arxiv: v2 [hep-th] 22 Nov 2018

Transcription

1 Stringy black-hole ga in α -corrected dilaton gravity Jerome Quintin, 1, Robert H. Brandenberger, 1, Maurizio Gaperini, 2, 3, 4, 5, and Gabriele Veneziano 1 Department of Phyic, McGill Univerity, Montréal, Québec H3A 2T8, Canada 2 Dipartimento di Fiica, Univerità di Bari, Via G. Amendola 173, Bari, Italy 3 Itituto Nazionale di Fiica Nucleare, Sezione di Bari, Via E. Orabona 4, Bari, Italy 4 Collège de France, 11 place M. Berthelot, Pari, France 5 Theory Department, CERN, CH-1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland arxiv: v2 [hep-th] 22 Nov 2018 We dicu the propertie of the ga of primordial tringy black hole poibly formed in the highcurvature phae preceding the bouncing tranition to the phae of tandard comological evolution. We how that the regime dominated by uch a tring-hole ga can be conitently decribed by explicit olution of the tring effective action including firt-order α correction. We preent a phae pace analyi of the tability of uch olution comparing the reult obtained from different action and including the poibility of O(d, d-ymmetric configuration. I. INTRODUCTION Since the rie of tring theory a an effort to unify quantum field theory and general relativity, there ha been a number of attempt to contruct very early Univere comological cenario embedded in tring theory. Notable tring comologie include tring ga comology [1, 2], pre-big Bang comology [3 7] (ee alo the review [8], and Ekpyrotic comology [9, 10]. There ha alo been a lot of effort put into trying to build a tringy realization of inflationary comology (ee, e.g., Ref. [11 13], though with limited ucce, given the difficulty of finding (quai-de Sitter olution in the tring landcape (ee, e.g., Ref. [14, 15] and alo [16] and [17]. Overall, current tring comologie have led to intereting prediction, but the theorie often remain incomplete, or conceptual iue perit. Neverthele, tudying tring comology might be one of the bet approache to tet the validity of tring theory. A common feature of many tring comologie i that they do not tart with an initial Big Bang ingularity. In tring ga comology and pre-big Bang comology, it i the T-duality of tring theory that protect the model from reaching a ingularity. T-duality roughly tate that a mall value of the radiu of the Univere (R i equivalent to a large value of the radiu. More preciely, the ymmetry goe a R α /R, where α l 2 i the tring theory dimenionful parameter related to the fundamental tring length l. Thu, one expect R l to define a minimal length cale at which point the Univere experience a curvature bounce, i.e., a tranition from growing to decreaing pacetime curvature. Detail of how thi i realized dynamically remain a challenge, but there ha been recent progre in the context of tring ga comology [18]. In pre-big Bang comology, the duality i called the cale factor duality [19 21], and the ymmetry goe a jquintin@phyic.mcgill.ca; Vanier Canada Graduate Scholar rhb@hep.phyic.mcgill.ca gaperini@ba.infn.it Gabriele.Veneziano@cern.ch a 1/a, where a i the cale factor. Again, reolving the ingularity dynamically in thi context i nontrivial but can be realized, for intance, with a nonlocal potential [3, 22], with quantum loop correction [23 25], or with limiting curvature [26] (ee alo the review [6, 27, 28], though the latter might be untable to comological perturbation [29]. A key difference between the T-duality of tring ga comology and the cale factor duality of pre- Big Bang comology i that the former require pace to be initially compact, while the latter doe not need compactification a the Univere can be infinitely large. The approach of thi paper i to conider a generic univere before the Big Bang, o generally a contracting univere in the Eintein frame. The goal i to decribe the tate of matter and the correponding comological evolution at very high denitie, when the energy cale i of the order of the tring ma, M l 1, from the point of view of tring theory. A the univere contract, one expect matter that atifie the uual energy condition of general relativity to clump and become inhomogeneou. In fact, the overdenitie can be uch that matter undergoe collape and form black hole. More preciely, it wa hown in Ref. [30] (ee alo Ref. [31] with the theory of comological perturbation that in a contracting univere hydrodynamical matter with mall ound peed uffer from the Jean intability and collape into Hubble-ize black hole well before a bounce i reached. Thi intability in a generic contracting univere wa firt tudied in Ref. [32], an analyi that wa extended by Ref. [33] to argue that the final tate of a contracting univere i a dene ga of black hole with a tiff equation of tate (in which the preure equate the energy denity. In the context of tring theory, it wa hown in Ref. [34] that the pat-trivial tring vacuum of the tree-level low-energy effective gravidilaton action i alo generically prone to gravitational intability, leading to the formation of black hole. All thee tudie thu indicate that the tate of a contracting univere at high denitie i compoed of many black hole. When the univere reache the tring cale, the black hole are then expected to become more tringy in nature. In fact, the tate of a black-hole ga i argued in

2 2 Ref. [35] to become a tring-hole ga. String hole repreent marginal black hole with ma equal to M g 2 (ee Ref. [36, 37] a well a [35, 38, 39], where g i the tring coupling. Thi repreent a correpondence curve along which the phyical propertie of black hole and tring match pectacularly well (ee, e.g., Ref. [38, 40]. In particular, the Schwarzchild radiu and Hawking temperature of a tring hole are given by the tring length and ma, repectively. Therefore, tring hole naturally decribe the tate of collaped matter at the tring cale. Correpondingly, a tring-hole ga i the logical outcome of a contracting univere in the Eintein frame at high curvature. The challenge that i tackled in thi paper i to find a tring-motivated action that can decribe the dynamic of a tring-hole ga in agreement with it propertie. In the tring frame, Ref. [35] argued that a tringhole ga hould have vanihing preure and be decribed by a contant Hubble parameter and contant dilaton velocity, though it wa not hown explicitly how thee propertie can arie from a tring theory action. The outline of thi paper i a follow. We firt review in Sec. II A the concept of tring hole and carefully derive in Sec. II B the propertie of a tring-hole ga, both in the Eintein frame and tring frame. We then how in Sec. III A that with tree-level dilaton gravity a a low-energy effective action of tring theory dynamic that matche the propertie of a tring-hole ga i only obtained in finely tuned ituation. It i only when α correction are included that we find more appropriate olution. We tudy two different firt-order α -corrected action. Firt, we extend the work of Ref. [4] in Sec. III B to include the contribution from matter in the dynamical equation. Second, in Sec. III C, we tudy the O(d, d- invariant action of Ref. [41]. In Sec. IV, we perform a phae pace analyi to judge the tability of the tringhole ga olution for both α -corrected action, and we comment on the overall evolutionary