arxiv: v2 [hep-ph] 16 Oct 2018

Transcription

1 Sme-sign op pir (plus W ) producion in flvor chnging vecor nd sclr models rxiv: v2 [hep-ph] 6 Oc 28 Jvd Ebdi, Femeh Elhi, Morez Khiri, Mojb Mohmmdi Njfbdi School of Physics, Insiue for Reserch in Fundmenl Sciences, P.O. Box , Tehrn, Irn School of Pricles nd Accelerors, Insiue for Reserch in Fundmenl Sciences (IPM) P.O. Box , Tehrn, Irn Absrc We invesige he prospec of he LHC for discovering new physics effecs vi new sregies in he sme-sign op pir nd sme-sign op pir ssocied wih W boson signures. Significn enhncemen in producion of sme-sign op qurks (plus W boson) is join propery of severl models beyond he sndrd model. We concenre on he leponic (elecron nd muon) decy of he op qurks nd sudy he exclusion rech of he LHC d for simplified model pproch where op qurk flvor chnging could occur hrough Z or neurl sclr φ exchnge. Less bckground conribuions nd clen signure re he dvnges of he leponic decy mode of he op qurks in he sme-sign producion processes. A combinion is performed on boh sme-sign op pir nd sme-sign op pir plus W boson producion modes which enbles us o rech lrge frcion of he model prmeer spce. Assuming he couplings of new physics of he order of 2, he mss of flvor chnging Z or neurl sclr bove TeV could be excluded. We propose momenum dependen chrge symmery nd ngulr observbles in he sme-sign op process which provide he possibiliy of seprion of new physics signl from he SM bckgrounds s well s discriminion of he flvor chnging ux from cx, where X = Z, φ.

2 Inroducion Despie he mrvelous successes of he Sndrd Model (SM) he elecrowek scle, we srongly believe here exiss new physics (NP) beyond he SM. Among ll fermions in he SM, op qurk cuses he mos serious hierrchy nd plys n essenil role in he vcuum sbiliy []. Top qurk hs he sronges coupling wih he Higgs boson s resul he qunum loop level effecs on precise mesured observbles could be significn. Such srong effecs cn be conneced o he couplings of new degrees of freedom o he op qurk. Wihin he SM frmework, flvor chnging neurl currens (FCNCs) in he op qurk secor re no presen leding-order in boh Yukw nd guge inercions. However, he FCNC couplings could be genered from loop-level box digrms which re exremely suppressed due o he Glshow-Iliopoulos-Mini (GIM) mechnism [2]. We noe h ny FCNC inercion occurring beween he firs wo qurk generions is significnly consrined by he low energy experimens [3]. However, here is lrge concenrion on he op qurk FCNC couplings s he consrins re rher mild. The op qurk FCNC processes could rise considerbly in he presence of well-moived new physics models. Among hese models, here re scenrios such s supersymmeric exensions of he SM nd he wo Higgs double models where he FCNCs increse becuse of he new loop level digrms medied by new pricles [4 3]. Moreover, here re proposed heories beyond he SM in which op qurk FCNCs could show up hrough he exchnge of new neurl sclr or neurl guge boson. Some of he models emp o explin he flvor srucure of he SM, where new medior is inroduced wih couplings h re sronger o qurks wih lrger msses. If he medior is sclr, which cquires vcuum expecion vlue (vev) similr o he Higgs mechnism, is couplings o fermions is proporionl o heir msses [,4 2]. In ddiion, he op qurk FCNC could occur vi Z boson exchnge which cn origine from Grnd Unified Theories (GUT). In such models, Z boson cn couple universlly o he hree fermion generions in flvor digonl wy wih possibiliy of mixing ll SM qurks by Z nd Z bosons [2]. The flvor chnging Z hs been lso expeced in heories wih dynmicl symmery breking pproch. The op qurk flvor chnging hve lredy been sudied in mny ppers in he conex of non-universliy, where he srengh of he couplings re differen mong differen generions [2 33]. There re lso beyond he SM heories where he flvor chnging could proceed hrough color sexe vecor nd sclr bosons [34, 35]. Oher clss of beyond he SM heories leding o possible op qurk FCNCs hrough neurl sclr φ or vecor Z is reled o he hidden secor. In hese models, he drk mer cndide from he hidden secor cn couple o he SM fields in flvor chnging wy hrough vecor or sclr medior [36, 37]. Such models led o producion of op qurk ssocied wih drk mer or in ssociion wih Z h decys ino drk mer he LHC [8, 38]. These processes hve finl se of op qurk plus lrge missing energy (so clled monoop) which is no presen leding-order in he SM. Serches for monoop producion hve been crried ou by he CMS nd ATLAS experimens he LHC where no significn excess bove he SM predicion hs been observed, nd bounds re plced on he mss nd couplings of he mediors [39 4]. I is noble h in ddiion o he FCNC inercions, he monoop producion he LHC is expeced from bryon number violion s well [42]. While mny of he bove models hve received much enion, considering he presen experimenl mesuremens ells us h hese 2

3 heories re llowed providing h he new degrees of freedom re hevy enough or heir couplings o he SM pricles re significnly smll. In Ref. [43], he LHC signures of he righ-hnded cz coupling hve been sudied. Such FCNC coupling is inspired o explin he observed nomly in he rnsiions of B K ( ). In ddiion o he monoop producion, if vecor or sclr flvor chnging exiss, sme-sign op qurks could be produced hrough he Z or φ exchnge in qq ( q q ) process, where q = u, c. In he SM, he sme-sign op pir producion proceeds hrough one loop s depiced in Fig.. The SM uu(ūū) ( ) is proporionl o V uq V q 2 (q = d, s, b) nd he down-ype qurk msses. Therefore, wihin he SM he sme-sign op pir producion is expeced o be significnly suppressed. This mkes he sme-sign op pir process very ineresing signure s i hs very smll moun of SM bckground nd could be observed s pir of sme-sign chrged lepons ssocied wih wo b-jes. q = u,c d,s,b W W q = u,c d,s,b Figure : Lowes order sme-sign op qurk pir producion in he SM he LHC. Anoher clen signure for he op qurk flvor chnging of qz nd qφ he LHC is he sme-sign op pir producion ssocied wih W boson. In he SM frmework, he lowes order W ( W + ) producion proceed hrough elecrowek inercions leding order wih producion re of order of 4 fb. Similr o he sme-sign op pir, sudying his process hs much cler signure nd his process is esy o discrimine from he SM bckground processes. The W process could be observed in he form of wo ligh flvor je from he W boson decy nd pir of sme-sign chrged lepons ssocied wih wo b-jes from he semileponic op qurks decys. In his pper, we sudy he sme-sign op pir producion he LHC sensiiviy on he bsis of simplified model pproch describing he op qurk flvor chnging hrough sclr or vecor boson. New vribles re inroduced o enhnce he signl-o-bckground rio. We propose rnsverse momenum bsed chrge symmery which could indice he new physics effecs in producion process s well s ngulr observbles o disinguish beween he signl from bckground processes nd ux signl scenrio from he cx. Addiionlly, we propose o use he W + W + process o serch for he vecor or sclr flvor violing effecs he LHC s complemenry chnnel o he monoop nd he sme-sign op qurk pir. Then, we perform sisicl combinion of nd W processes which improves he exclusion limis 3

