Stefano Gariazzo. Light sterile neutrino: the 2018 status. IFIC, Valencia (ES) CSIC Universitat de Valencia
|
|
- Quentin Sparks
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Stefano Gariazzo IFIC, Valencia (ES) CSIC Universitat de Valencia Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, Chicago, 03//08
2 Neutrino Oscillations - Some theory Electron (anti)neutrino disappearence 3 Muon (anti)neutrino disappearence 4 Electron (anti)neutrino appearence [ev ] m 4 Global Fit σ σ 3σ 5 Global fit 6 Sterile neutrinos and CEνNS 4 3 sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 3σ Dis App 7 Conclusions
3 Neutrino Oscillations - Some theory Electron (anti)neutrino disappearence 3 Muon (anti)neutrino disappearence 4 Electron (anti)neutrino appearence 5 Global fit 6 Sterile neutrinos and CEνNS 7 Conclusions
4 The Standard Model of Particle Physics st nd 3rd generation standard matter unstable matter force carriers Goldstone bosons outside standard model 6 quarks (+6 anti-quarks) 6 leptons (+6 anti-leptons).3 umev up 4.8 MeV d down 5 ekev electron < ν ev e e neutrino R/G/B R/G/B /3 / /3 / / /.8 cgev R/G/B /3 charm / 95 smev /3 strange / 5.7 µ MeV muon ν < 90 kev µ µ neutrino R/G/B / / 73. GeV topt 4.7 GeV b bottom.777 τgev tau < ν8. MeV τ τ neutrino R/G/B R/G/B /3 / /3 / / / charge colors mass spin g gluon γ photon color 80.4 GeV ± 9. GeV W ± Z strong nuclear force (color) 5. GeV H Higgs electromagnetic force (charge) 0 weak nuclear force (weak isospin) graviton gravitational force (mass) fermions (+ anti-fermions) increasing mass 5 bosons (+ opposite charge W ) [D. Galbraith & C. Burgard, 0] S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3
5 The Standard Model of Particle Physics st nd 3rd generation standard matter unstable matter force carriers Goldstone bosons outside standard model 6 quarks (+6 anti-quarks) 6 leptons (+6 anti-leptons).3 umev up 4.8 MeV d down 5 ekev electron < ν ev e e neutrino R/G/B R/G/B /3 / /3 / / /.8 cgev R/G/B /3 charm / 95 smev /3 strange / 5.7 µ MeV muon ν < 90 kev µ µ neutrino R/G/B / / 73. GeV topt 4.7 GeV b bottom.777 τgev tau < ν8. MeV τ τ neutrino R/G/B R/G/B /3 / /3 / / / charge colors mass spin g gluon γ photon color 80.4 GeV ± 9. GeV W ± Z strong nuclear force (color) 5. GeV H Higgs electromagnetic force (charge) 0 weak nuclear force (weak isospin) graviton gravitational force (mass) fermions (+ anti-fermions) increasing mass 5 bosons (+ opposite charge W ) [D. Galbraith & C. Burgard, 0] S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3
6 Three Neutrino Oscillations ν α = 3 U αk ν k (α = e, µ, τ) k= U αk described by 3 mixing angles θ, θ 3, θ 3 and one CP phase δ CP Current knowledge of the 3 active ν mixing: [de Salas et al. (08)] NO: Normal Ordering, m < m < m 3 IO: Inverted Ordering, m 3 < m < m m = ( ) 5 ev m3 = (.50 ± 0.03) 3 ev (NO) = ( ) 3 ev (IO) sin (θ ) = sin (θ 3 ) = = sin (θ 3 ) = (NO) (IO) (NO) = (IO) First hints for δ CP 3/π χ χ sin θ 7 8 m [-5 ev ] sin θ 3 sin θ m 3 [-3 ev ] see also: S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3 δ/π
7 Two types of neutrinos flavor neutrinos ν α ν α = U αk ν k massive neutrinos ν k ν(t = 0) = ν α = U α ν + U α ν + U α3 ν 3 ν ν ν α ν 3 ν β source L detector ν(t > 0) = ν β = U α e ie t ν + U α e ie t ν + U α3 e ie 3t ν 3 ν α Ek = p + mk define t = L P να νβ (L) = ν α ν(l) = ( U βk U αku βju αj exp i m kj L ) E k,j m ij = m i m j S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 3/3
8 A large family In principle, previous discussion is valid for N neutrinos only constraint: there are exactly three flavor neutrinos in the SM [LEP, Phys. Rept. 47 (006) 57, arxiv:hep-ex/ ] N (Z) ν =.9840 ± through the measurement of the Z resonance e + e Z ν a ν a 0 a=e,µ,τ σ had [nb] 30 0 ALEPH DELPHI L3 OPAL neutrinos α > 3 must be sterile average measurements, error bars increased by factor ν 3ν 4ν E cm [GeV] sterile neutrino = SM singlet: no couplings with other SM particles S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 4/3
9 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 4/3 A large family In principle, previous discussion is valid for N neutrinos N N mixing matrix, N flavor neutrinos, N massive neutrinos ν e U e U e U e3 U e4. ν ν µ U µ U µ U µ3 U µ4 ν ν τ = U τ U τ U τ3 U τ4 ν 3 ν s U s U s U s 3 U s 4 ν
10 A large family In principle, previous discussion is valid for N neutrinos N N mixing matrix, N flavor neutrinos, N massive neutrinos ν e U e U e U e3 U e4. ν ν µ U µ U µ U µ3 U µ4 ν ν τ = U τ U τ U τ3 U τ4 ν 3 ν s U s U s U s 3 U s 4 ν Our case will be 3 (active)+ (sterile), a perturbation of 3 neutrinos case ν 6 angles m 4 m l ν l =,, 3 3 Dirac ν α ν 3 ν β CP phases m4 ev ν 4 m4 3 Majorana m43 CP phases L source detector S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 4/3
11 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 5/3 Short BaseLine (SBL) P να ν β (L) = ν α ν(l) = k,j U βk U αku βju αj exp ( i m kj L E ) If m 4 m l, faster oscillations ν 4 oscillations are averaged in most neutrino oscillation experiments Effect of 4th neutrino only visible as global normalization Short BaseLine (SBL) oscillations: m 4 L E At SBL, oscillations due to m and m 3 do not develop
12 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 5/3 Short BaseLine (SBL) P να ν β (L) = ν α ν(l) = k,j U βk U αku βju αj exp ( i m kj L E ) If m 4 m l, faster oscillations ν 4 oscillations are averaged in most neutrino oscillation experiments Effect of 4th neutrino only visible as global normalization Short BaseLine (SBL) oscillations: m 4 L E At SBL, oscillations due to m and m 3 do not develop APPearance (α β) ( ) ν α source of ( ) ν α ( ) ν β detect different flavor ( ) ν β
13 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 5/3 Short BaseLine (SBL) P να ν β (L) = ν α ν(l) = k,j U βk U αku βju αj exp ( i m kj L E ) If m 4 m l, faster oscillations ν 4 oscillations are averaged in most neutrino oscillation experiments Effect of 4th neutrino only visible as global normalization Short BaseLine (SBL) oscillations: m 4 L E At SBL, oscillations due to m and m 3 do not develop APPearance (α β) DISappearance ( ) ν α source of ( ) ν α ( ) ν β detect different flavor ( ) ν β ( ) ν α source of ( ) ν α ( ) ν s goes undetected
14 Short BaseLine (SBL) P να ν β (L) = ν α ν(l) = k,j U βk U αku βju αj exp ( i m kj L E ) If m 4 m l, faster oscillations ν 4 oscillations are averaged in most neutrino oscillation experiments Effect of 4th neutrino only visible as global normalization Short BaseLine (SBL) oscillations: m 4 L E At SBL, oscillations due to m and m 3 do not develop APPearance (α β) DISappearance ( ) ν α source of ( ) ν α ( ) ν β ( ) ν α ( ) detect different source ν s goes flavor ( ) ν β of ( ) ν α undetected CP violation cannot be observed in SBL experiments! S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 5/3
15 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 6/3 New mixings in the 3+ scenario 4 4 mixing matrix: U e U e U e3 U e4 U µ U µ U µ3 U µ4 U τ U τ U τ3 U τ4 U s U s U s 3 U s 4
16 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 6/3 New mixings in the 3+ scenario 4 4 mixing matrix: U e U e U e3 U e4 U µ U µ U µ3 U µ4 U τ U τ U τ3 U τ4 U s U s U s 3 U s 4 ϑ 4 ϑ 4 ϑ 34
17 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 6/3 New mixings in the 3+ scenario 4 4 mixing matrix: U e U e U e3 U e4 U µ U µ U µ3 U µ4 U τ U τ U τ3 U τ4 U s U s U s 3 U s 4 ϑ 4 ϑ 4 ϑ 34 DISappearance ( ) m P SBL sin ϑ ( ) αα sin 4 L ν ( ) α ν α 4E sin ϑ αα = 4 U α4 ( U α4 ) ( ) ν e ( ) ν e U e4 = sin ϑ 4 reactor gallium ( ) ν µ ( ) ν µ accelerator atmospheric U µ4 = cos ϑ 4 sin ϑ 4
18 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 6/3 New mixings in the 3+ scenario 4 4 mixing matrix: U e U e U e3 U e4 U µ U µ U µ3 U µ4 U τ U τ U τ3 U τ4 U s U s U s 3 U s 4 ϑ 4 ϑ 4 ϑ 34 DISappearance ( ) m P SBL sin ϑ ( ) αα sin 4 L ν ( ) α ν α 4E sin ϑ αα = 4 U α4 ( U α4 ) ( ) ν e ( ) ν e U e4 = sin ϑ 4 ( ) ν µ ( ) ν µ U µ4 = cos ϑ 4 sin ϑ 4 reactor gallium accelerator atmospheric APPearance ( ) m P SBL sin ϑ ( ) ν ( ) αβ sin 4 L α ν 4E β sin ϑ αβ = 4 U α4 U β4 ( ) ν µ ( ) ν e sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 quadratically suppressed! for small U e4, U µ4 LSND MiniBooNE KARMEN OPERA...
