arxiv:hep-ph/ v1 13 Oct 2004

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "arxiv:hep-ph/ v1 13 Oct 2004"

Alisha Casey
5 years ago
Views:

1 arxiv:hep-ph/6v 3 Oct 2 Scearios for multiplicity distributios i pp collisios i the TeV eergy regio Roberto Ugoccioi ad Alberto Giovaii Dipartimeto di Fisica Teorica, Uiversità di Torio ad INFN, Sezioe di Torio, via Giuria, 25 Torio, Italy roberto.ugoccioi@to.if.it, alberto.giovaii@to.if.it Abstract. Possible scearios based o available experimetal data ad pheomeological kowledge of the GeV eergy regio are exteded to the TeV eergy regio i the framework of the weighted superpositio mechaism of ad evets. KNO scalig violatios, forward-backward multiplicity correlatios, H q vs. q oscillatios ad shoulder structures are discussed.. Itroductio Give the curret difficulty of performig QCD calculatios i the realm of multiparticle dyamics, oe possible alterative path cosists i studyig the features of hadroic fial states as obtaied i collisio experimets. The mai motivatio is the covictio that the complex structures which we observe might very well be simple at the origi, ad that such iitial simplicity maifests itself i terms of regularities i fial particle multiplicity distributios (MD s). Ideed, the Pascal regularity [] appeared very soo: that fial charged particle MD s were well described by the egative biomial (N), also kow as Pascal, distributio was discovered first i cosmic rays observatios [2] i the 6, ad later cofirmed i the 5 GeV eergy rage i pp collisios ad up to GeV i e + e aihilatios, as well as i other types of collisios (see, e.g., [3].) The N (Pascal) distributio is a two-parameter distributio: P (Pascal) (,k) = k(k + ) (k + )! k k ( + k) +k () where is the average multiplicity ad /k measures the deviatio of the variace D from the Poisso shape: /k + / = D 2 / 2. (2) I fact, for the Poisso distributio D 2 =, i.e., k, ad for the geometric distributio D 2 = + 2, i.e., k =. That differet reactios showed the same, approximate, regularity was worth of iterpretatio attempts. Probably the most successful of such attempt has bee cla structure aalysis []. Cla (recallig the Scottish sese of the word) refers to a group of particles of commo acestry:

2 2 6 2 Figure. The shoulder structure visible i this charged particle MD at 9 GeV c.m. eergy from the UA5 Collaboratio [5] is well described by the weighted superpositio of two N (Pascal) MD (dashed ad dotted lies). clas are by defiitio idepedetly produced i a umber which follows the Poisso MD, each cla cotais at least oe particle by assumptio ad all correlatios are exhausted withi each cla. Cla acestors, after their productio, geerate additioal particles via cascadig, accordig to a logarithmic multiplicity distributio. The two relevat parameters i cla structure aalysis are the average umber of clas, N, ad the average umber of particles per cla, c. They are liked to the stadard N (Pascal) parameters ad k by the followig o-trivial relatios N = k l( + /k) ad c = / N. (3) Cla structure aalysis reveals ew iterestig properties whe applied to above metioed collisios. I particular it is show that i e + e there are more clas tha pp collisios, whereas each cla is much smaller. I additio, clas i cetral rapidity itervals are larger tha i more peripheral itervals. The deep ielastic case is itermediate betwee the previous oes: clas are less umerous tha i e + e aihilatio ad hadroic i character, but the cla size teds to be leptoic. As soo as the c.m. eergy icreased, more detailed structures appeared i the data: the MD was see to have a shoulder structure i the itermediate multiplicity rage, first i p p collisios [6] ad later also i e + e aihilatio [7]. I both cases a explaatio was foud i terms of the weighted superpositio of differet classes of evets: evets with ad without mii-jets i the case of p p collisios (called ad, respectively; see Figure ), evets with a fixed umber of jets i e + e aihilatio []. It should be stressed here that the MD of each class

