arxiv: v1 [astro-ph.co] 2 Jun 2017

Transcription

1 Dft vesion June 6, 7 Pepint typeset using L A TEX style AASTeX6 v.. TESTING EMERGENT GRAVITY WITH ISOLATED DWARF GALAXIES Kis Pdo Deptment of Astophysicl Sciences, Pinceton Univesity 4 Ivy Lne, Pinceton, NJ 8544 Xiv:76.785v [sto-ph.co] Jun 7 ABSTRACT Velinde 6 hs poposed new modified theoy of gvity, Emegent Gvity EG, s n ltentive to dk mtte. EG epoduces the Tully-Fishe eltionship with no fee pmetes, nd gees with the velocity cuves of most mssive, spil glxies well. In its cuent fom, the theoy only pplies to isolted, spheiclly symmetic systems in dk enegy-dominted Univese, nd thus cn only be tested fily with such systems. Hee I develop equtions fo EG s velocity cuve pedictions given elistic, extended mss distibution. I pply this to isolted dwf glxies. Then I test the pedictions fom EG vesus the mximum velocity mesuements of 8 isolted dwf glxies with pojected shpes close to cicul. I find tht EG seveely undepedicts the mximum velocities fo those glxies with mesued velocities v > 65 km/s. Most of these glxies hve gete HI gs msses thn stell msses, nd it is seems tht EG is unble to descibe these systems well. Rottion cuves of these isolted, HI gs-ich, nely spheicl dwf glxies would povide the definitive test of EG.. INTRODUCTION Since Zwicky s ppe on dunkel mtte in the 93s Zwicky 933, thee hs been gowing evidence fo new physics. Rottion cuves of glxies Rubin et l. 98, the Cosmic Micowve Bckgound Plnck Collbotion et l. 6, nd Byonic Acoustic Oscilltions Eisenstein et l. 5 hve solidified the need fo something beyond the Stndd Model o Genel Reltivity GR. Is this new physics dk mtte pticle o modifiction of GR? Velinde 6 gives one possible solution to this question. In Emegent Gvity EG theoy Velinde 6, gvity emeges fom the entnglement of spcetime. Accoding to this theoy, dk enegy hs some entnglement entopy ssocited with it. Byonic mtte displces dk enegy, nd, due to the volume lw contibution to entopy, this cuses n elstic esponse foce on the mtte. This mnifests itself s n ext gvittionl foce ound mssive objects. Velinde 6 uses this elstic esponse foce nstz to poduce n eqution fo the ppent dk mtte given some byonic mss distibution. In the limit of point-souce mss, the eqution fo the ppent DM in EG conveges to the wek limit eqution fom Modified Newtonin Gvity MOND Milgom 983. Thus, Velinde 6 mnges to deive the Tully-Fische eltion within his theoy using no fee pmetes, nd diectly connects the MOND cceletion,, to the enegy density in dk enegy. Howeve, EG in its cuent fomultion only pplies to the cuent, desitte-like Univese. In ddition, the equtions given in Velinde 6 e only vlid fo spheiclly symmetic, isolted systems. Nonetheless, thee hve been sevel tests of this theoy. Bouwe et l. 6 studied the wek lensing of glxy clustes, nd found it to be consistent with EG. Ettoi et l. 6 found EG to gee with two lge, oughly spheicl glxy clustes, nd Diez-Tejedo et l. 6 lso found geement with the mss-to-light tios of the clssicl dwf spheoidl stellite glxies. Sevel studies clim tht EG is inconsistent with obsevtions: the initil mss functions of mssive ely-type glxies Toto et l. 7, the dil cceletion within the inne egions of spil glxies Lelli et l. 7, nd the peiheli of Sol system plnets Hees et l. 7. Howeve, ll of these tests ttempt to pply EG outside of the cuently now egime whee it mkes obust pedictions: spheiclly symmetic, isolted systems in the neby Univese. In this ppe, I conside EG s pedictions fo the velocities within isolted, spheicl dwf glxies nd compe these to obsevtions. These systems fulfill ll of the equiements of the cuent fomultion of EG, nd thus povide the stongest constints on EG. I deive the equtions fo specific extended mss distibution, depojected Sésic pofile, nd the coesponding ppent dk mtte pedicted fom EG in Section. In Section 3, I descibe how I pply these equtions to isolted, spheicl dwf glxies, nd the dt tht I employ. I compe EG s pedictions fo the velocities ound isolted dwf glxies to those mesued in ecent cm study Bdfod et l. 5 in Section 4. I discuss these esults nd conclude in Section 5. kpdo@sto.pinceton.edu

