arxiv: v2 [hep-lat] 18 Nov 2016

Transcription

1 Lttice Guge Theories nd Spin Models Mnu Mthur nd T. P. Sreerj S. N. Bose Ntionl Centre for Bsic Sciences, Slt Lke, JD Block, Sector 3, Kolkt , Indi The Wegner Z guge theory-z Ising spin model dulity in + 1 dimensions is revisited nd derived through series of cnonicl trnsformtions. The Krmers-Wnnier dulity is similrly obtined. The Wegner Z guge-spin dulity is directly generlized to SUN lttice guge theory in + 1 dimensions to obtin the SUN spin model in terms of the SUN mgnetic fields nd their conjugte SUN electric sclr potentils. The exct & complete solutions of the Z, U1, SUN Guss lw constrints in terms of the corresponding spin or dul potentil opertors re given. The guge-spin dulity nturlly leds to new guge invrint mgnetic disorder opertor for SUN lttice guge theory which produces mgnetic vortex on the plquette. A vritionl ground stte of the SU spin model with nerest neighbor interctions is constructed to nlyze SU guge theory. rxiv: v hep-lt] 18 Nov 016 I. INTRODUCTION In 1971 Frnz Wegner, using dulity trnsformtions, showed tht in two spce dimensions Z lttice guge theory cn be exctly mpped into Z Ising model describing spin hlf mgnets 1]. This is the erliest nd the simplest exmple of the intriguing guge-spin dulity. Wegner s work, in turn, ws strongly motivted by the self-dulity of plnr Ising model discovered by Krmers nd Wnnier 30 yers erlier ]. Such lterntive dul descriptions hve been extensively discussed in the pst s they re useful to understnd theories nd their phses t deeper level 3 13]. In the context of QCD, the dulity trnsformtions hve been studied to understnd color confinement vi dul superconductivity 3 5, 11] nd to extrct topologicl degrees of freedom 6, 7, 1, 13]. They my relte the importnt nd relevnt degrees of freedoms t high nd low energies providing better understnding of non-perturbtive issues in low energy QCD. The dulity ides in the Hmiltonin frmework re lso relevnt for the recent quest to build quntum simultors for belin nd non-belin lttice guge theories using cold toms in opticl lttices 14]. In these cold tom experiments, the dul spin description of SUN lttice guge theory should be useful s there re no exotic, qusi-locl Guss lw constrints to be implemented t every lttice site 15]. The dulity methods nd the resulting spin models, without redundnt locl guge degrees of freedom, cn lso provide more efficient tensor network, vritionl nstzes for the low energy sttes of SUN lttice guge theories 16]. In this work, we strt with brief overview of Krmers- Wnnier nd Wegner dulities within the Hmiltonin frmework. We show tht these old, well-estblished spin-spin nd guge-spin dulities cn be constructively obtined through series of itertive cnonicl trnsformtions. These cnonicl trnsformtion techniques re lectronic ddress: mnu@bose.res.in lectronic ddress: sreerjtp@bose.res.in esily generlized to SUN lttice guge theory to obtin the equivlent dul SUN spin model without ny locl guge degrees of freedom. Thus using cnonicl trnsformtions we re ble to tret spin, belin nd non-belin dulities on the sme footing. In + 1 dimensions the spin opertors in the dul spin models re the sclr Z, U1, SUN mgnetic fields nd their conjugte electric sclr potentils respectively. These spin opertors solve the Z, U1 nd SUN Guss lws. The Krmers-Wnnier nd Wegner dulities nturlly led to construction of disorder opertors nd orderdisorder lgebrs 8 10]. In both cses the disorder opertors re simply the dul spin opertors creting Z kinks nd Z mgnetic vortices on plquettes respectively. Note tht these cretion opertors re highly nonlocl in terms of the opertors of the originl Ising model or Z guge theory. Therefore without dulity trnsformtions they re difficult to guess. We generlize these elementry dulity ides to non-belin guge theories fter briefly recpitulting them in the simpler Z contexts mentioned bove. In prticulr, we exploit SUN dul spin opertors to construct new guge invrint disorder opertor for SUN lttice guge theory. Further, like in Z lttice guge theory, the non-belin order-disorder lgebr involving SUN Wilson loops nd SUN disorder opertors is worked out. The interesting role of non-loclities in non-belin dulity resulting in the solutions of SUN Guss lws nd production of locl vortices is discussed. For the ske of clrity nd continuity, the SUN guge theory results will lwys be discussed in the bckground of the corresponding Ising model, Z guge theory results. The similr fetures mongst them re emphsized nd the differences re lso pointed out. In the context of Z guge theory in +1 dimensions, the two essentil fetures of Wegner dulity 1] re it elimintes ll unphysicl guge degrees of freedom mpping it into Z spin model with Z globl symmetry. There re no Z Guss lw constrints in the dul Z spin model. it mps the intercting non-intercting terms in the Z lttice guge theory Hmiltonin into nonintercting intercting terms in the Z spin model

2 Hmiltonin resulting in the inversion of the coupling constnt. It is importnt to note tht the bove guge-spin dulity is through the loop description of Z lttice guge theory. The originl Hmiltonin is written in terms of fundmentl Z electric fields nd their conjugte mgnetic vector potentils. The Z mgnetic fields re not fundmentl nd obtined from mgnetic vector potentils. On the other hnd, in the dul Ising model the fundmentl spin degrees of freedom re the Z mgnetic fields nd their conjugte electric sclr potentils. Now the electric fields re not fundmentl nd re obtined from the electric sclr potentils. We rrive t this dul spin description through series of cnonicl trnsformtions. They convert the initil electric fields, mgnetic vector potentils into the following two mutully independent physicl & unphysicl clsses of opertors: 1. Z spin or plquette loop opertors: representing the physicl Z mgnetic fields nd their conjugte electric sclr potentils over the plquettes see Figure 5-,. Z string opertors: representing the Z electric fields nd the Z flux opertors of the unphysicl string degrees of freedom. These strings isolte ll Z guge degrees of freedom see Figure 5-b. The interctions of spins in the first set re described by Ising model. The corresponding physicl Hilbert spce is denoted by H p. The second complimentry set, contining Z string opertors, represents ll possible redundnt guge degrees of freedom. We show tht the Guss lw constrints freeze ll strings leding to the Wegner gugespin dulity within H p. Further, the electric sclr potentils re shown to be the solutions of the Z Guss lw constrints. Note tht no guge fixing is required to obtin the dul description. We show tht the bove dulity fetures lso remin vlid when these cnonicl/dulity trnsformtions re generlized to SUN lttice guge theory. As in the Z cse, the SUN Kogut-Susskind link opertors get trnsformed into the physicl spin/loop nd unphysicl string opertors. Agin the SUN strings re frozen nd the dul SUN spin opertors provide ll solutions of SUN Guss lw constrints. In fct, these SUN cnonicl trnsformtions hve been discussed erlier in the context of loop formultion of SUN lttice guge theories 17, 18]. The motivtion ws to ddress the issue of redundncies of Wilson loops or equivlently solve the SUN Mndelstm constrints. We now exploit them in the context of non-belin dulity. The pln of the pper is s follows. In section II, we discuss the cnonicl trnsformtion techniques to systemticlly obtin Krmers-Wnnier, Wegner nd then SUN dulities. The compct U1 lttice guge theory dulity cn lso be esily obtined from the SUN dulity by ignoring the non-belin, non-locl terms. In section II A, we strt with the simplest Krmers-Wnnier dulity in the Ising model. The order-disorder opertors, their lgebrs nd cretion, nnihiltion of kinks re briefly discussed for the ske of uniformity nd lter comprisons, 7 10, 19]. In section II A 1, we extend these cnonicl trnsformtions to discuss Wegner dulity in + 1 dimensions. We gin obtin the old nd well estblished results 1, 7 10] with cnonicl trnsformtions s the new ingredients. The Z guge theory order-disorder opertors, their lgebrs nd Z mgnetic vortices re briefly summrized. In section II C, the Z cnonicl trnsformtions re generlized to SUN lttice guge theories leding to SUN spin model. As mentioned before the SUN discussions re prllel to the Z discussions for clrity. A comprtive summry of Z guge-spin nd SUN guge-spin opertors is given in Tble 1. At the end of section II C, we construct the new SUN disorder opertor. The specil cse of t Hooft disorder opertor is discussed. The Wilson- t Hooft loop lgebr is derived. The lst section III is devoted to vritionl nlyses of the truncted SUN spin model. A simple single spin vritionl ground stte of the dul SUN spin model is constructed. The Wilson loop in this ground stte is shown to hve re lw behvior. In Appendix A, we discuss explicit constructions of Z Wegner dulity through cnonicl trnsformtions. In Appendix B, we discuss the highly restrictive, non-locl structure of SUN dulity trnsformtions. We explicitly show the non-trivil cncelltions of infinite number of terms required to solve the SUN Guss lw constrints by the dul SUN spin opertors. In prt of Appendix B, nother set of non-trivil cncelltions re shown to hold for the SUN disorder opertor to hve locl physicl ction in the originl Kogut-Susskind formultion. In the cse of much simpler Z Wegner dulity such cncelltions re obvious. In Appendix C, we show tht the single spin vritionl stte stisfies Wilson s re lw. In Appendix D, the expecttion vlue of the truncted dul spin Hmiltonin is computed in the vritionl ground stte. The expecttion vlue of the non-locl prt of the spin Hmiltonin in the bove disordered vritionl ground stte is shown to vnish. This shows tht non-locl terms ppering with higher powers of coupling g n, n 3 my be treted perturbtively s g 0 for the continuum. Throughout this work, we use Hmiltonin formultion of lttice guge theories 0] with open boundry conditions. We work in two spce dimensions on finite lttice Λ with N = N + 1 N + 1 sites, L = NN + 1 links, P = N plquettes stisfying: L = P + N 1. A lttice site is denoted by n or m, n with m, n = 0, 1,, N. The links re denoted by l or m, n; î with i = 1,. The plquettes re denoted by the coordintes of their upper right corner nd sometimes by p, p etc.. Any conjugte pir opertor P, X stisfying the corresponding conjugte cnonicl commuttion reltions will be denoted by P ; X. In Ising model, Ising guge theory, they re the Puli spin opertors σ 1 ; σ 3, µ 1 ; µ 3. In SUN lttice guge theory, they re the

