iai~wrinnpnuiui~maudii5'11iiiwia~ii~nkn~1~iu~g~~~u

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "iai~wrinnpnuiui~ma~~ud~~ii5'11iiiwia~ii~nkn~1~iu~g~~~u"

Godwin Edwards
5 years ago
Views:

I L I - 1 ~nisi+w~w~-%~iiqnra~~ud't::4iiaibw ~m~w~rwnsdq~n.r.ruimoj~ona'n~u~~~i iai~wrinnpnuiui~ma~~ud~~ii5'11iiiwia~ii~nkn~1~iu~g~~~u &~l(indi-auhii o~hknauuo~npnultlii 4 d3zrn3?

1 I L I - 1 ~nisi+w~w~-%~iiqnra~~ud't::4iiaibw ~m~w~rwnsdq~n.r.ruimoj~ona'n~u~~~i iai~wrinnpnuiui~ma~~ud~~ii5'11iiiwia~ii~nkn~1~iu~g~~~u &~l(indi-auhii o~hknauuo~npnultlii 4 d3zrn3?a ~hngn 3~~qfifmu nuaii?"~%4~~3a~d L: Y daniwcsi uariiirnqdsra~6rdon?iuqftn3'zu cw.rka:uun~iuqla~~u~h~~onivo~ 1 rl Y 40 npnuiu ~nn~nuiu~~unuinoiu?~n~iu~~n~~u~#bbdd~rai'~~uu"~~~~ nisdfid~fiid6 rinngnuiuiirflu&o~d~31u~~nff u~ci"uqan~3uodrl3::dil &#un?iuqiin~tu(dtfh qmn3uitorr3nu o~iaiqwu'nn~nui~ uonsin$u:itham:ciu~ai6wu'nng~uiu~~~an~~i1do~1u~i'~ioi~~~nau' qnnd3umu qna~6n3 'Ldiir~wnini~uian?anin~anmc rinnpnuiu'ljl~iliju.nu'ido~ 4d vm L: r l A ~ ~awidunia nuvwwinai 8uni~ nuionnurriiuu lund?u~iuuo~nini~uiauu~1n3 il y nnns ~~ldirnnpnuiu lwnmonacn"&a~l~rinngnuio ibu auini~~iirinnpnuio rl4 d Y A- L undmaingnuiu Gr~inu+-maucao ~duh d~nii$u~nn~uiu~~1fl6irl?n~i~~rid~raim~~~~n&i~u n~iihosrinnpnuiu?onis~fl~id?nn~~~~i~~n'~d~u~un~~d~::ai~u~~dijua~n~o~ ~dd~zwq~ijfnpuio mumni~1#6id?nw~~~i~~;~u'nn~o~ii~1lf(~o~ij~mn~~udnd~t QCiuiiuo~uniau rinnpnuiultj~~ofirnrloii~~u~flu~~iu~~~\tuni~u k~uq,l~n~u'u~~%ih~nn~~ui~~~~o~ 2 d~mi.rffa 1) n?iuqh~uar rawyiismu a~~uqisqq~fl#n~w~aubd~~b cinurur1~uk?ld~odn~1u~~n3~ ur~i~ng~nmg (i7.171.fi~rimurilun33u D1~ust~~~v LLRL~UILH~W~ "Reason" umnpmu&u *Inp~nmG 4d*d iln~iaflunssuuardbnqwanmn~3uniiqgn~~u fiin~~nmfljl~n~iub~una3u uaz'ldii Arrl rnnlwan~nl~m"inglnm6u"u~~y8nttu udn?iuqiin.raud~n~nuiu~~~t:n~iuq~n3fu 1uf~nu1dfioimmidu~n27u~~uf ~~~uej~ci?iw~l~~p(~~w'i~~ stfi~i.rcui8na~~~d-l