2 . APPARENT DM DISTRIBUTION PREDICTIONS FROM EG FOR A REALISTIC BARYONIC MASS DISTRIBUTION My gol is to descibe the velocity cuve of n extended mss distibution in EG. Consevtion of enegy tells us tht the cicul velocity, v, is given by GMD + M B v = ± whee is the dius fom the cente of the mss distibution nd M B is the byonic mss s function of dius. Fo stndd GR, M D is the dk mtte distibution. In EG, M D is the effective mss, o ppent DM distibution. Hee I deive the ppent dk mtte distibution pedicted by EG due to elistic byonic mss distibution within n isolted, spheicl distibution. Fo spheiclly symmetic, isolted system, the ppent DM pedicted by EG Velinde 6 is GMD d = 6 M B, whee G is the noml gvittionl constnt, nd = ch. By tking the deivtive of both sides with espect to, we find n eqution fo M D, MD = d M B. 3 6G d Note tht if we llow M B to be point-mss, then M D = 6G M B, which would give gvittionl cceletion of g D = GM D = 6 g B. 4 This is just the MOND cceletion in the wek-field limit Milgom 983 with M = 6. I only include this s n side dwf glxies e of couse not descibble s point-msses. Insted, let us conside n extended mss distibution. In pticul, I will employ depojected Sésic pofile. These pofiles fit the stell light of glxies well, nd since I m ssuming thee is no dk mtte, this should lso be good mesue of the mss. The Sésic pofile of glxy is given by ] /n [ b n RRe IR = I e exp, 5 whee I e nd R e e the intensity nd pojected dius t the hlf-light slice, espectively, nd n is the so-clled Sésic index, which is mesue of the concenttion of the light bout the cente. The constnt b n is given such tht Γn = γn, b n, 6 whee Γ is the complete gmm function nd γ, x is the lowe incomplete gmm function. To give the mss pofile, we must fist depoject the Sésic pofile to give the luminosity density. Assuming spheicl symmety, we cn then integte in the ngul diections to give the dil luminosity pofile. Mzue & Cpelto fist found the exct solution fo the dil luminosity pofile given genel Sésic pofile, nd I use thei esults hee. Since I m ssuming tht thee is no dk mtte, I just sy tht the mss follows the light. Then, the stell mss pofile should be the sme s the luminosity pofile except fo some scling fcto, the byonic mssto-light tio, Υ. This tio, long with the effective intensity simply give the nomliztion of the function, nd thus I let Σ = I e Υ, whee my pocess fo setting this nomliztion constnt is given in Section 3.. The finl eqution fo the mss pofile is n+ M =πc ΣRe n R e G n, {,n+ c n R e {β s }, {, n+ n } 7 whee G m,n p,q z,..., p is the Meije G function b,..., b q descibed in Appendix A., nd the constnts c, c, nd β s e given by c b n expb n π n 8 n n bn c 9 n { } j j β s ;. n j n n n+ j n Then, the ppent DM pedicted by EG due to this elistic mss distibution is given exctly by MD = π c ΣRe n+ n 3G R e [ G n, {,n+ c n R e {β s }, { n+ n } ] + G n, {} {},n c. R e {β s } {} Fo detiled desciption of my methods, see Appendix A. 3. MODELING ISOLATED DWARF GALAXY ROTATION CURVES WITH EG In this section, I pply my equtions fom Section to el isolted dwf glxies. Fist, I descibe the exct equtions I employ, nd then I discuss the dt. I choose glxies with pojected shpes close to cicul, nd ssume tht they e nely spheicl.