4 considerbly. The nlyses re bsed on relisic simulion of he deecor response nd he min SM bckground processes re ken ino ccoun. In priculr, o include he deecor response we focus on CMS-like deecor [44]. The res of his mnuscrip is orgnized s follows. In Secion 2, we presen he heoreicl formlism which is followed o serch for he new physics effecs. We hen exrc he exclusion limis on he prmeer spce for boh sclr nd vecor FCNCs from he D D mixing in Secion 3. Secion 4 is dediced o presen he deils of he sregies nd he nlyses of nd W chnnels s well s he new sensiive observbles. The resuls of he sisicl combinion of wo processes re given in his secion. Our conclusions re presened in Secion 5. 2 Theoreicl formlism As we discussed in he previous secion, he exchnge of new op qurk flvor chnging ses leds o ree level nd W producions, nd consequenly would resul in modificions of he inclusive nd W producion cross secions of hese processes. We perform deiled sudy of his possibiliy bsed on scenrios in which he SM is exended by eiher dding new vecor boson or new sclr boson ffecing he nd W producions ree level. Similr o he SM, we ssume QCD inercions respec flvor conservion nd he FCNC inercions occur vi wek secor. The relevn effecive Lgrngin including new flvor chnging vecor (Z ) or flvor chnging sclr (φ) is given by [36]: L = L SM + L Kineic + Z µū i ( Z ij γ µ + b Z ij γ µ γ 5 )u j + φū i ( φ ij + bφ ij γ5 )u j + h.c., () where he hevy mediors fields re denoed by Z nd φ, L Kineic conins he kineic erms of Z nd φ fields. The coupling mrices Z /φ ij nd b Z /φ ij denoe he vecor- nd xil-couplings beween up-ype qurks wih flvor i nd j which proceeds hrough he exchnge of eiher vecor Z or sclr φ. In his work, for simpliciy he xil couplings re negleced, i.e. b Z /φ ij =, nd we only consider he purely flvor chnging inercions of he new ses, i.e. ii = for i = u, c,. The new ses Z nd φ could ply connecion roles wih n invisible fermionic se χ [37]. In his pper, we resric ourselves o only producion mechnisms of nd W involving Z nd φ. Consequenly, he inercions wih he invisible secor re no ken ino ccoun. As we se ii =, ny digrms conining Z nd φ couplings do no conribue in he signl processes. The phenomenology of op qurk flvor chnging mediors hs been discussed in mny ppers. Some sudies hve considered he ssocie producion of op qurk wih he medior, where he medior subsequenly eiher decys o noher pir of SM pricles or is connecor o Drk Mer (DM) nd goes o pir of DM pricles [29, 45]. The producion of op qurk in ssociion wih chrm qurk he LHC nd he CLIC elecron-posiron collider vi Z flvor chnging in he s-chnnel hve been sudied in Refs. [2, 24] nd he discovery regions of he new model prmeer spce hve been presened. In ddiion o he producion mechnisms o probe he properies of he new flvor chnging mediors, such model s prmeer spce could be lso probed by looking he op qurk decys. Severl ppers hve looked cx flvor chnging rnsiions he LHC [3, 46 52], mosly wih he ssumpion of nomlous opup(chrm)-g/γ/z couplings. Noneheless, in he cse of ssuming new BSM pricle, such 4

5 medior is required o be hevier hn he op qurk [53]. However, s he bounds derived from hese serches rely on flvor digonl couplings, hey do no pply o our priculr scenrio. 3 Indirec probes: D D mixing In his secion, we discuss he effecs of sclr φ nd vecor Z boson wih FCNC couplings o he up-ype qurks on he D D mixing nd derive he bounds on he couplings nd msses of sclr φ nd Z boson. Wihin he SM, he D D mixing is mnifesion of FCNCs h occurs s he flvor eigenses re differen from he physicl mss eigenses of he D D sysem. Boh he shor-rnge qurk-level rnsiions nd he long-rnge processes conribue o D D oscillion. The shor-rnge conribuions proceed vi loops where he virul pricles re medied [54 56]. This cuses he sudy of he D D mixing more ineresing s new physics models wih new (FCNC) degrees of freedom could be exmined hrough i. The prmeers of he new vecor nd sclr FCNC inercions o wo up-ype qurks could be significnly consrined using he mesuremen of D D mixing which is ffeced boh he ree level nd loop level. The Feynmn digrms of sclr φ or vecor Z flvor chnging which conribue o he D D mixing re depiced in Fig.2. c u c u c u Z'/ φ Z'/ φ Z'/ φ Z'/ φ Z'/ φ u c u c u c Figure 2: The digrms of Z /φ h conribues o D D mixing ree level nd loop level. Assuming he medior hs up-chrm ( uc ), up-op ( u ), nd chrm-op ( c ) couplings, i cn hve significn conribuion o neurl D meson mixing. If he medior is Z, is conribuion o he mss difference beween he wo mss eigenses is given by [2]: M D = f D 2 M D 2 B [ D 2m 2 2 uc + ( u c ) 2 x ] Z 8π 2 (32f (x) 5g Z Z (x)) where f Z (x) = 2 ( x) 3 [ x2 + 2x log x] 2 g Z (x) = [2( x) + ( + x) log x] ( x) 3 (2) 5

6 nd he sclr FCNC conribuions o he mss difference cn be expressed s [57]: ( )] M D = f D 2 M DB D [ 2uc 24π 2 m 2 + ( u c ) 2 m 2 f φ φ m 2 φ where f φ (x) = x log(x) ( x) 2 + x2 4x log x 2( x) 3. (3) where in boh Eq.2 nd Eq.3, he firs erm in he squre brcke represens he ree level conribuion nd he second erm is due o he box conribuion, x m 2 Z /φ /m2, M D.9 GeV is he mss of D meson, f D 223 MeV is is decy consn, B D is he bg model prmeer, nd ij is he coupling beween i nd j up-ype qurks. In his work, we se uc = nd only focus on he FCNCs of op nd up/chrm qurks vi Z nd φ. The curren bound on D meson mixing is M D < [58, 59] by which consrins in he plnes of ( u, m Z /φ) nd ( c, m Z /φ) re presened in Fig.8 for differen vlues of c nd u, respecively. The bounds from D meson mixing on u nd c re similr. 4 Collider signures A he LHC, he res of op qurk producion re of he order of severl hundreds pb, which re relively lrge mong he ineresing processes. Alhough op qurks re minly produced singly vi elecrowek inercion or in pir of op-niop vi srong inercions, serches for sme-sign op qurks nd sme-sign op qurks ssocied wih W boson re imporn s new physics cn enhnce heir res. In his secion, firs we will crry he nlysis in he sme-sign op qurk pir producion, nd find he llowed region of he prmeer spce for differen scenrios of he inegred luminosiies he LHC wih he cener-of-mss energy of 4 TeV. Then, he rech wih sme-sign op qurks plus W boson is sudied. Finlly, combined sisicl nlysis is performed on nd W chnnels nd we show how he combinion cn exend he sensiiviy in he prmeer spce. 4. Two sme-sign ops The exisence of flvor chnging in he op qurk secor vi eiher sclr φ or vecor Z would llow he producion of sme-sign op qurk pir in proon-proon collisions he LHC. Represenive Feynmn digrms pron level for he sme-sign op qurk pir producion he LHC vi flvor chnging sclr (φ) or vecor boson (Z ) exchnge re shown in Fig.3. u,c u,c Z'/ φ Z'/ φ u,c u,c Figure 3: Represenive Feynmn digrms for he sme-sign op qurk pir producion he LHC vi sclr (φ) nd vecor (Z ). 6

7 Sme-sign op pir producion is he mos opiml chnnel o look for our signl, becuse of wo min resons: (i) i hs very low nd reducible bckground; (ii) in he cse of up-op flvor chnging, he op qurks will be produced from up qurks, which re proon s vlence qurks. Due o heir higher PDFs, he cross secion involving up qurks is more significn, nd he op qurks in he finl se re more energeic. This signl propery is helpful for more discriminion of signl from bckground. Top ni-qurks coming from ū-qurks (se qurks) suffer from lower PDF, nd he ŝ in his cse ends o be much lower. Therefore, he finl ses of ni-ops re less energeic wih respec o he sme-sign op pir. The producion cross secions of he process s funcion of he Z nd φ mss once wih u =.25 nd once wih c =.25 re presened in Fig.4. σ [fb] 7 6 σ [fb] W W 2 =.25 u =.25 c m Z' (GeV) m Z' (GeV) σ [fb] 5 4 σ [fb] =.25 u W m φ (GeV) W c = m φ (GeV) Figure 4: The producion cross secions of he sme-sign op pir nd sme-sign op pir ssocied wih W boson in erms of he mss of he Z (op) nd φ (boom). The righ plos re for he cse u =.25, c =. nd he lef plos re for he cse h u =., c =.25. As indiced before, sudy of he sme-sign op qurk due o he sclr nd vecor FCNCs hs he dvnge of enhncing he sensiiviy o he signl prmeer spce. Since he jes chrge mesuremen he LHC is much compliced sk nd hs high uncerinies, we require op qurks o decy leponiclly, even hough lower sisics is expeced due o lower brnching frcions. The finl se of signl consiss of wo sme-sign chrged lepons, wo b-jes nd lrge missing energy. Bsed on he finl se, he min bckgrounds re lised below which some emerge s resul of deecor limiions such s missing some objecs he deecor, or fke 7

