arxiv:hep-ph/ v3 18 Apr 2005

Transcription

1 Ref. SISSA 31/98/EP hep ph/ May, 1998 Diffrative-Like (or Parametri-Resonane-Like?) Enhanement of the Earth (Day-Night) Effet arxiv:hep-ph/ v3 18 Apr 2005 for Solar Neutrinos Crossing the Earth Core S.T. Petov a,b) a) Suola Internazionale Superiore di Studi Avanzati, I Trieste, Italy b) Istituto Nazionale di Fizia Nuleare, Sezione di Trieste, I Trieste, Italy Abstrat It is shown that the strong enhanement of the Earth (day-night) effet for solar neutrinos rossing the Earth ore in the ase of the small mixing angle MSW ν e ν µ(τ) transition solution of the solar neutrino problem is due to a new resonane effet in the solar neutrino transitions in the Earth and not just to the MSW effet in the ore. The effet is in many respets similar to the eletron paramagneti resonane. The onditions for existene of this new resonane effet are disussed. They inlude speifi onstraints on the neutrino osillation lengths in the Earth mantle and in the Earth ore, thus the resonane is a neutrino osillation length resonane. The effet exhibits strong dependene on the neutrino energy. Analyti expression for the probability aounting for the solar neutrino transitions in the Earth, whih provides a high preision desription of the transitions, inluding the new resonane effet, is derived. The impliations of our results for the searhes of the day-night asymmetry in the solar neutrino experiments are also briefly disussed. The new resonane effet is operative also in the ν µ ν e (ν e ν µ ) transitions of atmospheri neutrinos rossing the Earth ore. Also at: Institute of Nulear Researh and Nulear Energy, Bulgarian Aademy of Sienes, BG 1784 Sofia, Bulgaria. 0

2 1. Introdution In the present artile we show that the strong enhanement of the Earth effet in the transitions of the solar neutrinos rossing the Earth ore in omparison with the effet in the transitions of the only mantle rossing solar neutrinos, found [1 3] to our in the ase of the matter-enhaned small mixing angle ν e ν µ(τ) solution of the solar neutrino problem, is due to a new resonane effet in the transitions and not just to the MSW enhanement of the neutrino mixing aused by the matter in the ore. The effet is in many respets analogous to the eletron paramagneti resonane. The existene of the ore enhanement of the Earth matter effet was established numerially in the rather detailed and high preision studies of the day-night (D-N) effet for the Super-Kamiokande detetor, performed in [1 3] for the ν e ν µ(τ) and ν e ν s transition solutions. We have found, in partiular, that due to this enhanement the D-N asymmetry in the sample of events whose night fration is aused by the solar neutrinos whih ross the Earth ore before reahing the detetor, is in the ase of the small mixing ν e ν µ(τ) solution by a fator of up to six bigger than the D-N asymmetry determined using the whole night event sample produed by the solar neutrinos whih ross only the Earth mantle or the mantle and the ore. Suh a strong enhanement was interpreted to be purely due to the resonane in the neutrino transitions, generated by the effet of the ore matter on the neutrino mixing and taking plae in the Earth ore. We shaw in what follows that the origin of this enhanement is the presene of a new type of resonane in the transitions of the solar neutrinos rossing the Earth ore. For reasons to beome lear later we will use the term neutrino osillation length resonane for it. In the analyzes whih follow we use the Staey model from 1977 [4] as a referene Earth model. TheEarthradiusintheStaeymodelisR = 6371km. AsinallEarthmodelsknown to us, the density distribution is spherially symmetri and there are two major density strutures - the ore and the mantle, and a large number of substrutures (shells or layers). The ore has a radius R = km, so the Earth mantle depth is approximately R man = km. The mean matter densities in the ore and in the mantle read, respetively: ρ = 11.5 g/m 3 and ρ man = 4.5 g/m 3. Let us note that the density distribution in the 1977 Staey model pratially oinides with the density distribution in the more reent PREM model [5]. 1

3 We will assume in the present study that the simplest two-neutrino ν e ν µ(τ) or ν e ν s mixing (with nonzero mass neutrinos), ν s being a sterile neutrino, takes plae in vauum and that it is at the origin of the solar ν e matter-enhaned transitions into ν µ(τ) or ν s in the Sun, produing the observed solar neutrino defiit. 2. Enhanement of the Transitions of Solar Neutrinos Crossing the Earth Core Beause of the spherial symmetry of the Earth, the path of a neutrino in the Earth mantle before the neutrino reahes the Earth ore is idential to the path in the mantle after the neutrino exits the ore; in partiular, the lengths of the two paths in the mantle are equal. For the same reason a given neutrino trajetory is ompletely speified by its Nadir angle [2]. It proves onvenient to analyse the Earth effet in the transitions of solar neutrinos whih ross the Earth ore by using the two-layer model of the Earth: all the interesting features of the transitions an be understood quantitatively in the framework of this rather simple model. The density profile of the Earth in the two-layer model is assumed to onsist of two strutures - the mantle and the ore, having different densities, ρ man and ρ, and different eletronfrationnumbers, Y man e andy e,noneofwhihhowevervarywithinagivenstruture. The ore radius and the depth of the mantle are known with a rather good preision and these data are inorporated in the Earth models [4,5]. The densities ρ man and ρ in the ase of interest should be onsidered as mean effetive densities along the neutrino trajetories, whih an vary somewhat with the hange of the trajetory: ρ man = ρ man and ρ = ρ. In the Staey model one has: ρ man = (4 5) g/m 3 and ρ = (11 12) g/m 3. For the eletron fration numbers in the mantle and in the ore one an use the standard values [4 6] (see also [1]) Y man e = 0.49 and Y e = Numerial alulations show [7] that, e.g., the time-averaged probability P alulated within the two-layer model of the Earth with ρ man and ρ taken from the Staey 1977 model [4] reprodues with a remarkably high preision the probability alulated by solving numerially the relevant system of evolution equations with the muh more sophistiated Earth density profile of the Staey model [4]. The term whih aounts for the Earth matter effet in the solar ν e survival probability 2

