arxiv: v4 [physics.hist-ph] 29 Jun 2015

Transcription

1 O Drt Phy Dtal Phloohy/Dtal Cooloy a th Clllar toato: Prt Mathatal Dtrt Strtr or Ralty a H Cotatoal Slato arx: [hyht-h] 9 J Ra Zah * Lo a Phloohy o S Rarh Gro Hoao Urty Jaa Ja trat I th ar w ro a aaly a orw o o otal to wor a thoht or rt hy tal hloohy that aly t a t a rt haratrt or th hyal worl a wll a o th lllar atoato whh ol r a th a o a or th oly rt athatal trt ol or th hyal ralty I artlar a a a orato th rr [] xo x alo ha ro that th law th l qato o all th atal or o atr athatally a qly ol r a o a w alra aroah - whr t a that rta hyal qatt ar rt Kywor: oato o Phy Otoloy Drt Phy Drt Mathat Dtr Ralty Cotatoal Slato I or t qt ol that hy aot a o th l ot o oto trtr I that a oth ra o y tr atl th ar ratato thory l -a o- th rt o or hy Et Th ot a tyoloy o tal tt or rt Dt a t rat o ro th Lat t a r I tal hy aa tal hloohy or tal ooloy t ally o that a t oy a hyal tat a qatt ar ltatly t a rt Dtal hloohy roo trt rt ol or roo a atal hyal ro * Eal: Zah@lthoaa ZahR@alo

2 Th a rao or th ar th r trt o ay rat otorary tt th l a artlar th rt ar o o o th la tratoal hyt a Nol larat Pro Grar 't Hoot [-] Drt t Phyal Worl Th hyal worl ha alway r y orary all a artal rtal qato a o oto athatal ol I tal hloohy a rt aroah ta o that ot th ol o lllar atoato th xt [] Drt hy tal hloohy rw ot o a arlr tal hy that roo to ort h o atal thor o hy l qat thory a lllar atoato trtr Sally t wor throh th oq o a that th r a at lllar atoato It a tal trtr that oa all o hyal ralty l tal att a tal ro ro th ot o w o tr th tal aroah to hloohy a hy t r o th tal o th Coha trrtato o qat ha I at thr a oo ort to rta th hyal yt tr o tal ol or to th ol th r a o a th ott o a ral otr lato or a athatally oorh to h a otr whh a h lllar atoato [ ] Dtal hloohy roo to o way o al wth rta th hloohy o hy a artlar o tr [] I o th rt aroah to hy otty rtalty tal a t ar ao oto Dt that ay tt roo rt trtr a o rrt thor that a aroxat oto ol to ay r r o aray Rhar ya h ao ar [9] atr art rar o o th a hyal hoa ol that: all th th t that t' rally tr ohow that th hyal worl rrtal a rtz way It worth to ot hr alo Et' w o oto ol o hy: I or t qt ol that hy aot a o th l ot o oto trtr I that a oth ra o y tr atl th ar ratato thory l -a o- th rt o or hy []

3 Th Clllar toato Prooal o tal hy rt th ry oto o th ot a la that rrt oto thor ar aroxato o a tr rt thory o a t worl Tyally h ol ot o a rlar latt o ll wth t tat orato at ah ll Th latt ll o ot xt hyal a I at hyal a ar ro th rlatoh tw tat at th ll I th ot ooly t latt o ll or lllar atoato ol th tat rtrt to a x r o olt rtly lllar atoato ol wr t th arly 9 Vo Na tro lllar atoata or tha a hal-try ao [] y taar to a lllar atoato a ollto o tat or olor ll o a r o ha that ol throh a r o rt t t aor to a t o rta rl a o th tat o hor ll Th rl ar th al tratly or a ay t t a r I at o Na wa o o th rt ol to or h a ol Th ot trt lllar atoato oth that o Na all th ral otrtor Th at th aot lllar atoata that thy o t loo xatly l otr a thr ar o h otrt l rora ory or t Thy loo or l rt yaal yt a ta ha toally lar t atally tt otrt l olto rl a t a tal oto O o th ot atal rort o a lllar atoato a ty o r o whh t allat or ot Th lt r a o-oal l I two o qar tralar a hxaoal r a or Clllar atoata a alo lt o th Carta r artrary r o o [ ] Clllar atoata thory ha l rl a trtr that ar aal o ro a w arty o xt haor or xal thr ar ral lllar atoata that ar al to lat th haor o ay othr lllar atoato [] ra r o wor o lllar atoata rlat to hloohal art ar rt y rooal holar trt th otal lato o thr wor o th trt that ha alray ar throh th aroah o lllar atoata hloohy o ar r wll th atr o otato a lato a th otoloy o a tal worl []

4 I Drt Phy a Prt Dtrt Mol or Phyal Ralty? I th oo o th athor th awr arat [] Th oto o atr a a rt or/trtr or a lllar atoato l a otr lato ol to ort y a toloal rat a th lat hal try ay rat tt ha loally a raoaly roo that th hyal worl ht ha atally a rt a otatoal or otr latoal trtr [ ] Rhar ya ha lat that h rt trtr wll ltatly ro th ot olt a arat rto o hyal ralty []: t alway othr that aor to th law a w rta th toay t ta a ot ah a t r o loal orato to r ot what o o o attr how ty a ro o a a o attr how ty a ro o t How a all that o o that ty a? Why hol t ta a t aot o lo to r ot what o ty o a/t o to o? So I ha ot a th hyoth that ltatly hy wll ot rqr a athatal tatt that th th ahry wll ral a th law wll tr ot to l l th hqr oar wth all t aart olxt w alray ot Pro Grar 't Hoot a otorary la hyt ha alo lh ay ar o th t rt yar Partlarly h ha tr to or qto l: - Ca Qat Mha Rol wth Clllar toata Mol? - Otal o th Way Towar th Qatzato o Sa T a Mattr -- a Pol Rolto - Do Go Play D? O o th ao Et Otoloal Qto - Th Polty o a Loal Dtrt Thory o Phy Hr o o th Grar 't Hoot' o o th olty o a loal trt thory o hy [] alo [9]: qat ha ol wll rlat to ro-hy th a way throya rlat to ollar hy: t orally orrt t t ay wll ol to trt law at th ro al Why ot? Th athatal atr o qat ha o ot or th ro that o arlly lat th aart o-o thor aoat to th ll qalt Thr ar way to r- artl a l h that o latat otrato ar O t a that all aroo hoa h a artl oto ota a r rlat to roo aral th a way throya ot