8 objecs: pp ( ) l ± l ± bbν l ν l (SM process), pp W ± W ± leponic decy + jes, pp W ± leponic decy, nd pp Z leponic decy, pp W ± W ± leponic decy + jes, Double Pron Scering, pp b( l)lν l bjj, pp W ± W jj, nd pp V V jj, V = Z, γ, The producion of double sme-sign op qurks ( ) in he SM re hrough loops involving CKM enries nd hus negligible. The pp W ± W ± +jes process is he irreducible bckground, where he W s re sme-sign nd hey boh decy leponiclly. Figure 5 depics exmple Feynmn digrms for he QCD induced producion of W ± W ± +jes. The W ± [6] nd Z processes, wih leponic decy of he W boson or Z boson nd semileponic decy of he pir, could hve sme-sign dilepon in he finl se herefore i conribues o he bckground. The finl se of hese wo processes conins more jes wih respec o he ( ) signl evens. The Z process is in priculr bckground when one of he chrged lepons from he Z boson decy escpes deecion. Anoher imporn bckground is pp j b lν l j b jj, where one of he b-jes (j b ) include lepon in is je (he B meson decys o leponic finl ses wih s brnching frcion of bou %). If he wo lepons in he process hve sme-signs, his process would be bckground o our signl. Alhough he odds of such process seem smll, due o he high cross secion of he LHC, his process could be imporn. The oher bckgrounds re due o deecor mis-mesuremens or objecs h re missed in he deecor. Some of hese re W ± W +jes nd V V +jes, where he V = Z or γ decy leponiclly. In such siuions, we my hve wo lepons of he sme-sign nd wo jes. This hppens in he cses h rel opposie-sign dilepon pir is presen in he finl se nd he chrge of he lepons is misken by he deecor. The chrge misidenificion probbiliy is negligible for muons wih respec o elecrons. For he elecron, he min effec comes from he conversion of e ± e ± γ e ± e e ± in he deecor. The chrge misidenificion probbiliy is dependen on he lepon p T nd goes up very high p T. For he processes considered here, highly boosed lepons re very unlikely. Hence, due o smll cross secions of hese processes nd low chrge misidenificion of he lepons, we ignore hese bckgrounds in he nlysis. Anoher source of bckground is he W ± W ± jj from Double Pron Scering (DPS). The W ± W ± +jes from DPS rises from he cses h wo vrious hrd pron-pron inercions occur he sme ime in single proon-proon collision. The re of W ± W ± jj is esimed using σ(w ± j) 2 /(2σ eff ) [6], where σ(w ± j) is he W ± +je re, fcor of wo in he denominor is symmery fcor for he idenicl processes nd σ eff is he ol effecive proon-proon cross secion he LHC which is of he order of 5 mb. The signl processes re simuled using he Mone Crlo (MC) generor MdGrph5-MC@NLO [7], nd n lredy vilble Universl FeynRules Oupu (UFO) model [72,73]. Then he pronlevel evens re pssed hrough Pyhi 6 [74] for pron shower, hdronizion nd decy of unsble pricles. The deecor effecs re simuled using Delphes 3 [75]. A he deecor level, 8

9 u d d W + d d d ū W + d d ū W + u d d W + u d W + d d ū W + Figure 5: Represenive Feynmn digrms for he W ± W ± +jes producion he LHC. The iniil ses in his bckground cn be boh from he vlence qurks (lef), only one of hem coming from he vlence qurk (middle), or boh coming from se qurks (righ). he pile-up effecs re no considered. The bckground smples re lso genered in similr fshion. For bckground, in Pyhi, he mesons which include b-qurks re forced o decy leponiclly o increse he sisics of our sudy. The considered finl ses re µ ± µ ± ν µ ν µ j b j b, e ± e ± ν e ν e j b j b, nd e ± µ ± ν e ν µ j b j b, where j b denoes je origining from he hdronizion of b-qurk. The even selecion is designed o idenify sme-sign chrged lepon evens compible wih he wo sme-sign op qurks evens, while keeping down he conribuion of bckground processes. To rigger he evens, one cn eiher rely on he single or double lepon riggers [62]. These riggers re bsed on he presence of single energeic isoled lepon or wo low p T isoled chrged lepon. To ensure he evens sisfy he rigger, i is required o hve wo sme-sign chrged lepons wih p T (l) > 25 nd η < 2.5. Furhermore, he lepons re required o sisfy n isolion crieri. The relive isolion for he elecrons nd muons re defined s: RelIso(l) = R(l,i)<.3 i p T (i), (4) p T (l) where he sum in he numeror is over he rnsverse momen of pricles lying inside cone wih rdius of R =.3 excep for he chrged lepon l iself. For n isoled lepon, he RelIso(l) is expeced o ke smll vlues close o zero. In his nlysis, he mximum vlue of.5 is ken. Jes re reconsruced wih he ni-k T lgorihm [63] s implemened in he FsJe pckge [64] wih disnce prmeer of.4. Ech even is required o hve les wo jes wih p T (j) > 3 GeV nd η j < 2.5 from which les one is required o be b-gged. The efficiency of b-gging nd he misidenificion res re dependen on he je p T nd re ssumed o be similr o he CMS deecor [4]. A p T of 4 GeV, he b-gging efficiency is 6%, c-je misidenificion re is 4.6%, nd misidenificion re for ligh flvor je is.% [65]. In order o hve well isoled objecs in he finl se, he ngulr seprion beween ll seleced objecs o be lrger hn.4, he deecor level. All he explined cus bove excep for he isolion cu on he chrged lepons nd b-gging re clled s he bsic cus. The efficiencies fer ech cu for hree signl scenrios nd for he min bckgrounds re shown in Tble. As i is shown in Tble, he isolion requiremen does no ffec he signl or he W ± W ± +jes, W ±, nd Z bckgrounds, bu i compleely erdices he bckground. Th is becuse in he bckground, one of he 9

10 sme-sign lepons comes from b-je nd hus he environmen round he lepon is pollued by oher pricles in he je, wheres in oher processes he lepons re produced isoled nd hey sy isoled hroughou he deecor. The requiremen of hving les one b-gged je is quie effecive o suppress he W ± W ± +jes bckground. Techniclly, he jes in W ± W ± +jes could be b-jes, bu hose re produced eiher from b-qurk PDFs or from CKM flvor chnging couplings which boh re suppressed. As cn be seen in Tble, his requiremen significnly reduces he W ± W ± +jes bckground while leving he signl lmos unchnged. cus m Z SM bkg 6 GeV TeV W ± W ± +jes W ± Z Bsic cus 4.% 3.% 5.% 2% 3% 8% Isoled lepons 3.% 2.3% 4.5%.% 29% 7% B-gging.6%.%.2% 2% 4% φ(l, l 2 ) >.5 9.6% 9.2%.7% % 3% Tble : The efficiencies of ech cu on wo benchmrk poins m Z = 6 GeV nd TeV nd he min bckgrounds. The couplings of he benchmrks re no imporn becuse here is no inerference beween he signl nd bckground; hus he behvior of he disribuions do no depend on he couplings. As shown in he ble, he bckground ges suppressed by he lepon isolion cu, nd he W ± W ± +jes is reduced significnly by he b-gging requiremen s well s he φ(l, l 2 ) cu. The cross secion of he W ± W ± jj from DPS fer he bsic cus is found o be quie negligible s resul i is no considered in he res of his nlysis. To furher enhnce he signl nd suppress he min bckground evens, one cn look for he specil feures in he kinemics of he signl. In Appendix A, we show he nlyicl expression of he M 2 uu. Becuse none of he bckgrounds hve excly he sme iniil nd finl ses s he signl, here is no inerference beween signl nd bckground ree level. Therefore, he squred mrix elemen scles s 4 ij nd none of he kinemics should depend on he coupling. Consequenly, when he benchmrks re specified, only he mss of Z is imporn. In Fig.6, he normlized squred mrix elemen of uu versus ŝ for hree msses of Z re shown for insnce for he cse of cos θ =, where θ is he scering ngle in he pronic cener-of-mss frme. As one cn see, for lrger m Z, he ŝ becomes more imporn. This is common feure in he s-chnnel processes, bu no so rivil in - nd u-chnnels. The ŝ for he producion could ke lrge vlues becuse he iniil ses re vlence qurks. Since he squred mrix elemen dices he behvior of he finl se disribuions, he lrge ŝ seems o be more imporn in processes wih lrge m Z. As resul, for lrger m Z, he finl se op qurks re more energeic, nd heir finl ses re more colliner. Since boh op qurks re bck-o-bck, heir finl ses re expeced o be lmos bck-o-bck s well. Figure 7 shows he φ(l, l 2 ) nd indices h he finl decy producs of op qurks end o become more bck o bck s m Z increses. This is while he bckground shows no ineresing feure for ll vlues of φ. Thereby, wih cu on φ we cn enhnce our signl over bckground discriminion. Anoher vrible h ges ffeced by his observion is H T = visible p T. For