3 3 Kogut-Susskind electric fields, link opertors ; U αβ. Similrly, the cnoniclly conjugte SUN spin, string opertors in the dul spin models re defined in the text. II. DUALITY AND CANONICAL TRANSFORMATIONS A. Krmers-Wnnier dulity Krmers Wnnier dulity ws the first nd the simplest dulity, prt from electromgnetism, to be constructed. As prelude to the construction of dulities in Z nd SUN lttice guge theories, we pply cnonicl trnsformtions to dimensionl Ising model to get the Krmers-Wnnier dulity. The Ising Hmiltonin in one spce dimension is in terms of the cnoniclly conjugte opertors σ 1 ; σ 3 t every lttice site stisfying, σ 1m = 1; σ 3m = 1; 1 σ 1 mσ 3 m = σ 3 mσ 1 m or σ 1 m, σ 3 m] + = 0. The Hmiltonin is H = m=0 ] σ 1 m λ σ 3 mσ 3 m + 1. The Krmers-Wnnier dulity is obtined by the following itertive cnonicl trnsformtions long line with σ 3 m = 0 σ 3 m = 0 nd σ 1 m = 0 σ 1 m = 0: µ 1 m σ 3 mσ 3 m + 1, µ 3 m = σ 1 m 3 σ 3 m + 1 = σ 3 m + 1, σ 1 m + 1 = σ 1 mσ 1 m + 1 = µ 3 mσ 1 m + 1. The bove cnonicl trnsformtions itertively replce the conjugte pir σ 1 m; σ 3 m or equivlently σ 1 m; σ 3 m by new conjugte pir µ 1 m; µ 3 m. These new pirs re mutully independent nd lso stisfy the cnonicl reltions 1. Unlike guge theories to be discussed in the next section, there re no spurious string degrees of freedom. This process is grphiclly illustrted in Figure 1. The reltions 3 led to, µ 3 m = m σ 1 s. 4 s=0 The reltions 4 cn be esily inverted to give σ 1 m = µ 3 mµ 3 m 1 with the convention µ 3 m = 1 1. The Ising model Hmiltonin cn now be rewritten in its self-dul form in terms of the new dul conjugte pirs µ 1 m; µ 3 m: H = m=0 ] µ 3 mµ 3 m + 1 λ µ 1 m. 5 σ 10; σ 30 σ 10; σ 30 µ 10; µ 30 σ 11; σ 31 σ 1; σ 3 σ 11; σ 31 σ 1; σ 3 µ 11; µ 31 σ 1; σ 3 σ 13; σ 33 µ 1; µ 3 σ 13; σ 33 FIG. 1: Krmers-Wnnier dulity through cnonicl trnsformtions. The first three steps of dulity or cnonicl trnsformtions in 3 re illustrted. Therefore, Hσ; λ = λ 1 Hµ; λ 1. This is the fmous Krmers-Wnnier self dulity. As expected, dulity hs interchnged the intercting nd non intercting prts of the Hmiltonin on going from the σ 1, σ 3 to the dul µ 1, µ 3 vribles. In other words, dulity/cnonicl trnsformtions 3 mp strong coupling region to the wek coupling region nd vice vers. 1. Ising disorder opertor In Ising model the mgnetiztion opertor, σ 3 m is the order opertor s its expecttion vlue mesures the degree of order of the σ 3 vribles. It is zero for λ < λ c nd non-zero for λ > λ c. This implies tht the λ > λ c phse spontneously breks the globl Z symmetry: σ 3 σ 3. On the other hnd, the dul Hmiltonin 5 implies tht it is nturl to define µ 3 m s disorder opertor 8 10]. The vcuum expecttion vlue λ 0 µ 3 m 0 λ is the disorder prmeter. We lso note tht the disorder opertor µ 3 x 0 cting on completely ordered stte ll σ 3 m = +1 or 1, flips ll σ 3 spins t m < x 0 nd cretes kink t x 0. The resulting kink stte is orthogonl to the originl ordered stte nd the expecttion vlue of the disorder opertor µ 3 in n ordered stte vnishes: λ= 0 µ 3m 0 λ= = 0, λ= 0 σ 3m 0 λ= = 1. 6 On the other hnd, t λ = 0, the dul description 5 implies tht the Ising model is in ordered stte with respect to µ 3. As consequence, the disorder prmeter does not vnish nd order prmeter vnishes: λ=0 0 µ 3m 0 λ=0 = 1, λ=0 0 σ 3m 0 λ=0 = 0. 7

