MMIF-processed WRF data for AERMOD Case Study: North ID mountain terrain
|
|
- Stewart Mosley
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 MMIF-processed WRF data for AERMOD Case Study: North ID mountain terrain Tom Swain and Pao Baylon IDEQ
2 Outline Study Area Moyie Springs Sandpoint Part 1: Meteorological Data Analyses Part 2: Modeling Assessment
3 Study Area and Data Availability Spokane Sandpoint Coeur d Alene Moyie Springs Moyie Springs WRF/MMIF 01/15-12/17 Onsite 12/02-11/03 Sandpoint WRF/MMIF 01/15-12/17 NWS 01/15-12/17 DEQ 01/15-03/17
4 Moyie Springs, Idaho Moyie Springs Remote location Complex terrain Valley drainage flows
5 Sandpoint, Idaho Sandpoint NWS Sandpoint MMIF Sandpoint DEQ Complex terrain Valley flows Body of water located east and south of the sites
6 Mesoscale Model Interface program (MMIF) Uses data created by the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model. Processes this WRF data and creates raw meteorological input files (onsite, upper air, and surface/land use data) that can be processed by AERMET to create meteorological inputs that can be run with the AERMOD model.
7 Part 1: Meteorological Data Analyses
8 Moyie Springs Wind Roses WRF/MMIF ( ) Onsite ( ) Wind Class Frequency Distribution Wind Class Frequency Distribution % 45 20% % 9.99% 6.66% % % 12% 7.98% % % % Calms Calms Wind Class Wind Class Calms: 1.03% Calms: 3.50% WRF/MMIF data contains a much more prevalent flow from the southwest than the onsite data.
9 Meteorological Data at Moyie Springs Wind Speed (m/s) WRF/MMIF ( ) Onsite ( ) Rel Wind Temperature Humidity Speed Temperature (K) (%) (m/s) (K) Rel Humidity (%) Maximum Minimum Mean Missing 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.29% 0.29% 0.29% Calms 0.37% 0 Wind speeds from the WRF/MMIF data are greater than the onsite data.
10 Onsite WRF/MMIF Moyie Springs Diurnal Wind Roses Hours % 21.6% 27.6% 33.5% 18.1% 23.3% 23.8% 17.3% 22.1% 26.8% 14.5% 18.6% 17.8% 13% 16.6% 20.1% 10.9% 14% 11.9% 8.64% 11% 13.4% 7.24% 9.3% 5.95% 4.32% 5.52% 6.69% 3.62% 4.65% Calms: 0.39% Calms: 1.57% Calms: 2.44% Calms: 1.37% Calms: 0.30% Calms: 0.11% 40.9% 34.1% 11.6% 27.1% 18% 28.1% 32.8% 27.2% 9.28% 21.6% 14.4% 22.5% 24.6% 20.4% 6.96% 16.2% 10.8% 16.9% 16.4% 13.6% 4.64% 10.8% 7.18% 11.3% 8.19% 6.81% 2.32% 5.41% 3.59% 5.63% Calms: 4.01% Calms: 4.76% Calms: 2.79% Calms: 1.49% Calms: 3.74% Calms: 4.21%
11 Onsite WRF/MMIF Moyie Springs Diurnal Wind Roses Hours % 21.6% 27.6% 33.5% 18.1% 23.3% 23.8% 17.3% 22.1% 26.8% 14.5% 18.6% 17.8% 13% 16.6% 20.1% 10.9% 14% 11.9% 8.64% 11% 13.4% 7.24% 9.3% 5.95% 4.32% 5.52% 6.69% 3.62% 4.65% Calms: 0.39% Calms: 1.57% Diurnal wind roses match well except for hours 9:00-12:00, when the onsite monitor shows periods of light winds and scatter, while the WRF/MMIF Calms: 2.44% Calms: 1.37% Calms: 0.30% Calms: 0.11% data indicates a strong flow from the southwest. 40.9% 34.1% 11.6% 27.1% 18% 28.1% 32.8% 27.2% 9.28% 21.6% 14.4% 22.5% 24.6% 20.4% 6.96% 16.2% 10.8% 16.9% 16.4% 13.6% 4.64% 10.8% 7.18% 11.3% 8.19% 6.81% 2.32% 5.41% 3.59% 5.63% Calms: 4.01% Calms: 4.76% Calms: 2.79% Calms: 1.49% Calms: 3.74% Calms: 4.21%
12 Onsite ( ) WRF/MMIF ( ) Moyie Springs Seasonal Wind Roses Winter Spring Summer Fall 21.8% 17.4% 25.7% 16% 17.4% 13.9% 20.6% 12.8% 13.1% 10.4% 15.4% 9.6% 8.72% 6.94% 10.3% 6.4% 4.36% 3.47% 5.14% 3.2% Calms: 1.51% Calms: 0.77% Calms: 0.60% Calms: 1.25% 18% 18% 22.2% 22.1% 14.4% 14.4% 17.7% 17.7% 10.8% 10.8% 13.3% 13.3% 7.18% 7.2% 8.86% 8.84% 3.59% 3.6% 4.43% 4.42% Calms: 10.85% Calms: 0.72% Calms: 0.05% Calms: 2.46% Seasonal roses match well except for autumn, when winds from the southwest are more prevalent in the WRF/MMIF data.
13 Meteorological Data at Moyie Springs Wind Speed Temperature Relative Humidity WRF/MMIF produces wind speeds greater than those in the observed data, while temperature data match fairly well. Relative humidity appears to be under-predicted.
14 Sandpoint, Idaho NWS MMIF DEQ
15 Sandpoint Wind Roses WRF/MMIF ( ) NWS ( ) DEQ ( /2017) Wind Class Frequency Distribution Wind Class Frequency Distribution Wind Class Frequency Distribution % 15.8% 11.9% % % 8.08% 6.06% % % 12.7% 9.54% % % 3.95% Calms % 2.02% Calms % 3.18% Calms Wind Class Wind Class Wind Class Calms: 0.23% Calms: 40.10% 8 1 Calms: 8.14% Wind roses at DEQ have a larger contingent of lower wind speeds than either the WRF/MMIF or the NWS data. However, the NWS airport contains ~40% calm data, which is masked in the wind roses. Data from the DEQ site is very similar to the WRF/MMIF data, except that there is a larger distribution of lighter winds.
