arxiv: v2 [math.ap] 28 May 2015

Transcription

1 Citicality of the Axially Symmetic Navie-Stokes Equations axiv:155.68v [math.ap] 8 May 15 Zhen Lei Qi S. Zhang Abstact Smooth solutions to the axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations obey the following maximum pinciple: sup v θ (t, ) L v θ (, ) L. t We pove that all solutions with initial data in H 1 is smooth globally in time if v θ satisfies a kind of Fom Boundedness Condition (FBC) which is invaiant unde the natual scaling of the Navie-Stokes equations. In paticula, if v θ satisfies sup v θ (t,,z) C ln, δ (, 1 t ), C <, then ou FBC is satisfied. Hee δ and C ae independent of neithe the pofile no the nom of the initial data. So the gap fom egulaity is logaithmic in natue. We also pove the global egulaity of solutions if v θ (, ) L o sup t v θ (t, ) L ( ) is small but the smallness depends on cetain dimensionless quantity of the initial data. 1 Intoduction The global egulaity poblem of 3D incompessible Navie-Stokes equations is commonly consideed as supecitical because the a pioi estimates based on enegy equality become wose when looking into fine and fine scales (fo instance, see Tao [5]). Such a supeciticality baie is one of the main easons why this poblem is such a had poblem. Recently, the axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations have attacted temendous inteests of expets. See, fo instance, [1,, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 1, 13, 14, 15, 18,, 1,, 3, 4, 7] and many othes. These esults heavily depend on the maximum pinciple of the dimensionless quantity Γ = v θ, which makes the axi-symmetic Naive-Stokes equations patially citical (only the swil component v θ of the velocity field satisfies a dimensionless a pioi estimate). Although the axially symmetic Navie-Stokes equation is a special case of the full thee-dimensional one, ou level of undestanding had been oughly the same, with essential difficulty unesolved because the effective a pioi bound available is still the enegy estimate, which has a positive dimension 1. The aim of this aticle is to show that the axi-symmetic Naive-Stokes equation is in fact fully citical. Moe pecisely, we pove that all solutions with initial data in H 1 ae School of Mathematics, Fudan Univesity, Shanghai 433, P. R. China. Depatment of Mathematics, Univesity of Califonia, Riveside, CA 951 1

2 smooth globally in time if v θ satisfies a kind of Fom Boundedness Condition (FBC) which is invaiant unde the natual scaling of the Navie-Stokes equations. In paticula, if v θ satisfies sup v θ (t,,z) C ln, δ (, 1 t ), C <, then ou FBC is satisfied. Hee δ and C ae independent of neithe the pofile no the nom of the initial data. The poof is based on the obsevation that the voticity equations can be tansfomed into a system such that the votex stetching tems ae citical. This means that the potentials in font of unknown functions scale as 1/ x. Fo example, in (1.8) below, the function J is a egaded as unknown and the potential in font of it is vθ which scales as 1/ x. Wealsopovetheglobalegulaityofsolutionsifsup t v θ (t, ) L ( ) o v θ (, ) L is small but the smallness depends on cetain dimensionless quantity of the initial data. Ou wok is inspied by the ecent inteesting esult of Chen-Fang-Zhang in [5] whee, among othe things, global egulaity is obtained if v θ (t,,z) is Hölde continuous in vaiable. To state ou esult moe pecisely, let us ecall that in cylindical coodinates,θ,z with (x 1,x,x 3 ) = (cosθ,sinθ,z), axially symmetic solutions of the Navie-Stokes equations ae of the following fom v(t,x) = v (t,,z)e +v θ (t,,z)e θ +v z (t,,z)e z, p(t,x) = p(t,,z). The components v,v θ,v z ae all independent of the angle of otation θ. Hee e,e θ,e z ae the basis vectos fo R 3 given by ( x1 e =, x ), (, x eθ =, x ) 1,, ez = (,,1). In tems of (v,v θ,v z,p), the axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations ae t v +(v e +v z e z ) v (vθ ) + p = ( 1 )v, t v θ +(v e +v z e z ) v θ + v v θ = ( 1 )v θ, t v z +(v e +v z e z ) v z + z p = v z, v + v + zv z =. (1.1) It is well-known that finite enegy smooth solutions of the Navie-Stokes equations satisfy the following enegy identity Denote One can easily check that v(t, ) L + t v(s, ) L ds = v L, t. (1.) Γ = v θ. t Γ+(v e +v z e z ) Γ = ( )Γ. (1.3)