5 h a troy a tratr rlat to loal haal aral Th oto o th orato that artl a thr rort ar ot or ot trly ral th otoloal Th oly ralt th thory ar th th that ha at th Pla al Th th w all artl ar haot ollato o th Plaa qatt t Hoot h ot rt ar [9] alo [] whr th a tw th oo qat l a th lllar atoato two a-t o ol that: "th tat o th lllar atoato a a a a or th rto o th qat l thory Th ol ar qalt Th a ato rlt or rato w ha tol y or hy tahr a w xla to or tt that qat thor ar atally rt ro laal thor No-o hol ar to oar a l otr ol h a a lllar atoato a o th tr wth a lly qatz l thory Yt hr w a qat l yt a a atoato that ar a o tat that atly orro to ah othr thy ol tally I w r o roalt trto o ol atoato tat Hlrt a a a athatal w a ay wa to rtaly alo wa whh th artl ar tal a yt th tat ol xatly th a way Phyally 9th try lo th hol ha ay to rta: wh qatz a laal l thory w t ry at that ar qatz a ha a artl t xatly th a ar rat a lllar atoato a o th tr; th ha a artl a wll Why hol't thr a a"? O or o a a hol t Or l thory wa ot oly otrt wthot trato a wthot a t alo th wa to wa h a way that t aot ra o t hol ot o a a rr that o rol ar otr wth trr t o y all w ha a rt ol ot ry rrtat or th ral worl Or th t a "? H alo to h ar or thr a-t o or whh thr a al trt a ha th ltratr a rlat to th hyal ralty o thr oal -r [ ]: "th laal thory t that raty thr a-t o a qatz t oth ry al ha; ow that wol or to arh or trt laal ol or + oal raty I at th lty o orlat a al `Shror qato' or a + oal r a th ht that th qato wol roaly ha to trt wa o o th rt t or th athor to r-tat trt qat ha a wa o th wor rort aot hr: w wol or ay laal ol or + oal raty wth attr whh rtaly a orlat a at way lar t laal tat to a a Hlrt a th r or wor th that ol o a al ao qat yt"

6 I ato otorary rth hyt Joh arrow tat: w ow ha a a o th r a a rat otr rora who otwar ot o th law o atr whh r o harwar oo o th ltary artl o atr [9] a al t ortat a or ll' qalt t Hoot ot ot ll ha how that h aral thor that th qat artl ar ohow aoa y laal h aral that what th oto o ay o ol art wll th art ot a ar ralt W t ol that th lllar atoato thory - th ol o t Hoot [ 9] - aot o th artlar ty Yt w ha a laal yt a w la that t rro qat ha wth roalt rat y th qar or o wa to Qat tat a artlar tal qat tat ar rtly ltat to r tattal trto t to rta why ll' qalt a olat t o th at that w o tart o wth a laal trt rt thory a o th lllar atoato rqr a or tal xlaato [] Thr alo a olt xlaato rar th olla o th wa to a th lllar atoato trtr [ ] a rlatly wr rarh l o hy loo qat raty whh ay l ort to tal hy alo a a-t qatz [-] ro th htoral rt t worth to ot that o o th rt a that th r a otr lato wa lh y Kora Z [] H wa th rt to t 9 that th tr r ot o a h otr oly a lllar atoato I h ar h wrt: that at th ot w o ot ha ll tal ol o hy whh wol th oq o a total rtzato o all atral law? or la o a olt atoata-thort rto o th r h ot y ty ral l ol H hor ll that at thr al a o rro ll lt th ra a rato a ahlato o ltary artl H wrt: all th a w ar al wth atoata ty ow y th a "lllar atoata" th ltratr a t o Na' 9 oo: Thory o l-rro atoata [ ]

7 So rar ro th ao o a art o loal/otoloal qto atrally ar r w art o a otr lato? r thr o aa lzato who ha rat th h lato? I othr wor w or that w ar xt a ort o otr lato atrally a loally w a a who ha rat t a r th lato a alo or what rao? r w a art o a at t a oal xrt? Do t a to rao that th lato wa rat y othr? Th otoloal trtr o a rt-t ol o ralty rthr rarh O rot wol arh or hoa whh aot rt allat a r thortally/xrtally aor to rrt qat thor a othr atal thor o hy t ol yt oly y rt trtr Grar t 'Hoot o o h artl rar rt ol r y tr o ral worl wrt []: " I or ral r lay h a atal rol that t lt to a a worl wthot ral r Nrthl o ay t that ral r ar oth t a ha to y ha haty or or yar ao that or worl a rtoo ry aratly w hraz t law a t ytr y alat ral r ot oly ato a ltlato t alo trato a o a latr o or alo th xtrly rh athatal ahry yo that alato that o ot wor o wll or tr alo or or lt qatt h a oola aral Now a that otrat to th aara th ral worl at t ot atal ll wr ot a o ral r at all W hr or yt whr oly th tr r what ha at a r ll Ca o rta why or worl aar to a o ral r? Th ot w wh to a a tat that ryth w toarly o wth ral r a o wth tr alo" I artlar a a a orato th rr [] x ha ro that th law th l qato o all th atal or o atr athatally a qly ol r a o a w alra aroah - whr t a that rta hyal qatt ar rt ha tr al

