arxiv:hep-th/ v2 18 Sep 2005

Transcription

1 New developments in the spectral asymptotics of quantum gravity arxiv:hep-th/ v2 18 Sep Introduction Giampiero Esposito, Guglielmo Fucci, Alexander Yu Kamenshchik, Klaus Kirsten INFN, Sezione di Napoli, and Dipartimento di Scienze Fisiche, Complesso Universitario di Monte S. Angelo, Via Cintia, Edificio N, Napoli, Italy Department of Physics, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology, Leroy Place 801, Socorro, NM 87801, USA Dipartimento di Fisica and INFN, Sezione di Bologna, Via Irnerio 46, Bologna, Italy; L D Landau Institute for Theoretical Physics, Kosygin str. 2, Moscow, Russia Department of Mathematics, Baylor University, Waco, TX 76798, USA Abstract. A vanishing one-loop wave function of the Universe in the limit of small three-geometry is found, on imposing diffeomorphism-invariant boundary conditions on the Euclidean 4-ball in the de Donder gauge. This result suggests a quantum avoidance of the cosmological singularity driven by full diffeomorphism invariance of the boundary-value problem for one-loop quantum theory. All of this is made possible by a peculiar spectral cancellation on the Euclidean 4-ball, here derived and discussed. The physical motivations of our research result from the following active areas of research: i) Functional integrals and space-time approach to quantum field theory [1]. ii) Attempt to derive the whole set of physical laws from invariance principles [2]. iii) How to derive the early universe evolution from quantum physics; how to make sense of a wave function of the universe and of Hartle Hawking quantum cosmology [3, 4]. iv) Spectral theory and its physical applications, including functional determinants in one-loop quantum theory and hence the first corrections to classical dynamics [5]. The boundary conditions that we study are part of a unified scheme for Maxwell, Yang Mills and Quantized General Relativity at one loop, i.e. [6] [ ] πa = 0, 1) B [ ] ΦA) B = 0, 2)

2 New developments in the spectral asymptotics of quantum gravity 2 [ϕ] B = 0. 3) With our notation, π is a projector acting on the gauge field A, Φ is the gauge-fixing functional, ϕ is the ghost field or full set of ghost fields) [7]. Both equation 1) and 2) are preserved under infinitesimal gauge transformations provided that the ghost obeys homogeneous Dirichlet conditions as in 3). For gravity, we choose Φ so as to have an operator P of Laplace type on metric perturbations in the one-loop Euclidean theory. 2. Eigenvalue conditions for scalar modes On the Euclidean 4-ball, we expand metric perturbations h µν in terms of scalar, transverse vector, transverse-traceless tensor harmonics on S 3. For vector, tensor and ghost modes, boundary conditions reduce to Dirichlet or Robin [8]. For scalar modes, one finds eventually the eigenvalues E = x 2 from the roots x of [8] J nx) ± n x J nx) = 0, 4) J nx) + x 2 ± n ) J n x) = 0. 5) x Note that both x and x solve the same equation. For example, at small n and large x, the roots of Eq. 5) with + sign in front of n read as here s = 0, 1,..., ) x [ xs, n) βs, n) 1 + γ 1 β 2 s, n) + γ 2 β 4 s, n) + γ ] 3 β 6 s, n) + Oβ 8 ), 6) where βs, n) π s + n ), 7) 4 and having defined m 4n 2 ) γ 1 m) m 17), 8) 8 γ 2 m) m1/ m m2, 9) γ 3 m) = m1/ m+ 3 4 m3/ m m3, 10) as we have found in the second item of [9]. 3. Four generalized ζ-functions for scalar modes From Eqs. 4) and 5) we obtain the following integral representations of the resulting ζ-functions [8, 9]: ζ ± sin πs) A,B s) n 2s 2) dz z 2s π z log F ± A,B zn), 11) n=3 0

