arxiv: v2 [gr-qc] 19 Jul 2016

Transcription

1 GR GSG Hybid Gvity Nhomi Kn Ntionl Institute of Technology, Gifu College, Motosu-shi, Gifu , Jpn Tkuy Mki Jpn Women s College of Physicl Eduction, Setgy, Tokyo , Jpn Xiv: v [g-qc] 9 Jul 06 Kiyoshi Shiishi Gdute School of Sciences nd Technology fo Innovtion, Ymguchi Univesity, Ymguchi-shi, Ymguchi 75 85, Jpn Dted: Mch, 08 We popose model of gvity in which Genel Reltivity metic tenso nd n effective metic geneted fom single scl fomulted in Geometic Scl Gvity e mixed. We show tht the model yields the exct Schwzschild solution, long with cceleting behvio of scle fctos in cosmologicl solutions. PACS numbes: q, 04.5.Nx, Kd, Bw,.0.-z, k. kn@gifu-nct.c.jp mki@jwcpe.c.jp shiish@ymguchi-u.c.jp

2 I. INTRODUCTION Bigvity theoy is n ltentive theoy of gvity tht descibes both mssless nd mssive gvitons [, ] fo eview, see []. The low-enegy modifiction fom Genel Reltivity GR is expected to explin mysteious components of the univese known s dk mtte nd dk enegy. Bigvity models genelly contin two Einstein Hilbet tems epesenting the two metics, s well s the mixing tem of the two metics, in ode to genete mss fo gviton. Recent developments in the study of bigvity o mssive gvity theoies [4 8] hve stemmed fom the discovey of the ppopite mss tem fo ghost-fee nonline bimetic ction. Moe ecently, Nojii, Odintsov, nd thei collbotos hve consideed extensions of the bigvity theoy [9 4] in which the pue Einstein Hilbet tems e eplced by the Lgngin of FR gvity o scl tenso theoies. These uthos hve studied models hving scl degees of feedom with view to esolving the cosmologicl poblems in the vey ely e, s well s in the pesent univese. In 04, Novello nd collbotos pesented new theoy of gvity, clled Geometic Scl Gvity GSG [8 ]. In this theoy, the dynmics of gvity is descibed by single scl field. A nomlized deivtive of the scl field expesses pt of the dynmicl metic, s well s the scl field itself. Novello nd his collbotos found specific fom of the scl field potentil fom which the Schwzschild spcetime is deived s n exct solution. These eseches lso discussed the exotic cosmology bsed on GSG [8 ]. The novel behvio of the scle fcto in the GSG cosmology povides vey inteesting supplementy pespective on the issue of the initil singulity []. On the othe hnd, GSG pedicts scl gvittionl wves [8, 6], which my conflict with ecent diect obsevtions of gvittionl wves fom blck hole biny [7]. Futhe, moe scl degees of feedom my be needed in ode to explin the gvittionl field ound spinning souce [, 8]. Theefoe, the simplest GSG model hs pcticl difficulty in descibing stophysicl pocesses. In this ppe, we popose GR GSG hybid model of gvity. Ou model consists of the dynmics of fundmentl metic tenso in GR nd n effective metic in GSG. This In cetin sense, mssive gvity is just bigvity in which one of the metics is non-dynmic. Fo the vious models of modified gvity nd thei cosmologicl menings, see [5 7]. See lso [4, 5].