19 Neutrino Oscillations - Some theory Electron (anti)neutrino disappearence 3 Muon (anti)neutrino disappearence 3σ (solid dashed) Reactor Anomaly Gallium Anomaly 4 Electron (anti)neutrino appearence [ev ] m 4 5 Global fit 6 Sterile neutrinos and CEνNS 7 Conclusions NEOS+DANSS σ σ 3σ 3 sin ϑ ee
20 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 7/3 Gallium anomaly [SAGE, 006][Laveder, 007][Giunti&Laveder, 0] L.9 m L 0.6 m Gallium radioactive source experiments: GALLEX and SAGE ν e sources: e + 5 Cr 5 V + ν e e + 37 Ar 37 Cl + ν e E 0.75 MeV In the detector: E 0.8 MeV ν e + 7 Ga 7 Ge + e 3/ 500 kev 3/ 7 Ga 5/ 75 kev / 7 Ge 3 kev cross sections of the transitions from [Krofcheck et al., PRL 55 (985) 5] [Frekers et al., PLB 706 (0) 34]
21 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 7/3 Gallium anomaly [SAGE, 006][Laveder, 007][Giunti&Laveder, 0] L.9 m L 0.6 m Gallium radioactive source experiments: GALLEX and SAGE ν e sources: e + 5 Cr 5 V + ν e e + 37 Ar 37 Cl + ν e E 0.75 MeV In the detector: E 0.8 MeV ν e + 7 Ga 7 Ge + e Test detection of solar ν e 3/ 500 kev R =N exp N cal GALLEX SAGE Cr Cr R = 0.84 ± σ deficit GALLEX SAGE Cr Ar 3/ 7 Ga 5/ / 7 Ge 3 kev cross sections of the transitions from 75 kev [Krofcheck et al., PRL 55 (985) 5] [Frekers et al., PLB 706 (0) 34]
22 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 8/3 Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly (RAA) 0: new reactor ν e fluxes by Huber and Mueller+ (HM) [Huber, PRC 84 (0) 0467] [Mueller et al., PRC 83 (0) 05465] Previous reactor rates evaluated with new fluxes deficit [PRD 83 (0) ] R = N exp N cal Bugey 3 Bugey 4 Chooz Daya Bay Double Chooz Gosgen 3 L ILL Krasnoyarsk Nucifer [m] Palo Verde RENO Rovno88.8σ deficit R = ± 0.04 Rovno9 SRP Suppression at detector due to active-sterile oscillations?
23 Can we trust the HM fluxes? Data / Predicted 0.5 MeV.4..0 Data No oscillation Reactor flux uncertainty Total systematic uncertainty Best fit: sin θ 3 = Fast neutron (a) Accidental Li/ He [Double Chooz, arxiv: ] Events / 0. MeV (Data - MC) / MC Near Visible Energy (MeV) Prompt Energy Data [Daya Bay, arxiv: ] MC Prompt Energy (MeV) Events / 0. MeV 04: bump in the spectrum around 5 MeV! (b) cannot be explained Li/ He 5 Cf by SBL oscillations Prompt 6 Energy 7 (MeV) 8 [RENO, arxiv: ] (Data - MC) / MC Fast neutron Accidental (averaged at the observed distances) Prompt Energy 0 Far Data many attempts of MC possible explanations, how to clarify the issue? Prompt Energy (MeV) S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 9/3
24 Can we trust the HM fluxes? Data / Predicted 0.5 MeV.4..0 Data No oscillation Reactor flux uncertainty Total systematic uncertainty Best fit: sin θ 3 = Fast neutron (a) Accidental Li/ He [Double Chooz, arxiv: ] Events / 0. MeV (Data - MC) / MC Near Visible Energy (MeV) Prompt Energy Data [Daya Bay, arxiv: ] MC Prompt Energy (MeV) Events / 0. MeV 04: bump in the spectrum around 5 MeV! (b) cannot be explained Li/ He 5 Cf by SBL oscillations Prompt 6 Energy 7 (MeV) 8 [RENO, arxiv: ] (Data - MC) / MC Fast neutron Accidental (averaged at the observed distances) Prompt Energy 0 Far Data many attempts of MC possible explanations, how to clarify the issue? Model independent information! (i.e. take ratio of spectra at 3 different 4 5 distances) Prompt Energy (MeV) S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 9/3
25 NEOS Single detector experiment ε [PRL 8 (07) 80] S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3 Events /day/0 kev (a) Prompt Energy [MeV] Data signal (ON-OFF) Data background (OFF) MC 3ν (H-M-V) MC 3ν (Daya Bay) Neutrino Energy [MeV] 3 Data/Prediction..0 (b) NEOS/H-M-V Systematic total Data/Prediction (c) NEOS/Daya Prompt BayEnergy [MeV] Systematic total.0 (.73 ev, 0.050) (.3 ev, 0.4) Prompt Energy [MeV] Ratio to DayaBay measurement to be model independent
26 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3 Ratio Bottom/Top DANSS Single movable detector [arxiv: ] σ preference for 3+ oscillations Positron energy, MeV Detector can be at.5,.5 or.5 m from reactor core [D.Svirida@NOW08]
27 Model-independent fit of ( ) ν e DIS [SG et al., PLB 78 (08) 3] σ DANSS NEOS NEOS + DANSS [ev ] m 4 The NEOS and DANSS region perfectly overlap at m 4.3 ev sin ϑ ee 0.05 NEOS+DANSS σ σ 3σ 3 sin ϑ sin ϑ ee S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3
28 Model-independent fit of ( ) ν e DIS [SG et al., PLB 78 (08) 3] DANSS + NEOS + RAA + Gallium 3σ (solid dashed) Reactor Anomaly Gallium Anomaly [ev ] m 4 DANSS + NEOS do not agree with Gallium and RAA NEOS+DANSS σ σ 3σ 3 sin ϑ ee S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3
29 Model-independent fit of ( ) ν e DIS [SG et al., PLB 78 (08) 3] 3σ (solid dashed) NEOS+DANSS All data: [ev ] m 4 Fit dominated by DANSS + NEOS MIν e Dis σ σ 3σ 3 sin ϑ ee S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3
30 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 3/3 More to come... [STEREO, arxiv: ] = current DANSS+NEOS best fit [SG et al., PLB 78 (08) 3] [PROSPECT, arxiv: ] 4 [ev ] m m 4 (ev ) RAA 95% C.L. RAA 99% C.L. RAA: Best fit STEREO Exclusion Sensitivity (66 days) : 90% C.L. STEREO Exclusion (66 days) : 90% C.L. sin (θee) [Neutrino-4, arxiv:809.56] PROSPECT Exclusion, 95% CL PROSPECT Sensitivity, 95% CL SBL + Gallium Anomaly (RAA), 95% CL sin θ 4 [SoLiD, arxiv: ]
31 Neutrino Oscillations - Some theory Electron (anti)neutrino disappearence 3 Muon (anti)neutrino disappearence 4 Electron (anti)neutrino appearence 5 Global fit 6 Sterile neutrinos and CEνNS 7 Conclusions [ev ] m 4 99% CL CDHSW (984) CCFR (984) ATM SB MB ν µ (0) SB MB ν µ (0) IceCube (06) MINOS (06) MINOS+ (07) 3 U µ4
32 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 4/3 IceCube and DeepCore IceCube 4 High energy µ events 30 GeV < E < 0 TeV O( km) L O( 4 km) 0 m 4 /ev IceCube 99% CL Exclusions IC86 rate+shape IC86 shape only (blind result) IC59 result 0 sin θ 4 [PRL 7 (06) 0780]
33 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 4/3 IceCube and DeepCore IceCube 4 High energy µ events 30 GeV < E < 0 TeV O( km) L O( 4 km) IceCube string DeepCore string DeepCore Corridor 00 m DeepCore 0 m 4 /ev IceCube 99% CL Exclusions IC86 rate+shape IC86 shape only (blind result) IC59 result 0 Depth [ m ] m Veto cap DOMs m vertical spacing Dust layer bad optical properties DeepCore 50 HQE DOMs 7 m vertical spacing sin θ [PRL 7 (06) 0780] Absorption [ / m ]
