arxiv: v1 [astro-ph.co] 20 Dec 2018

Transcription

1 Preprint 24 December 28 Compiled using MNRAS LATEX style file v3. A new method to probe the mss density nd the cosmologicl constnt using configurtion entropy Biswjit Pndey nd Biswjit Ds Deprtment of Physics, Visv-Bhrti University, Sntiniketn, Birbhum, 73235, Indi rxiv:82.886v [stro-ph.co] 2 Dec December 28 INTRODUCTION Understnding the drk mtter nd drk energy remin the most chllenging problems in cosmology. Observtions suggest tht the bryons or the ordinry mtter constitutes only 5% oftheuniverse.itisbelievedtht 3 oftheuniverseis mde up of the grvitting mss out of which 85% is in the form of hypotheticl unseen mtter dubbed s the drk mtter. The remining 2 3 of the Universe is ccounted by some mysterious hypotheticl component dubbed s the drk energy. The drk energy is believed to be responsible for driving the current ccelerted expnsion of the Universe. The existence nd bundnce of these mysterious components re determined from vrious observtions. At present, theλcdm model whereλstnds for the cosmologicl constnt nd CDM stnds for the cold drk mtter stnds out s the most successful model in explining most of the cosmologicl observtions till dte. The CDM model ws initilly introduced by Peebles (982). Dvis et l. (985) crried out the pioneering numericl study of the CDM distribution which pved new er llowing comprison of theory with multitude of observtions. The current prdigm of structure formtion is sup- E-mil:biswp@visv-bhrti.c.in E-mil:bishoophy@gmil.com ABSTRACT We study the evolution of the configurtion entropy for different combintions of Ω m ndω Λ in the fltλcdm universe nd find tht the cosmologicl constnt plys decisive role in controlling the dissiption of the configurtion entropy. The configurtion entropy dissiptes t slower rte in the models with higher vlue of Ω Λ. We find tht the entropy rte decys to rech minimum nd then increses with time. The minimum entropy rte occurs t n erlier time for higher vlue of Ω Λ. We identify prominent pek in the derivtive of the entropy rte whose loction closely coincides with the scle fctor corresponding to the trnsition from mtter to Λ domintion. We find tht the pek loction is insensitive to the initil conditions nd only depends on the vlues ofω m ndω Λ. We propose tht mesuring the evolution of the configurtion entropy in the Universe nd identifying the loction of the pek in its second derivtive would provide new nd robust method to probe the mss density nd the cosmologicl constnt. Key words: methods: nlyticl - cosmology: theory - lrge scle structure of the Universe. ported by mny complementry observtions. The fct tht the CMBR ngulr power spectrum peks t l 2 suggests sptilly flt Universe where the men energy density of the Universe must be close to the criticl density (Komtsu et l. 2; Plnck Collbortion et l. 26). Other observtions from dynmics of glxies nd clusters (Crlberg et l. 996), the X-ry observtions of glxy clusters (Mohr et l. 999), Sunyev-Zeldovich effect (Grego et l. 2), wek lensing (Benjmin et l. 27; Fu et l. 28), bryonic coustic oscilltions (BAO) (Eisenstein et l. 25), correltion functions (Hwkins et l. 23) nd the power spectrum of density fluctutions (Tegmrk et l. 24; Reid et l. 2; Percivl et l. 2) reveled tht the totl mss density prmeter including both the bryonic nd non-bryonic components must be.3. A flt Universe withω m =.3 leves us with no other choice but Ω Λ =.7 which fits the bill perfectly. Further, the existence of drk energy is lso supported by independent observtions such s Type I supernov (Riess et l. 998; Perlmutter et l. 999) nd BAO (Wng 26; Eisenstein 25) with very high confidence. Recently, Pndey (27) propose tht the evolution of configurtion entropy of the mss distribution in the Universe my drive the cosmic ccelertion. It hs been rgued tht the configurtion entropy of the Universe decreses with c 28 The Authors