4 1 in the ase of interest is the probability of the ν 2 ν e transition in the Earth, P, where ν 2 is the heavier of the two mass eigenstate neutrinos in vauum. The probability amplitude of interest A(ν 2 ν e ), P = A(ν 2 ν e ) 2, is given by the following simple expression in the two-layer model: A(ν 2 ν e ) = sinθ + ( e i2 E X 1 )[ 1+ ( e i E X 1 ) os 2 (θ m θ m) ] os(θ θ m)sinθ m + ( e i E X 1 ) os(θ θ m )sinθ m ( e i E X 1 ) ( e i E X 1 ) sin(2θ m 2θ m )os(θ 2θ m ). (1) Here θ m and θ m E ( E ) = m2 2E ( 1 ρ man () ρ res man () ) 2 os 2 2θ+sin 2 2θ, (2) are the mixing angles in matter in the mantle and in the ore, respetively, sin 2 2θ m (sin 2 2θ m) = sin 2 2θ (1 ρ, (3) man() ρ res ) 2 os 2 2θ+sin 2 2θ man() X is half of the distane the neutrino travels in the mantle and X is the length of the path of the neutrino in the ore, and ρ res man and ρres are the resonane densities in the mantle and in the ore. The latter an be obtained from the expressions ρ res a = m2 os2θ 2E 2G F Y e m N, ν e ν µ(τ) transitions, (4) ρ res m 2 os2θ s = 2E m 1 N, ν e ν s transitions, (5) 2G F 2 (3Y e 1) m N being the nuleon mass, by using the speifi values of Y e in the mantle and in the ore. We have ρ res man ρ res (but ρ res man ρ res ) beause Ye = and Ye man = Obviously, 1 This is the probability that a solar ν e will not be onverted into ν µ(τ) (or ν s ) when it travels from the entral part of the Sun to the surfae of the Earth and further rosses the Earth to reah the detetor. 3

5 Ye ρres = Ye man ρ res man. For a neutrino trajetory whih is speified by a given Nadir angle h, the following relations hold true: X = R osh R 2 R2 sin 2 h, X = 2 R 2 R2 sin 2 h. (6) It is not diffiult to find from eq. (1) that for any θ the probability of interest P has the form: P = sin 2 θ [1 os E X ] [ sin 2 (2θ m θ) sin 2 θ ] [1 os E X ][1 os E X ] [ sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m +θ) sin2 (2θ m θ)] 1 4 [1 os E X ][1 os2 E X ] [ sin 2 (2θ m θ) sin 2 θ ] os 2 (2θ m 2θ m) [1+os E X ][1 os2 E X ] [ sin 2 (2θ m θ) sin2 θ ] sin E X sin2 E X [ sin 2 (2θ m θ) sin2 θ ] os(2θ m 2θ m ) [os( E X E X ) os( E X + E X )]sin(4θ m 2θ)sin(2θ m 2θ m). (7) The effet of the ore enhanement of the probability P was established to be dramati [1 3]atsmallmixingangles, sin 2 2θ < Forsin 2 2θ < 0.10,theprobabilityP, onsidered as a funtion of E/ m 2, or equivalently of the density parameter [1 3] ρ r = m2 os2θ 2E 2G F C a(s) m N, (8) where the onstant C a(s) = 0.50 (0.25) for the ν e ν µ(τ) (ν e ν s ) transitions 2, an have several prominent loal maxima in its bulk region. When the MSW resonane (i.e., the resonane in sin 2 2θ m or sin2 2θ m ) takes plae in the Earth ore, we have ρres = ρ, and 2 The parameter ρ r would oinide with the resonane density if Y e were equal to 1/2 both in the mantle and in the ore; it is equivalent to E/ m 2, but gives an idea about the densities at whih one has an enhanement of the Earth matter effet and we have used it for the latter purpose in [1 3]. 4