11 .2. m Z =.3 m Z = m Z =3 normlized M s (TeV) Figure 6: The behvior of squred mrix elemen in erms of ŝ for he signl process uu for m Z =.3,, 3 TeV ssuming he scering ngle in he cener-of-mss frme equls o π/2. lrger vlues of m Z, he disribuion of H T peks higher vlue. However, cu on H T is no very efficien nd i is m Z dependen s consequence no cu is pplied here. Evens.u Bckground m Z' = GeV = 4 GeV m Z' φ(l, l ) 2 Figure 7: The disribuion of φ(l, l 2 ) for wo benchmrk poins nd sum of ll bckground processes. The lepons h come from hevier medior end o be more bck-o-bck. To qunify our sensiiviy, single bin couning experimen is used o se he limis. A Poisson disribuion is ken s he probbiliy of mesuring n evens: P(n n s, n b ) = e (n b+n s) (n b + n s ) n, (5) n! where n s = ɛ L σ s nd σ s, ɛ, nd L re he sme-sign op pir signl cross secion, he signl efficiency fer cus nd deecor effecs, nd he inegred luminosiy, respecively. The number of bckground evens fer ll cus is denoed by n b. In Eq.5, σ s is ssumed o be free prmeer o be ble o consider vrious FCNC signl cross secions. In order o find he upper limi 95% confidence level (CL) on he signl re (σ 95% ), firs one needs o inegred over he poserior

12 probbiliy: R σ95% P(n σs L, nb )dσs R =.95, P(n σs L, nb )dσs (6) hen solve he Eq.6 under he ssumpion of n = nb fer giving he inpus for he expeced bckground, signl efficiency, nd he inegred luminosiy. The signl efficiencies ( ) for he hree msses of Z re given in Tble. The obined bounds for vrious vlues of inegred luminosiies re shown in Fig.8. As cn be seen, he sme-sign op qurk pir enbles us o consrin u &.5(.3) for mz 4 GeV nd u &.(5) for mz TeV wih he inegred luminosiy of (3) fb. The limis on c re looser due o he lower cross secion of processes involving chrm iniil ses compred wih h of up qurks: c &.(7) for mz 4 GeV, nd c &.25(.) for mz level TeV wih 95% (3) fb of d confidence level 95% CL. 95% confidence.5 f b b i x i ng D m. c = D xin.5 3 D..3. <lexi sh_bse64="lukhfluro6m/vle+c9ijhbuleq=">aaab63icbvbnswmxej3urq/qh69bivgqewwqbvvhisyd+gxuo2zbhsxzjskjz+he8efdeq3/im//gblshbxw8hhvhpl5ysk4sz73juobmvbo+xdy7+wefr9fiky+juu9msyhlysgc5y23irwc/rjmhqsg44vcv97hpthsfqc4sfkgyvjzilnhc8up+yiexvvabxo/iluoebrwpjgksqysfcsyvu8lnsiipwknq8musmsqqdkzpqokikzcblfrxn84zqrjmlslm8uh9pzeqm5oh65tetsyql4v/ef3urjdbxlwswqboclgucmxjnd+orwzsxmeuid7dioiguoviqbgq/nwxmnufddza9xezeuczzuaclsgh2jcpbsgdrqm8ayv8iykekhv6gpzwklfzcn8afr8acigjvo=</lexi> u = <lexi sh_bse64="pnuhxdxhppul+fw2/yusepqgmww=">aaab6nicbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbuhuupbs8okxorwfnptndmu3wzc7kqoot/biwdfvpqlvplv3ly5oudgcd7m8zmcmpdhrenwvb3yhvvr2d3b3qvshjybjnonnlshenqubskngg5oucxqhkrfcc3ubzxbusihncc8icmayuiwsh6d5zz3vvmud6m5bl4hekbguvepx5+wloykmtgdhwvxscnggwtfflpzonli3oghcsvttmjshnp7iivx6jeqlyvkpv6eyglszdgobwdmcwgwvn4n9fjmlokcqhsdlli8vrjgkmzpo36qvngcqxjzrpyw8lbegzwjtqdgq/mwxl8njme7rn93uff3gu4qio4rr8uiq63eidmsbgam/wcm+odf6cd+dj3lpyipld+apn8wduyi</lexi> mi D D c m ixi ng u sh_bse64="x6ezj7o8a7gwrkwfzdrxvcymzua=">aaab9hicdvdlsgmxfm3uv62vqks3wsk4gjkqcbcwy3lcvyb7vaydqgzjjjcqdqhn6hgxekupvj3pk3zvoaftqcnlovdybe8rsgcdk8mrk6b+q3cvbo77xf2dhokszxidrtlsryaloxidragesvwnib5mgdjp5zthxrktqhiyx9m6ukivgaur+bsbjjdf5i45kxblbh3ngsw78qslofec2c3kef3ir6cxsstkcpikxrq9eoofug2cst4dbldy8pgdmdbliocuons6wn+mqqpdypdk8ez93phsjhjgnjkkmlq/pyy8s+vnud/k+fihpgish9rojicjzargnngcgj5zqpoxdfbmhzsbzlgqj+fp9pgmxxi653vylvrxzx5neroknyemxqipuuq3veump6be9oxdn7dw5r87bvdtnlhooq847/m5dg</lexi> <lexi D 9 9 = 3. fb fb fb c.2.2 = fb 3 D b u % confidence level sh_bse64="mevjby5jxz9ezf5fqmzf7ub7e4=">aaab9hicdvdlsgmxfm3uv62vqks3wsk4gjklwegeghuxfewd2qfkrqnzwtg5e6hdpony4ucevhupnvzpqbknog5osce7k3j4ilmedip5nbw9/y3mpvf3z29/ypiodhtrmlmvegi2sk2wexarfgyba8nsoqdyvvb+cbzwxoujyjupuxj7odqmramapw8mkvztdd5i4pnorloh7qtlyd2vfygviufoblnas9v7xo9upwbjybuxsyzoeicfpqqbbjj8vuonhmwvjouqdsxunufht+dizfgvph5e2h4fek5+7hpmwdgxlsgfkfnuz+jfxswbw6dcxqlwxrdboneeoesadwxmjoquso8luimisra5lswix+iv8nzblrede7q5rqv8s48ugenjz5keqqqfbvecnxnadektp6mwzoe/oq/o2km5y55j9apo+xffwzds</lexi> <lexi sh_bse64="tm4hjftd7qxwrk7je5puez7rrxu=">aaab63icbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbuikrcflwyvhcvyd2la2227dhctdjdccflxjwo4u/5m/46bnqvsfddzem2fmxphwpo3nftuljc27z3ybmvv/+dwqhp8fxqghk5jhqhdittmtg2y4bsxkipfygk3nn7lfvejksi+whmcqehkswmyjnlnluvtgsjzxwwce78gnsjqgl/bqoypijkqzjwuu97iqkyrawjnm4rgttbjmpho+prilqonscescxvhlhkjy2zigldtfexkwws9edsfnho96uxif4/ndfnkdgzpizkslwupryzgowpoxftlbg+swqtxeyieywwstyeco2bh/5xxsqbu+5/opv7xmbrfhgc7ghc7bh2owj2oaejvamr/dmcoffexc+lqlp5g5ht9wpn8aylgnya==</lexi>.2 m6 M (GeV) [GeV] 7 8 Z V secion cross cross secion MV [GeV] 5.25 x i ng <lexi f 3 fb fb level fb g % confidence mzm V(GeV) [GeV] cross secion cross secion. MV [GeV] = c ng i x i fb m D. D. D 5. c fb 3 mi u = sh_bse64="bsbttvhhyhl6s35coizgo8gzw=">aaab9hicdvdlsgmxfm3uv62vqks3wsk4gjklpkceghuxfewd2qfkrqnzwtg5e6hdpony4ucevhupnvzpqbknog5osce7k3j4ilmedip5nbwvb38hvfr2d3b3ivshdrmlmve6i2skwwexarf6yba8lsoqdyzvb6cbzm2oujyjupuxi7odoerfmapw8mk3twckrzfxyvm3wcluoclg35ulkc+j585uukillrfj4vykniftbjjwl7jay/proek3x6csgx5sn6ic3lvu5mzpzp8ylvergfxsu4jn6vsolotgtmlcviywh+el4l9eo4h+pz8kfsfafzsp6icsq4szbhbpm5atiyhtau7k2zdqikdmpbhrd8kf6fnmqurzvrlkqxi3iykmjdixokycuubxdohqqi4yecn6ri/o2hlyxp23ewnowfqcoh9w3r8a+koq4g==</lexi>. = + <lexi D 25 m ix i c cross secion cross secion u f ng + D cross secion cross secion.. u. = <lexi sh_bse64="r2owkmpzo/vvvvmqkm8kqeyens=">aaab63icbvbnswmxej3urq/qh69bivgqeykoucl4mvjbfsb7vkybyntbjlkhxkr/gxymixvd3vw3zs9oudgcd7m8zmcxpbjfw8brw9/y3cpvv3z29/ypqodhbronmriwjuwsuyexthdfwpzbwbqjzksggnxcyv3ud56ynjxwj3secskeirp8tmklf3rwbvmlf35scrxc9idqob9wv/jcmqwtkukgm6fleyoommupylnkpzusixrcrqznqcksmscb3zrdz4z4ijwrptfc/x3rekmvmzuk5j7ngse7n4n9dlbxqtzfwlqwwklhzfqca2xvnjemgozmhsfuc3crpmoicbuunoolwv9+ezwl+q+i+zhs4leiowwmcwjn4canuicmidcgj7hfd6qrc/ohxswkuomdmgpcfp8csjv8=</lexi> D m g ixin. D m6 MV(GeV) [GeV] D mi xin g D MV(GeV) [GeV] m6 MV [GeV] MV [GeV] Figure 8: The 95% CL limis on Z (up) nd φ (down) h hve flvor chnging coupling wih up nd op qurks (lef) nd wih chrm nd op qurks (righ). The region o he lef of he plos re excluded up o 95% confidence level wih fb (mgen), 3 fb (blue) nd 3 fb (red) inegred luminosiy. The brown lines represens he D D mixing, where uc =, bu o ge ny bounds from neurl D mixing, we need o hve boh u 6= nd c 6=. For he LHC bounds, we hve ssumed only one flvor chnging couplings: c = (lef) nd u = (righ), bu for he neurl D mixing, we hve o urn boh couplings on. Following excly he sme procedure s used for Z FCNC nlysis nd using he sme cus 2

