arxiv: v5 [physics.class-ph] 26 Jan 2018

Transcription

1 Wae Defletion and Shifted Refousing in a Medium Modulated by a Supeluminal Retangula Pulse Zoé-Lise Dek-Lége, Aliea Akbaadeh and Chistophe Calo Dpt. of Eletial Engineeing, Polytehnique Montéal, Montéal, QC H3T 1J4, Canada axi: [physis.lass-ph] 26 Jan 2018 We eploe the poblem of satteing in a medium modulated by a supeluminal etangula pulse, with the pulse modulation ealied though tansese eitations. We sole this poblem in the moing fame whee the modulation appeas puely tempoal, sine the solution to a puely tempoal modulation is known. Upon this basis, we use a gaphial appoah to find the angle and fequeny of the wae satteed by the modulation unde oblique inidene. This study eeals that supeluminal modulations deflet plane waes eto-dietiely, and efous ylindial waes to a shifted point of spae with espet to the oiginal soue. I. INTRODUCTION Speula efletion fom wate o smooth sufaes has been epeiened by humans sine the dawn of times. The efletion fomula, θ θ i, was fist epoted in the book Catoptis, pesumably attibuted to Eulid 1. Refletion (and efation) fom slabs and moe omple stutues wee then studied by Huygens, Newton and many othes. In 1727, Badely disoeed that the abeation in the peeied positions of the stas was due to the motion of the eath 2, and subsequently established the theoy of abeation of light. In his foundational 1905 pape on the theoy of elatiity 3, Einstein poided the elatiisti oetion to Badley s abeation law, and soled the poblem of efletion by a moing mio, whih oesponds to a double-abeation poblem. Speifially, he poided fomulas fo the efletion angle and the efletion fequeny 4. It was late shown that the efletion phenomenology is the same fo a moing dieleti slab, and the tansmitted wae emeges at the same angle as the inident one 5. The poblem of efletion by a moing slab is depited in Fig. 1, with the efleted wae pogessiely defleted fom the speula angle (θ θ i ) fo 0 to the nomal of the intefae (θ 0) fo. (a) 0 θ θ i θ t (b) θ θ i FIG. 1. Defletion fom a etangula pulse modulation. (a) Subluminal (b) Supeluminal. Einstein s wok on the moing mio poblem was estited to subluminal eloities, sine he was onsideing a moing medium, whose eloity is limited to fom his own theoy. Hee, we will lift this estition θ t by onsideing modulated media, whee is ahieable when the soue of modulation is tansese to light popagation 6. Moing and modulated media ae fundamentally diffeent, but still ehibit a numbe of similaities. Isotopi moing media appea bianisotopi to a est obsee 7, wheeas modulated isotopi media emain isotopi. Moeoe, moing media indue Fieau dag 8, while modulated media do not. Howee, both media indue Dopple fequeny shifting and angle sanning. The limiting ase of a supeluminally modulated medium is a puely tempoally modulated medium, fo whih. This oesponds to a medium that is swithed eeywhee in spae between two states. Thee has been substantial eseah on suh media. Fist, Mogenthale 9 soled the poblem of satteing by a tempoal step modulation and deied the oesponding fequeny and amplitude satteing fomulas 10. Shotly late, Felsen noted that a tempoal step modulation efousses efleted waes bak to thei soue position 11, whih was eently epeimentally demonstated with an aousti wae in 12. Kallui addessed the poblem of tempoal modulation in plasmas; he published a tetbook on the topi 13 and eently epoted the appliation of a miowae to teahet fequeny and polaiation tansfome 14. Finally, Halei theoetially studied peiodi tempoal media 15 and epeimentally demonstated them in miowae tansmission lines loaded by time-modulated aatos 16. Supeluminally modulated media, although potentially haboing muh ihe physis than thei puely tempoal ountepats, due to the additional momentum paamete, hae been muh less eploed to date. The few studies on the topi hae all been estited to waes nomally inident to the supeluminal modulation. Piee and Ostoskiĭ 6,17 pointed out the patial feasibility of suh modulations and omputed the elated satteed fequenies fo a step pulse modulation. Bianalana 18 etended this wok by additionally poiding the satteed field amplitudes and soling the poblem of multiple ising and falling edges (fo nomal wae inidene). Cassedy studied peiodi supeluminal modulations; speifially, he deied thei dispesion elations, plotted the oesponding oblique dispesion diagams and desibed thei