2 2. Qi7UYn Positive

3 fiji~1~ac1~m'ud~::~n~1qnn~~il~~1~::a1a~~au~n~nn'~qn~~ i Lester ward nka41 na~uq~s~~u~~u~aud~::nouuoduny'd~un~~ r d a~ua33unrlu'~n1~iuun'u ud9ch~ti1laiiana1u~iq~iuun'u hfi~k~on~ahtah ii?adiluci~nuviold ~ ~ o u ~ u k o n ~ ~ f i n w ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f l n ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ n u A. 2 P $dnn~o~l~inrumu~a~u~~ld~an~r)~na~auna~uunwf o~n~~~~~w~ii~ua~~~d uvi ~%duo~$dnn~o~ko~~on~an~~n~~~nw~od~~~v;~~~uun'u~do~fl dold Karl Marx LLB: i r r ta Frederick Engelo ~~b~~l61<~~~~~~3~~~1l~udlcr'd~ wuornn iiynnad~uh&tud~rlu~6~~nniwo~n~ua::waw~au~n uaril~udillituriou hu~l3~~~a~ulffuwad~::~unrfu1n n14 ihuda~qu6auu~~~1ul&fuwad~::lu'11ri~ou ufluod Marx kaafi~~~uun~~uina"~au~u ~#~~RuLBuL~~uoJ~~~us~~" u#an3:01u wad~du?r6~1nnttu1n~~~n::wa~ija~~~1~~uun'u~ dalnnulfld~uodn.r.r& Guqun' luln~afi~~ual.ndaud~::~~;fu daw~ ddo~nnfwu~nf LL~=:H~WQ~ u: P uahadrmin~ua aw~ilu 17' Plato, The Republic, Book IV. 18. Aristotle, The Politics, Book Ill. 19' Lester F. Ward, Applied Sociology, p. 22. *' Karl Marx, Critique of the Gotba Program, p. 10.

4 Herkrt Spencer I~~~?I~HuILIYoJAI<I "qta33uw bbd~nll~~~~~~(~i~d~& mu&, ~on~~u~~a.r.ru~~~~u~~o~n'un~iu~~uo~n~~d~~u~~a~n uyabnq.r! n on.rrnwnqruaqnnn unqrninitchuu3 dondo( uar~~aamqiuiiak4u uriodi~l~fia~u ta3niwuo~bonauo:n'pcqn~in'na~lau8n.rmwuo~$~nu~~ I~n'RuruoJ Herbert Spencer ^O~mi~~~~in~h~o~%w~aiu1~i~uai~~o~u~~d u~~fi!~ij3tluw~iina3uuo~ 41MLQJ W m soll.~ nh~<in~iuq8a~mor#o~d~~nou&~unaiu~nuoflin uadn3rnw A #~no~~~ariio~~~"iui~~::ni~~uo~i~nu~a agn.r:riimnu 1 )!ni~w'amlm.rirnalnicauini~#nwitu odi~nli~uq~~ nu~flni.r#na~~uh~~s~f~i~r~~n~n~wn'un~iu~nuonind asnul&o*d3 2) sriio$ni.r6~llimumuncnu~m~nu~~~~n~~umui~~~~ou"~u 1 o~rrl%n~mwlum~iimug:ol~iian~iu~nuomnlu$~n~~l& UR: auieuriu~~b~~~w'auida::~n~aia~#~o~d~~ 6o uon~inni.r#nwua:oiiw~~&ac~8~.~! hudcnouih 7!nhu ih ni.rqacnsi~qdk.ln~~~dw=:~um~6fu~u 9 riic luld-iivl~ A b r 3) ~o~ifi~i~~~qn&~ulfl lumd'io~~2iurndd 3 nu. ~wonnuiuil4' luu~:dui~~uad~id~::did~u"iu~~i~~~ ld6n~imoio1dl? ~idu~uni'~~~~~niwwi~bu~~,john ~awk nhqii n~iuqta33u6o~d3rnau6~~ I) ~ ddl~tuuni) Q~iingi ~vii~;leun'u!.rin~iuui~intn~n~w UAL 2) n13ca3:~uasnu~~w~~qfwpiislfl~~dqnnu~~ John Rawls ~iu~~ud3:1u%d~o~n~u~u~du~~ ~d~dl~~~~~dn~iu~nu~ninbba~^o~fn biidu atxo~~ni~4~:uusijnu~~a~~~~~~~a~fl~r~1d~ uort{u Y d.r:luad~ o~a'~w.r~u~flu~uo~iuo~n~iuq6~~~~u&iau Thomas Hobk~ b$u'h n~iuq3n~~~~u~~nuni~~do~ nl3fl~jn'~fl?l~~~flj daoa5ulu#n ii~niu n8mfwbiu n ~iu~nuamm~ad~~niw~~~~1~iuii6q~o YE A mu~unikijdamv~uo~~~nu~~a::uodu~~fi!n~iu~i~qd~n~i ajuwwonnuiun~dao61iiuvo~ uywkrhb~~iunamnu~ijuonin~~a~~~~iu~n~niwuo~nu~d ~do~flnao~o~16odi~ dclon~%t~~ ~homsa ~obbes ~ilu~nd.naq?uriirtn Positive ~ unqiu~$~ya~~~i uyw~&o~bi(tt 21' Herbert Spencer, Justice, p ' William S. Sorley, The Morel Life, p ' John Rewls, A Theory of Justice, p Thomas Hobbes, De Cive, ch. I.

