arxiv: v3 [cond-mat.mes-hall] 19 May 2017

Transcription

1 Typeset with jpsj.cls<ver.1.> Letter nomlous Hll Effect nd Spontneous Orbitl Mgnetition in ntiferromgnetic Weyl Metl Nohiro Ito 1, Kentro Nomur 1 1 Institute for Mterils Reserch, Tohou University, Sendi rxiv:17.9v [cond-mt.mes-hll] 19 My 17 We study the nomlous Hll effect nd the orbitl mgnetition in chirl ntiferromgnets, constructing simple tight-binding model on stced Kgome lttice structure with spin-orbit coupling nd the exchnge interction between the loclied spins nd itinernt electrons. It is shown tht the chirl ntiferromgnet with spin-orbit coupling is n orbitl ferromgnet with the esy-plne nisotropy. The reltion between the orbitl mgnetition nd the configurtion of the Weyl points re discussed. KEYWORDS: nomlous Hll effect, orbitl mgnetition, chirl ntiferromgnet, Weyl semimetl Introduction The nomlous Hll effect is observed in 1, ) ferromgnetic mterils with spin-orbit coupling. It is nown tht the nomlous Hll effect is originted from extrinsic scttering by spin-orbit coupled sctterers or intrinsic contribution from the spin-orbit coupled electronic bnd structure. 1) In most cses the Hll resistivity is expressed in the following form where ext ρ xy = R ext + R s M spin, (1) is the spin mgnetition. t ero field, the Hll conductivity of ferromgnetic metl is proportionl to the perpendiculr component of the spin mgnetition, 1) is n externl mgnetic field nd M spin σ HE ǫ M spin. () ecuse of this reltion, the nomlous Hll effect is used to detect the mgnetition in ferromgnetic mterils. In mgnetic mterils with noncoplnr spin configurtions finite sclr spin chirlity cts s fictitious mgnetic field in rel spce for the conduction electrons nd contributes to the nomlous Hll effect even without spin-orbit coupling. 1) The nomlous Hll effect in ntiferromgnets hs been theoreticlly studied. 11) Recently, the nomlous Hll effect ws experimentlly observed t room temperture in noncolliner ntiferromgnets Mn Z, where Z = Sn, Ge, nd Ir. 1 15) The nomlous Hll conductivity is s lrge s tht in conventionl ferromgnetic metls such s Iron nd oblt even though the net spin mgnetition is negligibly smll. 1) Mn Z hs the lyered hexgonl lttice structure. Inside lyer, Mn toms form Kgome-type lttice with mixed tringles nd hexgons nd Z (Sn, Ge, nd Ir) toms re locted t the center of these hexgons. ll Mn moments re rrnged inside the Kgome plne forming tringulr spin structures, referred to chirl ntiferromgnets(f). Since the sclr spin chirlity is ero in ntiferromgnets, the mechnism of nomlous Hll effect is essentilly different from tht in mgnetic mterils with noncoplnr spin structures. Electronic structures in chirl ntiferromgnets hve been studied using first principle clcultion 7, 8, 1, 11), nd the existence of multiple Weyl points hs been observed. 1) It hs been lso shown tht the mechnism of the nomlous Hll effect in Mn Z cn be chrcteried by the cluster extension of octupole moments in the sme mnner s tht in ferromg- nomur@imr.tohou.c.jp nets by the mgnetition of dipole moment. 11) Up to now, however, simple tight-binding model hs not been studied in detil. In this pper we construct n effective tight-binding Hmiltonin with the exchnge interction nd spin-orbit coupling on stced Kgome lttice. We show tht the system hs spontneous orbitl mgnetition even though net spin mgnetition is ero. The nomlous Hll conductivities,σ xy,σ y, ndσ x re computed using the Kubo formul nd connected with the orbitl mgnetition. The existence of Weyl points plys n importnt role in the nomlous Hll effect. We discuss the reltion between the orbitl mgnetition nd the configurtion of the Weyl points. Model Hmiltonin In the following we construct single-orbitl tight-binding model on the lyered hexgonl lttice (the stced Kgome lttice structure) of Mn toms, neglecting electronic degrees of freedom on Z sites, s shown in Fig. 1 (). We