Martian Meteorites Discussion Summary Tabulated by Adeene Denton
|
|
- June Bryant
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 1 Martian Meteorites Discussion Summary Tabulated by Adeene Denton Greenwood et al., 2008 The Summary We began by reviewing the main findings of the Greenwood paper specifically, they identified the true deuterium/hydrogen ratio in martian meteorites. The three meteorites used were the Los Angeles, Alan Hills 84001, and Shergotty meteorites. The goal of this paper was to avoid measuring hydrogen that was added to the sample from terrestrial contamination in order to measure the bulk water content of Mars. From their resulting D/H ratios, they found two stages in the evolution of water in martian history, with a split in fractionation at 3.9 billion years ago. Before the 3.9 billion-year mark, Mars had significant early water loss followed by modest loss after the switch. The D/H ratios imply, however, that most of the water was lost by 3.9 billion years ago. The Hypotheses We moved on to possible hypotheses for explaining the change water loss, which must have had something to do with processes active in the earliest stages of Mars s history the loss of the magnetic dynamo (ALH is still magnetized, so we know it existed very early on), or possible early cessation of the late heavy bombardment. The biggest question we have is: are the ages of these meteorites correct? Different ages change how we reconstruct martian geologic history. The date of ALH84001 is specifically the problem, since that is our only really early meteorite, giving us our benchmark dates for the transition. However, even if the age of ALH is incorrect we still observe the measured split in fractionation between massive early loss and slower later loss. The Discussion The discussion turned to possible problems with their methods and how different researchers approach getting the most accurate data. The D/H ratios listed in the paper are measured in apatite grains; however, apatite can get re-set during a shock event, and the meteorite likely experienced several. Researchers looking for a D/H ratio at the time of formation of the rock have to avoid fractures and cracks, because fluids can infiltrate those cracks and instigate diffusion-based changes in crystal structure. The D/H ratio that Greenwood et al. measure is supposed to reflect magmatic water (as this is closest to the water budget of the martian mantle and thus most of Mars at the time), which depends on the pressure of the magma and other local properties. What they ve actually measured is a partition coefficient, a ratio of concentrations rather than a true value. Getting from D/H ratios to the actual characteristics of the magmatic water is difficult, as Ralph Miliken points out, since the partition coefficient depends on so many different system properties. We can only estimate a relative amount of water lost (some percent of the original), but since we don t have the original inventory we can t get at a volume. We can try to back-calculate from current values, which many research times have done. This is why we have Maven today so we can get better estimates of atmospheric lost rates in the present and thus make better estimates extrapolating backwards.
2 2 We finished by summarizing the hypotheses that result from this paper s findings how do we envision their demonstrated water loss actually happening? We know that such water loss is intimately tied to the loss of the atmosphere. We suggested that large impacts could be removing lighter gases, while turning off the martian dynamo could decrease Mars s ability to hold on to its atmosphere and water loss from degassing of the early magma ocean phase (very early on) could generate large changes in D/H ratios. There are different timescales for all of these possible hypotheses, which present different implications for early martian geologic history. Lapen et al., 2010 The Summary This subject of this paper directly follows from the previous one s issues with the ages of these meteorites, particularly our discussion of ALH Lapen et al. find a younger age for ALH84001 (from 4.5 Ga to Ga) and postulate that it might be linked to the sources of the shergottites, which are part of the younger groups of martian meteorites. The Hypothesis The authors tie their younger date for ALH84001 to a new interpretation of the evolution of Mars s magma ocean. ALH84001 has a source that is more enriched with incompatible elements compared to the shergottites, but they can still be broadly tied together to one ancient source. The authors conceptual model for a genetic tie between the two systems requires that the magma ocean s broad crystallization forms cumulates, but also traps smaller sections of liquids that crystallize later. Shergottite-type rocks are formed from the cumulates while ALH84001 forms from the residual trapped liquid that is left behind. The authors imply that the magma reservoirs producing volcanism on Mars (e.g., Tharsis and such) have been active for a long time because of this new age for ALH The Discussion We began by asking: how does this model actually work? Geochemical work suggests that we can use the same reservoir (here, the early magma ocean) to make both ALH84001 and the shergottites, but they don t align perfectly on a mixing line. Therefore, the differences between them cannot just be a crustal assimilant added to a magma reservoir. Figure 1: The new Lu-Hf isochron for ALH We found ourselves confused about the timeline outlined by the authors and the ease with which the paper tied ALH84001 to the shergottites. Ralph Miliken explained the multistep logic involved: in this conceptual model, the cumulates involved in magma ocean crystallization are in equilibrium with the residual trapped liquid. If those cumulates are later melted to produce the source magmas for shergottites, they represent a depleted endmember in terms of compositions. Previous investigations into the formation of the suite of shergottites have modeled a mixing process that generally requires a
3 3 depleted endmember as part of said process. The hypothetical magma ocean cumulate presented here is consistent with that preexisting shergottite model, and thus is palatable to the community. We were also confused by the author s decision to compare the values here to KREEP basalts, as it essentially shows that different planetary bodies can have very different paths towards differentiation. We concluded that the authors are demonstrating how a similar process (magma ocean crystallization) can have completely different results because of different planetary starting compositions. We can compare them to show how different degrees of crystallization manifest itself. Figure 2b: The aforementioned comparison between shergottites (red circles) and lunar KREEP basalts (blue squares). After the general discussion of the paper s concepts, we then walked through some guided discussion questions. First, the paper asserts that the primitive crust of Mars was completely obliterated, but why does that follow from getting a younger age of ALH84001? The paper assumes that this younger age means that the late heavy bombardment was much more efficient than the older age had previously suggested, because this