4 4 σ 3 = 0 σ 3 = 0 λ = 0 µ 3 = 0 λ = λ c = 1 µ 3 = 0 λ = disordered phse ordered phse FIG. : Dulity nd ordered & disordered phses of dimensionl Ising model 8 10]. The reltions 6, 7 re illustrted in Figure. B. Wegner dulity nd Z Spin Model Z nd Z N lttice guge theories re the simplest theories with guge structure nd mny rich fetures. Due to their enormous simplicity compred to U1 or nonbelin lttice guge theories nd the presence of confining phse, they hve been used s simple theoreticl lbortory to test vrious confinement ides 10]. They lso provide n explicit reliztion of the Wilson- t Hoofts lgebr of order nd disorder opertors chrcterizing different possible phses of the SUN guge theories 4, 10]. In 1964, Schultz, Mttis nd Lieb showed tht the two-dimensionl Z Ising model is equivlent to system of loclly coupled fermions 1]. This result ws lter extended to Z lttice guge theory which lso llows n equivlent description in terms of loclly intercting fermions ]. These re old nd well known results. In the recent pst, Z Z N lttice guge theories hve been useful to understnd quntum spin models 3], quntum computtions 4], tensor network or mtrix product sttes 5] nd their topologicl properties 6], cold tom simultions 14] nd entnglement entropy 7]. In view of these wide pplictions, the Z Z N lttice guge theories nd ssocited dulity trnsformtions re importnt in their own right. The Z lttice guge theory involves Z conjugte spin opertors σ 1 l; σ 3 l on the link l Λ. The nticommuttion reltions mongst these conjugte pirs on every link l re σ 1 l σ 3 l + σ 3 l σ 1 l = 0. 8 They further stisfy: σ 3 l = σ 1 l = 1. In order to mintin 1-1 correspondence with SUN lttice guge theory discussed in the next section, it is convenient to identify the conjugte pirs σ 1 l; σ 3 l with Z electric field, l nd Z vector potentil, Al s: σ 1 l = e iπl, σ 3 l = e ial. 9 Above l 0, 1 nd Al 0, π. A bsis of the two dimensionl Hilbert spce on ech link l is chosen to be the eigensttes ±, l of σ 3 l with eigenvlue ±1 with σ 1 l cting s spin flip opertor: σ 3 l ±, l = ± ±, l, σ 1 l ±, l =, l. 10 The Z lttice guge theory Hmiltonin is given by H = l Λ σ 1 l λ p Λ σ 3 l 1 σ 3 l σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l 4 H + λh B. 11 In 11 σ 3 l 1 σ 3 l σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l 4 represents the product of σ 3 opertors long the four links of plquette. The sum over l nd p in 11 re the sums over ll links nd plquettes respectively. The prmeter λ is the Z guge theory coupling constnt. The first term H nd the second term H B in 11 represent the Z electric nd mgnetic field opertors respectively. The electric field opertor σ 1 l is fundmentl while the ltter is composite of the four Z mgnetic vector potentil opertors σ 3 l long plquette. After series of cnonicl trnsformtions, the bove chrcteriztion of electric, mgnetic field will be reversed. More explicitly, the dynmics will be described by the Hmiltonin 11 rewritten in terms of the fundmentl mgnetic field the second term nd the electric field opertor the first term will be composite of the dul electric sclr potentils see 6 nd 31. The sme feture will be repeted in the SUN cse discussed in the next section. The Hmiltonin 11 remins invrint if ll 4 spins ttched to the 4 links emnting from site n re flipped simultneously. This symmetry opertion is implemented by the Guss lw opertor G: Gn l n σ 1 l n 1 t lttice site n Λ. In 1, l n represents the product over 4 links denoted by l n which shre the lttice site n in two spce dimensions. The Z guge trnsformtions re σ 1 l G 1 nσ 1 lgn = σ 1 l, l Λ, σ 3 l n G 1 nσ 3 l n Gn = σ 3 l n, 13 H G 1 n H Gn = H. Thus, under guge trnsformtion t site n, the 4 link flux opertor σ 3 l n on the 4 links l n shring the lttice site n chnge sign. All other σ 3 l remin invrint. The physicl Hilbert spce H p consists of the sttes phys stisfying the Guss lw constrints: Gn phys = phys or Gn 1 n Λ. 14 In other words, Gn re unit opertors within the physicl Hilbert spce H p. All opertor identities vlid only within H p re expressed by sign. We now cnoniclly trnsform this simplest Z guge theory with constrints 1 t every lttice site into Z spin model without ny constrints s shown in Figure 3. To keep the discussion simple, we strt with single plquette OABC shown in Fig. 4- before deling with the entire lttice. As the cnonicl trnsformtions re itertive in nture, this

5 5 Z lttice guge theory Z spin model. n Z Dulity/Cnonicl trnsformtions µ 1 ; µ 3 σ 1 ; σ 3 Locl Guss lw : G n = σ 1 n, î σ 1 n î, î = 1 i=1 No Guss lw constrints FIG. 3: Dulity between Z lttice guge theory nd Z Ising spin model. The initil nd the finl conjugte pirs σ 1; σ 3 nd µ 1; µ 3, re defined on the links nd the plquettes or dul sites respectively. The corresponding SUN dulity is illustrted in Figure 9. simple exmple contins ll the essentil ingredients required to understnd the finite lttice cse. The four links OA, AB, BC, CO will be denoted by l 1, l, l 3, l 4 respectively. In this simplest cse there re four Z guge trnsformtion or equivlently Guss lw opertors 1 t ech of the four corners O, A, B nd C: GO = G0, 0 = σ 1 l 4 σ 1 l 1 1, GA = G1, 0 = σ 1 l 1 σ 1 l 1, GB = G1, 1 = σ 1 l σ 1 l 3 1, GC = G0, 1 = σ 1 l 3 σ 1 l Note tht these Guss lw opertors stisfy trivil opertor identity: GO GA GB GC The bove identity sttes the obvious result tht simultneous flippings t ll 4 sites hs no effect. This is becuse of the belin nture of the guge group. We now strt with the four initil conjugte pirs on links l 1, l, l 3 nd l 4 : σ 1 l 1 ; σ 3 l 1, σ 1 l ; σ 3 l, σ 1 l 3 ; σ 3 l 3, σ 1 l 4 ; σ 3 l Using cnonicl trnsformtions we define four new but equivlent conjugte pirs. The first three string conjugte pirs: σ 1 l 1 ; σ 3 l 1, σ 1 l ; σ 3 l, σ 1 l 4 ; σ 3 l 4 describe the collective excittions on the links OA, AB, BC nd shown in Figures 4-b,,c respectively. The remining collective excittions over the plquette or the loop p OABC re described by µ 1 p; µ 3 p nd shown in Figure 4-c. As consequence of the three mutully independent Guss lw constrints GA, GB nd GC, the three string electric fields re frozen to the vlue +1. Therefore there is no dynmics ssocited with the three strings. In other words, string degrees of freedom completely decouple from H p. We re thus left with the finl physicl Z spin opertors µ 1 p; µ 3 p which re explicitly Z guge invrint. These dulity trnsformtions from guge vrint link opertors to guge invrint spin or loop opertors re shown in Figure 3. To demonstrte the bove results, we strt with the initil link opertors σ 1 l 3 ; σ 3 l 3 nd σ 1 l ; σ 3 l s shown in Fig. 4-. As ws done in dimensionl Ising model, we glue them using cnonicl trnsformtions s follows: σ 3 l σ 3 l, σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l σ 1 l = σ 1 l 3 σ 1 l GB, σ 1 l 3 = σ 1 l The cnonicl trnsformtions 18 re illustrted in Fig. 4-. After the trnsformtions, the two new but equivlent cnonicl sets σ 1 l = GB; σ 3 l, σ 1 l 3 ; σ 3 l 3 re ttched to the links l nd l 3 l 3 l respectively. They stisfy the sme commuttion reltions s the originl opertors 8: σ 1 l σ 3 l + σ 3 l σ 1 l = 0, 19 σ 1 l 3 σ 3 l 3 + σ 3 l 3 σ 1 l 3 = 0. One cn esily check: σ 1l = 1, σ 3l = 1, σ 1 l 3 = 1, σ 3 l 3 = 1. Further, note tht the two conjugte pirs σ 1 l ; σ 3 l nd σ 1 l 3 l ; σ 3 l 3 l re lso mutully independent s they commute with ech other. As n exmple, σ 1 l, σ 3 l 3 l ] σ 1 l 3 σ 1 l, σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l ] = 0. The new conjugte pir σ 1 l ; σ 3 l is frozen due to the Guss lw t B: σ 1 l = GB 1 in H p. We now repet 18 with l, l 3 replced by l 1, l 3 respectively to define new conjugte opertors σ 1 l 1 ; σ 3 l 1 nd