3 A significant consequence of (1.3) is that smooth solutions of the axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations satisfy the following maximum pinciple (see, fo instance, [, 7, 3,, 1]): sup Γ(t, ) L Γ L. (1.4) t We emphasis that Γ(t, ) L is a dimensionless quantity with espect to the natual scaling of the Navie-Stokes equations. Fom this point of view, the axi-symmetic Naive-Stokes equations can be seen as patially citical, while the geneal Navie-Stokes equations ae known to be supecitical (see [5]). Now let us intoduce the function class whee v θ lives. It is defined in an integal way which is usually called Fom Boundedness Condition (FBC), which is in spiit simila to a condition so that cetain Hady type inequality holds. Definition 1.1. We say that the angula velocity v θ (t,,z) is in (δ,c )-citical class if v θ f dx C v θ f dx δ f dx+c f dx, (1.5) f dx+c f dx, (1.6) holds fo some >, some C > and fo all t and all axi-symmetic scala and vecto functions f H 1. Clealy, unde the natual scaling of the Navie-Stokes equations: v λ (t,x) = λv(λ t,λx), p λ (t,x) = λ p(λ t,λx), the above definition of FBC is invaiant: (v λ ) θ also satisfies (1.5)-(1.6) if v θ does. Below is the fist esult of this aticle: Theoem 1.. Thee exists a constant δ > such that fo abitay C > 1, all local stong solutions to the axially symmetic Navie-Stokes equations with initial data v H 1 < and Γ L <, if the angula velocity field v θ is in (δ,c )-citical class, i.e. v θ satisfies the citical Fom Boundedness Condition in (1.5)-(1.6), then v is egula globally in time. An impotant coollay of Theoem 1. is: Coollay 1.3. Let δ (, 1 ) and C 1 > 1. Let v be the local stong solution of the axially symmetic Navie-Stokes equations with initial data v H 1 and Γ L <. If then v is egula globally in time. sup Γ(t,,z) C 1 ln, δ, (1.7) t<t We emphasis that C in Theoem 1. and C 1 in Coollay 1.3 ae independent of neithe the pofile no the nom of the given initial data. The poof of this Coollay will be given at the end of section. The point is that if (1.7) is satisfied, then the FBC of (1.5)-(1.6) is tue. Then one can apply Theoem 1. to get the desied conclusion. 3

4 Ouwok is inspiedby aecent vey inteesting wok by Chen, Fang and Zhang[5] whee, among othe things, the authos poved that v is egula if Γ is Hölde continuous. Let Ω = ωθ, J = zv θ. We emphasis that J was intoduced by Chen-Fang-Zhang in [5], while Ω appeaed much ealie and can be at least tacked back to the book of Majda-Betozzi in [17]. Both of the two new vaiables ae of geat impotance in ou wok. Following [17, 7, 5], we also study the equations fo J and Ω: t J +(b )J = ( + ) J +(ω +ω z z ) v, t Ω+(b )Ω = ( + ) (1.8) Ω v θ J. Hee ω θ is the angula component of the voticity ω = v, which eads with ω(t,x) = ω e +ω θ e θ +ω z e z, ω = z v θ, ω θ = z v v z, ω z = v θ + vθ. Ou new obsevation is that the axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations exhibit cetain citical natue when being fomulated in tems of a new set of unknowns J and Ω. Ou second obsevationisthat, withthefbcassumptions(1.5)-(1.6), thestetchingtem(ω +ω z z ) v in the equation of J could be abitaily small, by usingthe elation of v,v z and Ω in Lemma.1 (which was oiginally poved by Hou, Lei and Li [8] in the peiodic case and late on extended to the geneal case by Lei [1]. Altenatively, one may also use the magic fomula given by Miao and Zheng in [19] to pove it). Then we can deive a closed a pioi estimate fo J and Ω using the fist two obsevations and the stuctue of the stetching tem in Ω-equation. Ou second goal is to pove that the smallness of sup t Γ(t, ) L ( ) o Γ L implies the global egulaity of the solutions. Recently, Chen-Fang-Zhang in [5] poved that, among many othe inteesting esults, if Γ(t,, z) is Hölde continuous in -vaiable, then the solution of the axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations is smooth. Both of the esults depend on given initial data. Moe pecisely, the smallness of sup t Γ(t, ) L ( ) o Γ L in ou Theoem 1.4 depends on othe dimensionless noms of the initial data. Fom this point of view, ou esult impoves the one in [5]. We define V = vθ. Hee is the second main esult. Theoem 1.4. Let >. Suppose that v H 1 such that Ω L, V L and Γ L L. Denote ( Ω L + V L ) Γ L = M and ( V L + Ω L + v L Γ 3 L ) Γ L = M 1. 4