34 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 4/3 m 4 /ev IceCube and DeepCore IceCube 4 High energy µ events 0 30 GeV < E < 0 TeV O( km) L O( 4 km) Uτ4 = sin θ34 cos θ ln L DeepCore 5 3 tracklike events 6 GeV E 60 GeV SK, NO (05), 90 % C.L. SK, NO (05), 99 % C.L. 99% C.L. 90% C.L. IceCube, NO (06), 90 % C.L. IceCube, NO (06), 99 % C.L. IceCube, IO (06), 90 % C.L. IceCube, IO (06), 99 % C.L. 90% C.L. 99% C.L. IceCube 99% CL Exclusions IC86 rate+shape IC86 shape only (blind result) IC59 result 0 sin θ 4 [PRL 7 (06) 0780] Uµ4 = sin θ4 [PRD 95 (07) 0] Both also constrain U τ ln L
35 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 5/3 ν µ ) MINOS & MINOS+ µ P(ν Near (ND, 500 m) and far (FD, 800 km) detector Reconstructed energy (GeV) ND CC ν µ FD GeV E 40 GeV, peak at 3 GeV ν s ) µ - P(ν ND NC FD 3-flavor prob. m4 = 0.05 ev m4 = 0.50 ev m4 = 5.00 ev L / E (km / GeV) [PRL 7 (06) 5803]: far-to-near ratio [arxiv: ]: full two-detectors fit 0
36 ν µ ) MINOS & MINOS+ µ P(ν Near (ND, 500 m) and far (FD, 800 km) detector Reconstructed energy (GeV) ND CC ν µ FD GeV E 40 GeV, peak at 3 GeV Systematics: ν s ) µ - P(ν ND NC FD 3-flavor prob. m4 = 0.05 ev m4 = 0.50 ev m4 = 5.00 ev ) 4 (ev m 90% C.L. Sensitivity Statistics only Energy Scale Hadron Production Cross Sections Backgrounds Other Systematics Total Systematics L / E (km / GeV) [PRL 7 (06) 5803]: far-to-near ratio [arxiv: ]: full two-detectors fit POT MINOS POT MINOS+ ν µ mode simulation 3 sin (θ 4 ) [arxiv: ] S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 5/3
37 ν µ ) MINOS & MINOS+ µ P(ν Near (ND, 500 m) and far (FD, 800 km) detector Reconstructed energy (GeV) ND CC ν µ FD GeV E 40 GeV, peak at 3 GeV Sensitivity and exclusion limit: POT MINOS POT MINOS+ ν µ mode ν s ) µ - P(ν ND NC FD 3-flavor prob. m4 = 0.05 ev m4 = 0.50 ev m4 = 5.00 ev ) 4 (ev m L / E (km / GeV) [PRL 7 (06) 5803]: far-to-near ratio [arxiv: ]: full two-detectors fit MINOS & MINOS+ data 90% C.L. 90% C.L. Sensitivity (σ and σ) 3 sin (θ 4 ) [arxiv: ] S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 5/3
38 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 6/3 Global fit of ( ) ν µ DIS [SG+, preliminary] [ev ] m 4 99% CL CDHSW (984) CCFR (984) ATM SB MB ν µ (0) SB MB ν µ (0) IceCube (06) MINOS (06) MINOS+ (07) 3 U µ4 MINOS(+) dominates at small m 4
39 Neutrino Oscillations - Some theory Electron (anti)neutrino disappearence 3 Muon (anti)neutrino disappearence 4 Electron (anti)neutrino appearence [ev ] m 4 σ LSND MiniBooNE KARMEN NOMAD BNL E776 ICARUS OPERA 5 Global fit 6 Sterile neutrinos and CEνNS Combined σ σ 3σ 4 3 sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 7 Conclusions
40 LSND Beam Stop Overburden [PRD 64 (00) 07] ν µ ν e, 0 E/(MeV) m well known source of ν µ : p + target π + at rest µ + + ν µ µ + at rest e + + ν e + ν µ L 30 m ν e + p n + e + No signal seen in KARMEN (L 8 m) [PRD 65 (00) 0] LSND Detector Water Plug and Veto System Beam Excess Electronics Caboose Beam Excess p(ν _ µ ν_ e,e+ )n p(ν _ e,e+ )n other 3.8σ L/E ν (meters/mev) S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 7/3
41 MiniBooNE purpose: check LSND signal L 54 m, 00 MeV E 3 GeV ) (ev m no money, no near detector LSND 90% CL 68% CL 90% CL 95% CL 99% CL 3σ CL 4σ CL KARMEN 90% CL OPERA 90% CL Excess Events/MeV Events/MeV ν sample Data (stat err.) ν from µ +/- e +/- ν e from K 0 ν e from K π 0 misid Nγ dirt other Constr. Syst. Error Best Fit QE E ν (GeV) [arxiv:805.8] 0 ν e :.84 0 ν e :.7 POT POT ν + ν excess 3 LSND 99% CL sin θ QE E ν (GeV) S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 8/3
42 MiniBooNE purpose: check LSND signal L 54 m, 00 MeV E 3 GeV ) (ev m no money, no near detector LSND 90% CL 68% CL 90% CL 95% CL 99% CL 3σ CL 4σ CL KARMEN 90% CL OPERA 90% CL Excess Events/MeV Events/MeV ν sample Data (stat err.) ν from µ +/- e +/- ν e from K 0 ν e from K π 0 misid Nγ dirt other Constr. Syst. Error Best Fit QE E ν (GeV) [arxiv:805.8] MicroBooNE will check 0 ν e :.84 POT 0 low energy ν e :.7 excess POT ν + ν excess 3 LSND 99% CL sin θ QE E ν (GeV) S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 8/3
43 Global fit of ( ) ν µ ( ) ν e APP [SG+, preliminary] S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 9/3 [ev ] m 4 σ LSND MiniBooNE KARMEN NOMAD BNL E776 ICARUS OPERA ICARUS and OPERA exclude MiniBooNE best fit LSND and MiniBooNE only partially in agreement Combined σ σ 3σ 4 3 sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 KARMEN cuts part of LSND region
44 Neutrino Oscillations - Some theory Electron (anti)neutrino disappearence 3 Muon (anti)neutrino disappearence 4 Electron (anti)neutrino appearence [ev ] m 4 Global Fit σ σ 3σ 5 Global fit 6 Sterile neutrinos and CEνNS 4 3 sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 3σ Dis App 7 Conclusions
45 APPearance - DISappearance tension Without 08 data: [SG+, preliminary] [ev ] m 4 Global Fit σ σ 3σ 4 3 sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 3σ ν e Dis ν µ Dis Dis App S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 0/3
46 [ev ] m 4 APPearance - DISappearance tension Without 08 data: Status after Neutrino 08: [SG+, preliminary] Global Fit σ σ 3σ Global Fit σ σ 3σ 4 3 sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 3σ ν e Dis ν µ Dis Dis App [ev ] m sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 0/3 3σ Dis App
47 [ev ] m 4 APPearance - DISappearance tension Without 08 data: Global Fit 4 3 sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 3σ ν e Dis ν µ Dis Dis App [ev ] m 4 ithout 08 data: 3σ ν e σdis σ ν µ 3σDis Dis App µ4 [ev ] m 4 Status after Neutrino 08: 4 3 sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 ] [SG+, preliminary] Global Fit S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 0/3 3σ σ σ 3σ Dis App
48 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3 May something be wrong? [Dentler+, JHEP 08 (08) 0] (03 data from MiniBooNE)
49 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3 May something be wrong? [Dentler+, JHEP 08 (08) 0] (03 data from MiniBooNE) No improvements if MiniBooNE is not considered
50 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3 May something be wrong? [Dentler+, JHEP 08 (08) 0] (03 data from MiniBooNE) ( ) ν µ DIS also constrain U e4, while ( ) ν e DIS do not constrain U µ4
51 May something be wrong? [Dentler+, JHEP 08 (08) 0] (03 data from MiniBooNE) Only removing LSND or all ( ) ν µ constraints the fit is almost acceptable No reason to do so! S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3