6 orrespondingly 2θ m = π/2, while θ m = 1.7θ θ m. In the resonane region the probability P, as it follows from eq. (7), is given by the expression: P res 1 = 2 [1 os E X ]sin 2 (2θ m θ), (9) as long as the osillating fator 0.5(1 os E X ) is not small. Obviously, P res be suppressed even when sin 2 2θ m = 1 if in the resonane region of sin 2 2θ m an one has os E X = 1. In the latter ase the other terms in eq. (7), notably the last one with the fator sin(4θ m 2θ) sin(2θ m 2θ m ), an give substantial ontribution in P in the region where sin 2 2θ m is strongly enhaned by the matter effet. If the MSW resonane ours in the mantle, i.e., if ρ res man = ρ man, then 2θ m = π/2, π/2 θ m < θ θ m and at small mixing angles we expet P to be given in the resonane region of sin 2 2θ m approximately by the expression P mres = 1 4 [1+os E X ][1 os2 E X ]sin 2 2θ m. (10) Theeffet oftheorewillnotsuppress theprobabilityp mres inthisaseonlyifos E X = 1. However, if os E X = 1 we get P mres = 0 in spite of the resonane in sin 2 2θ m in the mantle. The probability P mres an also be suppressed if in the resonane region of sin 2 2θ m one has, e.g., (2 E X ) 2 1. In these ases P may turn out to be determined in the region of interest not by P mres, but rather by other terms in eq. (7) (see further). It is not diffiult to onvine oneself treating the phases E X and E X as independent parameters and θ, θ m and θ m as having fixed values that for any θ the probability P has a loal maximum if the following onditions are fulfilled: E X = π(2k +1), E X = π(2k +1), k,k = 0,1,2,..., (11) and sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m +θ) sin 2 θ > 0, sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m +θ)sin(2θ m 2θ m )sin(2θ m θ)os(2θ m 4θ m +θ) (12a) sin2 θsin(4θ m 8θ m +2θ)sin(4θ m 4θ m ) < 0. (12b) Conditions (11) are written in the most general form. As we shall see, the relevant onditions for the problem of interest - transitions of solar neutrinos rossing the Earth ore, orrespond 5

7 to k = k = 0. At the maximum one has: P max = sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m +θ). (13) This loal maximum will dominate in P at small mixing angles provided P max > ( ) max P mres, max P res, (14) and if it is suffiiently wide. It is not lear a priori whether inequalities (14) will hold in the ase of interest even if all the other onditions for the presene of the maximum in P are fulfilled. The requirements (12a) and (12b) are the two supplementary onditions whih ensure that P has a maximum when the equalities (11) hold 3. At small mixing angles ondition (12a) is fulfilled for ρ res man < (2 ρ Y e /( ρ manye man ) 1) ρ man = 17.4 g/m 3, ρ res man ρ man, and in this region ondition (12b) redues to the following simple onstraint 4 : os(2θ m 4θ m +θ) < 0 (15) It an be shown that onditions (12a) and (12b) (or ondition (15)) an be satisfied if ρ man < ρ res man, < ρ, (16) i.e., when 0 < 2θ m < π/2 and π/2 < 2θ m π. They are always fulfilled, in partiular, when ρ man ρ res man (2θ m = 2θ) and ρ /ρ res 1,tan 2 2θ (2θ m = π), but these inequalities are not realized for the Earth as ρ = 2.6 ρman ; moreover in this ase sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m +θ) = sin 2 (3θ) and at small mixing angles P max is suppressed. Atually, this observation indiates that the ratio between ρ and ρ man for the Earth is favorable for the effet under disussion. If, however, ρ man, ρ < ρ res man, (2θ m,2θ m < π/2, 2θ m < 2θ m ), the inequalities (12a) and (12b) will not hold. They do not hold also, e.g., for ρ man, ρ ρ res man,, aswell as when ρ res man = ρ man, ρ res < ρ or ρ res man > ρ man, ρ res = ρ. 3 If the sign of the inequality in eq. (12a) is opposite, P would have a minimum. 4 It is not diffiult to onvine oneself that in the problem of interest one always has: sin(2θ m 2θ m ) > 0 and sin(2θ m θ) > 0. 6

8 If only E X = π(2k +1), one finds from eq. (7) that for any θ P = sin 2 θ [1 os E X ] [ sin 2 (2θ m 4θ +θ) sin 2 θ ], E X = π(2k+1). (17) Note that at small mixing angles this expression differs from the one in eq. (9). Similarly, when E X = π(2k +1), for any θ we obtain: P = sin 2 (2θ m θ) [1 os E X ] [ sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m +θ) sin2 (2θ m θ)] 1 2 [1 os2 E X ] [ sin 2 (2θ m θ) sin2 θ ] os 2 (2θ m 2θ m ), E X = π(2k +1). (18) Let us disuss next the relevane and the impliations of the above results for the transitions of the solar neutrinos in the Earth. 2.1 MSW Resonane in the Earth Core Consider first the ase of ν e ν µ(τ) transitions. If the MSW resonane takes plae in the ore we have sin 2 2θ m = 1 for ρ res the maximum of P = P res the ondition = ρ = ( ) g/m 3. However, the position of (eq. (9)) in the resonane region of sin 2 2θ m is determined by E X = π(2k +1), k = 0,1,..., (19) for whih theosillating term ineq. (9), 0.5(1 os E X ), has a maximal value. For k = 0 thisondition isfulfilledfor theore-rossing neutrinos forρ res = ( )gr/m 3. Thus, the influene of the osillating term in eq. (9) shifts the position of the maximum of P res to values of ρ res whih differ from those at whih the maximum of sin 2 2θ m is loated. For the trajetory with h = 0 0, for instane, the maximum of P res ((E/ m 2 ) res a plae respetively at ρ res 14.5 g/m 3 ((E/ m 2 ) res a ours at ρ res = 13.4 g/m 3 = MeV/eV 2 ), while for those with h = 13 0 and h = 23 0 it takes = 14.2 g/m 3 ((E/ m 2 ) res a = MeV/eV 2 ) and ρ res = MeV/eV 2 ). At small mixing angles the values of ρ res at whih E X = π exhibit weak dependene on sin 2 2θ. At the position of the maximum of P res, sin 2 2θ m is still onsiderably enhaned by the matter effet: for sin2 2θ = 0.01, for instane, on finds for h = 13 0 ; 23 0 that at the maximum sin 2 (2θ m θ) = 0.15; For the trajetories with h = 0 0 ; 13 0 ; 23 0 we have max P res = = 0.20; 0.15; 0.11, in very good 7

