!"# 4 +, )-. / , 3* ( I GH ) "!" ( G 3% $ 7 *

Transcription

1 !"# ( ) (* ) #* ' :$ #" 4 +, )-. / , 3* )- 3 ) 5. / 8 4 " ( 59 :; <6"7. -+.!-". / )- 9 :$ > /- (*, ( 4 + )- #,), 0 B # #+ #_ / #,?@> * $. : " ( )> #, /- 3>7 9 :/-?@> (*. * * ; B (>.).,. ) / # #+ 2 # ) -, /-.F#* (*7, :E" D- ( I GH ) "!" ( G 3 $ 7 * I ) - > $ *9!" ( JE <B *.. &' "# (! "# $ 289

2 '# ) * #+, -'. / - 0 Disability Evaluation of Traumatic Injuries of Extremities From The Forensic Medicine Standpoint Mohammed Fawzi All-najjar * Abstract Background: the problem of disability evaluation of traumatic injuries is one of the real problems in the work of courts because of the absence of a standardized method consistent with the Syrian Penal Code and the law of insurance and cope with the real meaning of the concept of disability from the viewpoint of the Criminal Code, leading forensic doctors to adopt schedules disability of social insurance to estimate the disability from the standpoint of the judiciary. Objective: our goal is to find a method to assess the degree of disability judicial compatible with the characteristics of the Syrian society (for Penal and Insurance Act) beneficiaries of all methods. this method must be easy application-scientific-measurable- logical and far from the personal forensic physicians estimates. Methods: he most important methods used to estimate the degree of disability are totalitarian tables (d. Maher),Rice method,american method and Canadian. Every one of these methods disadvantages which make it inapplicable in Syria. Results and Conclusion: Ten simple equations has been found to define all forms of Traumatic injuries of limbs. Our research also created concept of wind weighting for some special injuries which are influenced by some factors as age, sex. in addition to, the agenda to estimate the possibility of a permanent impairment in some Traumatic injuries was given. * Prof. Ass.Disability Evaluation of Traumatic Injuries of Limbs from the Medicine Standpoint, Damascus Univrsity. 290

3 291

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

6 '# ) * #+, -'. / - 0 ; #' & "' 97-2 " ' " : *3 " -( 2$ 52 P GS3 R -'. K7 ) '' 2 A D "0 Q8' <3 & D -3.!3 A ''# /( /(!3 <3 /D >( ) / " 0!3 Q' Q>5 >P! N ( -.*2( I : 5 )!4/ 0!, J7!=, (!, ' "8!63, & M 03!!4,0 /! *6 V "2 :2; 2# -P K7 '$ Q 3 5! (2* 2-2$ C) '. R ( R P ' 2 27 (, "'),0!3# : *6 " / " 0 4# - J -P!2 ) '' / W$ '= < N 9-' 9!24/ 20 J2( 9 2!3 *( I : 5 ) (2' "2 0?$ M6' <4 M'' * &! 2 4 7( '. -'> : 7P,0 "! A N I V $ :; B'#' &P U '' ( J QD, 3./ './ " 0 '8 4# : = * 5#' :J 1, /- - :totalitarian tables : ( -1 K27 2) 2( 98 K7 A >( -'. 7 ( 3 9 -= -D6 :; 06 :23.<2 4/ 6 03 :, ( 6 03 : B' 294

7 M, ' 4 -'. '( 6!3 ( 1 > ' 2= 27 #203 7 ( ( -'>!6 # K0 " ( 5' Q 10 K0!( ' '(!4/ 92* '( 3 6 -D, A 06 ( / " 2$ :! "'# A$ :! 0 7! /!3 ' 03 <XS3 J(.-=!3! 0 5' Q 20 GS :; 0 '$! V3! "# I "0 7 9/ &0 V3 < Q'0 $!3 7?, = L : -=2 2 A0 6 -, -'. ( = 2* :2; &P = K7 :; Q3/ B0'; =; 9Q *,' <'. 7 Multi partial disability Method : )- 1, -2 *3 * A 0'!3 A / - 0# K7 ' / ' " S3 9!3 '; >( '2 2 2' 20' ' > '. ' > 9:.100 : '. Rice method :B -3 2$ 9#!3 / 0 6 ( $ : 0# - ( ' # '' Q Q *6, /2-0 N 3 0# K7 90 ( A 7 6 :' (' *' (! 295