52 Neutrino Oscillations - Some theory Electron (anti)neutrino disappearence 3 Muon (anti)neutrino disappearence 4 Electron (anti)neutrino appearence 5 Global fit 6 Sterile neutrinos and CEνNS 7 Conclusions
53 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3 Present and future... [Papoulias+, PRD 97 (08) ] COHERENT: 4.57 kg CsI m %C.L. full syst. simple syst. 0 sin θ new Assumption: all DIS mixing angles are equal sin ϑ ee = sin ϑ µµ = sin θ new not competitive (yet)
54 m 4 Present and future... [Papoulias+, PRD 97 (08) ] 0 COHERENT: 4.57 kg CsI 90%C.L. full syst. simple syst. 0 sin θ new Assumption: all DIS mixing angles are equal sin ϑ ee = sin ϑ µµ = sin θ new R m 4 (ev ) [Cañas+, PLB 776 (08) 45].05 E = 4 MeV E = 6.5 MeV MINER m MINER 3m MINER 5m RED0 5m RED0 9m Texono CONNIE L (m) 0% eff, Q f =.0 50% eff, Q f =.0 50% eff, Q f = 0. + not competitive (yet) TEXONO-like reactor experiment sin θ ee S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /3
55 Neutrino Oscillations - Some theory Electron (anti)neutrino disappearence 3 Muon (anti)neutrino disappearence 4 Electron (anti)neutrino appearence 5 Global fit 6 Sterile neutrinos and CEνNS 7 Conclusions
56 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 3/3 Conclusions first model-independent hints from reactors ( ) ν e DIS, some discrepancy with Gallium anomaly and RAA 3 nothing seen in ( ) ν µ DIS strong upper bounds on U µ4, but also first constraints on U τ4 strong APP-DIS tension What are LSND and MiniBooNE observing? Systematics or LSν or new physics? 4 incoming CEνNS experiments will enter the game!
57 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 3/3 Conclusions first model-independent hints from reactors ( ) ν e DIS, some discrepancy with Gallium anomaly and RAA 3 nothing seen in ( ) ν µ DIS strong upper bounds on U µ4, but also first constraints on U τ4 strong APP-DIS tension What are LSND and MiniBooNE observing? Systematics or LSν or new physics? 4 incoming CEνNS experiments will enter the game! Thank you for the attention!
58 8 LSν Constraints from oscillation experiments 9 Cosmological constraints
59 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /6 Fraction of 5 MeV excess (%) Fuel evolution Reactor fluxes produced by decay fissions of 35 U 38 U 39 Pu 4 Pu Can we use time evolution to identify source of 5 MeV bump? F Data Constant 5 MeV excess Best fit F 35 [RENO, arxiv: ] 0.5 F39 Fi Fuel fractions in reactors change with time 0.4 EH EH Year F35 F38 F39 F F 39 [Daya Bay, PRL 8 (07) 580]
60 σ39 [ 43 cm / fission] Fuel evolution Fit bump amplitude as a function of flux normalizations Daya Bay Huber model w/ 68% C.L. σ38 = (. ±. 0) 43 σ4 = (6. 04 ± 0. 60) 43 C.L 68% 95% 99.7% σ 35 [ 43 cm / fission] 9 4 χ 4 9 [Daya Bay, PRL 8 (07) 580] χ / fission] cm -43 [ 39 y Normalization of 35 U flux smaller than prediction! 99.7% C.L. 95.5% C.L. 68.3% C.L y cm / fission] χ [ 35 Model RENO [RENO, arxiv: ] Again, we need model-independent information! take ratios at different distances to avoid normalization dependency S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /6
61 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /6 Gallium anomaly and RAA revisited [SG et al., PLB 78 (08) 3] detection efficiencies in Gallium experiments fit with free parameters: normalization of spectra of reactor fuels
62 S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 /6 Gallium anomaly and RAA revisited [SG et al., PLB 78 (08) 3] detection efficiencies in Gallium experiments fit with free parameters: normalization of spectra of reactor fuels χ Reactor spectra: r 35 r 38 r r k 99.73% 99% 95.45% 90% 68.7% 35 U flux normalization smaller than at σ χ η S Gallium efficiencies: η G MIν edis σ σ 3σ χ SAGE efficiency η S smaller than at σ
63 8 LSν Constraints from oscillation experiments 9 Cosmological constraints
64 [to be precise: N eff is slightly smaller at CMB decoupling, when the LSν starts to be non-relativistic] S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 3/6 LSν thermalization Using SBL best-fit parameters for the LSν ( m 4, θ s): [Hannestad et al., JCAP 07 (0) 05] [Mirizzi et al., PRD 86 (0) ] (colors coding N eff ) (L: lepton asymmetry) Unless L O( 3 ), N eff See also: [Saviano et al., PRD 87 (03) ], [Hannestad et al., JCAP 08 (05) 09]
65 LSν constraints from cosmology CMB+local: [Planck Collaboration, 08] Neff H0 [km s Mpc ] [Archidiacono et al., JCAP 08 (06) 067] N eff ΛCDM+N eff +m s : TT ΛCDM+N eff +m s : TT+HST ΛCDM+N eff +m s : TT+HST+BAO m s [ev] H0 [km/s/mpc] mν, eff sterile [ev] { Neff < 3.9 < 0.65 ev m eff s (Planck8+BAO) [m s < ev] free N dataset eff [m s < ev] N eff = (TT) N eff < 3.5 m s < 0.66 ev (+H 0) N eff < 3.9 m s < 0.55 ev (+BAO) N eff < 3.8 m s < 0.53 ev BBN constraints: N eff =.90 ± 0. (BBN+Y p ) [Peimbert et al., 06] Summary: N eff = from LSν incompatible with m s ev! Planck8=Planck 08 TT,TE,EE + lowe + lensing All the constraints are at σ CL S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 4/6
66 Incomplete Thermalization Active-sterile oscillations in the early Universe: mixing parameters from SBL data = N eff [Hannestad et al., 0] [Mirizzi et al., 0] Many probes constrain N eff <. Do we need a mechanism to suppress oscillations and full thermalization of ν s? to compensate N eff = with additional mechanisms in Cosmology? Some ideas (an incomplete list!): large lepton asymmetry [Foot et al., 995; Mirizzi et al., 0; many more] new neutrino interactions [Bento et al., 00; Dasgupta et al., 04; Hannestad et al., 04; Saviano et al., 04; Archidiacono et al. 06; many more] entropy production after neutrino decoupling [Ho et al., 03] very low reheating temperature [Gelmini et al., 004; Smirnov et al., 006] time varying dark energy components [Giusarma et al., 0] larger expansion rate at the time of ν s production [Rehagen et al., 04] freedom in the Primordial Power Spectrum (PPS) of scalar perturbations from inflation compensate damping due to N eff [SG et al., 05] S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 5/6
67 Solving both σ 8 and H 0 Tension? [Planck Collaboration, 05] S. Gariazzo Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, 03//08 6/6 Planck TT+lowP +lensing +lensing+bao ΛCDM 0.9 +Neff +Neff+Σmν +Neff +Neff+Σmν σ Σmν +Neff+m eff ν, sterile +Σmν +Neff+m eff ν, sterile σ Ω m Ω m H H 0 dashed: local measurements ΛCDM model, ΛCDM + ν a,s models: full cosmological dataset H 0 increases σ 8 increases (and viceversa)! The correlations do not help.
Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti
Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy EPS-HEP 07 07 European Physical Society Conference on High Energy Physics Venezia, Italy, 5- July 07 C. Giunti Status of Light Sterile
More informationSterile Neutrinos. Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Sterile Neutrinos PPC07 6 May 07 /5 Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy XI International Conference on Interconnections between Particle Physics and Cosmology Corpus Christi, Texas,
More informationSterile Neutrinos in July 2010
Sterile Neutrinos in July 0 Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino Presidenza INFN, Roma, 19 July 0 Collaboration with Marco Laveder (Padova University) C. Giunti Sterile Neutrinos in July 0 Presidenza INFN,
More informationOscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing (Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos) Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Oscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing Moriond EW 07 4 March 07 /3 Oscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing (Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos) Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy Moriond Electroweak
More informationOscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing. Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Oscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing CNNP07 9 October 07 /3 Oscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy CNNP07 Conference on Neutrino and Nuclear Physics Catania,
More informationStefano Gariazzo. Light sterile neutrinos with pseudoscalar interactions in cosmology. Based on [JCAP 08 (2016) 067] University and INFN, Torino
Stefano Gariazzo University and INFN, Torino gariazzo@to.infn.it http://personalpages.to.infn.it/~gariazzo/ Light sterile neutrinos with pseudoscalar interactions in cosmology Based on [JCAP 08 (2016)
More informationStatus of the Sterile Neutrino(s) Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Status of the Sterile Neutrino(s) LNGS 7 September 07 /40 Status of the Sterile Neutrino(s) Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy Recent Developments in Neutrino Physics and Astrophysics th Anniversary
More informationStatus of Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos EPS-HEP 05 3 July 05 /5 Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino and Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Torino giunti@to.infn.it
More informationSterile neutrinos. Stéphane Lavignac (IPhT Saclay)
Sterile neutrinos Stéphane Lavignac (IPhT Saclay) introduction active-sterile mixing and oscillations cosmological constraints experimental situation and fits implications for beta and double beta decays
More informationCarlo Giunti. CERN Particle and Astro-Particle Physics Seminar. work in collaboration with Mario Acero Marco Laveder Walter Winter
Very-Short-BaseLine Electron Neutrino Disappearance Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Università di Torino mailto://giunti@to.infn.it Neutrino Unbound: http://www.nu.to.infn.it
More informationSterile Neutrino Searches: Experiment and Theory Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino
C. Giunti Sterile Neutrino Searches Tau06 Sep 06 /3 Sterile Neutrino Searches: Experiment and Theory Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino Tau06 4th International Workshop on Tau Lepton Physics 9-3 September
More informationTwo hot issues in neutrino physics
Bari Xmas Workshop /1/011 Two hot issues in neutrino physics Antonio Palazzo Excellence Cluster Universe - TUM 1 Outline! - Introduction - The evidence of! 13 >0 - Hints of new light sterile neutrinos
More informationC. Giunti Sterile Neutrino Mixing NOW Sep /25
Sterile Neutrino Mixing NOW and in the Next Years Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino NOW 06 Neutrino Oscillation Workshop 4- September 06 Otranto, Lecce, Italy C. Giunti Sterile Neutrino Mixing NOW 06
More informationShort-Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos. Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 /53 Short-Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy Seminar
More informationStatus and prospects of neutrino oscillations
Status and prospects of neutrino oscillations S. Bilenky JINR(Dubna)TRIUMF June 10, 2017 The award of the 2015 Nobel Prize to T. Kajita and A. McDonald for the discovery of neutrino oscillations, which
More informationThe reactor antineutrino anomaly & experimental status of anomalies beyond 3 flavors
The reactor antineutrino anomaly & experimental status of anomalies beyond 3 flavors G. Mention CEA Saclay / Irfu / SPP Rencontres IPhT-SPP, 24 janvier 2012 Overview List of anomalies: LSND MB, anti- Gallium
More informationImpact of light sterile!s in LBL experiments "
Xmas Theory Workshop Bari, 22/12/14 Impact of light sterile!s in LBL experiments " Work done in collaboration with L. Klop (Master Thesis at MPI) (now PhD student @ GRAPPA Institute, Amsterdam) Antonio
More informationStatus of Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti
Status of Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Università di Torino mailto://giunti@to.infn.it Neutrino Unbound: http://www.nu.to.infn.it NOW 0, Neutrino
More informationNeutrino Oscillation Measurements, Past and Present. Art McDonald Queen s University And SNOLAB
Neutrino Oscillation Measurements, Past and Present Art McDonald Queen s University And SNOLAB Early Neutrino Oscillation History -1940 s to 1960 s: - Neutrino oscillations were proposed by Pontecorvo
More informationev-scale Sterile Neutrinos
ev-scale Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti 1 and Thierry Lasserre 2 1 Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN), Sezione di Torino, Via P. Giuria 1, I 10125 Torino, Italy; email: carlo.giunti@to.infn.it
More informationNeutrino Experiments: Lecture 2 M. Shaevitz Columbia University
Neutrino Experiments: Lecture 2 M. Shaevitz Columbia University 1 Outline 2 Lecture 1: Experimental Neutrino Physics Neutrino Physics and Interactions Neutrino Mass Experiments Neutrino Sources/Beams and
More informationReactor anomaly and searches of sterile neutrinos in experiments at very short baseline
Reactor anomaly and searches of sterile neutrinos in experiments at very short baseline G. MENTION CEA Saclay Irfu / SPP Workshop Inνisibles 13 July 17 th, 2013 Content Is the standard 3 neutrino mixing
More informationOverview of Reactor Neutrino
Overview of Reactor Neutrino Chan-Fai (Steven) Wong, Wei Wang Sun Yat-Sen University 22 September 2016 The 14th International Workshop on Tau Lepton Physics Many thanks to Jia Jie Ling, Liang Jian Wen
More informationNeutrino Anomalies & CEνNS
Neutrino Anomalies & CEνNS André de Gouvêa University PIRE Workshop, COFI February 6 7, 2017 Something Funny Happened on the Way to the 21st Century ν Flavor Oscillations Neutrino oscillation experiments
More informationarxiv: v1 [hep-ph] 15 Apr 2019
International Journal of Modern Physics A c World Scientific Publishing Company arxiv:1904.07108v1 [hep-ph] 15 Apr 2019 Roles of sterile neutrinos in particle physics and cosmology Sin Kyu Kang School