3 New developments in the spectral asymptotics of quantum gravity 3 where here β + n, β n + 2) ) F ± A zn) z β ± zni n zn) ± ni nzn), 12) F ± B zn) z β ± zni n zn) + zn) 2 2 ) ) ± n I n zn). 13) Regularity at the origin is easily proved in the elliptic sectors, corresponding to ζ ± A s) and ζ B s). 4. Regularity of ζ + B at s = 0 We now define τ 1 + z 2 ) 1/2 and consider the uniform asymptotic expansion away from τ = 1, with notation as in [8, 9]) ) z β + F + B zn) enητ) hn) 1 τ 2 ) r j,+ τ) 1 +, 14) τ τ n j the functions r j,+ being obtained from the Olver polynomials for the uniform asymptotic expansion of I n and I n. On splitting 1 dτ = µ dτ + 1 dτ with µ small, we get an 0 0 µ asymptotic expansion of the l.h.s. by writing, in the first interval on the r.h.s., ) r j,+ τ) R j,+ τ) log 1 +, 15) n j n j and then computing C j τ) R j,+ τ 4j = 1 τ) j 1 a=j 1 K j) a τa. 16) The integral 1 dτ is instead found to yield a vanishing contribution in the µ 1 limit µ [9]. Remarkably, by virtue of the spectral identity gj) 4j a=j which holds j = 1,...,, we find and where lim s 0 sζ+ B s) = 1 6 Γa + 1) Γa j + 1) Kj) a = 0, 17) 12 a=3 ζ + B 0) = aa 1)a 2)K 3) a = 0, 18) 12 a=2 ωa)k 3) a + fj)gj) = , 19) ωa) 1 Γa + 1) [ log2) 6a2 9a + 1) Γa 2) 6 Γa + 2) 4 Γa + 1) ] + 2ψa + 1) ψa 2) ψ4), 20)

4 New developments in the spectral asymptotics of quantum gravity 4 [ ] fj) 1)j j + ζ R j 2)1 δ j,3 ) + γδ j,3. 21) j! The spectral cancellation 17) achieves three goals: i) Vanishing of log 2 coefficient in Eq. 19); ii) Vanishing of fj)gj) in Eq. 19); iii) Regularity at the origin of ζ + B. To cross-check our analysis, we evaluate r j,+τ) r j, τ) and hence obtain R j,+ τ) R j, τ) for all j. Only j = 3 contributes to ζ ± B 0), and we find ζ + B 0) = ζ B 0) 1 4 [ Γl + 1) ψl + 2) 1 ] κ 3) 2l+1 24 Γl 2) l + 1) l=1 = = , 22) in agreement with Eq. 19), where κ 3) 2l+1 are the four coefficients on the right-hand side of τ R 3,+ R 3, ) = 1 τ 2 ) 4 80τ 3 24τ τ 7 8τ ). 9 23) Within this framework, the spectral cancellation reads as 4 l=1 which is a particular case of Γl + 1) Γl 2) κ3) 2l+1 = 0, 24) a=a maxj) a=a min j) Γa + 1)/2) Γa + 1)/2 j) κj) a = 0. 25) Interestingly, the full ζ0) value for pure gravity is then found to be positive: ζ0) = [9], which suggests a quantum avoidance of the cosmological singularity driven by full diffeomorphism invariance of the boundary-value problem for one-loop quantum theory [9]. 5. Open problems Several open problems should be brought to the attention of the reader. Some key points are as follows. i) We have encountered a boundary-value problem where the generalized ζ-function remains well defined, even though the Mellin transform relating ζ-function to heat kernel does not exist, since strong ellipticity is violated [6]. Are the spectral cancellations 17) and 25) a peculiar property of the Euclidean 4-ball, or can they be extended to more general Riemannian manifolds with non-empty boundary? ii) What is the deeper underlying reason for finding ζ + B 0) ζ B 0) = 2? Is it possible to foresee a geometrical or topological or group-theoretical origin of this result?

