Tutorial General Relativity

Transcription

1 Tutorial General Relativity Winter term 016/017 Sheet No. 3 Solutions will be discussed on Nov/9/16 Lecturer: Prof. Dr. C. Greiner Tutor: Hendrik van Hees 1. Tensor gymnastics (a) Let Q ab = Q ba be a symmetric tensor and R ab = R ba be an antisymmetric tensor. Show that Q ab R ab = 0. Solution: From the symmetry of Q ab we have Q ab R ab = Q ba R ab, and from the antisymmetry of R ab that is Q ba R ab = Q ba R ba. Now we can rename the indices b a and a b over which is summed. So we have Q ab R ab = Q ab R ab, from which necessarily follows Q ab R ab = 0. (b) Let Q ab = Q ba be a symmetric tensor and T ab be an arbitrary tensor. Show that T ab Q ab = 1 Qab (T ab + T ba ). Solution: From the symmetry of Q ab we have T ab Q ab = T ab Q ba. Renaming again a b gives T ab Q ba = T ba Q ab. Thus one has T ab Q ab = Q ab (T ab + T ba ), and that we had to prove.. At the corners of a square of length a point masses m and M are located as shown in the figure in the xy plane (z = 0) of a Cartesian coordinate system. y y x m a M x M m

2 (a) Calculate the components of the tensor of inertia, Θ ij = k m k ( x k x k δ ij x i k xj k ), with respect to the Cartesian coordinate sytem (x, y, z) and with respect to (x, y, z ) (red), where z = z. The sum over k runs over the four point masses. Solution: In the original frame the position vectors of the masses can be read off the diagram as x 1 = (a, a, 0) T, x = ( a, a, 0) T, x 3 = ( a, a, 0) T, x 4 = (a, a, 0), (1) and the masses are m 1 = m 3 = M and m = m 4 = m. Using the definition of the tensor of inertia given in the problem yiel m + M (M m) 0 ˆΘ = (Θ ij ) = a (M m) m + M 0. () 0 0 (m + M) In the primed frame we read off the coordinates of the mass points as x 1 = (a, 0, 0) T, x = (0, a, 0) T, x 3 = ( a, 0, 0) T, x 4 = (0, a, 0) T. (3) Using again the formula for the tensor components gives ˆΘ = (Θ ij ) = 4a diag(m, M, m + M). (4) (b) Determine the rotation matrix D k i that transforms the vector components of the position vectors according to x k = D k ix i. Solution: We have a counter-clock-wise rotation of the original frame by π/4 around the z axis. With cos π/4 = sin π/4 = / thus the rotation matrix rea ˆD = (D i j) = (5) (c) Show through explicit calculation that the components of the tensor of inertia transform as the components of a second-rank tensor should, i.e., according to Θ kl = D k id l jt ij. Solution: In matrix-product notation the formula claims ˆΘ = ˆD ˆΘ ˆD T, (6) and performing the matrix multiplications using () and (5) indeed lea to (4) as claimed. 3. Geodesics 1 A great circle of a sphere is the intersection of the sphere and a plane which passes through the center point of the sphere. Show that geodesics on a sphere are great circles. Use with u 1 = θ, u = φ and R = const. = R (dθ + sin θdφ ) 1 In this exercise we follow the lecture given by Prof. Greiner on Tuesday, November 08!

3 (a) Determine the metric and the affine connections given as Γ h ki = 1 ( glk ghl u i + g li u k g ) ik u l Solution The metric components read g 11 = R, g 1 = g 1 = 0, g = R sin θ g 11 = 1 R, g1 = g 1 = 0, g 1 = R sin θ, (7) and thus the only non-vanishing Christoffel symbols are Γ 1 = sin θ, Γ 1 = Γ 1 = cot θ. (8) (b) Determine the geodesic equations for θ and φ, and show that these can be written as sin θ dφ = h = const. ( ) dθ + h sin θ = h sin = const. where h and 0 π Solution: are constants of integration. d θ + du i du k Γ1 ik = d θ + Γ1 ( ) dφ = d θ sin θ ( ) dφ = 0, (9) d φ + du i du k Γ1 ik = d φ + dφ dθ Γ 1 + dθ dφ Γ 1 = d φ + dθ dφ = 0. (10) sin θ Mutiplying Eq. (10) with sin θ gives and thus the first equation sin θ d φ dθ dφ + sin θ = d sin θ dφ Plugging this into (9) we obtain = h = const. dφ = d θ h sin 3 θ ( sin θ dφ ) = 0 (11) h sin θ (1) = 0. (13) This can also be written as a total derivative by multiplying with dθ [ (dθ dθ d θ dθ h sin 3 θ = d ) ] + h sin = 0, (14) θ i.e., ( ) dθ + h sin θ = h sin = const. with 0 π, (15) with the range for follows from the fact that sin is unique there. (c) Use your results from (b) to determine dφ/dθ and the function φ(θ). Use dθ 1 = = arctan sin θ sin θ sin θ sin θ sin θ.