3 3.. Theoy in ech glxy is tken to be the inclintion-coected Isolted dwf glxies contin significnt mount of velocity width of the cm line t % pek flux. HI gs tht often exceeds the mount of stell mss in Hee, I begin with the full Bdfod et l. 5 smple the glxy Geh et l. 6. This HI gs in dwf glxies typiclly extends f beyond the stell disk Boeils this smple, I use the NSA ctlog to select ll glx- of 546 isolted dwf glxies M < 9.5 M. Fom & Rhee 997. Thus, I must include the mss pofiles of ies with n ppent xis tio, b/, gete thn.75, both the stell mss nd the HI gs mss to popely which is compble to the xis tio of the clssicl model the byonic content of these glxies. dwf spheoidl glxy Fonx. This ensues oughly I model the stlight pofile s Sésic pofile with spheicl glxies, which is necessy fo the cuent fomultion of EG. My finl smple consists of 8 isolted, index, n. I model the HI mss pofile s n exponentil disk Sésic pofile with n =. This gives nely spheicl dwf glxies. The medin ppent xis tio fo my smple is b/ =.85. n+ M =πc Σ R n Fo ech of the glxies in my smple, I use the NSA R ctlog Sésic fit vlues fo n, R, nd M, nd I use G n, { the Bdfod et l. 5 vlues fo the HI mss nd,n+ c n R {β s }, { the mesued mximum cicul velocities. The medin n+ n } msses e M = M nd M HI = M, the medin Sésic index is n =., nd medin M HI =πc Σ HI RHI stell effective dius is R =.56 kpc. The medin R HI G, { mximum cicul velocity is v mx = 8 km/s. I do not hve diect obsevtions of the nomliztion,3 c R HI {, }, { constnts, Σ 3 nd Σ HI, nd the effective dius of the HI } gs, R HI. Insted I must infe them fom othe quntities. I set ech nomliztion constnt by ssuming tht MD, = π c Σ R n+ n hlf of the espective mesued mss is contined within 3G R [ G n, { the effective dius. In othe wods, I use M = R =,n+ c n R {β s }, { M,mes / nd M HI = R HI = M HI,mes /, whee the n+ n } left hnd sides e given by my Equtions 7 & nd ] the ight hnd sides e given by the mesued vlues. + G n, {} {} To set the effective dius of the HI gs, I employ the,n c R {β s } {} esults fom study of the HI content of spil nd iegul glxies which found tht log 3 M HI is linely MD,HI = π c Σ HI RHI coelted with the effective dius of the HI gs disk 3G R HI Boeils & Rhee 997. I e-fit the dt fom this ppe [ G, { see Appendix B nd find,3 c R HI {, }, { 3 } log R HI =.48 ±. log M HI 3.5 ±.6, ] 3 + G, {} {} whee M HI is given in sol msses, nd R HI is given in, c. R HI {, } {} kpc. I then find pobbility distibution fo R HI given M HI nd the eo on this mss gin, see Appendix B fo moe on this pocedue. The vlues fo R whee R is the stell effective dius, R HI is the HI HI e given by the expected vlues of ech pobbility distibution, scle length, Σ is the nomliztion constnt fo the nd the eos e given by the stndd devitions. stell content, nd Σ HI is the nomliztion fo the HI gs content. 4. RESULTS 3.. Dt My smple is bsed on the Bdfod et l. 5 smple of isolted dwf glxies in SDSS DR 8. They choose ll glxies within the NASA Slon Atls NSA ctlog Blnton et l. tht hve z >. nd M < 7.7. They then select ccoding to n isoltion citei: fo stell mss M < 9.5 M, glxy is isolted if d host >.5 Mpc. Fo ech of these glxies, Bdfod et l. 5 mesue the cm pek flux nd line width. The HI gs msses e clculted fom the pek fluxes, nd the infeed mximum cicul velocity Hee I pesent the velocity cuves pedicted by EG, s well s compison of the pedicted mximum cicul velocities fom EG to those mesued in Bdfod et l. 5. Fist, I will look t the velocity cuve fo smple dwf glxy with the medin vlues fom the dt descibed in Section 3.. I solve fo the stell contibution using the medin vlues fom my dt of R =.56 kpc Note tht eqution in Boeils & Rhee 997 ctully gives the HI mss in tems of the dimete of the opticl disk, D b,i 5. Howeve, they note tht the dius of the opticl disk is lmost exctly coelted with the effective dius of the HI disk. Thus, I simply eplce D b,i 5 with R HI hee. 3

