arxiv: v1 [hep-ex] 1 Oct 2009

Transcription

1 Proceedings of he DPF-9 Conference, Deroi, MI, July 7-31, 9 1 Discovery Poenial of he Sandard Model Higgs Boson Through H W W Decay Mode wih he Deecor a LHC H.J. Yang (on behalf of he Collaboraion) Deparmen of Physics, Universiy of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 4891, USA arxiv:9.193v1 [hep-ex] 1 Oc 9 We repor resuls of a sudy of he Sandard Model Higgs boson discovery poenial hrough he W-pair leponic decay modes wih he deecor a LHC a 14 TeV cener-of-mass energy. We used MC samples wih full deecor simulaion and reconsrucion of he experimen o esimae he deecion sensiiviy for he reacion of pp H W W eνµν wih no hard je or wo hard jes in he final saes. The prospecs for he Higgs boson searches a are presened, including rigger efficiencies and daa-driven mehods o esimae he backgrounds using conrol samples in daa. Wih fb 1 of inegraed luminosiy, one would expec o discover a Sandard Model Higgs boson wih deecor in Higgs boson mass range 13 < m H < 19 GeV. If he Higgs boson does no exis, we will exend and confirm he exclusion produced by he Tevaron Higgs boson search resul, which has ruled ou he Higgs boson mass range of 16 < m H < 17 GeV a 9% confidence level. If Higgs boson would be discovered, could measure is mass wih a precision of abou and 7 GeV for Higgs boson mass around 16 GeV and 13 GeV, respecively. 1. Inroducion The Sandard Model (SM) of paricle physics is a successful heory confirmed by numerous measuremens since he 197 s. Afer he direc observaions of he massive op quark and he ν τ a Fermilab in 199 and, respecively, only one fundamenal paricle prediced by he SM, he Higgs boson, remains o be discovered. The role of he Higgs boson is criical in he SM because fermions and W/Z bosons, via a process of sponaneous symmery breaking, acquire heir mass hrough ineracions wih he Higgs boson fields. In he SM he Higgs boson couplings o all fermions and elecroweak gauge bosons depend on heir masses. Generically, he SM Higgs boson couples mos srongly o heavy paricles. However, he SM doesn predic he Higgs boson mass, which resuled in a grea experimenal challenging o search for he Higgs boson in a very wide mass range and hrough many differen decay modes. The Leading Order (LO) SM Higgs boson producion mechanism a he LHC (Large Hadron Collider) is shown by he Feynman diagrams in Figure 1, including he processes of he Gluon-Gluon Fusion (GGF), he fusion, he Higgs-srahlung and he Vecor- Boson Fusion (VBF). The dominan process is he GGF Higgs boson as shown in he nex-o-leadingorder (NLO) cross-secion plo in he Figure. Higgs boson producion via VBF is also an imporan producion mechanism for Higgs boson searches a he LHC wih he specific signaure of a Higgs boson wih wo hard jes in he final saes. The Higgs boson producion cross-secion is very small compared o he enormous QCD je producions a he LHC. The abiliy o deec and idenify he Higgs boson decay final saes (see Figure 3) [1] is crucial o he success of he Higgs boson discovery. g g q _ q gg Fusion _ H Higgs-Srahlung W, Z W *, Z * H g g q q Fusion VV Fusion W,Z W,Z Figure 1: SM Higgs boson producion LO Feynman diagrams. The direc search a LEP ses a lower Higgs boson mass limi of GeV a 9% confidence level []. Recen searches a Tevaron exclude he Higgs boson mass beween 16 GeV and 17 GeV a 9% confidence level [3]. The elecroweak daa consrains deduced from consisency condiions of he SM can be used o derive an upper limi of SM Higgs boson mass of 19 GeV a 9% C.L.[1, 4]. Therefore he mos ineresing mass range indicaed by direc Higgs boson search and indirec consrains is beween 114 GeV and 19 GeV. H H

