Smart Cities and Urban Governance. The urbanapi Project: Bologna Case Study David C. Ludlow, Maria Paola Mauri, Chiara Caranti

Similar documents
Smart City Governance for effective urban governance. David Ludlow Assoc. Professor European Smart Cities University of the West of England, Bristol

We recommend you cite the published version. The publisher s URL is:

Tackling urban sprawl: towards a compact model of cities? David Ludlow University of the West of England (UWE) 19 June 2014

Community Engagement in Cultural Routes SiTI Higher Institute on Territorial Systems for Innovation Sara Levi Sacerdotti

AMS E-GOS Local governance and performance of open data policies at municipal level

3D Urban Information Models in making a smart city the i-scope project case study

Spatially Enabled Society

REGIONAL SDI DEVELOPMENT

Arctic Spatial Data Infrastructure Enabling Access to Arctic Location-Based Information

Economic and Social Council

Proposal for a DIRECTIVE OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL. establishing an infrastructure for spatial information in the Community

Adding value to Copernicus services with member states reference data

GLOBAL SMART SUSTAINABLE CITY INDEX (SSC INDEX) FIRST DRAFT

The Swedish National Geodata Strategy and the Geodata Project

Realizing benefits of Spatial Data Infrastructure A user s perspective from Environment Agency - Abu Dhabi

Implementing the Sustainable Development Goals: The Role of Geospatial Technology and Innovation

Grant Agreement No. EIE/07/595/SI BEn

Geography. Programme of study for key stage 3 and attainment target (This is an extract from The National Curriculum 2007)

THE ROLE OF REGIONAL SPATIAL PLANNING IN SUPPORTING LONG-TERM ECONOMIC GROWTH IN NORTHERN IRELAND

Council Workshop on Neighbourhoods Thursday, October 4 th, :00 to 4:00 p.m. Burlington Performing Arts Centre

Economic and Social Council

The role of community in urban regeneration: mixed use areas approach in USA

Interactive Visualization Tool (InViTo)

City and SUMP of Ravenna

Shetland Islands Council

Spatial Data Availability Energizes Florida s Citizens

Key Indicators for Territorial Cohesion & Spatial Planning Stakeholder Workshop - Project Update. 13 th December 2012 San Sebastián, Basque Country

PhD in URBAN PLANNING, DESIGN, AND POLICY - 34th cycle

THE SEVILLE STRATEGY ON BIOSPHERE RESERVES

Designing smart & Resilient cities:

Natura 2000 and spatial planning. Executive summary

The Process of Spatial Data Harmonization in Italy. Geom. Paola Ronzino

SPLAN-Natura Towards an integrated spatial planning approach for Natura th January, 2017 Brussels. Commissioned by DG Environment

Urbanization and Sustainable Development of Cities: A Ready Engine to Promote Economic Growth and Cooperation

SWEDISH SDI DEVELOPMENT & IMPLEMENTATION OF INSPIRE

Land Use in the context of sustainable, smart and inclusive growth

Exploit your geodata to enable smart cities and countries

Jordan's Strategic Research Agenda in cultural heritage

Key Points Sharing fosters participation and collaboration Metadata has a big role in sharing Sharing is not always easy

Outline National legislative & policy context Regional history with ESSIM ESSIM Evaluation Phase Government Integration via RCCOM Regional ICOM Framew

have been a number of high level and expert reviews including the most recent, the Marmot review.

Framework on reducing diffuse pollution from agriculture perspectives from catchment managers

Territorial Cooperation within the Northern Periphery and the Arctic

COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION. Brussels, 2 May /14 CULT 68

The purpose of this report is to recommend a Geographic Information System (GIS) Strategy for the Town of Richmond Hill.

