Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 1 of 17

Transcription

1 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 1 of 17

2 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 2 of 17

3 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 3 of 17

4 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 4 of 17

5 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 5 of 17

6 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 6 of 17

7 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 7 of 17

8 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 8 of 17

9 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 9 of 17

10 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 10 of 17

11 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 11 of 17

12 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 12 of 17

13 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 13 of 17

14 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 14 of 17

15 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 15 of 17

16 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 16 of 17

17 Case KG Doc 3336 Filed 12/08/17 Page 17 of 17

18 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 1 of 3

19 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 2 of 3

20 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 3 of 3

21 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 1 of 202 EXHIBIT A

22 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 2 of 202 BJS : Derivative Causes of Action Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP 919 North Market Street 17th Floor Wilmington, DE Invoice Client Matter BJS STATEMENT OF PROFESSIONAL SERVICES NDED THROUGH 10/31/2017 FEES $1,231, EXPENSES $44, TOTAL CURNT CHARGES $1,276, BALANCE FORWARD $3,959, TOTAL BALANCE DUE $5,236,174.79

23 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 3 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 2 Summary of Services by Task Code Task Code Description Hours Amount BL Bankruptcy Litigation [L430] $1,179, CA Case Administration [B110] 2.40 $ FN Financing [B230] 0.20 $ TR Travel $51, $1,231, Summary of Services by Professional ID Name Title Rate Hours Amount AJK Kornfeld, Alan J. Partner $241, ARP Paul, Andrea R. Case Man. Asst $6, BEL Levine, Beth E. Counsel $116, BJS Sandler, Bradford J. Partner $ CJB Bouzoukis, Charles J. Case Man. Asst $3, CRR Robinson, Colin R. Counsel $115, EG Gray, Erin Counsel $14, JAM Morris, John A. Partner $276, JHR Rosell, Jason H. Counsel $ JJK Kim, Jonathan J. Counsel $19, JKH Hunter, James K. T. Counsel $1, JNP Pomerantz, Jeffrey N. Partner $ JSP Pomerantz, Jason S. Counsel $43, KSN Neil, Karen S. Case Man. Asst $4, LAF Forrester, Leslie A. Other $1, LCT Thomas, Elizabeth C. Paralegal $2, MB Bove, Maria A. Counsel $97, PJJ Jeffries, Patricia J. Paralegal $65, PJK Keane, Peter J. Associate $6, RJF Feinstein, Robert J. Partner $104, SJK Kahn, Steven J. Counsel $47, SLH Hazan, Scott L. Partner $ SLP Pitman, L. Sheryle Case Man. Asst $4, SWG Golden, Steven W. Associate $53,595.00

24 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 4 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 3 TPC Cairns, Timothy P. Partner $5, $1,231, Summary of Expenses Description Air Fare [E110] Amount $2, Advita Atty Mess Service $3, Auto Travel Expense [E109] $1, Working Meals [E111] $ Conference Call [E105] $1, Federal Express [E108] $ Hotel Expense [E110] $13, Lexis/Nexis- Legal Research [E $ Pacer - Court Research $ Reproduction Expense [E101] $8,031.80

25 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 5 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 4 Summary of Expenses Description Reproduction/ Scan Copy Amount $11, Travel Expense [E110] $2, $44,745.77

26 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 6 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 5 Bankruptcy Litigation [L430] Hours Rate Amount 10/01/2017 JAM BL Work on pre-trial brief $1, /02/2017 RJF BL Office conferences with John A. Morris, Maria Bove $ regarding pretrial brief. 10/02/2017 RJF BL Research regarding pretrial brief $1, /02/2017 RJF BL Trial prep $1, /02/2017 JJK BL s Morris on designations, counterdesignations, 0.50 related issues, and consider same $ /02/2017 PJJ BL Telephone call with B. Levine and J. Morris re trial 0.50 exhibits $ /02/2017 SJK BL Review memorandum from John A. Morris 0.10 regarding trial preparation $ /02/2017 BEL BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris and P $ Jeffries regarding trial prep. 10/02/2017 BEL BL Deposition digests $2, /02/2017 BEL BL Trial preparation $1, /02/2017 MB BL Research for pretrial brief $5, /02/2017 MB BL Office conference with R. Feinstein and J. Morris re 0.50 pretrial brief outline $ /02/2017 JAM BL Telephone conference with P. Jeffries, B. Levine re $12, exhibits, deposition designations (.4); telephone conference with J. Dutton re Haggen value, damages (.6); meet with R. Feinstein, M. Bove re pre-trial brief (.4); communications with R. Feinstein re settlement, pre-trial brief (.3); to PSZJ team re exhibits and deposition designations (.3); s with J. Dutton re Comvest equity investment, damages (.4); work on pre-trial brief (10.3). 10/02/2017 JHR BL Correspondence with J. Howard re: transcript $ /02/2017 CRR BL Review re updates to pretrial schedule $ /02/2017 SWG BL Transmit documents to J. Morris for trial $ /02/2017 JSP BL Assist with trial preparation; review part of depo 2.70 transcript; confer with J. Morris, B. Sandler and $2, others; review correspondence and other documents 10/03/2017 JNP BL Conference with Robert J. Feinstein regarding $ settlement. 10/03/2017 RJF BL Work on pretrial brief and trial prep $3, /03/2017 JJK BL s Morris on designations/counterdesignations, etc. (0.2); review transcripts in connection and prepare notes (9.1) $6,975.00