3 theoy ntully possesses mssless mode fo the symmetic tenso field nd yields the Schwzschild solution exctly. Nevetheless, the cosmologicl solutions in the model e expected to be inteesting, becuse they my inheit novel chcteistics fom GSG solutions. In the next section, we define ou model. In Sec. III, we investigte spheiclly symmetic solution of the model in wek gvity. In Sec. IV, we exploe cosmologicl solutions fo ou model. We conside two cses: two metics independently coupled to coesponding mtte nd the cse in which the composite metic is consideed to be the physicl metic coupled to mtte. Finlly, we summize ou wok nd emk on the genel significnce of ou study in Sec. V. II. THE GR GSG HYBRID MODEL A. Bief eview of GSG Fist, we povide bief eview of GSG [8] to ende the pesent ppe self-contined. The effective metic q µν in GSG is descibed by scl field Φ s [ q µν = e Φ η µν e 4Φ VΦ e 4Φ VΦ ] µ Φ ν Φ,. w whee w η µν µ Φ ν Φ nd η µν is flt Minkowski metic with the signtue +++. The invese of the effective metic is then witten s [ ] q µν = e Φ η µν + e 4Φ VΦ η µρ η νσ ρ Φ σ Φ.. w Note tht detq = e 6Φ VΦ detη, q µν ν Φ = e 6Φ VΦη µν ν Φ.. We conside the following ction govening the dynmics of Φ with potentil VΦ: S GSG = Mq d 4 x detq VΦq µν µ Φ ν Φ,.4 whee M q is constnt with mss dimensions. The vition of the ction with espect to Φ is clculted s δs GSG = Mq d 4 x detq VΦ q ΦδΦ,.5

4 4 whee q Φ µ detqq µν ν Φ, detq [ = e 6Φ VΦ µ detηη µν ν Φ+ w ] d detη dφ lnvφ..6 Novello et l. [8] hve stted tht the fom fo VΦ must be chosen so s to elize the exct Schwzschild solution. Theefoe, they employ We lso dopt this potentil in the pesent ppe. VΦ = 4 eφ e Φ..7 B. Constuction of hybid model The following Einstein Hilbet ction is exploited in ode to povide the dynmics of the metic tenso g µν : S GR g = M g d 4 x detgr g,.8 whee M g is constnt with mss dimensions nd R g is the Ricci scl constucted fom the metic tenso g. The vition of the ction.8 with espect to g yields δs GR g = M g whee R µν g denotes the Ricci tenso constucted fom g. d 4 x [ detg R g µν R gg ]δg µν µν,.9 Next, we conside the mixing tem of g nd the effective metic q. Fo simplicity, we dopt tht used in the miniml cse of the ghost-fee bigvity, which is expessed s follows [, 5, 9 4, 9, 0]: S mix g,q = m M 0 d 4 x [ detg t g q +det ] g q,.0 whee m nd M 0 e two constnts with mss dimensions. Note tht M 0 is implicitly consideedtobeofthesmeodesm g ndm q. Thetenso g q mens g q µ ρ g q ρ ν = g µρ q ρν. The vition of.0 is given by δs mix g,q = m M0 d 4 x detg [g µν t g q + g q µ ρg ρν + g q ν ρg ρµ ]δg µν

5 5 + m M 0 d 4 x [ detg q µν det g q g q µ ρg ρν g q ν ρg ρµ ]δq µν.. Now, we define the totl ction fo the gviton secto s the following combintion: S = S GR g+s GSG +S mix g,q.. Note tht possible dditionl ction fo mtte fields S mtte will be consideed lte, in Sec. IV. The equtions of motion deived fom S cn be expessed s [ Mg R g µν ] R gg µν m M0 [g µν t g q + g q µ ρg ρν + ] g q ν ρg ρµ = 0,. nd M q VΦ q Φ+ m M 0 detg [τ + detq V ] dv ε+ gµχ µ = 0,.4 dφ whee τ 4det g q t g q,.5 ε det g q Ω g q µ ρg ρν µ Φ ν Φ,.6 χ µ e 4Φ V Ω g q µ ρg ρν g q ν ρg ρµ + Ω g q λ ρg ρσ λ Φ σ Φq µν ν Φ,.7 with Ω q µν µ Φ ν Φ = e 6Φ Vw, g µ χµ detg µ detgχ µ..8 Hee, we hve used [8] [ δq µν = δ [e Φ η µν e 4Φ V [ = q µν + 4 V dφ Ω + e 4Φ V Ω ]] e 4Φ Vw µφ ν Φ dv µ Φ ν Φ ] δφ, [ e 6Φ V Ω µφ ν Φ λ Φ λ δφ µ δφ ν Φ µ Φ ν δφ ]..9