4 4 nd n =.. As descibed in the pevious section, I clculte the nomliztion, Σ, by solving Eqution 5 t the effective dius ssuming tht the mss contined within the effective dius is hlf of the medin mesued stell mss M = M. This gives Σ =. M cm. Now, I solve fo the constnts descibing the gs mss contibution. The medin gs mss is M HI = M. I find medin gs effective dius of R HI = 7.4 kpc by using the pocedue outlined in the pevious section. As in the stell cse, I ssume tht hlf of the gs mss is concentted within the effective dius, nd then solve Eqution fo the nomliztion, which gives Σ HI =.5 3 M cm. The pedicted velocity cuve fom EG is given s the blue, solid cuve in Figue. Fo compison, I lso include the pediction fom Newtonin gvity ssuming only byonic mtte, which is given by the gey line. The medin mesued mximum velocity fom Bdfod et l. 5 is given by the ed, dshed line, s efeence. Note tht the mximum occus t pc. This is mny times the effective dius of the stell content. Howeve, it is.7r HI. Thus, it is cle tht the HI gs is the min dive behind the shpe of the velocity cuve, which gees with the lge gs fctions tht e obseved in these glxies. Cicul Velocity [km/s] EG Newtonin Medin Mesued Mximum Velocity Rdius [kpc] Figue. Cicul Velocity s Function of Rdius fo n Isolted, Spheicl Dwf Glxy. The blue line gives the pediction fom EG see Equtions 7, &. The ed, dshed line gives the medin mesued mximum velocity fom Bdfod et l. 5. I include the Newtonin pediction i.e. ssuming thee is only byonic mss nd Newtonin gvity s the gey cuve. In Figue, I plot the estimted mximum cicul velocity fom EG vesus the mesued mximum cicul velocities fom Bdfod et l. 5. If the theoy nd obsevtions wee pefect, then ll of the points would lie on the line y = x blck line. While this seems to be esonble fit fo those glxies with mesued Pedicted Velocity [km/s] Expected Fit Best Fit 3 Mesued Velocity [km/s] Figue. Pedicted Mximum Cicul Velocity fom EG vesus Mesued Mximum Cicul Velocities fo Isolted, Spheicl Dwf Glxies. The blck line gives the cse if thee ws pefect geement with the mesuements. The ed line gives the best fit to the dt. velocities 5 km/s, this is not the cse fo those bove this velocity. The mesued velocities ech 8 km/s, but none of the pedicted velocities e gete thn 65 km/s. I fit best fit line to the dt using Mkov chin Monte Clo MCMC outine. The best fit slope is m = nd the best fit intecept is b = The posteios fo these pmetes e shown in Fig. 3, whee the ed lines give the vlues fo the pefect pediction cse i.e. m =, b =. Note tht this lies well outside of the 3σ contous of the D posteio distibution. It is cle tht the pedicted velocities do not povide good desciption of the mesued velocities. The devition fom this pefect pediction line is even moe stiking fo binned dt. Figue 4 gives the invese-vince veged estimted mximum cicul velocity fom EG vesus the mesued mximum cicul velocities fom Bdfod et l. 5 in five bins. Ech bin hs ppoximtely the sme numbe of glxies. As cn be seen, the lst bin, v > 65 km/s, devites shply fom the y = x line. Tble gives moe infomtion on the glxies in this bin. It should be noted tht the no coeltion cse i.e. m = is lso stongly disfvoed by the dt. Howeve, consideing tht the equtions fo the pedicted velocities do include tems tht elte to the diectly mesued byonic msses, it is not supising tht thee is some degee of coeltion hee DISCUSSION & CONCLUSIONS In this ppe, I develop equtions fo EG s velocity cuve pedictions bsed on elistic byonic mss pofile. I then extend this to isolted, spheicl dwf glxies. These glxies contin lge mounts of HI gs, which must be teted septely fom the stell mss MHI/Mbyon