cheme. In particular, we addre the iue of connectivity to the tring perturbative vacuum. We ummarize the main concluion in Sec. V. The ection i alo devoted to a dicuion about the poible ubequent fate of a tring-hole ga and it role in leading to a noningular bouncing comology, and we mention future reearch direction. Throughout thi paper, we work with = c = k B = 1, and the reduced Planck ma and length are defined, repectively, by M 2 D Pl 8πG and l Pl M 1 Pl, where G (alo denoted G D i Newton gravitational contant in D = d + 1 pacetime dimenion. The number of patial dimenion i denoted by d, and we aume that it i an integer greater than or equal to 3 throughout. a radiu given by the tring length, i.e. M SH = M BH R D 3 BH /G and R SH = R BH = l, o M SH l D 3 /G. (For a review of D-dimenional black hole, ee, e.g., Ref. [42]. Introducing the tring ma given by the invere of the tring length, M = l 1, the tring coupling g, and the dilaton φ, we recall the following relation that hold in the weak-coupling regime of the cloed tring ector (ee, e.g., Ref. [27]: ( D 2 ( D 2 lpl M = = g 2 = e φ 1. (1 l M Pl From thi relation, one can ay that a tring hole lie along the correpondence curve [35 39] M SH M g 2. (2 It follow that the propertie of tring and black hole match impreively well along thi correpondence curve [38, 40]. For intance, the black hole Bekentein- Hawking temperature, T BH = D 3 4πR BH, (3 and the tring Hagedorn temperature (ee, e.g., Ref. [43] or [44] for an introduction, T Hag = 1 4π α, (4 both cale a l 1 for tring hole, where 2πα = l 2. Similarly, the black hole Bekentein-Hawking entropy for a tring hole, S BH = Ω D 2R D 2 BH 4G ld 2 l D 2 g 2, (5 Pl where Ω D 2 i the area of a unit (D 2-phere, i of the ame order a the entropy of a tring, S tr = 4π α E l M SH g 2, (6 where we make ue of Eq. (2 in the lat proportionality for a tring hole. From the above correpondence, it i natural to expect a black hole that reache the ize of a fundamental tring to become a tring hole. Furthermore, if a contracting univere i populated with a dene ga of black hole, then the appropriate decription of the ga at the tring cale mut be a tring-hole ga. Hence, the main ubject of thi paper i the tudy of a tring-hole ga a the tate of matter at the tring cale at the end of an Einteinframe contracting comology. The main thermodynamic propertie of a tring-hole ga are derived in the next ubection. II. STRING HOLES B. String-hole ga A. Black hole/tring correpondence One define a tring hole (SH a an object that ha the ma of a Schwarzchild black hole (BH confined within Let u conider a ga compoed of N tring hole. Conidering a dene ga, the tring hole have negligible momentum, and the energy of one tring hole can be expreed a E SH = M SH l 1 g 2 = l 1 e φ by ue of

3 3 Eq. (1 and (2. The ga with N tring hole thu ha total energy E ga E = NE SH Nl 1 e φ. (7 In the ame way, the entropy of one tring hole i S SH = e φ, o for a ga of N tring hole, one find g 2 S ga S = NS SH Ne φ. (8 Let the phyical volume of the ga be given by V ga V = fnv SH, where one tring hole ha volume V SH l D 1 and where f i a function that quantifie the eparation of the tring hole (e.g., f = 1 for a denely packed tring-hole ga, while f 1 for a dilute ga. Here, we conider a dene ga, o we take f to be of order unity and nearly contant. Thu, N V l 1 D, and the energy and entropy of the tring-hole ga are, repectively, given by and E V l D e φ V l 2 G 1 (9 S V l 1 D e φ V l 1 G 1, (10 where one ue Eq. (1 to expre e φ Gl 2 D. Accordingly, the energy and entropy denitie are given by repectively. ρ E V l D e φ l 2 G 1, (11 S V l1 D e φ l 1 G 1, (12 1. Eintein-frame propertie At thi point, there are everal way in which one can relate the energy and entropy together. Let u conider the Eintein frame in which the fundamental contant i Newton contant, i.e., G = contant, while the tring length can vary a a function of time. From thi point of view, one can eliminate l from Eq. (9 and (10 and relate the energy and entropy through the expreion EV S G, (13 or equivalently, from Eq. (11 and (12, the denitie are related by ρ/g. We note that thee equation correpond to the entropy and entropy denity equation of a black-hole ga (ee Ref. [45 47] a well a [33, 48]. Thi make ene; when viewed in the Eintein frame, the tring-hole ga i dominated by it gravitational nature, i.e., the tring behave more like black hole, at leat thermodynamically. We note that the entropy equation (13 ha been hown [45] to be the only formula that i manifetly invariant under the S- and T-dualitie of tring theory, at the ame time a approaching the tandard Bekentein-Hawking black-hole entropy at mall denitie. Thi entropy expreion alo appear in different high-energy phyic context (ee Ref. [45 47] and reference therein. Uing the thermodynamic identity T 1 = ( S/ E V, keeping G contant ince we are in the Eintein frame, and uing Eq. (11, one find T EG V = ρg l 1, (14 and one note that the temperature i proportional to the Hagedorn temperature (4. Furthermore, uing the identity p = T ( S/ V E for the preure, and uing Eq. (14 for the temperature, one find the equation of tate (EOS p = ρ. (15 Thi matche the EOS of a black-hole ga (ee Ref. [45 47] a well a [33, 48]. Similarly, if one conider a Friedmann-Lemaître- Roberton-Walker (FLRW univere with cale factor a and if one require the entropy in a comoving volume V a d to be contant, then it follow from Eq. (13 that E V 1 a d and furthermore ρ a 2d. (16 Conequently, from Eq. (11, thi implie a l 1/d e φ d(d 1, (17 where one ue again the fact that G i a contant in the Eintein frame. Therefore, if one conider a tringhole ga in a contracting univere, then the cale factor, the tring length, and the ize of the tring hole become maller a time progree, while the tring coupling, the dilaton, the energy denity, and the (Hagedorn temperature grow. 2. String-frame propertie Let u conider an alternative point of view: the tring frame in which the fundamental contant i the tring length, i.e., l = contant, while the gravitational contant can vary a a function of time. From thi point of view, one can eliminate G from Eq. (9 and (10 and relate the energy and entropy through the expreion S l E, (18 and equivalently, it follow that l ρ. From T 1 = ( S/ E V and keeping the tring length contant, it i traightforward to ee that T l 1 T Hag, (19