RURAL-URBAN PARTNERSHIPS: AN INTEGRATED APPROACH TO ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

CEMAT results - over the years

Building a National Data Repository

Using Space-based Downstream Services for Urban Management in Smart Cities

Global Geospatial Information Management Country Report Finland. Submitted by Director General Jarmo Ratia, National Land Survey

Geospatial natural disaster management

The future of SDIs. Ian Masser

econtentplus GS Soil

RETA 6422: Mainstreaming Environment for Poverty Reduction Category 2 Subproject

THE ROLE OF SPATIAL PLANNING IN INTEGRATED COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE INTERREG III B BALTCOAST PROJECT

Urban Climate Resilience

8 th Arctic Regional Hydrographic Commission Meeting September 2018, Longyearbyen, Svalbard Norway

D2. Addressing tourism related mobility

Implementation of the ESPON 2020 cooperation program. 16 January 2017 Anneloes van Noordt

2018/1 The integration of statistical and geospatial information. The Regional Committee of UN-GGIM: Americas:

Understanding the Spatial Effects of High Speed Rail

Towards a City Model for Heritage-Led Regeneration and Tourism Development

EuroSDR (European Spatial Data Research)

Status of implementation of the INSPIRE Directive 2016 Country Fiches. COUNTRY FICHE Netherlands

Low Density Areas : Places of Opportunity. Enrique Garcilazo, OECD Directorate for Public Governance and Territorial Development

2007 / 2008 GeoNOVA Secretariat Annual Report

Harmonizing spatial databases and services at local and regional level

Spatial Analysis Unit

What is Spatial Planning?

COLLABORATIVE GI BASED APPROACH: Discussing GI relevance towards monitoring EU Legal Framework. Maria José VALE Raquel SARAIVA Rui REIS

Policy and Legal Frameworks: The journey so far

The National Spatial Strategy

SCORE. INSPIRE-ing VOLUNTEERED GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION: CASES FROM SOUTH EAST EUROPE. mashing up community and spatial technology

INSPIRE and Land Use Planning System in Portugal

STATE GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION DATABASE

Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care Geographic Information System (GIS) Strategy An Overview of the Strategy Implementation Plan November 2009

Integrated Territorial Development Strategies in Greece under economic crisis

Work Packages. RECROS Project development workshop. Prague, 30 th April 2015

Declaration Population and culture

GRISI: Geomatic Regional Information Society Initiative M. Cabello 1, A. Valentín 2. 2

SPIMA Spatial dynamics and strategic planning in metropolitan areas

The Significance and Role of GIS and CSDI in Smart City Development

Topographic Mapping in Australia: The Future State

ACTION PLAN FOR WORLD HERITAGE IN LATIN AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN ( )

Set-up of subnational statistical systems Statistical Development Strategy for the State of Jalisco México, 2016

SMART CITIES NEED LOCATION DATA

A Preliminary Model of Community-based Integrated Information System for Urban Spatial Development

Advancing Geoscientific Capability. Geological Survey of Finland

Urban Planning in the Czech Republic & Humboldt project Otakar ČERBA, Karel CHARVÁT, Štěpán KAFKA

EMMA : ECDC Mapping and Multilayer Analysis A GIS enterprise solution to EU agency. Sharing experience and learning from the others

Standards in Action: The Canadian Geospatial Data Infrastructure (CGDI)

Spatial Data Management of Bio Regional Assessments Phase 1 for Coal Seam Gas Challenges and Opportunities

GIS at UCAR. The evolution of NCAR s GIS Initiative. Olga Wilhelmi ESIG-NCAR Unidata Workshop 24 June, 2003

SA Geospatial Analysis Platform (GAP) Methodology*, collaborators & data sources

UN-GGIM: Strengthening Geospatial Capability

Dublin City Schools Social Studies Graded Course of Study Grade 5 K-12 Social Studies Vision

Implementation of Inspire in Denmark - How we get it flying! Olav Eggers National Survey & Cadastre -Denmark

Raising awareness on mobility costs for households: a lever for changing residential choices and improving local governance?

