arxiv: v4 [physics.class-ph] 14 Jul 2018

Transcription

1 Noname manusipt No. will be inseted by the edito Long-Range Longitudinal Eleti Wave in Vauum Radiated by Eleti Dipole: Pat I Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva axiv:7.v4 [physis.lass-ph] 4 Jul 8 Reeived: date / Aepted: date Abstat In this wok by using the assumptions that wavelength is muh smalle than hage sepaation distane of an eleti dipole, whih in tun is muh smalle than a distane up to the point of obsevation, the new esults fo adiation of an eleti dipole wee obtained. These esults genealize and extend the standad lassial solution, and they indiate that unde the above assumptions the eleti dipole emits both long-ange longitudinal eleti and tansvese eletomagneti waves. Fo a speifi values of the dipole system paametes the longitudinal and tansvese eleti fields ae displayed. Total powe emitted by eleti and eletomagneti waves ae alulated and ompaed. It was shown that unde the standad assumption of hage sepaation distane being muh smalle than wavelength: a lassial solution oetly desibes the tansvese eletomagneti waves; b tansvese eletomagneti waves ae dominant and longitudinal eleti waves ae negligible; total adiated powe is popotional to the fouth degee of fequeny and to the seond degee of the hage sepaation distane; d fom lassial solution it is known that most of the powe is emitted pependiula to eleti dipole axis; e ou solution edues to lassial solution. In ase wavelength is muh smalle than hage sepaation distane: a the lassial solution is not valid and it oveestimates the total adiated powe; b longitudinal eleti waves ae dominant and tansvese eletomagneti waves ae negligible; total adiated powe is popotional to the thid degee of fequeny and to the hage sepaation distane; d most of the powe is emitted in a naow beam along the dipole axis, thus emission of waves is foused as with lases. Keywods Eleti dipole Long-ange waves Longitudinal eleti waves Tansvese eletomagneti waves Total adiated powe Altay Zhakatayev Shool of Siene and Tehnology, Leila Tlebaldiyeva Shool of Engineeing, Nazabayev Univesity Room 4, Blok 7, Kabanbay Baty Ave 53 Astana, Kazakhstan, Z5HP9 Tel.: azhakatayev@nu.edu.kz

2 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva Intodution Radiation of the long-ange eletomagneti waves, emitted by a lassial eleti dipole, is well known. Deivation an be found in almost any textbook on eletodynamis [,3,4,,]. The main assumptions used in the deivation of these esults ae d whee d is the distane between two point hages of the eleti dipole, is wavelength of the emitted eletodynami wave and is the distane fom midpoint of the dipole up to the obsevation point. We will onside adiation by the eleti dipole, but with the following assumptions d It tuns out that these new assumptions lead to ompletely novel esults. Thee ae two eleti dipole systems onsideed in the liteatue: one in whih hages have onstant magnitude but osillating position [3, 4], and anothe in whih hages ae fixed in spae and so do not move, but thei hage magnitudes ae osillating [4,6]. In this pape ou fous will be on the latte system. To the best knowledge of authos, these esults wee not published befoe. Liteatue oveing the longitudinal eleti waves is sae. This is due to the fat that aoding to Gauss s law longitudinal eleti waves ae impossible in vauum. Howeve in this pape we hallenge the impliations of the Gauss s law with espet to the existene of longitudinal eleti waves by onsideing the eleti dipole adiation. A theoetial method fo quantizing the adiation field using tansvese, longitudinal and sala photons was intodued in [5]. An attempt to onside the existene of longitudinal eleti waves using geneal famewok of lassial eletodynamis was tied in [5]. Possible existene and physial elevane of longitudinal eletomagneti waves fom quantum eletodynami point of view was studied in [9]. Fomation of tansient longitudinal eletomagneti wave at the instant when a point hage osses the pefetly onduting half-spae and annihilates with its image was theoetially shown in [3]. Theoetial Deivation Sala and veto potentials ae defined using hage ρ and uent J densities as V, t = ˆ ρ, t dv ɛ 3a A, t = µ ˆ J, t dv 3b hee is adius veto fom hage loation at etaded time t up to the point, whee potential fields ae being obseved, and is its magnitude. t is etaded time, i.e. time at whih sala potential was emitted by a hage element o veto potential was emitted by a uent element., and ˆ ae oespondingly adius veto fom the oigin of efeene oodinate system up to the point of obsevation, its magnitude and its unit veto. Radius veto fom oigin of efeene