9 agreement with the results of our numerial alulations 5 [1,2] (see Figs. 1a - 1). If solar neutrinos undergo ν e ν s transitions, the value of E/ m 2 orresponding to a given ρ res is for Y e = 0.467, as it follows from eqs. (2) and (3), by a fator of 2.33 larger than in the ase of ν e ν µ(τ) transitions: (E/ m 2 ) res s = 2.33(E/ m 2 ) res a. Sine E, E (E/ m 2 ) 1, ondition (20), E X = π, isnever satisfied forthe ore-rossing neutrinosin, orintheviinityof,theresonaneregionofsin 2 2θ m. Moreover, intheresonane region of interest E X is relatively small 6 and the osillating term in eq. (9) suppresses the probability P res. As a onsequene, P is given in the region of resonane enhanement of sin 2 2θ m by the expression: P res,s = 1 2 [1 os E X ]sin 2 (2θ m θ)+ 1 4 [1+os E X ][1 os2 E X ]sin 2 2θ m [os( E X E X ) os( E X + E X )]sin(4θ m 2θ)sin(2θ m 2θ m ). (20) The maximal value of P,s res at small mixing angles ours for the trajetory with, e.g., h = 0 0 (23 0 ) at ρ res = 10.9 g/m 3 (ρ res = 9.8 g/m 3 ) and its position essentially does not hange when sin 2 2θ varies from 10 3 to In the region of the maximum of P res,s, E X pratially does not depend on sin 2 2θ < 0.02 and for h = 0 0 (23 0 ) we have at the maximum: E X = 0.40π (0.38π). The value of the phase E X in the region of the maximum of P res,s depends on sin2 2θ: if, e.g., sin 2 2θ = 0.001; 0.01 we get for h = 0 0 (23 0 ) that at the maximum E X = 0.12π; 0.21π (0.15π; 0.19π). The mixing angle fators appearing in eq. (20) have the following values at the maximum for, e.g., sin 2 2θ = 0.01 and h = 23 0 : sin 2 (2θ m θ) = 0.43, sin4θ m = 0.43, and sin(2θ m 2θ m) = The last term in eq. (20) is either the dominant one (h = 23 0 ) or is omparable in magnitude to the first term and their sum gives the dominant ontribution in P res,s (h = 0 0 ). At the maximum the probability P res,s takes the following values for, e.g., sin 2 2θ = 0.01 and h = 0 0 ; 23 0 : max P res,s = 0.21; 0.15, whih is in good agreement with the numerial results 5 Let us note that for the indiated trajetories, at the positions of the orresponding maxima of P res one has E X = 3π/2 (h = 0 0 ), E X = 1.6π (h = 13 0 ) and E X = 2π (h = 23 0 ). 6 At the point where sin 2 (2θ m θ) = 0.8 (ρ res have E X = 0.2π. = 10.9 g/m 3 ) for sin 2 2θ = 0.01, for instane, we 8

10 in ref. [3] (see Figs. 2a - 2). It is interesting to note that for given h and sin 2 2θ one has: max P res,s max P res. 2.2 MSW Resonane in the Mantle Suppose that for the ore-rossing solar neutrinos the Earth matter effet leads to enhanement of sin 2 2θ m due to the MSW resonane in the mantle. We shall assume first that the (solar) ν e mix with ν µ(τ) in vauum. In the region of the enhanement of sin 2 2θ m the probability of interest P = P mres and is given approximately by eq. (10) as long as P mres is not rather strongly suppressed. Depending on the neutrino trajetory through the Earth ore, we will have sin 2 2θ m = 1 if ρ res m = ( ) g/m 3. However, the position of the maximum of P mres is determined by the position of the maximum of the osillating term 0.5(1+os E X ) in eq. (10), i.e., by the ondition E X = 2π(2k +1), k = 0,1,..., (21) and for most of the neutrino trajetories of interest differs from the position of the maximum of sin 2 2θ m. For h = 00 (13 0 ) and h = 23 0, for example, the ondition E X = 2π is realized at ρ res m = 5.9 (5.1) g/m 3 ((E/ m 2 ) mres a = (2.632) 10 6 MeV/eV 2 ), and at ρ res m = 4.0 g/m 3 ((E/ m 2 ) mres a = MeV/eV 2 ). Further, depending on the value of sin 2 2θ and on the trajetory, the maximum of P mres an lie outside or inside the resonane region of sin 2 2θ m. For the trajetories for whih for given sin 2 2θ < 0.02 the position of max P mres is within the resonane region of sin 2 2θ m (h > 15 0 if sin 2 2θ = 0.01, for instane), we have ( E X ) 2 1 at the maximum of P mres. Correspondingly, the term 0.5(1 os2 E X ) in the expression for P mres suppresses max P mres even when both E X = 2π and sin 2 2θ m = 1. For the same reason 0.5(1 os2 E X )sin 2 2θ m = (2πX /L v ) 2 sin 2 2θ and pratially does not depend on ρ m. When the maximum of P mres lies outside the resonane region of sin 2 2θ m, the term ontaining the fator sin E X sin2 E X in eq. (7) typially gives a non-negligible ontribution (15 30)% to the value of P mres at the maximum. Even in the latter ase sin 2 2θ m is rather strongly enhaned at the maximum of P mres. For the trajetories orresponding to h = 0 0 ; 13 0 ; 23 0 we get for sin 2 2θ = 0.01: max P mres = 0.14; 0.10; 0.07, in very good agreement with our numerial results [1,2] (Figs. 1a - 1). Note that at small mixing angles max P mres is smaller than max P res typially by a fator of

