arxiv: v2 [hep-th] 6 Jul 2009

Transcription

1 HIP-9-/TH Dirac Equation in Noncommutative Space for Hydrogen Atom arxiv:9.86v [hep-th] 6 Jul 9 T. C. Adorno, M. C. Baldiotti, M. Chaichian, D. M. Gitman and A. Tureanu Instituto de Física, Universidade de São Paulo, Caixa Postal 668, CEP São Paulo, S.P., Brazil Department of Physics, University of Helsinki and Helsinki Institute of Physics, P.O.Box 6, FIN- Helsinki, Finland Abstract We consider the energy levels of a hydrogen-like atom in the framework of θ- modified, due to space noncommutativity, Dirac equation with Coulomb field. It is shownthatonthenoncommutativenc)spacethedegeneracyofthelevelss /, P / and P / is lifted completely, such that new transition channels are allowed. Introduction Possible physically observable consequences of noncommutativity of space coordinates have attracted recently a lot of attention in order to justify the intensive study of noncommutative versions of QFT and quantum mechanics, mainly motivated by the seminal works [, ]. The results of Ref. [] show, e.g., that the noncommutativity leads to a deviation of the energy levels of the hydrogen atom from the well-known structure obtained in the framework of standard quantum mechanics. The results of [] show that the degenerate levels S P split in three others levels. However, the calculations of [] were done in the framework of θ-modified nonrelativistic Schrödinger equation with Coulomb field. It is interesting to refine these results, considering a noncommutative modification of the energy levels of the hydrogen atom in the framework of the θ-modified Dirac equation with the Coulomb field, which is the relativistic Schrödinger equation for the case under consideration. Such a problem is

2 solved in the present work. We show that in contrast with the nonrelativistic case, the noncommutativity lifts completely the degeneracy of the levels P / and P /, opening new allowed transition channels. θ-modified Dirac equation with Coulomb field The behavior of an electron with charge e e > ) and mass m in the Coulomb field of a nucleus Ze, in a noncommutative space, is determined by the θ-modified Dirac equation, whose Hamiltonian form is i t Ψx) = Ĥθ Ψx), Ĥ θ = α ˆp)mγ ea q), α i γ γ i, α = α i ), ˆp = p i ), ) where Ψx) is a four component spinor, ˆp = i, γ µ are the Dirac matrices and the θ -modified Coulomb potential A q) reads A q) = A x i ) θijˆp Ze j = xi θijˆp ) j xi θikˆp ), i,j,k =,,), ) k where θ jk is the constant anti-symmetric noncommutativity parameter that defines the algebra of noncommutative position operators q i, [ q j,q k] = iθ jk see, e.g., []). In what follows wecallĥθ theθ-modifieddirachamiltonianwithcoulombfieldonanoncommutativespace. Setting θ i = ε ijk θ jk ε ijk is the Levi-Civita simbol with the usual definition) and denoting r = x i x i, the potential ) can be written as A x i ) θijˆp j = Ze r Ze ) ˆL θ O θ ), θ = θ i), r where ˆL =[x ˆp]istheangularmomentumoperator. Thereforetheθ-modifiedDiracHamiltonian takes the form Ĥ θ = Ĥ ˆV θ O θ ), ) Ĥ = α p)mγ Ze r, ˆV θ = Ze ) ˆL θ. r ) Using the exact eigenfunctions of Ĥ and treating ˆV θ as a perturbation of the ordinary Dirac Hamiltonian Ĥ, one can calculate the modification of energy levels of the hydrogen atom in the framework of θ-modified Dirac equation. The spectrum of Ĥ and the corresponding eigenfunctions are well known, see [5, 6, 7, 9]. Below, we list the spectrum and the