3 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 3 Fig. Shemati diagam of an eleti dipole system up to the point whee hage o uent element is loated at etaded time t is denoted as and =. The point of obsevation is whee we want to find the eleti and magneti fields. In this pape we will use spheial oodinate system, as it is used fo deivation of dipole adiation in lassial ase, Fig.. The unit vetos of the spheial fame ae ˆ, ˆθ and ˆφ. All of the deivation will be done fo point hages. Howeve in eality we should employ in the analysis small finite ondutive sphees instead of point hages, due to the fat that by definition hage value of point hages like eleton is onstant. If we assume that eleti potential on the outside sufae of the small onduting sphee hanges simultaneously, then the analysis will not hange if point hages ae used instead of finite but small sphees. Theefoe bea in mind that even though point hage is used in the analysis, in eality we mean finite but small sphees, hage magnitude of whih an hange. In othe wods, it might be said that in this analysis adius of small sphees is taken as negligible ompaed to any othe spatial dimensions of the system. The sala and veto potentials of a point hage q and of a steady uent I fo lassial low veloity ase v ae given as V, t = q, t 4a ɛ A, t = µ I, t One point hage, whih will be alled uppe hage, is loated at z = d. The othe hage, it will be given a name of lowe hage, is loated at z = d. Two hages ae sepaated by a distane d. + is distane fom the uppe hage to the point of obsevation, while is the same distane but fom the lowe hage, Fig.. We assume that hages ae stationay, i.e. not moving, but hage magnitude is a funtion of time. The assumptions in an be ast in the following dimensionless fom d 5a 5b ω 5 4b

4 4 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva whee we used the identity = π ω, ω is the fequeny of the wave. We note that in the standad lassial deivation of the eleti dipole adiation invese of assumption 5b is used 6 We an use the following identity fo + and : ± = d os θ + d 7 If Taylo seies expansion is applied fo RHS of the above equation and 5a is used to take only the fist ode tems, then we obtain the following appoximations ± d os θ 8a ± ± d os θ 8b ± ± d os θ 8 Additionally the following appoximation, obtained by using 8a, will be useful fo us late osωt ± osωt os os θ ωt sin os θ 9 Let us assume that at the initial time t = the uppe hage has positive hage q, while the lowe hage has negative hage q. The value of these hages hanges aoding to osine funtion fo late times t > as q, t = ±q os ωt Let us find the sala potentials due to the uppe hage V +, t and due to the lowe hage V, t at point and at time t. Aoding to 4a we will have V +, t = q, t ɛ = q os ωt ɛ V, t = q, t ɛ = q os ωt ɛ = q os ωt + ɛ + = q os ωt ɛ Then sala potential field of the dipole will have the following fom V, t = V +, t + V, t = q + osωt ɛ + osωt If 8b and 9 ae used to open the bakets in above equation and late 5a is used fo the obtained expession, then we get V, t q ɛ ωt os θ 3 Gadient of the sala potential in the spheial fame is V = V ˆ + V θ ˆθ 4

5 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 5 The sala potential 3 does not depend on φ o ˆφ, and theefoe its gadient ontains only two tems. Let us evaluate the fist tem in the gadient by diffeentiating 3 and then applying 5 V q ω ɛ os θ osωt 5 The seond tem in the gadient is obtained again by diffeentiating 3 V θ = q ɛ sin θ os os θ ωt 6 Now we an ombine above two identities, apply 5a to the esultant expession, and finally we get gadient of the sala potential Cuent an be defined as V, t q ω ɛ os θ osωt ˆ 7 I, t = qt ẑ = q ω sin ωt ẑ 8 In ase of lassial dipole adiation, magnitude of the uent I = q ω is taken as onstant ove distane d due to assumption [7,8] and the only vaiable in the uent is the etaded time t. Above assumption intuitively an be undestood as the following. When assumption d is taken, it means that distane between hages is muh smalle than wavelength of the AC uent. If we feeze AC uent wave in time, then diffeent pats of the wavelength of the uent wave oespond to diffeent uent magnitudes. Theefoe at a given fixed time uent magnitude between two hages is almost onstant in spae. Thus it is easonable to assume that at any given time uent magnitude between two hages of the dipole is onstant. In this ase, howeve, we an no longe assume that uent magnitude is onstants ove d due to 5b. In othe wods, uent will vay due to vaiation of its magnitude in spae and due to vaiation of etaded time. Theefoe we have to onside the following uent I, t = q ω sin π d z + ωt ẑ 9 whih simplifies to old lassial expession 8 unde assumption d taken fo lassial hage. This uent, simila to its lassial ountepat 8, satisfies the hage onsevation law fo the uppe hage. In effet 9 epesents AC uent wave in spae and in time, flowing o taveling in the dietion of positive hage. Note also that we assume that eleti uent, o eletiity, is taveling along the wie onneting the point hages at the speed. This means that veloity fato of the wie onneting the point hages is taken to be %. We note that the non-onstant time-vaying uents, simila to the one in 9, ae onsideed in almost any textbook about linea antenna theoies o tansmission line theoies. Fo example, dipole antenna with standing wave uent onsisting of fou taveling onstant uent waves was onsideed in [7], tiangula and sine standing wave uents in the small and finite dipole antenna wee onsideed in [], sine wave uent in linea antenna was onsideed in [4].