4 4 which i a contant temperature. Furthermore, from p = T ( S/ V E, it follow that p = 0. (20 Thi confirm the reult of Ref. [35] and again matche what one could have gueed: in the tring frame, the tring-hole ga i dominated by it tringy nature, and thi i why the EOS i that of a tring ga with equal contribution from momentum and winding mode (ee, e.g., Ref. [27]. Alo, the expreion (18 matche the leading-order behavior of the entropy of a tring ga (ee, e.g., Ref. [1, 49]. Similarly, if one require adiabaticity (S = contant in a contant comoving volume in FLRW, then it follow that the energy mut be contant; hence, ρ a d. (21 From the tandard conervation equation (more on thi in the next ection, thi i in agreement with an EOS p = 0. With Eq. (11, thi implie a G 1/d e φ/d, (22 where one ue again the fact that l i a contant in the tring frame. Taking the time derivative of the above, thi further implie H = φ d, (23 where H ȧ/a i the Hubble parameter and a dot denote a derivative with repect to the (tring-frame comic time t. To be conitent with the fact that the ize of the tring hole i contant in the tring frame (R SH = l = contant, there are two poible comological evolutionary path conitent with the contraint (23. Firt, it could be that the univere i tatic in the tring frame (H = 0, imilar to the (quaitatic Hagedorn phae of tring ga comology [1] (ee alo Ref. [2, 50] for review that highlight the challenge in that context. Second, it could be that the radiu of the tring hole i of the order of the Hubble radiu (R SH H 1 with the tringframe Hubble parameter being contant (H l 1. In that cae, a dene tring-hole ga coincide with having one tring hole per Hubble volume. Thi lat avenue wa conjectured in Ref. [35] to correpond to the tring phae in pre-big Bang comology, and thi i what we explore in the ret of thi paper. We note that a dilute ga could alo be poible with le than one tring hole per Hubble volume in average, but naively, in thi ituation, curvature would continue to grow until the ga become dene. Converely, an overdene ga with more than one tring hole per Hubble volume i mot likely forbidden by entropy conideration. Indeed, a tring-hole ga a defined above exactly aturate the appropriate entropy bound [51 55] (ee Ref. [6, 35] and additional reference therein. Thi i alo confirmed in the Eintein frame in which aturation occur when the EOS i p = ρ [45, 48], and thi i the only afe outcome with repect to entropy bound in a contracting FLRW comology (ee, e.g., Ref. [35, 53] but alo [46]. Thee entropic conideration alo reinforce a tring-hole ga to be the tate of matter at high denitie. In ummary, auming expanion in the tring frame, the evolution of a tring-hole ga correpond to a contant Hubble parameter equal to the tring ma, while the dilaton grow linearly with tring-frame time according to the contraint (23. We note that expanion in the tring frame i conitent with contraction in the Eintein frame; thi i hown explicitly in Appendix A. The goal i then to find a tring-theoretic effective action that can upport the evolution of a tring-hole ga, i.e., an action of which the equation of motion (EOM have a phae of tring-hole ga evolution a a olution. III. DYNAMICS FROM DILATON GRAVITY A. Tree-level dilaton gravity We firt tudy the tring-frame, tree-level, low-energy effective tring theory action (ee, e.g., Ref. [6, 27] S 0 = 1 2l d 1 d d+1 x g e φ( R + g µν µ φ ν φ + 2l d 1 U(φ, (24 where g det(g µ ν i the determinant of the metric tenor, U(φ i the potential energy of the dilaton field, and R denote the Ricci calar in thi ection. Since we focu on the gravidilaton ector of the effective tring theory action, we et to zero the potential contribution from the antiymmetric field trength coming from the Neveu- Schwarz/Neveu-Schwarz 2-form. The above action repreent the effective action for vacuum tring theory, but we want to conider the addition of matter; hence, we take the total action to be S = S 0 + S m, where S m repreent the matter action. The energy-momentum tenor aociated with S m i defined a uual by T µν 2 g 1/2 δs m /δg µν. The matter action may alo depend on the dilaton, o σ 2 g δs m δφ (25 define the dilaton (calar charge denity. Varying the action (24 in a homogeneou, iotropic, and flat FLRW pacetime, g µν dx µ dx ν = dt 2 a(t 2 δ ij dx i dx j, (26 a et of dilaton-gravity background EOM in the tring frame can be written a (ee, e.g., Ref. [6, 27]

5 5 d(d 1H 2 + φ 2 2dH φ = 2l d 1 ( e φ ρ + U(φ, (27 Ḣ H φ ( ( + dh 2 = l d 1 e φ p σ U,φ, ( φ φ 2 + 2dH φ ( 2dḢ d(d + 1H2 = 2l d 1 e φ σ 2 U(φ + U,φ, (29 where one aume that the energy-momentum tenor can be decompoed a a perfect fluid 1 with T µ ν = diag(ρ, pδ i j. Combining Eq. (27 (29, one can derive the fluid conervation equation, which goe a ρ + dh(ρ + p = 1 2 σ φ. (30 General power-law olution to thee equation are well known (ee, e.g., Ref. [3, 6, 27, 28] but motly for vanihing potential, vanihing dilaton charge, and an EOS of the form p = wρ. We want to conider a tring-hole ga, in which thee aumption may not all be met. From Eq. (11 and (21, a tring-hole ga in the tring frame ha energy denity ρ = Cl d 1 e φ = ρ 0 a d, (31 where C i a dimenionle poitive contant and ρ 0 i a poitive contant with dimenion of energy denity. A een in the previou ection, thi implie the contraint equation H = φ/d. Subtituting thi contraint and Eq. (31 into the conervation equation (30, one find σ = 2p, (32 independent of the EOS (only auming H 0. Therefore, one notice that if the dilaton charge denity vanihe, the preure i zero, which i the naive EOS for a tring-hole ga in the tring frame a hown in the previou ection. Converely, if we expect the preure to vanih from thermodynamic argument, then thi tell u that the tring-hole ga matter action hould have no explicit φ dependence, o the dilaton charge denity vanihe. Inerting the contraint H = φ/d = contant (which implie φ = Ḣ = 0 and Eq. (32 into Eq. (28 immediately yield U,φ = 0. Therefore, a fixed-point olution atifying the contraint H = φ/d = contant i only poible with a contant potential independent of the dilaton. Then, Eq. (27 and (29 further reduce to d 2 H2 = Cl 2 d 2 H2 = wcl 2 + l d 1 U, (33 l d 1 U, (34 where we et the EOS to be of the form p = wρ. For the above equation to yield a real olution for H, the only poibility i to have a contant negative potential, U = 1 l d 1 ( d 2 H2 + C l 2, (35 where the poitive contant H hould be of the order of l 1 to yield the olution H = H l 1. Thi i equivalent to introducing a fine-tuned negative comological contant, Λ O(l D, in the tring frame 2. Any other form of the potential U(φ generically cannot upport a tring-hole ga evolution with H = φ/d = contant. Furthermore, the potential (35, which yield the olution H, i only conitent with Eq. (33 (34 provided the EOS i alo tuned to be w = 1 dl2 H 2 C, (36 which violate the null energy condition. In ummary, thi avenue doe not eem particularly appealing, conidering it would require tuning an ad hoc negative comological contant and the EOS to a phyically unexpected value. Thi concluion generalize to nonlocal potential of the form U( φ, where φ = φ ln a d (37 i the hifted dilaton. Indeed, we note that φ = φ dh = 0 for a tring-hole ga atifying the contraint H = φ/d. Thu, regardle of the modification to the EOM for a nonlocal potential (ee, e.g., Ref. [6, 27, 28] for the exact modified EOM, φ ha to remain contant during a tring-hole ga evolution, o any potential U( φ would imply be a contant, i.e., a comological contant. In ummary, it appear that one cannot upport the evolution of a tring-hole ga with tree-level dilaton gravity, no matter the form of the potential (unle it i a fine-tuned negative comological contant. Therefore, one hould explore the poibility of higher-order correction. 1 We comment on the poible preence of vicoity a a deviation from a perfect fluid decription later in thi ection. 2 We note, however, that uch a negative contant value of U may naturally appear in the tree-level tring effective action, but thi would require a noncritical number of dimenion (ee, e.g., Ref. [27].