8 Rr: []- G 't Hoot `"Qat Mha a tr" Pro o th Ehth It Co o "Partl Str a Cooloy U o North Carola Chal Hll r - P rato a J N E Rto Pr Prto - ; ITP- UU// SPIN-/ arx:h-th/; Dtr ath Qat Mha rt at Qo a Qat Mha? Tl Urty Phlalha Str ITP-UU-/9 SPIN-/ arx:qath/9 []- G 't Hoot Th athatal a or trt qat ha yo th Qat Worl St Th M Nwhz t al -9 arx:qath/ []- G 't Hoot "Qat Graty a a Dat Dtrt Syt" Cla Qat Gra 999 []- G 't Hoot "Dtr r oo" It J Thor Phy []- G 't Hoot "Etal qat tat a loal trt thory" Va Syo o th oato o Mor Phy J 9 ITP-UU-9/ SPIN- 9/; arx:9 [qat-h] 9 []- G 't Hoot "Claal lllar toata a Qat l Thory" Pro o th Cor Hoor o Mrray Gll-Ma' th rthay "Qat Mha Eltary Partl Qat Cooloy a Colxty" Saor rary H rtzh a K K Pha Worl St 9 - Rr : It J Mo Phy o -9 []- Grar 't Hoot "Qat Mha ro Claal Lo" Joral o Phy: Cor Sr IOP Plh []- G 't Hoot How a wa to a olla wthot olat Shror' qato a how to rta or' rl ITP-UU-/ SPIN-/ arx: [qat-h] [9]- Grar 't Hoot "Th Clllar toato Itrrtato o Qat Mha Vw o th Qat Natr o or Ur Colory or Iol?" arx: J []- Grar 't Hoot "Dalty tw a trt lllar atoato a a oo qat l thory + o" arx: [qat-h] []- S Dr R Jaw a G 't Hoot Thr-oal Et raty: ya o at a Phy 9 []- G 't Hoot Claal N-artl ooloy + o Cla Qat Gra S9-S9 99 []- G 't Hoot Cooloy + o Nl Phy Pro Sl - 99 []- G 't Hoot Qatzato o ot artl +-oal raty a at rt Cla Qat Gra -9 arx:r-q/9 99

9 []- E r Itroto to Dtal Phloohy Itratoal Joral o Thortal Phy Vol No rary []- Kora Z Rhr Ra Eltroh Datrart Vol 9 []- K Z Callat Sa Car M: MIT Pr 9 or o htoral tal aot Z wor alo: K Z Th Cotr - My L Kora Z t al Srr Vrla rl 99 []- K Z Th Cot Ur Itratoal Joral o Thortal Phy 9 9 [9]- Joh D arrow "Nw Thor o Eryth" Oxor Urty Pr []- Rhar ya "Th Charatr o Phyal Law" Mr Ltr Corll Urty 9 []- J Vo Na Th Gral a Loal Thory o toata Crral Mha haor: Th Hxo Syo Nw Yor: Joh Wly & So 9 []- G Rao Vath "Dtal Phloohy: r Clllar toata Iortat?" Roar I wwwroaro []- S Wolra Nw K o S Chaa IL: Wolra Ma []- P Ga "Rlal Clllar toata wth Sl-Orazato" J Stat Phy - []- rao rto Jaoo Tala Clllar toata # Clllar toata a Mol o Ralty Th Staor Eyloa o Phloohy [] Grar 't Hoot Do Go Play D Phy Worl Dr []- E r Nw Coooy Phy Co '9: Pro o th Worho o Phy a Cotato IEEE Cotr Soty Pr 99 []- S Wolra Stattal Mha o Clllar toata Rw o Mor Phy : 9 [9]- Rhar ya Slat Phy wth Cotr Itratoal Joral o Thortal Phy Vol - 9 []- Prr Szal lrt Et Mhl o: Corroa 9-9 Hra Par 9 []- Joh o Na Th Thory o Sl-rro toata r U o Illo Pr Uraa IL 9 []- Zzz Paola " Mal Mol or Qat Graty" Mo Phy Ltt - []- Zzz Paola "Cotalty at th Pla Sal" arx:r-q/ []- Marzol M Ratt "S Ntwor Qat Slator" Phy Ltt 9- []- Marzol M Ratt "Cot S Ntwor" al o Phy : - 9

10 []- Grll E R L "Rotrt Qat Gotry ro Qat Iorato: S Ntwor a Haro Ollator" Cla Qat Gra : 9- []- Ra Zah "O th Loal Strtr o th atal or o Natr: Nw Dtrt Mathatal roah" Hoao Urty Pl Jaa Jaary [ tt a at rarh rot Ra Zah O "oato o Phy" Jaa ; a xa ro o y arlr lh artl th llt o th L Phy Ittt Ra ay o S Nw Yor Srr-Vrla 99]; htt://wwwro/o/ []- G 't Hoot "Rlat th qat ha o rt yt to taar aoal qat ha" oato o Phy Srr-Vrla ; htt://arxor/a/9