16 DEQ NWS WRF/MMIF Sandpoint Diurnal Wind Roses Hours % 29.3% 22.7% 24% 19.5% 19.5% 21.3% 23.4% 18.2% 19.2% 15.6% 15.6% 16% 17.6% 13.6% 14.4% 11.7% 11.7% 10.7% 11.7% 9.08% 9.6% 7.78% 7.78% 5.33% 5.86% 4.54% 4.8% 3.89% 3.89% Calms: 0.05% Calms: 0.73% Calms: 0.36% 8 1 Calms: 0.11% 8 1 Calms: 0.09% 8 1 Calms: 0.05% 8.3% 10.1% 12.9% 13% 13.3% 8.4% 6.64% 8.04% 10.3% 10.4% 10.6% 6.72% 4.98% 6.03% 7.71% 7.8% 7.95% 5.04% 3.32% 4.02% 5.14% 5.2% 5.3% 3.36% 1.66% 2.01% 2.57% 2.6% 2.65% 1.68% Calms: 57.34% Calms: 51.94% Calms: 25.01% 8 1 Calms: 16.19% 8 1 Calms: 36.18% 8 1 Calms: 53.83% 16.7% 17.9% 16.1% 17.2% 14.9% 19.3% 13.3% 14.3% 12.9% 13.7% 12% 15.4% 9.99% 10.7% 9.66% 10.3% 8.97% 11.6% 6.66% 7.16% 6.44% 6.86% 5.98% 7.72% 3.33% 3.58% 3.22% 3.43% 2.99% 3.86% Calms: 11.99% Calms: 14.30% 8 1 Calms: 6.88% 8 1 Calms: 2.86% 8 1 Calms: 4.93% 8 1 Calms: 7.88%
17 DEQ NWS WRF/MMIF Sandpoint Diurnal Wind Roses Hours % 29.3% 22.7% 24% 19.5% 19.5% 21.3% 23.4% 18.2% 19.2% 15.6% 15.6% 16% 17.6% 13.6% 14.4% 11.7% 11.7% 10.7% 11.7% 9.08% 9.6% 7.78% 7.78% 5.33% 5.86% 4.54% 4.8% 3.89% 3.89% Calms: 0.05% Calms: 0.73% Calms: 0.36% 8 1 Calms: 0.11% 8 1 Calms: 0.09% 8 1 Calms: 0.05% 8.3% 10.1% 12.9% 13% 13.3% 8.4% 6.64% 8.04% 10.3% 10.4% 10.6% 6.72% 4.98% 6.03% 7.71% 7.8% 7.95% 5.04% 3.32% 4.02% 5.14% 5.2% 5.3% 3.36% 1.66% 2.01% 2.57% 2.6% 2.65% 1.68% Calms: 57.34% Diurnal wind roses match well, except for hours 8 1:00-4:00, where DEQ data shows periods of 1 Calms: 51.94% Calms: 25.01% Calms: 16.19% light winds from the northwest. 8 1 Calms: 36.18% 8 1 Calms: 53.83% 16.7% 17.9% 16.1% 17.2% 14.9% 19.3% 13.3% 14.3% 12.9% 13.7% 12% 15.4% 9.99% 10.7% 9.66% 10.3% 8.97% 11.6% 6.66% 7.16% 6.44% 6.86% 5.98% 7.72% 3.33% 3.58% 3.22% 3.43% 2.99% 3.86% Calms: 11.99% Calms: 14.30% 8 1 Calms: 6.88% 8 1 Calms: 2.86% 8 1 Calms: 4.93% 8 1 Calms: 7.88%
18 DEQ NWS WRF/MMIF Sandpoint Seasonal Wind Roses Winter Spring Summer Fall 23.1% 18.9% 15.1% 22.4% 18.4% 15.1% 12.1% 17.9% 13.8% 11.3% 9.06% 13.4% 9.22% 7.56% 6.04% 8.96% 4.61% 3.78% 3.02% 4.48% 8 1 Calms: 0.11% Calms: 0.21% Calms: 0.32% Calms: 0.31% 12.5% 10.6% 9.2% 11.1% 9.96% 8.52% 7.36% 8.84% 7.47% 6.39% 5.52% 6.63% 4.98% 4.26% 3.68% 4.42% 2.49% 2.13% 1.84% 2.21% Calms: 39.87% Calms: 37.44% Calms: 39.30% Calms: 40.92% 17.3% 17.4% 11.2% 17.2% 13.8% 13.9% 8.96% 13.8% 10.4% 10.4% 6.72% 10.3% 6.92% 6.94% 4.48% 6.88% 3.46% 3.47% 2.24% 3.44% Calms: 12.70% Calms: 5.91% Calms: 6.72% Calms: 6.20%
19 DEQ NWS WRF/MMIF Sandpoint Seasonal Wind Roses Winter Spring Summer Fall 23.1% 18.9% 15.1% 22.4% 18.4% 15.1% 12.1% 17.9% 13.8% 11.3% 9.06% 13.4% 9.22% 7.56% 6.04% 8.96% 4.61% 3.78% 3.02% 4.48% 8 1 Calms: 0.11% Calms: 0.21% Calms: 0.32% Calms: 0.31% 12.5% 10.6% 9.2% 11.1% 9.96% 8.52% 7.36% 8.84% 7.47% 6.39% 5.52% 6.63% 4.98% 4.26% 3.68% 4.42% 2.49% 2.13% 1.84% 2.21% Seasonal roses match well except for the summer months, when the DEQ data shows Calms: 39.87% Calms: 37.44% more light winds from the northwest. 8 1 Calms: 39.30% 8 1 Calms: 40.92% 17.3% 17.4% 11.2% 17.2% 13.8% 13.9% 8.96% 13.8% 10.4% 10.4% 6.72% 10.3% 6.92% 6.94% 4.48% 6.88% 3.46% 3.47% 2.24% 3.44% Calms: 12.70% Calms: 5.91% Calms: 6.72% Calms: 6.20%
20 Meteorological Data at Sandpoint Variable Scenario Mean Bias RMSE R 2 Wind Speed Temperature Relative Humidity MMIF-NWS MMIF-DEQ NWS-DEQ MMIF-NWS MMIF-DEQ NWS-DEQ MMIF-NWS MMIF-DEQ NWS-DEQ Differences between MMIF wind speeds and observed wind speeds appear to be higher than the difference between the two observed datasets. MMIF wind speeds are weakly correlated to both observed datasets. MMIF tends to over-predict temperature when compared to the observations. MMIF tends to under-predict relative humidity when compared to the observations.