More informationShort baseline neutrino oscillation experiments at nuclear reactors
Short baseline neutrino oscillation experiments at nuclear reactors Christian Buck, MPIK Heidelberg Erice School, Sicily Sept, 17th 2017 Neutrino oscillations = 3 2 1 3 2 1 3 2 1 3 2 1 ν ν ν ν ν ν τ τ
More informationThe Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment
The Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment Ming-chung Chu The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong On behalf of the Daya Bay Collaboration Partial support: CUHK VC Discretionary Fund, RGC CUHK3/CRF/10R
More informationNeutrino Physics II. Neutrino Phenomenology. Arcadi Santamaria. TAE 2014, Benasque, September 19, IFIC/Univ. València
Neutrino Physics II Neutrino Phenomenology Arcadi Santamaria IFIC/Univ. València TAE 2014, Benasque, September 19, 2014 Neutrino Physics II Outline 1 Neutrino oscillations phenomenology Solar neutrinos
More informationNeutrino Physics: Lecture 12
Neutrino Physics: Lecture 12 Sterile neutrinos Amol Dighe Department of Theoretical Physics Tata Institute of Fundamental Research Apr 5, 2010 Outline 1 Short baseline experiments and LSND anomaly 2 Adding
More informationDark Radiation and Inflationary Freedom
Dark Radiation and Inflationary Freedom Based on [SG et al., JCAP 1504 (2015) 023] [Di Valentino et al., PRD 91 (2015) 123505] Stefano Gariazzo University of Torino, INFN of Torino http://personalpages.to.infn.it/~gariazzo/
More informationMarch 30, 01 Lecture 5 of 6 @ ORICL Philosophical Society Yuri Kamyshkov/ University of Tennessee email: kamyshkov@utk.edu 1. Concept/misconception of mass in Special Relativity (March,9). and n Oscillations:
More informationCritical Review on Neutrino Anomalies. Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Review on Neutrino Anomalies Neutrinos: the Quest for a New Physics Scale 7 March 07 /49 Critical Review on Neutrino Anomalies Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy Neutrinos: the Quest for a New
More informationThe Hunt for Sterile Neutrinos. H. Ray, University of Florida
The Hunt for Sterile Neutrinos 1 Particle Physics is Over!..finding the Higgs arguably the most important discovery in more than a generation has left physicists without a clear roadmap of where to go
More informationMiniBooNE, LSND, and Future Very-Short Baseline Experiments
1 MiniBooNE, LSND, and Future Very-Short Baseline Experiments Mike Shaevitz - Columbia University BLV2011 - September, 2011 - Gatlinburg, Tennessee Neutrino Oscillation Summary 2! µ "! Sterile "! e New
More informationUnbound Neutrino Roadmaps. MARCO LAVEDER Università di Padova e INFN NOW September 2006
Unbound Neutrino Roadmaps MARCO LAVEDER Università di Padova e INFN NOW 2006-11 September 2006 Experimental Data : 2006 Experiment Observable (# Data) Measured/SM Chlorine Average Rate (1) [CC]=0.30 ±
More informationThermalisation of Sterile Neutrinos. Thomas Tram LPPC/ITP EPFL
Thermalisation of Sterile Neutrinos Thomas Tram LPPC/ITP EPFL Outline Introduction to ev sterile neutrinos. Bounds from Cosmology. Standard sterile neutrino thermalisation. Thermalisation suppression by
More informationAnalysis of Neutrino Oscillation experiments
Analysis of Neutrino Oscillation experiments Mario Andrés Acero Ortega Università degli Studi di Torino, LAPTH - Université de Savoie Second Year - Seminar Torino, Italy January 15th, 2008 Tutor: Carlo
More informationNeutrino Basics. m 2 [ev 2 ] tan 2 θ. Reference: The Standard Model and Beyond, CRC Press. Paul Langacker (IAS) LSND 90/99% SuperK 90/99% MINOS K2K
Neutrino Basics CDHSW m 2 [ev 2 ] 10 0 10 3 10 6 10 9 KARMEN2 Cl 95% NOMAD MiniBooNE Ga 95% Bugey CHOOZ ν X ν µ ν τ ν τ NOMAD all solar 95% SNO 95% CHORUS NOMAD CHORUS LSND 90/99% SuperK 90/99% MINOS K2K
More informationNeutrino Oscillations And Sterile Neutrinos
Neutrino Oscillations And Sterile Neutrinos Keshava Prasad Gubbi University of Bonn s6nagubb@uni-bonn.de May 27, 2016 Keshava Prasad Gubbi (Uni Bonn) Neutrino Oscillations,Sterile Neutrinos May 27, 2016
More informationSterile neutrino oscillations
Sterile neutrino oscillations after first MiniBooNE results GDR Neutrino, APC Paris, 22 June 2007 Thomas Schwetz CERN T. Schwetz, GDR Neutrino, Paris, 22 June 2007 p.1 Outline Introduction to the LSND
More informationExotic Charges, Multicomponent Dark Matter and Light Sterile Neutrinos
Exotic Charges, Multicomponent and Light Sterile Neutrinos Julian Heeck Max-Planck-Institut für Kernphysik, Heidelberg 2.10.2012 based on J.H., He Zhang, arxiv:1210.xxxx. Sterile Neutrinos Hints for ev
More informationHow to make the short baseline sterile neutrino compatible with cosmology
How to make the short baseline sterile neutrino compatible with cosmology a, Maria Archidiacono b, Steen Hannestad c and Thomas Tram d a Max-Planck-Institut für Kernphysik Saupfercheckweg 1, 69118 Heidelberg,
More informationSun Yat-Sen University, 135 Xingang Xi Road, Guangzhou, Guangdong, , China
Sun Yat-Sen University, 135 Xingang Xi Road, Guangzhou, Guangdong, 510275, China E-mail: lingjj5@mail.sysu.edu.cn The basic theory and experimental hints for light sterile neutrinos at ev 2 mass scale
More informationNeutrinos & Large Extra Dimensions. Renata Zukanovich Funchal Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil
Neutrinos & Large Extra Dimensions Renata Zukanovich Funchal Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil What is ν? Workshop June 26, 2012 ν Masses & Mixings Majorana CP Violating phases solar atmospheric accelerator
More informationHint of CPT Violation in Short-Baseline Electron Neutrino Disappearance
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 335 (011) 01054 doi:10.1088/174-6596/335/1/01054 Hint of CPT Violation in Short-Baseline Electron Neutrino Disappearance Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and
More informationNEUTRINOS II The Sequel
NEUTRINOS II The Sequel More About Neutrinos Ed Kearns Boston University NEPPSR V - 2006 August 18, 2006 Ed Kearns Boston University NEPPSR 2006 1 There is something unusual about this neutrino talk compared
More informationParticle Physics: Neutrinos part II
Particle Physics: Neutrinos part II José I. Crespo-Anadón Week 9: April 1, 2017 Columbia University Science Honors Program Course Policies Attendance Up to four absences Send email notifications of all
More informationSearch for sterile neutrino mixing in the muon neutrino to tau neutrino appearance channel with the OPERA detector
Search for sterile neutrino mixing in the muon neutrino to tau neutrino appearance channel with the OPERA detector INFN - Sezione di Bologna, I-4017 Bologna, Italy E-mail: matteo.tenti@bo.infn.it The OPERA
More informationSolar and atmospheric ν s
Solar and atmospheric ν s Masato SHIOZAWA Kamioka Observatory, Institute for Cosmic Ray Research, U of Tokyo, and Kamioka Satellite, Kavli Institute for the Physics and Mathematics of the Universe (WPI),
More informationWhy neutrinos? Patrick Huber. Center for Neutrino Physics at Virginia Tech. KURF Users Meeting June 7, 2013, Virginia Tech. P. Huber VT-CNP p.
