'23,'?"%$'"#5'?/;=(%,';0'U1,+$/;#(+'H.%(+Mi4;:?<8H:5=EE3-:KU:;9:7L ROOYj3XS RN

18 *D:;:B8?c99:EGe<8<E:C23,/,=(#GG8;9<C:B>?9<;=<:C8?ROMNS M &<@9:C<K>P=H@@B<@A: >9H8EE=<>;9<>I;>C@H:9>@?CS&?D89A>>VL0D=C=A:C:9H;8A:9<D:8?9<;@B:?<LD>K8<K=9 IE=7:C=?CD>K8<9>@?C9S *D:<D:;:B8?K=9=H=A8?:<=A>@<>?:G>><C::IL:8FD<::?8?HD:9K8C:L=?C=A>@< <K>G::<D8FDLIE=H:C>?=<=AE:>;9<=?CS+B:;F8?FG;>B<D:<>I;8FD<>G<D: H=A8?:<K=9=<D8?P:;<8H=E;>CLKD8HDK=9<D:I8<HD=?<:??=S(E>>IL<D:P>E@B: =?<:??=LK=9B>@?<:CD>;8d>?<=EE7>?<D:E:G<98C:>G<D:H=A8?:<S*D:;:B8? IE=7:C8<A7B>P8?FD89D=?C98?<D:=8;SWD:?D89;8FD<D=?CB>P:CHE>9:;<><D: P>E@B:=?<:??=L8<H=@9:C<D:I8<HD<>F>D8FD:;SWD:?D89E:G<D=?CB>P:CHE>9:; <><D:P>E@B:=?<:??=L8<H=@9:C<D:9>@?C<>F:<9>G<:;S*D:9>@?CK=9 9>B:KD:;:A:<K::?=P8>E==?C=HE=;8?:<L9B>><D=?CE7;8H=EL9>B:<8B:9 ;:B8?C8?FE89<:?:;9>G<D:D@B=?P>8H:S*D:;:B8?E=<:;9=8CLa&H>?H:8P:C>G=? 8?9<;@B:?<<D=<K>@ECH;:=<:9>@?CK8<D>@<@98?F=?7B:HD=?8H=E:?:;F7LE8V:<D: H>?C@H<>;>G=?>;HD:9<;=Sb Q *>C=7<D:E89<:?:;H=?G8?CP=;8>@9C:B>?9<;=<8>?9>G*D:;:B8?IE=78?F>?<D:&?<:;?:<L 8?HE@C8?F<D:G=B>@9*D:;:B8?IE=7:;L0E=;=%>HVB>;:S X &?ROM]L2=@;8H:2=;<:?><c9 J#5,%'H"/$,#;$K=9G8;9<C:B>?9<;=<:C=<<D:4=;89$I:;==?C=E9>@9:C>9H8EE=<>;9<> F:?:;=<:9>@?CS(F=8?L0D=C=A:?><:93 o2=;<:?><pi:;g>;b:co>?<d:8?9<;@b:?<pa78?9:;<8?f=g8?f:;8?=;8?f=?c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c9@9:>G<D:8?9<;@B:?<LKD8HD M *D:6:=HD6>79@9:C=*D:;:B8?8?<D:8;9>?Fa1>>C.8A;=<8>?9bG;>B<D:RO[Y=EA@B)=(1,&')=(1,=?C -8?:&?HD-=8E9D=9C:P:E>I:C<D:8;>K?P:;98>?>G=*D:;:B8?S Q 0D=C=A:L]S X ">;B>;:8?G>;B=<8>?>?<D:*D:;:B8?;:G:;<>D<<I3kk:?SK8V8I:C8=S>;FkK8V8k*D:;:B8?i=HH:99:C NMkNRkNOjS">;P8C:>9>G0E=;=%>HVB>;:;:G:;<>D<<I3kkKKKS7>@<@A:SH>BkK=<HDfPtI)d*41E-=Z,LKD8HD 89=I:;G>;B=?H:>G)=8?<e)=u?9c9a*D:)K=?b>;*HD=8V>P9V7c9.=E9:):?<8B:?<=E:G>@?C=< D<<I3kkKKKS7>@<@A:SH>BkK=<HDfPt\+EXd0v6PMHwG:=<@;:t;:E=<:Ci=HH:99:CNMkNRkNOjS&?ROYY':E>9 &?<:;?=<8>?=E=E9>;:E:=9:C=;:H>;C8?F>G0E=;=%>HVB>;:=HH>BI=?8:CA7-=C8=%:89:?A:;F>?I8=?> <8<E:C23,'</$';0'$3,'23,/,=(#6'71"/"'V;+W=;/,i0'RNRXjS Z 0D=C=A:LRMS RR