3 eigenfunctions of Ĥ for Z < 7: ĤΨ N,j,M,ζ = E N,j Ψ N,j,M,ζ, ζ = ±, E N,j = N = { m Ze γn,,..., ζ =,,..., ζ =, γ = κ Ze ), κ = ζ Ĵ Ψ N,j,M,ζ = jj )Ψ N,j,M,ζ, Ĵ Ψ N,j,M,ζ = MΨ N,j,M,ζ, ), j ), Ĵ = ˆL Σ, Σ = diagσ,σ), j =,,..., j M j, where σ = σ i ) are the Pauli matrices and the bispinors Ψ N,j,M,ζ are given by ) Ψ N,j,M,ζ r,ϑ,ϕ) = Ω j,m,ζ ϑ,ϕ)f N,j,ζ r) r iω j,m, ζ ϑ,ϕ)f N,j,ζ r), j ζ Ω j,m,ζ ϑ,ϕ) = ) ζ ζm Y j ζ ϑ,ϕ) j,m ) j ζ ζ ζm Y j ϑ,ϕ) ζ,m, 5) where Y A,B ϑ,ϕ) are the spherical harmonics [6, 7] and F ± N,j,ζ r) = ±Aλ± N zγ e z/ [η N κ)φ N,β;z) NΦ N,β;z)], A = λ N) / Γβ N) Γβ) η N η N κ)n!, λ± N = ± E N,j m, λ N = mλ N λ N, β = γ, η N = Ze m/λ N, z = λ N r, 6) where Φa, b; z) is the hypergeometric confluent function see [] for definition). θ-modification of energy levels As it was shown in [], for the hydrogenic atoms, without spin-orbit interaction, the nonrelativistic energy levels of the θ-modified Hamiltonian Ĥnr, Ĥ nr = ˆp m Ze r, 7) are characterized by a lift of degeneracy in the quantum number l = jζ/ eigenvalue of ˆL operator), implying certain splittings of the energy levels. Thus, there appears a possibility of new transition channels with distinct projections of total angular momentum M, i.e., in the spectroscopic notation, transitions like nlj M nlj M for l ), where n = N κ is the nonrelativistic principal quantum number, eigenvalue of the radial differential operator

4 of 7). The perturbation due to the noncommutativity is given by the same operator ˆV θ as in ), but it is calculated with the nonrelativistic wave functions, whose correction on degenerate levels, in leading order, is obtained by computing the eigenvalues of the secular matrix E nr, its elements being defined as { ] } π [ˆL θ Eaa nr = Ze drr dω ψ n,ar,ϑ,ϕ) ψ r n,a r,ϑ,ϕ), 8) wherethelabela = l,j,m)isthecollectionofthethreedegeneratednonrelativisticquantum numbers and ψ n,a r,ϑ,ϕ) ψ n,l,j,m r,ϑ,ϕ) = R n,l r)χ j,m ϑ,ϕ), ĵ χ j,m ϑ,ϕ) = ˆLσ/) χj,m ϑ,ϕ) = jj )χ j,m ϑ,ϕ) are the eigenfunctions of 7), Ĥ nr ψ n,a = E n ψ n,a. In order to obtain the θ-modification of the S /, P /, P / levels, we emphasize that ˆV θ is a vectorial operator and, according to angular momentum selections rules, allowed transitions are between levels with M M M =, and l l l = [8]. The 6 6 secular matrix E nr has three degenerate eigenvalues represented as E nr and E± nr and, restoring and c, these corrections have the form E nr =, Enr ± = mc Z α λ e ) ) ± θ ), θ = θ i θ i, 9) where α = e / c is the fine structure constant, λ e = λ e /π = /mc and λ e is the electron Compton wavelength. The same results are obtained if we choose θ = θ = and θ which can be done by a rotation or a redefinition of coordinates). With this choice, θ = θ, and the diagonal elements can be calculated using the general formulae obtained in []. Since thegoalof[]isthestudyofthetransition P / S /, itdoesnotcontaintheexpression for the nondiagonal elements of Ebb nr. For these nondiagonal elements, we have { ] } π [ˆL θ drr dω ψ,b r,ϑ,ϕ) ψ,b r,ϑ,ϕ) E nr bb = Ze = mc Z α λ e ) ) ) θ, b = r,,± ), b =, ),±. ) Rigorously this transition does not exist, as the perturbed level is actually a superposition of the degenerated levels P / and P /, and only the quantum number M is well defined. But this consideration does not change the numerical value of the transition and, consequently, could be ignored in [].