5 5 b 4 m = m. b = Figue 3. Posteio Distibutions fo the Best Fit Pmetes to the Velocity Dt. m is the slope of the line, nd b is the intecept. The blck dshed lines give the 6, 5, nd 84 pecentile loctions, nd the ed lines give the expected vlues if the theoy geed pefectly well with the dt i.e. line with slope of nd intecept of. Note tht this combintion of expected vlues is well outside the 3σ contous of the posteio distibution. Pedicted Velocity [km/s] Oiginl Bdfod 5 dt Tubulence Coected Dt Mesued Velocity [km/s] Figue 4. Invese-vince Aveged Estimted Mximum Cicul Velocity fom EG Vesus Mesued Mximum Cicul Velocities fom Bdfod et l. 5. The blck points give the oiginl velocities fom Bdfod et l. 5, nd the blue points give the tubulence coected velocities. The blck line gives the cse if thee ws pefect geement with the mesuements. Note tht the lst bin in both cses devites significntly fom this line. b Finlly, I compe these pedictions of EG vesus the HI -cm line width mesuements fom Bdfod et l. 5 fo 8 isolted, nely spheicl dwf glxies. As I show in the esults section, the pedicted velocities fom EG do not gee with the mesued velocities, especilly in the highest velocity bin. Inteestingly, lmost ll of the systems in this highest velocity bin hve much highe HI gs msses thn stell msses. Although it is not the cse tht ll systems with high HI gs mss fctions devite significntly fom the EG pedictions. Thee e fou possible explntions fo this discepncy between theoy nd dt: the % line width mesuements of the HI gs do not give the tue mximum cicul velocity; the eos fo eithe the mesuements o the theoy e too smll; 3 I hve not coectly modeled the byonic mtte distibution in these glxies; 4 EG does not popely explin the ottion cuves of these glxies. Below, I will discuss ech of these in tun. % HI line widths It is possible tht the % HI line widths e not good mesue of the ctul mximum cicul velocity. Bdfod et l. 6 give nice commenty on this issue. Although some pefe to use the 5% line widths insted, Bdfod et l. 6 gue tht the % line widths e moe esistnt to noise fetues nd tend to decese the esiduls in the low-mss end of the Byonic Tully- Fishe Reltionship. Using the 5% line widths would lowe the mesued velocities by km/s. Howeve, n even lge effect comes fom pplying tubulence coections. I cn nlyze this effect by using Eqution 6 fom Tchtench et l. 9 s my tubulence coection. This tends to lowe the mesued velocities by km/s. The blue points in Figue 4 give the esults fo this tubulence-coected dt. It is cle tht the pedicted velocities fo the lst bin e still too low. Eos It could lso be the cse tht I m unde-pedicting the eo in the dt nd the pedictions. I pplied n MCMC outine to solve fo the eo in eithe the pedicted o mesued velocities tht would minimize χ. I found tht medin vlue of σ v = 38 km/s would need to be dded to the mesued velocities, nd σ v = 6 km/s would need to be dded to the pedicted velocities to minimize χ. Howeve, even when I ccount fo these ext eos on both of these quntities, I still obtin significnt devition fom the mesued velocities in my lst bin. 3 Modeling of the Byonic Distibution Thee e mny ssumptions mde when modeling the byonic gs mss, nd it is entiely possible tht ny of these could be incoect. Pehps the most eo-pone methods e the use of n exponentil distibution fo the HI gs nd my pticul nomliztion outine fo ech of the pofiles. To model the HI gs pofile, I ssume tht the sufce bightness pofile is well ppoximted by n exponen-

6 6 til pofile. Consideing tht the medin Sésic index fo these glxies is n =. nd I do not expect the gs to be concentted significntly diffeently fom the sts, using n exponentil pofile seems esonble. This could be incoect, howeve. In ode to decese the mximum velocities, I would need to decese the Sésic index used i.e. decese the concenttion of the light t the cente. Howeve, this poduces negligible chnge in the pedicted ottion cuves. As I descibe in Section 3., I nomlize the mss distibution functions by ssuming tht hlf of the mss is contined within the effective dius. This nomliztion outine fo ech of the pofiles is somewht bity, nd it does hve lge effect on the finl pedicted ottion cuves. Thus, this seems to be the most likely plce whee n eo hs occued. Without mesued ottion cuves o integl field dt, howeve, it is difficult to set the nomliztions in moe ccute fshion. 