27 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 7 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 6 Hours Rate Amount 10/03/2017 PJJ BL Conference call with PSZJ team and K&E re exhibits and deposition designation logistics $ /03/2017 SJK BL Review memorandum from John A. Morris 0.10 regarding objection/counterdesignation assignments $ /03/2017 SJK BL Identify and assemble non-sjk designated transcripts and begin initial review $ /03/2017 BEL BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris, P Jeffries and defendants' counsel regarding trial prep $ /03/2017 BEL BL Review draft trial brief $ /03/2017 BEL BL Confer with John A. Morris regarding draft trial $ brief. 10/03/2017 BEL BL Digest deposition $3, /03/2017 BEL BL Trial prep $ /03/2017 MB BL Research for pretrial brief $3, /03/2017 MB BL Draft pretrial brief $3, /03/2017 JAM BL Communications with R. Howell re scheduling matters (.2); telephone conference with B. Levine, $9, Kirkland re exhibits, deposition designations (.4); to R. Feinstein, B. Sandler re scheduling (.1); work on pre-trial brief (9.0); communications to PSZJ team re deposition designations (.5); communications with experts re trial preparation (.2). 10/03/2017 CRR BL , telephone call with parties, chambers re page limitations on pretrial briefing $ /03/2017 CRR BL Review rules, chambers procedures and prepare, 0.80 send to J Morris re length of briefs $ /03/2017 CRR BL Telephone call with Defendants counsel re exhibit and deposition logistics $ /03/2017 SWG BL Annotate Garris on deposition and complete depo 2.20 digest $ /03/2017 CRR BL Review agenda prepared by Debtors $ /04/2017 AJK BL Review summary judgment order and s re $ same. 10/04/2017 RJF BL Work on pretrial brief $4, /04/2017 RJF BL s and internal discussions regarding 1.00 settlement $1, /04/2017 RJF BL Review opinion on PSJ motion $ /04/2017 RJF BL s regarding opinion on PSJ motion internally, $ and with UCC. 10/04/2017 KSN BL Prepare hearing binder for 10/6/17 hearing $82.50

28 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 8 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 7 Hours Rate Amount 10/04/2017 PJK BL Review 10/6 agenda $ /04/2017 LCT BL Review and distribute 10/6 hearing agenda and coordinate preparation of hearing binders $ /04/2017 JJK BL Review transcripts/prepare notes for 3.60 counterdesignations $2, /04/2017 JJK BL Conf. call with Morris, et al. on $ designations/counterdesignations issues. 10/04/2017 PJJ BL Update trial exhibit list $ /04/2017 PJJ BL Work on deposition designations $2, /04/2017 SJK BL Assemble additional transcripts for further marking 0.20 for testimony exchange $ /04/2017 SJK BL Review opinion denying motion for partial summary $ judgment. 10/04/2017 SJK BL Review draft (partial) of Trial Brief $ /04/2017 BEL BL Confer with John A. Morris regarding pre-trial brief $ /04/2017 BEL BL Review and comment on pre-trial brief $1, /04/2017 BEL BL Finalize Collison digest $ /04/2017 BEL BL Draft potions of pretrial brief $2, /04/2017 BEL BL Trial prep $ /04/2017 MB BL Draft pretrial brief; research re same; office 2.90 conferences with J. Morris and R. Feinstein re same $2, /04/2017 MB BL Review revised fact portions of pretrial brief $ /04/2017 MB BL Review summary judgment decision $ /04/2017 CJB BL Prepare hearing binder for hearing on 10/6/ $ /04/2017 JAM BL Work on pre-trial brief (8.7); communications with 9.70 R. Feinstein, B. Sandler re pre-trial brief (.3); $9, communications with C. Mackle re pre-trial brief (.2); communications with PSZJ team re decision of MPSJ (.5). 10/04/2017 JHR BL Review opinion re: MSJ $ /04/2017 JHR BL Correspondence with S. Golden and related research re: leases $ /04/2017 PJK BL Review court s opinion regarding summary 0.50 judgment, from Colin R. Robinson regarding $ same, discuss with Colin R. Robinson 10/04/2017 CRR BL Communications w/ defendants, JMorris re extension of time to file pretrial brief $ /04/2017 CRR BL Review Court s decision re defendants motion for 0.40 Partial Summary Judgment $ /04/2017 LCT BL Serve [signed] order denying def. motion in limine $70.00

