arxiv:hep-ph/ v1 5 Dec 1996

Transcription

1 BUHEP hep-ph/96167 A Comment on the Zero Temperature Chiral Phase Transition in SU(N) Gauge Theories arxiv:hep-ph/96167v1 5 De 1996 R. Sekhar Chivukula Department o Physis, Boston University, 590 Commonwealth Ave., Boston MA 015 Deember 5, 1996 Abstrat Reently Appelquist, Terning, and Wijewardhana investigated the zero temperature hiral phase transition in SU(N) gauge theory as the number o ermions N is varied. They argued that there is a ritial number o ermions N, above whih there is no hiral symmetry breaking and below whih hiral symmetry breaking and oninement set in. They urther argued that that the transition is not seond order even though the order parameter or hiral symmetry breaking vanishes ontinuously as N approahes N on the broken side. In this note I propose a simple physial piture or the spetrum o states as N approahes N rom below (i.e. on the broken side) and argue that this piture predits very dierent and non-universal behavior than is the ase in an ordinary seond order phase transition. In this way the transition an be ontinuous without behaving onventionally. I urther argue that this eature results rom the (presumed) existene o an inrared Banks-Zaks ixed point o the gauge oupling in the neighborhood o the hiral transition and thereore depends on the long-distane nature o the non-abelian gauge ore. addresses: sekhar@bu.edu

2 Reently Appelquist, Terning, and Wijewardhana [1] have investigated the zero temperature hiral phase transition in SU(N) gauge theory as the number o massless Dira ermions N is varied. To seond order, the beta-untion o suh a theory is given by where µ µ α(µ) = β(α) bα (µ) α 3 (µ) dα 4 (µ)..., (1.1) b = 1 6π (11N N ) ( ) (1.) = 1 4π 34N 10NN 3 N 1 N N. (1.3) For a small number o lavors the theory is asymptotially ree and one expets QCD-like behavior, with oninement and with the hiral SU(N ) L SU(N ) R symmetry broken to its vetorial subgroup. I the number o lavors is large enough (in perturbation theory, greater than 11N/) asymptoti reedom (and hene hiral symmetry breaking and oninement) is lost. For a range o N less than 11N/ the irst term in the β-untion is negative and the theory is asymptotially ree, but there appears (in perturbation theory) to be a nontrivial inrared (Banks-Zaks) ixed point [] beause the seond term in the β-untion is positive. For N just slightly less than 11N/, this ixed point α is at weak oupling and the analysis is sel-onsistent. As N is lowered urther, the ixed point moves to larger oupling. In vetor-like gauge theories an analysis o the gap equation [3, 4] suggests that, in a theory with an approximately onstant oupling, hiral symmetry breaking ours only i the oupling α exeeds a ritial value α π 3C (R) = πn 3(N 1). (1.4) The authors o [1] suggested that the Banks-Zaks ixed point [] persists to large oupling, and that the hiral-symmetry breaking transition in N should be assoiated with the point where α = α. They thereby estimated that ( 100N N ) 66 = N 5N. (1.5) 15 Furthermore, Appelquist, Terning and Wijewardhana suggested that the nature o this phase transition is peuliar. Based on a gap-equation analysis [5] o the the dynamial mass Σ(p) o the ermions in the broken phase, they argued that the order parameter or hiral symmetry breaking (whih is proportional to Σ(0)) Σ(0) Λexp π. (1.6) α α 1 1

