ASSESSMENT OF LOCAL GOVERNANCE STRUCTURES, ATTITUDES AND PERCEPTIONS INFLUENCING MANAGEMENT OF THE MANGROVE ECOSYSTEM IN VANGA, KENYA MARLYN ACHIENG OMONDI A Thesis submitted to the Graduate School in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of a Master of Science Degree in Natural Resource Management of Egerton University EGERTON UNIVERSITY MAY, 2017
DECLARATION AND RECOMMENDATION I hereby declare that this thesis is my original work and has never been presented for the fulfillment for the award of a degree in any other university and that all the sources I have used have been acknowledged. Marlyn Achieng Omondi NM11/3610/13 Signature: Date.. Recommendation by supervisors Dr. Bernard K. Kirui (PhD.) Department of Natural Resources Management, Egerton University, Signature. Date: Dr. James G. Kairo (PhD.) Department of Oceanography and Hydrography, Kenya Marine and Fisheries Research Institute (KMFRI), Signature:... Date:... ii
ABSTRACT Mangroves throughout the world are a critical ecosystem facing numerous threats. In Kenya, losses of mangroves in the last two decades have been estimated to be at 20%. Continued destruction could result in more than 70% of mangrove cover loss in the next 50 years thus affecting biodiversity and livelihoods of many coastal communities. Overexploitation and conversion pressure are the main causes of loss and degradation. Incentive based mechanisms such as Payment for Ecosystem Services (PES) and Reduction of Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD+) could significantly increase local community participation in mangrove conservation. Two important questions concerning the likely applicability of incentive based schemes to a given site are: what is the capacity of the local governance structures to manage these programs and what are the views of the local community regarding the state of the ecosystem? This study investigated the local governance structures that exist to support conservation and management of the mangrove ecosystem. Using Vanga mangrove ecosystem as a case study, the study further investigated attitudes and perceptions of local communities towards the status and condition of mangroves forests in their area. The data was collected through key informant interviews, focus group discussions, household surveys and participant observation. Data analysis was done using descriptive statistics, correlations, cross-tabulation, text analysis and data triangulation. The Forest Guard was recognized as the key decision maker in local mangrove governance by 78% of respondents while co-management by the Community Forest Association was only recognized by 32%. Poor monitoring strategies and lack of adequate community consultation were identified as major factors that led to continued destruction of the resource. More than half (62 %) of the respondents perceived the Vanga mangrove ecosystem as degraded to some extent; whereas 86% would be willing to participate in their conservation if incentives were provided. Local decision making on how to share benefits accrued was a significant motivation factor for participation in conservation as this allows for community priorities to be taken into consideration. It is highly likely that the attitude of the community towards the incentive based initiatives would be influenced by the perceived long-term benefits of conserving the mangrove ecosystem for carbon credits against the opportunity cost of shortterm benefits of exploitation. Providing opportunities for community monitoring through creation of by-laws and local sanctions would promote better community support. Community training on incentive based schemes is necessary in order to provide a better understanding of the concept and thus foster long term community support in conservation. vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS DECLARATION AND RECOMMENDATION... ii COPYRIGHT... iii DEDICATION...iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENT...v ABSTRACT...vi LIST OF FIGURES...x LIST OF TABLES...xi LIST OF ACRONYMS... xii CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION...1 1.1 Background to the study...1 1.2: Statement of the problem...3 1.3: Research Objectives...3 1.3.1: Broad objective...3 1.3.2: Specific objectives...3 1.3.3: Research questions...3 1.4: Justification...4 1.5: Scope and limitations...5 1.6: Definition of terms...5 CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW...7 2.1: Mangrove goods and services...7 2.2: Global status of mangroves...8 2.3: Conservation of mangroves...8 2.3.1: Local governance and conservation of mangroves....8 2.3.2: Theoretical framework for natural resource governance...9 2.4: PES and REDD+...12 2.5: Mangroves in Kenya...13 2.5.1: Utilization of mangroves in Kenya...13 2.5.2: Threats to mangroves in Kenya...14 2.5.3: Mangrove forest governance in Kenya...15 2.5.4. Incentive based mangrove conservation in Kenya...15 2.6: Conceptual framework for the study...16 CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY...18 vii
3.1: Description of the study site...18 3.1.1: Location and Size...18 3.1.2: Climatic conditions...18 3.1.3: Socio-economic status...19 3.1.4: Management status of Vanga mangrove area....19 3.2: Research Design...20 3.2.1: Sampling of key informants and FGD respondents...20 3.2.2: Sample size for household surveys...20 3.3: Data collection...20 3.3.1: Characterizing the major goods and services from mangroves of Vanga...20 3.3.2: Characterizing local governance systems, roles and acceptance...21 3.3.3: Local perceptions and potential to participate in incentive-based projects...21 3.4: Data Analysis...21 3.4.1: Characterizing the major goods and services of Vanga mangroves...21 3.4.2: Characterizing local governance systems, roles and acceptance...21 3.4.3: Local perceptions and attitudes toward the state of mangroves...22 3.4.4: Potential to participate in incentive-based mangrove projects...22 CHAPTER 4: RESULTS...24 4.1: Socio-economic characteristics of the respondents...24 4.2: Major goods and services from mangroves of Vanga...24 4.3: Local mangrove governance structure...25 4.3: Local attitudes and perceptions on the status of mangroves....30 4.4: Potential community involvement in incentive based mechanisms...34 CHAPTER 5: DISCUSSION...37 5.1: Major goods and services from mangroves of Vanga...37 5.2: Local mangrove governance structure in Vanga...37 5.3: Community attitudes and perceptions towards the state of mangroves...42 5.4: Willingness to participate in incentive based conservation...44 CHAPTER 6: CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...48 REFERENCES...50 APPENDICES...62 Appendix 1: Key Informant Interviews...62 Appendix 2: Focus Group Discussion (Community)...64 viii
Appendix 3: Focus Group Discussion (Local Conservation Groups)...65 Appendix 4: Household Survey Questionnaire...66 ix