29 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 9 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 8 Hours Rate Amount (.1); prepare aff of service (.1). 10/04/2017 SWG BL Work to identify and mark exhibits $ /04/2017 SWG BL Review and edit draft of brief $ /04/2017 JSP BL Review designations; prepare for objections and $2, counter-designations; analysis regarding same; confer with B. Sandler regarding various issues 10/05/2017 LAF BL Citecheck & edit pretrial brief $1, /05/2017 AJK BL Attention to trial brief $3, /05/2017 RJF BL s with UCC regarding settlement $ /05/2017 PJJ BL Work on deposition designations $1, /05/2017 PJJ BL PSZJ team conference call re trial prep $ /05/2017 SJK BL Conference call with team regarding review of Defendant deposition designations, objections and counterdesignations $ /05/2017 SJK BL Telephone conference with Jason S Pomerantz 0.10 regarding same $ /05/2017 SJK BL Review portions of revised trial brief; review transcripts for reference; revise portion of brief and send to John A. Morris $1, /05/2017 RJF BL Office conferences with John A. Morris regarding 0.50 trial issues $ /05/2017 RJF BL Internal discussions regarding settlement counteroffer $1, /05/2017 RJF BL Telephone conference with Mazza regarding 0.40 litigation status $ /05/2017 RJF BL Review Zolfo analysis of offer $ /05/2017 RJF BL Telephone conference with Seltzer regarding status $ /05/2017 MB BL Revise pretrial brief $1, /05/2017 MB BL Research for pretrial brief $ /05/2017 MB BL Further revise pretrial brief; office conferences re same $1, /05/2017 JAM BL Telephone conference with R. Howell re pre-trial conference (.3); to PSZJ team re pre-trial $16, conference (.3); telephone conference with A. Kornfeld re status, trial (.1); telephone conference with PSZJ team re deposition objections, counter designations (.5); work on pre-trial brief (16.6). 10/05/2017 SWG BL Call with PSZJ team regarding designations $ /05/2017 SWG BL Edit potential brief $ /05/2017 CRR BL Prepare re final pretrial hearing (.6) and review J Morris re same (.2) $580.00

30 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 10 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 9 Hours Rate Amount 10/05/2017 JSP BL Participate in conference call regarding trial $4, preparation, including objections and counter-designations; review and comment on pre-trial brief; telephone calls and correspondence in connection with same 10/06/2017 AJK BL Review deposition transcripts in preparation for trial $9, /06/2017 JJK BL Review pretrial brief re: issues being researched $ /06/2017 PJJ BL Work on trial exhibit list $1, /06/2017 PJJ BL Telephone call with Trialgraphix re exhibits and $70.00 logistics. 10/06/2017 PJJ BL Review pretrial brief $ /06/2017 RJF BL Prep for final pretrial $1, /06/2017 RJF BL Attend final pretrial $1, /06/2017 RJF BL Initial review of defendants' pretrial brief $ /06/2017 MB BL Revise pretrial brief $3, /06/2017 MB BL Review defendant's pretrial brief $ /06/2017 JAM BL Prepare for court hearing (1.9); court hearing (.8); 7.90 work on pre-trial brief (3.6); telephone conference $7, with A. Kornfeld re trial (.2); to Committee re status (.2); review pre-trial briefs (1.2). 10/06/2017 PJK BL Review pretrial briefs, from Colin R $ Robinson regarding same 10/06/2017 CRR BL Review, finalize pretrial brief and confer with J $2, Morris, M Bove re same 10/06/2017 CRR BL Review Defendants pretrial brief $ /06/2017 CRR BL Review, respond to RFeinstein, EGray re motion to $ shorten, approval of stipulation 10/06/2017 LCT BL Request today's hearing transcript $ /06/2017 LCT BL Serve [signed] final pretrial order (.1); prepare aff of $70.00 service (.1). 10/06/2017 LCT BL Efile and serve sealed plaintiff's pretrial brief (.3); prepare aff of service (.1) $ /06/2017 LCT BL Follow up with Colin R. Robinson re updates with 0.10 respect to certain pretrial deadlines $ /06/2017 SWG BL Prepare trial exhibits $ /06/2017 CRR BL Prepare for, attend final pretrial conference with J $2, Morris, R Feinstein 10/06/2017 JSP BL Assist with trial preparation; review deposition designations and other documents; correspondence in connection with same; confer with B. Sandler regarding trial $4,350.00

31 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 11 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 10 Hours Rate Amount 10/07/2017 AJK BL Continued review of deposition transcripts in $6, preparation for trial. 10/07/2017 PJJ BL Work on trial exhibits $2, /07/2017 RJF BL Review Depo Transcripts $2, /07/2017 RJF BL Review defendants' pretrial brief $1, /07/2017 RJF BL Internal s regarding defendants' brief $ /07/2017 JAM BL Trial preparation (5.7); to PSZJ trial team re $5, defendants' pre-trial brief (.6). 10/07/2017 JSP BL Trial preparation; review pre-trial briefs, $4, designations and prepare for objections and counter-designations 10/08/2017 AJK BL Review exhibits in preparation for trial $9, /08/2017 JJK BL s Morris, Kahn, Golden on designations, etc.; 4.20 review designations, prepare objections and $3, crossdesignations. 10/08/2017 PJJ BL Prepare trial exhibits $6, /08/2017 SJK BL Begin review of Defendant transcript designations $4, and preparation of objections/counter-designations. 10/08/2017 RJF BL s regarding trial prep $ /08/2017 BEL BL Review defendants exhibit lists and other pretrial 1.30 material $ /08/2017 TPC BL Assist with preparation of exhibits for upcoming trial $5, /08/2017 JAM BL to Committee re sealing, trial (.2); telephone 9.20 conference with P. Jeffries, B. Levine re exhibits, $8, deposition designations (.2); to R. Howell, PSZJ re exhibits, deposition designations (.3); s with PSZJ team re demonstratives, Comvest (.5); prepare for trial (3.9); review/designate Clark transcript (1.8); communications with A. Kornfeld, R. Howell re Defendants' deposition designations (.5); communications with P. Jeffries, B. Levine re production of exhibits, exhibit list, deposition designations (1.8). 10/08/2017 SWG BL Prepare objections to counter designations $1, /08/2017 JSP BL Trial preparation; deposition review, objections, 7.40 counter-designations; confer with C. Mackle, S $5, Kahn and others 10/09/2017 AJK BL Call with John and Beth re witnesses and issues $1, /09/2017 AJK BL Review transcripts and exhibits in preparation for $7, trial. 10/09/2017 JJK BL Review designations, prepare objections and crossdesignations; s Morris on same $5,250.00

