arxiv:gr-qc/ v1 1 Sep 2005

Transcription

1 Radial fall of a test paticle onto an evapoating black hole Andeas Aste and Dik Tautmann Depatment fo Physics and Astonomy, Univesity of Basel, 456 Basel, Switzeland andeas.aste@unibas.ch June 8, 25 axiv:g-qc/597v Sep 25 Abstact A test paticle falling into a classical black hole cosses the event hoizon and ends up in the singulaity within finite eigentime. In the moe ealistic case of a classical evapoating black hole, an obseve falling onto a black hole obseves a sudden evapoation of the hole. This illustates the fact that the discussion of the classical pocess commonly found in the liteatue may become obsolete when the black hole has a finite lifetime. The situation is basically the same fo moe complex cases, e.g. whee a paticle collides with two meging black holes. It should be pointed out that the model used in this pape is mainly of academic inteest, since the desciption of the physics nea a black hole hoizon still pesents a difficult poblem which is not yet fully undestood, but ou model povides a valuable possibility fo students to ente the inteesting field of black hole physics and to pefom numeical calculations of thei own which ae not vey involved fom the computational point of view. PACS numbes: g; 4.7.-s; 4.7.Dy The Schwazschild metic geneated by an unchaged non-otating classical black hole is given by ( ds 2 = s ) ( c 2 dt 2 s ) d 2 2 dω 2, () whee s = 2GM /c 2 is the Schwazschild adius, G the gavitational constant, M the mass of the black hole, c the speed of light, and dω 2 denotes the line element squaed on a two-dimensional unit sphee. Due to the Hawking adiation, the black hole evapoates, if we exclude any accetion of enegy. Fo macoscopic black holes, the luminosity is popotional to the invese mass squaed. The coesponding ansatz fo the time-dependent black hole mass M(t) Ṁ(t) = km(t) 2, (2) leads diectly to M(t) 3 = k 3 (t t), (3) whee t = 3M 3 /k is the lifetime of the black hole. Accodingly, we have s (t) = k (t t) /3. (4) It is clea that limited knowledge is available about the actual evapoation pocess of black holes at pesent, which is based mainly on the classic woks of Unuh and Hawking [, 2], and thee is an ongoing inteest in the subject [4, 5, 6]. Theefoe, ou model is puely academic, but we conside it wothwhile to investigate it due to its simplicity and because it exhibits the inteesting featue that a paticle falling onto a black hole does not vanish fom ou univese, since it expeiences an immediate black hole evapoation. A ealistic teatment of the pocess pesented hee would involve detailed

2 knowledge about the physics in the vey close vicinity of the black hole hoizon. E.g., Babichev et al. [6] discussed the case of black holes acceting dak enegy in the fom of a phantom enegy, whee the enegy density ρ > and the negative pessue p < fulfill the condition ρc 2 +p <. Fo a black hole suounded by a constant phantom enegy bath, the black hole mass deceases like (t +τ), whee τ > is a chaacteistic evolution time. Theefoe, we could have chosen decay laws fo ou discussion given below that diffe fom eq. (4), but the qualitative esults would nevetheless emain the same. It is also clea that equation (3) will fail to descibe the evapoation pocess of the black hole in its final stage. We also point out that an intoduction to the desciption of evapoating black holes can be found in a known pape by William Hiscock [7]. Thee, diffeent deceasing functions M(t) in a slightly diffeent famewok using the so-called Vaidya metic [8, 9] wee consideed. The main dawback of using simple appoaches like those in [7] is the fact that the impact of the emitted adiation is not taken into account, because the black hole does not evapoate due to the emission of adiation but by atificially adding negative enegy to the black hole. We give hee a handwaving agument in ode to illustate the stange physical conditions that might be expected in the vicinity of the black hole hoizon. Fo a distant obseve, a massive black hole is a vey cold object with Hawking tempeatue T BH = hc3 4k B GM, (5) whee k B is the Boltzmann constant. It is well-known that the condition fo themal equilibium in a static system is g ( )T( ) =const., whee T( ) is the tempeatue measued by a local static obseve. This condition can be most easily deived when two systems in themal equilibium ae consideed, which ae coupled only via thei themal adiation, such that the black body adiation of the two systems has to tavel though the gavitational field. Fo the egion nea the hoizon with = s +δ, whee δ > is small, g is given appoximately by ( ) ( ) g = s Futhemoe, the spatial distance d to the hoizon is d = s+δ( s s = ) /2 d s s +δ δ δ s. (6) s δ dδ = 2 s δ. (7) Theefoe, a hypothetical static obseve vey close to the hoizon with d = l P = hg/c 3 measues a tempeatue of the ode of the Planck tempeatue T P, since k B T BH g (δ = lp 2/4 s) = hc3 2 s = hc = k B T P. (8) 4GM l P l P Fo an extenal obseve, the test paticle gets abitaily close to the hoizon within finite time, but in contast to ou consideations made above, it is not in a static state, but acceleated, and does theefoe not expeience the exteme Unuh effect as a static obseve. Nevetheless, it will be difficult to make any easonable pedictions about the fate of a paticle appoaching the hoizon, whee the physics becomes Planckian. In the following, we assume that the metic geneated by the evapoating black hole is given by expession (), but with s eplaced by the time-dependent expession given by eq. (4). In view of the vey slow evapoation pocess and the low enegy density of the emitted Hawking adiation, this is cetainly a satisfactoy appoximation fo ou pupose. Nea the black hole hoizon, the validity of the appoximation is dubious at best. 2