5 Thee exists an absolute positive (small) constant δ > such that if eithe o Γ L δm 1, sup Γ(t, ) L ( ) δm1 1, t then the axially symmetic Navie-Stokes equations ae globally well-posed. The poof of Theoem 1.4 is based on a new fomulation of the axi-symmetic Navie- Stokes equations (1.1) in tems of V and Ω = ωθ v, and also on the estimate of in tems of Ω and its deivative (see Lemma.1). Now let us ecall some highlights on the study of the axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations. If the swil v θ =, then it is known since the late 196 s (see Ladyzhenskaya [11], Uchoviskii and Yudovich [6]), that finite enegy solutions to (1.1) ae smooth fo all time. See also the pape by Leonadi, Malek, Necas and Pokony [18]. In the pesence of swil, it is not known in geneal if finite enegy solutions blow up o not in finite time. In [7], Hou and Li constucted a family of lage solutions based on some deep insights on a 1D model. See also some extended esults in [8] by Hou, Lei and Li. We also mention vaious a pioi estimates of smooth solutions by Chae and Lee [] and Buke-Zhang [1]. To the best of ou knowledge, the best a pioi bound of velocity field is given in [13]: v(t,x) C ln 1. In [3], Chen, Stain, Tsai and Yau obtained a lowe bound fo the possible blow up ate of singulaties: if v(t,x) C, then v is egula. Thisseems to bethefisttime that peoplecan exclude possiblesingulaities in the pesence of assumptions on x 1 type non-smallness quantities. Soon late, Chen, Stain, Yau and Tsai [4] and Koch, Nadiashvili, Seegin and Sveak [1] extended the esult of [3] and in paticula, excluded the possibility of type I singulaities of v. See also a local vesion by Seegin and Sveak [3] and vaious extensions by Pan []. We also mention that in [14], Lei and Zhang excluded the possibility of singulaities unde v e + v z e z L ([,T],BMO 1 ) based on an obsevation in [15]. This solves the egulaity poblem of L ([,T],BMO 1 )solutionsofnavie-stokes equations intheaxi-symmeticcase. Moeove, it extends the esult of [3] and [1] since the assumptions on the axial component of velocity v z C 1 itself implies v e +v z e z L ([,T],BMO 1 ) (see [13] fo details). Let us also mention that Neustupa and Pokony [] poved that the egulaity of one component (eithe v o v θ ) implies egulaity of the othe components of the solution. Also poving egulaity is the wok of Jiu and Xin [9] unde an assumption of sufficiently small zeo-dimension scaled noms. See moe efined esults in [1] and the wok of Ping Zhang and Ting Zhang [7]. Chae and Lee [] also poved egulaity esults assuming finiteness of anothe cetain zeo-dimensional integal. Tian and Xin [4] constucted a family of singula axially symmetic solutions with singula initial data. The emainde of the pape is simply oganized as follows. In section we ecall two basic lemmas and pove Coollay 1.3 by assuming the validity of Theoem 1.. Then we pove Theoem 1. in section 3. Section 4 is devoted to the poof of Theoem