2 2 Pndey, B. nd Ds, B. time due to the mplifiction of the density perturbtions by the process of grvittionl instbility. The configurtion entropy continues to dissipte in mtter dominted Universe. The dissiption of configurtion entropy due to this trnsition from smoother to clumpier stte demnds existence of some efficient entropy genertion mechnisms to counterblnce this loss. If the other entropy genertion mechnisms re not sufficient to counter this loss then the Universe must expnd in such wy so s to prevent the further growth of structures nd stop the lekge of informtion entropy. Interestingly, the dissiption of the configurtion entropy comes to hlt in Λdominted Universe due to the suppression of the growth of structures on lrge scles. Recently Ds & Pndey (29) used the evolution of the configurtion entropy to distinguish vrious dynmicl drk energy prmeteristions. In the present work, we ssume tht theλcdm model with flt FRW metric to be the correct model of the Universe nd the density prmeters ssocited with mtter nd Λ re tobe determinedfrom observtions. We propose new method for the determintion of the density prmeter ssocited with the mss nd the cosmologicl constnt. The method is bsed on the study of the evolution of the configurtion entropy in the Universe. In future, the present genertion surveys like SDSS (York et l. 2), 2dFGRS (Colles et l. 2), drk energy survey (Abbott et l. 28) combined with vrious other future surveys like DESI, Euclid nd different future 2 cm experiments like SKA would llow us to mesure the configurtion entropy t different epochs nd study its evolution. The method presented in this work would provide n lterntive route to mesure the mss density nd the cosmologicl constnt in n independent nd unique wy nd compre their vlues obtined by the other methods from vrious observtions. 2 THEORY 2. Configurtion entropy nd its evolution The observtions of the cosmic microwve bckground rdition (CMBR) suggest tht the Universe ws highly uniform in the pst. But the mtter distribution in the present dy Universe is highly clumpy due to the structure formtion by grvity. Pndey (27) defines the configurtion entropy of the mss distribution following the ide of informtion entropy (Shnnon 948) s, S c (t)= ρ( x,t)logρ( x,t)dv. () Here S c (t) is the configurtion entropy of the mss distribution t time t over sufficiently lrge comoving volume V. The volume V is divided into lrge number of subvolumes dv nd the density ρ( x, t) is mesured inside ech volume element. The distributionis treteds fluidon lrge scles. The continuity eqution for the fluid in n expnding universe is given by, ρ t + 3 ȧ ρ+ (ρ v)=. (2) Here is the scle fctor nd v denotes the peculir velocity of the fluid inside the volume element dv. If we multiply Eqution 2 by ( + logρ) nd integrte over the entire volume V, then we get the entropy evolution eqution (Pndey 27) s, ds c (t) + 3 ȧ dt S c(t) ρ(3ȧ+ v)dv=. (3) Chnging vrible from t to in Eqution 3 we get, where F() is given by, ds c () ȧ+3ȧ d S c() F()=. (4) F()=3MH()+ ρ( x, ) v dv. (5) Here M= ρ( x,)dv= ρ(+δ( x,))dv gives the totl mss inside V ndδ( x,)= ρ( x,) ρ ρ gives the density contrst in subvolume dv centred t the comoving co-ordinte x. The ρ is the men density of mtter inside the comoving volume V. One cn simplify Eqution 4 further to get, ds c () d + 3 (S c() M)+ ρ f () D2 () δ 2 ( x)dv=. (6) where, D() is the growing mode of density perturbtion nd f ()= dlnd dln = D dd d is the dimensionless liner growth rte. We need to solve Eqution 6 to study the evolution of the configurtion entropy for ny given cosmologicl model. The time-independent quntities in the third term of Eqution 6 re set to for the ske of simplicity. We clculte D() nd f () for the cosmologicl model under considertion. We then numericlly solve the Eqution 6 using the 4 th order Runge-Kutt method. The second nd third term in Eqution 6 together decides the evolution of the configurtion entropy. The second term is decided by the initil condition wheres the third term is governed by the nture of the growth of structures in prticulr cosmologicl model. At the initil stge, the second term solely dicttes the evolution becuse the growth fctor remins negligible. The third term only comes into ply when the growth of structures becomes significnt. So the cosmology dependence of the configurtion entropy rises purely from the third term in Eqution 6. The Eqution 6 cn be solved nlyticlly ignoring the third term which is given by, S c () S c ( i ) = M ( S c ( i ) + M )( ) 3 i. (7) S c ( i ) where, i is the initil scle fctor nd S c ( i ) is the initil entropy. We choose i to be 3 throughout the present nlysis. According to this solution, we expect sudden growth or decy in the configurtion entropy ner the initil scle fctor i when S c ( i )< M nd S c ( i )> M respectively. On the other hnd,nosuch trnsients re expectedwhen S c ( i )= M. Since we re only interested in the cosmology dependence of the configurtion entropy, we shll focus on the solution of Eqution 6 for S c ( i )= M in the present work. The solutions in the other two cses re similr other thn the trnsients present ner the initil scle fctor.