2 2 instability egions 19. Finally, new eletomagneti modes ouing in dispesie media modulated by a peiodi supeluminal wae wee eently epoted in 20. In this pape, we sole the poblem of satteing fom a supeluminal etangula pulse modulation. Fo this pupose, we fist poide a gaphial solution fo the ase of nomal inidene. We patiulaly show that the supeluminal modulation equies a time-like desiption, athe than the onentional spae-like one fo the subluminal ase. We net etend the gaphial appoah to the ase of oblique inidene. Speifially, we show that the efleted wae sans negatie angles, as illustated in Fig. 1(b), whih etends the oeall sanning ange beyond the nomal of the modulation ompaed to the subluminal ase [Fig. 1(a)], and we deie fomulas fo oesponding satteed angles and fequenies. Finally, we demonstate that ylindial waes ae efoused by the supeluminal etangula pulse modulation to a point that is shifted fom the position of the oiginal soue. We fous on a etangula pulse athe than a simple step pulse beause this poides an oppotunity to highlight a multiple satteing phenomenology that is fundamentally diffeent fom that ouing in the subluminal egime. This also allows onenient ompaison with subluminal efletion, as will be seen. t (a) ω / (b) ψ t ψi ω/ m n 2 n 1 0 n 1 k k n 2 t t 0 ω 0 ψ ω / () (d) t m ω/ k 0 n 1 n 2 n 1 n 2 k k II. GRAPHICAL ANALYSIS Figue 2(a) epesents the satteing of a nomally inident wae,, by a subluminal etangula pulse whih modulates a medium of efatie inde n 1 to n 2, in the diet Minkowski diagam. Suh satteing inoles multiple efletions between the ising edge and the falling edge of the modulation, whih esult in a global efleted wae, ψ, and a global tansmitted wae,. Note that the slope of the ising and falling edges of the subluminal modulation is (t)/ / m > 1 in this epesentation. In ode to detemine the satteed fequenies, we will sole the satteing poblem in the fame moing with the modulation, whee the modulation appeas stationnay, as done onentionally. The spae and time aes of the moing fame ae set aodingly, with the ising edge tajetoy fied at 0, and the time ais of the moing fame t paallel to the modulation s tajetoy. The quantities in the moing fame ae elated to the quantities in the stationay fame though the Loent tansfomations 3 γ ( βt), t γ (t β), (1) with the Loent fato γ ( 1 β 2) 1/2 and the nomalied eloity of the moing fame β /. The slopes of the moing aes and t ae found by setting t 0 and 0 in (1), espetiely. The satteed fequenies ae found in the inese Minkowki diagam, as depited in Fig. 2(b), whih ontains the dispesion elations of the initial medium and FIG. 2. Satteing fom subluminal and supeluminal etangula pulse modulations fo nomal inidene in diet and inese Minkowski diagams. (a) Subluminal egime, diet spae. (b) Supeluminal egime, diet spae. () Subluminal egime, inese spae. (d) Supeluminal egime, inese spae. The unpimed and pimed aes labels oespond to the stationay and moing fames, espetiely. the modulated egion. The inese Loent tansfomations 21 k γ (k βω/), ω / γ (ω/ βk ), (2) poide the moing fame aes, that tun out to be paallel to those of the diet spae. Sine the modulation is stationay in the moing fame, the fequeny in this fame is onseed, i.e. ω 0 (see Appendi A 1), and the multiple spetal tansitions 22 stating fom the inident wae (half ed ile) ou along the oesponding (dotted) oblique line, paallel to k. The final efleted wae (blue ile) is geometially found to be upshifted to ω ω i (1 2 m/ 2 )/(1 + 2 m/ 2 ), (3) with m < 0, in aodane with the Dopple law, while the tansmitted wae (half geen ile) is found to hae the same fequeny as the inident wae, ω t ω i. Note that the final fequeny solutions ae independent of the efatie inde of the modulated egion. Satteing by a supeluminal etangula pulse modulation is epesented in the diet Minkowski diagam