3 Fom now on, we will use geometic units (G=c=) thoughout. If we paametize the (geodesic) woldline of a massive test paticle by its eigentime τ, then the equation of motion of the paticle falling adially onto the black hole can be deived fom the Lagangian L = B(,t)ṫ 2 B(,t) ṙ 2, B(,t) = ( k (t t) /3 ), (9) whee the dot denotes diffeentiation with espect to the eigentime τ. The Eule-Lagange equations τ δl δ(ṫ,ṙ) = δl δ(, t) () then ead Eq. () leads to τ (2B(,t)ṫ) = t Bṫ 2 t (B )ṙ 2, () τ (2B(,t) ṙ) = Bṫ 2 + (B )ṙ 2. (2) = B 2B ṙ2 + tb B ṙṫ B 2 Bṫ 2, (3) ẗ = B B ṙṫ tb 2B ṫ2 t(b ) ṙ 2. (4) 2B Additionally, we can take into account that the fou-velocity of the test paticle is constant Bṫ 2 B ṙ 2 =, (5) since we used the eigentime τ as cuve paamete. We solved eq. (2) in conjunction with eq. (5) numeically. We consideed fist the analytically solvable case of a paticle falling adially on a stable black hole (with mass M) stating at est at a distance R d dτ Intoducing the paamete η defined by one obtains =, (τ = ) = R. (6) =R ( 2 ) η = accos R, (7) = R 2 (+cosη), τ = R 3 (η +sinη), 8M R [ t = 2M 2M η + R ] 4M (η +sinη) +2M ln R 2M +tan η 2 R 2M tan η 2. (8) Such a paticle eaches the hoizon afte an eigentime τ H [ R τ H = 3 ( ) ] 2s accos 4 s R s +2 R 2 s R 2. (9) This value seved as a pactical independent check fo the accuacy of ou numeical calculation. A simple explicit finite diffeence Eule fowad scheme is fully sufficient fo the numeical integation of eq. (3), whee one can eliminate ṫ by using eq. (5). But it is necessay to adapt the eigentime step τ duing the integation pocess in ode to obtain an accuate solution. As long as 3

4 Extenal time t o eigentime τ Figue : Test paticle falling into a stable black hole with Schwazschild adius s =. This gaph can be found in many standad textbooks. the paticle has a elatively lage distance to the hoizon, the time step can be held constant, but in the vicinity of the hoizon, a update of the time step accoding to τ n+ = ṙn ṙ n τ n (2) fo each integation step is a good choice. The effect is a eduction of the time step when the adial coodinate stats tochange faste withespect totheeigentime τ, andtheesolution of thetajectoy with espect to the extenal obseve time t is maintained. Fig. shows the tajectoy of the paticle falling into a stable black hole with s = and R = 2 with espect to the paticle s eigentime τ and the extenal obseve time t. In this case, the paticle eaches the hoizon fo τ H = 2(π/2+) and the singulaity fo τ S = π 2 R 3 / s Fig. 2 shows the typical situation fo an unstable black hole. In ode to obtain easonable plots, we used shot black hole lifetimes, but the qualitative pictue emains the same independently fom the actual lifetime of the black hole which may be vey lage fo massive holes. Fom the extenal obseve s point of view, the paticle impinges on the black hole hoizon, whee it emains captued until the black hole evapoates. In the final evapoation phase, the paticle even looses contact to the hoizon due to the fast decease of the black hole adius. Fom the point of view of the test paticle, the black hole seems to evapoate as soon as the paticle appoaches the hoizon. The amusing point in ou toy model is the fact that fom the test paticle s point of view, the evapoation time of the black hole is lage fo black holes with a shot lifetime. This is due to the fact that the evapoation pocess continuously educes the distance between the hoizon to the paticle, such that the paticle expeiences a smalle time contaction nea the hoizon, when the hoizon shinks faste. Fo massive black holes, the black hole evapoation time appoaches the time that the paticle would need to each the hoizon of a stable black hole with s = s (τ = ), given by eq. (9). Fig. 3 shows τ(t ) τ H, i.e. basically the eigentime of the paticle with the same initial conditions as in Fig. 2 at which the evapoation pocess of the black hole with initial lifetime t comes to the end. We conclude with the emak that within ou simplified famewok one should expect basically the same esult fo moe complex pocesses, e.g. fo a test paticle appoaching two meging black holes which evapoate subsequently. The test paticle cannot coss the classical hoizon, and an asymptotic obseve will neve obseve that the paticle impinges the hoizon within finite time []. 4

5 s, s, t 2 4 τ Figue 2: Typical tajectoies fo a test paticle falling onto a black hole with initial Schwazschild adius s () = and a lifetime t =2. τ(t ) τ H Black hole lifetime t Figue 3: Eigentime τ(t ) educed by the eigentime τ H needed by a test paticle to each the hoizon of a stable black hole, vesus the black hole lifetime t. 5

6 Refeences [] W.G. Unuh, Phys. Rev. D4 (976) 87. [2] S.W. Hawking, Commun. Math. Phys. 43 (975) 99, Natue 248 (974) 3. [3] W.G. Unuh, Phys. Rev. D5 (995) [4] T. Jacobson, Phys. Rev. D44 (99) 73. [5] C. R. Stephens, G. t Hooft, B.F. Whiting, Class. Quant. Gav. (994) 62. [6] E. Babichev, V. Dokuchaev, Yu. Eoshenko, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (24) 22. [7] W. A. Hiscock, Phys. Rev. D23 (98) 283. [8] P. C. Vaidya, Poc. Indian. Acad. Sci. A33 (95) 264. [9] P. Hajicek, W. Isael, Phys. Lett. 8A (98) 9. [] N. Staumann, Geneal Relativity with Applications to Astophysics, Spinge (Belin) 24. 6