4 Emegent Gvity Finlly, it is possible tht EG does not popely descibe these systems. It is cuently still n incomplete theoy - thee is no cosmology ssocited with it, nd it only pplies in this vey specific instnce of n isolted, spheicl mss distibution in desitte-like Univese. It seems tht we cn sfely ule out esons nd s being the pedominnt effect hee. Howeve, without full ottion cuves we cnnot give definitive nswe between the finl two choices. Specificlly, the shpes of the ottion cuves nd loctions of the mximums would llow us to mke this distinction. In conclusion, I find significnt discepncy between the pedicted mximum cicul velocities fom EG nd the mesued mximum cicul velocities ound isolted, nely spheicl dwf glxies. We need ottion cuves of these glxies to identify if this discepncy is due to my nomliztion pocedue o the inbility of EG to descibe these systems. Given tht EG is only equipped to hndle systems of this type, howeve, it seems tht these discepncies should be tken seiously s possible issue with the theoy. The next step is to obtin ottion cuves of these isolted, spheicl dwf glxies with high HI gs fctions. This would povide the best test of EG t this time. The utho would like to thnk Dvid Spegel fo his help nd dvice on this poject. The utho would lso like to thnk Jeemy Bdfod, Eik Velinde, Emmnuel Schn, Adin Pice-Wheln, Andy Goulding, nd Michel Stuss fo helpful discussions. The utho cknowledges suppot fom the Ntionl Science Foundtion Gdute Resech Fellowship Pogm. Any opinions, findings, nd conclusions o ecommendtions expessed in this mteil e those of the uthos nd do not necessily eflect the views of the Ntionl Science Foundtion. REFERENCES Binney, J., & Temine, S. 8, Glctic Dynmics: Second Edition, by Jmes Binney nd Scott Temine. ISBN HB. Published by Pinceton Univesity Pess, Pinceton, NJ USA, 8., Blnton, M. R., Kzin, E., Mun, D., Weve, B. A., & Pice-Wheln, A., AJ, 4, 3 Bdfod, J. D., Geh, M. C., & Blnton, M. R. 5, ApJ, 89, 46 Bdfod, J. D., Geh, M. C., & vn den Bosch, F. C. 6, ApJ, 83, Boeils, A. H., & Rhee, M.-H. 997, A&A, 34, 877 Bouwe, M. M., Visse, M. R., Dvonik, A., et l. 6, Xiv:6.334 Diez-Tejedo, A., Gonzlez-Moles, A. X., & Niz, G. 6, Xiv:6.68 Fn, J., Ktz, A., Rndll, L., & Reece, M. 3, Physicl Review Lettes,, 3 Foemn-Mckey, D., Hogg, D. W., Lng, D., & Goodmn, J. 3, PASP, 5, 36 Eisenstein, D. J., Zehvi, I., Hogg, D. W., et l. 5, ApJ, 633, 56 Ettoi, S., Ghidini, V., Ecket, D., Dubth, F., & Pointecouteu, E. 6, Xiv:6.788 Geh, M., Blnton, M. R., Msjedi, M., & West, A. A. 6, ApJ, 653, 4 Gehd, O. E., & Spegel, D. N. 99, ApJ, 397, 38 Hees, A., Fmey, B., & Betone, G. 7, Xiv: Lelli, F., McGugh, S. S., & Schombet, J. M. 7, Xiv: Mzue, A., & Cpelto, H. V., A&A, 383, 384 Milgom, M. 983, ApJ, 7, 365 Plnck Collbotion, Adm, R., Ade, P. A. R., et l. 6, A&A, 594, A Rubin, V. C., Fod, W. K., J., & Thonnd, N. 98, ApJ, 38, 47 Toto, C., Koopmns, L. V. E., & Npolitno, N. R., Xiv: Tchtench, C., de Blok, W. J. G., McGugh, S. S., vn de Hulst, J. M., & Dettm, R.-J. 9, A&A, 55, 577 Velinde, E. P. 6, Xiv:6.69 Zwicky, F. 933, Helvetic Physic Act, 6,

7 7 NSA ID RA deg DEC deg M M M HI M R e kpc R HI kpc v mes km/s v ped km/s Sesic Index n Tble. Popeties of Isolted Dwf Glxies with Mesued Velocities Gete thn 65 km/s. These e the glxies in the lst bin of Figue 4. The Columns e: the NASA Slon Atls NSA identifiction numbe; Right Ascension RA; 3 Declintion DEC; 4 Stell Mss, s given by the NSA ctlog; 5 HI Mss, s given by Bdfod et l. 5; 6 Effective Stell Rdius, s given by the NSA ctlog; 7 Effective HI Rdius, s clculted in this wok; 8 Mesued mximum velocity, s given by Bdfod et l. 5; 9 Pedicted Mximum Velocity, s clculted in this wok; Sésic Index, s given by the NSA ctlog.