6 6 III. STATIC SPHERICAL SOLUTIONS In this section, we conside sttic vcuum solutions with the spheiclly symmetic nstz. Fist, we conside the flt metic in spheicl coodintes η µν dx µ dx ν = dt +dr +R dω.. whee dω is the line element on unit sphee. Becuse the spheicl symmety enfoces the fct tht the GSG scl field Φ hs only dil-coodinte dependence, i.e., Φ = ΦR, the effective line element ds q becomes ds q q µν dx µ dx ν = e Φ dt + e6φ VΦ dr +e Φ R dω.. Now, conveting the dil coodinte to e Φ R, we find ds q = q µν dx µ dx ν = q µν dx µ dx ν = Bdt +Hd + dω,. whee B = e Φ, H = e4φ dφ..4 VΦ d Next, we impose the bidigonl spheiclly symmetic nstz [], i.e., g is lso digonl nd ssumed to be ds g = g µνdx µ dx ν = Ddt + d + γdω..5 Fom these ssumptions, the quntities defined in.5,.6,.7 e expessed s τ = 4 HB B γ D D + H +, ε = HB γ γ D H, χ µ = 0,.6 nd.4 becomes B H B + m M0 γ HB Mq [ D HB 4 γ HB B D + +B B γ D + H + γ ] HB D H = 0,.7 whee the pime indictes the deivtive with espect to. On the othe hnd,. eds + γ γ + γ + γ γ γ γ 4γ + γ γ [ m M0 B Mg D + H + ] B + = 0,.8 γ D

7 D D + D [ m M 0 M g + γ D γ D + γ + γ γ [ m M 0 M g γ + γ 4γ B D + H + γ + H ] 7 = 0, D D + γ γ D D D + γ γ + γ γ γ γ + D γ Dγ ] B D + H + + = 0..0 γ γ Note tht, in the bove expessions, the function H is defined s H 4B B.. B B Fom these field equtions, one cn find tht the Schwzschild metic is obtined s n exct solution, i.e., B = D = = M, γ =,. whee M is n bity constnt. Unfotuntely, it is difficult to obtin genel solutions of the field equtions explicitly, becuse of thei sevee nonlineity. Theefoe, we petub the metic ound the Minkowski spce to the fist ode. Then, the field equtions.7,.8,.9,.0 give n symptotic solution in vcuum hving whee µ is given by B = M D = M = M e µm +e µ ζm,. +O,.4,.5,.6 +e µ µl 0 M + ζm +O γ = +e µ µg 0 M + g +ζm +O µ = +ζm M 0 ζm g +M q nd ζ is constnt. The othe coefficients e detemined to be,.7 l 0 = ζ5ζ +M4 g M g M q M4 q M gζm g +M q, g 0 = ζm g M q M g, g = ζm g M q ζm g +M q..8

8 8 Hence, H is clculted s H = M e µm µ +highe odes in M,M nd e µ..9 Inteestingly, we note tht q 00 q = B H = µm e µ 0 in the smll mss limit µ 0, up to this ode. In the sme mnne, we lso find tht g 00 g vnishes in the smll mss limit µ 0, up to this ode. These symptotic behvios show diffeent cse fom the bigvity theoy with two tenso fields [, ]. In this section, we hve found tht the sttic spheicl solution of ou model is vey simil to the GR solution. In the next section, we conside the cosmology bsed on ou model. IV. COSMOLOGICAL SOLUTIONS A. Cosmology with two metics In this section, we ttempt to study the cosmologicl solution fo ou hybid model. We expect new nd inteesting scle-fcto behvio, s GSG is known to give non-stndd evolution of the scle fcto [0]. We fist ssume the totl ction s S +S mtte, whee S mtte = d 4 x detgl g g,ϕ g + d 4 x detql q q,ϕ q. 4. This fom is known s the sfest nd most inteesting choice in bigvity theoies fo cosmology [, ]. It is often efeed to s twin mtte model. Of couse, this ssumption involves the oiginl Hssn-Rosen theoy [] fo L q = 0. Now, the field equtions including mtte e [ Mg R g µν ] R gg µν m M0 [g µν t g q + g q µ ρg ρν + ] g q ν ρg ρµ = T g µν, 4. whee detgl g g g ρµ g σν, 4. detg g ρσ T µν