11 If ν e ν s mixing takes plae in vauum, a given value of ρ res m orresponds now to a 2.09 larger value of E/ m 2 than in the ase of ν e ν µ(τ) mixing: (E/ m 2 ) mres s 2.09(E/ m 2 ) mres a. For this reason the ondition E X = 2π is never satisfied for the ore-rossing neutrinos for values of ρ res m lying in, or relatively lose, to the resonane region of sin 2 2θ m. For h = 00 (13 0 ), sin 2 2θ = 0.01 and ρ res m = 5.9 (5.1) g/m 3, for instane, E X = π, and P mres is suppressed. For this value of ρ res m we have ( E X ) 2 1 and E X dereases with the dereasing of ρ res m. As a onsequene of these irumstanes, in the ase of solar ν e ν s transitions, the probability P at small mixing angles does not have a loal maximum in the region of the resonane enhanement of sin 2 2θ m : as ρres m inreases from 3.0 g/m 3 to 6.0 g/m 3, P inreases monotonially 7. This is well illustrated in Figs. 2a Diffrative-Like Peak (or Parametri Resonane?) in P : the Maximal Core Enhanement of the Earth Effet It is quite remarkable that for the ν e ν µ(τ) solution of the solar neutrino problem onditions (11) are approximately fulfilled and the maximal enhanement of the Earth effet in the solar neutrino transitions at small mixing angles takes plae for ρ res man, satisfying inequalities (16) and not in the regions of the two possible MSW resonanes (Figs. 1a - 1). Indeed, for, e.g., sin 2 2θ = 0.01 and the trajetories orresponding to h = 0 0 ; 13 0 ; 23 0 we get E X = π for ρ res m = 10.0; 9.6; 8.0 g/m 3 ((E/ m 2 ) mres a = = 1.646; 1.401; MeV/eV 2 ). At the indiated values of ρ res m the phase E X is smaller than, but for most of the trajetories - rather lose to, π. For the three trajetories indiated above we have: E X = 0.55π; 0.75π; 0.88π. When E X = π, whih takes plae at smaller values of ρ res m, e.g., in the example onsidered above at ρres m = 8.7; 8.4; 7.6 g/m 3, the phase E X is somewhat smaller than π (in our example E X = ( )π). The same onlusions are valid for the other trajetories of interest and values of sin 2 2θ < Atually, the requirement that E X = E X = π is equivalent at small mixing angles 7 Lets us note that the Earth effet in the transitions of the neutrinos rossing only the mantle an be understood very well qualitatively and quantitatively using the one-layer approximation for the density distribution in the Earth mantle (see, e.g., ref. [8]). 10

12 in the ase of interest to the ondition π [ 1 X + 1 ] = G F 2 (Y X e m ρ Ye man ρ man ). (22) N It is not diffiult to onvine oneself using eq. (6), the values of the ore and Earth radii R and R and the values of Ye, ρ, Ye man satisfied for the trajetories of neutrinos rossing the Earth ore. and ρ man that the above equality annot be exatly The position of the absolute maximum of P, whih ould be loated, e.g., lose to one of the two values of ρ res man at whih E X = π or E X = π, is determined primarily by the properties of the funtion sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m +θ). The latter has a minimum (although a relatively shallow one) at ρ res man 7.5 g/m3 at small mixing angles, and inreases rather steeply monotonially when ρ res man inreases from 7.5 g/m3 to 11.5 g/m 3. Sine E X = π ours at larger values of ρ res man than the equality E X = π, the position of the maximum of P of interest on the ρ res man axis pratially oinides with the position of the point where E X = π. Correspondingly, the value of P at the maximum is determined by the expression (17). For sin 2 2θ = 0.01 and h = 0 0 ; 13 0 ; 23 0 we get max P = 0.51; 0.46; 0.40, whih is in beautiful agreement with the results of our numerial alulations [1] (see Figs. 1a - 1). Note that, indeed, for a given trajetory through the ore and given sin 2 2θ 0.10, max P exeeds max P res and max P mres respetively by the fators of 2.5 to 4.0 and of 3.0 to 7.0. Moreover, beause the MSW resonane in the ore (and the orresponding maximum) is loated relatively lose in ρ res man (or E/ m 2 ), the peak in P under disussion is rather wide 8. In any ase it is wider than any of the loal maxima orresponding to the MSW enhanement of the mixing at small mixing angles. Itshouldbenotedalsothatitisthespeifiombinationofmixingangles, (2θ m 4θ m+θ), and the fat that ρ and ρ man do not differ by a large fator for the Earth, whih makes sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m + θ) relatively large in the region of interest. The quantities sin2 2θ m and sin 2 2θ m assoiated with the MSW effet an be atually rather small: if, for instane, sin 2 2θ = 0.01, we find that at the position of the maximum of P under disussion, for the 8 Atually, as Fig. 1 indiates, for sin 2 2θ < 0.01 and 0 0 h < 15 0 the MSW maximum appears just as a shoulder on the slope of the maximum related to the onditions (11). 11