8 8 APPENDIX A. FINDING THE APPARENT DM PREDICTED FROM EG WITH A DEPROJECTED SÉRSIC PROFILE A.. The Sésic Pofile Fist, I epet the equtions descibing the Sésic pofile ] /n [ b n RRe IR = I e exp, A Γn = γn, b n. A Note tht IR nd R e pojected quntities. They do not give the 3D, physicl dius o intensity. To find the physicl luminosity nd then the physicl mss, we must depoject the Sésic pofile. I begin by elting the intensity, IR, to the luminosity density, n, IR = dz n, whee I ssume the luminosity density is symmetic in z. Note tht is the dius in spheicl coodintes nd R is the pojected dius i.e. the dius in cylindicl coodintes. Now, we cn chnge vibles using = R + z. This gives IR = R n R d. I find n by inveting Eqution A4 using the Abel Identity cf. Appendix B.5 of Binney & Temine 8 n = π di dr dr R This is unsolvble fo geneic IR. Howeve, the nlytic solution to this integl fo the IR given in Eqution A cn be expessed in tems of Meije G functions Mzue & Cpelto. A.. The Meije G functions The Meije G functions see nd http: //dlmf.nist.gov/6 fo moe fomule involving the Meije G functions e genelized hypegeometic functions tht give most of the specil functions we know i.e. tigonometic functions, Bessel functions, exponentil function, etc. s specil cses. The Stndd Meije G function is defined s G m,n p,q z,..., p b,..., b q = πi L m k= Γs + b k n p k=n+ Γs + k q k= Γ k s k=m+ Γ b k s z s ds A3 A4 A5 A6 A few useful identities of the Meije G functions e [fom DLMF] G m,n p,q z,..., p z c G m,n p,q z + c,..., p + c b,..., b q b + c,..., b q + c G m,n,..., p p,q G n,m b q,p z,..., b q z b,..., b q,..., p G m,n p,q z,..., p G m,n+ p+,q+ z,,..., p b,..., b q b,..., b q, The deivtive of the Meije G function leds to nothe Meije G function [fom Wolfm Functions] G m,n p,q z,..., p b,..., b q = G m,n+, p+,q+ z,..., n, n+,..., p z b, b m,, b m+,..., b q A7 A8 A9 A

9 By combining Equtions A & A7, I find the following useful fomul z G m,n p,q z,..., p b,..., b q = z G m,n p,q z z,,..., p b,..., b q 9. A By diffeentiting the left side of Eqution A, I find z z Gm,n p,q z,..., p = G m,n p,q z,,..., p b,..., b q b,..., b q + G m,n p,q z,..., p b,..., b q. A A.3. The Rdil Mss Pofile Hee I will give the dil mss pofile fo geneic Sésic pofile following the tetment of Mzue & Cpelto. This is esily modified to give eithe the stell o HI mss pofiles using the coect n, R e, nd Σ. Define the Sésic pofile in tems of dimensionless quntities x R e s R e A3 A4 ix = IR = exp[ b n x /n ] A5 I e νs = n R e I e = π Then, the depojected dil luminosity pofile is given by Ls = 4π s s di dx x s dx. s νs ds. Since I m ssuming tht the mss follows the light, the dil mss pofile is Eqution A7 times the mss-to-light tio, Υ, Ms = 4πΥ s s νs ds. Mzue & Cpelto find tht the nlytic solution to this integl fo Sésic pofile is Ms = πυc s n+ n G n,,n+ c s { n {β s }, {, A9 n+ n } whee A6 A7 A8 c b n exp[b n ] π n A n n bn c A n { } j j β s ;. A n j n n n+ j n A.4. EG Pedictions To give vlues pedicted by EG, I must find dm d. Fist, I diffeentite Eqution A9 using Eqution A, which gives dm ds = 4πΥc s n+ n G n,,n c s {} {}. A3 {β s } {} Now, I need to expess dm/ds nd Ms in tems of insted. This is done using the definition fo s given in Eqution A3 nd ccounting fo the ext fcto of /R e fom the chnge of vible in the deivtive. Howeve, I lso need