strt from the hopping term H = t c iσ c jσ, () i, j where c iσ cretes n electron with spinσ(= or ) t the ith site of the stced Kgome lyers, nd i, j denotes nerest neighbors. s Fig. 1 shows, unit cell of the crystl consists of six toms locted t =(,, c), =(,, c), = (,, c) in one lyer nd = (,, ), = (,, ), = (,, ) in nother lyer. Here nd c re lttice spcing intrlyer nd interlyer, respectively. The intrlyer nerest-neighbor vectors re given by 1 = (,, ), = (,, ), = (,, ), nd interlyer nerest-neighbor vectors re c 1 = (,, c), c = (,, c), c = (,, c) s shown in Fig. 1. In the following we set t = t (between nerest neighbor, otherwise ero) nd = c = 1 for simplicity. Next we introduce spin-dependent nerest-neighbor hopping which is one of ingredients for the nomlous Hll effect. In the stced Kgome lttice inversion symmetry is loclly broen. In process of nerest neighbor hopping n electron feels n electric field perpendiculr to the direction of hopping tht gives rise to the spin-orbit coupling term of the form H so = it so n c iσ σ σσ c jσ, () <i, j> 1

2 J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. Letter uthor Nme () y x c c 1 c (e) b b 1 1 Fig. 1. () Structure of lyered hexgonl lttice structure in Mn Z (Z=Sn, Ge, nd Ir). Ech lyer forms Kgome lttice of Mn toms. Z toms re locted t the center of hexgons. Nerest-neighbor vectors i in the Kgome plne of Mn toms. b i vectors chrcterie the symmetry of the spin-orbit interction. Nerest-neighbor vectors c i between neighboring Kgome plnes. (e) Vectors in the spin-orbit coupling term in Eq. (). where t so is the strength of spin-orbit coupling nd n (= n ji ) is the unit vectors perpendiculr to the directions of hopping nd the locl electric fields. In Kgome lyer n = n = n = n = n = n = (,, 1), while n = n = b 1 c 1 = ( 1, 1, 1 ) long c 1, n = n =b c = (,, 1 ) long c, nd n =n = b c = ( 1, 1, 1 ) long c, where b 1 = ( 1,, ), b = ( 1,, ), b = ( 1,, ) s shown in Fig. 1. ll unit vectors, n, re illustrted in Fig. 1(e). The interction between itinernt electron spins nd loclied spins is described by the exchnge coupling term H exc = J m i c iσ σ σσ c iσ, (5) () F1 y x i F Fig.. onfigurtion of locl spins on Mn toms () F1 nd F. Spin configurtions re experimentlly relied depending on the direction of mgnetic fields long x nd y, respectively. b where m i is the direction unit vector of the loclied mgnetic moment t ith site. We focus on two cses with spin textures under the mgnetic fields long the x nd y directions, referred to F1 nd F, respectively, s shown in Fig. () nd. In terms of the Fourier components of the cretion nd nnihiltion opertors, c σ = 1 N j c jσ e i R j, the totl Hmiltonin is represented in the form of H = H + H so + H exc = c σ H σσ ()c σ. () The energy eigenvlues, obtined by digonliing H(), re shown long high-symmetry lines in Fig. for () F1 nd F configurtions. Here we set t so =.t nd J = 1.7t. These prmeters hve been estimted from the first principle clcultion in Ref. 7 for Mn Ir. We checed tht qulittive behviors shown below remin unchnged s the prmeters chnge. nomlous Hll conductivity Using the Kubo formul the nomlous Hll conductivityσ (i j) from the intrinsic mechnism is given by σ = e h ǫ d (π) Ω n,() f (E n µ), (7) n Z whereω n () = n () is the erry curvture nd n () = i u n u n is the erry connection, u n being the loch stte obtined by solving the eigen eqution H() u n = E n u n. The nomlous Hll conductivities re shown s function of the Fermi energy E in Fig. for F1 nd for F. In the F1 configurtionσ y is finite, whileσ x =σ xy =. In the F configurtion, on the other hnd,σ x is finite, whileσ xy =σ y =. These results re consistent with experiments. 