6 6 σ1l4, σ3l4 σ1l4; σ3l4 σ1l4; σ3l4 C σ 1l 3; σ 3l 3 B O σ1l1; σ3l1 A σ 1l 3; σ 3l 3 σ 1l 1; σ 3l 1 σ 1l 31; σ 3l 31 σ1l; σ3l b c σ1l4; σ3l4 Frozen σ1l4 = GC; σ3l4 σ1l4; σ3l4 σ 1l 3; σ 3l 3 σ 1l 1; σ 3l 1 σ1l = GB; σ3l σ 1l 31; σ 3l 31 σ1l1 = GAGB; σ3l1 µ 1 p; µ 3 p Physicl Loop Opertor FIG. 4: The Z cnonicl trnsformtions 18, 0, 1 nd 1b re pictorilly illustrted in, b nd c respectively. The nd represent the electric fields of the initil horizontl nd verticl links respectively. σ 1 l 31 ; σ 3 l 31 ttched to the links l 1 nd l 31 l 3 l l 1 respectively: σ 3 l 1 σ 3 l 1, σ 3 l 31 σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l 1 0 σ 1 l 1 = σ 1 l 3 σ 1 l 1 = GAGB, σ 1 l 31 = σ 1 l 3. As before, the new conjugte pir σ 1 l 1 ; σ 3 l becomes unphysicl s σ 1 l 1 = GAGB 1 in H p. The lst cnonicl trnsformtions involve gluing the conjugte pirs σ 1 l 31 ; σ 3 l 31 with σ 1 l 4 ; σ 3 l 4 to define the dul nd guge invrint plquette vribles µ 1 p; µ 3 p, with p l 1 l l 3 l 4 : µ 1 p σ 3 l 31 σ 3 l 4 σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l σ 3 l 1 σ 3 l 4. µ 3 p σ 1 l 31 = σ 1 l 3, 1 σ 3 l 4 σ 3 l 4, 1b σ 1 l 4 = σ 1 l 31 σ 1 l 4 = σ 1 l 3 σ 1 l 4 GC. To summrize, the three cnonicl trnsformtions 18, 0, 1 nd 1b trnsform the initil four conjugte sets σ 1 l 1 ; σ 3 l 1,σ 1 l ; σ 3 l,σ 1 l 3 ; σ 3 l 3, σ 1 l 4 ; σ 3 l 4 ttched to the links l 1, l, l 3, l 4 to four new nd equivlent cnonicl sets σ 1 l ; σ 3 l, σ 1 l 1 ; σ 3 l 1, σ 1 l 4 ; σ 3 l 4 nd Frozen Frozen µ 1 p; µ 3 p ttched to the links l, l 1, l 4 nd the plquette p respectively. The dvntge of the new sets is tht ll the three independent Guss lw constrints t A, B nd C re utomticlly solved. They freeze the three strings leving us only with the physicl spin or plquette loop conjugte opertors µ 1 p; µ 3 p. The defining cnonicl reltions 18, 0, 1 nd 1b cn lso be inverted. The inverse trnsformtions from the new spin flux opertors to Z link flux opertors re σ 3 l 1 = σ 3 l 1, σ 3 l = σ 3 l, σ 3 l 3 = µ 1 p σ 3 l 4 σ 3 l 1 σ 3 l, σ 3 l 4 = σ 3 l 4. Similrly, the initil conjugte Z electric field opertors on the links re σ 1 l 1 = µ 3 p σ 1 l 1 = µ 3 p GAGB µ 3 p, σ 1 l = µ 3 p σ 1 l = µ 3 p GB µ 3 p 3 σ 1 l 3 = µ 3 p, σ 1 l 4 = µ 3 p σ 1 l 4 = µ 3 p GC µ 3 p. Thus the complete set of guge-spin dulity reltions over plquette nd their inverses re given in 18, 0, 1, 1b nd, 3 respectively. Note tht the Guss lw constrint t the origin does not ply ny role s GO GA GB GC. The totl number of degrees of freedom lso mtch. The initil Z guge theory hd 4 spins with 3 Guss lw constrints. In the finl dul spin model the 3 guge non-invrint strings tke cre of the 3 Guss lw constrints leving us with the single guge invrint spin described by µ 1 p; µ 3 p on the plquette p. The single plquette Z lttice guge theory Hmiltonin 11 cn now be rewritten in terms of the new guge invrint spins s: H 4 µ 3 p λ µ 1 p = λ 4 4 λ. 4 Note tht the equivlence of the guge nd spin Hmiltonins 11 nd 4 respectively is vlid only within the physicl Hilbert spce H p. The two energy eigenvlues of H re ɛ ± = ±4 1 + λ 4. Hving discussed the essentil ides, we now directly write down the generl Z guge-spin dulity or cnonicl reltions over the entire lttice. The detils of these itertive cnonicl trnsformtions nlogous to 18, 0, 1 nd 1b re given in Appendix A. Note tht there re L initil spins one on every link with N Guss lw constrints one t every site stisfying the identity: Gm, n 1. 5 m,n Λ The bove identity gin sttes tht simultneous flipping of ll spins round every lttice site is n identity opertor becuse ech spin is flipped twice. As mentioned erlier, it is property of ll belin guge theories which reduces the number of Guss lw constrints

7 7 n, 0, 1, n, µ 1 m, n; µ 3 m, n re see Appendix A µ 1 n; µ 3 n σ1 n; σ3 n µ 1 m, n = σ 3 m 1, n 1; ˆ1 σ 3 m 1, n 1; ˆ σ 3 m, n; ˆσ 3 m, n; ˆ1, 6 0, 1 1, 1, 1 0, 0 Z spins/loops physicl 0, 0 1, 0, 0 Z strings unphysicl FIG. 5: The physicl Z spin conjugte pirs µ 1 n; µ 3 n nd the unphysicl string conjugte pirs σ 1 n; σ 3 n dul to Z lttice guge theory re shown in nd b respectively. The co-ordintes of spin or loop opertors re the co-ordintes of their top right corners. The co-ordintes of the horizontl verticl strings re the co-ordintes of their right top end points. These re shown by in nd b. The strings decouple from the physicl Hilbert spce s σ 1 n = G n 1 by Guss lw constrint t n. The corresponding dul SUN spin nd SUN string opertors re shown in Figure 10-,b respectively. from N to N 1. In the non-belin SUN cse, discussed in the next section, there is no such reduction. The globl SUN guge trnsformtions, corresponding to the extr Guss lw constrints t the origin G 0, 0 = 1, need to be fixed by hnd to get the correct number of physicl degrees of freedom see section II C 3. After cnonicl trnsformtions in Z lttice guge theory, there re P physicl plquette spins nlogous to µ 1 p; µ 3 p in the single plquette cse shown in Figure 5- nd b N 1 stringy spins nlogous to σ 1 l 1 ; σ 3 l 1 ; σ 1 l ; σ 3 l nd σ 1 l 4 ; σ 3 l 4 in the single plquette cse s every lttice site wy from the origin cn be ttched to unique string. This is shown in Figure 5-b. The degrees of freedom before nd fter the cnonicl trnsformtions mtch s L = P + N 1. All N 1 strings decouple becuse of the N 1 Guss lw constrints. The lgebric detils of these trnsformtions leding to freezing of ll strings re worked out in detil in Appendix A. From now onwrd the P physicl plquette spin/loop opertors re lbelled by the top right corners of the corresponding plquettes s shown in Figure 5-. The verticl horizontl stringy spin opertors re lbelled by the top right end points of the corresponding links s shown in Figure 5-b. The sme nottion will be used to lbel the dul SUN opertors in section II C. 1. Physicl sector nd Z dul potentils The finl dulity reltions between the initil conjugte sets σ 1 m, n; î; σ 3 m, n; î on every lttice link m, n; î nd the finl physicl conjugte loop opertors b µ 3 m, n = N n =n σ 1 m 1, n ; ˆ1. 6b In 6 we hve defined σ 1 m, n; ˆ1 σ 1 m 1, n; ˆ1 nd σ 1 m, n; ˆ σ 1 m, n 1; ˆ. The reltions 6 nd 6b re the extension of the single plquette reltions 1 to the entire lttice. They re illustrted in Figure 6-. The cnonicl commuttion reltions re µ 1 m, nµ 3 m, n + µ 3 m, nµ 1 m, n = 0. 7 Further, µ 3 m, n = 1, µ 1 m, n = 1. The cnonicl trnsformtions 6 re importnt s they define the mgnetic field opertors µ 1 m, n nd its conjugte µ 3 m, n s new dul fundmentl opertors. The electric field is derived from the electric sclr potentils. This should be contrsted with the originl description where electric fields σ 1 m, n were fundmentl nd the mgnetic fields were derived from the mgnetic mgnetic vector potentils s σ 3 l 1 σ 3 l σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l 4.. Unphysicl sector nd Z string opertors The unphysicl string conjugte pir opertors re see Appendix A σ 3 m, 0 = σ 3 m 1, 0; ˆ1, σ 3 m, n = σ 3 m, n 1; ˆ; n 0 8 σ 1 m, 0 = σ 1 m, n = m 1 m =0 n =0 N n =n N Gm, n 1, Gm, n 1; n 0. 8b The reltions 8 nd 8b re illustrted in Figure 6-b nd Figure 6-c respectively. It is esy to see tht in the full guge theory Hilbert spce σ 1 m, n σ 3 m, n + σ 3 m, n σ 1 m, n = 0 nd different string opertors locted t different lttice sites commute with ech others. Further, one cn check tht ll strings nd plquette opertors re mutully independent nd commute with ech other: µ 3 m, n, σ 1 m, n ] = 0, µ 3 m, n, σ 3 m, n ] = 0, 9 µ 1 m, n, σ 1 m, n ] = 0, µ 1 m, n, σ 3 m, n ] = 0.