3 3 Fig. 2(), with the slope of the modulation tajetoy being now (t)/ / m < 1. The inident wae,, sattes into two waes at the ising edge. The efleted wae is in the seond medium, ontay to the subluminal ase, sine it is now slowe than the intefae. At the falling edge, eah wae geneates in tun two satteed waes, fo a total of fou satteed waes, as in the ase of the puely tempoal etangula modulation 13. This suggests that that the supeluminal poblem is like a tempoal poblem, o time-like, and should onsequently be tansfomed into a tempoal poblem, athe than a spatial one as done in the spae-like subluminal ase. 23 The moing fame aes ae set aodingly, with the pulse ising edge fied at t t 0, and the moing spae ais paallel to its tajetoy. Sine the modulation is now paallel to, we find, by inspetion of Fig. 2(), the following fundamental elationship between the modulation and fame eloities: / / m, (4) whee is the eloity an obsee must hae to see the modulation moing at m, o to see the subluminal modulation as tempoal. The gaphial esolution fo the supeluminal etangula pulse modulation is poided in Fig. 2(d). Sine the modulation is puely tempoal in the moing fame, the waenumbe in this fame is onseed, i.e. k 0 (see Appendi A 2), and the spetal tansitions fom the inident wae (half ed ile) hene ou along the oesponding (dotted) oblique line, paallel to ω / this time. This indiates that efleted waes now oespond to negatie fequenies, athe than negatie waenumbes. The fou satteing eents lead to the final efleted wae (blue ile) being upshifted to ω ω i (1 2 m/ 2 )/(1 + 2 m/ 2 ), (5) and the tansmitted wae (half geen ile) haing the same fequeny as the inident wae, ω t ω i. One again, the final fequeny solutions ae independent of the efatie inde of the modulated egion. III. REFLECTION FROM SUPERLUMINAL PULSE MODULATION We now etend the poblems studied in the peious setion to the ase of oblique inidene. Conside an inident wae popagating at an angle θ i (Fig. 1) with fequeny ω i and waenumbes k i (ω i /) os θ i, k i (ω i /) sin θ i. Figue 3 plots the hypeboli dispesion ue ω 2 / 2 k 2 ki 2 (top), with inidene point (k i, ω i ) (ed ile), and the oesponding isofequeny ue k 2 + k 2 ωi 2/2 (bottom), with inidene point (k i, k i ) and goup eloity gi k ω i (k). We fist onside the subluminal ase. Due to phase mathing, k k i, and theefoe the efleted wae,, lies on the same hypebola as the inident wae. ψ sub m / sub g sup g ψ sub ω / ψ 0 0 g θ sup g ω/ k 0 ψ θ sub k m / gi θ i ω 0 ψ sup FIG. 3. Satteing of hamoni plane waes fom subluminal and supeluminal etangula pulse modulations fo oblique inidene. Top: iso-k dispesion diagam. Bottom: iso-ω diagam. This gaph is fo the patiula ase of sub / / sup, whih oneniently leads to shaed Loent moing fames. Note that we hae hee hanged the onention angle of Fig. 1, fo oneniene. Enfoing ω 0 (spae-like poblem), we loalie the fequeny ω sub of the efleted wae in the (k, ω/) spae at the intesetion of the dispesion ue and the dotted line paallel to k (pale blue ile). We net pojet this point onto the ile k 2 + k 2 (ω sub ) 2 / 2 in the (k, k ) spae, and find the popagation dietion of the efleted wae as g sub k ω sub (k). We then immediately see that as m ( slope) ineases, ω sub ineases and hene the angle of efletion, θ sub, ineases towads the nomal of the modulation, in ageement with Einstein s mathematial esult [Fig. 1(a)], fom θ sub ( m 0) π θ i to θ sub ( m ) π. Now onside the supeluminal ase. Enfoing k 0 (time-like poblem) yields the fequeny ω sup of the efleted wae, ψ sup, in the (k, ω/) spae at the intesetion of the dispesion ue and the dotted line paallel to ω / (dak blue ile). Pojeting this point onto the (k, k ) spae to the ile k 2 +k 2 (ω sub ) 2 / 2 yields the popagation dietion of the efleted wae g sup. We then see that as m ineases, ω sub deeases and hene the angle of efletion, θ sup, is futhe ineased towads the inidene dietion, fom θ sub ( m ) π θ i to θ sub ( m ) π + θ i. This phenomenon, illustated in Fig. 1(b), onstitutes a ental esult of the pape, and etends Einstein s law to the supeluminal ase. k i k k k