13 trajetory with h = 23 0 one has sin 2 2θ m = 0.08 and sin 2 2θ m = 0.05, while sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m + θ) = It is quite interesting that, as our analysis shows, for values of ρ res man from the interval ( ) g/m 3, onditions (11) are not even approximately fulfilled if solar neutrinos take part in ν e ν s transitions, and hene the effet of strong enhanement of the probability P onsidered above does not take plae in this ase. However, as disussed in Setion 2.1, when the MSW resonane ours in the ore, the purely MSW-like term (9) in P, P res, is assisted by some of the additional interferene terms in P (see eq. (20)) and at the orresponding maximum, P is by a fator of (2 4) bigger than just P res. Still, at small mixing angles, sin 2 2θ < 0.02, the value of P at its absolute maximum in the ν e ν s ase is smaller than the orresponding value when ν e ν µ(τ) transitions take plae by a fator of ( ) (see also [3]). As to the physial nature of this new type of enhanement of the probability P whih aounts for the Earth effet in the solar neutrino transitions, it resembles the onstrutive interferene of waves after diffration, and the orresponding peak in P - a diffrative peak. This analogy (although not diret) is related to the fat that the amplitude of interest, A(ν 2 ν e ), has the following form in the two-layer model: A(ν 2 ν e ) = l,l =e,µ(τ) A man (ν 2 ν l )A (ν l ν l )Aman (ν l ν e), (23) where A man (ν 2 ν l ) and A man (ν l ν e ) are the probability amplitudes of the ν 2 ν l and ν l ν e transitions in the Earth mantle (whih is rossed twie by the neutrinos whih traverse the Earth), while A (ν l ν l) is the probability amplitude of ν l ν l transitions in the ore, l,l = e,µ(τ). It is the onstrutive interferene of the different amplitudes in the sum in eq. (23) whih leads to the remarkable enhanement of the probability P for the ore-rossing neutrinos. Anotherpossibleinterpretationoftheenhanement oftheprobabilityp disussed above is the existene of a parametri-like resonane in the ν 2 ν e transitions in the Earth for whih the onditions eq. (11) are approximately satisfied, although the term parametrilike does not suggest any speifi analogy. The possibility of a parametri-like enhanement of the ν e ν µ transitions in matter with density hanging periodially but not ontinuously along the neutrino path was onsidered in ref. [9]. Let us note that the ase studied in ref. 12

14 [9] is different from the ase onsidered by us. Although in [9] one period in the variation of density was assumed to onsist of two layers with different finite densities (periodi step funtion), it was supposed that the two layers have equal spatial dimensions (widths) and that the matter density is a periodi step funtion, i.e. that neutrinos ross an integer number of periods in density while they propagate in matter. This does not orrespond to the density profile of the Earth in the two-layer approximation. Further, the results presented in [9] were derived in the speifi ase of small vauum mixing angle and for ρ man ρ res man, ρ ρ res. It should be lear fromthe disussion following eq. (16) that this speifi ase also does not orrespond to the one of transitions of neutrinos rossing the Earth ore studied by us here 9. Finally, the relevant probability for the solar neutrino transitions in the Earth is the ν 2 ν e and not the ν e ν µ transition probability whih atually was onsidered in [9]. There exists a beautiful analogy between the resonane effet disussed in the present Setion and the eletron paramagneti resonane taking plae in a speifi onfiguration of magneti fields 10 : one onstant, B 0, loated in the xoz plane of the oordinate system and having a diretion whih forms an angle 2θ with the z-axis, os2θ > 0, and a seond, B 1, along the z-axis, whose magnitude an hange step-wise in time. In the initial moment t = t 0 the eletron spin points up along the z-axis and in the interval of time t 1 = t 1 t 0 > 0 it is assumed to preess in the field B 0 and in the onstant field B 1 pointing down along the z-axis and having a relatively small magnitude so that B z = B 0 os2θ B 1 > 0, where B 0,1 = B 0,1. At t = t 1 the field B 1 inreases onsiderably (step-wise) in magnitude and in the interval of time t 2 = t 2 t 1 > 0 we have B z = B 0 os2θ B 1 < 0. Finally, at t = t 2, B 1 hanges (again step-wise) to its initial value and the preession of the eletron spin ontinues in suh a onfiguration of fields for 11 t 3 = t 3 t 2 = t 1. As an be shown, there is one- 9 In the earlier version of the present work (hep-ph/ of May 8, 1998) we have inorretly stated that onditions (11) appear also in the speifi ase studied in ref. [9]. 10 The author is grateful to L. Wolfenstein who brought this analogy to the author s attention. 11 The last set of onditions is redundant in the ase of the eletron paramagneti resonane: we have added it to make the analogy with the transitions of the neutrinos rossing the Earth ore 13