8 8 µ3m, n m, n σ1m, n m, n σ1m, 0 m, 0 b c FIG. 6: The non-locl reltions in the Z guge-spin dulity trnsformtions: shows the reltions 6b expressing µ 3m, n s the product of σ 1 opertors denoted by. In b nd c, we show the reltions 8b expressing σ 1m, 0 nd σ 1m, n; n 0 respectively s the product of σ 1 opertors denoted by. As σ 1 = 1, the string opertors σ 1m, 0 nd σ 1m, n re lso product of Guss lw opertors t sites mrked by x in the shded regions. For similr SUN reltions, see Figures Inverse reltions The inverse reltions for the flux opertors over the entire lttice re σ 3 m, 0; ˆ1 = σ 3 m + 1, 0, σ 3 m, n; ˆ = σ 3 m, n + 1 n n σ 3 m, n; ˆ1 = σ 3 m, l l=1 q=1 σ 3 m + 1, q n µ 1 m + 1, p ; n 0 30 p=1 On the other hnd, the conjugte electric field opertors re σ 1 m, n; ˆ1 = µ 3 m, nµ 3 m, n + 1, σ 1 m, n; ˆ = µ 3 m, n + 1µ 3 m + 1, n In the second reltion in 31, we hve used Guss lws t m, l ; l = n + 1, n +,. The bove reltions re nlogous to the inverse reltions nd 3 in the single plquette cse. σ 1 l 3 σ 1 m 1, n; ˆ1 = µ 3 p 3 µ 3 p 4, σ 1 l 4 σ 1 m, n 1; ˆ = µ 3 p 4 µ 3 p 1. 3 In 3 we hve used link nd plquette lbels from Figure 7. As µ 3p = 1, we get Gm, n = σ 1 l 1 σ 1 l σ 1 l 3 σ 1 l The bove dulity property lso generlizes to the SUN cse. The dul SUN spin opertors or potentils re the solutions of locl SUN Guss lws t ll the sites except origin. However, unlike the trivil cncelltions bove, the non-belin cncelltions re highly nontrivil nd re worked out in detil in Appendix B 1. µ 3 p σ 1 l 1 µ 3 p 3 = 1 σ 1 l 3 σ 1 l µ 3 p = 1 σ 1 l 1 4. Z Guss lws & solutions µ 3 p 1 µ 3 p 4 = 1 σ 1 l 4 µ 3 p 1 = 1 It is esy to see tht the Guss lw constrints re utomticlly stisfied by the dul spin opertors s shown in Figure 7-,b. We write the Z electric fields round site m, n in terms of the electric sclr potentils: σ 1 l 1 σ 1 m, n; ˆ1 = µ 3 p 1 µ 3 p, σ 1 l σ 1 m, n; ˆ = µ 3 p µ 3 p 3, 0, 0 0, 0 FIG. 7: shows the Z link electric field opertor σ 1m, n; ˆ1 s the product of nerest neighbor loop opertors µ 3p 1 nd µ 3p, b grphiclly illustrtes how the spin or electric potentil opertors µ 3p 1, µ 3p, µ 3p 3, µ 3p 4 solve the Z Guss lw 33 t site m, n. A similr SUN proof is involved nd given in Appendix B 1. b

9 9 5. Z dul dynmics The Z lttice guge theory Hmiltonin 11 in terms of the physicl spin opertors tkes the simple nerest neighbor interction form: H = µ 1 p H + λh B, µ 3 pµ 3 p λ <p,pm,n> p = λ µ 1 p 1 ] µ 3 pµ 3 p λ p <p,p > 34 In 34 <p,p > denotes the sum over the nerest neighbor plquettes. Note tht the originl fundmentl nonintercting electric field terms re now described by nerest neighbor intercting electric sclr potentils. The non-intercting mgnetic fields, on the other hnd, hve now cquired the fundmentl sttus. Thus the two guge-spin descriptions: σ 1 l; σ 3 l µ 1 p; µ 3 p re relted by dulity. Further, Z lttice guge theory t coupling λ is mpped into Z spin model t coupling 1/λ, i.e, H Z gugeλ λ H Z spin1/λ. We hve used bove to emphsizes tht this equivlence is only within the physicl Hilbert spce H p. 6. Z Mgnetic disorder opertor The dul spin model 34 on n infinite lttice hs globl Z invrince: µ 1 p µ 1 p, µ 3 p µ 3 p, p Λ. 35 Its genertor G Λ µ 1 p leves the Hmiltonin 34 p Λ invrint: G Λ HG 1 Λ = H. Unlike the initil Z guge symmetry of Z guge theory, the globl Z symmetry of the dul spin model 34 is the symmetry of the spectrum. Being independent of guge invrince, it llows the Ising spin model 34 to be mgnetized through spontneous symmetry breking for λ << 1. As consequence of dulity: µ 1 p σ 3 l 1 σ 3 l σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l 4 µ 3 m, n = H z spin 1/λ H z spin 1/λ = N n =n σ 1 m, n H z guge λ H z gugeλ 36 The bove two equtions describe the reltionship between order nd disorder in the guge nd the dul spin system. Note tht we lwys mesure order or disorder with respect to the potentils. The first reltion bove Confined phse Deconfined phse λ = 0 λ = λ c λ = Disordered phse Ordered phse Σx, y = 0 Σx, y = 0 Ferromgnetic phse Z lttice guge theory Prmgnetic phse λ = 0 Ordered phse λ = λ c Disordered phse λ = µ3 = 0 µ 3 = 0 b Z spin model FIG. 8: Dulity nd order, disorder in + 1 dimensionl Z lttice guge theory, b + 1 dimensionl Ising model. The confining λ << 1 nd deconfining λ >> 1 phses of Z lttice guge theory correspond to the ferromgnetic nd prmgnetic phses of the Ising spin model 7 10]. sttes tht t low temperture or lrge coupling λ >> 1, the guge system is in ordered phse. This is becuse ll mgnetic vector potentils σ 3 l re ligned close to unity leding to σ 3 l 1 σ 3 l σ 3 l 3 σ 3 l 4 1. This is the free phse of Z guge theory mentioned in the introduction with Wilson loop following perimeter lw: W C] σ 3 l = exp λ PerimeterC, l C λ >> However, the dul spin system is now t high temperture. It is in the disordered phse s the dul electric sclr potentil or the spin vlues µ 3 p = ±1 re eqully probble. On the other hnd, t smll coupling λ << 1, the spin system is ordered with ll electric sclr potentils ligned to the vlue µ 3 p = +1 or 1. The guge system is now disordered s the two vlues of the mgnetic vector potentils σ 3 l = ±1 re eqully probble. This is the confining phse with the Z Wilson loop W C] round closed curve C following the re lw: W C] σ 3 l λ AreC = exp lnλ AreC, l C λ << The disorder in the guge system is the order in the dul spin system which is mesured by the expecttion vlue of electric sclr potentil µ 3 p. It is non-locl product of the originl link electric fields which flip the mgnetic vector potentils σ 3 l long n infinite pth. This is shown in Figure 6-. For ltter convenience nd comprisons with SUN results, the Z disorder opertor is relbeled s: Σm, n µ 3 m, n = N n =n σ 1 m, n. 39 Just like in the cse of Krmers-Wnnier dulity, 8 10], the disorder opertor Σm, n in Z guge theory cting on n ordered stte cretes kink stte 8, 9] which is orthogonl to the originl ordered stte. Note tht kink