4 4 We now mathematially deie the quantitatie esults oesponding to the gaphial qualitatie esults fo the supeluminal modulation. In a puely tempoal modulation, oesponding to the limit m in Fig. 3, the efleted wae is aligned with the inident wae 11, i.e. θ θ i +π. The same is tue fo the supeluminal modulation in the fame whee it is tempoal, i.e. θ θ i + π. Theefoe, we hae, with i, sin θ i,, i. Upon elatiisti tansfomation of eloities 3 (see Appendi B), this equation beomes in the stationay fame i ( 2 /2 1) ( 2 /2 2 / 2 + 1) whih, with i, sin θ i,, tanslates into (6) ases, espetiely. The intesetion between the ylindial wae and the subluminal modulation yields a hypebola, whih leads to diffation. In ontast, the intesetion between the ylindial wae and the supeluminal modulation yields an ellipse, whih leads to efousing. In the moing fame, whee the modulation is seen as tempoal, fousing ous at the spatial oigin of the soue 11,12, as shown in Fig. 4(b). This is seen in the stationay fame as efousing shifted to the left foal point of the ellipse, the soue being at the ight foal point, by the amount γt 0. Figue 5 shows snapshots of t t t sin θ ( 2 /2 1) sin θ i 2 /2 2 os θ i / + 1. (7) The elations between the efletion angle and the modulation eloity ae found by inseting (4) into (7). Modulation t 0 sin θ (1 2 m/ 2 ) sin θ i 1 2 os θ i m / + 2 m/ 2, (8a) os θ (1 + 2 m/ 2 ) os θ i 2 m / 1 2 os θ i m / + 2 m/ 2, (8b) whee (8b) was found by pefoming simila opeations to. These elations eeal that sin θ < 0 and os θ < 0 fo m >, in ageement with ou qualitatie gaphial analysis [Fig. 3]. Moeoe, the fequeny of the efleted wae is found by inseting (7) into the onseation of momentum k i k, o ω i sin θ i ω sin θ, whih yields ω ω i (1 2 m/ 2 ) 1 2 os θ i m + 2 m 2. (9) Note that the elations (8) and (9) ae idential to those found by Einstein fo efletion by a subluminal mio 3 (Appendi B 1) and ou finding theefoe genealies these laws to any eloity in the ase of a etangula pulse. This is not tue in the ase of a supeluminal step pulse, whee the efleted wae popagates in the medium 2 [Fig. 2()]. Note also the inteesting symmety ouing in the ase of opposite eloities, m sub / /m sup, and oesponding to the gaph of Fig. 3: θ sup 2π + θ sup, i.e. θ sup θ sub in the angle onention of Fig. 1, and ω sub ω sup IV.. SUPERLUMINAL SHIFTED REFOCUSING The analysis pefomed so fa was estited to plane waes. We now inestigate the satteing of ylindial waes, whose gaphial epesentations ae shown in Figs. 4(a) and (b) fo the subluminal and supeluminal (a) (b) FIG. 4. Satteing of ylindial wae by subluminal and supeluminal pulse modulations. (a) Subluminal ase: diffation. (b) Supeluminal ase: efousing. a standad finite-diffeene time-domain (FDTD) simulation of a ylindial pulse satteed by a naow supeluminal pulse modulation, with the modulation simulated as a hange in the efatie inde, updated at eah time step. The inident ylindial pulse is geneated fom an infinite line soue pependiula to the 2D satteing poblem. Refousing is seen to ou to the left of the oigin of the soue with the epeted shift. V. CONCLUSION We hae soled the anonial poblem of the satteing of waes in a medium modulated by a supeluminal etangula pulse. Suh a medium ould be epeimentally ealied in the fom of a 2D plana tansmission line stutue 25,26, whih may be modulated using fastswithing elements suh as aatos 27. Ou findings may lead to a new lass of deies ontolling both the spatial and tempoal speta of waes.