8 '# ) * #+, -'. / - 0 6!( 06 ' # '' 6 7 = / ' D( # 03 ' :0# K7 : P ( K7 03 ' 9N -( 7 ( 6 ( -' 72 -( K7 03!3 GH> 9# 6)!3 >P = -(./ & -'. K7 D3 / - GS3 GH> & # # ( L 0# K7 "!6 # -';!3 ; /2 '2 "2!3 A* -$ 0# 7 L : K "2 2, 6 ( # / $ V -'?'; '; N :> ' : # ( 7 ' #' 100 & 2 2 GS3 /' (0 # >D> 6) K27 55 "!0 65 " # 50 "! 6 7 :E ' ( " :2 #03 K7 =;.Q'0 100 = 300\ \ \50,2 ' ' 6 =,! ( '', 6) 2 2 2>?' ; <6), 7 03, #0 ; ( I ('.?'. K7 6!3 -$= :!5 ' 0# K7.6 L -( 7; # ( 6) 03 ',! ( 7; -2./ " 0' >P 296

9 : * ; -4 / " 0 A #' 0#!7 9 ( 0# ' # '. #!3 G= '; >( N 2 2*; Q3, : '. / ' & 4* /.N -'. / " V : * -5 2'( 2 Canadian Legal Information Center &2( - * 1 $.! *6 ' 6!3,6 < / " 0' * /( 2*6 9B2'# K -'!'# *6 7 permanent impairment 4 K0!3 J -'!4,$ *6 7 permanent disability 4 / 2= <3 ) < < " '' 5 '# L!2 0> " W#!3,6 <; < (.'. < P ' R > 3# *6 ( "L N * W$ -/2( 2$. (!3 ''?3 : D> $ L 2 [2' 1! / ' N? #0 : /( - : :- :; / " 4# * $ $ 9/ " 2> 2 : 9B, ' / "' : 2 9B,+!(!4/!6) B I0 / "' -2 -/2 ;.QD> # 0( -'. M'' : A '#!3 -' M' = *( 7; ( Q A>( &( * :-' K7 7 $ : G= 0#!3 QD 7 9!4,0! /! *6 ' 0# /."8!3 0 K7 R K(? : <H; \]; 297

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

12 '# ) * #+, -'. / - 0 principles of estimation judicial :)-L 1, M disability 2 / ' 0 ( = 4 7 *6' #' / *6 ; A3 -D' B6 '0 L 4 7 -'>, '..#0 ' "! '# 0 DL. /D A ' / " '2. 2( ) 03 '. I ' ( '2 2 /D A (B6!3 >P!, M./ # A!7 / ' '$ 7 " A ; 2 <26) :; ", A $ A!7.'O A0.B6 /D -D? B*' -'2. ( 3 J 91! P#; ( / ' $ ;.4 7( " = 1 $ / " "'! 2 ( 4)? / - N '' "., $.) (' ) M8'!4,0 / ' 9!2 "'# '$ -= M' 0> " > (4.7'! <!,0 *$,6 :E!7 ( # 03 / " :) 0 ; 75 # 6) # & # # 6) # L & # # 6) # *6 03 > 3#

13 Q2 Q 2, :0' $ ; <6 03, 03 ' / " 2 2# 2' 2' / N Q$3 ( 7 9Q6) 6 L <( ' -=!3 / - " ' /.< ( " 2 6) 03 -=!3 - "!3 9# 06 ( ' (5 ( ' ) # 6) 06 ' A20'?2 ( - 6 ' :!3 ( 0# 6 '' 7 ' -( V ( * -( A 2' 6 (? ( 96 6)!3 ( K7 7 "! ' 7 6 <;! &, '' 7. # 6) (2 ", -'. / " ' 0# * 2(!24/ 2 (!4/ # '!7 ( 26 -$2 2(!4/ # 6 -( #. "#, A -, ' :# 9 ) 1, J G :E #0 `abc.d( # 6) '' & # ( '# ( / # -( ( / # B/ ' / - -4 :( >7-1 2L 2 2# 4) ' 6 ( : /( ; :2# = #' K03 -'#,= 5 ' N J 9!0# 301