3 Mss density nd Λ from entropy ( m, ) = (.,.9) ( m, ) = (.2,.8) ( m, ) = (.3,.7) ( m, ) = (.4,.6) ( m, ) = (.5,.5) ( m, ) = (.6,.4) ( m, ) = (.7,.3) ( m, ) = (.8,.2) ( m, ) = (.9,.) D 2 ().8 f() (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.,.9) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.2,.8) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.3,.7) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.4,.6) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.5,.5) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.6,.4) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.7,.3) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.8,.2) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.9,.) Figure. The left pnel nd the right pnel of this figure respectively show D 2 () nd f () s function of scle fctor for different combintions of (Ω m,ω Λ ) within the flt ΛCDM cosmology. The vlue of D() is normlized to t present for the combintion (Ω m,ω Λ )=(.3,.7). The D() vlues in the other models re normlized with respect to this model M = S c ( i ) -. S c ()/S c ( i ) ( m, ) = (.,.9) ( m, ) = (.2,.8) (! m," # ) = (.3,.7) ($ m,% & ) = (.4,.6) (' m,( ) ) = (.5,.5) (* m,+, ) = (.6,.4) (- m,. / ) = (.7,.3) ( m, 2 ) = (.8,.2) (3 m,4 5 ) = (.9,.) ds c ()/d (6 m,7 8 ) = (.,.9) (9 m,: ; ) = (.2,.8) (< m,= > ) = (.3,.7) (? m,@ A ) = (.4,.6) (B m,c D ) = (.5,.5) (E m,f G ) = (.6,.4) (H m,i J ) = (.7,.3) (K m,l M ) = (.8,.2) (N m,o P ) = (.9,.) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.,.9) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.2,.8) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.3,.7) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.4,.6) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.5,.5) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.6,.4) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.7,.3) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.8,.2) (Ω m,ω Λ ) = (.9,.) d 2 S c ()/d Figure 2. The top left pnel of this figure shows the evolution of the configurtion entropy for different combintions of (Ω m,ω Λ ) within the fltλcdm model. The top right pnel nd the bottom middle pnel respectively show the first nd the second derivtive of the configurtion entropy in these models. The rrows in different colours in the bottom middle pnel mrk the scle fctors t = ( Ω m Ω Λ ) 3 corresponding to the trnsition from mtter to Λ domintion in the respective models. The trnsition scle fctors closely coincide with the pek loctions in ech model.