3 A Λ ρ m σ φ κ κ π Figure 1: Spetrum o bosoni exitations in NJL model or ouplings lose to κ. Chiral symmetry is broken or κ > κ, and preserved or κ < κ. The σ and π in the broken phase ombine to be the salar φ multiplet in the unbroken phase. The vetor and axial vetor resonanes orm one hiral multiplet, and are thereore degenerate, in the unbroken phase. goes to zero ontinuously 1 as N (N ) (and α α + ). Here the high-energy sale Λ represents the sale at whih the oupling is ar enough rom the ixed point value to begin to run [1]. On the other hand, based o an analysis o the Bethe-Salpeter equation or the quark-antiquark sattering amplitude, Appelquist, Terning, and Wijewardhana argue that in the symmetri phase (lose to the transition, when N is just above N ) there are no light salar resonanes. Indeed, sine the theory with N > N is presumed to be in a onormally-invariant non-abelian oulomb phase [], it annot have any isolated states. They then onluded that the phase transition is not seond order even though the order parameter hanges ontinuously. In this note I propose a simple physial piture or the spetrum o states as N approahes N rom below (i.e. on the broken side) and argue that this piture predits very dierent and non-universal behavior than is the ase in an ordinary seond order phase transition. In this way the transition an be ontinuous without behaving onventionally [7]. I urther argue that this eature results rom the (presumed) existene o an inrared Banks-Zaks ixed point o the gauge oupling in the neighborhood o the hiral transition and thereore depends on the long-distane nature o the non-abelian gauge ore. Beore moving to the ase o a long-range ore, let us review the amiliar be- 1 For momenta below Σ(0), the ermions an be integrated out and no longer ontribute to the β-untion. Thereore, stritly speaking, or any N < N there is no ixed-point. Nonetheless, or N lose to N the oupling remains lose to α or a large range o momenta, in a manner reminisent o walking tehniolor [6].

4 A m NAC ρ σ N > N α N < N π α Figure : Spetrum o bosoni exitations in SU(N) gauge theory or N lose to N. For N < N, hiral symmetry is broken. > For N N, the theory is assumed to be in a onormallyinvariant non-abelian oulomb (NAC) phase [] whih has no isolated single-partile states. havior o the hiral phase transition in a model with short-range interations, the NJL model [8]. Here the undamental interations are modeled by hirally-invariant loal our-ermion operators L = 4πκ Λ [ψγ µ λ a ψ ], (1.7) where the λ a / are the generators o SU(N) olor and the ψ are the N lavors o ermions. This interation is attrative in the hiral symmetry breaking hannel, but is suppressed by a (large) energy sale Λ. In the limit where the NJL oupling κ is small, hiral symmetry remains unbroken. When the oupling is large, the hiral symmetry breaking sale (as haraterized by the value o the F-onstant the analog o π in QCD or by Σ, the momentum-independent dynamial mass o the ermion) is o order Λ. There is a ritial value κ, estimated to be π/3 in the large-n limit, below whih hiral symmetry is unbroken and above whih it is broken. I the transition between these two regimes is smooth, as it is in the gapequation in the ermion-bubble approximation, the dynamial mass o the ermion goes smoothly to zero as κ (κ ) +, and remains identially zero or κ κ. In the ase o the Nambu-Jona-Lasinio model, the spetrum o bosoni exitations [10] is shown in Figure 1. Note that, aside rom the light salar-multiplet φ on the unbroken side and the σ and Goldstone bosons π on the broken side, all other exitations have a mass o order Λ! The reason or this is that the intrinsi physial sale o the interations is always o order Λ. Near κ = κ, the salar states are anomalously light due to the ine-tuning [9] o the NJL interation. This piture should be ontrasted with the analogous hange o the spetrum 3