13 for he sclr medior, he bounds presened in he boom plos of Fig. 8 re derived. Due o he smller cross secion of he sclr, he bounds re weker in erms of he sclr mss. This is he cse for boh LHC limis nd D D limis. 4.. Trnsverse momenum bsed symmery One of he sriking chrcerisics of he signl, +, is he symmery beween he nd cross secions. The producion res of uu nd ūū re differen he LHC due o he fc h u-qurk is vlence qurk nd crries lrger frcion of proon momenum (x) wih respec o he ū-qurk which is se qurk wih PDF pek low energies. This feure is quie helpful in discrimining he signl from he bckground nd hs been lredy proposed in Ref. [66] o sudy he bryon nd lepon number violion he LHC. As he pron disribuion funcions of c-qurk nd c qurk re he sme, he cross secions of cc nd c c re expeced o be similr. In he sme-sign dilepon decy chnnel, he / symmery cn be direcly observed in he chrges of sme-sign dilepon. This ssumpion is relisic s he lepon selecion efficiencies nd lepon conminions from fke do no depend on he chrge. As resul, o disinguish beween he ux nd cx signl scenrios nd o sepre he FCNC signl from he SM bckgrounds, we cn define momenum bsed chrge symmery in he following form: A ll (T ) N l + l +(T ) N l l (T ) N l + l +(T ) + N l l (T ), where T = p T l + p T l2, (7) where p T (l) is he lepon rnsverse momenum nd N l + l +(N l l ) is he number of evens wih opposie(negive)-sign dilepon. The disribuion of he A ll (T ) is presened for boh FCNC signl scenrios uz nd cz nd for he min bckground process in Fig.9. The cross secion for he sme-sign dilepon decy chnnel of he min bckground process i.e. W ± he nex-o-leding order hs been clculed in Ref. [6]. For high p T vlues, he number of posiive lepons should be much higher hn he negive lepons. Hence, if we look his symmery for differen inervls of T, n upwrd rend is observed. This is while, in he bckground he symmery hs downwrd rend versus T. Th is becuse s shown in Fig. 5, he iniil ses h led o l + l +, cn be boh vlence qurks, one vlence qurk nd one se qurk, or boh se qurks. Similrly, he ones h will mke l l cn lso be ny combinions of vlence qurk nd se qurk. There is sligh preference for posiive lepons l + l +, due o he slighly higher PDF of u-qurks compred wih d-qurks, leding o smll posiive A ll. High p T limi corresponds o high Q 2 in he PDFs, nd in high Q 2, digrms wih se qurk iniil se will conribue more significnly, nd hus cuse he symmery o fde off. Furhermore, he difference beween he up nd down PDF in high Q 2 limi lso becomes more negligible which is noher reson he symmery in he bckground hs modes decrese owrds zero. We presen he ol symmery (summed over ll bins) for vrious m Z in Fig., which demonsres smll increse in he vlue of he symmery for lrger m Z. For he cse h we urn u off, nd le c ke non-zero vlues, since chrm nd ni-chrm re boh se qurks wih lmos he sme PDF behvior, he symmery is lmos consn zero. This resul is consisen for ll m Z esed. I is imporn o menion h he inroduced symmery in Eq.7 is sensiive o he choice of proon pron disribuion funcions (PDFs). In mesuremen for such n observble (A ll ), 3

14 A ll Bckground m Z' = 4 GeV, m Z' = GeV, m Z' = 4 GeV, = GeV, m Z' u u c c =. =. =. = p T l + p (GeV) T l2 Figure 9: The behvior of A ll (T ) in erms of T = p T l + p T l2 for wo benchmrk poins of signl nd for he bckground. For he signl benchmrks wih u urned on, he symmery hs n upwrd rend due o he fc h up qurk is vlence qurk nd ni-up qurk is se qurk. For c urned on, boh chrm nd ni-chrm re se qurk leding o lmos consn nd zero vlue for he symmery..8 Signl, =., c =. u.8 Signl, =., c =. u.6.6 A ll A ll.4 Bckground.4 Bckground.2 Signl, =., c =. u m Z' (GeV).2 Signl, =., c =. u m φ (GeV) Figure : The ol symmery is shown s funcion of m med. Noe h for he cse of u nd c =, he symmery increses s funcion of m Z /φ. For c nd u =, however, he ol symmery is zero for ll msses of Z nd φ. one needs o include source of sysemic due o he limied knowledge of he proon PDF. For insnce, we esimed n unceriny from he choice of PDF by clculing he ol symmery wih hree PDF ses: CTEQ6.6 [67], NNPDF [68], nd MSTW [69]. The mximum relive vriion on he symmery is found o be A ll /A ll =.5% for he vecor FCNC couplings wih u =. nd m Z = TeV. 4