9 9 nd Mq VΦ q Φ+ m M0 detg [τ + ] dv ε+ gµχ µ detq V dφ = [ T q + ] dv E q + qµ V dφ Xµ, 4.4 whee T q T q µν q µν, E q Ω Tµν q µ Φ ν Φ, X µ e 4Φ V T µν q Eq µν ν Φ, 4.5 Ω with detql q q q ρµ q σν, q detq µ Xµ T µν q ρσ detq µ detqx µ. 4.6 To conside solutions of time-dependent homogeneous spce, we tke the GSG scl s time dependent function, Φ = Φt. Then, ds q becomes ds q = q µν dx µ dx ν = e6φ VΦ dt +e Φ dx. 4.7 If coodinte tnsfomtion is pefomed such tht dt = Nt e 6Φ VΦdt, new expession is ttined: ds q = q µν dx µ dx ν = q µν dx µ dx ν = Nt dt +e Φt dx = Nt dt +bt dx, 4.8 whee the scle fcto fo q is defined s bt e Φt. We gin conside the bidigonl nstz nd ssume tht g tkes the fom ds g = g µνdx µ dx ν = ct dt +t dx, 4.9 whee t is the scle fcto fo g. Note tht the metic is the usul flt Fiedmnn Lemîte Robetson Wlke metic fo ct =. If we set ct = t, we obtin the confoml fom of this metic. fluid We futhe ssume tht ech enegy-momentum tenso is given in the fom of pefect T µν g = ρ g +p g u µ g uν g +p gg µν, T µν q = ρ q +p q u µ q uν q +p qq µν, 4.0 whee u µ g nd u µ q e the fou-velocities tht stisfy g µν u µ gu ν g = nd q µν u µ qu ν q =, espectively. In the pesent cse, the fou-velocities hve the time-like component only.

10 0 Applying these nsätze, we find tht the field equtions 4., 4.4 cn be ewitten s Mg ȧ c +m M0 b = ρ g, 4. Mg ä c + ȧ ȧċ +m M 0 b c N = p g, 4. c Mq b b +ḃ N b b b ḃṅ [ ] + m M0 c τ b + bn b N b ε = [ ] T q b + b E q, 4. whee nd τ = 4 b N c b N c, ε = b N c N c, 4.4 T q = ρ q +p q, E q = ρ q. 4.5 The dot in the bove equtions denotes the deivtive with espect to the time coodinte t. We futhe ssume the consevtion of the enegy-momentum tenso: g µ Tµν g = detg µ detgt µν g +Γgν ρσ Tρσ g = 0, 4.6 whee Γg ν ρσ = gνλ ρ g λσ + σ g λρ λ g ρσ. 4.7 The consevtion gives ise to simple eqution fo the enegy density nd the pessue ρ g +ȧ ρ g +p g = Then, by pplying the Binchi identity to 4., o enging 4., 4., nd 4.8, one cn find simple eltion ȧ c = ḃ N. 4.9 We cn obtin n eqution without the second deivtive tem using 4., 4. nd 4.9. Futhe, using 4. nd 4.9 gin to eliminte ȧ nd ḃ, we obtin n lgebic eqution incopoting, b, N/c, ρ g, p g, ρ q, nd p q. The eqution cn be solved fo N/c nd yields N c = 4ρ g bm g ρ g+p g M g b M T q q b + b E q 6m M 0 Mq b b + m M 0 Mg m M 0 b M q b [ 4 b b + b b ] + m M 0 M g 5 4 b. 4.0