32 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 12 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 11 Hours Rate Amount 10/09/2017 PJJ BL Work on trial exhibits $3, /09/2017 SJK BL Memoranda to John A. Morris and Alan J. Kornfeld regarding exhibit inclusion $ /09/2017 SJK BL Continue transcript review and preparing 6.50 counter-designations and objections $5, /09/2017 SJK BL Memoranda to and from Patricia Jeffries regarding counter-designations and objections $ /09/2017 SJK BL Memorandum to John A. Morris regarding Ewing 0.10 counter-designations $ /09/2017 SJK BL Proof deposition objections and memorandum to Patricia Jeffries regarding same $ /09/2017 BEL BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris and Alan 1.20 J. Kornfeld regarding trial prep $ /09/2017 BEL BL Confer with John A. Morris regarding objections to $ exhibits. 10/09/2017 BEL BL Review and object to defendants exhibit list $7, /09/2017 BEL BL Trial preparation $ /09/2017 JAM BL Telephone conference with J. Dutton, C. Mackle, S Golden re demonstrative exhibits (.3); telephone $11, conference with C. Mackle re projects (.1); trial preparation (7.8); telephone conference with B. Levine, A. Kornfeld re trial preparation (1.2); meet with S. Golden re trial graphics (2.0); meet with B. Levine re objections to defendants' exhibits (.8). 10/09/2017 CRR BL s to and from J Morris re redactions to pretrial $ briefs 10/09/2017 CRR BL Review and provide objections and counter-designations for Speiser and Ragan deposition transcripts $2, /09/2017 LCT BL Serve [signed] order denying Def. motion for partial 0.20 summary judgment and opinion (.1); prepare aff of $70.00 service (.1). 10/09/2017 SWG BL Prepare objections and counter designations $ /09/2017 SWG BL Call with J. Dutton and John Morris regarding 0.40 exhibits $ /09/2017 SWG BL Prepare demonstratives for trial $ /09/2017 SWG BL Meet with trial slide expert $1, /09/2017 SWG BL Assist in preparation of opening slides $2, /09/2017 CRR BL s to and from chambers, Trial tech support re courtroom technology $ /09/2017 JSP BL Trial preparation; objections and 9.40 counter-designations; confer with C. Mackle, S $7,050.00

33 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 13 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 12 Hours Rate Amount Kahn, P. Jefferies, J. Morris and others 10/10/2017 AJK BL Trial preparation $11, /10/2017 JKH BL Telephone conferences with Cia H. Mackle regarding objection to deposition testimony, exhibit designations, hearsay $1, /10/2017 PJJ BL Prepare exhibits and transcripts for upload to $ TrialWorx in connection with trial preparation. 10/10/2017 PJJ BL Review exhibit list $ /10/2017 PJJ BL Prepare video designations $ /10/2017 RJF BL Review s regarding trial, evidentiary issues $ /10/2017 BEL BL Prepare witness examinations $3, /10/2017 BEL BL Review and analyze objections to plaintiffs' exhibits $3, /10/2017 BEL BL Multiple conferences with John A. Morris regarding $ open issues. 10/10/2017 MB BL Office conference with J. Morris re defendant's $ objection to trial exhibits. 10/10/2017 MB BL Analyze objection to trial exhibits $ /10/2017 MB BL Office conferences with C. Robinson and B. Levine $ re trial preparation. 10/10/2017 MB BL Office conference and s with J. Morris, C $ Robinson and B. Levine re trial preparation. 10/10/2017 JAM BL Telephone conference with R. Miller re Unified documents (.2); meet with D. MacGreevey, J. Dutton, R. Blokh re trial preparation (2.9); review Defendants' objections to exhibits (.7); review defendants' objections and counterdesignations re deposition transcripts (.7); communications with R. Howell re deliverables (.3); trial preparation (7.3); communications with C. Mackle re documents, deposition objections (.4); to J. Lula, R. Howell re confidential documents (.4); s with J. Lula, P. Jeffries re Clark videotape (.2) $12, /10/2017 CRR BL Complete filing of unredacted pretrial brief $ /10/2017 CRR BL Confer with L Thomas re service of Order re $ MPSMJ 10/10/2017 LCT BL Efile aff of service re opinion and order denying $35.00 Def. SJ motion. 10/10/2017 SWG BL Prepare for trial $2, /10/2017 CRR BL Initial review of exhibits for delivery to chambers $4, via hard copy and confer with staff re prepare 10/10/2017 CRR BL Discuss hearing logistics with M Bove, chambers re technology $362.50