Why neutrinos? Patrick Huber Center for Neutrino Physics at Virginia Tech KURF Users Meeting June 7, 2013, Virginia Tech P. Huber VT-CNP p. 1 Neutrinos are massive so what? Neutrinos in the Standard Model
More informationNeutrino Mass Limits from Cosmology
Neutrino Physics and Beyond 2012 Shenzhen, September 24th, 2012 This review contains limits obtained in collaboration with: Emilio Ciuffoli, Hong Li and Xinmin Zhang Goal of the talk Cosmology provides
More informationReactor Anomaly an Overview. Petr Vogel, Caltech INT Seattle 11/6/2013
Reactor Anomaly an Overview Petr Vogel, Caltech INT Seattle 11/6/2013 in ν e + p -> e + + n Illustration of the reactor anomaly. Rates in various experiments are compared with the expectations based on
More informationNeutrino Oscillations
Neutrino Oscillations Elisa Bernardini Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY (Zeuthen) Suggested reading: C. Giunti and C.W. Kim, Fundamentals of Neutrino Physics and Astrophysics, Oxford University Press
More informationHow large is the "LSND anomaly"?
How large is the "LSND anomaly"? Andrey Elagin on behalf of the HARP-CDP group HEP lunch, UChicago, March 12, 2012 Outline 3.8 σ LSND Final Paper PRD 64, 112007 3.8 σ 2.9 σ HARP-CDP Paper I arxiv:1110.4265
More informationThe Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly
The Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly M. Fechner, G. Mention, T. Lasserre, M. Cribier, Th. Mueller D. Lhuillier, A. Letourneau, CEA / Irfu arxiv:1101.2755 [hep-ex] Introduction New spectra calculations presented
More informationNeutrino Masses in Cosmology, Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay and Direct Neutrino Masses Carlo Giunti
Neutrino Masses in Cosmology, Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay and Direct Neutrino Masses Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Università di Torino mailto://giunti@to.infn.it
More informationThe future of neutrino physics (at accelerators)
Mauro Mezzetto, Istituto Nazionale Fisica Nucleare, Padova The future of neutrino physics (at accelerators) Present Status Concepts, strategies, challenges The two players: Dune and Hyper-Kamiokande Conclusions
More informationDaya Bay and joint reactor neutrino analysis
Daya Bay and joint reactor neutrino analysis Logan Lebanowski (Tsinghua University) on behalf of the Daya Bay collaboration 2016/11/4 - NNN16, Beijing 1 Contents Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment Introduction
More informationAccelerator Neutrino Experiments News from Neutrino 2010 Athens
Accelerator Neutrino Experiments News from Neutrino 2010 Athens Ed Kearns Boston University Outline Quick overview New result 1: OPERA tau appearance New result 2: MINOS nu- e appearance Looking forward
More informationPoS(ICRC2017)1024. First Result of NEOS Experiment. Kim Siyeon. Affiliation:Chung-Ang University. On behalf of NEOS Collaboration
Affiliation:Chung-Ang University On behalf of NEOS Collaboration E-mail: siyeon@cau.ac.kr Neutrino Experiment for Oscillation at Short baseline (NEOS) targeted the search of singlet neutrinos as natural
More informationSensitivity to sterile ν mixings at a ν Factory --Side business of a ν Factory --
Sensitivity to sterile ν mixings at a ν Factory --Side business of a ν Factory -- Osamu Yasuda Tokyo Metropolitan University 009-1-18 @ Miami009 1 1. Introduction. Light sterile neutrinos 3. Summary 1.
More informationNeutrino Oscillations
Neutrino Oscillations Heidi Schellman June 6, 2000 Lots of help from Janet Conrad Charge mass,mev tandard Model of Elementary Particles 3 Generations of Fermions Force Carriers Q u a r k s u d 2/3 2/3
More informationOn Minimal Models with Light Sterile Neutrinos
On Minimal Models with Light Sterile Neutrinos Pilar Hernández University of Valencia/IFIC Donini, López-Pavón, PH, Maltoni arxiv:1106.0064 Donini, López-Pavón, PH, Maltoni, Schwetz arxiv:1205.5230 SM
More information- Future Prospects in Oscillation Physics -
Measuring θ 13 and the Search for Leptonic CP Violation - Future Prospects in Oscillation Physics - Karsten M. Heeger Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory ν e flux θ 13 =? P ee, (4 MeV) 1/r 2 Evidence
More informationRecent Discoveries in Neutrino Oscillation Physics & Prospects for the Future
Recent Discoveries in Neutrino Oscillation Physics & Prospects for the Future Karsten M. Heeger Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 SNO φ ES SNO φ CC SNO φ NC SSM φ NC 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6
More informationThe Double Chooz Project
The Double Chooz Project Progress and Expected Sensitivity David McKee, KSU 13 17 July 2009 TeVPA @ SLAC Outline I. Neutrino mixing and θ 13 II. Existing θ 13 measurements III. This is hard with a single
More informationGrand Unification Theories
Grand Unification Theories After the success of the unified theroy of electroweak interactions it was natural to ask if strong interactions are united with the weak and em ones. The greater strength of
More informationSterile neutrinos: to be or not to be?
Sterile neutrinos: to be or not to be? Joachim Kopp (University of Mainz) June 9, 2015 @ WIN 2015, Heidelberg Joachim Kopp Sterile neutrinos: to be or not to be? 1 Outline 1 Sterile Neutrinos 2 Oscillation
More informationLatest Results from MINOS and MINOS+ Will Flanagan University of Texas on behalf of the MINOS+ Collaboration
Latest Results from MINOS and MINOS+ Will Flanagan University of Texas on behalf of the MINOS+ Collaboration Outline Overview of the Main Injector Neutrino Oscillation Search Detector Exciting physics
More informationUpdated three-neutrino oscillation parameters from global fits
Updated three-neutrino oscillation parameters from fits (Based on arxiv:14.74) Mariam Tórtola IFIC, Universitat de València/CSIC 37th International Conference on High Energy Physics 3th July 214, Valencia.
More informationNeutrino Oscillation and CP violation
Neutrino Oscillation and CP violation Contents. Neutrino Oscillation Experiments and CPV. Possible CP measurements in TK 3. Summary Nov.4, 4 @Nikko K. Nishikawa Kyoto niversity CP Violation Asymmetry between
More informationMeasuring the neutrino mass hierarchy with atmospheric neutrinos in IceCube(-Gen2)
Measuring the neutrino mass hierarchy with atmospheric neutrinos in IceCube(-Gen2) Beyond the Standard Model with Neutrinos and Nuclear Physics Solvay Workshop November 30, 2017 Darren R Grant The atmospheric
More informationNeutrinos in Supernova Evolution and Nucleosynthesis
Neutrinos in Supernova Evolution and Nucleosynthesis Gabriel Martínez Pinedo The origin of cosmic elements: Past and Present Achievements, Future Challenges, Barcelona, June 12 15, 2013 M.-R. Wu, T. Fischer,
More informationCosmic Neutrinos. Chris Quigg Fermilab. XXXV SLAC Summer Institute Dark Matter 10 August 2007
Cosmic Neutrinos Chris Quigg Fermilab quigg@fnal.gov XXXV SLAC Summer Institute Dark Matter 10 August 2007 Neutrinos are abundant! Each second, some 10 14 neutrinos made in the Sun pass through your body.
More informationKnown and Unknown for Neutrinos. Kim Siyeon Chung-Ang g University Lecture at Yonsei Univ.