11 whee We futhe ssume q µt µν q = This consevtion eqution implies detq µ detqt µν q +Γq ν ρσt ρσ q = 0, 4. Γq ν ρσ = qνλ ρ q λσ + σ q λρ λ q ρσ. 4. Simple nsätze fo the equtions of stte ρ q +ḃ b ρ q +p q = p g = ω g ρ g, p q = ω q ρ q 4.4 whee ω g nd ω q e constnts, give the dependence on scle fctos, i.e., ρ g = ρ g0 0 whee ρ g0, ρ q0, 0, nd b 0 e constnts. +ωg +ωq b0, ρq = ρ q0 b, 4.5 Using ll of the nsätze, the N/c given by 4.0 cn be expessed s n function of nd b. Then, we cn obtin the time-development of nd b by solving the diffeentil equtions 4., 4.9, nd 4.0. Figue shows the esults of numeicl clcultions. Hee, we set M g = M q = M 0 fo simplicity. We lso set c = so tht the pmete t becomes the stndd cosmologicl time. The initil vlue of t is set to = 0 =. We egd the mtte s dust ω g = 0. In these clcultions, we set ρ q = 0 fo simplicity. The solutions e obtined fo two cses of diffeent mss pmetes m: M g m /ρ g0 = 0 Fig. nd M gm /ρ g0 = Fig.. 4 As the initil vlue b, we tke b =,,4,nd 5 in ech cse. Fo ll cses, bt ppoches t in the lte stges. Thus, fo the limit t, the scle fctos behve s the stndd Fiedmnn univese; this cn be undestood fom 4. nd 4.0. Along with the incese of nd b, the lst tem of both the numeto nd 4 Slightly lge vlues e used to demonstte cceleted expnsion in the numeicl esults explicitly. The cceletion cn be tuned lmost bitily. Fo detils, see the discussion below 4.7.

12 ,b t FIG.. Timeevolution ofsclefctossolidcuvesndbbokencuveswithm gm /ρ g0 = 0. The lines coespond to b =,,4,nd 5. Fo the pmetes employed hee, plese see the text. 5 4,b t FIG.. Time evolution of scle fctos solid cuves nd b boken cuves with M g m /ρ g0 =. The lines coespond to b =,,4,nd 5. Fo the pmetes employed hee, plese see the text. denominto of N/c 4.0 become dominnt. Hence, in lte stges, we find tht b nd ȧ ḃ. The Fiedmnn-like eqution 4. indictes tht the mtte is lso dominnt when is vey smll, s b ppoches / in the ely stge. We exmined the cse with ρ q 0 nd found tht thee is no qulittive diffeence in the behvio of the scle fctos if thee is compble mount of odiny mtte ω q 0 coupled to q, i.e., ρ q0 ρ g0. This is becuse b soon becomes lge, s N/c is lge when is smll: then, ρ q /b +ωq becomes smll. The eltive evolution of the two scle fctos cn be clely seen if the solutions e plotted on n,b-plne s shown in Figs. nd 4. The ows in the figues indicte the nomlized vecto ȧ ȧ,ḃ = 4.6 +ḃ +N /c,n/c,

13 t ech point. In these figues, the shded egions indicte tht the ight hnd side of 4. becomes negtive. 5 4 b 4 5 FIG.. Solutions plotted on,b-plne fo M gm /ρ g0 = b 4 5 FIG. 4. Solutions plotted on,b-plne fo M gm /ρ g0 =. Retuning to Figs. nd, we find tht cceleted expnsion occus fo eltively lge b. Fom 4. nd 4., one ives t the eqution ȧ = ρ c c Mg g +p g m M0 b Mg + N. 4.7 c If we tke c = hee, in othe wods, t is the stndd cosmologicl time in the system descibed by g, theleft hndsideof4.7edsä/. Thus, we cnconfim thtcceleted expnsion is only possible if b/ N/c >. Becuse the vlue of N/c is negtive o lmost zeo t t =, cosmic cceletion is fesible fo lge vlue of b/ nd fo lge vlue of M g m /ρ g0, which is confimed by the numeicl clcultions. A subtle point to note is tht q 00 = N vnishes t cetin points fo sufficiently lge b nd m : in othe wods, thee e deteminnt singulities []. As we hold tht q is