1 15) Orbitl mgnetition Next we consider the orbitl mgnetition which is obtined by the following eqution,, 1) M orbit = e d h n Z (π) f (E n µ) un i {µ E n H()} u n, (8) nd discuss the reltion with the nomlous Hll effect. Here µ is the Fermi energy. The orbitl mgnetition M orbit = (M x, M y, M ) is shown in Fig. () for F1 nd for F s function of the Fermi energy E. In F1 M x is finite, while M y = M =. In F, on the other hnd, M y is finite, while M x = M =. These results show tht the ground stte of the our tight-binding Hmiltonin under the fixed locl spin mgnetitions (F1 nd F) possesses finite orbitl mgnetition contrry to the fct tht the net spin mgnetition is ero. In the presence of mgnetic field pointing in the Kgome plne, the orbitl mgnetition couples with the field, 1) vi M orbit. When points in the x direction, the F1 configurtion with M orbit pointing in the x direction is energeticlly fvored. Similrly, when points in the y direction, the F configurtion with M orbit pointing in the y direction is fvored, consistent with experiments. 1 15) Here we study the nisotropy of the orbitl mgnetition. We first consider the cse where the locl mgneti-

3 J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. Letter uthor Nme E/t E/t () F L Γ K M Γ F σ HE [e /h] σ y σ x σ xy () m. M orbit /t [e/h]..1 m m -.1 M x -. M y M M -. π π ε / t m m ε(,) ε(,) m π π, Fig. 5. onfigurtions of locl spins on Mn toms with () in-plne tilting ngle nd out-of-plne tilting ngle. Orbitl mgnetition s function of in-plne tilting ngle. Totl energy of electrons s function of nd L Γ K M Γ σ HE [e /h] σ y σ x σ xy Fig.. nd structure of the tight-binding Hmiltonin H() for configurtions of locl spins on Mn toms () F1 nd F, respectively., The nomlous Hll conductivities s function of the Fermi energy E for F1 nd F. tions re given s m = (cos, sin, ), m = (cos( π ), sin( π ), ), m = (cos(+ π ), sin(+ π ), ) on the,, nd sublttice, s shown in Fig. 5 (). Hereis the in-plne tilting ngle of the locl spin mgnetition from the F1 configurtion. Figure 5 shows the ngle dependence of the orbitl mgnetition M orbit = (M x, M y, M ) nd M orbit = M x + M y + M s function oft the Fermi energyµ= t. The results show tht the orbitl mgnetition chnges s M orbit = M ( cos, sin, ), where the norm M = M orbit is independent of. The qulittive be- E/t () F1 F M M orbit /t [e/h] M x M y M M orbit /t [e/h] M x M y σ y [e /h] σ y (ΙΙ) σ y Fig.. Orbitl mgnetition for () F1 nd F s function of the Fermi energy E. Totl nomlous Hll conductivityσ y ndσ (II) y. hviors remin unchnged s the Fermi energy chnges. To study the nisotropy of the orbitl mgnetition we compute the totl energy of electrons,ε= 1 N n, E n f (E n µ) s function of, where N is the number of unit cells nd f is the Fermi-Dirc distribution function. Figure 5 shows the totl energy of electrons s function of, ε(, ), tµ = t. Now we compreε(, ) to the energy in the cse of out-of-plne locl spin configurtion m = (cos,, sin), m = ( 1 cos, cos, sin), nd m = ( 1 cos, cos, sin), whereis the out-of-plne tilting ngle (Fig. 5 ). s shown in Fig. 5, the totl energy computed s function of,ε(,), hs mxim t=π/ nd π/, while ε(, ) is independent of. These behviors clerly indicte tht the system is n orbitl ferromgnet with the esy-plne nisotropy. y compring the nomlous Hll conductivity nd the orbitl mgnetition,σ y nd M x in F1 for exmple, one finds tht both quntities re not proportionl to ech other. In the conventionl ferromgnet, on the other hnd, the nomlous Hll conductivity is proportionl to the spin mgnetition s seen in eq. (). To see the connection between the nomlous Hll effect nd the orbitl mgnetition, we decompose the Hll conductivity into two terms 17) σ (I) σ =σ (I) +σ (II). (9) = (e /h)tr(v i G + v j G ), where G ± = (µ±i H) 1 nd v i = H()/ ( i ), is ssocited with sttes on the Fermi surfce. 17) On the other hnd, σ (II) M orbit = eǫ µ (1) is the contribution of ll filled sttes below the Fermi energy nd is thermodynmic equilibrium property of the mgnetic mteril. 17) In fig. the nomlous Hll conductivityσ y obtined by eq. (7) ndσ (II) y, eq.(1), re compred. Ner the pes of the nomlous Hll conductivity, these quntities re close ech other. Weyl points Finlly we study the Weyl points in the spec-