34 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 14 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 13 Hours Rate Amount 10/10/2017 JSP BL Assist with trial preparation; review $4, counter-designations, objections and other correspondence/documents; confer with B. Sandler AJK BL Preparation for trial $4, RJF BL Review draft hearing notice and trial agenda $ PJJ BL Pull confidential exhibits $ PJJ BL Review objection to exhibits with B. Levine $70.00 PJJ BL PSZJ team trial prep call $ PJJ BL Review video designations $ PJJ BL Prepare and confidential documents to 1.30 Committee members for review $ SJK BL Review memorandum from John A. Morris regarding McDonough transcript; check designations and respond $ SLP BL continued preparation of binder for $1, hearing. RJF BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris $ regarding trial issues. RJF BL Review deposition transcripts $2, BEL BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris and opposing counsel regarding exhibits and other trial exhibits $1, BEL BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris, Maria 0.20 Bove and Colin R. Robinson regarding trial $ logistics. BEL BL Conference with John A. Morris and Maria Bove $ regarding findings of fact. BEL BL Trial preparation $6, MB BL Telephone conferences with J. Morris and review 1.00 deposition designations and discrepancies $ MB BL Office conference with B. Levine and J. Morris re 0.90 trial preparation; telephone conference with C $ Robinson re same; draft agenda for trial preparation call. MB BL Conference call with trial team re trial preparation; $ follow-up re same. MB BL Trial preparation $1, MB BL Review Clarke deposition transcript $ CJB BL Prepare exhibit binders for hearing on 10/16/ $1, ARP BL Prepare Trial Exhibit hearing binders for hearing /20/ $1,787.50

35 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 15 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 14 Hours Rate Amount KSN BL Prepare exhibit binders for 10/16/17 hearing $1, JAM BL Prepare for meet and confer (2.7); telephone $11, conference with R. Feinstein re status (.3); meet and confer with B. Levine, Kirkland, Womble (1.4); trial preparation (4.5); meet with C. Flaton re prepare for direct examination (1.3); internal meeting re trial logistics and planning (.6); s to counsel for third parties re "confidential documents" (.8). CRR BL Multiple teleconference with K Mangan, chambers regarding exhibit lists, pretrial deadlines $ CRR BL Prepare notice of telephonic hearing regarding use of 0.30 confidential, third party documents $ LCT BL Confer with Colin R. Robinson and file clerks re $ preparation of exhibit binders for trial. SWG BL Edit opening trial presentation $1, CRR BL Trial preparation regarding review and assembly of 6.80 exhibits for Court, witness binders, confidential $4, documents, courtroom technology and teleconference with trial team regarding same JSP BL Assist with trial preparation $2, AJK BL Trial preparation $13, ARP BL Prepare hearing notebook for hearing on 10/25/ $ PJK BL Review trial agenda and docket in Comvest 0.20 adversary $ PJJ BL Revise video designations $ PJJ BL Work on trial preparation (finalizing trial exhibits, deposition designations and counters, exhibit objections, etc.) $3, SLP BL Continued preparation of binder for hearing $ RJF BL Office conferences with John A. Morris, Alan J $1, Kornfeld regarding trial issues. RJF BL Trial preparation $6, MB BL Research re PropCo proofs of claims; office with J Morris re Caple direct; Rodriguez direct $ MB BL Review Clarke deposition designations/video; office $ conference with J. Morris re same. MB BL Trial preparation $1, MB BL Create and revise trial preparation WIP list $ MB BL Two telephone conferences with C. Robinson re /13 hearing; office conference with J. Morris re $ same.

36 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 16 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 15 Hours Rate Amount MB BL Review trial documents $ MB BL Review and analyze Rodriguez transcript re trial $1, MB BL Review and revise exhibit list and voluminous $ s re same; trial preparation. CJB BL Prepare exhibit binders for hearing on 10/16/ $ ARP BL Prepare Trial Exhibit hearing binders for hearing /20/ $1, KSN BL Prepare hearing binders for 10/17/ /20/ $ hearing. KSN BL Prepare trial exhibit binders $ JAM BL Trial preparation $11, CRR BL Trial preparation $3, LCT BL Arrange telephonic appearance for J. Golden for trial 0.10 dates $35.00 LCT BL Efile and serve notice of telephonic hearing (.2); prepare aff of service (.1) $ LCT BL Confer with Colin R. Robinson re trial logistics and 0.40 prep (.2); follow up with file clerks re binder $ preparations (.2). LCT BL Coordinate with court reporter re trial transcripts $35.00 SWG BL Work on opening presentation $3, CRR BL Finalize agenda, communications with PSZJ trial team, Defendants re telephonic hearing on confidential documents $1, JSP BL Review deposition and designations for trial $2, preparation; confer with B. Sandler regarding trial ARP BL Prepare Trial Exhibit hearing binders for hearing $ /20/2017. AJK BL Trial preparation $13, PJJ BL Prepare redactions to confidential exhibits and $2, update trial exhibit list in accordance therewith. SJK BL Review and notate Defendant's exhibit objections $3, and memorandum to John A. Morris regarding same. SJK BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris $89.50 regarding Defendant objections to exhibits. RJF BL Trial preparation, including meetings with John A $4, Morris, Alan J. Kornfeld, Howard et al. MB BL Attend to exhibit list updates; open issues; trial preparation; telephone conferences with C. Robinson re same $1, MB BL Conference call with PSZJ team re trial slides $697.50