5 5 (a) (b) ψ () ψ These equations wee found fo the ising edge of the etangula pulse modulation, but ae also alid fo falling edge, suh that: k 2t k 2 k t, ω 2t ω 2 ω t. (A6) theefoe the spatial fequenies befoe and afte the etangula modulation ae elated by k i k k t, ω i ω ω t. (A7) ψ 2. Supeluminal Case (d) (e) γt 0 FIG. 5. Satteing of a ylindial pulse by a supeluminal pulse modulation. (a) Befoe satteing. (b) When the modulation has eahed the soue point. () When the modulation has ossed most of the pulse. (d) Afte ossing. (e) At the efous time. (f) Afte efousing. 24 (f) Appendi A: Spatial and Tempoal Fequeny Conseation Hee, we deie the onseed fequeny quantities at subluminal and supeluminal modulations. 1. Subluminal Case We stat by studying the satteing fom the ising edge of the etangula pulse modulation. The inident and efleted waes ae in the fist (unmodulated) medium and the tansmitted wae is in the seond, (modulated) medium, as in Fig. 2(a),(b), fo the ed, blue and dashed oange waes. The wae is a monohomati plane wae with a y-polaied eleti field, popagating in the dietion, i.e.: E m A m e i(km±km ωm) ŷ, (A1) with m i, and 2t, whee 2t stands fo tansmitted in medium 2. In the moing fame, E m A me i(k m ±k m ω m t) ŷ, (A2) The tangential eleti field is ontinuous aoss the bounday in the moing fame, i.e: [ E yi + E y E y2t] (A3) Inseting (A2) into (A3) yields 0. A ie i(k i +k i ω i t ) + A e i(k k ω t ) 0 A 2te i(k 2t +k 2t ω 2t t) 0, fom whih we dedue the onseation of k and ω : (A4) k i k k 2t, ω i ω ω 2t. (A5) We now study a tempoal modulation, whih is the limiting ase of a supeluminal modulation. We stat by studying the hange fom n 1 to n 2. The fields befoe and afte the modulation ae ontinuous. Thee is a ontoesy on the natue of the onseed field, as to whethe the D o E field is onseed, but this does not affet ou esult, sine we ae only inestigating the phase quantities and not the amplitudes. We hoose to wite the onseation of D, following 9, i.e. [D i D 2 + D 2t ] t0 (A8) whee 2, 2t and t oespond to the ed, dashed oange and dashed puple in Fig. 2(),(d). Following the same poedue as aboe, we find A i e i(ki+ki ωit) t0 A 2 e i(k2+k2+ω2t) + A 2t e i(k2t+k2t ω2tt) t0, (A9) fom whih we find k i k 2 k 2t, k i k 2 k 2t. (A10) A supeluminal ising edge an be seen as a tempoal modulation fom n 1 to n 2 in a fame moing at the eloity f / / m (4). In this moing fame, suh that [D i D 2 + D 2t] t 0 (A11) k i k 2 k 2t, k i k 2 k 2t. (A12) and theefoe, the fequenies befoe and afte the modulation ae elated by: k i k k t, k i k k t. (A13) Appendi B: Deiation of the Defletion Angle fom Veloity Addition Hee, we sole the defletion angle of a wae satteed by a subluminal and a supeluminal modulation. We stat with the subluminal modulation, fo whih the solution was poided by Einstein in 3 (ealling that the fequeny of a wae efleted fom a moing wall is the same as that fom a popagating modulation).