3 ( F ) 5 (a) 63 GeV f.p.s. ISR data comp UA5 data comp. comp. comp. (b) 9 GeV η < F F Figure 2. Results of the weighted superpositio model for ( F ) vs. F compared to experimetal data i full phase-space at 63 GeV (a) ad i the pseudo-rapidity iterval η < at 9 GeV (b) []. was agai well described by the Pascal distributio (which could ot, of course, by itself aloe reproduce the shoulder structure). The degree of precisio of such a descriptio is witessed by the fact that ot oly the overall shape is visibly reproduced, but also the quasi-oscillatory behaviour of the so-called H q momets (defied as the ratio of factorial cumulat momets of order q to factorial momets of the same order, H q = K q /F q ), which show sig chages whe plotted as a fuctio of the order q [9]. Fially, a third observable was brought ito play, with differet characteristic behaviour i e + e aihilatio ad pp collisios, but which ca be uderstood i terms of the Pascal regularity ad cla structure aalysis: the stregth of forward-backward multiplicity correlatios []. I particular, it was show that i e + e aihilatio the superpositio mechaism is sufficiet by itself to accout for the small amout of forward-backward multiplicity correlatios (FMC) preset i the data, cosistetly with the idea of a large umber of small clas; o the other had, the superpositio was ot eough i p p collisios (Figure 2): it is required that particle be produced i sizeable groups (clas!) which are ot localised i phase-space, i.e., clas must produce particles i both hemispheres (i other words, there must be a o-zero leakage : there are particles goig backwards from forward-emitted clas, ad vice versa.) 2. Extrapolatios to higher eergies We will ow abado the parallelism with e + e aihilatio, ad i the followig cocetrate o pp ad p p collisios. The kowledge from the GeV eergy rage, summarised briefly i the previous sectio, will ow be employed to extrapolate the MD s i the TeV eergy regio [, 2], i.e., the regio covered by Tevatro ad LHC colliders. The mai equatio of the extrapolatio is the followig: P () = α (Pascal) (,k ) + ( α ) (Pascal) ( 2,k 2 ), () where α is the fractio of evets i the sample. A evet is declared if it cotais o mii-jets: there is some ambiguity as to the threshold which defies a mii-jet, e.g., a calorimetric tower of a few GeV, but a small variatio of this threshold does ot result i a wild variatio of each class parameters. O the other had, a proper defiitio of what is hard ad what is is a extremely iterestig task o itself, but it goes well beyod the scope of this paper.

4 () (A) A 2.2 c.m. eergy (GeV) c.m. eergy (GeV) Figure 3. multiplicity. Extrapolatio of the average Figure. parameter. Extrapolatio of the weight The basic assumptios to be used i the extrapolatio are as follows (see Figure 3): (i) the average charged multiplicity i the sample grows with the logarithm of the c.m. eergy (best fit to available data); (ii) i agreemet with the fidigs at ISR, where oe compoet gives a adequate descriptio of the data, the growth of the average charged multiplicity i the sample is proportioal to l s. (iii) i agreemet with UA fidigs at SpS, the average multiplicity i the sample is twice as large as i the oe, but a very small term quadratic i l s could be added as a correctio (the two possibilities are called A ad i the figures). Accordigly, most, if ot all, of the l 2 s behaviour of comes from the icrease i the mii-jet productio cross sectio. Oe ow has eough iformatio to compute the expected eergy depedece of the weight α : α (s) = 2 (s)/ (s), (5) which is show i Figure. We come ow to the behaviour of k. k was foud to be costat i the GeV regio by the UA5 collaboratio; together with the metioed behaviour of this implies that KNO scalig behaviour is valid for the compoet i the TeV regio: D 2 / 2 costat. (6) We stay with this assumptio o k. As the data o the compoet are scarce, it was decided to explore three differet scearios for the eergy behaviour of k, summarised, together with the average umber of clas ad the average umber of particles per cla, i Figures 5-7. Sceario (Figure 5) I this sceario we assume that KNO scalig holds also for the compoet, i.e., that k is costat. This leads to a slow icrease of the average umber of clas ad of the average umber of particles per cla.