6 6 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva Next the veto potential needs to be evaluated A, t = µ d I, t dz = µ q ω ẑ d π d z + ωt dz hee is distane fom uent segment, whih is being integated, up to the point of obsevation of fields see Fig., z is integation vaiable, d z d. Fo uent segment we an wite simila appoximations as fo the two point hage loations z os θ a ± z os θ b z ± os θ hee the sign depend on whethe z is above o below it. Using tigonometi identities, sine tem inside the integal an be witten as a sum of fou tems d d d π d z + ωt dz = π d z osωt + os π d z ωt dz = os os πz os πz πz os osωt + πz + ωt dz Then evaluating the integal in an be done by integating sepaately eah of the fou tems in. Let us pefom integation fo the fist tem by using

7 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 7 a and b d ˆ d os πz osωt dz = os πz osωt + z os θ z os θdz+ os πz osωt z os θ + z os θdz = osωt ˆ d d os πz ωz os os θdz os πz ωz os os θ z os θdz + ωt ˆ d os πz ωz os πz ωz os θdz d os θdz os πz ωz os os θ z os θdz + os πz ωz os θ z os θdz 3 Hee we see that the above integal integal of the fist tem in is split into anothe six integal tems. Let us evaluate, using simple integal tigonometi identities when neessay, eah of the six integal tems in 3: d π os πz ωz os os θdz = os θ os θ + + os θ + os θ 4 os θ os θ ˆ d os πz ωz os os θ z os θdz = os θ + os θ os os os θ d + os θ d os πz ωz os os θ z os θdz = os θ + os θ os os os θ + d + os θ + d os θ + os θ os θ + os θ os θ+ + os θ 5 os θ+ + os θ 6

8 8 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva ˆ d os πz ωz os θdz = os + os θ + os θ + os os θ os θ 7 os πz os θ ωz os θdz = os + os θ + os θ + os os θ os θ 8 d os πz ωz os θ z os θdz = π + os θ π os θ + os θ d π os θ + d π + os θ os θ os + os θ os os θ By substituting 4-9 into 3, athe long expession is obtained 9 d os πz osωt dz = π osωt os θ π os θ os θ os θ + + os θ os os θ + π d os θ os θ + d + os θ π ωt os θ π + os θ + os θ + os θ os os θ os θ + os θ + os θ π d os os θ os θ d + os θ os θ os + os θ + os θ+ os + os θ + + os + os θ os θ+ 3 We need to emembe that the above expession epesents the integal of only one tem out of fou in. In ode to save spae, the detailed evaluation of the othe tems is given in the appendix Se. 6. The integal of the seond, thid and fouth tems in ae given in 64, 66 and 68 oespondingly. Let us substitute these esults into, then fo we get again long expession. The following simple identities will be useful fo us = 4 3a

9 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 9 π = ω 3b If the tems of the expession fo A, t ae then gouped and simplified using tigonometi identities, elations 3a and 3b ae applied, and late assumptions 5a and 5 ae implemented, we obtain the esult whih etains the most signifiant tems A, t q ɛ ẑ osωt os θ 4 ωt os θ + os θ os θ + os θ+ 4 + os θ os θ+ 4 + os θ os os θ + os θ+ 4 os + os θ 4 4 os θ 3 Equation fo veto potential 3 is simila to equation fo sala potential 3. Now we ae at the position to find the time deivative of the veto potential A t, t = q ω ɛ os θˆ sin θ ˆθ osωt os os θ 4 ωt os θ + os θ os os θ + os θ+ 4 + os θ os θ os θ + os θ+ 4 + os θ + os θ 4 4 os θ 33

10 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva whee we used identity ẑ = os θˆ sin θ ˆθ. Finally we an ombine 33 and 7 to find the eleti field E E, t = V A t = q [ ω osωt ɛ os θ os θ os 3 + os θ + os θ + os θ 4 4 os θ os + os θ os θ 4 4 os θ + ωt os θ 3 + os θ + os θ+ + os θ 4 4 os θ + os θ os θ 4 4 os θ ˆ+ osωt sin θ os 3 + os θ + os θ+ + os θ 4 4 sin θ os + os θ os θ 4 4 os θ + ωt sin θ 3 + os θ + os θ + os θ 4 4 sin θ ] + os θ os θ 4 4 os θ ˆθ 34 Next we need to find the magneti field B. Howeve befoe finding the magneti field, let us deive equation fo the ul of A = A ˆ + A θ ˆθ given in 3 A = A θ A θ ˆφ = A θ + A θ A θ ˆφ; 35 hee again, as was the ase with the sala potential, ul of the veto potential has only one omponent along ˆφ, beause the veto potential does not depend on φ o ˆφ. If we use ẑ = os θˆ sin θ ˆθ in 3, then substitute it to 35 and apply the assumptions 5a and 5, we get afte somewhat lengthy deivation B = A q ω ɛ osωt sin θ os 3 + os θ + os θ+ + os θ 4 4 sin θ os + os θ os θ 4 4 os θ + ωt sin θ 3 + os θ + os θ + os θ 4 4 sin θ + os θ os θ 4 4 os θ ˆφ 36 At last we found eleti and magneti fields adiated by the eleti dipole unde the assumptions 5a-5.