11 x O th Loal Strtr o th atal or o Natr: Nw Dtrt Mathatal roah Ra Zah * htt://sro: [Do/] r Lo a Phloohy o S Rarh Gro Hoao Urty Jaa Ja trat Th a a o th artl a o y arlr lh artl rr [] [] [] [] 99 I th artl o th a o a w athatal aroah a o th alra trtr o th oa o tr a a th rt o hyal qatt h a th oot o th rlatt -ot a aly th aoal qatzato w r th law th l qato o all th atal or o atr l ltroat lar a ratatoal l qato Th ota law that ar q tt a th or o olx tor qato rrt oly th ao ator o l a thr ralzato or o D Eah r tor qato ota tr o a a th rt a o a o or arrr artl that ol zro or o-zro a wll a a arat tr o th xtral rrt a th xtral or o th or l I o al oto th tor qato ar tr to qat rlatt wa qato that orro to Pal a Dra qato I at th tor qato ota th wor ar th ot ral or o th orary l qato l Maxwll a ltrowa Ya-Ml a Et l qato a wll a Pal a Dra qato a o o Moror aor to th w athatal aroah w r a qat rlatt wa qato whh ota ral aa atr a th ralz or o Dra qato a how that t ol oly orlat + o or + o w ota a w qat rlatt wa qato trtrally aaloo to Dra qato that ota otraarat atr orro to Clor alra Th aroah alo wth rato wth zro rt a alo rt a ratatoal l arrr artl wth o-zro rt a Moror a o th q trtr o th l qato r w alo ol that at oool oot ltr oool ol ot xt Kywor: oato o Phy Otoloy Drt Phy Drt Mathat Th atal or o Natr PCS Claato: C K 9+ + Hh Y 9+ -z P K -y - D - Itroto Lt tart wth o o th ratt otoloal qto: Why th r a th atal or that ar at t ar th way a or a ha whh w ralz th? ; th or that ar ar o all th ot a trato th hyal worl I th artl w ar o to or th qto y a athatal aroah * Eal: zah@lthoaa zahr@alo htt://arhor/tal/rzahoroatrlawr; Exa ro

12 Th ar a o y arlr artl [] [] [] a wll a y th wor 99 [] t a w xa rawor Hr o th a o a w axoat athatal aroah o th a o th alra trtr o th oa o tr a o rt o th oot o th rlatt -ot a aly th aoal qatzato w r th ot ral or o th law th l qato o all th atal or o atr Th ota law that ar q tt a th or o olx tor qato rrt ltroat lar a ratatoal l qato a thr ralzato Th a rlt o th ar l: - Dr th l qato o all th atal or o atr or o D qly th ollow tor or: D - D R [ ] R J - * G D - D [ Z ] Z J - * N D - D [ ] J - * E whr a D * D : : a th rt a o a ro or arrr artl oarat -loty o a tat

13 orr; a whr tor or th ltroat l tor or = a alo th lar wa l Z th lar tro l tor or = o a l arrr artl l lo a or o a a lar tro l arrr artl a R th Ra tor o th ratatoal l or = o a l arrr artl l rato a or o a ro a ratatoal l arrr artl a th qato rally rt t I at ah tor qato ol to two ator o a zro or o-zro I ato a w wll how th to ral qato - - rrt th ratatoal l alo ol wrtt a ollow: or two oal a-t D = w t R R T T T T K a or th hhr o D > w ota R 9 R T K whr K Eqato 9 ar qalt to Et l qato or = I th at qato 9 alo rt a ratatoal l arrr artl wth o-zro rt a - or to th q trtr o th tor qato - a - that at ar th ral or o th Maxwll qato or = w ll ol that thr ol ot ay at oool atr a al a o th ao tor qato w alo r a qat rlatt wa qato that ota ral aa atr atally a th ralz or o Dra qato a how that t ol oly orlat + o whr oqtly w alo ay ol that artl l ltro a qar wol two oal atal ot or + o w ota a w qat rlatt wa qato trtrally aaloo to Dra qato that ota otraarat atr atr orro to Clor alra W haz that all th ao rlt ar q oto o a l athatal aroah wthot rt o th ral at whh w rrt t th to I th xt to a a w athatal aroah w r th rl o th alra thory o larzato a o th thory o r/oa a th to w how t alato hy whr w ll o o athatally r th ot ral or o th law o all th atal or o atr or o D

14 Thory o Larzato th Doa o Itr: a Nw xoat Mathatal roah Th alra axo o th oa o tr wth ary orato ally ar a ollow []: - a a a - Clor: a a a a l - oatty: a a a a a a l l r l r a al ar a al ar - Cotatty: a a a a - Ext o a tty lt: a a l l a al al a a a - Ext o r lt or ato: a a - Dtrtty: a a a a a a a l r l r a l r r l r a a a a a a - No zro or: a a a a - l l qaltly th axo - ol a: [ a a a ] a a a a - r r r r I w t o [ a ] a [ a] a[ a] a Z th qaltly th axo ol alo wrtt y qarat atr wth tr oot a ollow: - M ] : M M M [ - Clor: M M l M M l - oatty: M M M M M M l r l r M Ml M r M Ml M r - Cotatty or ato: M Ml Ml M 9-

15 - Prorty o th trao or atrx ltlato: whr T M th trao o atrx M - Ext o a tty lt: M M - Ext o th r lt or ato: T T T M Ml Ml M 9- M I M M M - Dtrtty: M M M M M M M l r l r M l r r l r M M M M M M ; ro th axo w a ota th axo a ra I th artl w tro th ollow alra axo a a w rorty o tr a w a t to th axo th w axo oway th ralz or o th axo - a at th axo - wll rla wth th axo : xo - I w a th alra or [ a ] whr H q ar o ot a r q q a th qarat atr q a r H qq q H Z q q r r q th w ha th ollow axo: M [[ M M M M r M M r r ] r q q I ] Rar - I aor to th artrar o all th oot o th atrx M wthot lo o ralty w ay rla th atrx M wth a atrx M ah o th qato wth th a oto M t oly wth th r o artrary M oot Not that th tr lt a ar th lar or o th tr lt q

16 W a ota th axo - or t qalt th axo - ro th xo - t ot ra Oly or th al a th t o axo o qalt to th t o axo - Dtly th xo - a w axo a th to a th xt to w ll otrat o o t oto a alato Grally thr ar taar a tho aroah a ror or or a ol th lar qato th t o tr [] S o th a o th xo - th ary a t oto or a qato o th r th orr h a th oa o tr th traor or ort or at larz t to a yt o lar qato o th ty whr M M : atrx atrally th a alato o th xo - wll M th traor th hhr orr qato to th orro yt o lar qato I th to a o tally w ll ota th yt o lar qato that orro to th o orr qato o th or: a alo o o th hhr orr qato I th q thooloal ot o w rtly or ota a y a yt o lar qato that orro to a qato o th ty w a a or th al or th z r o th atr wth th lar or a q q atr Soly y rla th oot o r q H q q r w allat th rot a th w t t qal to th atrx q I Th th ota qato w a allat th ot H q whh ar t o lt q Throh th aly th ot H q ar allat a ota y rot a taar tho o ol th qato th t o tr Thrly th alra or r q q q a o rta rl a lar traorato ol traor to th alra or o th ty G r r r I otato y o xal w wll how how th or r q q ol q traor to th or G troh o lar traorato rthror a w ll how that xtoally th o orr or o ol traor to th ollow qarat or y lar lar traorato G