10 to ccount fo how I begn with dimensionless luminosity density by multiplying both dm/ds nd Ms by I e Re. Then, n+ M = πc ΣRe n G n, {,n+ c n R e R e {β s }, {, n+ n } n+ dm d = 4πc n ΣR e G n, {} {},n c, R e R e {β s } {} MD = π c ΣRe n+ [ n G n, { ],n+ c n 3G R e Re {β s }, { + G n, {} {} n+,n c, n } Re {β s } {} whee Σ = I e Υ. B. ERROR ANALYSIS Fo the most pt, I popgte eos nomlly i.e. ssuming tht they e independent nd ech of the quntities e Gussin. Howeve, thee is no given eo fo R HI. I would like to clculte R HI given the Boeils & Rhee 997 eltion. Thee is no detiled explntion of how Boeils & Rhee 997 fit thei dt, nd it is not cle how they clculte thei eo. Thus, I must e-fit the eltion nd clculte the eo, which I do by employing the Mkov Chin Monte Clo MCMC technique. I would like the opticl dimete, D, fo ech glxy given the HI mss in ech glxy emembe: the opticl dius is lmost exctly coelted with the effective dius of the HI gs disk. I ssume tht the dt cn be fit by stight line in log-spce. Then, I wnt to find, b such tht log D = log M HI + b. Note tht Boeils & Rhee 997 give no mesuement eos in thei ppe. Thus, I must fit fo the vince of the points s well. Then, the log-likelihood is given by ln L = D ˆD + ln πv, B V whee ˆD is the tue dimete, nd V is the vince. The pios fo the pmetes e ll flt pios ove some lge nge. Note tht I use logithmic pio fo V, nd thus, I fit fo ln V. I use the python pckge emcee 3 Foemn-Mckey et l. 3 to find the posteio distibution, nd the mginlized pobbilities fo, b, ln V. Fom this, I find =.48 ±. b = 3.5 ±.6 ln V = 4.6 ±.4 Now I hve pd ˆM,, b, V nd smples in, b, V. I wnt pd M, σ M, which cn be found by mginlizing ove ll of the othe pmetes pd M, σ M = pd, ˆM,, b, V M, σ M d ˆMd db dv = pd ˆM,, b, V p ˆM M, σ M p, b, V I d ˆMd db dv, whee I is the pio infomtion i.e. Boeils & Rhee 997 nd ˆM is the tue HI mss. The fist pobbility, pd ˆM,, b, V, is given by log -noml pobbility [ ] pd ˆM, log, b, V = log N D log ˆM + b, V = e D πv exp log D log ˆM + b. B8 V I ssume tht the second pobbility, p ˆM M, σ M, is Gussin, 3 B B3 B4 B5 B6 B7 p ˆM M, σ M = N ˆM M, σ M. B9

11 The thid pobbility, p, b, V I, is given by the MCMC chins tht I n peviously. If I combine the fist two pobbilities, I find pd, b, V = pd ˆM,, b, V p ˆM M, σ M d ˆM, B which is done fo fixed, b, V. This integl cn be clculted numeiclly. Then, to find pd M, σ M, I employ Monte Clo integtion. Tht is, I clculte pd M, σ M N N pd k, b k, V k fo the MCMC chin I found peviously. Howeve, I cnnot use the entie chin: MCMC chins e utocoelted. Fo only 3 pmetes, this uto coeltion length is less thn time steps. Thus, I evlute Eqution B t ech z th step of the chin, whee z. To find the pdf, I evlute pd M, σ M fo n y of D vlues. I set this y by finding the best guess fo the ctul vlue, D guess, i.e. I evlute Eqution B using the medin vlues of, b I found bove nd then setting the minimum nd mximum D vlues to be D guess / wy fom it. The vlue of D nd its eo tht I use fo ech glxy e given by the expected vlue nd stndd devition of ech distibution. Finlly, R HI = D/. k B