is still the oldest sample we have. There are several issues with this, namely the problem of how and why we have the martian meteorites that we have. As we noted in our discussion, the residence times of meteorites in the solar system is not very long, so these martian meteorites were ejected fairly recently relative to their formation history on the planet. This includes ALH84001 it was not ejected during/immediately after its formation 4 Ga. Based on this, we decide that the new age of ALH does not rule out the destruction (or not) of an early crust, as there may be locations on mars that retain early crust that we simply don t have samples for. We then asked what processes could actually destroy the crust, or how likely Mars is to retain old crust. Sean Wiggins, our cratering expert, suggests that if the Borealis Basin (the hemispheric dichotomy-forming impact) was a real event then it could completely destroy and/or alter whatever surface existed at that point. An impact event that large would have lots of overturn, thick ejecta, etc. capable of making the new surface of Mars unrecognizable. The smaller major impact craters on Mars Hellas and Argyre wouldn t destroy the whole crust, but definitely a part of it. In the end, we note that one data point (ALH84001) is not a great way to make an assumption about the entirety of the martian crust. Second, what does the younger age of ALH84001 imply for the magnetic field strength of Mars before 400-Myr cooling? What we know about magnetization on Mars comes from measurements of ALH84001, which has a weakened magnetic field, as well as a magnetic field map for Mars derived from measurements by a magnetometer from the Mars Global Surveyor (which has fairly low spatial resolution). As such we know that there is remnant magnetization of the crust found only in
4 4 Noachian (ancient) terrain so we believe that a dynamo existed and was shut down by whatever happened at the Noachian-Hesperian transition that also eliminated most surface water on the planet. And as we discussed when thinking about the last paper, once Mars loses its magnetic field, it can t protect its atmosphere from stripping by solar radiation, so there is likely a connection. We conclude that a younger age for ALH84001 indicates a lengthier survival for the magnetic field that matches the magnetic field map produced by Mars Global Surveyor, but do not speculate further. Third, we discussed alteration processes on Mars in more depth, motivated by presenter Sierra Kaufman s expertise in mineralogy. In this case, the alteration process active on Mars that was measured in this paper preferentially depletes the samples in the Neodymium relative to Samarium. What is this process? Nd is slightly more incompatible than Sm because of a small difference in radii, but both are highly insoluble (resistant to weathering). Nd and Sm are concentrated in the apatite and whitlockite, which are phosphates that are then affected by weathering. Was it weathering on Mars or weathering on Earth? We do not have an answer for this question. We concluded that constraining Martian history is a difficult task, and without more data points we will continue to struggle. Moser et al., (2013) The Summary This paper tackled the problem of distinguishing between the age of crystallization and the age of the impact event for martian meteorites. Specifically, Pb-Pb values give a really old age, but mineral isochrons represent a much younger (Amazonian) age. How do we differentiate between these two different results? The Hypothesis Through their analysis, this paper develops a timeline for the formation of martian meteorites, stating that the source region for the magma was a depleted upper mantle during an ancient fractionation event (4 Gr), then crystallization ~180 my and launching towards earth 22 My. The Discussion We first discussed the author s choice of baddeleyite for dating purposes. Baddeleyite is ZrO2, a zircon oxide. We want to use zircon because zircon survives forever in a sample it has a higher condensation temperature so it resists change. The baddeleyite is in very small amounts, but making the extra effort to find it should lead to more exact results. The meteorite used was NWA5298, found in Morocco in We focused on the second figure, which shows the uncorrected Pb-Pb diagram it does not fall on the 4.1 Gyr reference line proposed by other research groups, so they are inconsistent. We initially found this figure confusing because the Pb-Pb is uncorrected so the ages don t have much meaning. Why is this plot shown? We realized with the help of Ralph Milikin that the plot is shown because it is directly tied to the true point of the paper, which is here to call out another paper Bouvier et al. that contends that all of the martian meteorites are 4 Gyr old. Figure 2 exists to point out that the minerals used by Bouvier have been mucked up but later geologic processes on Mars (FUBAR, according to Ralph), and so are likely not representative of crystallization ages since their structures
5 5 are more mobile and disposed to change. This is why the paper uses zircone instead, since it is much more difficult to mess up a zircon. The uncorrected data is shown a) because correcting the data requires certain assumptions that we want to avoid, and b) because even without correction we can tell that the baddeleyite data falls along the 0.2-Gyr line. The point is that all of the other minerals that have been previously used to date these meteorites cluster together and are generally not good data to use. We wondered why we haven t used zircons on ALH84001 if they re so amazing because we haven t found it yet. These features are so small and difficult to find that progress is slow and often by accident. We moved on to discussing the corrected data (which was corrected using urianium). With this plot we can track the original growth of the zircon as well as subsequent recrystallization and shock resetting via the points on the corrected data graph. The authors present a gradiation of values for shock resetting because the grains could have transmitted shock differently during the same shock event, but have fairly exact ages for the martian igneous event (the oldest date) and the meteorite s launch from Mars to Earth (the youngest date). Figure 2: The uncorrected Pb-Pb plots and the corrected U-Pb plots showing the usefulness of baddeleyite and the new timeline. Consider what does the 4.0 Gyr age that the French people are getting actually represent? There was some confusion about how a measured age could erroneously skew older rather than younger, since most alteration would skew it younger. They explain this discrepancy by saying that the crystallization age is much younger, but we can get an older age because of a mixture between terrestrial contamination and primitive martian lead in Pb-Pb dating. Crystallization ages may inherit an isotopic signature of a primitive mantle process, which is characteristic of the source region (where the magma came from) as opposed to the crystallization age. We try to correct for terrestrial contamination in our measurements, but are not always successful. We noted that this isn t just a martian problem we have similar issues with dating terrestrial igneous rocks.