14 4 not genuine metic, no poblem exists especilly in the cse of L q = 0. The degenete metic, howeve, my induce field theoeticl poblems if the mtte field is coupled to q, i.e., L q 0. In this subsection, we hve found tht the of the physicl g cn exhibit cceleted expnsion if m nd the initil vlue of b/ e sufficiently lge, even if thee is no exotic mtte. It is woth noting tht the expnsion deceletes in the ely stges. The cceletion occus subsequently nd ends in the lte stges. B. Cosmology with composite metic Next, we conside model with composite metic, simil to the bigvity models poposed in [4, 5]. The ction fo mtte is now ssumed to be descibed with the composite metic G µν = α g µν +αβg µρ g q ρ ν +β q µν, 4.8 whee α nd β e constnts. The composite line element fo cosmology is given by ds G = G µνdx µ dx ν = αc+βn dt +α+βb dx C dt +A dx, 4.9 whee we use the sme symbols fo the components of the two metics s in the pevious subsection. The enegy-momentum tenso of the mtte field is undestood to be conseved with espect to the desciption when the composite metic is employed, i.e., G µ Tµν G = µ detgt µν G detg +ΓGν ρσ Tρσ G = 0, 4.0 nd we futhe ssume the pefect fluid fom fo the isotopic nd homogeneous univese to be whee u µ G stisfies G µνu µ G uν G =. T µν G = ρ G +p G u µ G uν G +p G G µν, 4. The field equtions e found using the tetment in [5] nd following simil clcultion to peviously, yielding M g M g ä c + ȧ ȧċ c ȧ c +m M0 b = α A ρ G, 4. +m M 0 b N c = α CA c p G, 4.

15 M q b N b [ = A b β b +ḃ b b ḃṅ bn ] b ρ G + Cb NA p G + m M 0 [ ] c τ b + b N b ε 5, 4.4 with the definition given in 4.4. Then, the Binchi identity yields the sme eltion s whee nd We cn solve ll the bove equtions to obtin C = 4A α b M g N = A α M g 6m M 0 M q ρ G βb m M 0 b M q N c = N C, 4.5 ρ G + α A p G + b b + m M 0 M g A αβ p b b Mq G b, 4.6 4A p A β G b b Mq b ρ G + βb A p G ] [4 b b + + m M b b Mg b Becuse N/c = ḃ/ȧ, 4. nd 4.5, 4.6, 4.7 cn expess the development of the scle fctos, if the eqution of stte fo mtte is given. Note tht N/c if ρ G,p G 0 nd b 0, s in the cse exmined in the pevious subsection. Hee, we gin tke simple ssumption fo the eqution of stte p G = ω G ρ G, 4.8 whee ω G is constnt. Then, the dependence on the scle fcto A is whee ρ G0 nd A 0 e constnts. ρ G = ρ G0 A0 A Note tht the following eltion holds: C c = αc+βn c 5 To be pecise, the identity leds to +ωg = α+β N c = α+βḃ ȧ = αȧ+βḃ ȧ m M0 A N αβ p G ḃ c ȧ = 0., 4.9 A = ȧ. 4.40