21 Meteorological Data at Sandpoint Wind Speed Temperature Relative Humidity
22 Wind Speeds at Sandpoint Daytime MMIF wind speeds are comparable to NWS observations. However, nighttime MMIF wind speeds over-predict NWS measurements. On the other hand, MMIF wind speeds over-predict DEQ observations throughout the day. Seasonal box plots suggest that NWS wind speeds have a much wider spread than DEQ observations.
23 Ambient Temperature at Sandpoint Median MMIF temperatures over-predict NWS and DEQ observations. Median temperatures from the three datasets at Sandpoint (MMIF, NWS, DEQ) during Winter and Fall are comparable.
24 Relative Humidity at Sandpoint MMIF relative humidity under-predicts observations from NWS and DEQ. Seasonal box plots suggest that NWS and DEQ RH measurements are comparable.
25 Part 2: Modeling Assessment
26 Source Representation A representation of a facility was created at the location of interest in Moyie Springs. The sources, buildings, and emissions were generalized to portray a typical lumber mill type facility. Sources included a boiler, drying kilns, and a handful of cyclones to represent process activity emissions. Buildings were created to allow for typical downwash effect. An ambient fenceline and a receptor grid were created to best capture impacts from the emissions as modeled.
27 Source and Receptor Location
28 Source and Building Representation
29 AERMOD Modeling Results Moyie Springs Sandpoint Pollutant Averaging WRF/MMIF Onsite WRF/MMIF NWS DEQ Period NO 2 1-hour Annual PM hour PM hour Annual WRF/MMIF data at Moyie Springs produces higher maximum concentrations than the onsite monitored data.
30 Q-Q Concentration Plots at Moyie Springs 24-hr PM 2.5 Annual PM hr NO 2 Annual NO 2 WRF/MMIF data results in higher concentrations than the onsite data. Results from modeling with the onsite meteorological data should be viewed with some caution, as the onsite data processing utilized cloud cover and ceiling height data from Coeur d Alene, Idaho (over 70 miles away) to determine stability parameters.
31 AERMOD Modeling Results Moyie Springs Sandpoint Pollutant Averaging WRF/MMIF Onsite WRF/MMIF NWS DEQ Period NO x 1 hour Annual PM hour PM hour Annual Results for the three Sandpoint meteorological data sets also show that the WRF/MMIF data produces higher concentrations than both the NWS data and the DEQ monitored data.
32 Q-Q Concentration Plots at Sandpoint 24-hr PM 2.5 Annual PM hr NO 2 Annual NO 2 Results from the WRF/MMIF data produce higher concentrations than the two monitored meteorological data sets.
33 Source Group Analyses Source PM 2.5 Averaging WRF/MMIF NWS Airport DEQ Onsite Group Period All 24-hour Annual Boiler 24-hour Annual Kilns 24-hour Annual Cyclones 24-hour Annual
34 24-hr PM 2.5 Q-Q Concentration Plots Boiler Kiln Cyclone All Results from the Cyclone source group show a good match for the WRF/MMIF and DEQ data sets for 24- hour PM 2.5 concentrations less than 3 μg/m 3.
35 Annual PM 2.5 Q-Q Concentration Plots Boiler Kiln Cyclone All In general, WRF/MMIF data produces higher concentrations than the other data sets for all three source groups. However, WRF/MMIF underpredicts annual PM 2.5 values for the less buoyant source group, Cyclones.
36 Wind Speed for 100 highest MMIF-derived NO 2 For the 100 highest MMIFderived NO 2, MMIF underpredicts wind speeds greater than 1 m/s.
37 Summary We compared onsite and airport meteorological data with prognostic datasets created from the WRF database. Some parameters (i.e., temperature, wind direction, relative humidity) have excellent correlations, some (i.e., wind speed) have moderately weak correlations and some have poor correlations. MMIF-driven AERMOD simulations produced maximum impacts greater than the impacts from monitored data sets, even though the prognostic meteorological data consistently has wind speeds of higher value. Modeling was performed with various source types typical of a lumber mill facility for numerous pollutants and averaging periods. Results from the Cyclone source group showed a good match for the WRF/MMIF and DEQ datasets for 24-hour PM 2.5 < 3 μg/m 3. Annual results were generally higher, but were sometimes less with nonbuoyant sources.