37 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 17 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 16 Hours Rate Amount MB BL Review updated trial slides $ MB BL Attend to exhibit issues $ MB BL Review final pretrial hearing transcript $ MB BL Trial preparation $ MB BL Review revised trial slides, comment on same $ CJB BL Prepare exhibit binders for hearing on 10/16/ $ KSN BL Prepare trial exhibits for hearing on 10/16/ $1, JAM BL Trial preparation $10, CRR BL Finalize, review exhibit binders and delivery of 3.50 same to chambers $2, LCT BL s re trial exhibt binder updates (.2); confer and 2.30 work with file clerks re trial binder $ preparation/updates to binders (2.0); submit Pl exhibit binders to Judge (.1). SWG BL Prepare for trial $3, MB BL Telephonic hearing $ PJK BL Attend teleconference with court regarding $ confidential exhibits CRR BL Telephonic hearing re confidential designations $ CRR BL Trial preparation $1, /14/2017 AJK BL Trial preparation $14, /14/2017 PJJ BL Prepare witness binders $ /14/2017 SJK BL Review and respond to memorandum from Brandon $89.50 Ryan regarding objection call setting. 10/14/2017 SJK BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris $ regarding same and review revised designations. 10/14/2017 SJK BL Revise objection list to comport with new $ designations. 10/14/2017 SJK BL Spot check deposition objections $ /14/2017 SJK BL Telephone conference with Defendant's counsel 1.50 regarding objections to meet and confer $1, /14/2017 SJK BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris $89.50 regarding meet and confer and next steps. 10/14/2017 SJK BL Review and annotate Defendant chart regarding objection status and memorandum to Defendant counsel regarding same $1, /14/2017 SJK BL Memorandum to Patricia Jeffries regarding updates $ to exhibit list. 10/14/2017 SJK BL Review Opening Trial Declaration $268.50

38 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 18 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 17 Hours Rate Amount 10/14/2017 RJF BL Review and comment on deck for opening $1, statement. 10/14/2017 BEL BL Prepare for trial $2, /14/2017 JAM BL Trial preparation $9, /14/2017 CRR BL Trial preparation-review, QC binders, review 8.30 updated opening presentation, telephone call with $6, Defendants re expert exhibits LAF BL Research re: Company press releases $ AJK BL Trial preparation $14, PJJ BL Prepare trial witness binders $4, SJK BL Telephone conference with Patricia Jeffries regarding revisions to exhibit list $ SJK BL Review and revise exhibit list and forward to 0.60 Patricia Jeffries $ RJF BL Trial prep session $2, BEL BL Prepare for trial $8, BEL BL Additional trial prep $1, MB BL Office conference with J. Morris re Rodriguez trial preparation $ MB BL Rodriguez trial preparation; review transcript and 2.00 digest, draft outline $1, MB BL Trial preparation $3, JAM BL Trial preparation $15, CRR BL Trial preparation, witness binders, assist trial team $6, w/ preparation, confer with trial team SWG BL Prepare for trial $5, AJK BL Prepare for trial $3, AJK BL Attend trial $8, AJK BL Prepare for trial (including attention to exhibits and 4.50 witness outlines) $4, PJJ BL Attend trial $2, PJJ BL Prepare witness binders $3, SLP BL Continued preparation of binder for hearing $ SLP BL Continued preparation of binder for hearing $ RJF BL Trial prep at office $1, RJF BL Attend trial Day $8,925.00

39 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 19 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 18 Hours Rate Amount RJF BL Post-mortem, trial prep at office $2, BEL BL Prepare for trial $2, BEL BL Attend trial $5, BEL BL Prepare for trial $4, MB BL Preparation for Rodriguez examination $1, MB BL Team meeting/trial preparation $ MB BL Rodriguez preparation with J. Morris $1, MB BL Trial preparation $1, ARP BL Prepare notebooks for hearing /20/ $ KSN BL Prepare trial exhibit binders $ JAM BL Trial preparation (3.8); trial (8.3); trial preparation (2.7) $14, PJK BL Review opening slide deck $ PJK BL s with Colin R. Robinson regarding trial $ CRR BL Trial preparation re witness binders, other matters $4, SWG BL Attend trial $3, SWG BL Prepare for trial $3, MB BL Attend trial $6, CRR BL Pre-hearing preparation $ CRR BL Attend trial $6, JSP BL Confer with B. Sandler regarding trial; review $ correspondence in connection with same AJK BL Prepare for and attend trial $17, PJJ BL Attend trial $2, PJJ BL Prepare witness binders $3, SLP BL Assist in preparing witness binders $1, SLP BL Assist in preparing witness binders $ RJF BL Trial prep at office $ RJF BL Attend trial Day $8, RJF BL Trial prep at office $ BEL BL Prepare for and attend trial $8, BEL BL Additional trial prep issues $1, MB BL Trial preparation $1, ARP BL Prepare notebooks for hearing /20/ $660.00