15 4..2 Angulr observbles In he ls subsecion, i hs been shown h he rnsverse momenum bsed symmery A ll is sensiive o qx FCNC couplings enbling us o disinguish beween he ux nd cx inercions. However, A ll hs shown negligible sensiiviy o he mss of he medior m Z /φ. In his subsecion, he concenrion is on inroducing sensiive observbles o he mss of he FCNC medior nd could discrimine beween he sclr nd vecor FCNC couplings nd he bckground. In his sudy, one min difference beween he sclr nd vecor signl scenrios nd he bckground is h in he bckground process here is no specific correlion beween he wo jes or he wo lepons while for he signl processes, he finl se pricles re highly correled. This feure of he signl processes (sclr nd vecor) nd bckground could be exmined using he he four momen of he visible pricles in he deecor. We look he following vribles: O = [ẑ ( p b p b2 )][ẑ ( p b p b2 )] m 3 O 2 = [ẑ ( p l p l2 )][ẑ ( p l p l2 )] m 3 (8) where b (l ) is he leding je (lepon), nd b 2 (l 2 ) is he second leding je (lepon). The momenum vecor of ech objec is specified by p, nd ẑ is he direcion long he bem. The disribuions of O nd O 2 observbles for he uz signl wih m Z =, 3 GeV nd for he bckground re depiced in Fig.. As i cn be seen, he disribuions pek zero nd he O nd O 2 disribuions become nrrower wih shrper pek zero when he mss of Z increses. The behviors of he O nd O 2 could be undersood by looking gin he squred mrix elemen of he signl process presened in Fig.6. A low vlues of ŝ, he squred mrix elemen ends o smll vlues nd in priculr for lrger m Z, i grows wih ŝ. As resul, he he op qurks in he for lrge Z mss re boosed which mens heir decy producs re lmos coliner, nd lmos long he sme direcion. Since he op qurks re nerly bck-o-bck, he jes nd lepons re expeced o be bck-o-bck s well. Hence, p b(l) p b(l) 2, leding o O = nd O 2 =. Thereby, he O,2 disribuions for he signl processes should hve pek in round zero, nd he pek ges shrper s he mss of Z increses. Evens.u. Bckground m Z' = 3 GeV = GeV m Z' Evens.u. Bckground m Z' = 3 GeV = GeV m Z' O O 2 Figure : The disribuions of O nd O 2 (defined in Eq. 8) for he signl wih he Z msses of GeV nd 3 GeV nd for he SM bckground. A mesure which qunifies he shrpness of he pek nd heviness of he il is kurosis. 5

16 Shrper peks led o smller vlue of kurosis. We cn hen compre he kurosis for vrious vlues of m Z /φ wih respec o he SM. Fig. 2 demonsres he vlues of kurosis for few benchmrk poins nd he blck dshed-line corresponds o he SM bckground vlue. The rgumen presened solely depends on he vlue of ŝ. To see how he peks zero vries for differen benchmrks, recll h for lrger medior mss, he effec of ŝ is more significn. Consequenly, he pek should be shrper for hevier Z mss, s shown in Fig.. Kurosis O Bckground u =. (vecor) u =. (sclr) Kurosis O Bckground u =. (vecor) u =. (sclr) m Z'/φ (GeV) m Z'/φ (GeV) Figure 2: The kurosis of our benchmrk poins in he O nd O 2 (defined in Eq. 8) disribuion. The blck solid line belongs o he SM vlue. The vlues h belong o o he Z mediion re shown in blue, nd he ones wih sclr medior φ, is in red. The Kurosis for ligher mediors is higher hn he hevier ones. Moreover, he peks when φ is he medior is consisenly shrper hn when Z medies. The O nd O 2 vribles re ble o disinguish beween φ nd Z mediors s hey hve differen spins which leds o some difference in he ngulr disribuion of he finl op qurks. As shown in Fig. 2, he difference is very noiceble especilly for smller m Z /φ. 4.2 Sme-Sign op pir plus W boson To furher enhnce he sensiiviy o he qz nd qφ flvor chnging, we lso look sme-sign op pir + X, where X could be eiher guge boson or je. X cn be deermined such h he rio of signl over bckground is he mos opiml or good sensiiviy is chieved. For he cses X = jes, phoon, or Z, since here re mny colored or elecromgneic chrged inermedie ses in he bckground, he digrms of he bckground increse much fser hn he one of he signl. In priculr, for X = je, significn increse in he signl cross secion is observed however he bckground is more roublesome. For X = W, he increse in he digrms of he bckground is more me, nd beer chnce of improving he sensiiviy is expeced. The represenive leding order Feynmn digrms for W in he SM (lef) nd in he pure FCNC model (righ) re presened in Fig.3. The cross secion of he W in he presence of he FCNC couplings is expeced o be smller hn he signl becuse we re exchnging one of he up qurks wih down qurk in he iniil 6

17 b d - W + W d,s,b u Z'/ φ u - W u Figure 3: Represenive Feynmn digrms for producion of sme-sign op qurk pir in ssociion wih W boson in he SM (lef) nd in he vecor nd sclr FCNC model (righ) he LHC. se nd lso W process hs smller phse spce due o he presence of hevy W boson in he finl se. The producion cross secion of he W process versus he mss of Z nd φ is presened in Fig.4. Less moun of bckground hn he process would conribue which mkes his chnnel ineresing enough o sudy. To sill benefi from sme-sign op pir feures, he leponic decy of he op qurks is considered nd he hdronic decys of he W boson is ken ino ccoun s i hs higher brnching frcion hn he leponic. The min bckground processes re V wih V = W, Z, W ± W ± +jes nd four op qurks producion. The irreducible SM W producion shown in he lef side of Fig.3 is expeced o be negligible due o CKM suppression. Consequenly, i is no considered in he nlysis. The sme s he sme-sign op sudy, he signl nd bckground evens re genered wih MdGrph5-MC@NLO. Then he genered evens re pssed hrough Pyhi 6 for showering nd hdronizion, nd finlly o Delphes 3 o inlcude he deecor level effecs. The signl evens re seleced by requiring excly wo sme-sign chrged lepons wih p l T > 25 GeV nd η < 2.5. The chrged lepons re required o be well-isoled wih RelIso <.5, where RelIso is defined in Eq.4. Jes re reconsruced using he ni-k T lgorihm wih disnce prmeer of.4. Ech even hs o hve les four jes wih p T (j) > 3 GeV nd η j < 2.5 from which wo should be b-gged. The missing rnsverse energy ET miss is required o be greer hn 4 GeV. For furher bckground reducion, lower cu is pplied on he rnsverse mss of he finl se defined s: m T = (E T b + E T b2 + E T l + E T l2 + E miss T ) 2 ( p T b + p T b2 + p T l + p T l + p miss T ) 2, (9) The disribuion of he m T for he W signl wih m Z = 6 GeV nd u =. nd for he he min bckground process i.e. W ± re presened in Fig.4. As i cn be seen, he signl evens end o hve pek lrger vlue wih respec o he bckground. For he bckground, he pek is round 3 GeV while he signl peks round 55 GeV. Therefore, pplying lower cu on m T is useful o suppress he bckground conribuion considerbly. A minimum vlue of 35 GeV is pplied on m T. Afer he cus, sum of he bckground cross secions is found o be.28 fb. The signl efficiencies fer he cus for he Z msses of 4 GeV, 6 GeV, TeV re 2.5%, 2.6%, 2.5%, respecively. 7

18 Evens.u. W Signl (W), m = 6 GeV, =. Z' u m T (GeV) Figure 4: The disribuion of he rnsverse mss m T of he sysem s defined in Eq.9 for he signl wih u =., m Z = 6 GeV nd for he W bckground process. Using he sme sisicl procedure s he one explined previously in Eq.6, upper limis he 95% CL re se on he W cross secion nd he limis re rnsled ino consrins on he prmeer spce of he model, i.e. ( q, m Z /φ). Figure 5 shows he bounds 95% CL on vecor flvor chnging nd sclr flvor chnging wih up nd op qurks nd wih chrm nd op qurks. The exclusion regions re depiced wih fb, 3 fb nd 3 fb inegred luminosiies. According o Fig.5, he W process excludes he prmeers u.3() for m Z 4 GeV nd u.2(.4) for m Z TeV wih (3) fb of inegred luminosiy. As expeced, he limis on c is looser which is found o be c.42(.25) for m Z 4 GeV, nd c.77(.42) for m Z TeV for he inegred luminosiy of (3) fb. Going o higher inegred luminosiies will improve he sensiiviy on u nd c by fcor of round 2. For he sclr scenrio, he sronges limi on he u nd c re.5 nd.45, respecively. The exclusion regions obined from he W process re looser wih respec o hose derived from he process. However, comprison of limis shows h, for given inegred luminosiy, he exclusion borders from chnnel hve lrger slopes in process hn he W. As resul, he combinion of hese wo chnnels would improve he exclusions limis in priculr for he lrge Z /φ mss regions. In he nex subsecion, he combinion procedure nd resuls will be presened. 4.3 Combinion of he nd W chnnels So fr, he sensiiviies of he sme-sign op nd sme-sign op ssocied wih W boson hve been sudied nd he exclusion limis presened in he previous secions. Here, he gol is o combine he wo nlyses which is expeced o provide beer sensiiviy o he prmeer spce of he model. In order o derive he bounds from he combinion of he wo producion mechnisms nd W, he sme sisicl echnique s explined in Eq.5 nd Eq.6 is used. The number of signl is defined s n s = i=chnnels ɛ i σ i L, where i runs over he conribuing processes. I should be noed h he cu efficiencies ɛ i vry depending on he producion mechnisms nd 8