GOVERNMENT MAPPING WORKSHOP RECOVER Edmonton s Urban Wellness Plan Mapping Workshop December 4, 2017

GIS and Community Health. GIS and Community Health. Institutional Context and Interests in GIS Development. GIS and Community Health

Transcription:

1 ABSTRACT Smart Cities and Urban Governance. The urbanapi Project: Bologna Case Study David C. Ludlow, Maria Paola Mauri, Chiara Caranti (David C. Ludlow, UWE University of the West of England, Bristol- UK, david.ludlow@uwe.ac.uk) (Maria Paola Mauri, AEW Srl Rome-Italy, mnemea@iol.it ) (Chiara Caranti, Comune di Bologna, Bologna Italy, Chiara.Caranti@comune.bologna.it) The urbanapi project has been funded by the European Commission in the context of European initiatives to improve policy as a more transparent and understandable process: it is a three-year, 4 million, multi-partner collaborative project developing ICT tools to support urban governance and spatial planning in four cities across Europe. Underpinning the project is the understanding that the delivery of more sustainable cities requires the application of enhanced intelligence in urban management, to produce an effective basis for assessment of urban complexity and decision-making. Fraunhofer IGD (Project Coordinator), AIT (Austrian Institute of Technology) assisted by GeoVille are responsible of ICT tool design and implementation, UWE and AEW (Rome) with the contribution of ICLEI, are responsible for engagement with stakeholders in order to define their needs, organisation of workshops and assessment of the tools application in the partner cities. Vienna, Bologna, Vitoria-Gasteiz, and Ruse are the partner cities supporting the applications with practical experience, governance needs and data. The urbanapi tools provide advanced ICT based intelligence in different urban planning contexts: First, directly addressing the issue of stakeholder engagement in the planning process by the development of enhanced virtual reality visualisation of neighbourhood development proposals. Second, at the city-wide scale, developing mobile (GSM) based applications that permit the analysis and visual representation of socio-economic activity across the city. Third, the development of simulation tool applications in the city-region responding to the simultaneous demands of both expanding city populations for certain European cities, and declining and frequently ageing populations elsewhere. Lessons derived from the urbanapi experience will permit the development of generic ICT tools that can be used in the majority of the cities of Europe. In this context, the enhanced ICT tools proposed by urbanapi offer the potential to provide urban planners with the tools and intelligence needed to actively manage the urban environment. These tools will provide planners with precisely the information they need to fully expose the socio-economic and environmental impacts associated with alternative options for territorial development and thereby create conditions in which the political mandate and the basis for more effective management is secured. In this paper will be analysed the project expected impact on urban governance and the results achieved with the 3D application in the city of Bologna during the first phase of the project implementation. 2 ICT-INTELLIGENCE FOR URBAN PLANNING CONTEXTS Effective governance of the cities and city regions of Europe today is fundamentally undermined by urban complexity, whereby the high degree of interconnectedness and multiple interactions between socioeconomic and environmental factors in a territorial context create major barriers to the effective implementation of sustainable urban development. The proactive governance of cities and the delivery of more sustainable compact cities require the application of enhanced intelligence in urban management, to produce an effective basis for assessment of urban complexity, and decision-making support. The governance of cities is a collective effort requiring joint initiative between planning and management agencies from EU to local level, clear coordination between a variety of agencies at the local level, as well as critical inputs from all stakeholder groups including citizens. In this context the urbanapi applications -3D virtual reality visualisation, mobile phone based mobility dynamics, city region growth simulation will be brought as common toolsets to the four cities serving as 1335