6 6 1. Subluminal Case Conside a wae obliquely inident on a subluminal etangula pulse modulation. In the fame moing with the modulation, the modulation appeas stationay, suh that the tansese eloities ae onseed and the nomal eloities ae inesed (see Fig. 3): i, i. (B1) The elatiisti eloity addition fomulas fo a fame moing along ae 3 1 2, γ ( 1 2 ), (B2a) + 1 +, γ ( 1 + ). (B2b) 2 2 Witing (B1) in the stationay fame by inseting (B2b) into (B1), we obtain: Similaly, fo : f 2 i + 1 i (1 ) 2 (1 ) 2 ( 2 ) 2 (1 + ) (B3a) (B3b) (B3) (B3d) 2. (B3e) ( ) (B4a) γ 1 + f 2 i ( ) (B4b) γ 1 i 2 γ 2 ( ) (1 ) 2 γ 2 (( 1 2 ) 2 ( ) ) (1 2 /2 ) Substituting sin θ, os θ, we find (B4) (B4d) (B4e) os θ os θ i(1 + 2 ) 2 2 /, (B5a) 1 2 os θ i sin θ sin θ i(1 2 /2 ) 1 2 os θ i (B5b) 2. Supeluminal Case Conside now a wae obliquely inident on a supeluminal modulation. Thee is a moing fame in whih this modulation appeas at one, i.e. appeas as a tempoal modulation. The efleted wae is ollinea with the inident wae, suh that (see Fig. 3): i, i (B6) These equations ae tansfomed to the est fame using (B2): Similaly, fo : i + 1 i (1 ) 2 (1 ) 2 ( 2 ) 2 (1 + ) 2 2 (B7a) (B7b) (B7) (B7d) (B7e) ( ) (B8a) γ i ( ) (B8b) γ 1 i 2 γ ( ) (1 ) 2 γ 2 (( 1 2 ) 2 ( ) ) (B8) (B8d) (1 2 /2 ). (B8e) Substituting sin θ, os θ, we find os θ os θ i(1 + 2 ) 2 2 /, (B9) 1 2 os θ i sin θ sin θ i(1 2 /2 ) 1 2 os θ i We finally substitute f 2 m, fom (4), leading to os θ os θ i(1 + 2 ) 2 2 / 1 2 os θ i (B10) (B11a)

7 7 sin θ sin θ i(1 2 /2 ) 1 2 os θ i (B11b) Notie that that the epessions (B11) and (B5) ae idential. Upon squaing (C4) and using the Helmholt elation, we find o, afte eaanging, k i 2 k i 2 k 2 k 2, k i 2 k 2 k i 2 k 2. (C5) (C6) Equation (C6) is ewitten as Appendi C: Deiation of the Defletion Angle fom Continuity Conditions We now deie (8) using an altenatie method, losely following 7, who teated the subluminal ase only. We stat with the -dieted waeeto onseation in the moing fame (A13). (k i k )(k i + k ) (k i k )(k i + k ), (C7) and diiding (C7) by (C3) yields k i + k 1 β (k i k ), (C8) o k i k. (C1) Applying the Loent tansfomation (2) to (C1) yields k i βk i k + βk. Substituting k m k m os θ m into (C9) yields k i (1 β os θ i ) k (1 + β os θ ), (C9) (C10) k i βω i k + βω. (C2) We onside the initial and final media ae fee spae, and so we substitue ω i, k i, / into (C2). Equations (C2) an be eaanged as k i k β (k i + k ). The -dieted waeeto in the moing fame is k i k. (C3) (C4) while pefoming the same substitution into (C2) yields k i (os θ i β) k (os θ + β). Finally, diiding (C10) by (C11) yields 1 β os θ i os θ i β 1 + β os θ os θ + β, (C11) (C12) whih eaanges to os θ os θ ( ) i 1 + β 2 2β 1 + β 2. (C13) 2β os θ i 1 T. L. Heath, A histoy of Geek mathematis, Vol. 1 (Claendon, 1921). 