38 Thanks for listening!
39 Extra Slides
40
41 Meteorological Data at Sandpoint Variable Scenario Mean Bias RMSE R 2 Zi c MMIF-DEQ MMIF-NWS e NWS-DEQ Zi m MMIF-DEQ MMIF-NWS NWS-DEQ MMIF-NWS L MMIF-DEQ NWS-DEQ MMIF-NWS Cloud Cover MMIF-DEQ NWS-DEQ
42 Meteorological Data at Sandpoint Zi c Zi m L Cloud Cover
43 Meteorological Data at Sandpoint Variable Scenario Mean Bias RMSE R 2 Heat Flux u* w* dθ/dz MMIF-NWS MMIF-DEQ NWS-DEQ MMIF-NWS e MMIF-DEQ NWS-DEQ MMIF-NWS MMIF-DEQ NWS-DEQ MMIF-NWS e MMIF-DEQ NWS-DEQ
44 Meteorological Data at Sandpoint H u* w* dθ/dz
AERMOD Sensitivity to AERSURFACE Moisture Conditions and Temporal Resolution. Paper No Prepared By:
AERMOD Sensitivity to AERSURFACE Moisture Conditions and Temporal Resolution Paper No. 33252 Prepared By: Anthony J Schroeder, CCM Managing Consultant TRINITY CONSULTANTS 7330 Woodland Drive Suite 225
More informationA Case Study of Sulfur Dioxide in Muscatine, Iowa and the Ability for AERMOD to Predict NAAQS Violations
A Case Study of Sulfur Dioxide in Muscatine, Iowa and the Ability for AERMOD to Predict NAAQS Violations Presented by Charlene Becka Air Quality Engineer NAAQS SO 2 Standards Respiratory irritant in sensitive
More informationPhoto by Ben Huff EPA Regional/State/Local Modelers Workshop Deanna Huff, PhD Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation April 24, 2013
Photo by Ben Huff 2013 EPA Regional/State/Local Modelers Workshop Deanna Huff, PhD Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation April 24, 2013 Overview of the North Slope Deadhorse 2 Focus on conducting
More informationComprehensive Analysis of Annual 2005/2008 Simulation of WRF/CMAQ over Southeast of England
Comprehensive Analysis of Annual 2005/2008 Simulation of WRF/CMAQ over Southeast of England The 13 th International Conference on Harmonization within Atmospheric Dispersion Modelling for Regulatory Purposes
More informationWen Xu* Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Air Quality and Acid Deposition Simulation of South Athabasca Oil Sands Area Applying WRF, CMAQ and CALPUFF Models, and Model Performance Evaluations of WRF and CMAQ Models Wen Xu* Alberta Environment
More informationWorldwide Data Quality Effects on PBL Short-Range Regulatory Air Dispersion Models
Worldwide Data Quality Effects on PBL Short-Range Regulatory Air Dispersion Models Jesse L. Thé 1, Russell Lee 2, Roger W. Brode 3 1 Lakes Environmental Software, -2 Philip St, Waterloo, ON, N2L 5J2, Canada
More informationGenerating and Using Meteorological Data in AERMOD
Generating and Using Meteorological Data in AERMOD June 26, 2012 Prepared by: George J. Schewe, CCM, QEP BREEZE Software 12770 Merit Drive Suite 900 Dallas, TX 75251 +1 (972) 661-8881 breeze-software.com
More informationJoseph S. Scire 1, Christelle Escoffier-Czaja 2 and Mahesh J. Phadnis 1. Cambridge TRC Environmental Corporation 1. Lowell, Massachusetts USA 2
Application of MM5 and CALPUFF to a Complex Terrain Environment in Eastern Iceland Joseph S. Scire 1, Christelle Escoffier-Czaja 2 and Mahesh J. Phadnis 1 TRC Environmental Corporation 1 Lowell, Massachusetts
More informationWeather History on the Bishop Paiute Reservation
Weather History on the Bishop Paiute Reservation -211 For additional information contact Toni Richards, Air Quality Specialist 76 873 784 toni.richards@bishoppaiute.org Updated 2//214 3:14 PM Weather History
More informationPERFORMANCE OF THE WRF-ARW IN THE COMPLEX TERRAIN OF SALT LAKE CITY
P2.17 PERFORMANCE OF THE WRF-ARW IN THE COMPLEX TERRAIN OF SALT LAKE CITY Jeffrey E. Passner U.S. Army Research Laboratory White Sands Missile Range, New Mexico 1. INTRODUCTION The Army Research Laboratory
More information4.5 Comparison of weather data from the Remote Automated Weather Station network and the North American Regional Reanalysis
4.5 Comparison of weather data from the Remote Automated Weather Station network and the North American Regional Reanalysis Beth L. Hall and Timothy. J. Brown DRI, Reno, NV ABSTRACT. The North American
More informationFire Weather Drivers, Seasonal Outlook and Climate Change. Steven McGibbony, Severe Weather Manager Victoria Region Friday 9 October 2015
Fire Weather Drivers, Seasonal Outlook and Climate Change Steven McGibbony, Severe Weather Manager Victoria Region Friday 9 October 2015 Outline Weather and Fire Risk Environmental conditions leading to
More informationMeteorological Modeling using Penn State/NCAR 5 th Generation Mesoscale Model (MM5)
TSD-1a Meteorological Modeling using Penn State/NCAR 5 th Generation Mesoscale Model (MM5) Bureau of Air Quality Analysis and Research Division of Air Resources New York State Department of Environmental
More informationPreliminary Experiences with the Multi Model Air Quality Forecasting System for New York State
Preliminary Experiences with the Multi Model Air Quality Forecasting System for New York State Prakash Doraiswamy 1, Christian Hogrefe 1,2, Winston Hao 2, Brian Colle 3, Mark Beauharnois 1, Ken Demerjian
More informationMeteorological and Dispersion Modelling Using TAPM for Wagerup
Meteorological and Dispersion Modelling Using TAPM for Wagerup Phase 1: Meteorology Appendix A: Additional modelling details Prepared for: Alcoa World Alumina Australia, P. O. Box 252, Applecross, Western
More informationValidation n 1 of the Wind Data Generator (WDG) software performance. Comparison with measured mast data - Complex site in Southern France
Validation n 1 of the Wind Data Generator (WDG) software performance Comparison with measured mast data - Complex site in Southern France Mr. Tristan Fabre* La Compagnie du Vent, GDF-SUEZ, Montpellier,
More information8.1 Attachment 1: Ambient Weather Conditions at Jervoise Bay, Cockburn Sound
8.1 Attachment 1: Ambient Weather Conditions at Jervoise Bay, Cockburn Sound Cockburn Sound is 20km south of the Perth-Fremantle area and has two features that are unique along Perth s metropolitan coast
More informationTAPM Modelling for Wagerup: Phase 1 CSIRO 2004 Page 41
We now examine the probability (or frequency) distribution of meteorological predictions and the measurements. Figure 12 presents the observed and model probability (expressed as probability density function
More informationImpacts of Wildfires on Particulate Matter in Pima County, Arizona
Impacts of Wildfires on Particulate Matter in Pima County, Arizona Erika K. Wise Department of Geography and Regional Development University of Arizona Air Quality Trends in the Southwest Forum January
More informationQUANTITATIVE VERIFICATION STATISTICS OF WRF PREDICTIONS OVER THE MEDITERRANEAN REGION
QUANTITATIVE VERIFICATION STATISTICS OF WRF PREDICTIONS OVER THE MEDITERRANEAN REGION Katsafados P. 1, Papadopoulos A. 2, Mavromatidis E. 1 and Gikas N. 1 1 Department of Geography, Harokopio University
More informationClimate Variables for Energy: WP2
Climate Variables for Energy: WP2 Phil Jones CRU, UEA, Norwich, UK Within ECEM, WP2 provides climate data for numerous variables to feed into WP3, where ESCIIs will be used to produce energy-relevant series
More informationDispersion Modeling of the Transport and Dispersion of SO 2 Pollutants Emitted from a Power Plant in Tong Liang
Final Report for the Project Dispersion Modeling of the Transport and Dispersion of SO 2 Pollutants Emitted from a Power Plant in Tong Liang Contractors: Dr. Darko Koracin, Dr. John Watson, 1. Executive
More informationEnd of Ozone Season Report
End of Ozone Season Report Central Ohio: April 1 through October 31, 2016 The Mid-Ohio Regional Planning Commission (MORPC) is part of a network of agencies across the country that issues daily air quality
More informationresearch highlight Wind-Rain Relationships in Southwestern British Columbia Introduction Methodology Figure 2 Lower Mainland meteorological stations
research highlight June 2007 Technical Series 07-114 Introduction Building envelope failures in southwestern British Columbia has brought to light the strong influence of wind-driven rain on building envelopes.