19 cross secion cross secion.. 95% confidence level 95% confidence level cross secion cross secion <lexi sh_bse64="qcqygwv3e3zczzzrvy8hbry=">aaab63icbvbnswmxej2x7v+vt6crbbu8mwgh4lxjxwsb/qliwbzvqjlskwes/qepcjit/kzx9j2dj4yelw3w8y8mbhcwiy/vdlw9s7uxnm/cnb4dhxspt3rmjjvlhvolgldd4lhgivwsdwkk8iziurbfo7nk/98s4bf6poebzjmfi84jtxcl2br9urumlcbxckdaur9ws4jmkqmbjuegmgpk5skbforvsurmmhiwezsiedrxvrditzmbf+jkkwmuxdqvsmip/p7iidrmlkpxkymdmnuvf//zbqmnboomqystnhvoigvymyofxynuwbuirkjhgrubkvsjshsvtcsh46y9vkm6j7uo6/9cszpfhgw4geu4bh9uoax3iyoujjcm7zcmye9f+/d+ilrxi5hz+wpv8ab8cjvq=</lexi> W fb fb 3..8 <lexi sh_bse64="olhjtcjzo+yux4bqdynqeiu6po=">aaab63icbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbuikyi8flx4r2a9oq9lsn+3s3u3ynqil9c948civ/+qn/+nszudj4yelw3w8y8mjhcoud9o6w7z3dvfj+5edw6pikenrwsxfqgg+zwmmfllpdc8jqil7ywguxvk3g2nd7nffelgilg/4izhgjjlslbkos5zyqw2rnc7lycbxckdaqh9wswilmqueymqbv93swmfodgkm+qaxsyxpkpntm+xnvvhebzje3lshvpoxifjusnjkl+nitpwmxvmnyrixk57ufif8xgrzozmuuwrrveqccykf5ymhoem5swjlbmr3uryhbrkmisnd8fff3mtdg5c33p9h3qws/ikmmfxmi+haltbihfrsbwqse4rxehow8oo/ox6q5bqz5/ahzucpjoinna==</lexi>.5 fb.6 fb 3 u c.4 3 <lexi sh_bse64="7ip+w3ghd4kojiofbozrkk5roa=">aaab7xicbvdlsgnbeoynrxhfuy9ebopgkexkqi8blx4jmacks5idtjixszpltk8qlvydfw+kepv/vpk3tpi9gjbqhvtxdxlehhfe/vclg5b2tng3ld/chhupj5pwzxpms26ebvccswbkfdytmi4jspj29hkdu63n7ixqqshncy8joliifgfj3uov2m4xfrvhvfwgytokcvcbho/+6gs2oukelqbtfwewwzlawywelxmp5qmejnjxuuvjbsnsce2mxdhlqibufjifurviyzgk7jyhxgfmd2zul/3ndfic3yszukijxbllomeqcmsxfjwnhoem5dyqyi9yhi2poqxdqcuxqrd68jppxvudvxrcyrwh5hec7ghc4hgguowxoakmhuezxuhn96l9+59lfslxj5zcn/gff4ay6+pnw==</lexi>. fb <lexi sh_bse64="5ilojuocv4szmydpqujalkq8ke=">aaab63icbvbns8naej34wexoxxsj4coku9fjw4rgc/ya2lm2i7d3ytdjvbc/4ixd4p49q9589+ydlo64obx3szzmwle8gn9bxvz2nz3n7jx3t84pdqunzx2tjxqhmwij3qmpqcivy63axqkrylbgn5zefx73cbxhsxqswqdscekr5xrwie26go3xp9ryg68qvsrkir8eozqlezzmgxvr9l7fbrrxltoc8okgnjprn6rj7ovvuogmyxzcpkrixlfoi9lyul9pzfrcxmhnmnphzivrc/m/rpz6dtkuksiysfusqijunxoblxjcykwu4ozy/lbajztzpj4ibh/5xxsuxz9z/ufgvvmo4yjaudwavfgww4r5ayge3igv3hzpppivdsfy9ynp5w5gz9wpn8aihsnma==</lexi>.5.2 cross secion cross secion <lexi sh_bse64="lyuiokwjvuxgvjsw8polgzxdq8u=">aaab63icbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbulkqy8flx4r2a9oq9lsn+3s3u3ynqgl9c948civ/+qn/+nszudj4yelw3w8y8ijbcou+o6w7z3dvfj+5edw6pikenrwvfigo+wsemhdlpdc8gwil78eguxvi3gmd7nfe+lgikg/4jzmvqitlulbkosw29urww3exijvekgncrrh/hogkj4hqzpnyopddgp6ugbzn8urkmlseuzeiedzkqqelwt5e3lshvpoxjgjmsnjkl+nsipcruqqytkvxe9xpzpgyqy3vqphgcxlpvojcrbcosp7gwncgcp4ryozibivssglmmwth+cv7xjuo26599h2szikmmfxmiehadlbihnnsawrse4rxehow8oo/ox6q5bqz5/ahzucphwqnlg==</lexi> % confidence level m MV(GeV) [GeV] cross secion Z MV [GeV] <lexi sh_bse64="uyfad27el+fxpkuzabh6uqrik=">aaab6nicbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbuhewpri8ekhbudbbsbswm7g6ge/gqvhhtx6i/y5r9x2+grq8ghu/nmdmvtaxxxvo+ndlk6r6rnmzsrw9s7x3t94emmgdzzihlvdqlgwsu2dtcc26lcgoccw+hozuq3nlbpnsghm4xiola8ogzqx77kxvwrnc7zydlxckdaoe9vbtgwozrmuk7vpeikfkcczwuulmglpkrnsahusljveh+ezuctmxsp9eibildzmpvydygms9jkpbgvmzivevpzp62qmugpylpmogtzrvemieni9g/s5wqzewnlkfpc3krykcrkje2nykpwf9ejo9nru+5/5rx5dxfggizigu/dheupwcwoaombpmmrvdncexheny958kpzg7hd5zphmmjss=</lexi> W fb <lexi sh_bse64="comofoirdnv3en9xrqu+pm3rq=">aaab7hicbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbulegpbi8ckpi2owy2k3bpzhn2nij/qepcjir/kzx/jpsbwx8s+3hvhpl5ysq4nq777vq2nre2d6q7b39g8oj+vfjryezyuizrcsqfkngkvdtcce6lcgoccu+hrvc7t6gt+sjmuyxhqsecqznvbyvbrobhmv/amsdecvpqin2sp4gcusiejqjwfc9ntzbtztgtok8nmopzvm6xr6lksog3yx7jxcwgveoktzjwzql87chprpydwxltm9grxih+5/uze9gozdpzlcy5aoe8qkplicjlhczstmesou7ssnqgkmmpzkulwvk9ej52rpuc2vyfrruu6jkmkz3aol+dbdbtghrgawmoz/akb45xpx352nzwnhknlp4a+fzb/jqjwc=</lexi> 3 fb 3 fb. 9 <lexi sh_bse64="5ilojuocv4szmydpqujalkq8ke=">aaab63icbvbns8naej34wexoxxsj4coku9fjw4rgc/ya2lm2i7d3ytdjvbc/4ixd4p49q9589+ydlo64obx3szzmwle8gn9bxvz2nz3n7jx3t84pdqunzx2tjxqhmwij3qmpqcivy63axqkrylbgn5zefx73cbxhsxqswqdscekr5xrwie26go3xp9ryg68qvsrkir8eozqlezzmgxvr9l7fbrrxltoc8okgnjprn6rj7ovvuogmyxzcpkrixlfoi9lyul9pzfrcxmhnmnphzivrc/m/rpz6dtkuksiysfusqijunxoblxjcykwu4ozy/lbajztzpj4ibh/5xxsuxz9z/ufgvvmo4yjaudwavfgww4r5ayge3igv3hzpppivdsfy9ynp5w5gz9wpn8aihsnma==</lexi> c.75 u 8 MV [GeV] b f W % confidence level mzm V(GeV) [GeV] cross 6 secion 7 <lexi sh_bse64="m2w9fhdwdg97vnhv9j9jxql5wa=">aaab7hicbvbns8naej3s9vqkcvixwfjki6lhoxwmfxbudbbtbswm7g6ge/gyvhhtx6g/y5r9x+grq8ghu/nmdmvtaxxxnw/dr6xubwdmwnuru3f3byozpu6yrtlpkeynqhkqzwsxzdtecdvpfsbwkgknd4xfewjk8q+mmnkgpimji84jczkvucrqqdw3dnwkvfkuocsruhqz9mbyzggwvc8nzvbtpthvlbzz9plhi6ispwsssmokgnx87w+dwgeioubkwxp9royq2ncwg7y2lgekrxp+8xmimydnmsmk3sxkmoengkupsddrhgymojoyrbwzedewosfkuixjll6+sdspxxmd7ukw3b8s4knakz3abhlxde+6hbt5q4pamr/cgjhpb7+hjbqgypkt+ap+qmboo8</lexi>.4 