5 With this definition of coordinates, [Ĵ,ˆV θ] =, therefore the eigenstates of Ĥθ,nr = Ĥnr ˆV θ, in leading order, have the magnetic quantum number M well defined. This result allows us to conclude that, in nonrelativistic case, the S P levels split in three other levels, all of them twofold degenerate, as illustrated in Figure. In the relativistic theory, the θ-modification of the energy levels are obtained by computing the eigenvalues of the secular matrix E rel, characterized by the mean values of the operator ˆV θ ), but now with respect to the Dirac spinors Ψ N,j,M,ζ 5), with the same angular momentum selection rules, i.e., M M M =, and l l l =. The perturbation operator ˆV θ does not mix the small F N,j,ζ r) and the big F N,j,ζ r) components of the Dirac spinor 5), so E rel consists of two terms, which read: Eµµ rel = Ze Ze dr r dr r [ ) F F ] π { } N,j,ζ N,j,ζ dω Ω j,m,ζ ˆL θ )Ω j,m,ζ [ F N,j,ζ ) F N,j,ζ ] π { } dω Ω j,m, ζˆl θ )Ω j,m, ζ, where the label µ = M, ζ) is the set of two degenerated relativistic quantum numbers. However, F N,j,ζ r) is approximately by /c smaller then F N,j,ζ r), so we can neglect the terms proportional to small components, retaining only the first term above. We are interested in calculating the θ-modifications of the relativistic energy of the S, P levels. The nonrelativistic degeneracy in the quantum number j is naturally removed in the Diractheory, in such a way that the level P / is lifted from the still degenerate S /, P / levels. The space noncommutativity leads to additional splittings and a separate analysis for the j = / and j = / relativistic energy levels is required. The elements of the secular matrix E rel j), in leading order, are EMM rel j) = Ze drr F whose results, for each level, follow below. N,j,ζ { π dω Ω j,m,ζ ] [ˆL θ r Ω j,m,ζ }, ). Relativistic NC correction for the P / level The θ-correction for the P / level N =, j = /, ζ =, M = ± ) follows from ): EMM rel / = /) = Ze dr r /Θ rel MM, F,,r), Θ rel MM = π [ ) ] dω Ω ˆL θ,m, Ω,M,. ) 5

6 Expressing the hypergeometric confluent functions 6) in terms of exponentials and polynomials, we obtain [ ) / = λ ) β λ ] {η ) η η )β )β )β ) [ ] ) η )η )β ) η β )β )}, ) β η = Ze m λ, γ = β Ze ), β = γ, with λ, λ given in 6). The matrix Θ rel, whose elements are Θ rel MM, reads ) Θ rel = θ θ, θ ± = θ ±iθ, ) θ θ and its eigenvalues, denoted by Λ ± j, are Λ ± / = ± θ, θ = θ i θ i. 5) The θ-corrections to the relativistic energy of the P / level, E rel ± j), restoring and c, reads E rel ± /) = Ze = mc Z α ηη ) η β /Λ ± / ) ± θ ) { ) λ β ) λ e β )β )β ) )[ ) η ) η )η )β ) β ) β )β )]}. 6) Therefore there is a splitting of this level in such way that the originally degenerate level S /, P / splits in three sublevels. Similarly to the nonrelativistic case, the same results can be obtained by choosing a reference frame where θ = θ = and θ. The advantage of this frame is that [Ĵ, ˆV ] θ = and therefore, the new states have the magnetic quantum number M well defined. In this reference frame, the splitting of the level S /, P / in the three levels P / /, S /, P / / is illustrated in Figure. 6