6 6 B. Action with α correction The low-energy effective action S 0 introduced in the previou ubection i only compatible with the conformal invariance of quantized tring on a curved background to zeroth order in α l 2. When going to firt order, conformal invariance allow new higher-derivative term uch that the effective action contain term that cale a the quare of the pacetime curvature and o on. A long a curvature i mall, e.g., l 2 R 1, then the perturbative expanion i dominated by the zeroth-order action. However, when the curvature reache the tring cale, which i the cae when H l 1, then higher-order term are neceary. In fact, when the perturbative expanion break down on ubtring cale, working with an effective action i no longer viable, and one would have to work with a proper conformal field theory that could account for α correction nonperturbatively (ee, e.g., Ref. [56]. Thi approach, however, i beyond the cope of thi tudy, and in what follow, we aume that a firt-order α -corrected effective action i a ufficient approximation when H l 1. Demanding general covariance and gauge invariance of the tring effective action, one can write down many perfectly valid action that are compatible with the condition of conformal invariance to firt order in α. Thoe action are related by imple field redefinition of the metric and dilaton; hence, it i ambiguou which action to chooe (ee, e.g., Ref. [6, 27] and reference therein. For intance, the implet conitent action to firt order in α i S = S 0 + S α with S α = kα 8l d 1 d d+1 x g e φ R µνκλ R µνκλ, (38 where R µνκλ i the Riemann tenor and either k = 1 for boonic tring or k = 1/2 for heterotic upertring. However, working with the above action (i.e. with the quare of the Riemann tenor in a comological context i rather cumberome, becaue the field equation contain, in general, higher than econd derivative of the metric tenor. Such a formal complication can be avoided, however, by performing an appropriate field redefinition [4] and conidering the action with S α = kα 8l d 1 d d+1 x g e φ ( G ( µ φ µ φ 2, (39 where G R µνκλ R µνκλ 4R µν R µν + R 2 i the Gau- Bonnet invariant, R µν g κλ R κµλν i the Ricci tenor, and R g µν R µν i the Ricci calar. Thi wa firt conidered by Gaperini, Maggiore & Veneziano [4] (GMV hereafter; alo tudied in Ref. [23, 24, 57] and dicued in [6, 27]. Therefore, for a firt attempt, we examine the action S = S 0 +S α +S m with S α given by Eq. (39, and for the ret of thi paper, we aume that the dilaton ha no potential; i.e., we et U(φ = 0 in S 0. GMV already howed that thi action admit no homogeneou and iotropic fixed-point olution with φ = 0, i.e. with H = φ/d = contant for a tring-hole ga. However, GMV only conidered the vacuum action with no matter, i.e. S = S 0 + S α. To find dynamic for the tring-hole ga, one mut include the matter action S m a before. The EOM that follow from varying the correponding action in a FLRW background are ρ = 1 ( 2 l1 d e φ φ 2 + d(d 1H 2 2dH φ 3kα 4 F ρ(h, φ ( σ = l 1 d e φ 2 φ + 2dḢ + φ 2 + d(d + 1H 2 2dH φ + kα 4 F σ(h, φ, Ḣ, φ p = 1 ( 2d l1 d e φ 2d(d 1Ḣ + 2d φ d 2 (d 1H 2 + 2d(d 1H φ d φ 2 + kα 4 F p(h, φ, Ḣ, φ,,, (40 where we define F ρ (H, φ c 1 H 4 + c 3 H 3 φ φ4, F σ (H, φ, Ḣ, φ 3c 3 ḢH 2 12 φ φ 2 + (c 1 + dc 3 H 4 4dH φ φ 4, F p (H, φ, Ḣ, φ 12c 1 ḢH 2 + 3c 3 φh 2 + 6c 3 ḢH φ + 3dc 1 H 4 2(2c 1 dc 3 H 3 φ 3c3 H 2 φ2 + d φ 4, (41 and c 1 d (d 1(d 2(d 3, 3 c 3 4d (d 1(d 2. (42 3 Thee equation generalize the EOM that were already derived, e.g., in Ref. [4, 6, 27], to include matter; the vacuum limit (ρ = p = σ = 0 reduce to the EOM in Ref. [4, 6, 27]. We note that the above three EOM are not all independent. Indeed, one can verify that the

7 7 continuity equation ρ + dh(ρ + p = 1 2 σ φ (43 relate the three EOM. We now eek to find olution to the above EOM that could decribe a tring-hole ga. To do o, one et ρ = Cl d 1 e φ, σ = 2p, and H = φ/d. Furthermore, we relate the preure and energy denity through an EOS of the form p = wρ. We expect the EOS to be p = 0 for a tring-hole ga in the tring frame from the thermodynamic argument of Sec. II B 2, o the EOS parameter w i et to zero later on. Neverthele, the more crucial property for a tring-hole ga i that p eff p σ/2 = 0; thu, we perform a lightly more general analyi in what follow with a generic EOS parameter w. One then look for fixed-point olution with y 1 H = contant, y 2 = contant, and φ = Ḣ = 0. The contraint H = φ/d implie y 2 = dy 1, and the three differential EOM reduce to three algebraic equation for y 1, ( dy kα y1 2 = 2Cl 2, 4 ( dy1 2 1 kα y1 2 = 2wCl 2, 4 d 2 y 2 1 ( 1 kα y = 2dwCl 2, (44 where we define 2d 2 + d 2. We note that i trictly poitive (in fact, 19 for d 3. The econd and third equation above are completely equivalent, which i due to the fact that the three EOM are not independent. Therefore, one only ha to olve the firt and econd equation for y 1. Requiring real olution for y 1, one can how that thee two equation yield the ame nontrivial olution, y 1 = H = ± 2 2π(1 w l k(1 3w, (45 if and only if w < 1/3 and C = 8πd(1 w k(1 3w 2, (46 where we ue 2πα = l 2 to implify the expreion. The olution for φ immediately follow by multiplying Eq. (45 by d. A couple of comment are in order. One firt note that H l 1 a expected. Second, one notice that the retriction w < 1/3 and Eq. (46 impoe C > 0, which mean that no real and conitent olution (except the trivial olution H = φ = 0 would have followed from etting C = 0. Thi reproduce what wa tated by GMV, i.e. that there exit