17 Rar - Cor th orla t ay to how that r q r r q r q q r q q q - r q r q r q a t - q r q r q q q r q whr th aratr t a artrary tr wth oto t low w wrt th yt o lar qato that orro wth o al a o th ollow qato that aor to th xo - o yt or ah a oh: r q q - q that ha at So al a o - whh w wll or low artlar l th o orr qato wth th rt r o th lt a o o th hhr orr qato or r qato - o a ollow rtly q q q q q q q q 9 q q ; Now a atrx qato hr w a a yt o lar qato orro to aor to axo

18 whr ; Slarly or w ha th ollow atrx qato whr ; U w ay t qaltly th ollow atrx qato or whr ; yt o lar qato orro to 9 whr ; ro w a ota th ollow atrx qato or qato 9

19 9 whr ; Slarly how w ota th atrx qato a or qato a 9 th atrx qato orro to a ar ota a ollow or w t whr ; a or w ota

20 9 whr ; Slarly yt o lar qato wth larr z ol ota or th qato - r whr I ral z o th qarat atr o th atrx qato orro wth th o orr qato o th ty - or r t xtoally th z rl to oly or th a o th o orr qato a t wa or qato 9 Grally th z o th qarat atr o th atrx qato orro wth th ral a o th qato - r r or all al o r th atrx qato aor to a orro to th ral a o th qato - ar ral a allal Mawhl a w roly ot ay o qarat atr th atr qato a o o t o o th ol atr ro whh w ay ota Dtly thr ar othr atr rt o t wth th a z a lar trtr whh w ay ota or otrt othr qalt a a o o th qato ; w t lt tho al atr a o thr artlar trtr a thr al alato that wll how th xt to

21 o xal o th thr orr a o qato - th yt o lar qato orro wth two qato q q 9 ; q q rtly ar 9 whr Th z o th qarat atrx th atrx qato orro to th xt r orr qato q q Cor th orth orr a o qato - h a q q

22 ; q q rtly th yt o lar qato orro to th ar h 9 h h h h h h h h whr h h Slarly a w ot ao or th th a th hhr orr a o - wth th larr r o ow lt w t th atrx qato l th qarat atr wth th z r r Mawhl w a th ollow lar rlato a th ral rl or traor th o th thr th orth a th hhr orr a o th or to th or ; or th o orr

23 q q w ha ; a or th thr orr: q q 9 w ha Slarly or traor th orth orr a th hhr orr a o qato to w a o lar traorato h a a Howr ary t ol or traor to w othr lar traorato a wll or to th artlar alato o th o orr a o th qato - th xt to th to hr w o or a tro o o th rort o th atrx qato rt w or th ollow qato whh t lt art a al a o :

24 Whr Now th atrx qato or or or a or a o o a wll a th lar traorato o th ty or - ; - w ota th ollow atrx qato that orro to qato rtly

25 whr -

26 9 whr - W t ot that thr ar ot th a lar traorato h a a xtoally thy xt or or th thr a th hhr orr qato o th or l l l l Now y th ollow ho

27 ; E D C 9 w a rwrt th traorato - a - a ollow D C D C E ro w alo t E D E C Whr th r o ; aor to qato a ytr atrx; alo w a that t Th rlato a at that thr a o to o orro tw th oot o D C a th oot o E ; th rorty a th rlato a w wll tr th olto o th yt o lar qato o th a o th olto o qato a Utlz th taar a tho o ol th yt o lar qato th t o tr [] rtly w ota th ollow t o th olto or qato a or ow a rtly w t haz that th ral a taar olto o th qato o th ty

28 x a th t o tr a ollow [ ]: a x a x whr th aratr ar artrary tr a whr w o a Now or th qato w t th ollow olto whr w o : whr th aratr ; ar artrary tr or th qato w ha whr w o : whr th aratr ; ar artrary tr U Rar - w a alo t th ollow ral olto or th yt o lar qato whr w o : whr th aratr ; ar artrary tr or th qato th ollow olto ar ota whr w o a thr alo a oto or th aratr low:

29 9 whr th aratr ar artrary tr a th aratr hol aty th ollow qato a a ary oto or th aratr that xt th aratr olto : S th aratr o ot xt th olto th oto aly ol ol y th ollow ho: 9 Now Rar - a th rlato 9 a th olto o ar tr a ollow t t t t whr th aratr ; t ar artrary tr a t Slarly w ota th ollow olto or th atrx qato whr w o a thr ar alo oto or th aratr low:

30 whr th aratr ar artrary tr a th aratr hol aty th ollow qato a th ary oto or th aratr that xt th aratr olto : 9 I l ar th aratr 9 o ot xt th olto th oto wll ol y th ollow ho: 9 U th rlato a a Rar - th olto o o a ollow t t t t - t whr th aratr t ; ar artrary tr a t

31 Slarly th aratr olto o th atrx qato wth th z orro to qato lar to - wll ott t wth xt atoal oto or aratr th oto l xt hooo o orr qato that ah qato ota oly or tr lar to a Th oto ol ol aly wth o ho or aratr lar to 9 a I ral th aratr olto o th atrx qato th yt o lar qato orro to th o orr qato o th or wll la to r o oto or aratr l th or tr hooo o orr qato that th oto wll ol y o ho or aratr lar to th ao ho th ho 9 a a ltatly th ral olto o wll ota Mawhl th olto - ol alo rrt a ollow rtly ; t t whr w t o t a ; t t t whr w t o t a