6 Notations and Lemmas Fo abbeviation, we denote b(t,x) = v e +v z e z. The last equation in (1.1) shows that b is divegence-fee. The Laplacian opeato and the gadient opeato in the cylindical coodinate ae = θ + z, = e + e θ θ +e z z. Fo scala axi-symmetic function f(t,, z), we often use the commutation popety: f(,z) = f(,z). Thoughout the poof, we will denote f L = f ddz, dx = ddz. The following estimate will be used vey often. It was oiginally poved in [8] in the peiodic case and then extended to the geneal case in [1] (see (4.5)-(4.6) thee by noting the elation v = z ψ θ ). Altenatively, one may also use the magic fomula given by Miao and Zheng in [19] to pove it. Lemma.1. Let v be the adial component of the velocity field and Ω = ω θ /. Then thee exists an absolute positive constant K > such that v L K Ω L, v L K z Ω L. The following lemma gives the unifom decay estimate fo the angula component of voticity in diection fo lage. We point out that a weake estimate fo ω θ has appeaed in []. Even though we don t need to use the estimate fo ω and ω z in this pape, we will still include them below fo possible futue use. Lemma.. Suppose that v L is an axially symmetic divegence-fee vecto and (ω, ω θ,ωz ) L. Then the smooth solution of the Navie-Stokes equation with initial data v satisfies the following a pioi estimates: ( sup ω (t, ) L, ω z (t, ) ) T ( L + [ω (t, )] L, [ω z (t, )] ) L dt (.1) t<t ω L + ω z L +4( Γ L +1) v L, and T sup ω θ (t, ) L + ( ω θ ) L dt (.) t<t { C ( ω θ L + ( v 4 L + Γ L 3 ) v L )exp T } Γ + v L 3 4, L whee C is a geneic positive constant. 6

7 Poof. Fist of all, let us ecall that t ω +b ω v ω = ( 1 ) ω + z v ω z, t ω θ +b ω θ v ωθ = ( 1 ) ω θ (v + θ ) z, t ω z +b ω z z v z ω z = ω z + v z ω. (.3) Let us fist pove (.1). Take the L inne poduct of ω equation with ω and ω z equation with ω z in (.3), we have 1 d (ω ) dx ω ( 1 ) ω dt dx = ω b ω dx+ v (ω ) dx+ ω z v ω z dx and 1 d dt = (ω z ) dx ω z ω z dx ω z b ω z dx+ z v z (ω z ) dx+ ω z v z ω dx Using integation by pats, we have ω ( 1 ) ω dx = (ω ) dx and ω z ω z dx = (ω z ) dx ω z dx. Using the integation by pats and the incompessibility constaint, one has ω b ω dx ω z b ω z dx + v (ω ) dx+ z v z (ω z ) dx = (v + v )(ω ) +(v + z v z )(ω z ) dx = [ z v z (ω ) + v (ω z ) ]dx. Consequently, we have 1 d ( (ω [(ω ) +(ω z ) ] dx+ ) + (ω z ) ) dx dt = ω z dx [ z v z (ω ) + v (ω z ) ]dx ( + ω z v ω z + ω z v z ω ) dx ω z dx+ b L ( ω L + ω z ) 4 L. 4 7

8 Note that by Gagliado-Nienbeg s inequality and the maximum pinciple Γ L Γ L, one has ω L 4 + ω z L 4 = Γ L 4 = ( Γ ( Γ Γ )dx )1 3 Γ L Γ L 3 Γ L ( (ω z ) L + z (ω ) L + ω z L ). Hence, by Holde inequality, we have d ( (ω [(ω ) +(ω z ) ] dx+ ) + (ω z ) ) dx dt 4( Γ L +1) b L. Integating the above diffeential inequality with espect to time and ecalling the basic enegy estimate, one gets (.1). Next, let us pove (.). Let us fist wite the equation of ω θ in (.3) as: t ( ω θ )+b ( ω θ ) 3v ω θ = zγ + ( ω θ ) 4 ( ω θ )+3ω θ. The standad enegy estimate gives that 1 d dt ω θ L + ( ω θ ) L = 3 v ω θ ω θ dx+ z Γ ω θ dx+3 ω θ ω θ dx. It is easy to estimate that z Γ ω θ dx Γ L 3 v θ L ω θ L 6 4 Γ L 3 v θ L ( ω θ ) L. Next, one also has ω θ ω θ dx ω θ L ( R(t)) R (t)+ ω θ L (>R(t)) R (t) ω θ L R (t)+ ω θ L R (t). Finally, we estimate that v ω θ ω θ dx v L ( ω θ ) 3 L 4 (ω θ ) 1 L 4 By taking R(t) = Γ L 3 + u L, we aive at v 4 L ω θ L ( ω θ ) L. d dt ω θ L + ( ω θ ) L ( Γ L 3 + v 4 L ) v L + ( Γ L 3 + u 4 L ) 1 ω θ L. Clealy, (.) follows by basic enegy estimate and applying Gonwall inequality to the above diffeential inequality. 8