11 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 3 Results In effet the eleti field of the dipole 34 an be witten as E = E ˆ + E θ ˆθ and it onsists of adial E and tansvese E θ omponents. If simple tigonometi identities ae used, then we an wite the adial and tansvese omponents of the eleti field in a fom moe suitable fo late analysis E = q ɛ ω osωt os θ+ os θ + os θ+ + os θ os θ os θ os θ + ωt os θ os os + os θ+ + os θ os θ os os θ os os θ E θ = q ω osωt ɛ sin θ os θ ωt sin θ os θ sin θ + os θ sin θ + os θ os θ + os os os os θ + os θ + + os θ os + 37a 37b The magneti field 36 an be witten as B = B φ ˆφ, whee again afte applying some tigonometi identities B φ = q ω ɛ osωt sin θ + os θ + os θ + sin θ os θ os θ + ωt sin θ os + os θ os + os θ + sin θ os os os θ os θ 38 Let us ty to qualitatively undestand the obtained esults. The fist obsevation is that eleti 37 and magneti 38 fields ae invesely popotional to the distane in the fist powe. Theefoe we onlude that these ae indeed fa fields long-ange adiated by the eleti dipole. The seond obsevation is that if we ompae 37b and 38, then B φ = E θ, B φ and E θ ae in phase, they ae mutually pependiula and they ae pependiula to tavel dietion ˆ. Thus

12 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva we onlude that B φ and E θ togethe ompise tansvese eletomagneti omponent of the adiation. On the othe hand, E is dieted adially outwad along the tavel dietion ˆ and thee is no magneti field assoiated with this eleti field. Theefoe we onlude that E is pue adial o longitudinal eleti omponent of the adiation. Also we notie that total eleti field lies in θ plane, while total magneti field is pependiula to that plane along ˆφ. Thus total eleti field is still othogonal to the total magneti field. The thid obsevation is that, apat fom tems ontained within lage bakets, E and E θ ae equal in magnitude. Thus it suggests that longitudinal eleti field is on pa in tems of intensity with its taditional tansvese ountepat, i.e. it is not some seond ode faint effet. In othe wods, longitudinal eleti field is as eal as the tansvese eleti field. We an all E pue eleti wave, in ontast to eletomagneti wave, beause it is eleti field adiated and taveling outwad by the dipole without aompanying magneti omponent. Anothe impotant item that we should point out is that duing the deivation of these esults up to this point we atually neve used expliitly the assumption 5b. We used it impliitly by aying ove not eduing all tems whih ontain, fo example, you see tems with it in 37 and 38. Theefoe we an say that the above deivation was done using only two assumptions 5a and 5. Howeve we know that duing the deivation of adiation in the standad lassial ase, the invese assumption 6 o is used in addition to 5a and 5. Thus, judging only by the numbe of assumptions used duing the deivation, we an onlude that the deivation pesented hee is moe geneal than the taditional one. Howeve that also gives us oppotunity to hek ou solution, beause with the assumption 6 ou solution should be edued to the taditional lassial eleti dipole adiation esults. Let us veify that, using the following appoximations obtained by employing 6 os By applying 39 to 37 and 38, the following is obtained E q ω osωt ɛ os θ+ os θ + os θ + os θ + os θ os θ os θ ωt os θ os θ + + os θ os θ = + 39a 39b 4a E θ q ω osωt sin θ ɛ + os θ + os θ + sin θ os θ os θ + ωt sin θ sin θ + + os θ os θ = q ω d ɛ osωt sin θ 4b