5 New developments in the spectral asymptotics of quantum gravity 5 iii) Is it correct to say that our positive ζ0) value for pure gravity engenders a quantum avoidance of the cosmological singularity at one-loop level? [9, 10] Does the result remain true in higher-loop calculations or on using other regularization techniques for the oneloop correction? iv) The whole scheme might be relevant for AdS/CFT in light of a profound link between AdS/CFT and the Hartle Hawking wave function of the universe [11]. v) What happens if one considers instead non-local boundary data, e.g. those giving rise to surface states for the Laplacian? [2, 12, 13] As far as item i) is concerned, we should add what follows. The integral representation 11) of the generalized ζ-function is legitimate because, for any fixed n, there is a countable infinity of roots x j and x j of Eqs. 4) and 5), and they grow approximately linearly with the integer j counting such roots. The functions F ± A and F ± B admit therefore a canonical-product representation which ensures that the integral representation 11) reproduces the standard definition of generalized ζ-function [8]. Furthermore, even though the Mellin transform relating ζ-function to integrated heat kernel cannot be exploited when strong ellipticity is not fulfilled, it remains possible to define a generalized ζ-function. For this purpose, a weaker assumption provides a sufficient condition, i.e. the existence of a sector in the complex plane free of eigenvalues of the leading symbol of the differential operator under consideration [8, 9]. To make sure we have not overlooked some properties of the spectrum, we have been looking for negative eigenvalues or zero-modes, but finding none. Indeed, negative eigenvalues E would imply purely imaginary roots x = iy of Eq. 5), but such roots do not exist, as one can check both numerically and analytically; zero-modes would be non-trivial eigenfunctions belonging to zero-eigenvalues, but all modes tensor, vector, scalar and ghost modes) are combinations of Bessel functions [8] for which this is impossible. As far as we can see, we still find sources of singularities at the origin in the generalized ζ-function resulting from lack of strong ellipticity, but the particular symmetries of the Euclidean 4-ball background reduce them to the four terms in Eq. 24), which add up to zero despite two of them are non-vanishing. The years to come will hopefully tell us whether our calculations may be viewed as a first step towards finding under which conditions a quantum theory of gravity is singularity free in cosmology [14]. Acknowledgments We are grateful to Gerald Dunne, Dmitri Fursaev, Mariel Santangelo and Antonello Scardicchio for stimulating questions, and to Emilio Elizalde for having organized such a beautiful Conference. The work of G Esposito has been partially supported by PRIN SINTESI. K Kirsten is grateful to the Baylor University Research Committee, to the Max-Planck-Institute for Mathematics in the Sciences Leipzig, Germany) and to the INFN for financial support. The work of A Yu Kamenshchik was partially supported

6 New developments in the spectral asymptotics of quantum gravity 6 by the Russian Foundation for Basic Research under the Grant No and by the Scientific School Grant No References [1] DeWitt B S 2003 The Global Approach to Quantum Field Theory Clarendon Press, Oxford) [2] Esposito G 2000 Int. J. Mod. Phys. A [3] Hartle J B and Hawking S W 1983 Phys. Rev. D [4] Hawking S W 1984 Nucl. Phys. B [5] Esposito G 1994 Quantum Gravity, Quantum Cosmology and Lorentzian Geometries, Lecture Notes in Physics, New Series m, Vol. m12 Springer, Berlin) [6] Avramidi I G and Esposito G 1999 Commun. Math. Phys [7] Esposito G, Kamenshchik A Yu and Pollifrone G 1997 Euclidean Quantum Gravity on Manifolds with Boundary, Vol. 85 of Fundamental Theories of Physics Kluwer, Dordrecht) [8] Esposito G, Fucci G, Kamenshchik A Yu and Kirsten K 2005 Class. Quantum Grav [9] Esposito G, Fucci G, Kamenshchik A Yu and Kirsten K 2005 hep-th/ , hep-th/ ) [10] Hawking S W 2005 Phys. Scripta T [11] Horowitz G T and Maldacena J 2004 JHEP [12] Schröder M 1989 Rep. Math. Phys [13] Esposito G 1999 Class. Quantum Grav [14] Kiefer C 2005 Quantum gravity: general introduction and recent developments gr-qc/ )