2 Proceedings of he DPF-9 Conference, Deroi, MI, July 7-31, 9 Cross-secion [pb] 1 gg H qqh WH ZH H m H 3 [GeV] Table I Mone Carlo generaors and cross secions for he Higgs boson signal and background processes. The W+jes cross secions lised is he cross secion per lepon flavor. Physics Process Generaor σ(pb) gg H W W (M H = 17 GeV) MC@NLO VBF H W W (M H = 17 GeV) Pyhia.83 qq/qg W W MC@NLO gg W W GGWW.6 pp MC@NLO 833. Z ττ + jes ALPGEN 1 W lν + jes ALPGEN Figure : SM Higgs boson producion NLO cross-secions a he LHC a 14 TeV Branching Raio bb τ τ γ γ WW ZZ Figure 3: SM Higgs boson decay branching raios. Mone Carlo Samples m H 3 [GeV] As shown in he Figure, here are wo dominan Higgs boson producion modes: GGF and VBF, which are in he kinemaic region of ineres for he H W W decay mode. When boh W bosons decay o lepons, he Higgs boson signaure includes wo energeic lepons wih large missing ransverse energy in he final sae. These wo lepons end o go same direcion due o spin correlaion. For he VBF Higgs boson, he final sae also includes wo hard jes which end o be well-separaed in pseudo-rapidiy. The Higgs boson signal and major background sources (SM W W,, Z+jes and W+jes) are lised in Table I. The MC generaors we used o produce MC evens and corresponding cross secions are also lised in he Table I. 3. Leponic W Pair Producion wih No Hard Jes The even selecion for H W W lνlν channel consiss of a se of simple cus. Require ha he seleced even has exacly wo isolaed, opposie-charge lepons (elecron or muon) wih P T > 1 GeV. To suppress single-op background, backgrounds from dileponic decays of b b and c c resonances, and lepon pairs from b c cascade decays, require ha he invarian mass m ll of he lepons is beween 1 GeV and 3 GeV. Require ha he even has missing ransverse energy ET miss > 3 GeV. To suppress Z ττ background, rejec evens which have invarian mass of a hypoheical τ pair in he range M ττ M Z < GeV. To suppress backgrounds from op quark decays, rejec evens ha conain any hard jes wih p T > GeV and η j < 4.8. To furher suppress he op-relaed background, rejec evens wih any jes wih p T > 1 GeV and a b-agging weigh greaer han 4. Table II shows he cross secions in he eµ channel for signal and background afer hese cus. Evens are required o pass a leas one of he single-lepon or double-lepon riggers [1]. The following noaion is used o label differen rigger iems: e (elecron), EM (elecromagneic), MU or mu (muon), I or i (isolaed). As an example EM1I means wo isolaed elecromagneic objecs wih ransverse energy E T > 1 GeV. The Level (L1) rigger menus used here are EM1I, EMI,

3 Proceedings of he DPF-9 Conference, Deroi, MI, July 7-31, 9 3 Table II Cu flows(in fb) for M H = 17 GeV in he H + j, H W W eνµν channel. The WW background conains he wo processes q q W W and gg W W. Selecion Selecion Cus gg H WW Z τ τ W+jes Pre-selecion Lepon Selecion + M ll ET miss > 3 GeV Z τ τ Rejecion Je Veo b-veo Signal region φ < 1.7, M T < 6 GeV.6±..3± ±.7 < ±38 Conrol region φ > 1.7, M T < 6 GeV.9± ± ± ±4. 38±38 EM6I, MU and MU4. For he Level- (L) rigger and Even Filer (EF), evens are required o pass he ei, e1i, e6 or mui riggers. For he eµ channel, he rigger efficiency for L1 is 99.%; for L i is 96.7%, and for EF i is 9.%. The rigger efficiency for signal is quie high and he rigger efficiency does no disor he shapes of he kinemaic variables of ineres in he signal in a significan way. Table II does no include he rigger efficiency. Afer he basic even selecion, he signal o background raio is abou 1:4. This analysis focuses on hree variables: he ransverse opening angle φ ll ; a cu on his variable explois differences in he spin correlaions in he WW sysem in he Higgs boson signal and he WW background (Figure 4) Signal QCD WW φ ll Figure 4: Transverse opening angle φ ll of wo lepons afer preselecion cus. he ransverse momenum of he WW sysem, p W T W, which ends o be slighly larger for signal han for WW background because gluoniniiaed processes end o have more iniialsae