Known and Unknown for Neutrinos Kim Siyeon Chung-Ang g University Lecture at Yonsei Univ. Known and Unknown for Neutrinos Dirac vs. Majorana 3 generation vs. 4 generation (neutrino vs. antineutrino) (terrestrial
More informationRecent results from Super-Kamiokande
Recent results from Super-Kamiokande ~ atmospheric neutrino ~ Yoshinari Hayato ( Kamioka, ICRR, U-Tokyo ) for the Super-Kamiokande collaboration 1 41.4m Super-Kamiokande detector 50000 tons Ring imaging
More informationShort baseline experiments and sterile neutrinos. Nick van Remortel Solvay-Francqui Workshop on Neutrinos May
Short baseline experiments and sterile neutrinos Nick van Remortel Solvay-Francqui Workshop on Neutrinos May 27-29 2015 2 Overview Tensions with 3 neutrino paradigm by range of experiments sterile neutrinos
More informationParticle Physics: Neutrinos part II
Particle Physics: Neutrinos part II José I. Crespo-Anadón Week 9: November 18, 2017 Columbia University Science Honors Program 3 evidences for 3 neutrinos 2 3 neutrinos: 3 charged leptons Neutrinos are
More informationProspects of Reactor ν Oscillation Experiments
Prospects of Reactor ν Oscillation Experiments F.Suekane RCNS, Tohoku Univ. Erice School 3/09/009 1 Contents * Motivation * Physics of Neutrino Oscillation * Accessible Parameters of Reactor Neutrinos
More informationPrecise Determination of the 235 U Reactor Antineutrino Cross Section per Fission Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Determination of the 235 U Reactor Antineutrino Cross Section per Fission AAP 2016 2 Dec 2016 1/10 Precise Determination of the 235 U Reactor Antineutrino Cross Section per Fission Carlo Giunti
More informationMINOS. Luke A. Corwin, for MINOS Collaboration Indiana University XIV International Workshop On Neutrino Telescopes 2011 March 15
MINOS Luke A. Corwin, for MINOS Collaboration Indiana University XIV International Workshop On Neutrino Telescopes 2011 March 15 2 Overview and Current Status Beam Detectors Analyses Neutrino Charged Current
More informationNeutrinos: status, models, string theory expectations
Neutrinos: status, models, string theory expectations Introduction Neutrino preliminaries and status Models String embeddings Intersecting brane The Z 3 heterotic orbifold Embedding the Higgs triplet Outlook
More informationShort-Baseline Neutrino Anomalies Carlo Giunti. Selected Puzzles in Particle Physics Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati December 2016
C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Anomalies Selected Puzzles in Particle Physics LNF Dec 06 /67 Short-Baseline Neutrino Anomalies Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino giunti@to.infn.it Neutrino Unbound: http://www.nu.to.infn.it
More informationNew Results for ν µ ν e oscillations in MINOS
New Results for ν µ ν e oscillations in MINOS Jelena Ilic Rutherford Appleton Lab 4/28/10 RAL PPD Seminar 1 Neutrino Mixing Mass eigenstates flavour eigenstates Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata: Flavour composition
More informationNeutrinos. Thanks to Ian Blockland and Randy Sobie for these slides. spin particle with no electric charge; weak isospin partners of charged leptons
Neutrinos Thanks to Ian Blockland and Randy Sobie for these slides spin particle with no electric charge; weak isospin partners of charged leptons observed in 193, in 1962 and in the 199s neutrino physics
More informationNEUTRINO COSMOLOGY. ν e ν µ. ν τ STEEN HANNESTAD UNIVERSITY OF AARHUS PARIS, 27 OCTOBER 2006
NEUTRINO COSMOLOGY ν e ν µ ν τ STEEN HANNESTAD UNIVERSITY OF AARHUS PARIS, 27 OCTOBER 2006 OUTLINE A BRIEF REVIEW OF PRESENT COSMOLOGICAL DATA BOUNDS ON THE NEUTRINO MASS STERILE NEUTRINOS WHAT IS TO COME
More informationNeutrinos: Three-Flavor Effects in Sparse and Dense Matter
Neutrinos: Three-Flavor Effects in Sparse and Dense Matter Tommy Ohlsson tommy@theophys.kth.se Royal Institute of Technology (KTH) & Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences (KVA) Stockholm, Sweden Neutrinos
More informationNeutrinos and Cosmos. Hitoshi Murayama (Berkeley) Texas Conference at Stanford Dec 17, 2004
Neutrinos and Cosmos Hitoshi Murayama (Berkeley) Texas Conference at Stanford Dec 17, 2004 Outline A Little Historical Perspective Interpretation of Data & Seven Questions Matter Anti-Matter Asymmetry
More informationRecent Results from T2K and Future Prospects
Recent Results from TK and Future Prospects Konosuke Iwamoto, on behalf of the TK Collaboration University of Rochester E-mail: kiwamoto@pas.rochester.edu The TK long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiment
More informationGLOBAL ANALYSIS OF NEUTRINO DATA
GLOBAL ANALYSIS OF NEUTRINO DATA Stony Brook & IFIC-Valencia) Nobel Syposiu, August 4 Introduction: The Paraeters of the New Minial Standard Model Orthodox Global Fits Solar and Reactor Neutrinos Atospheric
More informationSterile Neutrinos. Patrick Huber. Center for Neutrino Physics Virginia Tech
Sterile Neutrinos Patrick Huber Center for Neutrino Physics Virginia Tech XIII Workshop on Electron-Nucleus Scattering June 23-27, 2014, Marciana Marina, Isola d Elba, Italy P. Huber p. 1 Outline The reactor
More informationThe Daya Bay and T2K results on sin 2 2θ 13 and Non-Standard Neutrino Interactions (NSI)
The Daya Bay and TK results on sin θ 13 and Non-Standard Neutrino Interactions (NSI) Ivan Girardi SISSA / INFN, Trieste, Italy Based on: I. G., D. Meloni and S.T. Petcov Nucl. Phys. B 886, 31 (014) 8th
More informationSolar spectrum. Nuclear burning in the sun produce Heat, Luminosity and Neutrinos. pp neutrinos < 0.4 MeV
SOLAR NEUTRINOS Solar spectrum Nuclear burning in the sun produce Heat, Luminosity and Neutrinos pp neutrinos < 0.4 MeV Beryllium neutrinos 0.86 MeV Monochromatic since 2 body decay 2 kev width due to
More informationChapter 2 Neutrino Oscillation
Chapter Neutrino Oscillation Physics works, and I m still alive. Walter Lewin. Neutrinos and the Standard Model of Particle Physics The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics is the theory describing
More informationRecent advances in neutrino astrophysics. Cristina VOLPE (AstroParticule et Cosmologie APC, Paris)
Recent advances in neutrino astrophysics Cristina VOLPE (AstroParticule et Cosmologie APC, Paris) Flux (cm -2 s -1 MeV -1 ) 10 24 10 20 10 16 10 12 10 8 10 4 10 0 10-4 10-8 Neutrinos in Nature Cosmological
More informationLargeθ 13 Challenge and Opportunity
Largeθ 13 Challenge and Opportunity Patrick Huber Center for Neutrino Physics at Virginia Tech Experimental Seminar January 15, 2013, SLAC P. Huber VT-CNP p. 1 θ 13 is large! The Daya Bay result is sin
More informationSearching for Physics Beyond the Standard Model. IceCube Neutrino Observatory. with the. John Kelley for the IceCube Collaboration
Searching for Physics Beyond the Standard Model with the IceCube Neutrino Observatory John Kelley for the IceCube Collaboration Wisconsin IceCube Particle Astrophysics Center University of Wisconsin Madison,
More informationLong baseline experiments
Mauro Mezzetto, Istituto Nazionale Fisica Nucleare, Padova Long baseline experiments Present Status Concepts, strategies, challenges The two players: Dune and Hyper-Kamiokande Conclusions M. Mezzetto,
More informationImplications of cosmological observables for particle physics: an overview
Implications of cosmological observables for particle physics: an overview Yvonne Y. Y. Wong The University of New South Wales Sydney, Australia TAUP 2015, Torino, September 7 11, 2015 The concordance
More informationJarek Nowak University of Minnesota. High Energy seminar, University of Virginia
Jarek Nowak University of Minnesota High Energy seminar, University of Virginia Properties of massive neutrinos in the Standard Model. Electromagnetic properties of neutrinos. Neutrino magnetic moment.
More information