15 to-one orrespondene between the physial quantities haraterizing this problem and the ones in the problem of transitions of neutrinos rossing the Earth ore. At small values of sin 2 2θ the probability P orresponds to the probability of the spin flip of the eletron. It is known that the latter an be made maximal ( = 1) by hoosing t 1, t 2, B 0 and the two values of B 1 in suh a way that the preession angles in the intervals of time t 1 and t 2 obey onditions equivalent to (11) and the analog of the funtion sin 2 (2θ m 4θ m + θ) for this problem be lose to 1. Obviously, in the ase of neutrinos rossing the Earth ore the parameters are muh more onstrained beause they are predetermined by the properties of the Earth, the limited interval of energies of solar neutrinos and the rather small range of relevant values of m 2. It seems almost a mirale that onditions (11) an be fulfilled even approximately for the requisite values of m 2 and E and that the strong enhanement of the probability P, assoiated with the onditions (11), (12a) and (12b) atually takes plae. Sine the existene of the resonane effet we have disussed depends ruially on the onditions (11) whih for a given neutrino trajetory through the Earth are atually onditions on the neutrino osillation length in the Earth ore, L = 2π/ E, and mantle, L man = 2π/ E, we shall use the term neutrino osillation length resonane 12. In ontrast, the MSW effet is a resonane effet in the neutrino mixing. The impliations of the osillation length resonane enhanement of the probability P for the ore-rossing solar neutrinos for the tests of the ν e ν µ(τ) transition solution of the solar neutrino problem via the measurement of the day-night effet related observables are disussed indetailinref.[1](seealso[2,3]). Itisquiteremarkablethatforvaluesof m 2 from the small (and part of the large) mixing angle MSW solution region the enhanement takes plae for values of the 8 B neutrino energy lying in the interval (6 12) MeV to whih the Super-Kamiokande and SNO experiments are sensitive. The peak in P at sin 2 2θ = 0.01 for omplete. 12 In the earlier version of the present artile (hep-ph/ of May 8, 1998) we have used onditionally the term diffrative-like enhanement for the new resonane effet. We think that neutrino osillation length resonane better desribes the essene of the effet. 14

16 the trajetory with h = 23 0 taking plae at ρ res man 8.0 g/m3, for instane, orresponds to E = 5.3 (10.5) MeV if m 2 = 4.0 (8.0) 10 6 ev 2. Correspondingly, at small mixing angles this enhanement leads to a muh bigger (by a fator of 6) day-night asymmetry in the sample of events due to the ore-rossing solar neutrinos in the Super-Kamiokande detetor than the asymmetry determined by using the whole night event sample[1]. As a onsequene, it may be possible to test a rather large part of the small mixing angle solution region in the m 2 sin 2 2θ plane by performing seletive day-night asymmetry measurements. The new enhanement effet also leads to a rather large day-night asymmetry in the reoil - e spetrum whih is being measured in the Super-Kamiokande experiment [1]. It is not exluded that some of the future high statistis solar neutrino experiments will be able to observe diretly this effet. A detetor loated at smaller geographial latitudes than the existing ones or those under onstrution [10] would obviously be better suited for this purpose. 3. Conlusions Wehave shown inthepresent workthat thestrong enhanement oftheeartheffet inthe transitions of the solar neutrinos rossing the Earth ore in omparison with the effet in the transitions of the only mantle rossing neutrinos in the ase of the MSW small mixing angle ν e ν µ(τ) transition solution of the solar neutrino problem [1,2], is due to a new osillation length resonane effet in the transitions and not just to the MSW enhanement of the neutrino mixing taking plae in the Earth ore. The effet exhibits strong energy dependene. We have derived analyti expression for the relevant transition probability in the two-layer approximation for the density distribution in the Earth, whih reprodues with high preision the probability alulated numerially by using the Earth density profile provided by the Earth model [4]. The general onditions for the existene of the osillation length resonane in the solar neutrino transitions in the Earth were obtained and it was shown that at small mixing angles they are approximately satisfied in the ase of ν e ν µ(τ) transitions. These onditions are not fulfilled if solar neutrinos undergo ν e ν s transitions. Nevertheless, a similar but weaker (in what regards the maximal value of the relevant transition probability P ) enhanement takes plae in the region of the MSW resonane in the ore in the latter ase. For solar neutrino transitions into ative neutrino and for the geographial latitudes at 15

17 whih the Super-Kamiokande and SNO experiments are loated, the resonane enhanement takes plae in the neutrino energy interval (5 12) MeV if m 2 = ( ) 10 6 ev 2, whih is just in the region of the small mixing angle MSW solution. If the transitions are into sterile neutrino it ours at approximately two times larger neutrino energies for the same values of m 2. The osillation length resonane enhanement is present at large mixing angles in the transitions of solar neutrinos into an ative neutrino [1,2] as well. It an also be present in the ν µ ν e (and ν e ν µ ) transitions of atmospheri neutrinos [11]. The probability of the ν µ ν e (ν e ν µ ) transitions, P(ν µ ν e ) = P(ν e ν µ ), and the analogs of the maximum onditions (12a) and (12b) for this probability (onditions (11) are the same as for P ) an be obtained from eqs. (7), (12a) and (12b) by formally setting θ = 0 while keeping θ m 0 and θ m 0. Thus, ondition (12a) beomes sin2 (2θ m 4θ m ) > 0 and is always fulfilled, while ondition (12b) transforms into os(2θ m 4θ m ) < 0. (24) At small mixing angles, sin 2 2θ < 0.05, we have P = P(νµ ν e ) and thus Fig. 1 illustrates the dependene of P(ν µ ν e ) on ρ r as well. The new enhanement mehanism an be effetive in this ase for ρ res and ρ res m satisfying inequalities (16). For sin 2 2θ = 0.01, m 2 = 10 3 ( ) ev 2, and enter-rossing (h = 0 0 ), for instane, the absolute maximum of P(ν µ ν e ) takes plae at E = 1.6 (0.8) GeV. Thus, for values of m 2 ( ) ev 2 of the region of the ν µ ν τ osillation solution of the atmospheri neutrino problem the osillation length resonane strongly enhanes the ν µ ν e (and ν e ν µ ) transitions of the atmospheri neutrinos rossing the Earth ore, making the transition probabilities large (and perhaps the transitions detetable) even at small mixing angles. The transitions under disussion should exist if three-flavour-neutrino mixing takes plae in vauum Atually, the exess of e-like events in the region 1 osθ z 0.6, θ z being the Zenith angle, in the sub-gev sample of atmospheri neutrino events observed in the Super-Kamiokande experiment (see, e.g., Y. Fukuda et al., hep-ex/ and submitted to Physis Letters B), 16