4 (d) Show, that cot θ = cot cos(φ φ 0 ) Hint: Use the relations tan(x ± π/) = cot x and 1 + cot x = 1 sin x. Solution: Applying the chain rule we find dθ = dθ dφ dφ = dθ h dφ sin θ, (16) where we have used (1). Now we can use (16) in (15) to obtain h sin 4 θ dφ dθ = ± 1 sin θ ( ) dθ + h dφ h sin θ = sin, ) 1/. ( sin θ sin (17) Due to (15) is θ {, π } since (17) is only defined in this range. Separation of variables and integrating, using the integral given in the problem, lea to θ φ = φ 0 ± dθ 1 sin θ sin θ sin After some algebra this simplifies to ( tan φ φ 0 π ) = φ 0 ± arctan = cot(φ φ 0 ) = = sin θ 1 sin sin θ sin θ sin = φ 0 arctan ± π sin θ sin sin θ sin θ (18) (19) cot θ = cot cot θ, where we have used the given trigonometric relations. Finally we can resolve for cot θ: cot (φ φ 0 )(cot cot θ) = cot θ cot (φ φ 0 ) cot = cot θ(1 + cot (θ )) cot θ = cot(φ φ 0) cot θ cot (φ φ 0 ) = cot(φ φ 0) cot θ 0 1 sin (φ φ 0 ) = cos(φ φ 0 ) cot. (0) To see that this indeed describes a great circle on the sphere we identify the point on the geodesic with coordinate (, φ 0 ) as its highest point. We get the great circle through this point, r 0 = R(sin cos φ 0, sin sin φ 0, cos ), (1) by rotating r 0 around an axis n through the origin of the coordinate system that is perpendicular to r 0. With respect to the axis n is this great circle through r 0 the equator, and thus n is parallel to the unit vector e θ ( r 0 ) along a latitude. In the figure we show such a great circle with r 0 as the point with the minimal angle θ =

5 The unit vector at this place is given by n = e θ ( r 0 ) = d sin θ cos φ sin θ sin φ dθ θ0,φ0 = cos cos φ 0 cos sin φ 0. () sin Only for a great circle the position vector along the cirlce r(θ, φ) is always perpendicular to this special unit vector in direction of growing θ. For smaller circles the scalar product won t vanish. Thus we find as a condition e θ (, φ 0 ) r(θ, φ) = R(cos cos φ 0 sin θ cos φ + cos sin φ 0 sin θ sin φ sin ) = R(cos sin θ(cos φ 0 cos φ + sin φ 0 sin φ) sin ) = R(cos sin θ cos(φ φ 0 ) sin )! = 0 cos sin θ cos(φ φ 0 ) = sin cot cos(φ φ 0 ) = cot θ, where in the 3rd line we have used cos α cos β + sin α sin β = cos(α β). Now according to (0) this condition is precisely the solution for the geodesic on the sphere. (3) 4. Additional problem (just for fun): Geodesics on the sphere simplified That the great circles are the geodesics on the sphere can be much simpler derived by using that the geodesics equation can be derived by the variational principle with the Lagrangian L = 1 g ijẋ i ẋ j, where g ij = g ij ( x) are the metric components and x = x(λ) is a parametrization with a parameter λ that is automatically affine. For the geodesics on the sphere use the Euclidean metric in R 3 with components g ij = δ ij and implement the constraint x = R = const with a Lagrange parameter Λ leading to the Lagrangian L = 1 x Λ ( x R ).

6 (a) Derive the equations of motion from the variational principle (Euler-Lagrange equations). Solution: First we calculate to canonical momenta: (b) p = L ẋ = x. (4) From this according to the Euler-Lagrange equations the geodesics are described by the differential equations p = x = L = Λ x. (5) x (c) To determine the Lagrange multiplier Λ, take the nd derivative of the constraint x = R = const with respect to λ, and then use the equations of motion from (a). Hint: One can use the fact that λ is automatically an affine parameter, which can be normalized such that x = 1. Solution: Taking twice the derivative of the contraint lea to With the equations of motion (5) this lea to x x = 0, x + x x = 1 + x x = 0. (6) 1 Λ x = 1 ΛR = 0 Λ = 1 R. (7) (d) Solve the equations of motion to show that it is a great circle on the sphere. Solution: The equations of motion now read and the general solution is x = x, (8) R x = x 1 cos(λ/r) + x sin(λ/r). (9) Now we have to work in the constraints. From the first equation (6) we get x x = 1 R [ x 1 sin(λ/r) + x cos(λ/r)] [ x 1 cos(λ/r) + x sin(λ/r)] = 0. (30) Now for λ/r = 0 this implies x 1 x = 0, i.e., x 1 and x are prependicular vectors. This implies that x = x 1 cos (λ/r) + x sin (λ/r)! = R, (31) and now setting first λ/r = 0 gives x 1 = R, and setting then λ/r = π/ lea to x = R. Then (31) is indeed fulfilled for all λ. Since thus x 1 and x are two perpendicular vector of length R, (9) indeed describes a circle with radius R around the origin, and this is of course a great circle on the sphere. This proves again that the geodesics on a sphere are great circles (or pieces of great circles).