6 6 Figure 3: A pictorial representation of the evolution of the Martian crust as seen by this shergottite. Lastly, we asked: why are all the Shergottites youngish? They re not identical ages, but they all cluster around a young age. We have a bias towards young basalts, but could it also be differences in survivability of material in space? If we consider Noachian crust vs. Hesperian/ Amazonian rocks, the Noachian rocks have been mucked up and are more friable ( brecciated megaregolith ), so if such rocks were ejected maybe they would fail to survive the journey to earth without breaking up. We also consider that maybe these were ejected from the same stack of lava flows, hence the clustering but we can t prove it. People are trying to find the impact crater that generated the SNCs, but it is incredibly difficult without know what size of crater is require to narrow down the search. People have tried using spectra, but that is a needle in a haystack approach. The French (i.e., Bouvier) have published a paper detailing the crater Mojave, a young crater southwest of Arabia Terra, as a source for the shergottites but base that on spectra, which we established as a sketchy justification in this case. They use the old age of the terrain to say that the shergottites are old, which is very obviously circular logic. The French also believe that all of the zircons have been melted during shock metamorphism, but the Moser paper accounted for that by using the zircons that have experienced the least amount of shock. We conclude that dating rocks, particularly those from another planet, is tricky business and should be handled with care. We suggest sample return missions from the martian surface to clear up some of these disputes once and for all. References Greenwood, J.P. et al., (2008). Hydrogen isotope evidence for loss of water from Mars through time. GRL 35, 5. Lapen, T.J. (2010). A younger age for ALH84001 and its geochemical link to Shergottite sources in Mars. Science 328, Moser, D.E. et al. (2013). Solving the Martian meteorite age conundrum using micro-baddeleyite and launchgenerated zircon. Nature 499, Nyquist, L.E., et al. (2001). Ages and geologic histories of Martian meteorites. Space Sciences Series of ISSI chronology and Evolution of Mars,
Insights into the Evolution of the Solar System from Isotopic Investigations of Samples. Lars Borg
Insights into the Evolution of the Solar System from Isotopic Investigations of Samples Lars Borg Harold Masursky Harold Masursky was a stalwart of the U.S. planetary exploration program for nearly three
More informationMartian Meteorites 1
Martian Meteorites 1 The SNCs How do we know the SNCs are from Mars? [Taylor & McLennan, 2009] 2 The SNCs Abundances and isotopic compositions of gases trapped in impact melt glasses match those measured
More informationThe Moon: Internal Structure & Magma Ocean
The Moon: Internal Structure & Magma Ocean 1 Lunar Magma Ocean & Lunar Interior 2 Two possible views of the Moon s interior: The Moon: Internal Structure 3 Like Earth, the Moon is a differentiated body.
More informationQuestion. Which volcano on the Tharsis region of Mars is the youngest?
Question Which volcano on the Tharsis region of Mars is the youngest? Importance We believe that this question is important and interesting because we don t have any evidence of recent tectonic activity
More informationRecords of Martian Paleotemperatures and Paleofields in Meteorites. Benjamin Weiss
Records of Martian Paleotemperatures and Paleofields in Meteorites Benjamin Weiss Viking Orbiter (1976) 250 km across 24 S, 182 W Crustal Magnetic Fields 4 Billion Years Ago Today From J. Kargel s webpage
More informationFundamental Importance of Returned Samples to Understanding the Martian Interior
Fundamental Importance of Returned Samples to Understanding the Martian Interior David S. Draper and Carl B. Agee Institute of Meteoritics Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences University of New Mexico
More informationWed. Oct. 04, Makeup lecture time? Will Friday noon work for everyone? No class Oct. 16, 18, 20?