no conitent nontrivial olution atifying the contraint φ = 0 (which i equivalent to H = φ/d = contant in vacuum. In ummary, the GMV α -corrected action that include a tring-hole ga matter action doe allow for conitent olution with the propertie of a tring-hole ga for any w < 1/3 and provided ρ ha the appropriate amplitude, with C given in Eq. (46. The unique phyical olution for the EOS p = 0 (w = 0 i then H = φ d = 2 2π l k, (47 taking the poitive olution for expanion in the tring frame. For intance, in d = 3 dimenion and for k = 1, the olution i H = 2l 1 2π/19. In the cae w = 0, the phyical olution i valid only if C = 8πd/(k, which might appear a a fine-tuning problem. However, we recall that C i only an arbitrary contant amplitude for the energy denity [c.f. Eq. (31], and it i certainly tunable depending on the total energy denity of the univere and the other matter content prior to the tring-hole ga phae. In um, the α -corrected action conidered in thi ubection ha background EOM that have a unique and natural olution [Eq. (47] correponding to a tring-hole ga evolution. C. O(d, d-invariant α -corrected action A we mentioned in the previou ubection, there are everal conitent α -corrected action related through field redefinition. In thi ubection, we conider a different choice for S α, pecifically S α = kα 8l d 1 d d+1 x g e φ( G ( µ φ µ φ 2 4G µν µ φ ν φ + 2( µ φ µ φ φ, (48 where G µν R µν Rg µν /2 i the Eintein tenor and g µν µ ν i the d Alembertian. Thi action hare the Gau-Bonnet and ( φ 4 term with the action (39, but the econd in line in Eq. (48 i new; neverthele, thi action i till free from higher derivative in the comological field equation. The action (39 and (48 are related by a field redefinition (ee Ref. [27]. Thi action wa firt introduced by Meiner [41] (ee alo Ref. [58] who howed that it i invariant under the O(d, d ymmetry to firt order in the α expanion. The O(d, d ymmetry play a key role in tring theory and even more in the context of pre-big Bang comology (ee Ref. [6, 27] and reference therein. Indeed, the comological cale factor duality a 1/a [19] i actually extendable to a continuou ymmetry, the tranformation group of which i O(d, d. It wa found that the action of the group tranform known olution to the effective comological tring theory into new olution [21, 59]. The ymmetry wa hown to be preent for the low-energy action to zeroth order in α with the preence of matter [60], but it wa alo argued to apply to all order in α

8 8 [19, 21]. The action that ha the ymmetry to firt order in α i the one found by Meiner [41], and it i the one introduced above that we conider below. Since S 0 i already invariant under O(d, d tranformation [6, 27, 60], it i natural to conider the α -corrected action (48 that bare the ame ymmetry. Let u comment on the nature of the ymmetry for a tring-hole ga. Conidering an iotropic and homogeneou comology for implicity, the EOM of the full action S = S 0 + S α + S m are O(d, d invariant under the tranformation a 1/a, φ φ, ρ ρ, p p, and σ σ, where the hifted dilaton i given by Eq. (37 and the other hifted variable are ρ = ρa d, p = pa d, and σ = σa d. Thu, for a tring-hole ga with p = σ/2 = 0, we expect ρ = Cl d 1 e φ = ρ 0, p = 0, and σ = 0, and readily, we notice the O(d, d invariance. Let u mention that in general, though, deviation from a perfect fluid decription could change thi concluion. Indeed, it wa hown in Ref. [60] that a particular nontrivial action of the O(d, d group can tranform a perfect fluid with a diagonal tre tenor into a fluid with nondiagonal element in it tre tenor. More preciely, a perfect fluid with EOS p = wρ tranform into a preurele fluid (o p 0 with hear vicoity given by η = wρ/(2h. However, for a tring-hole ga, the perfect fluid EOS i preciely expected to be that of a preurele fluid to tart with (w = 0, o the tranformation turn out to be trivial, and no hear vicoity appear. Therefore, a tring-hole ga with vanihing preure in the tring frame ha a valid and conitent perfect fluid decription from the point of view of O(d, d invariance of it action. If one allow w 0 to decribe a tring-hole ga (but till with p eff = p σ/2 = 0, then a more refined analyi hould drop the perfect fluid decription and include the poible effect of vicoity, a wa firt conidered in Ref. [46]. We keep the exploration of thi poibility for future work. Let u now derive the EOM. We conider the FLRW metric g µν dx µ dx ν = N(t 2 dt 2 e 2β(t δ ij dx i dx j, (49 where, in thi ubection, we introduce the lape function N(t [which we later et to N(t 1]. Alo, the cale factor i written a a(t = e β(t, o the Hubble parameter become H(t = β(t. Thi i only a matter of convenience to compute the EOM below. The action S = S 0 + S α thu reduce to the form S = (l /2 dt V t L(t, where V t l d Σ t d d x i the volume of the patial hyperurface of contant time Σ t (at time t in tring unit, and the Lagrangian denity i L(t = e dβ φ{ 1 [ 2d N β d(d + 1 β 2 + 2dF β + φ 2] [ kα 4N 3 3c 3 F β 3 + (d + 1d(d 1(d 2 β 4 + 3c 3 β β2 2d(d 1 φ 2 β2 + 2 φ φ 2 + 2d φ 3 β 2F φ3 φ 4]}, where F Ṅ/N. After integration by part, the action reduce to S = l dt V t e dβ φ{ 1 [ 2 N φ 2 d(d 1 β ] [ 2 + 2d β φ + kα 4N 3 c β4 1 + c 3 φ β3 2d(d 1 φ 2 β d φ 3 1 β 3 φ 4]}. (51 Let u add to the above action a matter action S m decribed by an energy denity ρ, preure p, and dilaton charge denity σ a before. Then, varying the total action with repect to N, φ, and β [and afterward etting N(t 1], one find three EOM, which are the ame a the et of equation (40, except the function F ρ, F σ, and F p that are replaced by F ρ (H, φ = c 1 H 4 + c 3 H 3 φ 2d(d 1H 2 φ dh φ φ 4, (52 F σ (H, φ, Ḣ, φ = 3c 3 ḢH 2 8d(d 1ḢH φ + 4dḢ φ 2 4d(d 1 φh 2 + 8d φh φ 4 φ φ 2 + (c 1 + dc 3 H 4 4d 2 (d 1H 3 φ + 2d(3d 1H 2 φ2 4dH φ 3 + φ 4, (53 F p (H, φ, Ḣ, φ = 12c 1 ḢH 2 + 6c 3 ḢH φ 4d(d 1Ḣ φ 2 + 3c 3 φh 2 8d(d 1 φh φ + 4d φ φ 2 + 3dc 1 H 4 2(2c 1 dc 3 H 3 φ (3c3 + 2d 2 (d 1H 2 φ2 + 4d(d 1H φ 3 d φ 4. (54 (50 Note that we reexpreed the Hubble parameter β with H. A in the previou ubection, we conider a tringhole ga with ρ = Cl d 1 e φ, σ = 2p, p = wρ, and H = φ/d. One look for fixed-point olution with y 1 H =