4 4 Pndey, B. nd Ds, B. 2.2 The growing mode nd the dimensionless liner growth rte The CMBR observtions show tht the Universe is highly isotropic. But the sme observtions lso revel tht there re smll nisotropies of the order of 5 imprinted in the CMBR temperture mps. These tiny fluctutions re believed to be the precursor of the lrge scle structures observed in the present dy Universe. The primordil density perturbtions were mplified by the process of grvittionl instbility for billions of yers. The growth of the density perturbtions δ( x, t) cn be described by the liner perturbtion theory when δ <<. Considering only perturbtions to the mtter sector, the linerized eqution for the growth of the density perturbtion is given by, 2 δ( x,t) t 2 + 2H δ( x,t) t 3 2 Ω mh 2 3δ( x,t)=. (8) HereΩ m nd H re the present vlues of the mss density prmeter nd the Hubble prmeter respectively. This eqution hs two solutions, one which grows nd nother which decys wy with time. The growing mode solution mplifies the density perturbtions t the sme rte t every loction so tht the density perturbtion t ny loction x cn be expressed s,δ( x,t)=d(t)δ( x). Here D(t) is the growing mode nd δ( x) is the initil density perturbtion t the loction x. The growing mode solution of Eqution 8 cn be expressed (Peebles 98) s, D()= 5 2 Ω mx d 2 (), (9) 3 X 3 2 ( ) where X()= H()2 = [Ω H 2 m 3 +Ω Λ ] in n Universe with only mtter nd cosmologicl constnt. In flt Universe, the dimensionless liner growth rte cn be well pproximted (Lhv et l. 99) by, f ()= d lnδ d ln f ()=Ω m () [ 2 Ω m()(+ω m ())], () where the mtter density historyω m () cn be written s Ω m ()= Ω m 3 X(). In the present work, we consider different combintions ofω m ndω Λ within the frmework of the fltλcdm model nd clculte D() nd f () in ech cse. The D 2 () nd f () for different models re shown in Figure. These re then used to solve Eqution 6 to study the evolution of the configurtion entropy in ech model. 3 RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS We show the evolution of S c() S c ( i ) with scle fctor in the top left pnel of Figure 2. We see tht the configurtion entropy initilly decreses with time. The dissiption of the configurtion entropy is driven by the growth of structures. The dissiption is higher inthemodels withlrger vlueofω m. This is directly relted to higher growth fctor D() nd growth rte f () in the models with lrgerω m (Figure ). Clerly, the dissiption is less pronounced in the models with lrgerω Λ. The structure formtion is the outcome of two competing effects: one is the tendency of the overdense regions to collpse under their self grvity nd the other is the tendency to move prt with the bckground expnsion. The cosmologicl constnt Λ contributes to the lter nd thus resists the lekge of the configurtion entropy in the Universe by incresing the Hubble drg nd suppressing the structure formtion on lrge scles. We show the rte of chnge of the configurtion entropy in the top right pnel of Figure 2. We find tht the cosmologicl constnt Λ plys n influentil role in controlling the dissiption of the configurtion entropy. Models with lrger vlue ofω Λ nd smller vlue ofω m show dipin the slope of the configurtion entropy t smller vlue of the scle fctor. For exmple in the model withω Λ =.9, initilly the slope decreses with incresing scle fctor reching the minimum t.3. The slope then turns upwrd remining negtive upto.8 therefter upcrossing the zero. It then slowly plteus towrds stble vlue. A similr trend is observed for the other models with different combintions ofω m ndω Λ. The minimum occur t.4 nd.5 in the models withω Λ =.8 ndω Λ =.7 respectively. The minimum of the slope indictes the time since Λ becomes proctive in suppressing the dissiption of the configurtion entropy. The minimum ppers t smller vlue of scle fctor in the higherω Λ models simply becuse the presence of theλterm is felt erlier in these models. The bottom middle pnel of Figure 2 shows the derivtive of the slopes shown in the top right pnel of the figure. Initilly, the derivtive of the slopes re negtive for ll the models which imply tht the slopes re decresing with time. But the second derivtive keeps on incresing with time nd eventully upcrosses zero t some vlue of the scle fctor. This scle fctor corresponds to the minimum of the slope. For exmple the model withω Λ =.9 exhibit the zero upcrossing of the second derivtive t.3 where minimum ws observed in the