Wed. Oct. 04, 2017 Reading: For Friday: Bugiolacchi et al. 2008 Laurence et al. 1998" Makeup lecture time? Will Friday noon work for everyone? No class Oct. 16, 18, 20? Today: Finish Lunar overview (from
More informationComposition and the Early History of the Earth
Composition and the Early History of the Earth Sujoy Mukhopadhyay CIDER 2006 What we will cover in this lecture Composition of Earth Short lived nuclides and differentiation of the Earth Atmosphere and
More informationPhys 214. Planets and Life
Phys 214. Planets and Life Dr. Cristina Buzea Department of Physics Room 259 E-mail: cristi@physics.queensu.ca (Please use PHYS214 in e-mail subject) Lecture 10. Geology and life. Part 1 (Page 99-123)
More informationIsotope Geochem Notes (U,Th-Pb; Sm-Nd; Re-Os; Lu-Hf)
Isotope Geochem Notes (U,Th-Pb; Sm-Nd; Re-Os; Lu-Hf) Reading for this topic: White, Nos. 7,8,9,11. Guide questions: What are the special features of the U,Th - Pb system that make it uniquely useful for
More informationLecture 38. Igneous geochemistry. Read White Chapter 7 if you haven t already
Lecture 38 Igneous geochemistry Read White Chapter 7 if you haven t already Today. Magma mixing/afc 2. Spot light on using the Rare Earth Elements (REE) to constrain mantle sources and conditions of petrogenesis
More informationGeophysics & Meteorology on the surface of Mars. P.Lognonné, T.Spohn, F.Forget IPGP, DLR, IPSL
Geophysics & Meteorology on the surface of Mars P.Lognonné, T.Spohn, F.Forget IPGP, DLR, IPSL Geophysics on the Martian surface Why a geophysical exploration of Mars? Many strong geophysical differences
More informationAn Adulterated Martian Meteorite Written by G. Jeffrey Taylor Hawai'i Institute of Geophysics and Planetology
1 of 5 posted July 20, 1999 An Adulterated Martian Meteorite Written by G. Jeffrey Taylor Hawai'i Institute of Geophysics and Planetology Martian meteorite Elephant Moraine (EET) A79001 is composed of
More informationThe Moon. Part II: Solar System. The Moon. A. Orbital Motion. The Moon s Orbit. Earth-Moon is a Binary Planet
Part II: Solar System The Moon Audio update: 2014Feb23 The Moon A. Orbital Stuff B. The Surface C. Composition and Interior D. Formation E. Notes 2 A. Orbital Motion 3 Earth-Moon is a Binary Planet 4 1.
More informationWelcome to Class 13: Is (or was) Life on Mars? Remember: sit only in the first 10 rows of the room
Welcome to Class 13: Is (or was) Life on Mars? Remember: sit only in the first 10 rows of the room What are we going to discuss today? Why didn t Mars maintain a warm, wet climate? If life could exist
More informationFormation of the Earth and Solar System
Formation of the Earth and Solar System a. Supernova and formation of primordial dust cloud. NEBULAR HYPOTHESIS b. Condensation of primordial dust. Forms disk-shaped nubular cloud rotating counterclockwise.
More informationThe Moon & Mercury: Dead Worlds
The Moon & Mercury: Dead Worlds There are many similarities between the Moon and Mercury, and some major differences we ll concentrate mostly on the Moon. Appearance of the Moon from the Earth We ve already
More informationPTYS 214 Spring Announcements. Graded exams available. Writing assignment early deadline 4/17
s PTYS 214 Spring 2018 Announcements Graded exams available Writing assignment early deadline 4/17 1 Midterm #4 Total Students: 19 Class Average: 79 Low: 48 High: 100 If you have questions see one of us!
More informationOrigin of terrestrial life: in situ hypothesis. The terrestrial and astronomical context for the emergence of life
Origin of terrestrial life: in situ hypothesis The terrestrial and astronomical context for the emergence of life Planets and Astrobiology (2016-2017) G. Vladilo To contrain the chronology and physical/chemical
More informationDifferentiation of planetary interiors. Rocky Planets Interiors and surface geophysics
Differentiation of planetary interiors Rocky Planets Interiors and surface geophysics Process of separation of internal planetary layers that takes place as a result of the physical and chemical properties
More informationcrater density: number of craters per unit area on a surface
Reading for this week: Chap. 9, Sect. 9.4-9.5, Chap. 10, Sect. 10.1-10.5 Homework 6: due in recitation Friday/Monday (Oct. 13, 16) Midterm grade estimates posted on Blackboard this week Astro 120 Fall
More informationAstro 1010 Planetary Astronomy Sample Questions for Exam 4
Astro 1010 Planetary Astronomy Sample Questions for Exam 4 Chapter 8 1. Which of the following processes is not important in shaping the surface of terrestrial planets? a) Impact cratering b) Tectonism
More informationPlate Tectonics. Development of a Theory
CHAPTER 7 LESSON 2 Plate Tectonics Development of a Theory Key Concepts What is seafloor spreading? What evidence is used to support seafloor spreading? What do you think? Read the two statements below
More informationLab 5: An Investigation of Meteorites Geology 202: Earth s Interior
Lab 5: An Investigation of Meteorites Geology 202: Earth s Interior Asteroids and Meteorites: What is the difference between asteroids and meteorites? Asteroids are rocky and metallic objects that orbit
More informationHalogen and argon evidence of Martian hydrous fluids in nakhlite meteorites Ray Burgess
Halogen and argon evidence of Martian hydrous fluids in nakhlite meteorites Ray Burgess School of Earth, Atmospheric and Environmental Sciences University of Manchester, UK Topics Halogens and noble gases
More informationOur Barren Moon. Chapter Ten. Guiding Questions
Our Barren Moon Chapter Ten Guiding Questions 1. Is the Moon completely covered with craters? 2. Has there been any exploration of the Moon since the Apollo program in the 1970s? 3. Does the Moon s interior
More informationMULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question.
ASTRO 102/104 Prelim 2 Name Section MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1) This is version E of the exam. Please fill in (E). A) This
More informationMapping the Surface of Mars Prelab. 1. Explain in your own words what you think a "geologic history" for a planet or moon is?