32 ; o t t t t t t t t t 9 I w th atrx K a K whr w o K th a w t th ollow t o th rlato

33 C t U K D E tk t U K UK K t ; D t U t U C E t t U C M t U C K t U C C t ; C t U t U D E t t U D M t U D K t U D D t I ot o at th orla ar th tr aratr olto o qato whr th atr C D K U ha y th rlato 9 a a th aratr t a artrary tr t O th othr ha th orla a how that w o that th al or whr ar al th w a allat th al or tr o th a th atr U

34 Th oto o th aratr or th aratr olto a th oto o th aratr or th aratr olto ol ol y othr tho a wll S th aratr o ot xt th olto th oto aly wll ol y th ollow ho or th aratr : - a r Itr aratr - : - whr qato - aor to th olto a alo ol ol l two ort o th olto: a ollow ; : a r Itr aratr ; a : a r Itr aratr whr th aratr ; ar artrary tr y rla th al o ro th rlato or orla a ta to aot orla - a - w t a w ral aratr olto or th atrx qato

35 aothr lar a th aratr 9 o ot xt th aratr olto th oto or th aratr xt th olto o th atrx qato ol ol y th ollow ho a wll - 9 a r Itr aratr - : th qato - ol r ro a - w wll ot or t th xt rlat allato Rrr to th olto a or qato that orro to th qarat qato 9 rtly th qato a - ar ol a ollow rt th olto w t: - 9- ;

36 - ; 9- - ; y th to o th ty th olto 9-9- ol l or ta Now th olto w t th othr ty or xa o tha 9-9- o th olto or qato - rtly - ; 9

37 - ; 9 - ; 9-9 y ly th rlato 9 9 ltatly w t th ollow t o th ral olto or qato - -:

38 : 9 aratr Itr r a 9 whr th aratr ; ar artrary tr y rla th al o ro th rlato 9 orla a ta to aot orla - a - w t aothr or o th ral aratr olto or th atrx qato Slarly or th yt o lar qato orro to wth or aral lt larr al o th lar oto a rlato to - - a - - a - - a o o ol ho ltatly Th a o th w a tr th olto or th yt o lar qato orro to ah a o th qarat qato

39 9 Dr th Mot Gral Strtr o th Law th l Eqato o ll th atal or o Natr I w a that th al rlatty oto th oot o th -ot ar rt ha tr al th arat a th ry-ot rlato 9 9 whr ar otat ot a ar th oot o th ot tor two rr ra th th rlato 9 a 9 ar th al a o th alra rlato ; a oqtly thy arly hol larz o th a a rawor o axo a traor to yt o lar qato H th atrx rlato w t th ollow q yt that orro to th rlato 9 a 9; rt or 9 w ha rtly ar tr aratr lar to th aratr th atrx rlato 9 9 whr ; 99 whr ; Thr ar ay or taar a ott qat rlatt thor hy whh thr ar a th rt o hyal tal qatt l latt l a a thor qat raty thor latt QCD a ay othr wll-ow thor

40 whr a - - 9

41 whr w ha ; a or 9 w t whr w o : rtly

42 whr ; whr ; whr a - -

43 9 whr w ha ; 9 -

44 - a I th to w wll th otrz t [9] Et otato a th ollow oto: - Mtr oto: - Ra a R tor: R R R - Et tor : R R T It worth to ot that or th rlato 9 or th oot a w a th rlato a th olto 9 to tr th lar traorato tw two rr ra I othr wor th ral or o th lar traorato tw two rr ra rtly a atly ar tr ro th rlato 9 or all o Now aally w th rlato or r - qly a oltly - th l qato o all th atal trato o hy or th oal rl w aoally qatz th rlato Th a a ral ttto rl w ttt th ollow aoal oarat orator ota qat haal orator wth thr qalt qatt th rlato l otat : - Coarat -ot orator: - Gral oot o th tr tor: ĝ 9 - Coot o o l tor: ; Z ; ;

45 I at w at a how that th ot ral or o l qato o th atal or o atr ar r y th aoal qatzato o th q larz or rlato ota o th a o axo - o th ral ry-ot rlato 9 or to th trtr th ooto a th r o qato o th yt w o ol that thr xt oly thr o at-ytr tor that thr oot ol ttt wth th aratr xt th qato whh a al a tral a a thy traor th yt to th tor qato Th tor ar a orr a r orr a a th orr tor Th th orr tor o th tor t ath th Ra tor R whh at th a t a a a tor t ary or allat a y th oot o th tr tor ; othr two tor that ol wrtt a Z a arly hol at-ytr wth rt to th h a: Z Z a a w wll how thy ar th lar tro ltrowa l th lar wa a ltroat l tor Th rtly orro to qato that thy o t ota ay oto or aratr w t th ollow tor qato rtly: th tor qato orro to rlato a al a tral a that Ra tor alo ah that a; w t wrt t ow ay a a a tor h a ttt wth a whr w a * D - whr a D - [ ] D J - * E E E E whr a J D D - [ Z ] D Z J - * N

46 N N N whr a Z J D D - R [ ] D R J - * G G G G whr a R J D D - [ ] D J - * E whr a E E J D E D - [ Z ] D Z J - * N whr a Z Z Z N J N D N D - R [ ] D R J - * G

47 whr a R R R G J G D G whr qato - - w ha D D * - - : - : E E E I I J - N N N I I J Z - I G I G J G R D J * G - I yt o lar qato th aratr wr t artrary tr aratr that w ttt th oot o tor Z R wth th a o th ral orator to or wrt th tor qato orro to th rlato a whh ar lar to th tor qato - - a w wll how lt at rt to th ollow two rar Rar - or th xt yt o lar qato a a o o th tato or th aratr a t rt Thr ar o oto or th aratr l th qarat qato - a - - that hol or a ol I th ro to w alt wth th tato two rt way W ha two ty o th ral olto or th oto; o l th olto o th or 9 a that ly thy rtly ar