10 10 SUN lttice guge theory SUN spin model. m, n SUN Dulity/Cnonicl trnsformtions m, n ±; W ±; U Locl Guss lw : G m, n = ] +m, n, î + m, n, î = 0 i=1 Globl Guss lw : G globl = m,n + m, n + m, n ] = 0 FIG. 9: Dulity between SUN lttice guge theory nd n SUN spin model. Unlike the corresponding Z dulity in Figure 3-,b, globl SUN Guss lw constrints t the origin remin unsolved due to the non-belin nture of the guge trnsformtions. t plquette p is mgnetic vortex t p in the originl guge lnguge. Therefore the expecttion vlue of the disorder opertor in n ordered stte no kinks or vortices is 0. Below the criticl point λ c, its expecttion vlue is non-zero. This is the disordered phse nd cn be understood in terms of kink or mgnetic vortex condenstion 9]. We therefore obtin: Σm, n 0 λ << 1, Σm, n = 0 λ >> The Z guge-spin dulity nd the phse digrms re shown in Figure 8. Note tht the disorder opertor Σm, n is guge invrint s it commutes with the locl Guss lw opertors Gn. We further define µ 3 m, n e iπm,n. Using 9, we get: Σm, n = exp i π n =n exp i π m, n = m, n ; ˆ1 Σ π m, n. 41 The order-disorder lgebr is obtined by using the nticommuttion reltion between σ 1 l nd σ 3 l: W C] Σ π m, n = 1 q Σ π m, n W C]. 4 As C is closed loop: q = 1 if the point m, n is inside C nd q = 0 if m, n is outside C. This cn be generlized to more complicted curves where q equls the winding number which is the number of times the curve C winds round the plquette t m, n. The lgebr 4 is the stndrd Wilson- t Hooft loop lgebr for the simplest Z lttice guge theory in + 1 dimensions. In the next section, we construct SUN dulity trnsformtions nd exploit them to generlize 41 nd 4 to SUN lttice guge theory. C. SUN dulity nd SUN Spin Model In this section, we construct SUN spin model which is dul to SUN lttice guge theory. As mentioned erlier, dulities in belin, non-belin lttice guge theories hve been extensively studied in the pst 3, 4, 6 10, 1, 13]. Most of these studies involve pth integrl pproch nd belin guge groups. The dulity trnsformtions re used to mke the compctness of the belin nd non-belin guge groups mnifest in the form of topologicl mgnetic monopoles degrees of freedom 6]. Our purpose in this section is to show tht SUN lttice guge theory cn be constructively dulized like Z lttice guge theory in the previous section. This is illustrted in Figure 9. The SUN dul spin opertors lso led to new SUN disorder opertor discussed in section II C 6. We directly motivte the SUN results through the Z lttice guge theory dulity discussed in the previous section. All lgebric detils of SUN cnonicl trnsformtions cn be found in 17]. For the ske of comprison nd convenience, ll initil nd finl dul spin opertors involved in Z nd SUN lttice guge theories re shown in Tble-1. The belin U1 results cn be esily obtined by ignoring ll non-belin terms from the dulity trnsformtions t the end. The bsic opertors involved in the Kogut-Susskind Hmiltonin formultion of SUN lttice guge theories re SUN flux opertors U n; î nd the corresponding left, right electric fields + n; î nd n + î; î nd on every link 0]. They stisfy the following cnonicl commuttion reltions: ] + n; î, U αβ n; î = ] n + î; î, U αβ n; î = λ U n; î U n; î λ αβ, αβ 43

11 ] + n; î, + n; b î = if bc + n; c î, ] n; î, n; b î = if bc n; c î. 43b In 43 nd 43b, λ = 1,,, N 1 re the representtion mtrices in the fundmentl representtion of SUN stisfying T r λ λ b = 1 δb nd f bc re the SUN structure constnts. n + î; î nd + n; î re the genertors of right nd left guge trnsformtions on the link flux opertor U n; î. The left nd the right electric fields re not independent nd re relted by: n + î; î = R b U n; î+ n; b î; R b U n; î 1 λ T r U n; îλ b U n; î. 44 The rottion opertor R stisfies R T R = RR T = 1. The locl SUN guge trnsformtions rotte the link opertors nd the electric fields s: ± n; î Λ n ± n; î Λ n, U n; î Λ n U n; î Λ n + î 45 the genertors of SU guge trnsformtions t ny lttice site n re: d= G n = n; î + + n; î, n,. 46 i=1 Therefore there is Guss lw constrint G n ψ phys = 0 t ech lttice site n, where ψ phys is ny physicl stte. The Hmiltonin is H = g l l l + 1 g p N T r U p + h.c g H + 1 g H B. 47 Above, l nd p refer to links nd plquettes on the lttice. U p is the product of link opertors corresponding to the links long plquette. g is the coupling constnt. Like in Z guge theory Hmiltonin 11, ll interctions re contined in the mgnetic prt H B of the Hmiltonin. The electric prt H, with no interctions, cn be esily digonlized leding to guge invrint strong coupling expnsion in terms of loop sttes 13, 0]. After dulity in the next section, like Z lttice guge theory in section II B 5, their roles will be reversed. 1. Physicl sector nd SUN dul potentils We now define the dul SUN spin nd SUN string opertors nlogous to the Z spins nd strings in 6, 6b nd 8, 8b respectively. They re pictorilly described in Figure 10-,b respectively. Due to the nonbelin nture of the electric field nd the flux opertors, m 1, n m 1, n 1 +m, n 0, 0 m, n Wm, n m 1, 0 SUN loops physicl m, n m, n 1 m, n SUN strings unphysicl b Tm, n m, n 0, 0 m, 0 11 FIG. 10: The physicl SUN spin conjugte pirs ±; W αβ nd the unphysicl SUN string conjugte pirs ±n; Tn dul to SUN lttice guge theory re shown in nd b respectively. Like in Z cse in Figure 5, we lbel the SUN spin opertors by their top right corners nd the SUN string opertors by their endpoints. The strings decouple from the physicl Hilbert spce s +m, n 0 by the Guss lw constrints in H p. the SUN dulity reltions hve dditionl non-belin structures 17]. To begin with, the N SUN Guss lw constrints t N different lttice sites re ll mutully independent. In other words, identities like 5 do not exist. As result, there is globl SUN invrince in the SUN spin model corresponding to the guge trnsformtions t the origin. All dul opertors trnsform covrintly under this globl SUN. As shown in Figure 10, the SUN dulity trnsformtions involve prllel trnsports from the origin to the site of the dul opertors. The string flux opertor Tm, n t lttice site m, n nlogous to σ 3 m, n in the Z cse is defined through the pth 0, 0 m, 0 m, n: m n Tm, n = Um, 0; ˆ1 Um, n ; ˆ, 48 m =0 n =0 +m, n = G m, n 0, +m, n = G m, n 48b These strings nd their electric fields +m, n re shown in Figure 10-b nd Figure 11-b respectively. The reltions 48 nd 48b re the SUN nlogues of the Z string reltions 8 nd 8b respectively. The dul SUN spin nd the SUN electric sclr potentil opertors in terms of the originl Kogut-Susskind opertors re defined 17] s Wm, n = Tm 1, n 1 U p m, n T m 1, n 1, 49 +m, n = R b Sm, n; n m, b n ; ˆ1. n =n 49b The two opertors in 49 nd 49b re the non-belin extensions of the two Z dul opertors defined in 6