5 25' Jsremy Bentham, Theory of Legislation, p

6 2' r 3 5 $ & cb 2 0, 2- $ i5 3 dt 3, s 3 5t 2 3t s If 3- P-' E~ tl rn 3 n s; < St!3 J ;t 2 m 3 fi2 '. G s! E~

7 Morris v. Crown Offlce, 2 W.R.L. (1970) 792.

8 c wn iiqnnuar 3 ~tou ~d30ni~a~lww!5rio~ luakrqnasm ~wwinwidr~uuiiirmnwilu'~~u qwnsdfio ~wd Denning ddb~u(~winl~~dfl~ab~uduin nhaii iir~u!uldoiaqnnl!lid n onill+ainhiiu ni~n~:riiuo~~uiauna~!6~uni'~uneio~d!&~~~a~naiu~a~~u udnaiuiia 1.Ld Yod~uioinaxini3 ~~ila~~niadiian~nuiu TauWdi%iini!Mnnou riiaiu'~in~41lu 0: Y rijnuuo~ho~ui!d~iinpui~uu~u~n~au~quyw6~~ars'nwiuyw~k~i~~q~~1~u mu!d & wd a &uu y~niaiung~uiufi~in'uiiaiu~~ubo~bbar~iaiui~nu~~dnaiuiia ni3nclwq 41fjn 3 3 h. 4 ~ ~ L ~ ~ ' B ~ n l 3 ~ d ~ ~ ~! f l d ' b d ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ b b 3 J b ~ ~ 2. rinn~~uiuiiatl#n~~uiuo~i~bouxia~u ibiuri nisl#iiuil~iiiduo~nu w do lurn~ng~muohshn~~~~bhdka~o~~iiui~~uiwwi!& hodindu miunaiuoiw:ldiu iin8dnw#wii!d~iluxi33u oirnisoill:~#qa~i~l~d!dflodn~una~n"nw#uii'bdb~u%a~u bnuunnws2uua.r ngiwinwiifjnlunaiuiia~ius'u7uuu~ifuan'u~udw1ufli!~ nlzu 'Lddwlnu~Kn~iuouui~oi~nfju~n~!& ~lb~ul:~~ddij$m~u~uu"ubqdb~uwulu kd datua~np~uiuoiqi~qq~~i$~uuun"~naiufia&au udbdods:~a~uniaboi~a.r & ijuuniuia~lnw oiutn~u~nis~mddflo~~~uuu~~uil~ni~~~uwuiu ~w.n:!&rii d aldu -3 dsduaflkn'ud3:bw~"1112 n is~~~ado~~u~iui~~~iduodw~ndiuo'un ngvwiu miap~goiamigwinwin~~~iun~~uiu uduou~unqagig~luniaiii~ualww~az ni~rii~~arii~iiu~-1uvi~lkmiaaiuiandounaiunaiu!dqgxi~'~ulu6auwn~~uiua~!6 ~du niuw~:~iauiyq7iikaunaiu~a8u~~~~inni~ rii~uanaiuw'cmi~oiqi~~ auh~nnuiia!d!l ~~riprsounaiu'b8 ~~dfiih@iru~iu!duo~~naiu naiu~~~ufl~:~jn~o~ d A 0 'buna~usoi~auoon~#n~au!~~nui!d~at~~uniu~#nb~unai~~fin douirz~iisiibiiun~ d~inaii(~iiu~iufiii~au3ni~~nnauau~6n'u ciilfiya~&iu~%n~r3u udnaiuiiafi~ d P God ua:(~gu~iu!duounouflod miajni.u~wwinwliii~audnai~~~a~~a:~oni~ 11-3 (14lww~~ ~3uni~l#qaGiii~~Aaeiounaiunaiu! dqixif ~uw~na'uw~riu'or~n"~~i 98u ii~s'u4iu u~~i~~a:ihu~gy'~q~n*!unfnwdauw'~unaiunaiu!dq~xiaaulung~~~iu~~!& ih~u5~ia w o~~~:oanwa~~ian~a~niwa~~i~wiu~stulww iriuunu~q3oi~~:aonwa:'~iay'qq3 G~lwanmu w3t3ia~q7h~uafiu ad 1 ~iluaawounaiunaiuldqgaaau~una~uiuw~ u o n ~ i n n i s l # ~ i u i m Q i ~ ~ ~ i u n p ~ u i u ~ ~ ~ a ~ n fiom3~naiuna~mu rinnr~~muniu7an~#naiuq~%aaubh~~n~uni~u Z