Smart Cities and Urban Governance. The urbanapi Project: Bologna Case Study test cases (Vienna, Bologna, Vitoria-Gasteiz, and Ruse) addressing different spatial scales in the multi-level governance setting of urban environments. The proposed urbanapi toolset and the applications will make use of the vast data resources geospatial and statistical datasets related to urban planning, by integrating smart ICT technologies to promote sustainable planning policies by engagement with the public through ideas and visions that address alternative urban planning perspectives and new city development proposals. Local initiatives will be encouraged to participate within the planning process, to contribute to the appropriate solutions and understand and finally endorse the expected impacts on environment and citizens. Each application developed in one city context will be paired with another similar application in another and different city and national context, where different socio-economic, environmental and territorial characteristics, as well is governance structures and practices will be evident. Lessons will be derived from the comparative assessment of the applications developed in these differing contexts that will form the basis for the future development of generic ICT tools that can be utilised in the majority of the 500 cities of Europe with populations over 100,000, as well as other smaller cities and towns throughout Europe. Fig. 1: City wise urbanapi applications at the three urban contexts: neighbourhood (3D), city (PME) and urban region (UGS) The urbanapi project will support both sides in the urban policy and governance system: the policymaking and practitioner side as well as the stakeholders and the public. The generic ICT applications will be built from a set of common libraries for data integration, policy modelling, simulation and visualisation, to be easily adapted to changing requirements by integration of the relevant data sets, to inform the practitioners and gather feedback from the public. Public participants in urban governance processes usually are not always ready to observe simulations for hours, to orient themselves in relation to complex cartographic products or use special equipment to experience results. Making these applications available to the public requires on the one hand simplification in the simulation concept, and on the other hand enhancement of visualisation techniques. 3 THE USER PERSPECTIVE Most European citizens embrace the "collaborative Internet" and expect to be able to interact with city governments using ICTs. ICTs are seen as enablers of more and better participation (e-participation), and democracy (e-democracy) and more inclusive societies (inclusive e-governance and e-inclusion), extending beyond enhanced service delivery, to facilitate and enhance interactions between actors, thus requiring change in regulatory and governance processes. However, especially at the city level there is as yet only limited evidence of the direct effects of ICT-enabled innovations on city governance systems. The urbanapi project provides ICT enabled innovations for city governance and adapted governance models to support new stakeholder engagement and citizen participation, in order to enhance sustainable urban policy development and delivery. The conceptual frame for the project is based upon the understanding that urban managers throughout Europe face common challenges in responding to the desire for a more participatory democracy, in order to define the basis for securing urban economic vitality, social inclusion and environmental sustainability. The urbanapi project ICT tools will be developed with the application cities of Vienna, Ruse, Vitoria- Gasteiz, and Bologna. Local initiatives in the four urban regions working in this project will be encouraged to participate within the planning process, to contribute to the final solutions and understand and finally accept the expected impacts on environment and habitants. In order to gain relevance beyond the four cities implementing the ICT tools proposed by urbanapi, to gather additional input from urban experts and to reach out to the many cities throughout Europe that could 1336 REAL CORP 2013: PLANNING TIMES

David C. Ludlow, Maria Paola Mauri, Chiara Caranti potentially benefit from the project's results, various activities at different stages in the project foresee the involvement of one or more relevant stakeholder organisations: Stakeholder Board: This advisory group convened a number of (approx. 10) networks, associations and other organisations dealing with urban policies, urban planning and/or urban sustainability. Requirement Workshops, organised in each application city: In order to tailor the application of the ICT tools proposed by urbanapi as much as possible to the needs and possibilities of the four cities participating in the project. Evaluation Workshops: In the evaluation phase, expert input will be organised through another series of workshops, setting the criteria for analysing the outcomes and reflecting on the experiences made during the application of the ICT tools. 4 3D VR APPLICATION The 3D urbanapi system is built on the basis of the City Server 3D, developed by Fraunhofer IGD, which has already been proven in use by various municipalities. A web-portal is set up for the integration of several reusable visual interaction components that will be accessible over the internet. The applications in the three cities (Bologna, Vitoria Gasteiz and Vienna) will allow, through an interactive process, the implementation of a new 3D scenario creator. These technical developments will permit the transfer of Virtual Reality from academic research to real world applications by developing a generic tool: to display live content, such as other usersʹ interactions, sensor data and simulation results; to render 3D content adapted to the requirements of the policy making support application; to add content and to modify 2D and 3D objects depicting alternative urban planning decisions, e.g. on the basis of parameters (such as eaves height) defined in the zoning plan; to create custom projections, e.g. in vertical and horizontal cross-sections across time, space and theme on the fly; to process large amounts of rich 3D models, but also little and coarse 3D information from standard CAD and GIS data bases and selected elevation views (photos, renderings) as texture information; to allow easy and widespread applications, by providing a simple and intuitive graphical user interface (GUI) to introduce alternative planning scenarios; to focus on data integration and harmonisation and to the delivery of seamless applications. Figure 1: Preview of the 3D scenario creator (source: Fraunhofer) 1337