9 9 contant, y 2 φ = contant (o Ḣ = φ = 0, and y 2 = dy 1. The three EOM then reduce to two independent algebraic equation: dy1 (1 2 3(d 2kα y1 2 = 2C 4 l 2 ; (55 dy1 (1 2 (d 2kα y1 2 = 2wC 4 l 2. (56 Thoe two equation hare the ame nontrivial olution, y 1 = H = ± 2 2π(1 w l k(d 2(1 3w, (57 if and only if the amplitude parameter atifie C = 8πd 1 w k(d 2 (1 3w 2 (58 and a long a w < 1/3. Thee expreion are not the ame a Eq. (45 and (46, but they only differ by numerical factor that depend on the number of patial dimenion. Eentially, = 2d 2 + d 2 in Eq. (45 and (46 i replaced by d 2 in Eq. (57 and (58. The olution are certainly of the ame order, and a before (a expected, H l 1. The phyical olution with w = 0 reduce to H = φ d = 2 2π l k(d 2, (59 and it require C = 8πd/(k(d 2. A before, we argue that C i an arbitrary contant, o thi doe not repreent fine-tuning. Therefore, the O(d, d-invariant α - corrected action of thi ubection yield a unique and natural olution, which correpond to a tring-hole ga evolution but which i different from the olution of the previou ubection. The difference are due to the fact that the phyical effect of the higher-curvature correction are not invariant, in general, under field redefinition truncated to firt order in α. Such an ambiguity affect all model truncated to any given finite order of the α expanion and can be reolved, in principle, only by conidering exact conformal model, which automatically include the correction to all order. In the following ection, retricting our dicuion to the firt order in α, we perform a phae pace analyi of the two previou olution in order to find the mot appropriate one to decribe in thi approximation the main propertie of the tring-hole ga and of it dynamical evolution. IV. PHASE SPACE ANALYSIS At thi point, two ditinct olution that correpond to a tring-hole ga evolution given two different α - corrected action have been found: the olution (47 and (59 follow from GMV action and Meiner action, repectively. In the perpective of a greater evolutionary cheme, we now eek to determine the tability of thoe fixed point in the whole phae pace of comological olution. For intance, the nontrivial fixed point found by GMV [4] in vacuum were hown to be attractor in phae pace and moothly connected to the tring perturbative vacuum (i.e., to the aymptotic tate with vanihing tring coupling and flat pacetime, g 0 and H 0. Converely, the attractor fixed point from Meiner action in vacuum are diconnected from the low-energy trivial fixed point (ee Ref. [6, 27]. We analyze the phae pace with the addition of matter and in particular for a tring-hole ga in the ubequent ubection. A. Stability of the fixed point with GMV action Recall the GMV EOM given by Eq. (40. In general, for an EOS of the form p = wρ and auming that σ i alo proportional to ρ, one can ee that there are only three independent variable in configuration pace: H, φ, and e φ ρ. One can chooe to ue the Hamiltonian contraint [the firt equation of the et (40] to eliminate e φ ρ from the other two evolution equation. Thi amount to projecting the configuration pace onto a twodimenional vector pace, where the vector are of the form y A = (H, φ, A {1, 2}. One can thu reexpre the et (40 a two independent differential equation, written in vector form a ẏ A = (Ḣ, φ = C A, where C 1 and C 2 are function of H and φ only [i.e. C A = C A (y B ]. For example, when p = σ/2 = 0 (w = 0, their expreion are C 1 (H, φ = 1 D { 16H(dH φ [ + 2kl2 3c3 π 4 (d + 3H4 3c 3 2d H3 φ 2(d 1(2d 1H 2 φ2 + 2(2d 3H φ 3 + 3k2 l 4 4π 2 [ 3c d (d + 1H6 + 3c 1 H 4 φ2 + c 3 d (2d 3H3 φ3 9c 3 4d H2 φ4 + φ 4] φ 6]}, (60

10 C 2 (H, φ = 1 { [ 8 d(d 1H 2 D φ 2] [ + kl2 3c3 π 4 (d 7H4 + 3c 3 2d (2d 3H2 φ2 8(d 1 2 H φ 3 + (4d 3 φ 4] 3k2 l 4 c [ 3 16π 2 d H 3c 1 H 5 + 6c 1 H 4 φ + 3c3 H 3 φ2 + 4d(d 3H 2 φ3 3(4d 3H φ φ 5]}, (61 10 where D kl2 c 3 πd + 3k2 l 4 c 3 4π 2 d H ( (d + 3H 2 + 2H φ 3 d 2 φ 2 ( 3c3 4 H3 3(d 3H φ φ 3. (62 For w = 0, we recall that the tring-hole ga fixed point i given by Eq. (47, and here we denote it a and upon calculating the partial derivative and evaluating at the fixed point (H, φ, one find D u C 1 (H, φ = P1 2π l Q k(2d 4 + d 3 + d 2, D u C 2 (H, φ = P2 2π l Q k(1 + d 2, (69 where y A = (H, φ = 2 2π (1, d. (63 l k P 1 4d(d + 2(2d 1, P 2 8d 4 8d 3 18d d, (70 One can check that C 1 (H, φ = C 2 (H, φ = 0 (C A (y B = 0, o Ḣ = φ = 0 (ẏ A = 0 a expected. The Jacobian matrix for the ytem of differential equation i then J A B = A C B, (64 and it eigenvalue are r ± = 1 { [ ( H H C φc 2 ± C 1 + φ C2 2 4 ( H C 1 φc 2 φc 1 H C 2] 1/2 }. (65 After calculating the partial derivative and evaluating at the fixed point (H, φ, one find where r ± = ± 2 l 2πd kq, (66 Q 16d 5 32d 4 46d d d 20. (67 Since r + > 0 > r, it follow that the fixed point (H, φ i a addle point, and therefore, it i generally not table and certainly not an