19 H>BI>9:C8?ROX[eX]S [ (9K8<D<D:*D:;:B8?L<D:;:=;:=E9>P=;8>@9C:B>?9<;=<8>?9>G IE=78?F<D:$?C:92=;<:?><<D=<H=?A:G>@?C>?<D:&?<:;?:<S Y *D:G8;9<H>BB:;H8=EE79@HH:99G@E:E:H<;>?8H8?9<;@B:?<K=9#=@;:?95=BB>?Cc9 ROQZ5=BB>?C:E:H<;>?8H>;F=?S&<K=9K8C:E7@9:C8?;>HVL\=ddLAE@:9L=?CF>9I:E B@98HS&?4:<:;2=??8?Fc9A>>V>?:E:H<;>?8HB@98HLD:?><:93 *D:5=BB>?C$;F=?L=E<D>@FD=B>;:H>?P:?<8>?=E8?9<;@B:?<G;>B<D: I:;G>;B:;c9I>8?<>GP8:KLF=8?:C=;:I@<=<8>?G>;8<9C89<8?H<8P:8G?><:?<8;:E7 =@<D:?<8H9>@?CJ@=E8<7S*D89K=9E=;F:E7C@:<><D:B:<D>C>G<>?:F:?:;=<8>? :BIE>7:CL8?P>EP8?F<D:;><=<8>?>G9@8<=AE7H>?<>@;:CC89H98?=B=F?:<8HG8:EC8? =B=??:;;:B8?89H:?<>G<D:'7?=B>ID>?:S ] *D:5=BB>?C>;F=?;:H;:=<:9=I8I:>;F=?e<7I:9>@?CA7@98?F=CC8<8P:97?<D:989>G K=P:G>;B9G;>B<D:D=;B>?8H9:;8:9SWD8E:<D:8?9<;@B:?<899<8EE8?@9:<>C=7L H>BI>9:;9H=?=E9>8B8<=<:<D:5=BB>?C9>@?CC8F8<=EE7S +=;E8:;8?RORQ=I=8?<:;?=B:C#@8F8%@99>E>LKD>K=9I=;<>G<D:&<=E8=? "@<@;89<B>P:B:?<L8?P:?<:C8?9<;@B:?<9H=EE:C(#$;#"/.=;/(L>;?>89:8?<>?:;9S*D: 9:;8:9>G8?9<;@B:?<9C8P8C:8?<>a98`<8BA;=E<7I:93A>>B9LKD89<E:9LKD89I:;9L9H;:=B9L I:;H@998P:9>@?C9=?CP>H=E9>@?C9iD@B=?=?C=?8B=EjSb O 0D=C=A:?><:9<D=<<D: 8?9<;@B:?<9K:;:aA>`:9>GP=;8>@998d:9L:=HDK8<D=H;=?V8?<D:A=HVL=9>@?Ce F:?:;=<8?FB:HD=?89B8?98C:L=?C=?=BIE8G8H=<8>?D>;?8?G;>?<S(E:P:;B>@?<:C>?<>I >G:=HDA>`LK=9@9:C<>=C\@9<I8<HDSb RN ->?:<D:E:99L%@99>E>c98C:>E>F789>GB>;: 8BI>;<=?H:<D=?<D:=H<@=E8?9<;@B:?<9<D:B9:EP:9LKD8HD@?G>;<@?=<:E7=;:?><8? :`89<:?H:=?7B>;:S(9%>A:;<2>;F=??><:93 "@<@;89B9<=?C98?<D:D89<>;7>G<K:?<8:<DeH:?<@;7B@98H=9<D:G8;9<HE:=; B=?8G:9<=<8>?>G=B=\>;=?C:?C@;8?FH>?H:;?3<D:;:E=<8>?9D8IA:<K::??:K B@98H=?CB>C:;?<:HD?>E>F7S(E<D>@FD<D:"@<@;89<9=II=;:?<E7D=C?>C8;:H< 8?GE@:?H:>?9@A9:J@:?<H>BI>98<8>?=EC:P:E>IB:?<9L<D:8;K89Dl<>H>?J@:;<D: [ (P=8E=AE:;:H>;C8?F9>G<D:H>BI>98<8>?9B:?<8>?:C8?<D89HD=I<:;H=?A:G>@?C8?<D:(II:?C8`S Y ">;B>;:8?G>;B=<8>?;:G:;<>D<<I3kk:?SK8V8I:C8=S>;FkK8V8k$?C:9T2=;<:?><>; D<<I3kkRMN7:=;9S?:<kB=HD8?:9kB=;<:?><kLKD8HD8?HE@C:9=B>;:C:<=8E:CD89<>;7LI8H<@;:9L=?C9>@?CG8E:9 i=hh:99:cnmknrknojs">;=p8c:>i:;g>;b=?h:>g<d:g8;9<b>p:b:?<>g*@;=?f=exe=e)7bid>?8:g:=<@;8?f 48:;;:#=@;:?<(8B=;CL07?<D8=28EE=;L(?C;:K'=P89L=?C<D:-=<8>?=E/>@<D$;HD:9<;=>G1;:=<6;8<=8? ;:G:;<>D<<I3kkKKKS7>@<@A:SH>BkK=<HDfPtRYN.y1">*^Fw-%tRi=HH:99:CNMkNRkNOjS ] 4:<:;2=??8?FLU1,+$/;#(+'"#5'7;=*.$,/'H.%(+MM?C :CSi$`G>;C,?8P:;98<74;:993$`G>;CLROOQj3QS O %>A:;<(S2>;F=?L2R,#$(,$3S7,#$./&'H.%(+6'<'O(%$;/&';0'H.%(+"1')$&1,'(#'H;5,/#'U./;*,'"#5'<=,/(+"M iwsws->;<>?=?c0>bi=?73-:k/>;vlroorj3rr[s RN 0D=C=A:LQS RM