Prelab 1. Explain in your own words what you think a "geologic history" for a planet or moon is? 2. Describe some of the major features seen on the Martian surface by various spacecraft missions over the
More informationTime to Solidify an Ocean of Magma
1 of 6 March 25, 2009 Time to Solidify an Ocean of Magma --- A small mineral grain places limits on how long it took the lunar magma ocean to solidify. Written by G. Jeffrey Taylor Hawai i Institute of
More informationEARTH S ENERGY SOURCES
EARTH S ENERGY SOURCES The geological processes that shape the Earth s surface are powered by two major sources of energy; geothermal heat from the Earth s interior and external energy from the sun. The
More informationGeochemistry of Mars from SNCs meteorites
Geochemistry of Mars from SNCs meteorites Marc Chaussidon Centre de Recherches Pétrographiques et Géochimiques CRPG-CNRS, UPR 2300, Nancy (France) Their composition : from mineralogy to major elements,
More informationMULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question.
ASTRO 102/104 Prelim 2 Name Section MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1) This is version B of the exam. Please fill in (B). A) This
More information9/15/16. Guiding Questions. Our Barren Moon. The Moon s Orbit
Our Barren Moon Guiding Questions 1. Is the Moon completely covered with craters? 2. Has there been any exploration of the Moon since the Apollo program in the 1970s? 3. Does the Moon s interior have a
More informationpage - Lab 13 - Introduction to the Geology of the Terrestrial Planets
page - Lab 13 - Introduction to the Geology of the Terrestrial Planets Introduction There are two main families of planets in our solar system: the inner Terrestrial planets (Earth, Mercury, Venus, and
More informationExamining the Terrestrial Planets (Chapter 20)
GEOLOGY 306 Laboratory Instructor: TERRY J. BOROUGHS NAME: Examining the Terrestrial Planets (Chapter 20) For this assignment you will require: a calculator, colored pencils, a metric ruler, and your geology
More informationMeteorites free samples from the solar system
Meteorites free samples from the solar system It is easier to believe that Yankee professors would lie, than that stones would fall from heaven [Thomas Jefferson, 3rd president of the USA] 2.1 Collection
More informationImpact Age Dating. ASTRO 202 Lecture Thursday, February 14, Review. What is relative age dating? What is relative age dating?
Review Impact Age Dating ASTRO 202 Lecture Thursday, February 14, 2008 Carbon-14, Potassium-Argon isotopic age determination: (1) Parent decays to daughter at some predictable rate (2) How much now? (3)
More informationRadiogenic Isotopes. W. F. McDonough 1 1 Department of Earth Sciences and Research Center for
Radiogenic Isotopes W. F. McDonough 1 1 Department of Earth Sciences and Research Center for Neutrino Science, Tohoku University, Sendai 980-8578, Japan (Dated: May 17, 2018) I. SUMMRY Isotope systems
More informationWritten by G. Jeffrey Taylor Hawai i Institute of Geophysics and Planetology
http://www.psrd.hawaii.edu/may10/youngeralh84001.html 1 May 12, 2010 --- New isotopic analyses show that famous Martian meteorite ALH 84001 formed 4.09 billion years ago, not 4.50 billion years ago as
More informationRelative Dating. How do we determine a rocks age by the surrounding rocks?
Relative Dating How do we determine a rocks age by the surrounding rocks? 1 Geologic History 2 Relative Dating Uniformitarianism - the idea that forces working on our planet today worked on our planet
More informationStudent Guide to Moon 101
Student Guide to Moon 101 LINKS TO WEBSITES AND DOCUMENTS NECESSARY TO COMPLETE MOON 101 CAN BE FOUND AT: 1) Read the following articles: PART 1 - FORMATION OF THE MOON a) The Scientific Legacy of Apollo,
More informationDifferentiation 2: mantle, crust OUTLINE
Differentiation 2: mantle, crust OUTLINE Reading this week: Should have been White Ch 10 and 11!! 7- Nov Differentiation of the Earth, Core formation W 10.6.6, 11.4 9- Nov Moon, crust, mantle, atmosphere
More information10. Our Barren Moon. Moon Data (Table 10-1) Moon Data: Numbers. Moon Data: Special Features 1. The Moon As Seen From Earth
10. Our Barren Moon Lunar plains & craters Manned lunar exploration The lunar interior The Moon s geologic history The formation of the Moon Moon Data (Table 10-1) Moon Data: Numbers Diameter: 3,476.km
More informationTOPIC 1: RELATIVE DATING ESSENTIAL QUESTION: HOW DO WE DETERMINE A ROCK S AGE BY THE SURROUNDING ROCKS?
TOPIC 1: RELATIVE DATING ESSENTIAL QUESTION: HOW DO WE DETERMINE A ROCK S AGE BY THE SURROUNDING ROCKS? TOPIC 1: RELATIVE DATING UNIFORMITARIANISM: THE IDEA THAT THE SAME FORCES HAVE BEEN AND CONTINUE
More informationBackground Image: SPA Basin Interior; LRO WAC, NASA/GSFC/ASU
B. L. Jolliff1, C. K. Shearer2, N. E. Petro3, D. A. Papanastassiou,4 Y. Liu,4 and L. Alkalai4 1Dept. of Earth & Planetary Sciences, Washington University, St. Louis, MO 2Institute of Meteoritics, University
More informationVenus Earth s Sister Planet
Venus Earth s Sister Planet 9 9.1 Orbital Properties 3rd brightest object in the sky, after Sun and Moon. Can even be seen in broad daylight Often called the morning star or the evening star, as it is
More informationThe Sun and Planets Lecture Notes 6.