attractor in phae pace. If one worrie only about perturbation around the fixed point that preerve the condition H = φ/d, one may check the directional derivative of C A with repect to the unit vector parallel to the line correponding to H = φ/d. The unit vector i expreed a u A = (1 + d 2 1/2 (1, d. The expreion for the directional derivative i then D u C A u B B C A = HC A + d φc A 1 + d 2, (68 Noting that P A > 0 and Q > 0 for any d 3, it follow that D u C A (H, φ < 0, A = 1, 2, (71 and thu, the fixed point (H, φ i table in the direction correponding to the line H = φ/d. Thi implie that if one conider perturbation about the tring-hole ga addle point that repect the condition H = φ/d the tring-hole ga evolution i table. However, for general perturbation about the addle point, the trajectorie might flow away from the tring-hole ga evolution. Further inight can be gained numerically. For example, etting k = 1, l = 1, and d = 3, one find two real poitive nontrivial fixed point that atify C A (H, φ = 0: the tring-hole ga fixed point with y A = (2 2π/19, 6 2π/19 and another fixed point approximately located at (1.546, The phae pace trajectorie are plotted in Fig. 1. The tring-hole ga fixed point i depicted by the red dot, and viual inpection confirm that it i a addle point (ee the left plot of Fig. 1 for a cloe-up. The other fixed point, depicted by the black dot, i the attractor of tandard (vacuum pre-big Bang comology 3 (ee, e.g., Ref. [4, 6, 27]. We note that thi i exactly the fixed point found by GMV, and it appear in the phae pace no matter what the EOS parameter w i ince e φ ρ 0 at that point. The dahed gray curve in Fig. 1 depict the line φ = dh. When projecting the trajectorie onto that line, it i clear from the left plot that the flow i attracted toward 3 Our numerical value differ from thoe of Ref. [4, 6, 27] imply due to the choice of unit. We work with k = l = 1, while Ref. [4, 6, 27] et kα = 1, o baically the number differ by a factor of 2π.

11 φ φ H H 1.5 FIG. 1. Phae pace trajectorie for GMV action in a FLRW background with matter atifying the continuity equation and p = σ/2 = 0. Setting k = 1, ` = 1, and d = 3, H and φ are computed from Eq. (60 and (61, repectively. The red dot denote the tring-hole ga addle point (63, and the black dot denote the attractor fixed point of vacuum pre-big Bang comology. The dahed gray curve depict the line φ = dh, along which the addle point i table. The left and right plot how different range in H and φ. The left plot i a blowup of the right plot near the two nontrivial fixed point. In the right plot, the green line how an example of trajectory that tart near the trivial fixed point at H = φ = 0 and goe to the attractor fixed point. the tring-hole ga addle point in it vicinity. Thi i in agreement with the earlier (analytical reult that the tring-hole ga addle point i table in the direction of the contraint H = φ /d. In the right plot of Fig. 1, we how the phae pace including the trivial fixed point (H, φ = (0, 0 correponding to the tring perturbative vacuum, and the green curve how one trajectory paing infiniteimally cloe to that fixed point. We notice that it moothly reache the attractor fixed point (black dot, confirming the reult of GMV4 [4]. Thi alo implie, however, that it i not poible for a trajectory to tart near the tring perturbative vacuum and evolve toward the tring-hole ga fixed point moothly. In the context of pre-big Bang comology, the goal would be to tart at the tring perturbative vacuum and evolve toward a tring-hole ga a the high-energy tate of the univere before a bounce. Although GMV α0 -corrected action allow for a unique tring-hole ga olution, it doe not eem to be ufficient to decribe the 4 Thi time, we note that thi curve may not be exactly the olution found by GMV. However, it i cloe enough ince eφ ρ i ubdominant at all time along the green trajectory. In particular, it hare it qualitative behavior: the perturbative evolution tart in the region φ = φ dh > 0 (above the dahed gray line, croe the gray line (where φ = 0, and end at the attractor fixed point in the region φ < 0 (below the gray line. evolution of the univere thoroughly from the perturbative vacuum to the tringy tate at high energie. Thi i not urpriing becaue black-/tring-hole formation i not a continuou proce; rather, the hole collape intantaneouly from the vacuum fluctuation that have grown in amplitude. Therefore, aking for continuou trajectorie connecting the vacuum to the tring-hole ga fixed point i ill poed. Neverthele, there are argument to upport that a tring-hole ga hould be connected to the vacuum in ome way. In a broader comological context, one could imagine tarting aymptotically far in the pat in a contracting univere (in the Eintein frame which ha normal matter (e.g., a mix of dut [w = 0] and radiation [w = 1/d]. A hown in Ref. [30] (ee alo Ref. [31 33], tarting with vacuum initial condition, the preurele matter would collape into a black-hole ga, and a tated in the preent work, it would evolve into a tring-hole ga with EOS p = ρ. From that point of view, a tring-hole ga with EOS w = 1 i naturally an attractor5, and the 5 Matter with the EOS w = 1 i generally (marginally an attractor in a contracting univere, whether it i a black-/tring-hole ga, aniotropie, or a male calar field. We ue the word marginal ince any other component with EOS w > 1, e.g., an Ekpyrotic field with negative exponential potential, would overturn thi concluion and become the new attractor (ee, e.g., Ref. [61].