48 th olto o th oto - a - - whr Th othr o l th olto o th or a that ly thy o th olto o th oto - whr a th olto o th or 9-9- a 9 that ly thy alo o th olto o th oto - - whr I all th olto or th oto - a - - th aratr arly ar wrtt tr o th w aratr a whh w ay rrt th a th ral or H ; whr th aratr a ar artrary tr Now or al wth th tato w ay ar that to th tor oot orro to th orator ŝ aor to th to ttt wth th aratr a at th a t th aratr ar ot artrary aratr a thy y whr a ar artrary aratr th w ol that th orator ŝ hol ha th ollow or a wll H ; whr û a ar o orator that ttt wth th aratr a a thy hol or th tor oot orro to th orator ŝ So ro th ao oto a art rl w at a ol that H ; ] [ H ; ] 9 [ Mawhl aor to th aratr olto a 9 th or H ot a q or y 9 th or H a û a ol at orha w wll lary that whh or o wth th orator ŝ that orro to th oot o th tor H ar atal h that thy wll ott Z R Rar - I oto wth th ao ot a th rlato a 9 or y th or H a th orator û a th trtr o th tor Z R aally w wll

49 9 th Ra tor R a th a that o o ha t ary or y th oot o th tr tor a o othr ha t a aal tor wth a trtr Th o th a a or th or H a 9 oly th aratr olto o th ty orally wth rt to : : aratr Itr r a - or qato - a wll a oly th aratr olto o th ty 9 orally wth rt to : : 9 aratr Itr r a - or qato - - ar atal; rthror y tart ro th Ra tor a t trtr a th rlato w t

50 I w th orator R C orat o a o orr tor Y a ollow C Y a Y Y Y whr a a o-zro otat th w ay rwrt h a R [ C C C C ] a Now w th orator D a wll D C C Th th rlato or th Ra tor ol wrtt a ollow R D D a Mawhl th atral ralzato o orator C orat o a artrary th orr tor C [ ] a or to a th oly a th ot ral or rrt th trtr o Ra tor R R a whr D Now a w tat Rar - a Rar - w a aly th rlato a a aal rtro a th rlato 9 or tr th ral orlato o th orator ŝ

51 that ttt wth th aratr th yt whh orro to th oot o th Ra tor That rtly }; : { : aratr Itr r a a ar a G }; : { : aratr Itr r a a a a ar a ar a ar a G 9 }; : { : aratr Itr r a a a a a a a ar a ar a ar a ar a ar a ar a G

52 : { a ar a ar a ar a ar 9 a ar a a a ar ar ar a a ar ar G a a a a 9 a a a a a a : a r Itr aratr } whr th aratr a ar artrary I th ao orla or th lt a t a artrary aratr a t th ao orla rrt ŝ th lt a wll latr that a or to Rar - a Rar - a orla t lar that or th or H a 9 oly th rlato - a - ar atal whh ar ott wth th orla a rtly t ay to how that th alra orla rrt th a 9 ar alo ott wth ro alra oto o th aratr yt a whr thy t wr artrary tr or xal rar th alra orla rrt 9 y th ollow ho

53 a whr th aratr ar artrary tr rtly w a how that th aratr ar alo artrary a ah ol ta ay tr al Soly or th orla a rtly w ol how that y th ollow ho rtly ; : aratr Itr r a a a a a : 9 aratr Itr r a a a a a a th orla a oltly aor wth orla - a - a oly wth th a t hol Now aor to th ao oto a aroah a Rar - a Rar - a th rlato a w r th ollow tor qato qly a rtly ] [ D - * E J D -

54 whr a E E E D J ] [ Z D - * N J Z D - whr a N N N D J Z Z Z Z Z Z ] [ R D - * G J R D - Whr a

55 R R R R R R G J G D G whr th to a rlato - - ar al to th qato - - a wll Now a o Rar - a Rar - a th rlato 9 a a a a a aal a ral rtro or y th trtr o th qatt ŝ that orro to th oot o th l tor th ollow rlato rar th trtr o th tor rtly whr Q a a all qato - - a - - ar ary Z DQ DQ a S D H D H a H ar a alar l a a tor l a whr w t orator that ltatly ar ota or th l a Z or S a wll a Th ollow a : E C Q Q - whr E th ol otat; E [ ] Slarly th rlato a w ay ota th tor qato orro to th yt Howr thr ht aar o ltato or th hhr o w o th rt o th othr qatt h a a-t oorat a o o

56 a Z : L Z S H N L H H N L [ H H N ] [ H L H L ] 9-9- whr N th ol otat Now rl w ay ol that tor qato - - a - - th ltroat l tor or = a alo th lar wa l tor or th lar tro l tor or = o a l arrr artl l lo a or o a a lar tro l arrr artl a Z R th Ra tor o th ratatoal l or = o a l arrr artl l rato a or o a ro a ratatoal l arrr artl a th qato rally rt t I at ah tor qato ol to two ator o a zro or o-zro a o th q trtr o qato a - - that ar qalt to th ral or o Maxwll qato at oool oot ltr E E oool J D ol ot xt Th Gral or o Et l qato ol ota ro qato U th o ah tty a th oto w t R R R Now ro a qato a th ato J T T T T whr T th tr-ry tor T T a th tr tor a a otat w t R T T K q