12 1 Z lttice guge theory SUN lttice guge theory Guge Opertors Dul/Spin Opertors Guge Opertors Dul/Spin Opertors µ 1m, n; µ 3m, n ±m, n; W αβ m, n Z Loops/Z Ising spins SUN Loops/SUN spins σ 1m, n; î; σ 3m, n; î ±m, n; î; U αβ m, n; î σ 1m, n; σ 3m, n Frozen Z Strings ±m, n; T αβ m, n Frozen SUN Strings TABL I: The bsic conjugte opertors of the originl nd the dul Z, SUN guge theories in + 1 dimensions. nd 6b respectively. In 49, 49b, the plquette opertor U p m, n nd the prllel trnsport Sm, n; n re defined s U p m, n = Um 1, n 1; ˆ1 Um, n 1; ˆ U m 1, n; ˆ1 U m 1, n 1; ˆ, 50 Sm, n; n Tm 1, n Um 1, n; ˆ1 n q=n Um, q; ˆ. The reltion 49 defines the SUN mgnetic field opertor s fundmentl opertor. The second reltion 49b defines SUN electric sclr potentil m, n which is dul to the originl mgnetic vector potentil. The ppernce of the Tm, n nd Sm, n; n in 49 d 49b is due to the non-belin nture of the opertors. These prllel trnsports from the origin re required to hve consistent guge trnsformtion proper- ties of the SUN mgnetic fields nd the SUN electric sclr potentils see 56. The dul or loop opertors stisfy the expected nonbelin dulity or quntiztion rules: m, n, W αβ m, n ] λ = Wm, n, αβ + m, n, W αβ m, n ] = Wm, n λ, 51 m, n, b m, n ] = if bc c m, n, + m, n, b +m, n ] = if bc c +m, n. 51b Further, the two electric fields re relted through prllel trnsport nd commute: αβ m, n R b W m, n b +m, n m, n => m, n, b +m, n ] = 0. 5 Sm, n, n + m, n Wm, n Sm, n, n m, n m, n + m,n = G m,n Tm, n m, n The quntiztion reltions 51, 51b nd 5 re exctly similr to the originl quntiztion rules 43 nd 43b respectively. Thus the electric field opertor m, n; î nd the mgnetic vector potentil opertor U αβ m, n; i hve been replced by their dul electric sclr potentil m, n nd the dul mgnetic field opertor W αβ m, n. This is similr to Z lttice guge theory dulity where σ 1 m, n; σ 3 m, n get replced by µ 3 m, n; µ 1 m, n. We gin emphsize tht m, n defines the dul electric sclr potentil s it is conjugte to the fundmentl mgnetic flux opertor W αβ m, n. b FIG. 11: The non-locl reltions in SUN dulity trnsformtions nd the Guss lw constrints. We show the reltions 49b expressing +m, n s the sum of b m, n ; ˆ1. The Kogut-Susskind electric fields nd nd the plquette loop electric fields re denoted by nd respectively. In b we show the SUN Guss lw constrints 55. The corresponding Z illustrtions re in Figure 6-,b,c.. Unphysicl sector nd SUN string opertors The unphysicl sector, representing the guge degrees of freedom, consists of the string flux opertors Tm, n in 48 nd their conjugte electric fields m, n in 48b. They stisfy the cnonicl quntiztion reltions:

13 m, n, T αβ m, n ] λ = Tm, n + m, n, T αβ m, n ] = Tm, n λ m, n, b m, n ] = if bc c m, n, αβ αβ, sclr potentils, like Z electric potentils in 33, solve the SUN Guss lw constrints wy from the origin nd led to 57 t the origin. The residul globl constrints 57 cn be solved by using the ngulr momentum or spin network bsis 1, 13, 17, 18]. Note tht in the belin U1 cse there is no residul Guss lw s L m, n Lm, n + m, n + m, n 0. + m, n, b +m, n ] = if bc c +m, n. 53b 4. Inverse reltions Agin, the opertors T + nd T b re relted through prllel trnsport nd commute mongst themselves: m, n R b T m, n b +m, n => m, n, b +m, n ] = The right string electric fields re +m, n = i=1 m, n; î + +m, n; î = G m, n 0, m, n 0, Thus s in Z lttice guge theory, the SUN Guss lw constrints freeze ll SUN string degrees of freedom. This is shown in Figure 10-b. As consequence, ll strings or guge degrees of freedom completely decouple from the theory. 3. The residul Guss lw Unlike Z lttice guge theory, the SUN Guss lw t the origin is independent of the SUN Guss lws t other sites. In other words, the belin identity 5 hs no non-belin nlogue. Under this residul globl guge invrince t the origin Λ Λ0, 0, ll loop opertors trnsform like djoint mtter fields: ± p Λ ± p Λ, Wp Λ Wp Λ. 56 Above, ± p ± m, n, Wp Wm, n nd Λ Λ0, 0 is the guge trnsformtion t the origin. This globl invrince t the origin is fixed by the N 1 globl SUN Guss lws: G G 0, 0 = +0, 0; ˆ1 + 0, 0; ˆ = m, n + +m, n + m, n m=1 n=1 =0 L m,n L m, n = m=1 n=1 In 57, the totl left nd right electric flux opertors on plquette locted t p = m, n re donted by L m, n nd equtions 54, 55 re used to get m, n = 0. In Appendix B 1 we show tht the dul SUN electric ] The inverse flux opertor reltions, nlogous to the Z reltions 30, re Um, n; ˆ1 = T m, n Wm + 1, n Wm + 1, n 1 Wm + 1, 1 Tn + 1, y, Um, n; ˆ = T m, n + 1 T m, n. 58 The inverse electric field reltions, nlogous to the Z electric field reltions 31, re +m, n; ˆ1 = R b Tm, n m b + 1, n b +m + 1, n + δ n,0 L m=m+ n=1 L b m, n, +m, n; ˆ = R b Tm, n +m b + 1, n R bc W m, n c m, n n=n+ L b m + 1, n.59 In the lst step in 59 we hve defined, R b W m, n R b Wm, nwm, n 1 Wm, 1, L m, n m, n + +m, n. In the belin U1 cse 59 involves only the nerest neighbor loop electric fields s there re no color indices L L 0 nd R b U SUN dul dynmics The Hmiltonin of pure SUN guge theory in terms of the dul opertors is H = g m + 1, n ] + m + 1, n + XY m, n m,n Λ + + m + 1, n R bc W m, n ] m, c n Y m, n + 1 g N T r Wm, n + h.c g H + 1 H g B. 60 In 60 we hve defined 17], XY m, n L m, n nd Y m, n L m, n, δ m,0 m=m+ n=1 n=n+ where Lm, n is given in the eqution 57. Thus the SUN Kogut-Susskind Hmiltonin in its dul description unlike the Z lttice guge theory