16 6 If we choose new cosmologicl time T, which stisfies dt = Cdt, this eltion is no moe thn da = ȧ dt c. Thus, if ȧ/c > 0, A lso inceses with T. Fom 4. nd 4., we find the second-ode diffeentil eqution ȧ = α A c c Mg ρ G + A p G m M0 b Mg + N c. 4.4 Using T, this eqution becomes C d A cdt = α A Mg ρ G + A p G m M 0 M g b + N. 4.4 c Povided C/c is positive, we expect tht cceleted expnsion of AT is only possible if b/ N/c >, s in the cse teted in the pevious subsection. Figue 5 shows the esults of numeicl clcultions fo the composite metic model. Hee, we set M g = M q = M 0 fo simplicity. We lso set c = so s to mke the pmete t the stndd cosmologicl time. The pmetes α,β e tken to be 0.5,0.5, m is chosen to stisfy Mg m /ρ G0 = 0, nd the initil vlue of the scle fcto t is set to = 0 =. We conside dust mtte ω G = 0. As the initil vlue b, we tke b =,,4,nd 5.,b,A t FIG. 5. Time evolution of scle fctos A = b solid cuves, gy solid cuves, nd b gy boken cuves. The lines coespond to b =,,4,nd 5. Fo the pmetes employed hee, plese see the text. The behvios of nd b e simil to the cse teted in the pevious subsection. This time, howeve, the physicl nd unique scle fcto is A. One cn see the novel behvio of At fom Fig. 5; howeve, we must be in mind tht t is not the most suitble cosmologicl time.

17 7 We plot AT fo b = ginst T in Fig. 6. Fo smll nd lge T, the solution esembles tht of the Fiedmnn univese. A only seems to ccelete in the intemedite e..5 A T FIG. 6. Plot of AT fo b = nd α = β = 0.5 T = t t =. Figue 7 shows plot of the solutions on the,b-plne. In this figue, the shded egion indictes whee the ight hnd side of 4. o C becomes negtive. Fo sufficiently lge b, we find tht the solution psses the point whee C = 0 nd da dt = 0 t the sme time, fo The degenete metic with G 00 = 0 is too cuious to ssign physicl mening. 5 4 b 4 5 FIG. 7. Solutions plotted on,b-plne fo α = β = 0.5. Thus, the initil vlue b cnnot be lge, fo instnce, b must be less thn in the cse of α = β = 0.5. If the vlue of α/β is lge, lge b is llowed. This fct cn be seen fom Figs. 8 nd 9, in which the solutions fo α = 0.65 nd β = 0.5 e plotted. The evolution of AT is plotted in Fig. 0 fo α = 0.65 nd β = 0.5. A lge initil vlue of b/ yields lge cceletion in the pemitted pmete nge.

18 8,b,A t FIG. 8. Solutions plotted on,b-plne fo α = 0.65 nd β = b 4 5 FIG. 9. Solutions plotted on,b-plne fo α = 0.65 nd β = 0.5. In this subsection, we hve found tht the physicl scle fcto A = α+βbcn exhibit cceleted expnsion if m nd the initil vlue of b/ e sufficiently lge. The pmetes e esticted by the condition tht the physicl metic should be non-degenete i.e., G 00 does not vnish. The expnsion shows successive deceletion, cceletion, nd deceletion. V. SUMMARY AND PROSPECTS In this ppe, we hve pesented GR GSG hybid model of gvity. We hve shown tht the exct Schwzschild solution is poduced nd the cceleting phse of the univese is obtined without the cosmologicl constnt in this model. In this ppe, we hve shown only qulittive nlyses, becuse thee e mny tunble pmetes of ou model, such s M q /M g, ρ q0, nd ω g ω q, s well s m, b, nd. Moeove, we cn ssume genel

19 9 4 A T FIG. 0. Plot of AT fo b = lowe cuve nd b = uppe cuve fo α = 0.65 nd β = 0.5 T = t t =. mixing of g nd q in S mix g,q othe thn the miniml choice consideed in the pesent ppe. Futhe esech should be followed in futue. Unfotuntely, ou model does not povide mechnism fo infltion. Howeve, becuse the ely phse of the univese in ou model esembles the Fiedmnn univese, incopotion of the infltion dynmics cn be ntully intoduced in the vey ely phse. The spect of infltion in the GR GSG hybid model is n impotnt subject fo futue study. The quntum cosmology of ou GR GSG hybid model is nothe vey inteesting subject, s the evolution of scle fctos is nively dependent on the initil conditions. In pticul, ou clssicl model cnnot void the singulity poblem, unfotuntely. Quntum cosmologicl ppoches to the poblem of singulities e common topics of study to which bimetic theoies e pplied [9]. In futue, we hope to investigte mny spects of GR GSG hybid gvity, such s compct objects, instbility poblems including initil fluctutions 6, nd nisotopic solutions in the model, s well s the bove-mentioned subjects. Though these investigtions, we will find the phenomenologicl limit of the theoy nd obtin the bility to constuct moe elistic model bsed on the pesent model. 6 If twin mtte exists in ou model L q 0, the pimodil fluctutions my exhibit novel behvio becuse of the pid expnsion of bt. Howeve, the poblem of degenete effective metic ises fo some pmete choices.