9 At last, let us pove Coollay 1.3 by using Theoem 1.. Poof. It suffices to check the validity of FBC in (1.5)-(1.6) unde the assumptions in Coollay. Let δ (, 1 ) and C 1 > 1 be abitaily lage. Noting Γ L < and using the maximum pinciple, we have Γ(t, ) L Γ L. Take a smooth cut-off function of such that Fo all δ < δ, using (1.7), one has φ 1 if 1, φ if. v θ φ( δ )f ddz Using integation by pats, one has 1 ln φ( δ )f ddz = φ( δ )f d ln 1 dz = ln 1 φ( δ )f [φ( δ )f]ddz 1 1 ln φ( δ )f ddz + 1 C 1 ln φ( δ )f ddz. [φ( δ )f] ddz. Hence, we have 1 ln φ( δ )f ddz [φ( δ )f] ddz, which futhe gives that On the othe hand, it is easy to see that Consequently, we have v θ φ( δ )f ddz C 1 [φ( δ )f] ddz. v θ [1 φ( δ )]f ddz Γ L δ [1 φ( δ )]f ddz. v θ f ddz C 1 [φ( δ )f] ddz (.4) [1 φ( + Γ L δ δ )]f ddz 4C 1 f ddz +Cδ f ddz. 9 δ

10 Hee and in the next inequality we usec to denote a geneic positive constant whose meaning may change fom line to line and which may depend on Γ L and C 1. Next, using (.4), we have v θ f ddz + v θ [1 φ( δ )]f ddz v θ vθ φ( δ )f ddz (.5) v C 1 lnδ θ φ( δ )f ddz + Γ L δ Cδ f ddz + 8C1 lnδ f ddz. δ δ f ddz Hence, one may choose δ small enough so that 16C 1 lnδ δ and choose C = 4C 1. Then it is clea fom (.4) and (.5) that the assumptions in (1.5)-(1.6) ae satisfied. Using Theoem 1., one concludes that v is smooth fo all t >. 3 Citicality of Axis-Symmetic Navie-Stokes Equations Poof of Theoem 1.. Fist of all, fo initial data v H 1, by the classical esults of Leay [16] and Fujita-Kato [6], thee exists a unique local stong solution v to the Navie-Stokes equations (1.1). Moeove, v(t, ) H s fo any s at least on a shot time inteval [ǫ,ǫ]. In paticula, ω(t, ) L at least on a shot time inteval [ǫ,ǫ]. A consequence is that ω, ω θ, ω z, ω, ωθ ae all L -functions. In paticula, ecalling that J = ω, Ω = ωθ, one has J(t, ) L, Ω(t, ) L fo t [ǫ,ǫ]. Inductively, one also has J(t, ) H and Ω(t, ) H. Without loss of geneality, we may assume that J H, Ω H. Othewise we may stat fom t = ǫ. As long as the solution is still smooth, one has J(t, ) L + Ω(t, ) L <, J(t, ) L + Ω(t, ) L < and ( J(t,,z) + Ω(t,,z) ) dz J(t, ) H + Ω(t, ) H <. So all calculations ae legal below as long as the solution is still smooth. Ou task is to deive cetain stong enough a pioi estimate. By applying standad enegy estimate to J equation, we have 1 d dt J L = J(b )Jddz + J( + )J + J(ω +ω z z ) v ddz. 1