14 14 θ θ θ Dirc String m, n Σ θ m, n θ θ m, n θ m, n θ m, n Σ + θ m, n Σ + θ m, n Σ + θ m, n b c FIG. 1: The disorder opertor Σ + θ m, n creting mgnetic vortex t m, n in the dul spin description, b in the originl Kogut-Susskind guge description but now with n infinitely long Dirc string, c vortex-nti-vortex pir connected through finite length Dirc string. The drk hevy horizontl links cross the Dirc strings in b nd c represent rottions of the Kogut-Susskind link opertors Um 1, n ; ˆ1, n n by θ. More detils re given in Appendix B. Ising model Hmiltonin becomes non-locl. The nonloclities in 60 comes from the terms RW, XY m, n nd Y m, n. But, since RW = 1 + og + og +, L is of order g n, n 1 which implies tht XY m, n nd Y m, n re both t lest of the order of g. Therefore we expect tht in the g 0 continuum limit, these non-locl prts cn be ignored to the lowest order t low energies. This leds to simplified locl effective Hmiltonin H spin which my describe pure SUN guge theory t low energies, sufficiently well. P H spin = g 4 p + p + p + p=1 <p,p > 1 g N T rwp + h.c g H + 1 g H B. 61 In 61, < p, p > is used to show the nerest plquettes. The bove simplified SUN spin Hmiltonin H spin describes nerest neighbouring SUN spins intercting through their left nd right electric fields. All interctions re now contined in the electric prt H nd the mgnetic prt H B T rwp is non-intercting term. As result, the coupling constnt of the dul model is the inverse of tht of the originl Kogut Susskind model: H SUN guge 1 SUN g H spin g. We hve used bove to stte tht this equivlence is only within the physicl Hilbert spce H p. The bove reltion is SUN nlogue of the Z result H Z gugeλ H Z spin λ 1 discussed erlier. Note tht the globl SUN invrince 56 of the dul SUN spin model is to be fixed by imposing the Guss lw 57 t the origin. The degrees of freedom before nd fter dulity mtch exctly s follows. We hve converted the initil 3L Kogut-Susskind link opertors into 3P plquette spin opertors nd 3N 1 string opertors see Tble 1 nd L = P + N 1. There re N mutully independent Guss lws in SUN but N 1 in Z cse lttice guge theory. Out of these, N 1 freeze the N 1 strings. We re thus left with single Guss lw constrint 57 in SUN spin model fter dulity nd none in Z cse. 6. SUN Mgnetic disorder opertor xploiting dulity trnsformtions, we now construct SUN guge invrint opertor which mesure the mgnetic disorder in the guge system 4]. Such disorder opertors nd their correltions in the context of -dimensionl Ising model nd Krmers-Wnnier dulity hve been extensively discussed in the pth integrl pproch by Kdnoff nd Cev 19]. These disorder vribles were clled mgnetic disloctions. In this section we work with dul SU spin model with globl SU guge invrince 56. We construct SU invrint mgnetic disorder or vortex opertor which cretes mgnetic vortex on single plquette. We focus on single plquette p = m, n in Λ with fixed m nd n s in Figure 1 nd write the SU mgnetic spin opertor W αβ in the mgnetic field eigen bsis s: ωm,n Wm, n cos σ 0 + i ŵ m,n σ ωm,n sin ŵ m,n ŵ m,n = 1. 6 In 6, ωm, n re guge invrint ngles, ŵm, n re

15 15 the unit vectors in the group mnifold S 3 nd σ 0, σ re the unit, Puli mtrices. Under globl guge trnsformtion Λ Λ0, 0 in 56, ω, ŵ trnsform s: ωm, n ωm, n, ŵ m, n R b Λ ŵ b m, n. 63 Above, R b Λ re given in 44. We define two unitry opertors: Σ ± θ ŵm, m, n exp i n ± m, n θ, 64 which re locted on plquette p m, n s shown in the Figure 1-. They both re guge invrint becuse ±m, n nd ŵm, n guge trnsform like vectors. In other words, G, Σ ± θ m, n] = 0, where G is defined in 57. As the left nd right SUN electric sclr potentils re relted through 5, Σ ± θ m, n re not independent nd stisfy: Σ + θ m, n Σ θ m, n = Σ θ m, n Σ+ θ m, n = I. 65 Above I denotes the unit opertor in the physicl Hilbert spce H p nd Σ θ = Σ + θ. The physicl mening of the opertors Σ ± θ m, n is simple nd exctly similr in spirit s Σ π m, n in 41 in the Z lttice guge theory cse. The non-belin electric sclr potentils ±m, n re conjugte to the mgnetic flux opertors W αβ m, n. They stisfy the cnonicl commuttion reltions 51. Therefore the guge invrint opertor Σ ± θ m, n loclly nd continuously chnges the mgnetic flux on the plquette p = m, n s function of θ 1. They re the mgnetic vortex opertors. To see this explicitly, we consider eigensttes ωm, n, ŵm, n of W αβ m, n on single plquette. These sttes re explicitly constructed in C1 in Appendix C. They stisfy: ω T rw ω, ŵ = cos ω, ŵ. 66 We hve ignored the irrelevnt plquette index p m, n in 66 s we re deling with single plquette. It is esy to check: ω, ŵ ±θ Σ ± θ ω, ŵ = ω ± θ, ŵ, 67 implying, ω ± θ T r W ω, ŵ ±θ = cos ω, ŵ ±θ. 68 The equtions 66 nd 68 stte: Σ ± π T rw = T rw Σ± π This is similr to the role of momentum opertor ˆp s genertor of trnsltion in quntum mechnics: e i ˆp θ x = x + θ. This should be compred with 64 nd 67. We thus recover the stndrd Wilson- t Hooft loop Z lgebr 4, 8] for SU t θ = π. Similrly, we get T rw q Σ ± π = 1q Σ ± π T rwq. 70 These reltions re nlogous to the Z results 4. The opertor Σ π is the well known SU t Hooft opertor. The reltions 69 nd 70 cn be esily generlized to n rbitrry Wilson loop W C. In the dul spin model ny Wilson loop cn be written in terms of the P fundmentl loops W αβ s shown in Figure 13: W C = Wp 1 Wp Wp 3 Wp nc. 71 Here p 1 is the plquette opertor in the bottom right corner of C nd p nc is the plquette opertor t the left top corner of C. Now the fctor 1 q in 70 is the phse when the curve C winds the mgnetic vortex t m, n creted by Σ ± π m, n q number of times. The plquette mgnetic flux or the vortex opertors Σ ± θ m, n in 64 cn lso be written s non-locl sum of Kogut-Susskind link electric fields long line nd the corresponding prllel trnsports using 49b. The mgnetic chrge on the plquette p = m, n thus develops n infinite Dirc string in the originl stndrd l; Ul description. This is similr to the discrete Z disorder opertor Σm, n written in terms of the originl electric field opertors σ 1 m, n in 39 nd 41. The Dirc string is shown in Figure 1-b for our choice of cnonicl trnsformtions. Note tht it cn be rotted by choosing different scheme for the cnonicl trnsformtions. Only the end points of Dirc strings loction of the vortex re physicl nd independent of the cnonicl trnsformtion schemes. This is exctly nlogous to the rottions of the Z Dirc strings nd the loction of Z vortices in 39 or 41. Their orienttions do not mtter s Dirc strings themselves re invisible. In Z or U1 guge theories they re trivilly invisible s two horizontl links in Figure 1-b chnge by opposite phses which commute through the plquette links nd cncel ech other. However, in the present non-belin cse, the non-locl prllel trnsport R b Sm, n; n in reltion 49b plys n importnt role in mking the Dirc string invisible. These issues re further discussed in detil in Appendix B. We note tht the disorder opertors in the strong coupling vcuum stisfy: 0 Σ ± θ m, n 0 = 1. The vcuum expecttion vlues of ll Wilson loops, on the other hnd, re zero: 0 W C U 0 = 0. It will be interesting to study the behvior of the vcuum expecttion vlues of Σ ± θ for the finite vlues of the coupling long with the vcuum correltion functions Σ ± θ pσ θ p, shown in Figure 1-c, s p p. The work in this direction is in progress nd will be reported elsewhere.