5 .5 /k D 2 / A..3.2 A Sceario 36 N 9 c Sceario Figure 5. Iterpolated ad extrapolated N (Pascal) parameters i sceario. Sceario 2 (Figure 6) Here we test the assumptio of maximum KNO scalig violatio, by assumig that the growth k.52l s. cotiues i the TeV regio. Oe otices that this sceario implies a fast decrease with icreasig eergy of the average umber of clas, a fact which is quite uusual ad iterestig, ad is explored further i these proceedigs [3]. Sceario 3 (Figure 7) I this sceario we trasport the QCD-predicted (at leadig log level) behaviour to fit the low eergy p p data: k.2/l( =.3 s/). It correspods to a icrease, slower tha i sceario 2, toward a asymptotic costat value, i.e., toward a MD which is asymptotically KNO scalig. From the poit of view of cla aalysis, this sceario is itermediate betwee ad 2, ad shows agai a decrease i N with icreasig s ( N will start to icrease agai i the KNO scalig regime, due to the icrease of.) 3. Extesio to small rapidity itervals I goig from full phase-space (FPS) to pseudo-rapidity (η) itervals, our mai cocer is to be cosistet with the scearios explored i FPS ad exted them. It should be poited out that by assumig oly a logitudial growth of phase space ad costat height of the rapidity plateau with c.m. eergy for evets, as doe i Ref. [2], CDF data [] i pseudo-rapidity itervals are uderestimated. These data are well described by allowig a l 2 s growth of the rapidity plateau: from this cosideratio oe deduces a more appropriate

6 .5 /k D 2 / A..3.2 A Sceario 2 36 N 9 c Sceario Figure 6. Iterpolated ad extrapolated N (Pascal) parameters i sceario 2. growth of the plateau height; the costrait is that i full phase space follows a logarithmic growth with s as discussed above (curves ). Predicted charged particle multiplicity distributios i the three scearios of the two-compoet model for the iterval η < at Tevatro ad LHC eergies, calculated for the last metioed case, are show i Fig. 9 (otice that a direct compariso with CDF data, i view of the relatively large value of their resolutio p T >. GeV/c, is questioable). If this behaviour for the compoet will be cofirmed by data oe should coclude that evets populate maily the cetral rapidity regio givig a importat cotributio to the icrease of charged particle desity i cetral rapidity itervals.. Fermilab results Two sets of data are available from Tevatro: the E735 Collaboratio [5] gives full phase-space results, from data measured i η < 3.25 ad p T >.2 GeV/c ad the exteded via a Mote Carlo program, which do ot completely agree with those obtaied at comparable eergies at the SpS collider, as show i Figure (left pael); Tevatro data are more precise tha SpS data at larger multiplicities (they have larger statistics ad exted to larger multiplicities tha UA5 data), but much less precise at low multiplicity. oth sets of data show a shoulder structure, but the Tevatro MD is somewhat wider. As see from the same Figure (right pael), sceario 2 is the oe that come closer to these data. The secod set of data comes from CDF [6] for charged particles i η < ad p T >. GeV/c: it was foud that by subdividig the miimum bias sample ito two groups, characterised respectively by the absece ( evets) or the presece ( hard evets) of mii-

7 .5 /k D 2 / A..3.2 A Sceario N c Sceario Figure 7. Iterpolated ad extrapolated N (Pascal) parameters i sceario sceario E735 GeV E735 GeV E GeV E735 3 GeV UA5 9 GeV UA5 56 GeV UA5 2 GeV Figure. E735 results do ot quite agree with UA5 oes (left pael; data from the two experimets which were take at early the same eergy are here rescaled by the same factor), but are close to sceario 2 s predictios (right pael).

8 GeV sceario GeV sceario GeV sceario 2 GeV sceario GeV sceario 3 GeV sceario Figure 9. Predictios for the multiplicity distributios i η < at ad GeV i our scearios for pp collisios.

