arxiv: v2 [physics.gen-ph] 28 Oct 2017

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "arxiv: v2 [physics.gen-ph] 28 Oct 2017"

Edward Booth
5 years ago
Views:

1 A CHART FOR THE ENERGY LEVELS OF THE SQUARE QUANTUM WELL arxiv: v [physics.gen-ph] 8 Oct 017 M. CHIANI Abstract. A chart for the quantum mechanics of a particle of mass m in a one-dimensional potential ell of idth and depth V 0 is derived. The chart is obtained by normalizing energy and potential through multiplication by 8m /h, and gives directly the alloed couples potential, energy, providing insights on the relation beteen the parameters and the number of alloed energy levels. 1. Introduction One of the classical eamples in quantum mechanics is the study of the alloed energy E for a particle of mass m under the effect of a potential ell of idth and finite potential depth V 0 Fig. 1. By solving the Schrödinger equation it results V V 0 Figure 1. Potential in a quantum ell that there is no quantization for E > V 0, hile for E V 0 the quantized energy levels are the roots of some transcendental equations. The graphical discussion of the alloed energy levels is commonly based on plots hich must be dran specifically for the numerical values of the potential depth V 0 of interest [1 10]. In this note e sho that, ith a suitable normalization, the inverse problem V 0 = V 0 E is in simple closed form, and can be represented ith a graph valid for arbitrary V 0, m and. The graph gives the alloed couples potential, energy, ith direct insights on energy quantization and on the number of energy levels.. Energy levels for the potential ell The material in this section is ell knon and reported here just for the sake of completeness. Date: September 9,

2 M. CHIANI The bounded alloed energy levels E V 0 for a particle of mass m under the effect of a potential ell of finite idth and potential V are given by the solutions of the time-independent Schrödinger equation [6, 8] 1 ψ m + V ψ = E ψ here ψ is the particle ave functions, and ψ d = 1. By introducing the normalized potential depth and energy 8m Ṽ 0 = V 0 h Ẽ = E 8m h here h is the Planck constant, equation 1 for the quantum ell is ritten as Ṽ0 Ẽ π 3 ψ = Ẽ π ψ > / ψ < /. Due to symmetry of the potential, only even parity solutions ψ = ψ or odd parity solutions ψ = ψ are possible. The even parity general solution of 3 is 4 ψ = a ep π Ṽ 0 Ẽ > / b cos π < / here a, b are constants. To have continuity of ψ and its derivative at ±/, the folloing equations have to be satisfied: π 5 a = b cos ep Ṽ 0 Ẽ 6 Ṽ 0 Ẽ = tan. Similarly, the odd parity general solution of 3 is a ep π Ṽ 0 ψ = Ẽ sign > / 7 b sin π < /. Imposing the continuity of ψ and of its derivative at ±/ e have π 8 a = b sin ep Ṽ 0 Ẽ 9 Ṽ 0 Ẽ = cot. In particular, equations 6 and 9 give the alloed energy levels for a fied potential depth, for even and odd parity ave functions, respectively. The transcendental equations 6 and 9 are usually discussed plotting separately the functions tan Ẽ π/, cot Ẽ π/ and Ṽ0 /Ẽ 1 for a given Ṽ0 [6, 8]. An eample is reported in Figure, for Ṽ0 = 13. The abscissa of the intersections are the alloed energy levels. Unfortunately the graph requires draing the curve Ṽ0 /Ẽ 1 for the specific potential Ṽ0.

3 A CHART FOR THE ENERGY LEVELS OF THE SQUARE QUANTUM WELL 3 = Figure. Blue: the function tan Ẽ π/. Red: the function cot Ẽ π/. Black: the function Ṽ0 /Ẽ 1 for Ṽ0 = 13. The alloed energy levels can be read as the abscissa of the intersections. 3. A universal graph giving the couples potential, energy In order to Ẽ provide a universal graph, valid for all cases, e look eplicitly for the function Ṽ0. To this aim, e square 6, getting 1 Ṽ 0 Ẽ = Ẽ π 10 tan. Ẽ Thus, the inverse relation Ṽ0 = Ṽ0 for the even parity solutions is simply Ṽ 0 = Ẽ 1 + tan π Ẽ 11 = = Ẽ sec cos π/ here only the solutions ith positive derivative have to be considered. Similarly, for the odd parity case, from 9 e get Ṽ 0 Ẽ = Ẽ π 1 cot. Thus, for the odd-parity ave functions the alloed energy levels are the solutions ith positive derivative of the equation Ṽ 0 = Ẽ 1 + cot π Ẽ 13 = = Ẽ sin csc. π/ In summary, e have the folloing result: the alloed couples potential depth, energy levels are given by 11 and 13 or, equivalently, by 14 Ṽ 0 = sec π/, Ṽ 0 = csc π/ for the even and odd parity ave functions, respectively. In the previous equations only the positive derivative parts of the functions have to be considered. The chart is reported in Fig. 3. This chart is universal as it can be used for a graphical analysis of the alloed energy levels for arbitrary potential depth and ell idth. 1 Here the normalization makes the results easier to interpret ith respect to [11]. These are the only alloed for obvious physical reasons. In fact, it can be checked that the solutions of 11 ith negative derivative do not satisfy 6.