radiaion han quark-iniiaed processes (Figure ) Signal QCD WW he ransverse mass which is defined as M T = (ET ll + Emiss T ) (p ll T + pmiss T ) (Figure 6) Fiing Algorihm A -dimensional fi of ransverse mass (M T ) and p W T W in wo bins of he dilepon opening angle φ ll in he ransverse plane has been implemened. Afer he preselecion cus and he addiional requiremen ha M T < 6 GeV is applied, he remaining evens are separaed ino wo subsamples, one wih φ ll < 1.7 (signal region) and he oher wih φ ll > 1.7 (conrol region), as lised in Table II. The op background is esimaed wih he help of b-agged conrol samples wih he same kinemaic WW P T (GeV) Figure : Transverse momenum p W T W afer preselecion cus. of he WW sysem cus as he signal-enriched and background-enriched regions. The cross secion is esimaed based on Mone Carlo samples ha use MC@NLO o model he op background. Sandalone fis are performed on he b-agged conrol samples before he fi o he b-veoed regions begins, he op background in he b-

4 4 Proceedings of he DPF-9 Conference, Deroi, MI, July 7-31, 9 Evens / ( ) W+jes WW Signal Pseudodaa L d= fb M T (GeV) Figure 6: Transverse mass M T for evens wih φ ll < 1.7 and p W T W > GeV assuming a SM Higgs boson wih M H = 17 GeV and fb 1 inegraed luminosiy. veoed regions is esimaed by exrapolaing boh he shape and he normalizaion from he b-agged region o he b-veoed region based on raios obained from MC@NLO. The Z τ τ background is normalized and is shape is deermined by sudying a sample of Z µµ evens aken from real daa, where he reconsruced muons are replaced by simulaed aus. Two muons evens wih a dimuon invarian mass beween 8 and 98 GeV are seleced, and he same je veo is applied o seleced evens. Afer even selecion cus are applied, he effecive cross secion of Z ττ background is abou fb. A sandalone fi o hese daa-mone-carlo evens is performed o deermine he shape and normalizaion of he Z τ τ background; in he final fi, he shape parameers obained from he fi o conrol sample are fixed and he normalizaion is rescaled by a facor ha is assumed in his sudy o be well-prediced. W+jes is one of he main sources of fake backgrounds for he dilepon channels, i is crucial o achieve a good rejecion agains his background. The average je fake as elecron rae is (1.7 ±.) 4 before isolaion and (6.7 ± 1.) afer elecron isolaion. The corresponding je fake as muon rae is (1.7 ±.6) afer isolaion cus are applied. For W+jes background esimaion, due he limied size of he available W+jes Mone Carlo sample, he shape of he ransverse mass and p W T W disribuions are aken from a se of evens wih loosen isolaion and shower shape cus. Furher deailed sudies are needed o esimae W+jes background. Once he fis o he conrol samples are compleed, a simulaneous fi o he wo φ ll bins in he b-veoed region is performed. A few of he parameers ha described he shape of he ransverse mass and p W T W disribuions of he WW background are allowed o floa in he fi. The normalizaions of he WW background are free o floa independenly. However, we add a penaly erm of he form (R fi R rue)/σ R, where R fi is he raio of he bes-fi number of WW background evens in he small- φ ll region over he number in he large large- φ ll region, R rue is he Mone Carlo predicion of he raio aken from he cenral-value calculaion, and σ R is he uncerainy in he predicion of R rue, aken o be %. Probabiliy Nominal L d= fb miss Smeared P T Q scale 1 Q scale Q scale 3 Q scale 4 Leading-order Leading-order WWbb log Likelihood Raio Figure 7: The log Likelihood Raio disribuions for background-only Mone Carlo in H + j, H W W eνµν assuming fb rue M H =17 GeV Mean=-.38 RMS=1.9 Nominal Q Scale 1 Q Scale Q Scale 3 Q Scale 4 Leading-order Leading-order WWbb miss Smeared P T Pull on M H Figure 8: The pull disribuions for M H = 17 GeV for Higgs boson signal and background Mone Carlo in H + j, H W W eνµν assuming fb 1. In order o demonsrae he robusness of he fi agains sysemaic uncerainies, op Mone Carlo has been used o compue he sampling disribuions for he Likelihood Raio in several scenarios where he rue probabiliy disribuion has been disored o model various sources of sysemaic error. Seven disored scenarios are considered: four alered Q