57 whr q a otat al that r atrally wh w ota qato a whr ha - a K K K to t olx ot rt qato or - or two oal a-t ta th ollow or K T - T whr q a th ooloal otat R T ; - R T or qato - or thr oal a-t th l qato ta th ollow or R R T K whr q a th ooloal otat K or qato - or or oal a-t th l qato ta th ollow or a wll R R T K whr q a th ooloal otat Eqato a ar qalt to Et l qato or = I qato w ay ha th total orato law a ollow T Z Hr w alo haz that qato o th ratatoal l l two ator: or = o a l arrr artl l rato a or o a ro a ratatoal l arrr artl a th ao qato rt t Mawhl aor to th o ah tty ro th qato - a - w ay ha a : R a ; that th a a th rt a o a ro ratatoal or arrr artl thr ay aar o atoal oto or th oot o th Ra tor

58 I th al rlatty oto qato a - - alo ol wrtt th or ] [ I ] [ Z I 9 whr I th tty atrx; a whr or qato - - or two oal a-t w ha ] [ ] [ N E Z Z a a ralz or orro to Pal qato a N E ; a or qato - - or thr oal a-t w t ] [ ] [ N E Z Z Z Z a a ralz or orro to Dra qato a N E ;

59 9 a or qato - - or or oal a-t w ota ] [ ] [ N E Z Z Z Z Z Z Z rrt a tr to th ral or o qat rlatt wa qato or or oal a-t a N E ; W haz that all th α-alha atr ar ral a otraarat l ro atr a orro to Clor alra [ ]

60 I at al a h a: a E N th qato a 9 a wll a th qato - - a - - ar tr to th qat rlatt wa qato that orro to Pal a Dra qato Whr thy ar th ralz or o Pal qato that to t oly ol orlat two oal a-t a Dra qato that to t ol orlat oly thr oal a-t a oq hr w ay alo ol that artl l ltro a qar hol two oal atal ot I + o w ha to aly a w qat rlatt wa qato trtrally aaloo to Dra qato that ota th otraarat atr orro to Clor alra Colo I to th t o alra axo or tr ha orlat tr o th qarat atr wth a artrary w a ol that or a olt rrtato o alra rort o tr arly a tly th qarat atr : [ a ] [ ] [ ] hol al; a orary ol alra axo - that ha orlat tr o th l lt: a a a whr at thy ar l oot o atr h a: [ a] a [ a] a[ a] a Z ar ot t or a olt rto o th alra rort o tr I to y a th rt o oot o th rlatt -ot a th aoal qatzato o th q larz or rlato ota o th a o axo o th ral ry-ot rlato 9 qly w r th ot ral or o th l qato o all th atal or o atr that l tor qato - - a - - Th r ral l qato r th thr a ator a oly thr o l l ratatoal ltroat l ltowa a tro lar or or o D Eah r tor qato ota tr o a a th rt a o a ro or arrr artl a ol to two ator o zro or o-zro rthror wh w oar th r l qato wth orary l qato h a Maxwll a th lar wa Ya-Mll a Et l qato that thy ha orlat rally a o ral thr alo r a w ralzato or th orary l qato I othr wor th r l qato ar th ot ral or o l qato o th atal trato o hy I artlar w how that th tro lar l hol rrt y a r orr tor I o al oto th ral tor qato wr tr to rlatt qat wa qato that orro to Pal a Dra qato a o o I artlar w r a qat rlatt wa qato that ota ral aa atr a th ralz or o Dra qato a how that t ol oly orlat + o whr oqtly w ay alo ol that artl l ltro a qar hol th ha o two oal atal ot I + o w how that w ha to aly a w qat rlatt wa qato trtrally aaloo to Dra qato that ota th otraarat atr orro to Clor alra I ato th aroah alo wth rato wth zro rt a rt a ratatoal l arrr artl wth o-zro rt a a wll or to th q trtr o th l qato ota w alo ol that oot ltr oool at oool ol ot xt

61 W haz aa that th ror o r th l qato o th atal or wa a o a w l athatal aroah that wa rrt th to or th alra trtr o th oa o tr a th ato o rt o th oot o th rlatt -ot a y th aoal qatzato o th q larz or ota o th a o xo - o th ry-ot rlato w to th r l qato ar q a o o th a oal o th artl to how that th ral l qato o all th atal or o atr ar ral ro rta athatal art Th rlt ota th to otrat th y o th thory o larzato a a alra trtr a a w ra o t ol alato Th roo athatal trtr th to otl a l ay t l artlarly whr th rt o rta otatoal qatt o a al owlt Sal tha ar xt to Pro a aa Vtaly L Gzr Ra Pro a aa Dtry V Shro Ra Pro Lo Shl Ra Pro Vlar Ya ar Ra Pro Wola Rlr US Pro Roa W Jaw US Pro Ror Pro UK Pro St Wr US Pro Ezra T Nwa US Pro Graha Jao UK Pro Sry Rhta Ra a ay othr or thr ort a alal a r y t a rarh Rr Zah R Larzato Mtho th R Thory Ra ay o S RS llt o th L Phy Ittt Nw Yor Srr-Vrla No - 99 Zah R O l t o th R Thory Ra ay o S RS llt o th L Phy Ittt Nw Yor Srr-Vrla No - 99 Zah R O th Coto tw Mtho o th R Thory a th Gro roah Ra ay o S RS llt o th L Phy Ittt Nw Yor Srr- Vrla No - 99 Zah Ra Th Larzato Mtho a o th Thory o R a t lato Phy Ra ay o S RS Pl Ra 99 htt://arhrlr//atalo/ror/9 htt://lrlr/wr/9#?a= Dr Joh R Mor lra: Itroto r Joh Wly a So US 99; lyth TS; Rorto E "Gro r a l: lra throh rat" oo Car Urty Pr UK 9 Do Loar E Htory o th Thory o Nr Vol II: Dohat aly Mola Dor Plato NY US Morll L J Dohat Eqato Pr a l Mathat a Pr 99 Irla K; Ro M Claal Itroto to Mor Nr Thory Srr- Vrla Nw Yor US 99 9 Gry M W Ga l Thor: Itroto wth lato Joh Wly a So US 99 yr J Cotatoal Nootat lra a lato Srr-Vrla - ora Nola lra rl Nw Yor Srr-Vrla 9