9 Table. N (Pascal) ad cla structure aalysis parameters for pp collisios at TeV i the two-compoet model. FPS % k N c η <.9 % k N c Table 2. Forward-backward multiplicity correlatios stregth parameter for pp collisios at TeV i the two-compoet model. F corr. stregth FPS η < (weighted).9.92 Soft 63 GeV GeV Hard 63 GeV GeV <> P(z) <> P(z) Ratio(63/) z = / <> Ratio(63/) z = / <> Figure. CDF results o MD s at GeV: the compoet satisfies KNO scalig, the hard oe does ot [6]. jets, iterestig features of the reactio ca be ivestigated. More precisely, a hard evet has bee defied as a evet with at least oe calorimeter cluster i η < 2., a cluster beig defied as a seed calorimeter tower with at least GeV trasverse eergy E t plus at least oe cotiguous tower with E t GeV. A subdivisio which is iterestig per se ad ca be tested at TeV. I summary, the compoet is foud to satisfy KNO scalig (as expected i our scearios), while the hard oe does ot (i disagreemet with sceario, but i agreemet with scearios 2 ad 3); also the p T distributio scales at fixed multiplicity i the compoet ad ot i the hard oe; the dispersio of p T vs. the iverse of the multiplicity is compatible with a extrapolatio to as i the compoet but ot i the hard oe, idicatig i this limit a lack of correlatios i the compoet. 5. Coclusios The weighted superpositio mechaism of two N (Pascal) MD s describes ot oly MD ad H q oscillatios, but also forward-backward multiplicity correlatios i pp ad p p collisios ad e + e aihilatios. I hadroic collisios, the two compoets were foud to correspod to

10 evets (without mii-jets) ad to evets (with mii-jets) respectively. ased o this mechaism, the kowledge of the features of MD s up to 9 GeV c.m. eergy has bee used to predict the characteristic behaviour expected i the TeV eergy rage: the compoet satisfies KNO scalig, while the oe violates it strogly. These predictios do ot disagree with the successive fidigs at Tevatro. I terms of cla structure aalysis, a peculiar behaviour was foud: particles i the compoet ted to aggregate formig few, large clas. This behaviour, ad its cosequeces for the LHC experimets, will be ivestigated further i A. Giovaii s cotributio to these proceedigs [3]. Refereces [] Giovaii A ad Ugoccioi R 2 Cla structure aalysis ad qcd parto showers i multiparticle dyamics. A itriguig dialog betwee theory ad experimet Preprit DFTT 2/2, hep-ph/525 [2] MacKeow P K ad Wolfedale A W 966 Proc. Phys. Soc [3] Giacomelli G ad Jacob M 979 Physics Reports 55 Adamus M et al 96 Phys. Lett Derrick M et al 96 Phys. Lett Areodo M et al 97 Z. Phys. C [] Va Hove L ad Giovaii A 97 XVII Iteratioal Symposium o Multiparticle Dyamics ed M Markita et al (Sigapore: World Scietific) p 56 Giovaii A ad Va Hove L 9 Acta Phys. Pol [5] Fuglesag C 99 Multiparticle Dyamics: Festschrift for Léo Va Hove ed A Giovaii ad W Kittel (Sigapore: World Scietific) p 93 [6] Asorge R E et al 99 Z. Phys. C [7] Abreu P et al 99 Z. Phys. C 5 5 [] Abreu P et al 99 Z. Phys. C [9] Ugoccioi R, Giovaii A ad Lupia S 995 Phys. Lett [] Giovaii A ad Ugoccioi R 22 Phys. Rev. D 66 3 [] Giovaii A ad Ugoccioi R 999 Phys. Rev. D [2] Giovaii A ad Ugoccioi R 999 Phys. Rev. D [3] Giovaii A these proceedigs [] Abe F et al Phys. Rev. D 233 [5] Alexopoulos T et al 99 Phys. Lett [6] Acosta D et al 22 Phys. Rev. D

ISMD October

ISMD October ISMD 05 4-9 October Searchig for hidde sectors i multiparticle productio @ the LHC Miguel-Agel Sachis-Lozao Departameto de Física Teórica - IFIC Uiversidad de Valecia CSIC Edward Sarkisa-Gribaum Uiversit