9 ~w'ari~lr~niunngwu~u~fi~n~~u~fi~~~r~#u\k ~du nliunnuiiaa1wts:s1'11y'qq3i1k2u n21uia~wh~1nn13'i%~qn cnaljrnsi~3wi1 rnsoonthdods:hwvld \d~ihmuiaenu Jd A A d wsrsiay'qjfl~guu onl.rodwudna ri4(cyhmolnnu~~ni~cqtbri~d~~~3ua~ R191q11d-1 t: w 1 uugrn~auaisrcirniq~od~q~ Ldot~dmu ~qw~~d~.r:jiil~~ ~(ii~o~~~~j~~iia~u ~I~L~IQ&MI?~~%~uIJ~T:L~~ ~du &duo2 ~~d1tio~duduci1aauunu~~u13udau r d1rioaf1di1u2u~6~~o~1ha1u\~aily~1~1~:~uflia1u1~r11iun6u13ui1u~~u\k Y ~iinrmulu'qi~~.ruvplb~rimu7n~0~~~1 ma~n~~~nf~~knn~wu~u'i~~u'wi~auo~~u ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~. ~. ~ ~ ~ I C ~ ~ I K J ~ ~ I ~ 6a I O ~ Q ~ ~ uon~1niia*ryqahukc~6iqqrb(1(i1~mou~1nug~~~d~:nou&~u hut$d1\iiimljud2u w w d w ww I g cilriowiid ~~~a~~~u~u~nao~nouilnp)~o~~~~a~uu\~orjtuo~ i~di~)uni~~::nfu W W I g A W I aiyq~ ~ :u:~~rnuo~q~~s~d~na~u~~uw~f::i~i~d~ni~~~~~~ Rjuu~uog~a~a~u n1ui~~ail$di~~n~\~~~1dt::~~'11d~i~~cycyidiil[ila~~~~u~~\d I ~ ~ ~ v N I ~ I ~ I ~ J rr6nnilheilrn~iuoliiil~niilnfm ~IR~~~~"L~U~~?I~LLU~IUIUTPI?IU~~~I~~~~~::LL r s J ~Ilun~iuiingiuehniwo nilnntzua~rlfln0uw6ililiu Idldnk6~wti::\d~Bu?'rnq~ tdiiil uai ~ ~ ainain ~ iur ~ ~ ii ~ ~ ~ a ~'~ ~ au"~ ~ ~ ~ ailfn ~ ~ dhail ~ a ~ ~ n"l Y fli~~nit~n?iuci~1l6t~nn?iuq~i~~tu 3. rinngwu1usi6~qu~~flngwu~u~i?iafi~1u~~u~3~~ 60 ng~u~u'ia'li~ilusf.ru t: Y linngwmuiiowu~u~uu~vng~uiuu~~~~u%f f u v 'Iun~fdnfifoddf:~n~u"w~n~uwdd duni~ Rule of Law 60 ~ ~:L~R~~R~Q~&~U~QHUIU O\Kdnn~a~ii2u~nna u~:'iungwu~u ~ng~nm~o~\u~doonng~857u\&aiud~rn~'i~ wcn~nm~vo~n~rnlud~:jo~~im~~'qfia~ luniunngwulu~u~ot i~n~safilungvu~ul~woanio~n'unaiuqi~~~~u 41uGlY'qqT ~8lulon.nngw)Hrnu u(iduou~vni~n'.o$u Rule of Law Q:QInng~u1ua1~61~1o'I~)\i\~ 1 P au14nani~~~nu.nu~~w1u1~0~wu~i~~n~~7u1o~~~~~a1~m1i1~n~ d rfims:d 1 imcnrn3 nfm 2 r n ~ ~ L I ~ ~ ~ z d ~ ~ j i n ~ ~ x n ~ r n ~ ~ ~ dduinhu~ 21f:d 3 ~flc1~iu~~u~ou ~ ~ D I. I I U ~ I ~ ~ ~ Q I ~ ~ I ~ D J ~ ~ I ~ L L 1 6 ~ n i d ~ i n ~ 3 ~ ~ fitll~ul~~u~~u i ~ ~ m ~ A ~ I H ~ U C ~ I ~ U ~ M I ~ U O ~ Q I ~ ~ ~ ' L ~ ~ ~ I ~ 6~unngwu1u'Ifiiian~1u~~us~f~1~#~~~dunuin'Iun1~~~~~vng~u~uiau dqolw~nhd6 i1n~u1ur'2u~m~\&~~11f~wuo\d'~intthu~1?~7f bunl:nm dhd 7 ~wwklf idng~w dna.:i~uuai nm:~uun~fi~~~m~?u~~nn~f~wr"~~~~~dd\d'i~nm:nf~u a.r2oufinumtiua nn~unltnf~um7nrlw~rnddn~um'iorifi~ibuu~~3'~f~u~mf 29

11 n%niurid.r taiauiiaiui.r nrii~~u3nid~ ~KOJ'I~~U~'LY~'~Q~ ~ucijnud.r:a~tdlmula' *rl w n~~uiudnn.rodn~.rd~u~'iuo~ir'n.r~itdnn'~o~~~oodfin~ ~~nnu~iouflug~nunamo~ ~u.kunpanu iicin npanu~~~~wj, njnm?nd.r:a?s~n3.r0=:d~~%muau'i~l.ri~0: qnxo~ ong~~m~ft~nud.r:aitd~~uiiu"nng~uiu~ci~diunuindnm.r o~~lluiiu7u d 4- uin lua~i~o~uin~d~ :siuisubi~~iunu~~uun~d&~un~~uiu ~rou?sl~wni JAU

OTSEGO COUNTY HERALD TIME3

OTSEGO COUNTY HERALD TIME3 V UNY RD 3 875 U 2 7 U { ^ ««««««B NN-KD UR Y; R «5 jj /j // ; N V W ; / B * j R- 5 W 268000 U-27-3 $30000 2 000 U-27 5 W $ 5000 46000 U-27 32 $72000 5000 D V $7674 000 $2225000 $450000 - * j 25 j 934