5 o partiles near the hiral phase transition in non-abelian gauge theory as N (N ). Beause o the inrared ixed-point, the high-energy sale Λ (see eqn. 1.6) is no longer relevant. In this ase the only relevant dynamial sale is the magnitude o dynamial mass Σ(0). All other sales, the F-onstant, the oninement sale, et. are o the same order o magnitude [1]. Thereore, i Σ(0) 0 ontinuously as N (N ), we expet the spetrum o bosoni exitations to be as shown in Figure. Note that as N (N ), the entire spetrum ollapses to zero mass. So long as the Banks-Zaks ixed point persists in the non-abelian gauge theory, all high-energy sales are irrelevant. Thereore, unlike the NJL model, i Σ(0) 0 the mass o all exitations must also tend to zero. What are the impliations o this behavior? In the ase o the NJL model near the ritial oupling, it is appropriate to integrate-out all higher-mass states and the ritial behavior o the theory is determined entirely by the inrared behavior o the orresponding salar ield theory 3. We thereore expet similar behavior in any SU(N ) SU(N ) hirally-invariant our-dimensional ield theory with short-range interations near the phase boundary: i.e. we expet the behavior to be universal. In ontrast, in the ase o non-abelian gauge theory with N just below N, we annot redue the theory to an eetive low-energy salar theory. In priniple all higher resonanes ontribute to any orrelation untion and the behavior is nonuniversal. In this ase it is plausible that the order parameter hanges ontinuously as N (N ), even though the theory with N > N has no light salar states. Finally, I note that arguments similar to those presented here may ast light on the disrepanies between the gap-equation [14, 15] and the eetive salar ieldtheory [16] analyses o the hiral phase transition in QED3. In this note I have proposed a simple physial piture or the spetrum o states in SU(N) gauge theory as the number o lavors N approahes the ritial number N rom below (i.e. rom the broken side). This piture predits very dierent and non-universal behavior than is the ase in a onventional seond order phase transition. I have urther argued that this eature results rom the (presumed) existene o a Banks-Zaks ixed point o the gauge oupling in the neighborhood o the hiral transition and thereore depends on the long-distane nature o the non-abelian gauge ore. Aknowledgments I thank Koihi Yamawaki and the organizers o the 1996 International Workshop on Perspetives o Strong Coupling Gauge Theories (SCGT 96) held in Nagoya, Japan rom November, 1996 or holding a stimulating onerene where this More properly, sine we are in the broken phase where no true ixed-point exists, so long as the oupling remains lose to α over a large range o momenta. 3 In some ases the resulting salar theory annot have a seond order transition, but will have a lutuation-indued irst-order transition instead [11]. I the transition is driven to be irst-order, all relevant dimensional quantities will be [1, 13] o order Λ. 4

6 work was begun. I also thank Nik Evans, Stephen Selipsky, Rohana Wijewardhana, Elizabeth Simmons and John Terning or disussions and or omments on the manusript. This work was supported in part by the Department o Energy under grant DE-FG0-91ER

7 Reerenes [1] T. Appelquist, J. Terning, and L. C. R. Wijewardhana, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 (1996) 114. [] T. Banks and A. Zaks, Nul. Phys. B196 (198) 189. [3] T. Maskawa and H. Nakajima, Prog Theor. Phys 5 (1974) 136; 54 (1976) 860; R. Fukuda and T. Kugo Nul. Phys. B117 (1976) 50; P.I. Fomin and V.A. Miransky, Phys. Lett. B64 (1976) 166. [4] J.M. Cornwall, R. Jakiw, and E. Tomboulis, Phys. Rev. D10 (1974) 48. [5] V.A. Miransky Il Nuovo Cimento 90A (1985) 149; V.A. Miransky and P.I. Fomin, Sov. J. Part. Nul. 16 (1985) 03. [6] B. Holdom, Phys. Rev D4 (1981) 1441; B. Holdom, Phys. Lett. B150 (1985) 301; K. Yamawaki, M. Bando, and K. Matumoto, Phys. Rev. Lett. 56 (1986) 1335; T. Appelquist, D. Karabali, and L.C.R. Wijewardhana, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57 (1986) 957; T. Appelquist and L.C.R. Wijewardhana, Phys. Rev D35 (1987) 774; T. Appelquist and L.C.R. Wijewardhana, Phys. Rev D36 (1987) 568. [7] For an alternative, and possibly omplementary, view o the physis o this transition, see V. A. Miransky and K. Yamawaki, hep-th/ [8] Y. Nambu and G. Jona-Lasinio, Phys. Rev. 1, 345 (1961). [9] G. t Hoot, in Reent Developments in Gauge Theories, G. t Hoot, et. al., eds., Plenum Press, New York NY [10] For the ρ-meson see, or example, V. Bernard and U. G. Meissner, Nul. Phys. A489 (1988) 647. [11] S. Coleman and E. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. D7 (1973) [1] R. S. Chivukula, M. Golden, and E. H. Simmons, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) [13] W. A. Bardeen, C. T. Hill, D. Jungnikel, Phys. Rev. D49 (1994) [14] T. Appelquist, D. Nash, and L.C.R. Wijewardhana, Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 575 (1988); D. Nash Phys. Rev. Lett. 6 (1989) 304; T. Appelquist and D. Nash, Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 71 (1990). [15] T. Appelquist, J. Terning, and L.C.R. Wijewardhana, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 (1995) 081. [16] R. D. Pisarski, Phys.Rev. D44 (1991)