14 '# ) * #+, -'. / - 0 (( 4 7)!( "#, ' =; * " * $ ' K7 :!5 ( 6 ( 7 ( V/ $' ' :0' # 6) 50 = ( 6 7 # 6) 50 = # 6, 75 = ( A ( d 6 7 V 2 (2?' 65 +(' d)10 A'!7 100 = 300\ \ \50 :E 65 (2 2* ' 2?' 6 7 S3, :!5 ( V/ 5 "0 ( 10 6 ( 7 G; R' 25 = *6 *'. - # 6) #2 10 = "0 6 7 G; R' 20 = *6 '' - # 6) ' 4 = '20 26 ( 7 G; R' 10= *6 :# - & # 6) 2 = ' 26 7 V/ R' * ( 5 = *6 ' - 26) 1 = ' 6 7 # 6) 2 * ( '0.# 9# ( QD( & # 6) 2 :* 6 # -.# 6) 10 *6 # ( :# ( )* ( -2 :'# ( -( = (!6! V?3 (* 302

15 170 =!' V?3 ( * 140 = ( *?3!( ( 60 6 :; '' -( K7 7 V/ 30 :'# 3 -( 6 '' 80 *7 145 = #' # ( * 6 '' 40 *7 155 = B0= "( ( * :'# -( 6 80 *7 150 =! &*) # ( * 6 40 *7 50 = &/ &'( = ( * :'# *'. -( 6 A0 100 *7 50 = "0 6 ( * 6 A0 100 *7 80 = ' 6 ( * :'#?' 6 -( 90 = "0 6 ( * 90 = # 6 ( * 100 (2 6 ( 7 5' Q. 60= ' 6 ( *.# $ 0' A06!3 K( ( 6 * ( A0 206 Q2 K2 #!( $ Q4,6 :)D '2 2' 2 / *( ' G=!(?2 20# K7 (.( - *6' "'! ( M' 2 A # I3 N <X; ; (, ".*6 '' " # #03, # 7 -( " 303

16 '# ) * #+, -'. / $ (!7 7;! -( ; 2(!2 -, -( K7 0 6( 4 L N -( 27 -!7 *' #. ( = \]; B'#+ *(3 6!(.7 >' :)- -3 :6!4/ / !2( 2( :; A 06!( " : 0# '2 ",2 2> 9 <'' & 06!( I0 ' 3 '2' ' ", > 96 '' ( 7 '.(75) QD2( # 6) 03 / '' ", 9# :& :)> ( * 0 * 6, ( 1 0+) L #*, # ( >7 (# * >7 *, R2' 2( 6!( :; - '. M6 :1 >!2 24* / ' GS '!?3 ( / -03 :!7 K7 *'' ( 6) 12 = = \110 = L -, O ( ) * G*7 6 (2 0+ ) 3\3 + 2\2 + 1 L (L + ) -, ( G * :( 3 0+ ) 0@.)# 1 J + B 1 > (,8 304

17 :?' -'; 6 / " " "2 " 03?' 6 ( / " " K 2 2( :; :; A' # :; ''?' 6 7. :4 > '2 GS23 ( (' '' 6 -( :; - '. M6 / # '' '' 7 ' = '. K7 /.15 =20 75= # 6 03 = 24* /2 GS3 QD> 6 (!3.4 7 '. K7 " = J 1 $!7 0,8=1 75 > 1, ( ) 1, 8:(4 0+ ).- L,L G* ) 9 G*7 :( 5 0+).0 5# 9 (* 1,, R, - :& #!3 / $ :; &P Q'L 6!3 :; &P! -'. ) ; 2 >( N :> 0# GS3 J 6 - N!3!6) '. / '?' J. / " 0#!7 '; A20 0' ', *! '. / ' :; N'( :& '; >( N (7.( -100 ) 2= + 1 = = (6 0+) = = : L 7 ) 9 G*7 6 (@= 100 ) 3= + (1= :R 305