40 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 20 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 19 Hours Rate Amount JAM BL Trial preparation (9.1); trial. (7.8) $16, PJK BL Research regarding evidentiary issues and fraudulent conveyance issues for Comvest trial, draft and summary to Colin R. Robinson regarding same, s with Colin R. Robinson regarding research issues and follow up $1, CRR BL Trial preparation, preparation and review of witness $4, binders, research projects for AJK, review of Defendants exhibit lists LCT BL Assist with preparing witness binders and 0.60 miscellaneous trial prep $ SWG BL Prepare for and listen in to trial $7, MB BL Attend trial; trial preparation $6, CRR BL Attend trial $5, JSP BL Confer with B. Sandler regarding trial; review correspondence and document in connection with same $ /18/2017 AJK BL Prepare for and attend trial $15, /18/2017 PJJ BL Attend trial $1, /18/2017 PJJ BL Prepare witness binders $2, /18/2017 SJK BL Review and respond to s from Beth E. Levine $ regarding Defendant's objections to exhibits. 10/18/2017 RJF BL Trial prep at office $ /18/2017 RJF BL Attend Trial Day $6, /18/2017 RJF BL Post-mortem at office $ /18/2017 RJF BL Factual research $ /18/2017 BEL BL Prepare for and attend trial $5, /18/2017 BEL BL Attend to multiple exhibit issues $1, /18/2017 BEL BL Additional trial preparation $1, /18/2017 MB BL Trial preparation $ /18/2017 MB BL Trial preparation $1, /18/2017 MB BL Meetings with R. Feinstein, J. Morris and C $ Robinson re use of funds from PropCo Entities. 10/18/2017 KSN BL Prepare trial exhibit binders $ /18/2017 JAM BL Trial preparation (3.6); trial. (7.4) $10, /18/2017 PJK BL Research regarding expert report issues for trial, $ prepare and summary to Colin R. Robinson 10/18/2017 PJK BL Research regarding recharacterization issues for trial, draft and summary to PSZJ team $2,201.50

41 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 21 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 20 Hours Rate Amount 10/18/2017 CRR BL Meet and confer with PSJ team, Defendants re $1, exhibits lists, update to same; review various exhibits marked confidential 10/18/2017 CRR BL Trial preparation, review witness binders, other tasks 3.00 for next day of trial $2, /18/2017 LCT BL Miscellaneous trial assistance $ /18/2017 SWG BL Trial $2, /18/2017 SWG BL Prepare for trial $1, /18/2017 MB BL Attend trial $6, /18/2017 CRR BL Attend trial $4, /18/2017 JSP BL Confer with B. Sandler regarding trial; review $ correspondence in connection with same 10/19/2017 AJK BL Prepare for and attend trial $15, /19/2017 PJJ BL Attend trial $2, /19/2017 PJJ BL Prepare witness binders $2, /19/2017 RJF BL Pre-trial prep $1, /19/2017 RJF BL Attend Day 4 of trial $8, /19/2017 RJF BL Draft argument in opposition to directed verdict $2, /19/2017 RJF BL Prep for argument $1, /19/2017 BEL BL Prepare for and attend trial $5, /19/2017 BEL BL Research for directed verdict motion and comment 2.70 on directed verdict action $1, /19/2017 BEL BL Additional trial preparation $2, /19/2017 MB BL Review P. Keane research re recharacterization; to R. Feinstein and J. Morris re same; research $ re payments to professionals; to R. Feinstein, J. Morris and C. Robinson re same; revise exhibit list and s with team re same. 10/19/2017 MB BL Trial preparation $2, /19/2017 JAM BL Trial preparation (4.0); trial (7.7) $11, /19/2017 CRR BL Meet and confer, review re exhibit lists of $1, Defendants, update J Morris re same 10/19/2017 LCT BL Miscellaneous trial assistance $ /19/2017 SWG BL Trial $3, /19/2017 MB BL Attend trial $6, /19/2017 CRR BL Pre-hearing preparation $ /19/2017 CRR BL Attend hearing $5, /19/2017 CRR BL Hearing preparation re witness binders $1,232.50

42 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 22 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 21 Hours Rate Amount 10/19/2017 JSP BL Confer with B. Sandler regarding trial; review $ correspondence/document in connection with same 10/20/2017 JSP BL Confer with B. Sandler regarding trial (.3); review $ document in connection with same (.4). 10/20/2017 AJK BL Prepare for and attend trial $12, /20/2017 PJJ BL Prepare witness trial binders $ /20/2017 PJJ BL Attend trial $2, /20/2017 RJF BL Trial prep, including argument against directed $1, verdict motion. 10/20/2017 RJF BL Attend Day 5 of trial $8, /20/2017 BEL BL Review defendants exhibit list $ /20/2017 BEL BL Trial prep $ /20/2017 BEL BL Attend trial $3, /20/2017 MB BL Trial preparation $ /20/2017 ARP BL Prepare hearing notebook for hearing on / $ , /20/2017 JAM BL Trial preparation (1.7); trial (8.0) $9, /20/2017 CRR BL Review exhibit lists and prepare, send e/c to $1, chambers re same 10/20/2017 CRR BL Review Defendants exhibit list for submission to $ chambers 10/20/2017 MB BL Attend trial $6, /20/2017 CRR BL Pre-trial preparation re objections to exhibits $ /20/2017 CRR BL Attend trial $5, /20/2017 CRR BL Post-trial review of binders, exhibits $ /21/2017 BJS BL Various s with PSZJ regarding trial $ /22/2017 JAM BL Communications with PSZJ team re post-trial work $ /23/2017 BJS BL Various s with PSZJ regarding post-trial work $ /23/2017 LCT BL Review and distribute 10/25 hearing agenda $ /23/2017 EG BL Call re: post trial preparation of findings of fact and conclusions of law (Committee v. Comvest) with John A. Morris, et al $ /23/2017 EG BL Review materials in preparation for drafting 0.50 conclusions of law and call re: same (Committee v $ Comvest) 10/23/2017 PJJ BL Post-trial conference call with PSZJ trial team $ /23/2017 SJK BL Telephone conference with John A. Morris $ regarding findings preparation.