20 RR >9H8EE=<>;LF:?:;=<>;KD8?:L=?CH>?<=H<B8H;>ID>?:Sb RM H>BI>98<8>?=E=:9<D:<8HS&?ROX]L<D:";:?HDB=?48:;;:)HD=:GG:;A:F=?K>;V8?F=<<D: RQ RR 2>;F=?LRRYS RM RQ *D:+F7I<8=?A>;?H>BI>9:;L5=E8B:Ee'=ADH>BI>9:C4(/,'V,+;/5,/'?(,+,'8?'ROXXLKD8HDK=9A;>=CH=9< imnn[js RQ

21 *D89C:<:;B8?=<8>?<>H>BI>9:K8<DB=<:;8=E9<=V:?G;>B=?:`89<8?FH>EE:H<8>?>G >A\:H<9C:G8?:C=?CKD>E:S RX )HD=:GG:;c9G8;9<H>BI>98<8>?=99>H8=<:CK8<D<D:<:;B=.%(D.,'+;#+/E$,K=9=? &?$H<>A:;>GROX]L)HD=:GG:;I;:9:?<:C<D:7;#+,/$'5,'-/.($%i0>?H:;<>G )&=*3;#(,'*;./'.#'O;==,'),.1L=H>EE=A>;=<8>?A7)HD=:GG:;=?C5:?;78?ROZNS&? :?=V89 9:;8=E89BS RZ H>BIE:`9H>;:9LG>;B=EE7:E=A>;=<:C8?=CP=?H:L8?<D:9I8;8<>G<D:9:;8=EB:<D>C9>G RX 0D=C=A:LM[eMYS RZ RX

22 R[ U1,W$/;#(%+3,'H.%(WH>?989<:C>G K=P:9LK:;:)$.5(,'K'=?C)$.5(,'KKK;8<<:?8?ROZQ=?CROZX;:9I:H<8P:E7S RY K8<D<D:H>BI>9:;9S&?ROZQL6:;8>B:<2=C:;?=LKD>K>;V:C8?1:;B=?7L=?C<D:7 R] R[ %899:<L`8PS RY R] RZ

23 H>?<;>EE:CS28E<>?6=AA8<<K>;V:CK8<D<D:B=HD8?::`<:?98P:E7=?C?><:93 9<=;<G;>B9H;=<HD=?CC>:P:;7<D8?FG;>B<D:A:F8??8?FSqW:C8C?c<K=?<<> R[