More informationApplication and verification of ECMWF products 2009
Application and verification of ECMWF products 2009 Hungarian Meteorological Service 1. Summary of major highlights The objective verification of ECMWF forecasts have been continued on all the time ranges
More informationUSE OF LOKAL MODELL FOR THE METEOROLOGICAL INPUT OF CHIMERE
1 st Chimere workshop USE OF LOKAL MODELL FOR THE METEOROLOGICAL INPUT OF CHIMERE Palaiseau, France March 21-22, 2005 Enrico Minguzzi, Giovanni Bonafè, Marco Deserti, Suzanne Jongen, Michele Stortini HydroMeteorological
More informationWater Balance in the Murray-Darling Basin and the recent drought as modelled with WRF
18 th World IMACS / MODSIM Congress, Cairns, Australia 13-17 July 2009 http://mssanz.org.au/modsim09 Water Balance in the Murray-Darling Basin and the recent drought as modelled with WRF Evans, J.P. Climate
More informationAREP GAW. AQ Forecasting
AQ Forecasting What Are We Forecasting Averaging Time (3 of 3) PM10 Daily Maximum Values, 2001 Santiago, Chile (MACAM stations) 300 Level 2 Pre-Emergency Level 1 Alert 200 Air Quality Standard 150 100
More informationClimate Dataset: Aitik Closure Project. November 28 th & 29 th, 2018
1 Climate Dataset: Aitik Closure Project November 28 th & 29 th, 2018 Climate Dataset: Aitik Closure Project 2 Early in the Closure Project, consensus was reached to assemble a long-term daily climate
More informationAERMOD Technical Forum
AERMOD Technical Forum Roger W. Brode MACTEC Federal Programs, Inc. Research Triangle Park, NC EPA R/S/L Modelers Workshop San Diego, California May 16, 2006 Presentation Outline Brief History of AERMOD
More informationPRELIMINARY EXPERIENCES WITH THE MULTI-MODEL AIR QUALITY FORECASTING SYSTEM FOR NEW YORK STATE
PRELIMINARY EXPERIENCES WITH THE MULTI-MODEL AIR QUALITY FORECASTING SYSTEM FOR NEW YORK STATE Prakash Doraiswamy 1,,*, Christian Hogrefe 1,2, Winston Hao 2, Brian Colle 3, Mark Beauharnois 1, Ken Demerjian
More informationAir Quality Screening Modeling
Air Quality Screening Modeling 2007 Meteorology Simulation with WRF OTC Modeling Committee Meeting September 16, 2010 Baltimore, MD Presentation is based upon the following technical reports available
More informationUsing Prognostic Model-Generated Meteorological Output in the AERMOD Dispersion Model: An Illustrative Application in Philadelphia, PA
TECHNICAL PAPER ISSN:1047-3289 J. Air & Waste Manage. Assoc. 57:586 595 DOI:10.3155/1047-3289.57.5.586 Copyright 2007 Air & Waste Management Association Using Prognostic Model-Generated Meteorological
More informationDust storm variability over EGYPT By Fathy M ELashmawy Egyptian Meteorological Authority
WMO WORKSHOP ON CLIMATE MONITORING INCLUDING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF CLIMATE WATCH SYSTEMS FOR ARAB COUNTRIES IN WEST ASIA, AMMAN, JORDAN, 27-29 MAY 2013 Dust storm variability over EGYPT By Fathy M ELashmawy
More informationImproved Atmospheric Stable Boundary Layer Formulations for Navy Seasonal Forecasting
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A. Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. Improved Atmospheric Stable Boundary Layer Formulations for Navy Seasonal Forecasting Michael Tjernström Department of
More informationApplication and verification of ECMWF products at the Finnish Meteorological Institute
Application and verification of ECMWF products 2010 2011 at the Finnish Meteorological Institute by Juhana Hyrkkènen, Ari-Juhani Punkka, Henri Nyman and Janne Kauhanen 1. Summary of major highlights ECMWF
More informationJ4.2 ASSESSMENT OF PM TRANSPORT PATTERNS USING ADVANCED CLUSTERING METHODS AND SIMULATIONS AROUND THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA, CA 3.