20 0 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This study is suppoted in pt by Gnt-in-Aid fom the Nikido Resech Fund. [] S. F. Hssn nd R. Rosen, JHEP [] S. F. Hssn nd R. Rosen, JHEP [] A. Schmidt-My nd M. von Stuss, J. Phys. A [4] C. de Rhm, G. Gbddze nd A. J. Tolley, Phys. Rev. Lett [5] S. F. Hssn nd R. A. Rosen, JHEP [6] S. F. Hssn, R. Rosen nd A. Schmidt-My, JHEP [7] K. Hintebichle, Rev. Mod. Phys [8] C. de Rhm, Living Rev. Reltivity [9] S. Nojii nd S. D. Odintsov, Phys. Lett. B [0] S. Nojii, S. D. Odintsov nd N. Shii, JCAP [] K. Bmb, A. N. Mkenko, A. N. Mygky, S. Nojii nd S. D. Odintsov, JCAP [] K. Bmb, S. Nojii nd S. D. Odintsov, Phys. Lett. B [] S. Nojii, S. D. Odintsov nd V. K. Oikonomou Phys. Rev. D [4] K. Bmb, Y. Kokusho, S. Nojii nd N. Shii, Clss. Qunt. Gv [5] S. Nojii nd S. D. Odintsov, Phys. Rep [6] S. Cpozziello nd M. De Luentis, Phys. Rep [7] T. Clifton, P. G. Feei, A. Pdill nd C. Skodis, Phys. Rep [8] M. Novello, E. Bittencout, U. Moschell, E. Goult, J. M. Slim nd J. D. Tonito, JCAP ; JCAP , E0. [9] M. Novello nd E. Bittencout, Xiv:.6984 [g-qc]. [0] E. Bittencout, U. Moschell, M. Novello, nd J. D. Tonito, Phys. Rev. D [] E. Bittencout, M. Novello, U. Moschell, E. Goult, J. M. Slim nd J. D. Tonito, Nonlin. Phenom. Complex Syst [] J. D. Tonito, A teoi geométic-escl d gvitção e su plicção à cosmologi, Tese de Doutodo Rio de Jneio, 04.

21 [] E. Bittencout, U. Moschell, M. Novello nd J. D. Tonito, Phys. Rev. D [4] I. C. Jdim nd R. R. Lndim, Xiv: [g-qc]. [5] N. Kn nd K. Shiishi, J. Theo. Appl. Phys [6] J. D. Tonito nd M. Novello, Xiv: [g-qc]. [7] B. P. Abbott et l., Phys. Rev. Lett [8] M. Novello, Tlk in Hot Topics in Moden Cosmology, Spontneous Wokshop IX, 7 Apil - My 05, Cgèse. [9] F. Dbi nd M. Mousvi, Xiv:5.0 [g-qc]. [0] T. Ktsugw nd S. Nojii, Phys. Rev. D [] J. Ennde nd E. Mötsell, JHEP [] K. Aoki nd K. Med, Phys. Rev. D [] P. Gti, W. Hu nd M. Wymn, Phys. Rev. D [4] C. de Rhm, L. Heisenbeg nd R. H. Ribeio, Clss. Qunt. Gv [5] A. Schmidt-My, JCAP