2 J. Badley, Philosophial tansations 35, 637 (1727). 3 A. Einstein, Ann. Physik 322, 891 (1905), epinted in C. Dopple, Übe das fabige Liht de Doppelstene und einige andee Gestine des Himmels (Cale, 1842). 5 C. Yeh and K. F. Casey, Phys. Re. 144, 665 (1966). 6 J. R. Piee, J. Appl. Phys. 30, 1341 (1958). 7 K. Kun, J. Appl. Phys. 51, 873 (1980). 8 H. Fieau, C.R. Aad. Si. 33, 349 (1851). 9 F. R. Mogenthale, IEEE Tans. Miow. Theoy Tehn. 6, 167 (1958). 10 He did this by applying ontinuity onditions on the D and B fields, while othe authos (e.g. 13 ) onsideed ontinuity of the E and H fields. The natue of the onseed fields does not affet the esults epoted in this pape. 11 L. Felsen and G. M. Whitman, IEEE Tans. Antennas. Popag. 18, 242 (1970). 12 V. Baot, M. Labousse, A. Eddi, M. Fink, and E. Fot, Natue Phys. 12, 972 (2016). 13 D. K. Kallui, Eletomagnetis of Time Vaying Comple Media: Fequeny and Polaiation Tansfome (CRC Pess, 2010). 14 D. K. Kallui and R. K. Lade, IEEE Tans. Plasma Si. 40, 3070 (2012). 15 J. R. Zuita-Sánhe, P. Halei, and J. C. Ceantes- Gonále, Phys. Re. A 79, (2009). 16 J. R. Reyes-Ayona and P. Halei, IEEE Tans. Miowae Theoy and Tehniques 64, 3449 (2016). 17 L. A. Ostoskiĭ, So. Phys. Usp. 18, 452 (1975). 18 F. Bianalana, A. Amann, A. V. Usko, and E. P. OReilly, Phys. Re. E 75, (2007), equation E. S. Cassedy, Po. IEEE 55, 1154 (1967). 20 N. Chamanaa, Z.-L. Dek-Lége, C. Calo, and D. Kallui, axi pepint axi: (2017). 21 J. A. Kong, Theoy of eletomagneti waes (Wiley- Intesiene, New Yok, 1975).

8 8 22 Z. Yu and S. Fan, Nat. Photon. 3, 91 (2009). 23 Note that the Loent fato (γ) beomes imaginay fo f >. Theefoe, tansfoming the supeluminal poblem into a spatial poblem would yield unphysial imaginay spae and time quantities, whih we aoid by tansfoming to a tempoal modulation. 24 See supplementay mateial at [] fo the oesponding ideo. 25 G. V. Eleftheiades, A. K. Iye, and P. C. Keme, IEEE Tans. Miow. Theoy Teh. 50, 2702 (2002). 26 A. Sanada, C. Calo, and T. Itoh, IEEE Tans. Miow. Theoy Teh. 52, 1252 (2004). 27 S. Taaati, N. Chamanaa, and C. Calo, Phys. Re. B 96, (2017). 28 H. A. Loent, A. Einstein, H. Minkowski, H. Weyl, and A. Sommefeld, The piniple of elatiity: a olletion of oiginal memois on the speial and geneal theoy of elatiity (Doe Publiations, 1952) pp. 27.