4 4 M. CHIANI Figure 3. Normalized potential depth vs. energy levels for a particle of mass m and energy E in a finite potential ell of depth V 0 and idth. Blue: plot of the function Ẽ sec Ẽ π/ positive derivative parts only corresponding to the even parity solutions; Red: plot of the function Ẽ csc Ẽ π/ positive derivative parts only corresponding to the odd parity solutions Eample of use of the chart. Let us consider an electron, for hich 8m/h = [ev 1 m 1 ], in a ell of idth = 10Å. The normalizing constant is then 8m /h =.66 [ev 1 ]. Assume a potential depth V 0 = 4.9 [ev ], giving the normalized potential Ṽ0 = 13. From the chart e see that for the ordinate Ṽ 0 = 3.6 there are four possible normalized energy levels, approimately of values Ẽ {0.85, 1.7,.5, 3.3}. Squaring e have Ẽ {0.7,.89, 6.5, 10.89}, hich in electronvolt are E[eV ] {0.7, 1.09,.36, 4.1}. These values, obtained from the graph, are quite close to the eact values, hich can calculated as the numerical solution of 14 to be Ẽ {0.7,.85, 6.30, 10.73}, E[eV ] {0.7, 1.07,.37, 4.04}. By inspection of the chart e can also see the effect of an increase or decrease in the potential depth level. 3.. Some insights from the chart. The graph of the alloed couple potential, energy reported in Fig. 3 leads simply to several observations. Some are reported belo, here k N denotes a non-negative integer. 1 Quantization does not depend separately on the system parameters, but on the product V 0 m.

5 A CHART FOR THE ENERGY LEVELS OF THE SQUARE QUANTUM WELL 5 For a given normalized potential Ṽ0, the overall number of energy levels is N = Ṽ There is a solution E = V 0 only for specific combinations of V 0, m,, producing an integer Ṽ 0. In particular, hen Ṽ0 = k and Ṽ0 = k + 1, for even and odd parity, respectively. 4 As a particular case, if e let Ṽ0 e obtain the infinite depth quantum ell. The vertical asymptotes in the chart are at Ẽ = k, corresponding to cos Ẽ π/ = 0 or sin Ẽ π/ = 0. Thus, the normalized energy levels for the infinite depth ell are Ẽ = k, and the unnormalized alloed energy levels are E = k h /8m. 4. Conclusions For the classic problem of a particle in a finite potential quantum ell, the chart in Fig. 3 described in this note gives the possible couples normalized potential, normalized energy. It has the advantages to be universal i.e., valid for arbitrary system parameters V 0, m, and, and to give general insights on the role of the parameters, on the number of quantized energy levels, and on the relation ith the infinite depth ell case. The chart is simply obtained by plotting the functions sec π/ and csc π/. References [1] L. D. Landau and E. Lifshitz, Course of Theoretical Physics: Vol.: 3: Quantum Mechanis: Non-Relativistic Theory. Pergamon Press, [] P. H. Pitkanen, Rectangular potential ell problem in quantum mechanics, American Journal of Physics, vol. 3, no., [3] C. D. Cantrell, Bound-state energies of a particle in a finite square ell: An improved graphical solution, American Journal of Physics, vol. 39, no. 1, [4] D. W. L. Sprung, H. Wu, and J. Martorell, A ne look at the square ell potential, European Journal of Physics, vol. 13, no. 1, p. 1, 199. [5] D. L. Aronstein and C. Stroud Jr, General series solution for finite square-ell energy levels for use in ave-packet studies, American Journal of Physics, vol. 68, no. 10, pp , 000. [6] D. Griffiths, Introduction to Quantum Mechanics. Pearson Prentice Hall, 005. [7] O. F. de Alcantara Bonfim and D. J. Griffiths, Eact and approimate energy spectrum for the finite square ell and related potentials, American Journal of Physics, vol. 74, no. 1, 006. [8] J. Binney and D. Skinner, The physics of quantum mechanics. Oford University Press, 015. [9] K. R. Naqvi and S. Waldenstrøm, The finite square ell: hatever is orth teaching at all is orth teaching ell, arxiv: , 015. [10] V. Barsan, Understanding quantum phenomena ithout solving the Schrödinger equation: the case of the finite square ell, European Journal of Physics, vol. 36, no. 6, p , 015. [11] P. Guest, Graphical solutions for the square ell, American Journal of Physics, vol. 40, no. 8, pp , 197. Dept. DEI G. Marconi, University of Bologna, Italy address: marco.chiani@unibo.it

6.5 Trigonometric Equations

6.5 Trigonometric Equations 6. Trigonometric Equations In this section, we discuss conditional trigonometric equations, that is, equations involving trigonometric functions that are satisfied only by some values of the variable (or