fb 3 <lexi sh_bse64="m4qwjybilb3vajo6rr8ylzztmi=">aaab63icbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbumkqmecf48v7aeowy2m3bp7ibstoqs+he8efdeq3/im//gpmbwx8mpn6bywzeeehxw/ndlg5b2tnm3srd/chhupt7p2cgxjldzjcptc6jlumjerogs92ldqqok7wbtu9zvpnfjrqfcrzzx9gxfqfgfhpjrv9xhww3cxiovekgncrsg/bkgkj4hqzpnb2ptdgp6ugbzn8xhkklseutemy9zoqqelwtxe3zslfpoxigjmsnjkf+nsipcrmqqytkvxyle9xpzp6ycy3vqphgcxlplojcrbcosp5gwncgcpyryozibivsqglmmwth+cvrxooldz67d4sheuyyzoidl8oagmnaplwgdgwk8wyu8ocp5cd6dj2vryslmtuepnm8fi36nmg==</lexi> W..2 <lexi sh_bse64="7ip+w3ghd4kojiofbozrkk5roa=">aaab7xicbvdlsgnbeoynrxhfuy9ebopgkexkqi8blx4jmacks5idtjixszpltk8qlvydfw+kepv/vpk3tpi9gjbqhvtxdxlehhfe/vclg5b2tng3ld/chhupj5pwzxpms26ebvccswbkfdytmi4jspj29hkdu63n7ixqqshncy8joliifgfj3uov2m4xfrvhvfwgytokcvcbho/+6gs2oukelqbtfwewwzlawywelxmp5qmejnjxuuvjbsnsce2mxdhlqibufjifurviyzgk7jyhxgfmd2zul/3ndfic3yszukijxbllomeqcmsxfjwnhoem5dyqyi9yhi2poqxdqcuxqrd68jppxvudvxrcyrwh5hec7ghc4hgguowxoakmhuezxuhn96l9+59lfslxj5zcn/gff4ay6+pnw==</lexi>.3 3 fb <lexi sh_bse64="uzujebqvz2lw6jyohfr4fjguqk=">aaab63icbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbumomecf48v7aeowy2m3bp7ibstoqs+he8efdeq3/im//gpmbwx8mpn6bywzeeehxw/ndlg5b2tnm3srd/chhupt7p2cgxjldzjcptc6jlumjerogs92ldqqok7wbtu9zvpnfjrqfcrzzx9gxfqfgfhpjrv9xhww3cxiovekgncrsg/bkgkj4hqzpnb2ptdgp6ugbzn8xhkklseutemy9zoqqelwtxe3zslfpoxigjmsnjkf+nsipcrmqqytkvxyle9xpzp6ycy3vqphgcxlplojcrbcosp5gwncgcpyryozibivsqglmmwth+cvrxooldz67d4sheuyyzoidl8oagmnaplwgdgwk8wyu8ocp5cd6dj2vryslmtuepnm8fhu+nlw==</lexi>.5 <lexi sh_bse64="tsmf4nch3yekq+osd5ybf6ou88=">aaab7hicbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbu9hiry8flx4rmlbqhrlzbqlm3y3qgl9dd48civ3+qn/+nmzyhbxw8hhvhpl5ysq4nhh/o5wnz3nepubw//4pcofnzsummkpnpihlvc4lmgkvmg24e66wkktgurbo7wq/+8su5ol8nloubtezsx5xsoyvfoxe49qw3sauxgce68kdsjrh/bqoezjgthgqidd/dqqlyogyngsrgyzlnapgbo+pzletaf54g5urdkcewjsiunwqi/j3isz2lq9szezprq4h/ufmxpdbjmxwypmfusqsvdxorpxxgrmsivdzeiuiekeknzciwv9ezrlwpu95ds9fqlnfu4qzo4ri8uiew3embfkda4rle4c2rzovz7nwswyooxmkf+b8/gd4zor</lexi> <lexi sh_bse64="lyuiokwjvuxgvjsw8polgzxdq8u=">aaab63icbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbulkqy8flx4r2a9oq9lsn+3s3u3ynqgl9c948civ/+qn/+nszudj4yelw3w8y8ijbcou+o6w7z3dvfj+5edw6pikenrwvfigo+wsemhdlpdc8gwil78eguxvi3gmd7nfe+lgikg/4jzmvqitlulbkosw29urww3exijvekgncrrh/hogkj4hqzpnyopddgp6ugbzn8urkmlseuzeiedzkqqelwt5e3lshvpoxjgjmsnjkl+nsipcruqqytkvxe9xpzpgyqy3vqphgcxlpvojcrbcosp7gwncgcp4ryozibivssglmmwth+cv7xjuo26599h2szikmmfxmiehadlbihnnsawrse4rxehow8oo/ox6q5bqz5/ahzucphwqnlg==</lexi> fb 3 <lexi sh_bse64="wf8qebeqybz/lyxbzbsrvry9gu8=">aaab7hicbvbns8naej3urq/qh69lbbbu9iiuo8flx4rmlbqhrlzbqlm3y3qgl9dd48civ3+qn/+nmzyhbxw8hhvhpl5ysq4nhh/o5wnz3nepubw//4pcofnzsummkpnpihlvc4lmgkvmg24e66wkktgurbo7wq/+8su5ol8nloubtezsx5xsoyvfow2b2rdego7eagtrysnkbeej/gowsmsvmgiqinppybiitkccjvdtlnukknzmz6lkosmx3ki2pn6miqixqlypykh+nshjrpusdmntmxer3qf+j/xzxg+rcpplhki4xrzlajkhf52jefngzcwhvhf7k6itoggnp8ibg/5xxsuxi97hop43wdrlhfc7ghc7bgy4b74amfds/wcm+odf6cd+dj2vpxyplt+apn8wcdgoy</lexi> m MV(GeV) [GeV] m MV(GeV) [GeV] (up) nd φ (down) h hve flvor MV [GeV]chnging coupling wih Figure 5: The 95% CL limis onmvz[gev] up nd op qurks (lef) nd wih chrm nd op qurks (righ). The exclusion regions re presened wih fb (pink), 3 fb (blue) nd 3 fb (red) inegred luminosiy. lso for ech process he efficiency is dependen on he mss of he Z /φ. Therefore, o derive 95% CL exclusion limis on he model prmeers q nd mz /φ, one needs o properly considers he selecion efficiencies. The exclusion plos of he combined chnnels 95% CL for (u, mz ) nd (u, mφ ) re depiced in Fig.6. The combinion improves he upper limi on u for vrious msses of Z nd φ in priculr wih he inegred luminosiies of fb nd 3 fb. Wih n inegred luminosiy of fb, for mz (mφ ) = TeV, he upper limi on u ges improved wih n moun of 2%(3%). In Refs. [39,4], he ATLAS nd CMS experimens presened he resuls of serches for monoop evens using he proon-proon collisions he cener-of-mss energy of 8 TeV wih n inegred luminosiy of 2.3 fb nd 9.7 fb, respecively. Boh serches re bsed on he leponic decys of he op qurk which is produced ssocied wih missing energy. For coupling srengh of q =., ATLAS nd CMS excluded Z mss lower hn 523 GeV nd 432 GeV, respecively. From he he combined nlysis of nd W chnnels, wih fb, lower limi of 5 GeV is obined for u =.. 9