18 '# ) * #+, -'. / (' A0 >> > 4* / '= : / ' 7 = (1-100) 2 +1 = b : #" 1, 1, -4 :# GH> # ( 4)? 03! ' G; ( ' N 6 4) K7 03 " : ' :!5 ( $ *$ " ' ( 80!7 ( / :# :D(!6( 6 # ' 1-4.E # # 2 &P < L ' 7 :d :, N!3 # ' -2-4 (( '$) Q( < (!3!0' 0 =; # 6) 03 :; # -( Q$ $! # -'>!3 &, 0# #! *) Q$ M 9> D () S } _ S = : 8 ) (7 0+)!7 0 {() ( ) *' " # 4* '!7 : R # 80!7 QD( # 03 '!7 :J.E # 2(?' ' 9d N : ' -= (!3 K7 6 :!5?'3!#2 26 N 2!23) (?'. ' :# :?' ' 3-4 ''2 2*'. '3 9?'. K7 03 ( / ' (!D 306

19 -D N!3?' ' 2 0= $ / ' :E A0 3 ) 7 E, ( E, 6, ).; 6 :( 8 0+ ) O ; 6, (L R + ( 2 / ( ) = 6, <2; Q3,2 (?'. 6) 03! # N!3?' 03 G;.# 03 / ' :O 0 )U, ( 6, ) ; 8 ) 7 (. + 2 ) = :(9 0+).JE* :& # / " 4) ' Q # B0'? # ( N # 75!7 ' :0' 5!7 2( '2; /2 " :# D3!4/ 03 9E # ' ' " ##')? '0 L '. -'>S', "2 -B 0 (; J!3 "' ($ : '. 2 ( * *S3 4, " K7 L 9( '. "8' =; D2 2*4#; 2,26 J #' " K7 "'' - (.*'>S' :& # $ / " 2 " # # ' # 3 7 0' 0 9A 2 6 B0'? '. K7 CD, '. 307

20 '# ) * #+, -'. / - 0.?#0 0# - 03 & ' *6 0 *6 6 J Q # " # ' # 3 (3 0 -=!3!3 ( 4 # $ 6 ' # B/ 4 (28 2 ';!4/ ) # 4L= -'#,= : / ' " 20 0) # ( / ' = # $ / ' (!'# # # ' / ) S = :OL + 8 ) (100+ ) (.' " # ' # 3 0 = R ' # # = # )#, 9 1, :GG B> J7 ( 9& #!3 ( 7(! 0 :E A0 '# R # $!7 * " 8 ) (10) 0 / ( :(11 0+) L L L,, * 7. ( 3 8 3L 7 1L 10 L, O ( 10-4,L O ( 11 5#, (7-5) 1 2#! "' >( 6 3# ' -(!3 Q'#, "' $!6 Q ' <'' :(* (* 59, )#, ( >7-1.# 6) 54 <7 :&6!6$ 6 308

21 !6 # 6) 55 <7 :'( 6 7 9!6 # 6) 55 <7 :0 ( = (300 55) + (200 55) +(100 54) :E 0 20!26 ' : V/ 3 0 (, 7?/ 6) $ 25 7$ 7 :# A A ( i!6 &!# 6 (!6 # 6) 5 V/ R' 9QD(!6 # :!E ( : V/ # $ 30 :#3?' 6.!'(.!D 6 ( 7,5 R' 15 *'..D 6 ( 2 R' 6 >?'..6 ( 1 V/ * ( 3 :5-4-3?'. :)#, ( )* ( -2 :*7 "!7 -( RD> J :J 6!( *7 9'(!>? 140 # #'' 110:#' #.6 6).6 6) 50 * :' "0.6 6) 45 * :!! 7$ 9#' #!7 A ( '( :'( 6!(. 135.( 0 6 :0 6!( 26) * K0! &*) #.6.* :!! "D0= 309

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

24 '# ) * #+, -'. / - 0 #!3!( ' 06!( 0 Q *!2'# (2' '2 2 ' / *( N G=.6 ' 6 ( 6 -' :D- + L Q0' 7 ( 9 5( 7 ( K7 7./ " V K7 > : P!2 "'# ( 0# B#;? 7 I!7 2 Q' " 5' $ ( 0' / - N, A / - :0' #' A' L " " M' ' 0 9N 4# '0.0# ' 6 3 0#' A " ' (* )-.; 1, -1 L L 1, ) (> ( #* 1, K5 > #* (, 7 K 7) 1, K K KK KK K KK KKK K ; 6, ) * K K 3 KK KK K 3 KK KK K JE*. 3 K K 5, 312

