How to display data badly

Transcription

1 How to display data badly Karl W Broman Biostatistics & Medical Informatics University of Wisconsin Madison kbroman.org

2 Using Microsoft Excel to obscure your data and annoy your readers Karl W Broman Biostatistics & Medical Informatics University of Wisconsin Madison kbroman.org

3 Inspiration This lecture was inspired by H Wainer (1984) How to display data badly. 38(2): American Statistician Dr. Wainer was the first to elucidate the principles of the bad display of data. The now widespread use of Microsoft Excel has resulted in remarkable advances in the field. 3

4 General principles The aim of good data graphics: Display data accurately and clearly. Some rules for displaying data badly: Display as little information as possible. Obscure what you do show (with chart junk). Use pseudo-3d and color gratuitously. Make a pie chart (preferably in color and 3d). Use a poorly chosen scale. Ignore sig figs. 4

5 Example 1 5

6 Example 1 6

7 Example 1 7

8 Example 1 8

9 Example 1 9

10 Example 1 10

11 Example 1 11

12 Example 1 12

13 Example 2 13

14 Example 2 14

15 Example 2 15

16 Example 2 16

17 Example 2 17

18 Example 3 18

19 Example 3 19

20 Example 3 20

21 Example 3 21

22 Example 4 22

23 Example 4 23

24 Example 4 24

25 Example 5 25

26 Example 5 26

27 Example 5 27

28 Example 5 28

29 Example 5 29

30 Example 5 30

31 Example 6 31

32 Example 6 32

33 Example 7 33

34 Example 7 34

35 Displaying data well Be accurate and clear. Let the data speak. Show as much information as possible, taking care not to obscure the message. Science not sales. Avoid unnecessary frills (esp. gratuitous 3d). In tables, every digit should be meaningful. Don t drop ending 0 s. 35

36 More on data visualization Karl W Broman Biostatistics & Medical Informatics University of Wisconsin Madison kbroman.org

37 Ease comparisons (things to be compared should be adjacent) Phenotype 14 Phenotype Female Male Female Male Female Male AA AB BB AA AB BB AA AB BB Female Male 2

38 Ease comparisons (add a bit of color) Phenotype 14 Phenotype Female Male Female Male Female Male AA AB BB AA AB BB AA AB BB Female Male 3

39 Which comparison is easiest? A B A B A B B 300 B B A A A 0 0 4

40 Don t distort the quantities (value radius) Wheat (17 Gbp) Human (3.2 Gbp) Arabidopsis (0.145 Gbp) 5

41 Don t distort the quantities (value area) Wheat (17 Gbp) Human (3.2 Gbp) Arabidopsis (0.145 Gbp) 6

42 Don t use areas at all (value length) 15 Genome size (Gbp) Arabidopsis Human Wheat 7

43 Encoding data Quantities Position Length Angle Area Luminance (light/dark) Chroma (amount of color) Categories Shape Hue (which color) Texture Width 8

44 Ease comparisons (align things vertically) Women Men Height (in) Height (in) Men Height (in) 9

45 Ease comparisons (use common axes) Women Women Height (in) Height (in) Men Men Height (in) Height (in) 10

46 Use labels not legends Petal width (cm) setosa versicolor virginica Petal width (cm) versicolor virginica setosa Petal length (cm) Petal length (cm) 11

47 Don t sort alphabetically Argentina Australia Austria Belgium Brazil Canada China France Germany India Indonesia Italy Japan Korea, Rep. Mexico Netherlands Norway Poland Russian Federation Spain Sweden Switzerland Turkey United Kingdom United States United States Netherlands France Canada Germany Switzerland Austria Belgium Italy Spain Sweden United Kingdom Japan Norway Australia Brazil Argentina Korea, Rep. Poland Turkey Russian Federation Mexico China India Indonesia Health care spending (% GDP) Health care spending (% GDP) 12

48 Must you include 0? % 98.1% 99.2% 99 Detection rate (%) Detection rate (%) A B C 95 A B C Method Method 13

49 Summary Put the things to be compared next to each other Use color to set things apart, but consider color blind folks Use position rather than angle or area to represent quantities Align things vertically to ease comparisons Use common axis limits to ease comparisons Use labels rather than legends Sort on meaningful variables (not alphabetically) Must 0 be included in the axis limits? Consider taking logs and/or differences 14

50 Further reading ER Tufte (1983) The visual display of quantitative information. Graphics Press. ER Tufte (1990) Envisioning information. Graphics Press. ER Tufte (1997) Visual explanations. Graphics Press. WS Cleveland (1993) Visualizing data. Hobart Press. WS Cleveland (1994) The elements of graphing data. CRC Press. A Gelman, C Pasarica, R Dodhia (2002) Let s practice what we preach: Turning tables into graphs. The American Statistician 56: NB Robbins (2004) Creating more effective graphs. Wiley Nature Methods columns: 15