13 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 3 B φ q ω ɛ osωt sin θ + os θ + os θ + sin θ os θ os θ + ωt sin θ sin θ + + os θ os θ = q ω d ɛ 3 osωt sin θ 4 Thus we an lealy see that ou solution edues to the standad lassial solution unde the assumption 39, whih poves that the new solution pesented hee is genealized ase of the lassial solution. Let us ty to visualize the adiation patten fo the new ase. We assume the following paametes: q = 9 Q, d = m, = 4 m, = = 4 m, t = s, ω = π = 6 π ad/s. Note that assumed values fo, d and satisfy ou assumptions 5a-5. With the given values we want to plot longitudinal 37a and tansvese 37b eleti field values as a funtion of θ and in the following ange θ π and +. Inteestingly when these funtions wee plotted we found that eleti fields ae zeo fo all values of θ exept at the angles lose to and π. In the small egions aound θ = and θ = π eleti fields have finite values. Theefoe in Fig. and in 3 fo laity longitudinal and tansvese eleti fields ae shown fo a small egion θ π 5. We an also say that these figues depit time shots of eleti fields as they ae taveling in spae at t = s. A ange of the dimensionless paamete oesponds to +. In ode to save spae with numbeing of the z axis in the plots, eleti fields had to be saled as E = E 6 fo longitudinal eleti field and Eθ = E θ 4 fo tansvese eleti field. To investigate the effet of the distane d on the eleti fields, eah subplot in Fig. and in 3 depits eleti fields fo diffeent values of = π d. Hee d is vaied as d = + i. fo i =,,.., 9. Fo < and > eleti fields ae just yli epetitions of these plots this is valid only if vaiation of is small enough to neglet amplitude vaiation of the eleti fields due to the invese tem. Fo a egion aound θ = π eleti fields look idential to thei oesponding images aound θ =, but fo some eason shifted in phase. By ompaing Fig. and 3 we notie the following let us emind that this is valid fo the hosen values of the paametes: The magnitude of the longitudinal eleti fa field is lage by an ode of than the magnitude of the tansvese eleti fa field. Maximum and minimum values of the longitudinal eleti wave lie exatly on θ = and θ = π, while max and min values of the tansvese eleti field lie not exatly but slightly off these angle values. Tansvese eleti field is atually lose to zeo at θ = and θ = π values. Radiation of the longitudinal and tansvese waves happens in vey naow one beam with plana angle aound θ π 5. A small vaiation of d aound its given value affets only the phase of the eleti field adiation. Shape of the longitudinal eleti field wavelet is diffeent than the shape of the tansvese field wavelet. Spatially, min values of the longitudinal field oughly oespond to max values of the tansvese field.

14 4 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva Fig. Longitudinal eleti field as a funtion of and θ fo diffeent saled eleti field E = E 6 edued by million is plotted.. Fo laity the

15 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length Fig. 3 Tansvese eleti field as a funtion of and θ fo diffeent eleti field Eθ = Eθ 4 edued by ten thousand is plotted. 5. Fo laity the saled

16 6 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva The next step fo us is to find the total adiated powe. Longitudinal and tansvese eleti waves ay enegy away fom the dipole. Let us fist evaluate the aveage net powe adiated by the longitudinal eleti field. Due to the fat that Poynting veto aounts only fo enegy tansfe by tansvese eleti and magneti fields, we have to use longitudinal eleti field enegy density in ode to alulate its enegy tansfe. Enegy density of the longitudinal eleti field is given as η = ɛ E 4 If we assume that longitudinal eleti field also tavels outwad with the speed, then magnitude W of enegy tansfeed away by the longitudinal waves pe unit time t pe unit aea S is given as dw dtds = η ˆ = ɛ E ˆ 4 hee ˆ just shows dietion of enegy flow. Aveage enegy pe peiod passing ove unit aea by the longitudinal waves, whih is equal to aveage powe pe aea, an be found as: d W ds = ɛ ˆ ˆ T E tdt 43 T In ode to evaluate the above integal we an ewite 37a E t = q ɛ ω osωt A + ωt B whee A = os θ os θ os θ+ +os θ +os θ+ os θ os θ and B = os θ +os θ os os + os θ + os θ os θ os os θ os. A and B do not depend on time. If 44 into 43 ae substituted, and the following identities ˆ T os ωt T dt = 45a ˆ T T ae used, then we obtain T ˆ T sin ωt dt = osωt ωt dt = 44 45b 45 d W ds = 4 ɛ q ɛ ω A + B ˆ 46 Infinitesimal sufae aea in spheial oodinate system at onstant adius is given as ds = sin θdθdφˆ. The net aveage powe adiated by the longitudinal eleti waves of the dipole is W = q ω 3πɛ W ds ds = 4 ɛ q ɛ ω ˆ π A + B sin θdθ ˆ πˆ π A + B sin θdθdφ = 47

17 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 7 As we an see the aveage adiated longitudinal powe of the dipole does not depend on, whih is expeted. With the same analysis we an obtain the expession fo aveage net powe, adiated by the tansvese eleti and magneti waves of the dipole. Fo that the Poynting veto is given as P = µ E θ ˆθ B φ ˆφ = ɛ E θˆ 48 The aveage enegy pe peiod pe aea adiated away an be found P = ɛ ˆ T ˆ T E θtdt 49 As befoe, in ode to evaluate 49, 37b an be ewitten as E θ = q ω osωt ɛ C + ωt D whee C = sin θ +os θ + os θ + sin θ os θ os θ and D = sin θ +os θ os + os θ os + sin θ os θ os os os θ. Again C and D do not depend on time. Theefoe fo 49 we obtain 5 P = ɛ q ɛ ω C + D ˆ 5 In ode to find the aveage net powe adiated by the tansvese eleti and magneti waves, the above expession needs to be integated with espet to aea ˆ W t = q ω 6πɛ P ds = ɛ q ɛ ω ˆ π C + D sin θdθ ˆ πˆ π C + D sin θdθdφ = The aveage total powe enegy pe peiod adiated by the eleti dipole is equal to the sum of net longitudinal 47 and tansvese 5 powes 5 W total = W + W t 53 We ould not find the analytial solution fo the integals in 47 and 5. Theefoe we ae poviding numeial esults. Just fo the sake of ompaison, we pesent the lassial esult fo total powe tansvese only adiated by the dipole with the assumption 6 W old = q d ω 4 πɛ 3 54 In ode to see the effet of the atio d on powe, we fixed = 4 m and vaied d. Fo the dipole with hage sepaation d, we an define fundamental wavelength and fundamental fequeny as = d and ω = π. The longitudinal powe 47, tansvese powe 5, total powe 53 and total powe aoding to lassial solution 54 adiated by the dipole as a funtion of d is shown in