43 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 23 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 22 Hours Rate Amount 10/23/2017 SJK BL Review materials for post-trial $ /23/2017 SJK BL Conference call with John A. Morris and review $ team regarding preparation of findings of fact. 10/23/2017 BEL BL Review outline and other material for post-trial $ submissions. 10/23/2017 BEL BL Telephone conference with working group regarding $ post-trial submission. 10/23/2017 BEL BL Confer with John A. Morris, Maria Bove and Steve $72.50 Golden regarding post-trial submission. 10/23/2017 BEL BL Review forms of proposed findings of act and $ conclusions of law. 10/23/2017 MB BL Research for findings of facts/conclusion of law $ /23/2017 MB BL All hands PSZJ conference call re findings of $ facts/conclusion of law. 10/23/2017 MB BL Telephone conference with E. Gray re conclusions of law $ /23/2017 JAM BL Organize for post-trial work (4.6);telephone 5.60 conference with PSZJ team re marshalling the $5, evidence (.4); to PSZJ team re marshalling the evidence (.5); meet with B. Levine, M. Bove, S. Golden re marshalling the evidence (.1). 10/23/2017 CRR BL Post-trial review of exhibits, witness binders and $2, reorganization re same for findings of fact project 10/23/2017 CRR BL Review J Morris, attachments prepare for telephone $ call on post-trial matters 10/23/2017 CRR BL Telephone call with Post-trial team re findings of $ fact 10/23/2017 CRR BL Review combined exhibit, deposition exhibit list $ and with Defendants re same 10/23/2017 SWG BL Call with PSZJ Team (.4); Follow up conference (.1) $ /23/2017 CRR BL Review agenda and to B Sandler, P Keane re $ same 10/24/2017 RJF BL Call with John A. Morris, Maria Bove et al $ regarding findings of fact. 10/24/2017 RJF BL Call with Maria Bove regarding conclusions of law $ /24/2017 PJK BL Review 10/25 amended agenda $ /24/2017 LCT BL Review and distribute amended agenda canceling $35.00 hearing. 10/24/2017 SLH BL Final briefing strategy (with Steve Golden) $ /24/2017 EG BL Call re: post trial preparation of findings of fact and conclusions of law (Committee v. Comvest) with John A. Morris, Robert J. Feinstein and Maria Bove $217.50

44 Case KG Doc Filed 12/08/17 Page 24 of 202 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP Page: 23 Hours Rate Amount 10/24/2017 EG BL Review pre-trial trial briefs and other materials in $2, connection with preparing conclusions of law in Committee v. Comvest 10/24/2017 SJK BL Review new outlines and charts for Finding of Fact 0.40 insertions $ /24/2017 SJK BL Direct preparation of, and review, breakouts of ALB $ digest information. 10/24/2017 SJK BL Begin digest review for Findings of Fact inserts $2, /24/2017 SJK BL Review new outline for Findings of Fact and create witness breakouts $ /24/2017 BEL BL Draft sections of proposed findings of fact $3, /24/2017 MB BL Judicial notice research; draft insert re same for findings of fact $ /24/2017 MB BL Review trial notes re findings of facts/conclusion of 0.20 law $ /24/2017 MB BL Conference call re conclusions of law with R. Feinstein, J. Morris and E. Gray $ /24/2017 MB BL Telephone conference with R. Feinstein re findings 0.30 of facts/conclusion of law $ /24/2017 JAM BL Telephone conference with R. Feinstein, E. Gray, M. Bove re post-trial conclusions of law (.3); meet with S. Golden re post-trial findings of fact (.2); telephone conference with C. Robinson re post-trial findings of fact (.2); to PSZJ team re converting deposition exhibits to trial exhibits (.2); work in post-trial brief (3.4); telephone conference with C. Mackle re glossary of defined terms (.1); to C. Mackle re glossary of defined terms (.2); to E. Gray, M. Bove re materials for conclusions of law (.4); s with P. Mohr, C. Robinson, P. Jeffries re exhibit lists (.3); review/revise outline of proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law (1.8); to PSZJ team re outline (.2) $6, /24/2017 CRR BL Finalize combined exhibit, deposition list and e/c to $1, and from Defendants counsel re submission to chambers 10/24/2017 CRR BL Review from J Morris re witness assignment $ /24/2017 CRR BL Review updated outline re findings of fact $ /24/2017 CRR BL Initial review of deposition transcripts re PNC, 0.40 Spirit, and GIG $ /24/2017 SWG BL Conference with John Morris regarding post trial $45.00 matters. 10/25/2017 EG BL Research and draft Conclusions of Law (Counts $2,175.00