Smart Cities and Urban Governance. The urbanapi Project: Bologna Case Study Using the 3D VR (virtual reality) visualisations, the general effects and the visual impact of urban development plans can be realistically shown. The 3D scenarios support the negotiation process for urban development projects. Interactive control of planning interventions and presentation of the new visual effects, released through changes in zoning, help citizens to experience these changes. In order to guarantee the best user experience possible high quality 3D geodata are used as well as rich interaction elements, especially to provide feedback on planning in various forms. This means that special emphasis is put on user-friendly client interfaces and an easy-to-understand simulation. Users will have the possibility to choose between the 3D web client and a mobile application. 5 BOLOGNA NEIGHBOURHOOD SCALE: 3D APPLICATION Bologna is pursuing ICT solutions for both urban planning as well as environmental objectives. The aim is to communicate more effectively with citizens by visualising future development and potential impacts and enhance public engagement for a quick feedback on planning initiatives. The development of the 3D scenario creator is conceived to enhance public and stakeholder engagement in the rehabilitation and mobility plan for the city centre ( Di nuovo in centro ). A pilot area of the city centre has been chosen for the application: this area is also involved in a project called Ambiente Vitale, which aims to increase awareness and public participation in relation to green and public spaces provision, as well as sustainable lifestyles. The 3D application will help planners to better visualize urban transformations in the district, improve interdepartmental collaboration and coordination in decision-making, and take account of citizens opinions and suggestions, in line with the community participation processes already started with the many citizen committees and cultural associations. Citizens will be able to interact with the Municipality through the 3D scenario creator, and chose their focus on including, for example, the rehabilitation and mobility plan, bike and car sharing points, public transportation and cycle track routes. They can also provide inputs concerning the management of pedestrians route ways, the rubbish collection system and the use of public spaces. The tool will help public and private planners to take easily in consideration citizens' suggestions and feeds, in order to better take care of interests and needs of the community, and come to an agreement with environmental sustainability issues. The application is started: the process of needs definition and requirements gathering has been completed, work on cartographic data is finished, it was time consuming work, because available data derived from different sources and have been collected for different purposes; after the selection and the final check, Geoville harmonized the data. At present the visualisation of the district s routes has been realised and we are working on communication to public and private stakeholders: a specific urbanapi 3D application link to add to the Bologna Municipality web page, is under development. Fig.2- Bologna city centre 1338 REAL CORP 2013: PLANNING TIMES

6 CONCLUSION David C. Ludlow, Maria Paola Mauri, Chiara Caranti The urbanapi 3D virtual reality visualisation toolset will allow the fast development and deployment of participative policy support applications for decision support, conflict management, analysis and visualisation, being developed and evaluated in collaboration with the cities partners. The Bologna application will be assessed in comparison with the experiences going on in differing city contexts (Vitoria and Vienna) and will form the basis for future generic and reusable ICT tools. Setting this goal will ensure the sustainability of the approach, as the created solutions will be applicable beyond the application cases used for evaluation in this project. 7 REFERENCES Comune di Bologna, AmbienteVitale Project: http://www.comune.bologna.it/ambiente/servizi/6:6197/14256/ Comune di Bologna, Mobility Plan: http://www.comune.bologna.it/dinuovoincentro Comune di Bologna, PSC (Municipality Structural Plan): www.comune.bologna.it/urbanisticaedilizia urbanapi Deliverables: D1.3.1 Annual Report 2012, D2.1 User Requirement Definition, D4.1.4 Dissemination and Exploitation Plan 1339