11 Using the incompessibility constaint, one has J(b )Jddz = 1 J bddz =. On the othe hand, by diect calculations, one has J( + )J = J L J(t,,z) dz. Consequently, we have 1 d dt J L + J L + J(t,,z) dz (3.1) = J(ω +ω z z ) v ddz Similaly, by applying the enegy estimate to the equation of Ω, one obtains that 1 d dt Ω L + Ω L + Ω(t,,z) dz (3.) v θ = JΩddz. In the emaining pat of the poof of Theoem 1., we will use C to denote a geneic positive constant whose meaning may change fom line to line and which may depend on Γ L, C, C and. Using Γ L Γ L and the Fom Boundedness Condition in (1.5), one has v θ JΩddz 1 v θ Ω v θ ddz +C J ddz (3.3) 4C 1 Ω ddz +C J ddz 4 + C ( J + Ω )ddz. Inseting (3.3) into (3.), one has d dt Ω L + Ω L + C J L +C ω L. Ω(t,,z) dz (3.4) Next, we estimate that J(ω +ω z z ) v dx = [ (v θ e θ )] (J v )dx J L v θ v L. 11

12 Again, using the Fom Boundedness Condition in (1.6), one has Using Lemma.1 and the identity we have v θ v L δ v L +C v dddz. Inseting (3.5) into (3.1), we have v = v v e = v v + z v z +e, J(ω +ω z z ) v ddz (3.5) 1 J L + δ v L + C 1 J L + K δ zω L +C v v dddz dddz d dt J L + J L + J(t,,z) dz (3.6) K δ z Ω L +C v dddz. Multiplying (3.6) by 3C and then adding it up with (3.4), we have d ( 3C dt J L + Ω ) ( L + C J L + Ω ) L ( + 6C J(t,,z) + Ω(t,,z) ) dz K δ Ω L +C v ddz. Integating the above inequality with espect to time, we have 3C J(t, ) L + Ω(t, ) L + + t t ( C J L + Ω L ) ds ( 6C J(t,,z) + Ω(t,,z) ) dzds t CC ( J L + Ω L )+K δ Ω L ds+ C v L. Hee we used the basic enegy identity (1.). Recall that K is an absolute positive constant detemined in Lemma.1. Hence, we may take δ so that K δ < 1. Consequently, we have sup t<t T + ( J(t) L + Ω(t) ) T ( L + J L + Ω ) L dt (3.7) ( J(t,,z) + Ω(t,,z) ) dzdt < 1

13 fo all T <. Clealy, the a pioi estimate (3.7) and Sobolev imbedding theoem imply that sup b(t, ) L p ( 1) <, 3 p 6, T <. (3.8) t<t Remak 3.1. Thee ae seveal ways to pove egulaity of v fom hee. Fo instance, the easiest way is just to use the esult in []. If one would like to assume futhe decay popeties on the initial data so that the conditions in Lemma. ae satisfied, then one can easily deive an L ([,T],L p ) estimate fo b when 1 and 3 p 6, by using the basic enegy estimate and Sobolev imbedding theoem. This combining the local L p estimate of v in (3.8) immediate gives that b L ([,T],L 3 ) fo any T <. Using Sobolev imbedding theoem once moe, one has b L ([,T],BMO 1 ). Then the esult in [14] implies that v is egula up to time T. Let us give an altenative and simple self-contained poof below. We fist deive an L 4 a pioi estimate fo v θ without using the esult of [14] and Lemma.. Using the equation of v θ in (1.1) and standad enegy estimate, one has d dt vθ 4 L + (v θ ) 4 L + 1 (v θ ) L v (v θ ) 4 C ddz C 1 v L v θ 4 L 4. Hence, byusinglemma.1andtheedimensionalintepolationinequality f L f L f L, one has v L ψ θ z 1 L ψ θ z 1 L = v 1 L v 1 L Ω 1 L z Ω 1 L. and (3.7), one concludes fom Gonwall s inequality that v θ L 4 <, T 1 (v θ ) L dt <, t T. Then we use the equation of ω θ to deive that d dt ωθ L + ω θ L + 1 ω θ L v = (ωθ ) ddz + ω θ (v θ ) z ddz C 1 v L ω θ L + z ω θ L (v θ ). 4 L Hence, Gonwall s inequality similaly gives that ω θ L, T <. 13