18 8 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva Fig. 4 Aveage longitudinal powe W ed dot, aveage tansvese powe W t blue dot, aveage total powe W total geen dot and total powe aoding to lassial solution W old blak dot adiated by the dipole as a funtion of d. a fo vaiation of d = 4 m, b fo vaiation of d = m. Fig. 4a. As we an see, total powe aoding to the lassial solution, whih is the tansvese powe, has onstant slope in log sale plot. Fo d, whih in anothe wods means fo ω ω, total powe 53 onsists of solely tansvese powe 5, whih also oinides with lassial solution, while longitudinal powe 47 is seveal odes of magnitude less and thus is negligible. In this egion due to assumption 6 lassial solution is valid, and so W total d. Fo d, o in othe wods fo ω ω, total powe onsists of mostly longitudinal powe, whih is seveal odes of magnitude lage than tansvese powe. This means that in this egion tansvese powe is negligible. Total powe fom lassial solution is seveal odes of magnitude lage than total powe 53. In this egion due to assumption 6 lassial solution is not valid, and fom the figue it an be found that W total d. Fo a egion aound d, o fo ω ω, longitudinal powe is on pa with tansvese powe. It is inteesting to note that tansvese powe 5 has some dip aound ω ω, whih we speulate would be inteesting to obseve expeimentally. In ode to see the effet o ω on the adiated powe, we deided to plot the powe again as a funtion of d, but in this ase by fixing the d = m and by vaying instead the, Fig. 4b. Geneally it onveys the same infomation as in Fig. 4a. Howeve it an be notied that fo d W total ω 4, whih is the same as lassial esult W old. While fo d W total ω 3. Ratio of longitudinal to tansvese powe R = W W t 55 is shown in Fig. 5. This figue onfims ou pevious obsevations, fo d longitudinal powe is negligible, while fo d tansvese powe is negligible. In ode to see the adiation patten plot of the longitudinal eleti waves of the dipole system, the expession 46 should be dawn as a funtion of θ. While plotting the expession 5 would povide adiation patten fo tansvese eleti o magneti fields of the dipole.

19 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 9 Fig. 5 Ratio of longitudinal powe and tansvese powe adiated by the dipole as a funtion of d. 4 Disussion We an summaize the esults as the following. Fo ω ω, whee ω is fundamental fequeny of an eleti dipole as defined above, the tansvese powe is dominant and oinides with lassial solution. Classial solution is valid in this egion and total adiated powe is popotional to the fouth degee of the fequeny and to the seond degee of the hage sepaation distane. Fo ω ω the longitudinal powe is dominant and in this egions the lassial solution geatly oveestimates the total adiated powe. In this egion lassial solution is invalid and total adiated powe is popotional to the thid degee of the fequeny and to the hage sepaation distane. Thus lassial solution pedits oetly only the tansvese adiated powe and only in ω ω egion. In the egion ω ω both longitudinal and tansvese powes ae equal. In some books deivation of adiation of the lassial eleti dipole is done fo the ase when point hages have onstant hage and ae osillating [3]. While in othe deivations point hages ae taken as fixed in spae, but thei hage magnitudes ae osillating [4]. Fo the lassial dipole ase d these two appoahes lead to the same esults. In this wok we extended the latte ase, while simila extension of the fome ase is impossible. This omes fom the fat that point hages, while osillating with peiod T, an not move faste than v d T = d 56 Theefoe extension of the ase, whee point hages of the dipole have onstant hage but ae moving osillating, is impossible fo d. Even though in the egion d the above two appoahes ae equivalent, we speulate that in the egion d these two appoahes lead to diffeent outomes. We note also that fo deivation of adiation fom geneal hage-uent distibution mostly the following assumption is made instead of the assumption that we used