The Sun and Planets Lecture Notes 6. Lecture 6 Venus 1 Spring Semester 2017 Prof Dr Ravit Helled Cover photo: Venus in true color (Courtesy of NASA) Venus Properties Venus is the second brightest natural
More informationESS 312 Geochemistry Simulating Earth degassing using radionuclides
ESS 312 Geochemistry Simulating Earth degassing using radionuclides CHEMICAL AND ISOTOPIC EVOLUTION OF A TWO-RESERVOIR SYSTEM In lectures we discussed radioactive decay and build-up of a daughter isotope
More informationMoon 101 Presentation. Mike Delmonaco Trevor Rosenlicht Nicole La Reddola
Moon 101 Presentation Mike Delmonaco Trevor Rosenlicht Nicole La Reddola Feature 1: Dome Feature 2: Cone Feature 3: Main dome crater Image 1 Color key: Dome/Cone: Dome Crater Cone Dome Craters: Endogenic
More information2) Elucidate a weakness of two of the lines of evidence you listed in the previous question.
GEO 110 Final Test May 30 2003 Name: IMPORTANT: Please write legibly!!! Short Answer (2 points each) 1) List three of the four lines of evidence that the Johnson Space Center team presented as evidence
More informationIsotopic measurements for the Mars Ice Cap -Matt Siegler PSI/SMU KISS workshop
Isotopic measurements for the Mars Ice Cap -Matt Siegler PSI/SMU KISS workshop 1) Temperature dependent fractionation of stable isotopes ( 18 O/ 16 O, D/H ) 2) Cosmogenic Nuclides ( 10 Be, 1.4 Myr halflife)
More informationRotated Magnets. posted May 22, 1997
1 of 6 posted May 22, 1997 Low-temperature Origin of Carbonates Consistent with Life in ALH84001 Written by G. Jeffrey Taylor Hawai'i Institute of Geophysics and Planetology, SOEST, University of Hawai'i
More informationGeol. 656 Isotope Geochemistry
RADIOGENIC ISOTOPE GEOCHEMISTRY: THE MANTLE II ISOTOPE GEOCHEMISTRY OF THE MANTLE: THE PB PICTURE Pb is by far the most powerful of the isotopic tools available to us because three parents decay to three
More informationEARTH TAKES SHAPE 1. Define all vocabulary words. Crust: The thin and solid outermost layer of the Earth above the mantle. Mantle: The layer of rock
EARTH TAKES SHAPE 1. Define all vocabulary words. Crust: The thin and solid outermost layer of the Earth above the mantle. Mantle: The layer of rock between the Earth s crust and core Core: The central
More informationWhat is the Moon? A natural satellite One of more than 96 moons in our Solar System The only moon of the planet Earth
The Moon What is the Moon? A natural satellite One of more than 96 moons in our Solar System The only moon of the planet Earth Location, location, location! About 384,000 km (240,000 miles) from Earth
More informationMeteorite Shock Ages, Early Bombardment, and the Age of the Moon
Meteorite Shock Ages, Early Bombardment, and the Age of the Moon William Bottke 1, David Vokrouhlicky 1, Simone Marchi 1, Tim Swindle (U. Arizona), Ed Scott (U. Hawaii), A. Jackson (ASU) John Weirich (U.
More informationUNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND ASTRONOMY DEPARTMENT. Mars Cratering. Crater count isochrons of Arsia and Pavonis Mons
UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND ASTRONOMY DEPARTMENT Mars Cratering Crater count isochrons of Arsia and Pavonis Mons Paul Hearding and Ben McIlwain 5/21/2007 Imagery of Arsia and Pavonis Mons taken by Mars Global
More informationGCSE ready intervention tasks
7. Earth 1 LEARNING CONTEXT AQA Big idea: 3.7 Earth AQA Strand: 3.7.1 Earth structure 3.7.2 Universe AQA Enquiry processes: 2.3 Draw conclusions 2.7 Critique claims How this provides GCSE readiness: The
More informationEvolution of the Slave Province and Abitibi Subprovince Based on U-Pb Dating and Hf Isotopic Composition of Zircon
Evolution of the Slave Province and Abitibi Subprovince Based on U-Pb Dating and Hf Isotopic Composition of Zircon John W.F. Ketchum 1, Wouter Bleeker 2, William L. Griffin 1, Suzanne Y. O Reilly 1, Norman
More informationIssues of the Age of the Earth Parts 1 & 2
Issues of the Age of the Earth Parts 1 & 2 Why is Age such an issue? Incomprehensible ages make evolution seem possible. In billions of years anything can happen Impossible to test possible to construct
More informationNotepack 18 AiM: How can we tell the age of rock layers? Do now: Which Jenga piece was placed first to build this tower? Support your answer with
Notepack 18 AiM: How can we tell the age of rock layers? Do now: Which Jenga piece was placed first to build this tower? Support your answer with complete sentences. How old is the Earth? The Earth is
More informationEvidences for geochemically distinct mantle components
Evidences for geochemically distinct mantle components 1 Mantle Array Oceanic basalts, including seamounts, oceanic islands and middle ocean ridge basalts, were used. 2 Binary All analyses fall between
More informationAstronomy 1 Fall 2016
Astronomy 1 Fall 2016 Announcements: 1. Midterm exam on Thursday (in this room) 2. Oct 21 st - 26 th : Sections replaced by evening observing) Lecture 8: October 18, 2016 Previously on Astro 1 Solar System
More informationDating. AST111 Lecture 8a. Isotopic composition Radioactive dating
Dating Martian Lafayette Asteroid with patterns caused by the passaged through the atmosphere. Line on the fusion crust were caused by beads of molten rock. AST111 Lecture 8a Isotopic composition Radioactive
More informationMars Internal Structure, Activity, and Composition. Tilman Spohn DLR Institute of Planetary Research, Berlin
Mars Internal Structure, Activity, and Composition Tilman Spohn DLR Institute of Planetary Research, Berlin Interior Structure Interior Structure models aim at 2 the bulk chemistry of the planet the masses
More informationSUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
doi:10.1038/nature10326 Supplementary Discussion All known modern terrestrial mantle reservoirs evolved from a primitive precursor with superchondritic 143 Nd/ 144 Nd. What is this reservoir? The terms
More informationPlate Tectonics. Development of a Theory. Mapping the Ocean Floor
Plate Tectonics Development of a Theory Mapping the Ocean Floor Scientists began exploring the seafloor in greater detail during the late 1940s. They used a device called an echo sounder to measure the
More informationThe Rise of Oxygen in the Earth s Atmosphere
The Rise of Oxygen in the Earth s Atmosphere The Rise of Oxygen in the Earth s Atmosphere This article is provided courtesy of the American Museum of Natural History. On a chilly October afternoon, Grant
More informationVolatiles (H, C, N, F, S, Cl) in the lunar mantle, crust, and regolith: What questions remain and where to go next?