18 The new enhanement mehanism of P(ν µ ν e ) is operative at large mixing angles as well, at whih the probabilities P and P(ν µ ν e ) exhibit different dependene on E/ m 2 [11]. The effets of the osillation length resonane enhanement of the solar neutrino transitions in the Earth an be observed in the urrently operating high statistis solar neutrino experiments (Super-Kamiokande, SNO) by performing seletive day-night asymmetry measurements [1]. A high statistis solar neutrino detetor loated at smaller geographial latitudes would be better suited for the observation of this enhanement. an be due to ν µ ν e small mixing angle, sin 2 2θ eµ = ( ), transitions with m ev 2, strongly enhaned by the neutrino osillation length resonane as neutrinos ross the Earth ore on the way to the detetor. Suh transitions are naturally predited to exist in a threeneutrino mixing sheme, in whih, e.g., the small mixing angle MSW ν e ν µ transitions with m 2 21 (4 8) 10 6 ev 2, or large mixing angle ν e ν µ osillations with m ev 2, provide the solution of the solar neutrino problem and the atmospheri neutrino anomaly is due to ν µ ν τ large mixing angle osillations with m ev 2. It should be added that if m 2 31 = ev 2, the exess of e-like atmospheri neutrino events in the Super-Kamiokande data due to the neutrino osillation length resonane should be present in the multi-gev sample at 1 osθ z <

19 Aknowledgements. The author would like to thank M. Maris for valuable disussions of the day-night effet, V. Rittenberg for his kind and supportive interest in the present work and B. Mahet for helpful omments on the interpretation of the new effet suggested and disussed in this paper. Thanks are also due to Zhenia Akhmedov, to whom the author ommuniated the main results of the present work long before they were assembled in the present publiation, for graiously waiting for the text of this artile to be written in order to publish his own omments on the subjet of the present study. This work was supported in part by the Italian MURST under the program Fisia Teoria delle Interazioni Fondamentali and by Grant PH-510 from the Bulgarian Siene Foundation. 18

20 REFERENCES [1] M. Maris and S.T. Petov, Phys. Rev. D 56, 7444 (1997). [2] Q.Y. Liu, M. Maris and S.T. Petov, Phys. Rev. D 56, 5991 (1997). [3] M. Maris and S.T. Petov, SISSA Report ref. SISSA 154/97/EP, Marh 1998, E-arhive report hep-ph/ [4] F.D.Staey, Physis of the Earth, 2 nd edition, JohnWiley andsons, London, NewYork, [5] A.D. Dziewonski and D.L. Anderson, Physis of the Earth and Planetary Interiors 25, 297 (1981). [6] R. Jeanloz, Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Si. 18, 356 (1990); C.J. Allègre et al., Earth Planet. Si. Lett. 134, 515 (1995); W.F. MDonough and S.-s. Sun, Chemial Geology 120, 223 (1995). [7] M. Maris and S.T. Petov, in preparation; M. Maris, Q.Y. Liu and S.T. Petov, preliminary study performed in Deember of 1996 (unpublished). [8] A.J. Baltz and J. Weneser, Phys. Rev. D 50, 5971 (1994). [9] E.Kh. Akhmedov, Yadernaya Fizika 47 (1988) 475. [10] J.M. Gelb, W. Kwong and S.P. Rosen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 2296 (1997). [11] S.T. Petov, in preparation. 19

21 Figure Captions Figure 1. The dependene of the probability P on ρ r (see eq. (8)) in the ase of ν e ν µ(τ) transitions of solar neutrinos for sin 2 2θ = 0.01 (from ref. [2]). The five plots are obtained for 0.1 gr/m 3 ρ r 30.0 gr/m 3 (Y man e = 0.49, Y e = 0.467) and five different solar neutrino trajetories in the Earth determined by the Nadir angle h: a) h = 0 0 (enter rossing), b) h = 13 0 (winter solstie for the Super-Kamiokande detetor), ) h = 23 0 (half ore for the Super-Kamiokande detetor), d) h = 33 0 (ore/mantle boundary), e) h = 51 0 (half mantle). Figure 2. The dependene of the probability P on ρ r for ν e ν s transitions of solar neutrinos (from ref. [3]). The five plots were obtained for sin 2 2θ = 0.01 and the same neutrino trajetories as in figure 1. 20

22

23