20 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva in 8b and b, whih might patially explain the new esults obtained in this pape [, ]. We note that even though the esults fo eleti and magneti fields given in 37 and 38 ae genealized ases of the lassial solution, the esults fo longitudinal eleti field ae stitly valid only fo the ase d = N N, whee N is non-negative intege N =,,,...,. This is due to the speifi fom of sala potential taken in. The esults fo tansvese eleti and magneti fields ae valid fo geneal ase d = R R, whee R is positive eal numbe. Afte obtaining these esults, let us now be bold by tuning on ou imagination and let us disuss some issues o questions whih the new findings open up. We know that tansvese eletomagneti waves ae tansmitted by photons. Ae thee longitudinal photons, whih tansmit the longitudinal pue eleti waves? We speulate that if these longitudinal photons exist, then they might have popeties ompletely diffeent than tansvese photons. Fo the paametes that wee used to obtain the esults, it was obseved that the tansvese and longitudinal eleti waves exist only in small angula egion aound θ = and θ = π. This means that fo these paametes the adiation patten is vey naowly foused beam, like a lase beam. We speulate that the lage is the atio d the moe foused the beam is. Fousing of the beam is ahieved just by ineasing the sepaation distane d, without using any efleting mios. The lage is the atio d, the moe powe is adiated by longitudinal waves. Theefoe it will be inteesting to investigate the possible usage of the longitudinal eleti waves fo ommuniation and possibly fo powe tansmission. We speulate that longitudinal eleti waves an shed a light and explain the so alled EM dive phenomena [6]. Also phenomena of displaement uent, whih is used to desibe the magneti field aising aound apaitane when altenating uent is passing though it, might be explained by this longitudinal eleti waves. In fat, we note that lassial solution suggests that point eleti hages, hamonially osillating along the staight line, emit mostly tansvese waves pependiula to the line. While the new esults indiate that when d, point eleti hages, with hamonially osillating hage magnitude, emit longitudinal and tansvese waves mostly along the line joining the two hages. Thus if we think of two apaitane plates as onsisting of many infinitesimal point hages, then we believe that apaitane is the best emitte of longitudinal waves in the dietion pependiula to the plates. In most of the solid medium longitudinal aousti waves tavel faste than tansvese aousti waves. If we apply this analogy to eletomagnetism, then what is the speed of popagation of longitudinal eleti waves? Is it faste than? Is it possible that is onstant and limit to tansvese eletomagneti waves, but it is not a limit to longitudinal eleti waves? Final note is that existene of longitudinal eleti waves ontadits one of the Maxwell equations Gauss s law E =, whih in the given fom is thought to be valid in vauum fo volumes of spae outside of eleti hages. Howeve in ou next wok, whih is almost omplete, we will pove that Gauss law is only valid fo a point hage with onstant magnitude qt = onst, no matte how it moves. Results show that fo a system in whih total hage is not a onstant, but instead is a funtion of time qt, the Gauss s law is invalid, unde the assumption that eletodynami potentials ae moe fundamental than fields. This leads in geneal

21 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length ase to E even in vauum fo volumes of spae outside of eleti hages. Theefoe longitudinal eleti waves ae possible in vauum o fee spae. We hope that soon ou theoetial esults will be heked expeimentally and eithe veified o ejeted. Howeve we speulate that Nikola Tesla might have woked aleady expeimentally with these longitudinal eleti waves. Also longitudinal eleti waves emitted by spheial antenna wee obseved in []. 5 Conlusion In this wok existene of longitudinal eleti waves, adiated by eleti dipole when hage sepaation distane is muh lage than wavelength, has been poven theoetially within the famewok of lassial eletodynamis. By using the assumptions d, the new esults fo adiation of an eleti dipole wee obtained, whih ae not studied in lassial eletodynamis. These esults genealize and extend the lassial solution, and they indiate that unde the above assumptions the lassial eleti dipole emits both long-ange longitudinal eleti and tansvese eletomagneti waves. Fo a speifi values of the dipole system paametes the longitudinal and tansvese eleti fields ae displayed. Total powe emitted by eleti and eletomagneti waves ae alulated and ompaed. It was shown that unde the assumption d : a lassial solution oetly desibes the tansvese eletomagneti waves; b tansvese eletomagneti waves ae dominant and longitudinal eleti waves ae negligible; total adiated powe is popotional to the fouth degee of fequeny and to the seond degee of the hage sepaation distane; d fom lassial solution it is known that most of the powe is emitted pependiula to eleti dipole axis; e ou solution edues to lassial solution. In ase d: a the lassial solution is not valid and it oveestimates the total adiated powe; b longitudinal eleti waves ae dominant and tansvese eletomagneti waves ae negligible; total adiated powe is popotional to the thid degee of fequeny and to the hage sepaation distane; d most of the powe is emitted in a naow beam along the dipole axis, thus emission of waves is foused as with lases. It would be vey inteesting to obseve these phenomena in expeiments. Longitudinal eleti waves ould evolutionize wieless ommuniation, emote powe tansmission and 5G ommuniation tehnologies. Aknowledgments We would like to thank ou family and ou supevisos Pof. Atakan Vaol and Pof. Theodoos Tsiftsis fo thei suppot. 6 Appendix I Hee we pesent the deivation of integal expessions. The integal of the seond tem in an be witten as