5 Proceedings of he DPF-9 Conference, Deroi, MI, July 7-31, 9 scale choices (facorizaion and renormalizaion scales raised and lowered by facors of 8), wo alernaive op background models (based on leading-order pp W W bb and leading-order pp W W bb), and one alernaive model of all irreducible backgrounds where he x and y componens of ET miss have been independenly smeared by GeV each. Figure 7 shows he Likelihood Raio disribuions for backgroundonly oucomes and Figure 8 represens he disribuions of pulls of he fied Higgs boson mass for signal plus background wih a rue Higgs boson mass of 17 GeV. The lineariy of he mass deerminaion as a funcion of he rue Higgs boson mass is shown in Figure 9. The line shows he mean of a Gaussian fi o he region around he peak of he disribuion of bes-fi Higgs boson masses in he Mone Carlo sample for he case of nominal deecor performance. The green band shows he widh of he Gaussian fi and is a direc measure of he variabiliy of he mass esimae on repeiion of he experimen, he error bars show he median fi error. The ypical variabiliy of he mass deerminaions wih fb 1 inegraed luminosiy are. GeV, 1.6 GeV and 4. GeV a M H = 13, 16 and 19 GeV, respecively. (GeV) rue -M H rec M H Median Fi Error Widh of Gaus. fi o bes-fi Mass dis. L d= fb rue Figure 9: The lineariy of he Higgs boson mass deerminaion for H + j, H W W eνµν a fb 1 inegraed luminosiy. The H W W eνµν is he mos promising channel for Higgs boson masses near he WW hreshold. The expeced SM Higgs boson deecion significance assuming fb 1 inegraed luminosiy is shown in Figure. Median Significance L d = fb Figure : The expeced Higgs boson deecion significance for he H + j, H W W eνµν a fb 1 inegraed luminosiy. 4. Leponic W Pair Producion wih Two Hard Jes For SM Higgs boson produced hrough VBF producion mechanism, he final sae has wo energeic lepons from boh W bosons leponic decays associaed wih wo hard jes. The disincive characerisics of VBF Higgs boson signal include: The wo jes arising from sruck quarks end o be he highes-p T jes in he evens, and hey end o be well-separaed in pseudo-rapidiy; hey end o have a large invarian mass; here is very lile je aciviy in he region beween he wo agging jes. Figure 11 shows he disribuion of he pseudorapidiy gap beween wo agging jes (op lef), invarian mass of wo agging jes (op righ), azimuhal angle beween wo agging jes (boom lef) and ransverse energy of he hird je (boom righ). Where black solid hisograms represen VBF Higgs boson signal wih M H = 17 GeV, green dash-doed hisograms mean WW background, red doed hisograms are and blue dashed hisograms are Z+jes background. The following cus have been applied o seleced H + j, H W W lνlν evens. Two isolaed lepons wih p T > 1 GeV Missing ransverse energy E miss T > 3 GeV A leas wo jes wih p T > GeV and η < 4.8 The wo jes wih highes ransverse momenum are required o be in opposie hemispheres wih η(je1, je) > 3

6 6 Proceedings of he DPF-9 Conference, Deroi, MI, July 7-31, PYTHIA, VBF H Alpgen, Z+jes MC/NLO, bar MC/NLO, WW Pseudorapidiy gap beween Tagjes - -3 PYTHIA, VBF H Alpgen, Z+jes MC/NLO, bar MC/NLO, WW 1 Tagje invarian mass (GeV) PYTHIA, VBF H Alpgen, Z+jes MC/NLO, bar MC/NLO, WW Azimuhal angle beween Tagjes 1 - PYTHIA, VBF H Alpgen, Z+jes MC/NLO, bar MC/NLO, WW Third Je E (GeV) Figure 11: Pseudo-rapidiy gap beween wo agging jes(op lef), invarian mass disribuion of wo agging jes(op righ). azimuhal angle gap beween wo agging jes(boom lef) and E of he hird je(boom righ). Table III Cu flows(in fb) for M H = 17 GeV in he H + j, H W W eνµν channel. Selecion Cus VBF H (17 GeV) WW+jes Z τ τ W+jes Lepon Selecion Forward Je Tagging Lepons Beween Jes Z τ τ Rejecion ET miss,m T,m llν T b-veo signal box, b-je veo 9.8±.7 8.±.7 4.7±.3-4.3±4.3 signal box, no b-je veo Conrol box, b-je veo 3.±.1 89± 9.78± ±. Conrol box, no b-je veo Require ha boh lepons are beween he wo leading jes in pseudo-rapidiy Rejec even which has M ττ M Z < GeV Require ransverse mass < M T < 6 GeV Require ransverse mass m llν T > 3 GeV, m llν T = PT (ll)pt miss (1 cos φ) where φ is he angle beween he di-lepon vecor and he vecor in he ransverse plane. P miss T To suppress b-relaed background, b-veo cus are applied on boh agging jes Table III shows he cu flows (in fb) for M H = 17 GeV in he H + j, H W W eνµν channel. If he even has φ ll < 1. and η ll < 1.4, i lies in he signal box; oherwise, i lies in he conrol region. The rigger efficiency of 99.% afer Level 1, 96.8% afer Level, and 94.% afe he Even Filer. Afer he preselecion, a four-variable Neural Nework is used o furher enhance he separaion be-

7 Proceedings of he DPF-9 Conference, Deroi, MI, July 7-31, 9 7 Evens / (. ) Neural Nework Oupu Figure 1: The Neural Nework oupu disribuion in he signal box, for he 17 GeV H + j, H W W eνµν a fb 1 inegraed luminosiy. Median Significance L d= fb Fixed Exrapolaion Floaing Exrapolaion Sherpa Signal Pyhia 6.4 Signal Figure 14: The expeced Higgs boson deecion significance for he H + j, H W W eνµν a fb 1 inegraed luminosiy. Evens / ( ) Pseudodaa, L d= fb Bes-fi Signal -lepon Background Fake BG (W+jes) M T (GeV) Figure 13: The ransverse mass disribuion for evens in he signal box wih Neural Nework oupu larger han.8 for he 17 GeV H + j, H W W eνµν a fb 1 inegraed luminosiy. curve represens -lepon background and green curve is faked background from W+jes. The fi is a wo-dimensional fi o he Neural Nework oupu and ransverse mass disribuions. Boh he signal model and he background model are uncorrelaed produc probabiliy densiy funcions (PDFs). The Neural Nework oupu disribuion for he background in he signal box is aken o be he same as he disribuion in he conrol region, bu i is muliplied by a linear exrapolaion facor. Apar from he slope of his exrapolaion facor, all parameers governing he shape of he Neural Nework oupu disribuion in he wo regions are required o be he same. The expeced significance is shown as a funcion of he rue Higgs boson mass in Figure 14. ween he signal and he background. The inpus o he Neural Nework are: η(je1, je), he pseudo-rapidiy gap beween wo agging jes M jj, he invarian mass of wo agging jes he ransverse momenum of he leading nonagging je in he region η < 3. η = η 3 (η 1 +η )/, he pseudo-rapidiy gap beween wo agging jes and he hird non-agging je. The Neural Nework oupu disribuion in he signal box is shown in Figure 1. The ransverse mass disribuion for evens in he signal box wih Neural Nework oupu larger han.8 is shown in Figure 13, where black dos wih error bar show Pseudodaa, blue curve shows bes-fi Higgs boson signal, red. Furher Improvemens We expec furher improvemens for Higgs boson deecion sensiiviy. The analysis presened above only includes he eνµν channel wih je-veo or wo forward je agging in evens. Including he eνeν and µνµν channels and adding dilepon evens wih 1 je in final saes will cerainly increase he deecion sensiiviy in. Based on LEP and Tevaron Higgs boson search experiences, he analysis can be carried ou by using maivariae echniques, such as Arificial Neural Neworks (ANN) and Boosed Decision Trees (BDT) [], which would furher improve he deecion sensiiviies. physics group has exensively explored hese advanced analysis mehods [1] and fully developed he ools ha will be used in Higgs boson search program wih LHC collision daa.