Volatiles (H, C, N, F, S, Cl) in the lunar mantle, crust, and regolith: What questions remain and where to go next? Francis M. McCubbin & Charles K. Shearer Motivation behind this work 100, In Revision,
More informationVolatiles in the terrestrial planets. Sujoy Mukhopadhyay University of California, Davis CIDER, 2014
Volatiles in the terrestrial planets Sujoy Mukhopadhyay University of California, Davis CIDER, 2014 Atmophiles: Elements I will talk about rock-loving iron-loving sulfur-loving Temperatures in Protoplanetary
More informationComet Science Goals II
Comet Science Goals II {questions for goals} Don Brownlee Did the events postulated by the Nice Hypothesis really happen? Were there wide-spread solar system wide impact events that were coeval with the
More informationImportance of Sample Return to Understanding Mars. Meenakshi Wadhwa, ASU Curation and Analysis Planning Team for Extraterrestrial Materials (CAPTEM)
Importance of Sample Return to Understanding Mars Meenakshi Wadhwa, ASU Curation and Analysis Planning Team for Extraterrestrial Materials (CAPTEM) Outline General Principles for Planetary Missions Importance
More informationItalian Lunar Science Studies and Possible Missions a.k.a. The Moon: an Italian Approach. Angioletta Coradini Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica
Italian Lunar Science Studies and Possible Missions a.k.a. The Moon: an Italian Approach Angioletta Coradini Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica Goals of the Study The primary goal of the present study is
More informationThe Moon. Tidal Coupling Surface Features Impact Cratering Moon Rocks History and Origin of the Moon
The Moon Tidal Coupling Surface Features Impact Cratering Moon Rocks History and Origin of the Moon Earth Moon Semi-major Axis 1 A.U. 384 x 10 3 km Inclination 0 Orbital period 1.000 tropical year 27.32
More informationProblem Set 3: Crater Counting
Problem Set 3: Crater Counting Introduction Impact craters are the dominant landforms on most of the solid surfaces in our solar system. These impact craters have formed on the surfaces over the 4.6 billion
More informationMoon 101. Bellaire High School Team: Rachel Fisher, Clint Wu, Omkar Joshi
Moon 101 Bellaire High School Team: Rachel Fisher, Clint Wu, Omkar Joshi Part I Formation of the Moon Planetary Formation In the solar nebula, dust particles coalesced to form smaller planetesimals and
More informationMars: The Red Planet. Roman God of war Blood Reflects 30% of its incident sunlight 2 small moons : Phobos and Deimos
Mars: The Red Planet Roman God of war Blood Reflects 30% of its incident sunlight 2 small moons : Phobos and Deimos Property Earth Mars Radius 6378km 3394km ~ 0.51R E Mass 5.97x10 24 kg 6.42x10 23 kg =
More informationLUNAR OBSERVING. What will you learn in this lab?
LUNAR OBSERVING What will you learn in this lab? The Moon is the second most noticeable object in the sky. This lab will first introduce you to observing the Moon with a telescope. You will be looking
More informationShocked Carbonates May Spell in Martian Meteorite ALH84001
1 of 5 posted May 22, 1997 Shocked Carbonates May Spell in Martian Meteorite ALH84001 Written by Edward R.D. Scott Hawai'i Institute of Geophysics and Planetology, SOEST, University of Hawai'i In an electrifying
More informationN = N 0 e -λt D* = N 0 -N D* = N 0 (1-e -λt ) or N(e λt -1) where N is number of parent atoms at time t, N 0
N = N 0 e -λt D* = N 0 -N D* = N 0 (1-e -λt ) or N(e λt -1) where N is number of parent atoms at time t, N 0 is initial number of parents, D* is number of radiogenic daughter atoms, and λ is the decay
More informationHighs and Lows Floods and Flows
Highs and Lows Floods and Flows Planetary Mapping Facilitator Guide Becky Nelson Education Specialist The Lunar and Planetary Institute Highs and Lows, Floods and Flows Planetary Mapping Overview In this
More informationRadiogenic Isotopes as Tracers of Sources and Mixing in the Solid Earth, Hydrosphere, Biosphere
Radiogenic Isotopes as Tracers of Sources and Mixing in the Solid Earth, Hydrosphere, Biosphere Reading: White, Lecture 22, part on the mathematics of binary mixing. Also: Faure, 1986, Chs. 9, 11 OR...