12 12 ame concluion would necearily follow in the tring frame, although the phyical intuition might be le obviou in the tring frame. In that context, one cannot decribe the entire comological evolution with the tringy action tudied in thi paper; they would be applicable only at the time of formation of the tring hole. In that cae, when the condition H = φ/d i met, a we howed above, the tring-hole ga evolution i an attractor in the tring frame. B. Stability of the fixed point with Meiner action We now perform the ame tability analyi a in the previou ubection, except tarting with the EOM derived in Sec. III C for Meiner action and etting p = σ/2 = 0. Here the fixed point i [recall Eq. (59] y A = (H, φ = 2 2π (1, d. (72 l k(d 2 A before, we put the et of differential equation in the form ẏ A = (Ḣ, φ = C A (H, φ and compute the eigenvalue of the correponding Jacobian matrix J B A = A C B evaluated at the fixed point y A. A a reult, we find that there i one poitive and one negative eigenvalue indicating that the fixed point i again a addle point. Thi i confirmed by viual inpection of Fig. 2 (ee the left plot for a cloe-up; Fig. 2 i generated the ame way a Fig. 1, in particular, etting k = 1, l = 1, and d = 3. Contrary to the addle point of the previou ubection, though, the addle point here turn out to be untable in the direction of the tring-hole ga contraint H = φ/d. Indeed, evaluating D u C A at y A yield two poitive value. Thi i confirmed by looking at the direction of the flow along the dahed gray line in the left plot of Fig. 2, which depict the line φ = dh; the trajectorie are moving away from the fixed point (in red. Additional fixed point are found by numerically olving C A (H, φ = 0, and they are hown by the yellow and black dot in Fig. 2. The black dot i an attractor and wa alo found in the context of vacuum pre-big Bang comology (ee Ref. [27]. However, in thi cae, one notice that the attractor fixed point i diconnected from the trivial fixed point at the origin (ee the right plot of Fig. 2, which confirm the reult of Ref. [27, 62]. Furthermore, we find that the tring-hole ga addle point i alo not connected to the tring perturbative vacuum a it wa the cae with GMV action. In fact, trajectorie that tart near the origin tend to grow rapidly in φ, while H remain mall, and go nowhere near the fixed point. In ummary, the tring-hole ga fixed point, which i a olution of Meiner action, hare everal characteritic with the olution of GMV action: both are addle point, diconnected from the tring perturbative vacuum. However, the trajectorie in the vicinity of the addle point behave very differently for both action. Indeed, the latter (GMV i table in the direction of the tring-hole ga contraint H = φ/d, but the former (Meiner i untable. Therefore, Meiner action appear very unlikely to be the phyical action that can decribe the evolution of a tring-hole ga and of the univere at high energie. Let u end by noting that, although the analyi outlined in thi ection focue on the cae w = 0, we found that the qualitative reult about the characterization and (intability of the fixed point are the ame for any value of w ( 1, 1/3. We do not include the quantitative detail for a generic value of w for the ake implicity and readability. V. CONCLUSIONS AND DISCUSSION In thi paper, we reviited the propoal that the tringy high-energy tate of the Univere i a tring-hole ga, i.e., a ga of black hole lying on the tring-/black-hole correpondence curve. By analyzing it thermodynamic propertie, we confirmed that a tring-hole ga ha the ame EOS and entropy equation in the Eintein frame a a black-hole ga with p = ρ and S EV/G. In the tring frame, we found that a tring-hole ga ha vanihing preure, and we derived the correponding evolution to be given by H = φ/d l 1. Our goal wa then to find uch a fixed point olution from the dynamical comological EOM of a tring theory motivated action. We tudied the gravidilaton ector of the low-energy effective action of tring theory and found that, to zeroth order in the α expanion, there i no tring-hole ga olution without adding a tuned negative comological contant. However, going to firt order in α, we tudied two different action, and both yielded a natural tring-hole ga olution. Stability of thoe fixed point olution wa aeed by performing a phae pace analyi. We found that both olution are addle point in (H, φ phae pace, but the olution coming from the action of GMV [4] tend to be better behaved ince it i table in the direction of the tring-hole ga contraint H = φ/d. The olution coming from the action of Meiner [41] i untable in the ame direction and thu le appealing, even though it poee the deired O(d, d ymmetry of tring comology to firt order in α. In ummary, our reult how that tring theory conitently upport a tring-hole ga phae of comological evolution, at leat at the level of a gravidilaton effective action and minimally to firt order in the α expanion. Our tability analyi alo indicate that a particular choice of action (GMV action i more appropriate at the level of our approximation. We would like to point out ome of the limitation of the current analyi. A mentioned before, the cale at which a tring-hole ga form and evolve i right at the limit of perturbative tring theory in term of the α expanion. Our analyi howed that one need an action that i valid at leat to firt order in α, but one could eek for a yet higher-order action (e.g., to econd order in

13 φ φ H H FIG. 2. Phae pace trajectorie for Meiner action in a FLRW background with matter atifying the continuity equation and p = σ/2 = 0 (and etting k = 1, ` = 1, and d = 3. The red dot denote the tring-hole ga addle point (72, the yellow dot denote the repeller fixed point, and the black dot denote the attractor (ee the text. The two plot how different range in H and φ. The left plot i a blowup of the right plot near the tring-hole ga fixed point. Alo in the left plot, the dahed gray curve depict the curve φ = dh, along which the addle point i untable thi time. α0 or an exact conformal model (valid to all order in α0 for a more robut implementation. Beforehand, it might be more traightforward to try to find a decription of a tring-hole ga uch that it correponding matter action ha firt-order α0 correction. Indeed, if firt-order α0 correction are included in the gravity ector, they may a well be firt-order α0 correction at the level of the matter action. For example, higher energy-momentum tenor correction in the matter ector have been conidered in Ref. [63] for Eintein gravity, but thi ha never been tudied in the context of a tring theory effective action or for any other theory beyond Eintein gravity. We note that uch a poibility might alo open the window to obtaining a noningular curvature bounce following the tring-hole ga phae. Another limitation come from the fact that the current analyi wa only performed within effective field theorie of tring theory and did not ue perhap the full trength of tring theory. A future work, one could try to contruct the proper matter action for tring hole from firt principle rather than uing a thermodynamic approach. At the level of general relativity, there ha been recent progre in decribing a black-hole lattice in comology (ee, in particular, Ref. [64] in a noningular bouncing comological background a well a, e.g., Ref. [65] and reference therein, which may be viewed a an approximation of a black-hole ga. Similar idea with the addition of appropriate tringy ingredient could be ued to develop a nonperturbative action for a tring-hole ga. Let u alo mention the fact that black hole in tring theory may not be bet decribed by the emiclaical picture ued in thi paper. The ingularity at the center of black hole may be reolved in full tring theory, and even the concept of a black-hole horizon may need to be revied. For intance, a tringy black hole might be better decribed by a fuzzball (ee, e.g., Ref. [66] and reference therein. In that context, a black-hole ga may be realized a a et of interecting brane tate [45], which i related to the concept of fractional brane ga (ee, e.g., Ref. [67] and reference therein. Within the context of a tring-hole ga a tudied in thi paper, we plan to extend the preent work to determine what i the comological evolution ubequent to the tring-hole ga phae and what the comological obervable prediction intrinic to the reulting very early Univere cenario are. Firt, the goal i to determine how a tring-hole ga phae can be connected to tandard Big Bang comology tarting with radiation-dominated expanion. A tring-hole ga phae i not expected to be table for an infinitely long period of time. The ga will ultimately (Hawking evaporate into radiation [35], a nonadiabatic proce of entropy production that can be viewed a quantum particle creation in curved pacetime. Given that the tring-hole ga i already aturating the appropriate entropy bound, the entropy releae from the evaporation of the tring hole cannot occur if the pacetime curvature remain contant or grow to a higher energy cale. Intead, the decay of the tring hole mut coincide with a (noningular curvature bounce; in par-