8 8 Proceedings of he DPF-9 Conference, Deroi, MI, July 7-31, 9 Median Significance L d = fb H+j, H WW eµ H+j, H WW eµ Combined Figure 1: The expeced Higgs boson deecion significance for he H + j and H + j, H W W eνµν a fb 1 inegraed luminosiy. The prospecs for SM Higgs boson searches in he WW decay mode have been sudied using a realisic model of he deecor. The H + j, H W W eνµν channel is very promising for Higgs boson masses in he region around he WW hreshold. Wih fb 1 of inegraed luminosiy, one would expec o be able o achieve a σ discovery wih he H W W eνµν channel alone if here a SM Higgs boson wih a mass beween 14 GeV and 18 GeV. A measuremen of he mass of he Higgs boson a fb 1 inegraed luminosiy would have a precision of less han GeV for Higgs mass boson of 16 GeV, or a precision of less han 4 GeV for Higgs boson wih mass of 14 GeV. The H + j, H W W eνµν channel has a smaller even rae han he H + j channel. Wih fb 1 of inegraed luminosiy, we expec o reach σ discovery if SM Higgs boson mass beween 1 GeV and 18 GeV. The combined mass deerminaion for he combined fi of H + /j is shown in Figure 16. The corresponding combined significance as a funcion of Higgs boson mass is shown in Figure 1. Acknowledgmens The auhor would like o express graiude o he Collaboraion for excellen work on he Mone Carlo simulaion and he sofware package for physics analysis. The Higgs working group deserves a special hank for producing he resuls presened in his paper. The auhor is suppored by he Deparmen of Energy (DE-FG-9ER4899) of he Unied Saes. (GeV) rue -M H rec M H Median Fi Error Widh of Gaus. fi o bes-fi Mass dis. L d= fb rue Figure 16: The lineariy of he mass deerminaion for he combined fi of H + /j, H W W eνµν a fb 1 inegraed luminosiy. 6. Conclusions References [1] Collaboraion (G. Aad e.al.), Expeced Performance of he Experimen - Deecor, Trigger and Physics, CERN-OPEN-8-, Geneva, 8; [arxiv:91.1]. The Trigger for Early Running, p [] LEP Higgs Working Group, R. Barae e.al., Search for he sandard model higgs boson a LEP, Phys. Le. B6 (3) [3] CDF and D Collaboraion, Combined CDF and D Upper Limis on Sandard Model Higgs-Boson Producion wih up o 4. fb 1 of Daa, Fermilab- PUB-9-6-E (9),[arXiv:93.41]. [4] CMS Collaboraion, S. Abdullin e.al., Summary of he CMS poenial for he Higgs boson discovery, Eur. Phys. J. C 39S () [] H.J. Yang e.al., Nucl. Insrum. Meh. A () Nucl. Insrum. Meh. A43 () 77-84, Nucl. Insrum. Meh. A74 (7) JINST 3:P44 (8).