14 By basic enegy identity (1.) and Sobolev imbedding, one has b L p, p 6. Hence, v L T (L4 x). So Sein type citeion implies that v is egula up to time T. 4 Small Γ L o Γ(t, ) L ( ) Global Regulaity This section is devoted to poving Theoem 1.4. Poof of Theoem 1.4. Recall that V = vθ, Ω = ωθ. Let us fist fomulate the axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations (1.1) in tems of V and Ω as follows: t V +b V + 3v V = ( ) 4 V, t Ω+b Ω = ( + ) (4.1) Ω+ zv. By enegy estimate, one has 1 d dt Ω L + Ω L 1 zω L V. (4.) L Let us fist pove the global egulaity unde Using Lemma.1, one has Noting that Γ L δm 1. v L Ω 1 L z Ω 1 L. V 4 L 4 1 V 3 L Γ L 4, one can apply L 4 enegy estimate fo V to get d V + V + 1 V (4.3) dt L L L v L V 4 L Ω 1 4 L z Ω 1 L 1 V 3 L Γ L 4 Ω 1 L Γ 1 L Γ 1 L ( z Ω L + 1 V L ). Combining (4.) and (4.3), we aive at d ( V ( V + Ω dt L L )+ ) + Ω L L Ω 1 L Γ 1 L Γ 1 L ( z Ω L + 1 V L ). (4.4) 14

15 Recall that we have the following a pioi estimate: Γ L Γ L, Γ L Γ L. Hence, unde the condition of the theoem, thee exists T > such that V L + Ω L < V L + Ω L, t < T. If δ is a suitably small positive constant and is satisfied, then we have Γ L δm 1 Ω 1 L Γ 1 L Γ 1 L M 1 (δm 1 )1 δ 1, t < T, Hence, by (4.4), we deive that d ( V ) + Ω dt L L, t < T, which implies that V + Ω L L V + Ω L L, t T. The above agument implies, by the standad continuation method that V L + Ω L V L + Ω L, t. Hence the poof fo fist pat of the theoem is finished. On the othe hand, if Γ(t, ) L ( ) δm 1 1 is satisfied, then one may teat (4.3) as follows: d V + V + 1 V dt L L L v L V 4 L 4 ( ) + v (v θ ) 4 ddz Ω 1 L Γ 1 L Γ 1 ( L ( ) z Ω L + 1 V ) L + 4 v vθ L L Γ 3 L ( ), which combining (4.) gives that V(t, ) t ( V + Ω(t, ) L L + + Ω L L )ds V L + Ω L + 4 v L Γ 3 L + ( )1 Γ L ( ) Γ L sup Ω(s, ) ( L z Ω L + 1 V ) L. s t Hee > is abitay. Then simila continuation aguments as the poof used in the fist pat implies that if δ is a suitable small absolute positive constant, then the solution v is egula. Hee M 1 is given in the statement of Theoem 1.4. This shows that the smallness of Γ locally in implies the egulaity of the solutions. 15

16 Remak 4.1. The constant M in Theoem 1.4 is dimensionless. Indeed, V L and Ω L have dimension 3, and Γ L has dimension 3. Hence, the dimension of M is. Similaly, one can also check that M 1 is also dimensionless if one assigns dimension 1. Acknowledgement The authos would like to thank Pof. Daoyuan Fang, D. Bin Han, M. Xinghong Pan and Pof. Ting Zhang fo discussions. Z. Lei was in pat suppoted by NSFC (gant No , and 1117), Shanghai Shu Guang poject, Shanghai Talent Development Fund and SGST 9DZ79. Qi S. Zhang is gateful of the suppots by the Siyuan Foundation though Nanjing Univesity and by the Simons foundation. Refeences [1] J. Buke Loftus and Qi S. Zhang, A pioi bounds fo the voticity of axially symmetic solutions to the Navie-Stokes equations. Adv. Diffeential Equations 15 (1), no. 5-6, [] D. Chae and J. Lee, On the egulaity of the axisymmetic solutions of the Navie-Stokes equations, Math. Z., 39 (), [3] C. C. Chen, R. M. Stain, T. P. Tsai and H. T. Yau, Lowe bound on the blow-up ate of the axisymmetic Navie-Stokes equations, Int. Math Res. Notices (8), vol. 8, atical ID nn16, 31 pp. [4] C. C. Chen, R. M. Stain, T. P. Tsai and H. T. Yau, Lowe bound on th blow-up ate of the axisymmetic Navie-Stokes equations II,Comm. P.D.E., 34(9), no. 1 3, 3 3. [5] H. Chen, D. Fang and T. Zhang Regulaity of 3D axisymmetic Navie-Stokes equations. Available online at axiv: [6] H. Fujita and T. Kato, On the Navie-Stokes initial value poblem. I. Ach. Rational Mech. Anal. 16(1964), [7] T. Y. Hou and C. M. Li, Dynamic stability of the 3D axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations with swil, Comm. Pue Appl. Math., 61 (8) [8] T. Y. Hou, Z. Lei, and C. M. Li, Global euglaity of the 3D axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes equations with anisotopic data, Comm. P.D.E., 33 (8), [9] Q. Jiu and Z. P. Xin, Some egulaity citeia on suitable weak solutions of the 3-D incompessible axisymmetic Navie-Stokes equations, Lectues on patial diffeential equations, New Stud. Adv. Math., vol., Int. Pess, Someville, MA, 3, pp [1] G. Koch, N. Nadiashvili, G. Seegin, and V. Sveak, Liouville theoems fo the Navie- Stokes equations and applications, Acta Math. 3(9), no. 1,

