Spacetime Diagrams Relativity and Astrophysics Lecture 21 Terry Herter Outline Fate of the Universe Forever expansion Dark Energy Time is Private Spacetime diagrams Prelim Wednesday, Oct. 21 Closed book and notes, will cover lectures 11 20 But some of this material depends on earlier lectures Should know Will have both qualitative and quantitative questions Most equations will be provided (if needed) A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 2 A2290-21 1
The Two Omegas So now we only need to know M and. With zero (no) cosmological constant Have M and k with k = 1 M With a non-zero cosmological constant Have M,, and k with k = 1 M Determine Dynamics and Geometry M and set acceleration/deceleration k sets geometry ( k = 1 M ) A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 3 0 Accelerating empty Distance Present Time bound unbound marginally bound Look back in time Time Expansion velocity in the past depends upon M and. Galaxies would be moving faster in the past for a non-empty universe. A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 4 A2290-21 2
Type Ia SN results M = 0, = 1 M = 0.3, = 0.7 M = 0, = 0 M ~ 0.5, = 0 Figure from: Riess and Turner, SciAm, Feb. 2004 A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 5 Cosmic Acceleration: Updated The results from 2004 have not appreciably changed. Here are some results from 2007. SNe Ia Hubble diagram with best model fit ( M = 0.27, = 0.73). Insert residual Hubble diagram after subtracting empty universe model (and binning data). Expansion history of universe. Top Hubble constant vs. z. Bottom expansion rate vs. z. From Riess, et al. 2007, ApJ, 659, 98. A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 6 A2290-21 3
0.0 decelerating accelerating The Cosmic Triangle (with the Three Omegas) 1.0 0.5 2.0 M 1.5 1.0 recollapses eventually expands forever OPEN CLOSED 0.5 k 0.0-0.5 Matter + Cosmological Constant + Curvature 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 7 0.0 decelerating accelerating Observations in the Cosmic Triangle 0.5 1.0 CMB refers to measurements of structure in the Cosmic Microwave Background 2.0 M 1.5 1.0 recollapses CMB eventually expands forever OPEN CLOSED SNe 0.5 Clusters 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 8 k 0.0-0.5 Clusters refers to mass estimates of clusters of galaxies SNe refers to data from Type Ia Supernovae. Intersection gives Omegas consist with all the data See: http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/284/5419/1481 A2290-21 4
The Cosmic Triangle (updated) Updated with WMAP data From: http://webphysics.davidson.edu/faculty/thg/247_files/cosmic-triangle.htm (haven t found direct reference) A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 9 Dark Energy The acceleration of the Universe driven by an enormous amount of energy. What causes the acceleration? Or what is the cosmological constant? Unknown! This unknown energy is call dark energy. Attempts to estimate it from particle physics are off by at least a factor of 10 55! Even more of the Universe is unknown to us than we thought! Illustration from WMAP website A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 10 A2290-21 5
The Fate of the Universe The best estimates now yield H o = 71 km/sec/mpc M = 0.27, = 0.73 k = 0 Age of universe is 13.67 Gyr This implies The Universe will go on expanding forever Because > 0, it will expand ever faster! A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 11 Time is a Private Matter Time is a private quantity It is carried with the particle Time is not a public quantity that is, there is no absolute time Time is route dependent! Time depends on the path a particle takes This differs from a quantity such as temperature A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 12 A2290-21 6
Spacetime diagram (or map) same time Plots space on one axis and time on the other Payoffs Place space and time on equal footing Review history of events and motions along a given line in spacetime Plot same events in different spacetime diagrams for different inertial reference frames Can find what is different and what is the same between the frames D time B C same place Reference event O, along with other events A, B, C, and D. The dashed horizontal line represents events simultaneous in time while the dashed vertical line represents events at the same location. O A space A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 13 Same events, different frames Considers a light flash reflected off a mirror and back as seen from three different frames rocket, lab, and super-rocket The mirrors are at rest in the rocket frame and the superrocket is traveling in the same direction but faster (relative to lab frame) than the rocket The light paths look like that shown below: rocket lab super-rocket A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 14 A2290-21 7
Spacetime interval is conserved The spacetime interval is conserved (the same for each frame). (interval) 2 = (time) 2 (space) 2 = constant lab time The red hyperbola in the spacetime plots show the line of constant interval. The arrows represent the same arrow in spacetime! Maps show different perspectives of the same arrow in spacetime. Spacetime geometry is Lorentz geometry, not Euclidean. R lab space rocket time super-rocket time R R rocket space super-rocket space A2290-21 Spacetime Diagrams 15 A2290-21 8