slope. Similrly, zero upcrossing cn be seen t.4nd.5intheω Λ =.8 ndω Λ =.7models respectively. The positive vlue of the second derivtives fter this scle fctor suggest tht the slopes re incresing with time. However, the slopes themselves remin negtive fter the occurrence of the minimum. This suggest tht the configurtion entropy still continues to dissipte with time but with grdully decresing rte. The second derivtives of the configurtion entropy do not increse monotoniclly but show prominent pek t specific vlue of the scle fctor. The peks re clerly identified in the models with Ω Λ =.9,Ω Λ =.8,Ω Λ =.7 ndω Λ =.6 t the scle fctor =.48, =.63, =.75 nd =.87 respectively. Interestingly, the trnsition from mtter to Λ domintion in the respective models re expected to occur t nerly the sme scle fctors. It my be noted tht the second derivtives remin negtive throughout the entire rnge of scle fctor forω Λ =. ndω Λ =.2 models. The peks in these models nd the rest of the models re expected to occur in future nd hence re not present in the figure. The dissiption rte of the configurtion entropy chnges t slower rte once theλdomintion tkes plce. This is relted to the fct tht the growth of structures re completely shut off on lrger scles onceλbegins to drive the ccelerted expnsion of the Universe. We hve repeted these nlyses for S c ( i )> M nd S c ( i )< M nd recovered the peks t exctly the sme loctions. This indictes tht the pek loctions re insensitive

5 Mss density nd Λ from entropy 5 to the initil conditions nd depend only on the vlues of Ω m ndω Λ. The proposed method requires us to mp the distribution of unbised trcers of the underlying mss distribution t multiple redshifts. We expect tht combining the mesurements of the configurtion entropy t different redshifts from the present nd future genertion surveys would enble us to study the evolution of the configurtion entropy. This would llow us to identify the loction of the pek in its second derivtive nd constrin the vlue of both the mss density nd the cosmologicl constnt in the Universe. Here we would like to mention tht the introduction of bis my complicte the nlysis which we would like to ddress in future work. Finlly, we conclude tht the nlysis presented in this work provides n lterntive venue for the determintion of the mss density nd the cosmologicl constnt Λ by studying the evolution of the configurtion entropy in the Universe. We expect this to find mny useful pplictions in the study of the mysterious drk mtter nd the elusive cosmologicl constnt. Plnck Collbortion, Ade, P. A. R., Aghnim, N., et l. 26, A&A, 594, A3 Reid, B. A., Percivl, W. J., Eisenstein, D. J., et l. 2, MN- RAS, 44, 6 Riess, A. G., Filippenko, A. V., Chllis, P., et l. 998, AJ, 6, 9 Shnnon, C. E. 948, Bell System Technicl Journl, 27, , Tegmrk, M., Blnton, M. R., Struss, M. A., et l. 24, ApJ, 66, 72 Wng, Y. 26, ApJ, 647, York, D. G., et l. 2, AJ, 2, 579 This pper hs been typeset from TEX/LATEX file prepred by the uthor. 4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The uthors would like to cknowledge finncil support from the SERB, DST, Government of Indi through the project EMR/25/37. BP would lso like to cknowledge IUCAA, Pune nd CTS, IIT, Khrgpur for providing support through ssociteship nd visitors progrmme respectively. REFERENCES Abbott, T. M. C., Abdll, F. B., Allm, S., et l. 28, ApJS, 239, 8 Benjmin, J., Heymns, C., Semboloni, E., et l. 27, MNRAS, 38, 72 Crlberg, R. G., Yee, H. K. C., Ellingson, E., et l. 996, ApJ, 462, 32 Colles, M. et l.(for 2dFGRS tem) 2,MNRAS,328,39 Ds, B., & Pndey, B. 29, MNRAS, 482, 329 Dvis, M., Efstthiou, G., Frenk, C. S., & White, S. D. M. 985, ApJ, 292, 37 Eisenstein, D. J., Zehvi, I., Hogg, D. W., et l. 25, ApJ, 633, 56 Eisenstein, D. J. 25, New Astronomy Reviews, 49, 36 Fu, L., Semboloni, E., Hoekstr, H., et l. 28, A&A, 479, 9 Grego, L., Crlstrom, J. E., Joy, M. K., et l. 2, ApJ, 539, 39 Hwkins, E., Mddox, S., Cole, S., et l. 23, MNRAS, 346, 78 Komtsu, E., Smith, K. M., Dunkley, J., et l. 2, ApJS, 92, 8 Lhv, O., Lilje, P. B., Primck, J. R., & Rees, M. J. 99, MN- RAS, 25, 28 Mohr, J. J., Mthiesen, B., & Evrrd, A. E. 999, ApJ, 57, 627 Pndey, B. 27, MNRAS, 47, L77 Peebles, P. J. E. 98, The Lrge-scle Structure of the Universe, Princeton University Press, p., Peebles, P.J. E. 982, ApJ, 263, L Percivl, W. J., Reid, B. A., Eisenstein, D. J., et l. 2, MN- RAS, 4, 248 Perlmutter, S., Aldering, G., Goldhber, G., et l. 999, ApJ, 57, 565