17 [11] O. A. Ladyzhenskaya, Unique global solvability of the thee-dimensional Cauchy poblem fo the Navie-Stokes equations in the pesence of axial symmety, Zap. Naucn. Sem. Leningad. Otdel. Math. Inst. Steklov. (LOMI) 7 (1968), (Russian). [1] Z. Lei, On Axially Symmetic Incompessible Magnetohydodynamics in Thee Dimensions. Available online at axiv: , to appea in JDE. [13] Z. Lei, E. A. Navas and Q. S. Zhang, A pioi bound on the velocity in axially symmetic Navie-Stokes equations. Available online at axiv: [14] Z. Lei and Q. S. Zhang, A Liouville Theoem fo the Axially-symmetic Navie-Stokes Equations, Jounal of Functional Analysis, 61 (11) [15] Z. Lei and Q. S. Zhang, Stuctue of solutions of 3D Axi-symmetic Navie-Stokes Equations nea Maximal Points. Pacific Jounal of Mathematics, 54 (11), no., [16] J. Leay, Su le mouvement d un liquide visqueux emplissant l espace. Acta. Math., 63 (1934), [17] A. Majda and A. Betozzi, Voticity and incompessible flow. Cambidge Texts in Applied Mathematics, 7. Cambidge Univesity Pess, Cambidge,. [18] S. Leonadi, J. Malek, J. Necas, and M. Pokony, On axially symmetic flows in R 3, Z. Anal. Anwendungen, 18 (1999), [19] C. Miao and X. Zheng, On the global well-posedness fo the Boussinesq system with hoizontal dissipation. Comm. Math. Phys. 31 (13), no. 1, [] J. Neustupa and M. Pokony, An inteio egulaity citeion fo an axially symmetic suitable weak solution to the Navie-Stokes equations, J. Math. Fluid Mech., (), [1] J. Neustupa and M. Pokony, Axisymmetic flow of Navie-Stokes uid in the whole space with non-zeo angula velocity component. Poceedings of Patial Diffeential Equations and Applications (Olomouc, 1999). Math. Bohem. 16 (1), no., [] X. Pan, Regulaity of Solution to Axis-symmetic Navie-Stokes Equations with a Slightly Supecitical Condition. Available online at axiv: [3] G. Seegin and V. Sveak, On type I singulaities of the local axi-symmetic solutions of the Navie-Stokes equations, Comm. P.D.E., 34(9), no. 1 3, [4] G. Tian and Z. P. Xin, One-point singula solutions to the Navie-Stokes equations, Topol. Methods Nonlinea Anal., 11 (1998), [5] T. Tao, Why global egulaity fo Navie-Stokes is had. Available online at [6] M. R. Ukhovskii and V. I. Yudovich, Axially symmetic flows of ideal and viscous fluids filling the whole space, J. Appl. Math. Mech., 3 (1968),

18 [7] P. Zhang and T. Zhang, Global axisymmetic solutions to thee-dimensional Navie- Stokes system. Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN 14, no. 3,