More information(4) Meteorites: Remnants of Creation
(4) Meteorites: Remnants of Creation Meteoroid: small piece of debris in space Meteor: space debris heated by friction as it plunges into the Earth s atmosphere Meteorite: Space debris that has reached
More informationUnraveling Earth s Early History High School Sample Classroom Assessment
Unraveling Earth s Early History High School Sample Classroom Assessment Introduction Direct terrestrial evidence about the formation of Earth and its early history is rare on Earth itself, driving scientists
More informationThe Sun and Planets Lecture Notes 5. The Moon
The Sun and Planets Lecture Notes 5. Spring Semester 2019 Prof Dr Ravit Helled The Moon Definitions Escape Velocity Escape velocity is the minimum speed needed for an object to escape a massive body. The
More informationMoon and Mercury 3/8/07
The Reading Assignment Chapter 12 Announcements 4 th homework due March 20 (first class after spring break) Reminder about term paper due April 17. Next study-group session is Monday, March 19, from 10:30AM-12:00Noon
More informationChapter 20 Earth: The Standard of Comparative Planetology
Chapter 20 Earth: The Standard of Comparative Planetology Guidepost In the preceding chapter, you learned how our solar system formed as a by-product of the formation of the sun. You also saw how distance
More informationMeteorites from Mars
Meteorites from Mars Easy way to get pieces of Mars to study Asteroid impact on Mars knocks off pieces. Some land on Earth Evidence for Life? Antarctic ice fields are a good place to look for meteorites
More informationJupiter. Jupiter is the third-brightest object in the night sky (after the Moon and Venus). Exploration by Spacecrafts
Jupiter Orbit, Rotation Physical Properties Atmosphere, surface Interior Magnetosphere Moons (Voyager 1) Jupiter is the third-brightest object in the night sky (after the Moon and Venus). Exploration by
More informationIn Situ Noble Gas-based Dating On Terrestrial Planet Surfaces
In Situ Noble Gas-based Dating On Terrestrial Planet Surfaces Tim Swindle Lunar and Planetary Laboratory, University of Arizona Decadal Survey Terrestrial Planets Panel Irvine, California October 26, 2009
More informationMeteorites from Mars, Rocks from Canada Written by Rachel C. Friedman Department of Geology and Geophysics, University of Hawai'i
1 of 7 posted December 21, 1996 Meteorites from Mars, Rocks from Canada Written by Rachel C. Friedman Department of Geology and Geophysics, University of Hawai'i Meteorites from Mars have been in the news
More informationb. atomic mass H What is the density of an object with a volume of 15cm 3 and a mass of 45g?
Name Period Date Earth Science Midterm Review 2015-2016 Quarter 1 Review Assign #1 Basic Chemistry An atom is a basic chemical building block of matter. An atom consists of protons, neutrons, and electrons.
More informationChapter 11. The Archean Era of Precambrian Time
Chapter 11 The Archean Era of Precambrian Time 1 Guiding Questions When and how did Earth and its moon come into being? How did the core, mantle, crust form? Where did Archean rocks form, and what is their
More information(Received April 28, 2016; Accepted September 10, 2016)
Geochemical Journal, Vol. 51, pp. 81 to 94, 2017 doi:10.2343/geochemj.2.0446 New constraints on shergottite petrogenesis from analysis of Pb isotopic compositional space: Implications for mantle heterogeneity
More informationThe Moving Story of Plate Tectonics
08 January 2012 MP3 at voaspecialenglish.com The Moving Story of Plate Tectonics AP Smoke and ash from Italy's Mount Etna volcano last week FAITH LAPIDUS: This is SCIENCE IN THE NEWS in VOA Special English.
More information9. Moon, Mercury, Venus
9. Moon, Mercury, Venus All the heavier elements were manufactured by stars later, either by thermonuclear fusion reactions deep in their interiors or by the violent explosions that mark the end of massive
More informationGeochemical and mineralogical technics to investigate the lithosphere and the asthenosphere. 07/11/2017 GEO-DEEP 9300 Claire Aupart
Geochemical and mineralogical technics to investigate the lithosphere and the asthenosphere 07/11/2017 GEO-DEEP 9300 Claire Aupart Introduction Introduction Getting samples Cores: Maximum depth reach in
More informationASTR 100. Lecture 10: Planetary geology and atmospheres
ASTR 100 Lecture 10: Planetary geology and atmospheres Still in the innermost part of the Solar system To understand the differences between Terrestrial planets, need to look at their structure differentiation
More informationInside Planet Earth: Surface to Center
Inside Planet Earth: Surface to Center Section 1: Introduction 1. What percentage of the Earth cannot be accessed by humans? 99% 2. True or False: It would be easier to invent something to travel to the
More informationWhat can isotopes tell us about mantle dynamics? Sujoy Mukhopadhyay. Harvard University
What can isotopes tell us about mantle dynamics? Sujoy Mukhopadhyay Harvard University The mantle zoo Hofmann, 1997 187 Os/ 188 Os 0.168 0.156 0.144 0.132 EM1 Hawaii Pitcairn DMM peridotites Shield Basalts
More information