J4.2 ASSESSMENT OF PM TRANSPORT PATTERNS USING ADVANCED CLUSTERING METHODS AND SIMULATIONS AROUND THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA, CA Scott Beaver 1*, Ahmet Palazoglu 2, Angadh Singh 2, and Saffet Tanrikulu
More informationGridded Met. Data Workgroup
Gridded Met. Data Workgroup R/S/L Modelers Workshop New Orleans, LA Dennis Atkinson May 17, 2005 Outline Background Gridded Met. Data Project (CALPUFF & AERMOD) Gridded Met. Data Workgroup New Developments
More informationPM 2.5 Forecasting: Preliminary Results
PM 2.5 Forecasting: Preliminary Results William F. Ryan The Pennsylvania State University Department of Meteorology Joint MARAMA/NESCAUM Air Monitoring Meeting West Atlantic City, NJ 9/6 120 100 80 60
More informationSensitivity of AERMOD to AERMINUTE- Generated Meteorology
Sensitivity of AERMOD to AERMINUTE- Generated Meteorology Paper No 22-A-42-AWMA Prepared By: George J. Schewe, CCM, QEP Principal Consultant Abhishek Bhat, PhD Consultant TRINITY CONSULTANTS 77 Dixie Highway
More information1.21 SENSITIVITY OF LONG-TERM CTM SIMULATIONS TO METEOROLOGICAL INPUT
1.21 SENSITIVITY OF LONG-TERM CTM SIMULATIONS TO METEOROLOGICAL INPUT Enrico Minguzzi 1 Marco Bedogni 2, Claudio Carnevale 3, and Guido Pirovano 4 1 Hydrometeorological Service of Emilia Romagna (SIM),
More informationOn Improving the Output of. a Statistical Model
On Improving the Output of Mark Delgado 4/19/2016 a Statistical Model Using GFS single point outputs for a linear regression model and improve forecasting i. Introduction Forecast Modelling Using computers
More informationAverage Weather For Coeur d'alene, Idaho, USA
Average Weather For Coeur d'alene, Idaho, USA Information courtesy of weatherspark.com Location This report describes the typical weather at the Coeur d'alene Air Terminal (Coeur d'alene, Idaho, United
More informationA Community Gridded Atmospheric Forecast System for Calibrated Solar Irradiance
A Community Gridded Atmospheric Forecast System for Calibrated Solar Irradiance David John Gagne 1,2 Sue E. Haupt 1,3 Seth Linden 1 Gerry Wiener 1 1. NCAR RAL 2. University of Oklahoma 3. Penn State University
More information{ 2{ water vapor prole is specied by the surface relative humidity and a water vapor scale height (set at 2 km). We nd a good, theoretically based (se
SMA TECHNICAL MEMO 123 Date: 3 June 1998 Estimates of Haystack Opacity at 225 GHz Mark A. Gurwell ABSTRACT We estimate opacity at 225 GHz for the SMA Haystack site, based upon local weather data, measurements
More informationCalibrating forecasts of heavy precipitation in river catchments
from Newsletter Number 152 Summer 217 METEOROLOGY Calibrating forecasts of heavy precipitation in river catchments Hurricane Patricia off the coast of Mexico on 23 October 215 ( 215 EUMETSAT) doi:1.21957/cf1598
More informationClimate Change RMJOC Study Summary
Climate Change RMJOC Study Summary Erik Pytlak Weather and Streamflow Forecasting Bonneville Power Administration Portland, OR IPCC: International Panel on Climate Change Established by the United Nations
More informationHigh resolution rainfall projections for the Greater Sydney Region
20th International Congress on Modelling and Simulation, Adelaide, Australia, 1 6 December 2013 www.mssanz.org.au/modsim2013 High resolution rainfall projections for the Greater Sydney Region F. Ji a,
More informationAdded Value of Convection Resolving Climate Simulations (CRCS)
Added Value of Convection Resolving Climate Simulations (CRCS) Prein Andreas, Gobiet Andreas, Katrin Lisa Kapper, Martin Suklitsch, Nauman Khurshid Awan, Heimo Truhetz Wegener Center for Climate and Global
More informationPrecipitation processes in the Middle East
Precipitation processes in the Middle East J. Evans a, R. Smith a and R.Oglesby b a Dept. Geology & Geophysics, Yale University, Connecticut, USA. b Global Hydrology and Climate Center, NASA, Alabama,
More informationJ2.20 URBAN AND REGIONAL AIR QUALITY MODELLING IN THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST
J2.20 URBAN AND REGIONAL AIR QUALITY MODELLING IN THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST Xin Qiu*, Mike Lepage, J. Wayne Boulton, and Martin Gauthier RWDI West Inc. 650 Woodlawn Rd. West Guelph, Ontario, Canada, N1K 1B8
More informationZachary Holden - US Forest Service Region 1, Missoula MT Alan Swanson University of Montana Dept. of Geography David Affleck University of Montana
Progress modeling topographic variation in temperature and moisture for inland Northwest forest management Zachary Holden - US Forest Service Region 1, Missoula MT Alan Swanson University of Montana Dept.
More informationESCI 344 Tropical Meteorology Lesson 7 Temperature, Clouds, and Rain
ESCI 344 Tropical Meteorology Lesson 7 Temperature, Clouds, and Rain References: Forecaster s Guide to Tropical Meteorology (updated), Ramage Tropical Climatology, McGregor and Nieuwolt Climate and Weather
More informationAir Quality Modelling for Health Impacts Studies
Air Quality Modelling for Health Impacts Studies Paul Agnew RSS Conference September 2014 Met Office Air Quality and Composition team Paul Agnew Lucy Davis Carlos Ordonez Nick Savage Marie Tilbee April
More informationINVISIBLE WATER COSTS
Every Drop Every Counts... Drop Counts... INVISIBLE WATER COSTS Corn - 108.1 gallons per pound How much water it takes to produce... Apple - 18.5 gallons to grow Beef - 1,581 gallons per pound Oats - 122.7
More informationJordan G. Powers Kevin W. Manning. Mesoscale and Microscale Meteorology Laboratory National Center for Atmospheric Research Boulder, CO
Jordan G. Powers Kevin W. Manning Mesoscale and Microscale Meteorology Laboratory National Center for Atmospheric Research Boulder, CO Background : Model for Prediction Across Scales Global atmospheric
More informationReplacement of Dry Deposition Velocities (Vd) at CASTNET Sites (cont d) Gary Lear George Bowker CAMD
Replacement of Dry Deposition Velocities (Vd) at CASTNET Sites (cont d) Gary Lear George Bowker CAMD Introduction For CASTNET, hourly deposition velocity estimates are the output of the Multi-Layer Model
More informationTechnical Memorandum. City of Salem, Stormwater Management Design Standards. Project No:
Technical Memorandum 6500 SW Macadam Avenue, Suite 200 Portland, Oregon, 97239 Tel: 503-244-7005 Fax: 503-244-9095 Prepared for: Project Title: City of Salem, Oregon City of Salem, Stormwater Management
More informationData assimilation and inverse problems. J. Vira, M. Sofiev
Data assimilation and inverse problems J. Vira, M. Sofiev SILAM winter school, 2013 Introduction How to combine observations and model fields into an estimate of the atmospheric state? Chemical data assimilation
More informationAIRQUEST Annual Report and State of the Model
AIRQUEST Annual Report and State of the Model Brian Lamb 1, Serena Chung 1, Farren Herron-Thorpe 2 and Joseph Vaughan 1 1 Laboratory for Atmospheric Research, Washington State University, Pullman, W, USA
More informationUrban Forest Effects-Dry Deposition (UFORE D) Model Enhancements. Satoshi Hirabayashi
Urban Forest Effects-Dry Deposition (UFORE D) Model Enhancements Satoshi Hirabayashi The Davey Institute, The Davey Tree Expert Company, Syracuse, New York 13210, USA Surface Weather Data NOAA Integrated
More information1.7 APPLICATION AND EVALUATION OF MM5 FOR NORTH CAROLINA WITH A 4-KM HORIZONTAL GRID SPACING
.7 APPLICATION AND EVALUATION OF MM5 FOR NORTH CAROLINA WITH A 4-KM HORIZONTAL GRID SPACING Srinath Krishnan, Shiang-Yuh Wu 2, Danny Hamilton, Yang Zhang, and Viney P. Aneja Department of Marine, Earth
More informationQuality Control of the National RAWS Database for FPA Timothy J Brown Beth L Hall
Quality Control of the National RAWS Database for FPA Timothy J Brown Beth L Hall Desert Research Institute Program for Climate, Ecosystem and Fire Applications May 2005 Project Objectives Run coarse QC
More informationA REAL-TIME OPERATIONAL FORECAST MODEL FOR METEOROLOGY AND AIR QUALITY DURING PEAK AIR POLLUTION EPISODES IN OSLO, NORWAY
A REAL-TIME OPERATIONAL FORECAST MODEL FOR METEOROLOGY AND AIR QUALITY DURING PEAK AIR POLLUTION EPISODES IN OSLO, NORWAY ERIK BERGE 1, SAM-ERIK WALKER 2, ASGEIR SORTEBERG 1,MOTHEI LENKOPANE 2, STEINAR
More informationArizona Climate Summary May 2012
Arizona Climate Summary May 2012 Summary of conditions for April 2012 April 2012 Temperature and Precipitation Summary April 1 st 16 th : Although April began with another low pressure system sweeping
More informationInfluence of 3D Model Grid Resolution on Tropospheric Ozone Levels
Influence of 3D Model Grid Resolution on Tropospheric Ozone Levels Pedro Jiménez nez, Oriol Jorba and José M. Baldasano Laboratory of Environmental Modeling Technical University of Catalonia-UPC (Barcelona,
More informationThe Climate of Texas County
The Climate of Texas County Texas County is part of the Western High Plains in the north and west and the Southwestern Tablelands in the east. The Western High Plains are characterized by abundant cropland
More informationP1.15 DECADAL WIND TRENDS AT THE SAVANNAH RIVER SITE
1. INTRODUCTION P1.15 DECADAL WIND TRENDS AT THE SAVANNAH RIVER SITE Allen H. Weber, Robert L. Buckley, and Matthew J. Parker Savannah River National Laboratory, Aiken, South Carolina One possible consequence
More informationMPCA Forecasting Summary 2010
MPCA Forecasting Summary 2010 Jessica Johnson, Patrick Zahn, Natalie Shell Sonoma Technology, Inc. Petaluma, CA Presented to Minnesota Pollution Control Agency St. Paul, MN June 3, 2010 aq-ppt2-01 907021-3880
More informationBenchmarking Polar WRF in the Antarctic *
Benchmarking Polar WRF in the Antarctic * David H. Bromwich 1,2, Elad Shilo 1,3, and Keith M. Hines 1 1 Polar Meteorology Group, Byrd Polar Research Center The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA
More informationChapter 4: Weather & Climate. (Pg )
Chapter 4: Weather & Climate (Pg. 54 73) Introduction: Distinguish between the terms weather & climate. P. 54 Weather: the state of the atmosphere at any one place or time. (short term) Climate: the average
More informationApplication and verification of ECMWF products 2013
Application and verification of EMWF products 2013 Hellenic National Meteorological Service (HNMS) Flora Gofa and Theodora Tzeferi 1. Summary of major highlights In order to determine the quality of the
More informationNational Wildland Significant Fire Potential Outlook
National Wildland Significant Fire Potential Outlook National Interagency Fire Center Predictive Services Issued: September, 2007 Wildland Fire Outlook September through December 2007 Significant fire
More informationWind Assessment & Forecasting
Wind Assessment & Forecasting GCEP Energy Workshop Stanford University April 26, 2004 Mark Ahlstrom CEO, WindLogics Inc. mark@windlogics.com WindLogics Background Founders from supercomputing industry
More informationThe Evaluation of Precipitation Information from Satellites and Models
The Evaluation of Precipitation Information from Satellites and Models Mathew R P Sapiano University of Maryland msapiano@umd.edu 1 Validation activities at CICS/UMD Continuation of daily IPWG validation
More informationSensitivity of AERSURFACE Results to Study Area and Location. Paper 2009-A-127-AWMA
Sensitivity of AERSURFACE Results to Study Area and Location Paper 2009-A-127-AWMA Prepared by: Anthony J. Schroeder, CCM Senior Consultant George J. Schewe, CCM, QEP Principal Consultant Trinity Consultants
More informationAir Quality in Port Alberni
Air Quality in Port Alberni A Summary of Trends and Patterns in Meteorology, and Common Air Pollutants January 2016 BRITISH COLUMBIA MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION DIVISION MONITORING,
More informationCondensation: Dew, Fog, & Clouds. Chapter 5
Condensation: Dew, Fog, & Clouds Chapter 5 The Formation of Dew & Frost Dew forms on objects near the ground surface when they cool below the dew point temperature. More likely on clear nights due to increased
More informationRegional Climate Simulations with WRF Model
WDS'3 Proceedings of Contributed Papers, Part III, 8 84, 23. ISBN 978-8-737852-8 MATFYZPRESS Regional Climate Simulations with WRF Model J. Karlický Charles University in Prague, Faculty of Mathematics
More informationWind conditions based on coupling between a mesoscale and microscale model