24 <D:I;>AE:BK=9<D=<8<K=9=B>?9<:;>G=B=HD8?:S&<K=9<D:98d:>G=KD>E: RO MN $?<D:><D:;98C:>G<D:H>?<8?:?<8?<D:RO[N9LH>BI>9:;98?)=?";=?H89H>A:F=? MR $E8P:;>9\>8?:C=7:=; RO MN MR '=P8CWS6:;?9<:8?;:H:?<E7:C8<:C=A>>V<8<E:C23,')"#'/"#+(%+;'2"*,'H.%(+'7,#$,/6'XYa[%' 2"*,'H.%(+'7,#$,/6'XYa[%'7;.#$,/+.1$./,'"#5'<N"#$S:"/5,i,?8P:;98<7>G0=E8G>;?8=4;:9936:;V:E:7L MNN]j3M]OS RY

25 E=<:;8?RO[MS*D89H:?<:;K=9=E9>=A;8CF:A:<K::?<D:=:9<D:<8H9>G=.%(D.,'+;#+/E$, <D=<K=9>?<=I:Sb MM &?RO[Y<D:)"*20;:H:8P:C=F;=?<<>\>8?<D:28EE90:?<:;G>; =I=;<S MQ (I;8B::`=BIE:>G=<=I:I8:H:89)<:P:%:8HDc9K$b%':;##"'V"(#GKD8HDK=9 H>BB8998>?:CA7<D:)"*208?RO[ZS MX ROYN9K8<D<D:C:P:E>IB:?<>GC8F8<=E<:HD?>E>F7=?CI;>F;=B9<D=<K>;V8?;:=Ee<8B: I;>H:99:9S MM 0D=C=A:L]Ye]]S MQ MX 6>:DB:;L[MS R]

26 97?<D:98d:;LD=;ILH8BA=E>BLP8A;=ID>?:L=?C`7E>ID>?:jK:;:8?C:I:?C:?<E7 MZ ->< 6:??:<<L2=`2=<D:K9L=?CU>D?0D>K?8?FS(90D=C=A:?><:93 A71:;=EC6:??:<<iKD>9:\>A8<K=9<>V::I<D:><D:;C:I=;<B:?<98?= H>>I:;=<8P:;:E=<8>?9D8IjS M[ +"//(,/G89P=;8:CA7=?><D:;K=P:G>;BLH=EE:C<D:=;5.1"$;/M*D::`<:?<<>KD8HD MZ 0D=C=A:LR]RS M[ RO

27 MY ";>B<D:/=B=D=;>7=E<8:9=?C><D:;F;=?<9<D:H:?<:;K=9=AE:<>F;>KH>?98C:;=AE7 2&*L,?8P:;98<7>G0=E8G>;?8=)=?'8:F>L28HD8F=?)<=<:,?8P:;98<7L=?C<D:,?8P:;98< K>>>Sb M] MO MY 0D=C=A:GMZRS M] MO MN

28 QN )8?H:?/;*3,$S^K=9I;>F;=BB=AE: &?=CC8<8>?L9:P:;=EU=I=?:9:H>BI=?8:9A:F=?C:P:E>I8?FV:7A>=;C97?<D:98d:;9 &?U=I=?<D:;:K=9?>D89<>;7>G<D:>;F=?S(?C=<<D=<<8B:L?>>;F=?9S)> 9>B:>?:&V?:K8BI>;<:C=P:;798BIE::E:H<;>?8H>;F=?G;>B<D:,)(S&<K=9 QR K=9D>K<>9D=;:C=<=L=?C?><<>D=P:=9<=?C=;CK=9?><I>998AE:Sb QM 97?HD;>?8d:CA7=98?FE:I:;G>;B:;L=?C<D89GE:`8A8E8<78?979<:BC:98F?=EE>K:C D=;CK=;:>;9>G<K=;:LKD:<D:;B=C:A7=E=;F:>;9B=EEH>BI=?7LKD:<D:; QQ QN 0D=C=A:LRZYS QR QM QQ MR

LOWELL WEEKLY JOURNAL

LOWELL WEEKLY JOURNAL W WY R G «( 5 R 5 Y q YG R ««W G WY Y 7 W \(\ 5 R ( W R R W ) W «W W W W< W ) W 53 R R Y 4 RR \ \ ( q ) W W X R R RY \ 73 «\ 2 «W R RG ( «q ) )[ 5 7 G ««R q ] 6 ) X 5 5 x / ( 2 3 4 W «(«\Y W Q RY G G )