7 . Relativistic NC correction for the P / level According to ), the θ-correction for the P / level N =, j = /, ζ =, M = ±/, ±/) is where the radial integral is / = γ = dr r E rel MM rel /) = Ze /ΘMM, 7) F,, r) = λ ) [ λ ) β )β )β ) Ze ), β = γ, ], 8) withλ,λ givenin6). Comparedtothepreviouscase, thematrixθ rel isnowa -matrix, whose elements are and explicitly is given by Θ rel = Θ rel MM = π [ ) ] dω Ω ˆL θ,m, Ω,M,, 9) θ θ θ θ θ θ θ θ θ θ Its four nondegenerate eigenvalues, Λ ± j and Λ ± j, are, θ ± = θ ±iθ. ) Λ ± / = ± θ, Λ± / = Λ± /, θ = θ i θ i. ) The θ-corrections for the P / level, in dimension of energy restoring and c), have the form E rel /) ± = Ze /Λ ± /, Erel /) ± = Erel /) ±, ) E rel /) ± = mc Z α ) λ ± θ ) λ e β )β )β ). ) Choosing again the reference frame where θ = θ = and θ, we have [Ĵ, ˆV ] θ = and the level P / splits in the four levels P / /, P / /, P / /, P / /, as illustrated in Figure. The energy levels and their modifications due to presence of space noncommutativity, for the relativistic and nonrelativistic cases, are shown in Figure. Onthisfigure,theenergysplitsindicatedbythedashed-pointarrowcomesfromtheusualDiracequation, so it does not depends on θ and this split can not be compared with the others θ-modified levels. 7

8 Figure Splittings for relativistic and nonrelativistic energy levels due to space noncommutativity. All numerical values of the coefficients of the first-order θ-corrections are in units of ev/m. We conclude that, from the point of view of the θ-modified relativistic Dirac theory there is an additional, in contrast to the nonrelativistic case, splitting of some degenerate levels and there appear new transition channels. In particular, in the presence of the space noncommutativity, the degenerate levels S /,P / split into three nondegerenerate sublevels and the level P / splits into four nondegenerate sublevels, and the transition P ±/ / S / is possible. Except for the spherically symmetric levels S ±/ /, these results show that in the noncommutative relativistic theory degeneracy is completely removed. The obtained results show explicitly the dependence of the energy levels of the hydrogen atom on the noncommutative parameter. Once these energy levels can be measured experimentally with a high accuracy, the actual spectroscopy data can be used to impose bounds on the value of the noncommutativity parameter θ. Acknowledgements T.C.A. thanks CNPq; M.C.B. thanks FAPESP; D.M.G. thanks FAPESP and CNPq for permanent support. The support of the Academy of Finland under the Projects no. 7 and 766 is greatly acknowledged. 8

9 References [] S. Doplicher, K. Fredenhagen and J. E. Roberts, Phys. Lett. B 99) 9; Commun. Math. Phys ) 87, hep-th/7. [] N. Seiberg and E. Witten, JHEP 9 999), hep-th/998. [] M. Chaichian, M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari and A. Tureanu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86 ) 76. [] D. M. Gitman and V. G. Kupriyanov, Eur. Phys. J. C 5 8) 5-. [5] H. A. Bethe and E. E. Salpeter, Quantum Mechanics of One - and Two-Electron Atoms Springer - Verlag 957). [6] M. E. Rose, Relativistic Electron Theory John Wiley & Sons 96). [7] A. I. Akhiezer and V. B. Berestetskii, Quantum Electrodynamics Interscience 965). [8] L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Quantum Mechanics Pergamon Press 977). [9] B. Voronov, D. M. Gitman and I. V. Tyutin, Teor. Math. Phys. 5 ) 7). [] I. S. Gradshtein and N. M. Ryzhik, Tables of integrals, sums, series and products 7 th ed. Academic Press 7). 9