Energetic neutral and negative ion beams accelerated from spray target irradiated with ultra-short, intense laser pulses Sargis Ter-Avetisyan ELI - Extreme Light Infrastructure Science and Technology with Ultra-Intense Lasers Institute of Physics, Prague, Czech Republic R. Prasad, B. Ramakrishna, M. Borghesi, Queen s University of Belfast (UK) M. Schnürer, A. Andreev, P. V. Nickles, F. Abicht, J. Braenzel, L. Ehrentraut, G. Priebe, Max-Born-Institute, Berlin (Germany) V. Tikhonchuk CALIA University Bordeaux1 (France)
laser-driven acceleration of ion is a burgeoning field of research state-of-the-art laser systems allow to accelerate bunches of positive ions from the foil targets with unique properties: extreme laminarity: rms emittance <.2 π mm-mrad short duration source: ~ 1 ps ( E t < -6 ev-s) high energy - 6 MeV at present high brightness: ~13 protons/ions (> 3 MeV) high current (if stripped of electrons): ka range This work highlights another important property of laser-plasma interaction, namely the capability of acting as a source of high energy and high brightness negative ion beams
outline spray target - charged particle acceleration from the spray: protons, heavy ions main experimental evidences energetic negative ions - acceleration of negative ions energetic neutral atoms - heavy atoms and hydrogen
spray generator 35 bar pulse valve water poppet insulator Al body heater 15Χ nozzle laser spray Patent; DE 2 6 376 A1 (24) Ter-Avetisyan, Schnürer, Nickles, Device and method for the creation of droplet target
spray characterisation The spray was characterized by employing Mie scattering and transmission measurements measuring angular scattering pattern of the probe beam beam r e s e la prob PM de tec tor < λlaser δskin depth ddroplet < water (H2) single droplet size 15 ± nm droplet density 11 cm-3 average spray density 18 cm-3 ethanol (C2H5H) single droplet size 18 ± nm droplet density 5 11 cm-3 average spray density 19 χµ 3 S. Ter-Avetisyan et.al., J. Phys. D: 36, 2421 (23), R. Prasad et al., RSI,
ion acceleration from the droplets 5 19 W/cm2 ~ 2 mm contrast -8 focal spot ~6 µm < λlaser δskin depthddroplet < by pre-evaporation of the droplets, its diameter is reduced outer shell (~ 15 nm) is ionized to high degree cold core remains iso-coulomb-potential accelerates ions to high energies Ter-Avetisyan, et al., Phys.Plasmas (212), R,amakrishna et al., Phys.Plasmas 17 83113 (2), - +-- - + + + ++ + +++ - -nm 15 Ter-Avetisyan, et al., Phys.Plasmas 16 431 (29)
set-up to measure ion yield from the spray for calibration and quantitative analyses I ~ 5 19 W/cm2 τ ~ 4 fs laser contrast -8 Ion yield was characterised laser laser changing the delay between laser and spray pulse for calibration of detector response MCP was substituted with CR39
negative ion acceleration in water spray electric field deflection laser propagation direction H+ 4 + 32+ + 1+ - + magnetic field deflection ions in nsr @ 5% energy bandwith electric field deflection lateral direction electric field deflection magnetic field deflection 9 negative ions per steradian in 5% energy bandwidth 9 8 7 + -..2.4.6 S. Ter-Avetisyan et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 99, 5151 (211)
negative ion emission from single droplet Ion spectra from H2 and D2 exploded droples p I ~ 5 19 W/cm2 pulse duration 4 fs laser contrast -8 -- + + +- + +Laser +Laser + - +- - 8+ D- 1+ 1- droplet size 2 µm electric field deflection positive and negative ions - + electric field deflection 1+ 7+ D+ p up to 4 shot accumulation magnetic field deflection S. Ter-Avetisyan et.al., J. Phys. B: 37, 3633 (24),
asymmetry of negative ions emission laser pulse is at the rising edge of the spray density electric field deflection lateral direction H+ magnetic field deflection 3 H 2 1 1+ + 2+ 3+ detection background..5 1. 1.5 2. 2.5 Ions in 7 nsr @ 5% bandwidth 4 +3 + 2+ 1+ ions in 7 nsr @ 5 % bandwidth electric field deflection laser propagation direction S. Ter-Avetisyan et al., A.P.L. 99, 5151 (211) H+ 4+ 3+ 2+ + magnetic field deflection 3 2 3+ 2 1-2+ 1+ 1 + H 1 detection background detection background Ion max. energy increase with charge state + 1.25 MeV - 1 2 3.5 1. 1.5 all ions have similar ( 3 MeV) max. energy - 1.25 MeV no negative hydrogen has been observed from water spray
negative ion formation in charge-exchange spray density distribution is modified by the laser pulse in forward direction a low density channel is created by ionizing and heating the medium the propagation of ion through the cold spray medium is collisional for oxygen atoms L 5 µm, for protons mean free path length: L >> dspray ( mm) +, -, p, Laser low ne Ionization, n+, p n+ (n-1)+ charge-exchange in a spray can explain the formation of negative ions: resonant process: probability is max. if vion vbound el. (1MeV 1+ = 3.4 6 m/s) ( )σ-1 ~ 1-16 cm2 (for.1 1 MeV ), angular diagram is narrow ( 1 )
electron capture and loss in the spray competitive processes are: electron capture A+ A A- two electron capture A+ A- A electron capture and loss A+ A A- A elastic-collisions cross-section is smaller than the charge-exchange cross-section inelastic-collision cross-section -18 cm2: at spray densities 18 cm-3, the probability of scattering events is < % over the spray length of 1 mm
3 2 1 H laser propagation direction + 2+ 1+ Probability of collisions is reduced: ions spectrum defined by the acceleration process 3+ 3 detection background..5 1. 1.5 2. 2.5 lateral direction Propagation is highly collisional: nσℓ >> 1 charge-exchange is efficient; all ions have same energy 2 ions in 7 nsr @ 5% bandwidth Ions in 7 nsr @ 5% bandwidth ions in 7 nsr @ 5 % bandwidth negative ion formation in charge-exchange negative ion formation 2 detection background + H 1 detection background 1 2.5 1+ 3 The charge-exchange proceeding elastically, without energy exchange therefore the energy distributions of the positive and negative ions should be the same: -, + 1.25 MeV 1 2+ 1-3+ 1. 1.5 B = 1.7 8 A cm-2 sr-1 This is the brightest negative ion source observed so far
ethanol spray Ethanol (C2H5H) single droplet size 18 ± nm (water 15 ± nm) droplet density 5 11 cm-3 (water 11 χµ 3 ) average spray density 19 χµ 3 (ωατερ 18 χµ 3) is it possible to accelerate negative ions other than oxygen? what could be an effect of bigger droplets and/or high density?
negative ion acceleration in ethanol spray lateral direction 1+ C1+ 2+ C2+ p C11-212113L6 carbon and hydrogen ion spectra ions in nsr @ 5% energy bandwith ions in nsr @ 5% energy bandwith oxygen ion spectra 9 1+ 8. 1-.2.4.6 11 H + C 2+ 1+ 9 C 1- C 8 1 2 3 4
negative hydrogen from ethanol spray forward direction lateral direction H+ H- H- kev we don t see H- from water spray because it is not thick enough for the charge-exchange of hydrogen.
implication of the model ur model implies the existence of a large number of fast neutrals with high energies Neutral oxygen and protons through 1mm pinhole, accelerated from water spray CR39 picture of the zero point CR39 EMT detector
pits on CR39 crated by ion impact hydrogen pits oxygen pits hydrogen and oxygen pits on zero point Number of positive and negative ions and neutrals are similar
spray as secondary target Ions accelerated from foil target are propagating through the spray carbon
spray as secondary target ion spectra accelerated from Ti target C1+ C2+ C3+ C4+ p 2121189 through ethanol spray C1+ C2+ C- through water spray C3+ C1+ C2+ C3+ C4+ C4+ p p 212118 C- 21211913
spray as secondary target spectra of Ti ions propagating through the water spray or without spray 3 4 4 5 15 2 (c) 4 2 1 2 3 (d) 3 4 5 C2+ through spray C2+ without spray 3 1 C1+ through spray C1+ without spray C1-2 C3+ through spray C3+ without spray 2 3 part icle number 3 25 (b) 3 2 part icle number C4+ through spray C4+ without spray part icle number part icle number (a) 2 1 2 3 4 5
spray as secondary target ion spectra accelerated from carbon target 1+ 2+3+ C3+ C1+ C2+ C4+ 6+ p accelerated ions through water spray 1+ 2+ 3+ C3+ C1+ C2+ C4+ 21211931 p C- - 21211932
summary - negative ions are generated in electron-capture and loss processes when high-energy positive ion interacts with atoms in the spray: these processes proceed - almost elastically without energy exchange and - angular diagram is very narrow: ion that captures an electron propagates essentially in the same direction as before the collision and with the same energy. - different positive ions species can be converted to negative in the spray environment and with high efficiency - the brightness of negative ion source is extremely high, exceeding 8 A cm-2sr-1 (mainly due to the ultrashort duration of the emission) method offers a sizeable jump (3-4 orders) in the achieved source brightness avoiding high costs and technological challenges typical for accelerator technology.
Why the negative ions are interesting? - Recently negative ions have been proposed as an alternative to positive ions for heavy ion fusion drivers in inertial confinement fusion, because electron accumulation would be prevented and, if desired, the beams could be photo detached to neutrals. - High brightness beams of heavy negative ions are required for high current tandem accelerators for ion beam microscopy and lithography