25 K K " K 3 KK KK 3 K ; 6, ) # G. 3# G. 7 3# K K. 2', -3D 7! K7!3 $ M' 0 "2 2 : "L!3 5 0#!3 > 0# (2 5' < ( 7 9*'0 7 0#' A 2( 9< B/, < B/ # 03 ' & 7!3? N!# 9QD> #??'. '?'. ' ' 6 = * 2 $?2, " '! "'# 0 R' -./ - = 2, -'2. M'2 20#' A0 / - ' 0 BS' :!5 *6 -'O 0#' A0 / - 1, 0 B 0 1, (, 2) 5, 5 "# 0 E, ( (,7 E,.) 5 ; R@. * ; )* (# (* )* ( 313

26 '# ) * #+, -'. / - 0 2! =! -'. M' ' 7 )D ; (0#? : 7 ) A' D 06( & 0!3 / " )D ( 9 " / 4-7 7' "2 A0 / " '0? (' : 0#' A0 2( 203 2' -0 A 0' / 0# ( 9.2!3 " <'!0# ; j6 -( ( A /2 2!4/ ( 6 =!# 7?20 20# "2 A0 " 9 ( A ' -0 J, $ " *, ( 7,. -=2 (2 : '>?, 7! * G Q) N2 4#' / " W0 N' D.? / " 0 A =' 0# " A0 / " 0 B; 'D3 3-0 K7 -'> $.-'O N 4#' A0 / "?.N 4# 7' 0# permanent impairment & disability : B'# ' 4 >( :!,0 *6 7 ; 20.*' / " 0 N # # ' I -2'!2'# 2* *6' 4 $. 7! "'# 6) 2 J *6 *' <; &!,0 4 / W$ QD(!# R' 'O!'# #? 'O 03 (. K7 > ' * Q6 Q4* 314

27 2( 2$!23 / ' / QD (!,0 ^ $ M0 ( $ 745 A$) < Q/ J 1 = 4/!2 "2'# 2'$ 2 0> " W$ ( J ( 1985/5/19?3 "! -= K7!3!,0! k B#. A,.*3 / ' 20# "2 A2 24 $. ",' 4 / 2 >5 A " ' W > ' 2 >52 3) : N 03 ' / = R' N 9QD( ' 4* ' / X= " 6!27 K7 7 ( (7...# 03 4* ' / = ".!=?, : I 9 &P2 R2 -'S' *?!3 A>(' -'. K7 $ - &206!3 / -3U -7 :; 7! -, M' < 0.7(? # 3, -'.!3 9I (' : = N -3E K7 >!3 / - 0 A 0# J7 K > 92# :2 -'. K7 <6 &!6) "#,= V2!3 7>5 D ((,!3 7>5 R -'#,=./D -D B; ' J 9'!( recommendations: B2'# : #+, -'.!3 / - 0# -1./ - 0#( 7 9 (.R'!3 A -'. M'!3 0> *

28 '# ) * #+, -'. / - 0-2P "2 2*$DL; '# A : (5-3.R'!3 0 A # 2 / - A'!3! "'# : (5-4 A2 72; '. I'!3 E = B'#.* '> *46 2, -'. / - 4#!3 R' -5. B, '' 316

29 2'# R2> 6.! "# "( jl / ( ' / 148 2$! ' & -' 0 $ -2 ( A).<D B/ -( A D) R! *= j! ', : '# 311 I Gui- 2( 2'# 2#' L(2 42 / I K' '# 1993]N(925N) Gunnar B.J Andersson ; Linda Cocchiarella -guides to the evaluation of permanent impairment; American medical association International classification of functioning; Disability and health /W H O / 2001 (p: 59) 7- Robert T. Reville ;An evaluation of California s permanent disability rating system Ronald Mc Race ; Clinical Orthopaedic Examination- second edition 1985 (p: /11/11 : :; R' ^.2009/1/22: < '$ ^ 317