Wind conditions based on coupling between a mesoscale and microscale model José Laginha Palma and Carlos Veiga Rodrigues CEsA Centre for Wind Energy and Atmospheric Flows Faculty of Engineering, University
More informationFRAPPÉ/DISCOVER-AQ (July/August 2014) in perspective of multi-year ozone analysis
FRAPPÉ/DISCOVER-AQ (July/August 2014) in perspective of multi-year ozone analysis Project Report #2: Monitoring network assessment for the City of Fort Collins Prepared by: Lisa Kaser kaser@ucar.edu ph:
More information5. Light Extinction In The Desert Southwest
5. Light Extinction In The Desert Southwest This chapter describes the spatial and temporal variations of light extinction and its components over the study area. 5.1 Principles of Light Extinction Perception
More informationLand Surface Processes and Their Impact in Weather Forecasting
Land Surface Processes and Their Impact in Weather Forecasting Andrea Hahmann NCAR/RAL with thanks to P. Dirmeyer (COLA) and R. Koster (NASA/GSFC) Forecasters Conference Summer 2005 Andrea Hahmann ATEC
More informationUsing Multivariate Adaptive Constructed Analogs (MACA) data product for climate projections
Using Multivariate Adaptive Constructed Analogs (MACA) data product for climate projections Maria Herrmann and Ray Najjar Chesapeake Hypoxia Analysis and Modeling Program (CHAMP) Conference Call 2017-04-21
More informationElements of a subseasonal-to-seasonal excessive heat outlook system (SEHOS) Augustin Vintzileos
Elements of a subseasonal-to-seasonal excessive heat outlook system (SEHOS) Augustin Vintzileos University of Maryland ESSIC/CICS This study is supported by NOAA grants: NA15OAR4310081 NA14NES4320003 NA16OAR4310147
More informationa geophysical grid, constructed using gridded terrain and land cover data (obtained from GeoGratis Government of Canada); and
1.0 INTRODUCTION The following is a summary of model inputs and odour modelling results conducted for the purpose of assessing potential odour impacts from a private organics management facility located
More informationATMOSPHERIC CIRCULATION AND WIND
ATMOSPHERIC CIRCULATION AND WIND The source of water for precipitation is the moisture laden air masses that circulate through the atmosphere. Atmospheric circulation is affected by the location on the
More informationUsing Temperature and Dew Point to Aid Forecasting Springtime Radiational Frost and/or Freezing Temperatures in the NWS La Crosse Service Area
Using Temperature and Dew Point to Aid Forecasting Springtime Radiational Frost and/or Freezing Temperatures in the NWS La Crosse Service Area WFO La Crosse Climatology Series #21 The formation of radiational
More informationWill a warmer world change Queensland s rainfall?
Will a warmer world change Queensland s rainfall? Nicholas P. Klingaman National Centre for Atmospheric Science-Climate Walker Institute for Climate System Research University of Reading The Walker-QCCCE
More informationSOME CHARACTERISTICS OF ATMOSPHERIC BOUNDARY LAYER OVER MAKASSAR
SPERMONDE (28) 4(): -6 ISSN: 246-56 EISSN: 264-549 SOME CHARACTERISTICS OF ATMOSPHERIC BOUNDARY LAYER OVER MAKASSAR ABSTRACT. Alimuddin Hamzah Assegaf *, Wasir Samad 2, Sakka Submitted: 4 January 28 Accepted:
More informationODOR FOOTPRINTS AND THE ODOR FOOTPRINT TOOL
ODOR FOOTPRINTS AND THE ODOR FOOTPRINT TOOL An Overview Introduction: As animal production has changed and the facilities in which livestock and poultry are raised have grown in size, neighbors of animal
More informationMPAS Atmospheric Boundary Layer Simulation under Selected Stability Conditions: Evaluation using the SWIFT dataset
MPAS Atmospheric Boundary Layer Simulation under Selected Stability Conditions: Evaluation using the SWIFT dataset Rao Kotamarthi, Yan Feng, and Jiali Wang Argonne National Laboratory & MMC Team Motivation:
More information5.0 WHAT IS THE FUTURE ( ) WEATHER EXPECTED TO BE?
5.0 WHAT IS THE FUTURE (2040-2049) WEATHER EXPECTED TO BE? This chapter presents some illustrative results for one station, Pearson Airport, extracted from the hour-by-hour simulations of the future period
More informationWxChallenge Model Output Page Tutorial
WxChallenge Model Output Page Tutorial Brian Tang University at Albany - SUNY 9/25/12 http://www.atmos.albany.edu/facstaff/tang/forecast/ Clicking on square brings up graphic for the specified variable
More informationP3.20 A CLIMATOLOGICAL INVESTIGATION OF THE DIURNAL PATTERNS OF PRECIPITATION OVER THE COMPLEX TERRAIN OF WESTERN COLORADO
P3.20 A CLIMATOLOGICAL INVESTIGATION OF THE DIURNAL PATTERNS OF PRECIPITATION OVER THE COMPLEX TERRAIN OF WESTERN COLORADO Jeffrey D. Colton*, J.D. Ramey Jr., B. Avery, and M.P. Meyers National Weather
More informationP4.479 A DETAILED ANALYSIS OF SPC HIGH RISK OUTLOOKS,
P4.479 A DETAILED ANALYSIS OF SPC HIGH RISK OUTLOOKS, 2003-2009 Jason M. Davis*, Andrew R. Dean 2, and Jared L. Guyer 2 Valparaiso University, Valparaiso, IN 2 NOAA/NWS Storm Prediction Center, Norman,
More informationANNUAL WRF SIMULATIONS FOR THE UTAH BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT S AIR RESOURCE MANAGEMENT STRATEGY (ARMS) AIR QUALITY MODELING
ANNUAL WRF SIMULATIONS FOR THE UTAH BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT S AIR RESOURCE MANAGEMENT STRATEGY (ARMS) AIR QUALITY MODELING Kenneth Craig*, Stephen Reid, Garnet Erdakos Sonoma Technology, Inc., Petaluma,
More informationAPPENDIX B PAVEMENT TEMPERATURE PREDICTION
APPENDIX B PAVEMENT TEMPERATURE PREDICTION TABLE OF CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION...B-1 MODEL DEVELOPMENT...B-4 Heat Transfer in Pavement...B-4 The Surface Boundary Condition...B-5 The Bottom Boundary Condition...B-7
More informationScatterometer winds in rapidly developing storms (SCARASTO) First experiments on data assimilation of scatterometer winds
Scatterometer winds in rapidly developing storms (SCARASTO) First experiments on data assimilation of scatterometer winds Teresa Valkonen, EUMETSAT fellow Norwegian Meteorological Institute MET Norway,Oslo
More informationApplication and verification of ECMWF products: 2010
Application and verification of ECMWF products: 2010 Hellenic National Meteorological Service (HNMS) F. Gofa, D. Tzeferi and T. Charantonis 1. Summary of major highlights In order to determine the quality
More information