22 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva d ˆ d πz osωt dz = πz osωt + z os θ z os θdz+ πz osωt z os θ + z os θdz = osωt ˆ d d πz ωz os os θdz πz ωz os os θ z os θdz + ωt ˆ d πz ωz πz ωz os θdz d os θdz πz ωz os os θ z os θdz + πz ωz os θ z os θdz Eah of the six integal tems in the last expession is evaluated below: 57 d πz ωz os os θdz = 58 os θ os θ ˆ d πz ωz os os θ z os θdz = + os θ os θ + os θ d os θ d πz ωz os os θ z os θdz = + os θ os θ ˆ d + os θ d os θ d πz ωz os θdz = os θ + os θ os θ + os θ os θ os + os θ+ os os θ 59 os + os θ+ os os θ os θ + os θ + os θ 6 6

23 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 3 πz os θ ωz os θdz = os θ + os θ + os θ 6 d πz ωz os θ z os θdz = 63 If we substitute the last six equations into 57, then we get d πz osωt dz = 64 The integal of the thid tem in an be witten as d ˆ d os πz ωt dz = os πz ωt + z os θ z os θdz+ os πz ωt z os θ + z os θdz = ωt ˆ d os πz ωz os d os θ z osωt ˆ os πz os πz ωz os os θdz d os πz ωz os θdz + os θdz + ωz os θdz+ d os πz ωz os os θ z os θdz + os πz ωz os θ z os θdz 65

24 4 Altay Zhakatayev, Leila Tlebaldiyeva Eah of the six integal tems in the last expession wee aleady evaluated in 4-9. If we substitute these esults into 65, then we obtain d os πz ωt dz = π osωt os θ π os θ os os θ os θ + + os θ os θ + π d os os θ os θ d + os θ π ωt os θ os π + os θ + os θ os + os θ os θ os θ + + os θ + os θ + π d os θ os θ + d + os θ The fouth integal tem in an be witten as os θ + os θ os + os θ+ + os θ+ + + os θ+ os os θ + 66 d ˆ d πz ωt dz = πz ωt + z os θ z os θdz+ πz ωt z os θ + z os θdz = ωt ˆ d πz ωz os d os θ z osωt ˆ πz πz ωz os os θdz d πz ωz os θdz + os θdz + ωz os θdz+ d πz ωz os os θ z os θdz + πz ωz os θ z os θdz 67 The six integals in 67 wee aleady evaluated in Theefoe we obtain d πz ωt dz = 68

25 Title Suppessed Due to Exessive Length 5 Refeenes. Balanis, C.A.: Antenna Theoy, Analysis and Design, 3d edn. John Wiley and Sons, USA 5. Fanklin, J.: Classial Eletomagnetism. Peason, USA 5 3. Geine, W.: Classial Eletodynamis. Spinge Giffiths, D.J.: Intodution to Eletodynamis. Pentie Hall, USA Gupta, S.N.: Theoy of longitudinal photons in quantum eletodynamis. Poeedings of the Physial Soiety. Setion A 637, URL /63/i=7/a=3 6. Heald, M.A., Maion, J.B.: Classial Eletomagneti Radiation, 3d edn. Saundes College Publishing, USA Jefimenko, O.D.: Eletiity and Magnetism: An Intodution to the Theoy of Eleti and Magneti Fields, nd edn. Eletet Sientifi, USA Jefimenko, O.D.: Causality, Eletomagneti Indution, and Gavitation: A Diffeent Appoah to the Theoy of Eletomagneti and Gavitational Fields, nd edn. Eletet Sientifi Co, USA 9. Khvoostenko, N.P.: Longitudinal eletomagneti waves. Russian Physis Jounal 353, URL Monstein, C., Wesley, J.P.: Obsevation of sala longitudinal eletodynami waves. EPL Euophysis Lettes 594, 54. URL 4/a=54. Ohanian, H.C.: Classial Eletodynamis. Allyn and Baon, In, USA 988. Panofsky, W.K.H., Phillips, M.: Classial Eletiity and Magnetism, nd edn. Addison- Wesley Publishing Company, In., USA Pijmenko, S.D.: To fomation of the longitudinal eletomagneti wave at disete hange of a hage density fo nomal and inlined falling of the aeleated point hage patile. In: MICROWAVES, RADAR AND REMOTE SENSING SYMPOSIUM, pp DOI.9/MRRS Shwinge, J., DeRaad, L.L.J., Milton, K.A., Tsai, W.y.: Classial Eletodynamis. Peseus Books, USA van Vlaendeen, K.J., Wase, A.: Genealisation of lassial eletodynamis to admit a sala field and longitudinal waves. Hadoni J. 4, White, H., Mah, P., Lawene, J., Vea, J., Sylveste, A., Bady, D., Bailey, P.: Measuement of impulsive thust fom a losed adio-fequeny avity in vauum. Ameian Institute of Aeonautis and Astonautis, Jounal of Populsion and Powe 334, URL 7. Zangwill, A.: Moden Eletodynamis. Cambidge Univesity Pess, USA 3