4 J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. Letter uthor Nme E/t E/t () y WP x WP1+ (e) x x y (f) (g) (h) y Fig.. () Positions of Weyl points in momentum spce. The sign ± corresponds to the chirlities of the Weyl points. Direction of the erry curvture round the Weyl points. Dotted circles indicte the positions of the Weyl points. -(h) Energy dispersions round the Weyl points WP1 nd WP. trum of H(). Weyl semimetls nd Weyl metls re chrcteried by the presence of nondegenerte bnd-touching points (Weyl points) which pper s seprted pirs in momentum spce. 18, 19) In terms of the erry curvture, Weyl points re synthetic mgnetic monopoles, nd thus contribute to the nomlous Hll conductivity. Here we focus on the Weyl points ppering between fourth bnd nd fifth bnd in F, where the nomlous Hll conductivityσ x tes mximum vlue round E/t = in Fig.. The model Hmiltonin H() with prmeters shown bove hs 1 Weyl points between fourth nd fifth bnds in the first rillouin one s shown in Fig. (). Figure shows the erry curvture ) of the fourth bnd in the vicinity of the Weyl point WP noted in Fig. (). y exmining whether the erry flux is inwrd or outwrd, the chirlity of the Weyl points cn be ssigned by the sign±in Fig. (). Figures -(h) show energy spectr ner the Weyl points. We now present qulittive rgument showing the reltion between the directions of the orbitl mgnetition, nomlous Hll conductivity tensor, nd the positions of the Weyl points. In Weyl semimetl the low-energy excittions re 18, 19) described by the Weyl Hmiltonin y x H (α)± Weyl ()=± v Fσ ( Q (α) ± ). (11) Here we consider the cse where the energy dispersion is isotropic for simplicity. The Weyl points pper s pirs with opposite chirlities: the sign in the right hnd side of eq. (11). Q (α) + is the position of the Weyl point ofαth pir with the positive chirlity, nd Q (α) is tht with the negtive chirlity. The seprtion of the Weyl points Q (α) = Q (α) + Q (α) cn be relied when time-reversl nd/or inversion symmetries re broen. When time-reversl symmetry is broen, the nomlous Hll effect occurs. In n idel Weyl semimetl where ll Weyl points pper t the sme energy, syµ=, the nomlous Hll conductivity is given by the sum of contributions from pirs of Weyl points seprted by Q (α), σ Weyl =ǫ e πh α Q (α), (1) tµ=. 18, 19) In terms of decomposition of the nomlous Hll conductivity eq. (9),σ (I) = becuse there is no finite Fermi surfce tµ=, vnishing the density of sttes. On the other hnd, eq. (1) connects the Hll conductivity nd the orbitl mgnetition, leding the reltion ) M orbit = eµ Q (α) (1) πh t the Fermi levelµ. In our model the bnd dispersions re bent s shown in Fig. so tht hole pocets pper when the Fermi level resides t the Weyl point. The nomlous Hll conductivity nd the orbitl mgnetitions re not s simple s eqs. (1) nd (1). Nevertheless, qulittive behviors such s the reltion between the directions of the orbitl mgnetition, the nomlous Hll conductivity tensors, nd the configurtions of the Weyl points re the sme s those. Indeed, the position of the Weyl points shown in Fig. () re 1 (±.51,±.898,±.11) nd 1 (±1.98,±.,±.55), nd the sum of the reltive displcements of ll pirs, α Q (α) = 1 (, 8.71, ), point the y direction. Thus, eq. (1) indictes thtσ x ndσ xy = σ y =, nd eq. (1) indictes tht M y nd M x = M =, consistent to the results shown in Figs. nd. The estimted = 1.9 [e /h] nd M y / µ= 1.9 [e/h], from eq. (1) nd eq.(1) respectively, re in resonble greement with the nomlous Hll conductivityσ x = 1.1 [e /h] nd M y / µ= 1.1 [e/h] t E= 1.9t in the lttice model shown in Figs. nd. onclusion In this wor we studied the nomlous Hll effect nd the spontneous orbitl mgnetition in chirl ntiferromgnets. We showed tht the single-bnd tight-binding Hmiltonin indictes n orbitl ferromgnetic order with the esy-plne nisotropy. The symmetry reltion between the nomlous Hll conductivity nd the locl spin configurtion is chrcteried by the Weyl points nd is consistent with experiments. While we were finliing the pper, preprint Ref. ppered. While we focus on itinernt electrons on Mn toms, Ref. focuses on Z toms in Mn Z where Z=Sn or Ge. This wor ws supported by JSPS KKENHI Grnts No. JP15H585 nd No. JP8. vlueσ Weyl x 1) N. Ngos, J. Sinov, S. Onod,. McDonld, nd N. Ong, nomlous Hll effect, Rev. Mod. Phys. 8, 159 (1). α

5 J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. Letter uthor Nme 5 ) D. Xio, M.-. hng, nd Q. Niu, erry phse effects on electronic properties, Rev. Mod. Phys. 8, 1959 (1). ) W. H. Kleiner, Spce-Time Symmetry of Trnsport oefficients, Phys. Rev. 1, 18 (19). ) F. E. Mrnn, ontributions to the Theory of the nomlous Hll Effect in Ferro- nd ntiferromgnetic Mterils, Phys. Rev. 1, 1 (197). 5) R. Shindou nd N. Ngos, Orbitl Ferromgnetism nd nomlous Hll Effect in ntiferromgnets on the Distorted fcc Lttice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 1181 (1). ) P. Mndl nd P. houdhury, Hll effect in the metllic ntiferromgnet N x oo (.7 x.9), Phys. Rev. 8, 9 (1). 7) H. hen, Q. Niu, nd. H. McDonld, nomlous Hll effect rising from noncolliner ntiferromgnetism. Phys. Rev. Lett. 11, 175 (1). 8) J. Kübler,. Felser, Non-colliner ntiferromgnets nd the nomlous Hll effect. Europhys. Lett. 18, 71 (1). 9). Seine nd K. Nomur, hirl Mgnetic Effect nd nomlous Hll Effect in ntiferromgnetic Insultors with Spin-Orbit oupling, Phys. Rev. Lett. 11, 91 (1). 1) Ho Yng, Yn Sun, Yng Zhng, Wu-Jun Shi, Sturt S. P. Prin, inghi Yn, Topologicl Weyl semimetls in the chirl ntiferromgnetic mterils Mn Ge nd Mn Sn. New J. Phys. 19 (17) ) M.-T. Suui, T. Koretsune, M. Ochi, nd R. rit, luster multipole theory for nomlous Hll effect in ntiferromgnets. rxiv:111. (1). 1) S. Ntsuji, N. Kiyohr, T. Higo, Lrge nomlous Hll effect in non-colliner ntiferromgnet t room temperture. Nture 57, 1 (15). 1). K. Ny, J. E. Fischer, Y. Sun,. Yn, J. Krel,.. Komre,. Shehr, N. Kumr, W. Schenelle, J. Kübler, S. S. P. Prin,. Felser, Lrge nomlous Hll effect driven by nonvnishing erry curvture in the noncoliner ntiferromgnet MnGe. Sci. dv., e15187 (15). 1) N. Kiyohr, T. Tomit, S. Ntsuji, Gint nomlous Hll effect in the chirl ntiferromgnet MnGe. Phys. Rev. pplied 5, 9 (1). 15) Xiong Li, Lingci Xu, Lincho Ding, Jinhu Wng, Mingsong Shen, Xiufng Lu, Zengwei Zhu, Kmrn ehni, nomlous Nernst nd Righi-Leduc effects in MnSn: erry curvture nd entropy flow. rxiv:11.18 (1). 1) D. eresoli, T. Thonhuser, D. Vnderbilt, nd R. Rest, Orbitl mgnetition in crystlline solids: Multi-bnd insultors, hern insultors, nd metls, Phys. Rev. 7, 8 (). 17) P. Strěd, Quntised Hll effect in two-dimensionl periodic potentil, J. Phys. : Solid Stte Phys. 15, 717 (198). 18) X. Wn,. M. Turner,. Vishwnth, nd S. Y. Svrsov, Topologicl semimetl nd Fermi-rc surfce sttes in the electronic structure of pyrochlore iridtes, Phys. Rev. 8, 511 (11). 19).. urov nd L. lents, Weyl Semimetl in Topologicl Insultor Multilyer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 17, 175 (11). ) In ferromgnetic Weyl semimetl, the vectors Q (α) re relted to the locl mgnetition vi the exchnge interction, or to n externl mgnetic field vi the Zeemn interction. The corresponding reltion to eq. (1) ws studied in Refs. 1, nd 1) K. Nomur nd D. Kurebyshi, hrge-induced Spin Torque in nomlous Hll Ferromgnets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 171 (15). ) M. Koshino nd I. F. Hibullh, Mgnetic susceptibility in threedimensionl nodl semimetls, Phys. Rev. 9, 51 (1). ) D. Kurebyshi nd K. Nomur, Microscopic theory of electriclly induced spin torques in mgnetic Weyl semimetls, rxiv: ) J. Liu nd L. lents, nomlous Hll effect nd topologicl defects in ntiferromgnetic Weyl semimetls: Mn Sn/Ge, rxiv: