Some Rarita-Schwinger Type Operators

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Some Rarita-Schwinger Type Operators"

Transcription

1 Some Rarita-Schwinger Type Operators Junxia Li University of Arkansas April 7-9, th University of Arkansas Spring Lecture Series joint work with John Ryan, Charles Dunkl and Peter Van Lancker

2 A reference J. Bureš, F. Sommen, V. Souček, P. Van Lancker, Rarita-Schwinger Type Operators in Clifford Analysis, J. Funct. Annl. 185 (2001), No.2,

3 Introduction In representation theory for the orthogonal group,o(n), one can consider spaces of homogeneous harmonic polynomials. If one refines to solutions to the Dirac equation, namely to spaces of homogeneous monogenic polynomials one refines the representation theory to the covering group of O(n). Then the Rarita-Schwinger operators arise. The Rarita-Schwinger operators are generalizations of the Dirac operator. They are also known as Stein-Weiss operators. We denote a Rarita-Schwinger operator by R k, where k = 0, 1,, m,. When k = 0 it is the Dirac operator.

4 Goals of my talk 1. Construct the Rarita-Schwinger operators based on the Dirac operator. 2. Construct fundamental solutions to the Rarita-Schwinger equations. 3. Give some basic integral formulas related to the Rarita-Schwinger operators.

5 Clifford algebras We need Clifford algebras: A Clifford algebra, Cl n, can be generated from R n by considering the relationship x 2 = x 2 for each x R n. We have R n Cl n. If e 1,..., e n is an orthonormal basis for R n, then x 2 = x 2 tells us that e i e j + e j e i = 2δ ij, where δ ij is the Kronecker delta function. An arbitrary element of the basis of the Clifford algebra can be written as e A = e j1 e jr, where A = {j 1,, j r } {1, 2,, n} and 1 j 1 < j 2 < < j r n. Hence for any element a Cl n, we have a = A a Ae A, where a A R.

6 For a Cl n, we will need the following anti-involutions: Reversion: ã = ( 1) A ( A 1)/2 a A e A, A where A is the cardinality of A. In particular, e j1 e jr = e jr e j1. Also ãb = bã for a, b Cl n. Clifford conjugation: ā = A ( 1) A ( A +1)/2 a A e A. Further, we have e j1 e jr = ( 1) r e jr e j1 and ab = bā for a, b Cl n.

7 Pin(n) and Spin(n) Pin(n) := {a Cl n : a = y 1... y p : y 1,..., y p S n 1, p N} is a group under multiplication in Cl n. Note for y S n 1, x R n then yxy is a reflection in the y direction. By the Cartan Dieudonné Theorem each O O(n) is the composition of a finite number of reflections. If we choose y 1,..., y p arbitrarily in S n 1 the group homomorphism θ : Pin(n) O(n) : a O a with a = y 1... y p and O a (x) = axã is surjective. Further ax( ã) = axã, so 1, 1 ker(θ). In fact ker(θ) = {±1}. Let Spin(n) := {a Pin(n) : a = y 1... y p and p is even}. Then Spin(n) is a subgroup of Pin(n) and is surjective with kernel {1, 1}. θ : Spin(n) SO(n)

8 Dirac Operator The Dirac Operator in R n is defined to be D := n j=1 e j. x j Note D 2 = n, where n is the Laplacian in R n. The solution of the equation Df = 0 is called a left monogenic function.

9 Almansi-Fischer decomposition Let P k denote the space of Cl n valued monogenic polynomials, homogeneous of degree k and H k be the space of Cl n valued harmonic polynomials homogeneous of degree k. If h k H k then Dh k P k 1. But Dup k 1 (u) = ( n 2k + 2)p k 1 (u), so we have an Almansi-Fischer decomposition H k = P k upk 1. Hence for any h k H k, h k (u) = p k (u) + up k 1 (u). Note that if Df (u) = 0 then f (u) D = f (u)d = 0. So we can talk of right k monogenic polynomials and we have a right Almansi-Fisher decomposition, H k = P k P k 1 ū.

10 Rarita-Schwiger operators R k Suppose U is a domain in R n. Consider a function f : U R n Cl n such that for each x U, f (x, u) is a left monogenic polynomial homogeneous of degree k in u.

11 Rarita-Schwiger operators R k Suppose U is a domain in R n. Consider a function f : U R n Cl n such that for each x U, f (x, u) is a left monogenic polynomial homogeneous of degree k in u. Consider D x f (x, u)

12 Rarita-Schwiger operators R k Suppose U is a domain in R n. Consider a function f : U R n Cl n such that for each x U, f (x, u) is a left monogenic polynomial homogeneous of degree k in u. Consider D x f (x, u) = f 1,k (x, u) + uf 2,k 1 (x, u), where f 1,k (x, u) and f 2,k 1 (x, u) are left monogenic polynomials homogeneous of degree k and k 1 in u respectively.

13 Rarita-Schwiger operators R k Suppose U is a domain in R n. Consider a function f : U R n Cl n such that for each x U, f (x, u) is a left monogenic polynomial homogeneous of degree k in u. Consider D x f (x, u) = f 1,k (x, u) + uf 2,k 1 (x, u), where f 1,k (x, u) and f 2,k 1 (x, u) are left monogenic polynomials homogeneous of degree k and k 1 in u respectively. Let P k be the left projection map P k : H k (= P k upk 1 ) P k, then R k f (x, u) is defined to be P k D x f (x, u). The left Rarita-Schwinger equation is defined to be R k f (x, u) = 0. We also have a right projection P k,r : H k P k, and a right Rarita-Schwinger equation f (x, u)d x P k,r = f (x, u)r k = 0.

14 Are there any non-trivial solutions to the Rarita-Schwinger equation? First for any k-monogenic polynomial p k (u) we have trivially R k p k (u) = 0. Now consider the fundamental solution G(u) = 1 u ω n u n to the Dirac operator D, where ω n is the surface area of the unit sphere, S n 1. Consider the Taylor series expansion of G(v u) and restrict to the kth order terms in u 1,..., u n (u = u 1 e u n e n ). These terms have as vector valued coefficients k v 1 k 1... vn k n G(v) (k k n = k).

15 As DG(v) = n i=1 e G(v) j v j = 0, we can replace by v 1 occurs and collecting v 1 n j=2 e 1 1 e j. Doing this each time v j like terms we obtain a finite series of polynomials homogeneous of degree k in u P σ (u)v σ (v) σ where the summation is taken over all permutations of monogenic polynomials (u 2 u 1 e1 1 e 2),, (u n u 1 e1 1 e n), P σ (u) = 1 k! Σ(u i 1 u 1 e 1 1 e i 1 )... (u ik u 1 e 1 1 e i k ) and V σ (v) = v j 2 2 k G(v)... v jn n, j j n = k.

16 Further V σ (u)up µ (u)ds(u) = δ σ,µ where δ σ,µ is the S Kronecker n 1 delta and µ is a set of n 1 non-negative integers summing to k. Consequently, the expression Z k (u, v) := σ P σ (u)v σ (v)v is the reproducing kernel of P k with respect to integration over S n 1. See [BDS]. Further as Z k (u, v) does not depend on x, R k Z k = 0.

17 Are there any solutions to R k f (x, u) = 0 that depends on x? To answer this we need to look at the links to conformal transformations. Any conformal transformation on R n { } can be expressed as y = φ(x) = (ax + b)(cx + d) 1 where a, b, c, d Cl n and satisfy the following conditions: 1. a, b, c, d are all products of vectors in R n. 2. a b, c d, bc, da R n. 3. a d b c = ±1. When c = 0, φ(x) = (ax + b)(cx + d) 1 = ±axã + bd 1. Now assume c 0, then φ(x) = (ax + b)(cx + d) 1 = ac 1 ± (cx c + d c) 1. These are called Iwasawa decompositions.

18 Conformal invariance of P k Let P k,w and P k,u be the projections with respect to w and u respectively. 1. Orthogonal transformation: Let x = ayã, and u = awã, where a Pin(n). Lemma 1 P k,w ãf (ayã, awã) = ãp k,u f (x, u). 2. Inversion: Let x = y 1, u = ywy y 2. y Lemma 2 P k,w y n f (y 1, ywy y 2 ) = y y n P k,uf (x, u). 3. Translation: x = y + a, a R n. In order to keep the homogeneity of f (x, u) in u, u does not change under translation. Lemma 3 P k f (x, u) = P k f (y + a, u). 4. Dilation: x = λy, where λ R +. Lemma 4 P k f (x, u) = P k f (λy, u).

19 Using the Iwasawa decomposition and combining the previous lemmas, we get the following result: Theorem 1 (cx + d)w(cx + d) P k,w J(φ, x)f (φ(x), cx + d 2 ) = J(φ, x)p k,u f (φ(x), u), (cx where u = + d)w(cx + d) cx cx + d 2 and J(φ, x) = + d cx + d n.

20 Conformal invariance of the equation R k f = 0 The following is known for the Dirac operator cx + d J 1 (φ, x)d y = D x J(φ, x), where J 1 (φ, x) = cx + d n+2. Hence we have Df (y) = 0 iff DJ(φ, x)f (φ(x)) = 0. Now using the Iwasawa decomposition of (ax + b)(cx + d) 1 and the previous theorem, we obtain that (cx + d)w(cx + d) J 1 (φ, x)r k,u f (x, u) = R k,w J(φ, x)f (φ(x), cx + d 2 ), (cx where u = + d)w(cx + d) cx + d 2, and R k,w, R k,u are the Rarita-Schwinger operators with respect to w and u respectively. So R k,u f (x, u) = 0 implies (cx + d)w(cx + d) R k,w J(φ, x)f (φ(x), cx + d 2 ) = 0.

21 The Fundamental Solution of R k Applying inversion to Z k (u, v) from the right we obtain E k (y, u, v) := c k Z k (u, yvy y 2 ) y y n is a non-trivial solution to f (y, v)r k = 0 on R n \ {0}, where c k = n 2 + 2k. n 2 Similarly, applying inversion to Z k (u, v) from the left we can obtain that y c k y n Z k( yuy y 2, v) is a non-trivial solution to R k f (y, u) = 0 on R n \ {0}. In fact, this function is E k (y, u, v), and E k (y, u, v) is the fundamental solution of R k.

22 Basic Integral Formulas Definition 1 For any Cl n valued polynomials P(u), Q(u), the inner product (P(u), Q(u)) u with respect to u is given by (P(u), Q(u)) u = P(u)Q(u)dS(u). S n 1 For any p k P k, one obtains p k (u) = (Z k (u, v), p k (v)) v = Z k (u, v)p k (v)ds(v). S n 1 See [BDS].

23 Basic Integral Formulas Theorem 2 [BSSV] (Stokes Theorem for R k ) Let Ω and Ω be domains in R n and suppose the closure of Ω lies in Ω. Further suppose the closure of Ω is compact and Ω is piecewise smooth. Then for f, g C 1 (Ω,P k ), we have [(g(x, u)r k, f (x, u)) u + (g(x, u), R k f (x, u)) u ]dx n Ω = Ω where dσ x = (g(x, u), P k dσ x f (x, u)) u = n ( 1) j 1 e j d ˆx j and j=1 Ω d ˆx j = dx 1 dx j 1 dx j+1 dx n. (g(x, u)dσ x P k,r, f (x, u)) u,

24 Basic Integral Formulas Theorem 3 [BSSV](Borel-Pompeiu Theorem ) Let Ω and Ω be as in Theorem 2 and y Ω. Then for f C 1 (Ω, P k ) f (y, u) = (E k (x y, u, v), P k dσ x f (x, v)) v Ω (E k (x y, u, v), R k f (x, v)) v dx n. Ω Here we will use the representation (x y)v(x y) x y E k (x y, u, v) = c k Z k (u, x y 2 ) x y n.

25 Basic Integral Formulas Theorem 4 (Cauchy Integral Formula) If R k f (x, v) = 0, then for y Ω, f (y, v) = (E k (x y, u, v), P k dσ x f (x, v)) v Ω = (E k (x y, u, v)dσ x P k,r, f (x, v)) v. Ω Theorem 5 (E k (x y, u, v), R k ψ(x, v)) v dx n = ψ(y, u) R n for each ψ C0 (Rn ).

26 Basic Integral Formulas Definition 2 For a domain Ω R n and a function f : Ω R n Cl n, which is monogenic in u, the Cauchy, or T k -transform, of f is formally defined to be (T k f )(y, v) = (E k (x y, u, v), f (x, u)) u dx n, y Ω. Ω Theorem 6 R k T k ψ = ψ for ψ C 0 (Rn ). i.e R k R n (E k (x y, u, v), ψ(x, u)) u dx n = ψ(y, v).

27 References L. V. Ahlfors, Old and new in Möbius groups, Ann. Acad. Sci. Fenn. Ser. A I Math., 9 (1984) F. Brackx, R. Delanghe, and F. Sommen, Clifford Analysis, Pitman, London, J. Bureš, F. Sommen, V. Souček, P. Van Lancker, Rarita-Schwinger Type Operators in Clifford Analysis, J. Funct. Annl. 185 (2001), No.2, C. Dunkl and Y. Xu, Orthogonal Polynomials of Several Variables, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, A. Sudbery, Quaternionic Analysis, Mathematical Procedings of the Cambridge Phlosophical Society, (1979), 85, K. Th. Vahlen, Über Bewegungen und complexe zahlen, (German) Math. Ann., 55(1902), No

Some Rarita-Schwinger Type Operators

Some Rarita-Schwinger Type Operators Some Rarita-Schwinger Type Operators Junxia Li University of Arkansas March 17-19, 2011 University of Florida 27th South Eastern Analysis Meeting, Gainesville, FL Introduction In representation theory

More information

RARITA-SCHWINGER TYPE OPERATORS ON SPHERES AND REAL PROJECTIVE SPACE. Junxia Li, John Ryan, and Carmen J. Vanegas

RARITA-SCHWINGER TYPE OPERATORS ON SPHERES AND REAL PROJECTIVE SPACE. Junxia Li, John Ryan, and Carmen J. Vanegas ARCHIVUM MATHEMATICUM BRNO Tomus 48 2012, 271 289 RARITA-CHWINGER TYPE OPERATOR ON PHERE AND REAL PROJECTIVE PACE Junxia Li, John Ryan, and Carmen J. Vanegas Abstract. In this paper we deal with Rarita-chwinger

More information

f k j M k j Among them we recognize the gradient operator on polynomial-valued functions which is part of the complete gradient (see [9]) u j xj.

f k j M k j Among them we recognize the gradient operator on polynomial-valued functions which is part of the complete gradient (see [9]) u j xj. Advances in Applied Clifford Algebras 4, No. 1 (1994) 65 FUNCTIONS OF TWO VECTOR VARIABLES F. Sommen* and N. Van Acker Department of Mathematical Analysis, University of Gent, Galglaan 2 B-9000 Gent, Belgium

More information

Archiv der Mathematik Holomorphic approximation of L2-functions on the unit sphere in R^3

Archiv der Mathematik Holomorphic approximation of L2-functions on the unit sphere in R^3 Manuscript Number: Archiv der Mathematik Holomorphic approximation of L-functions on the unit sphere in R^ --Manuscript Draft-- Full Title: Article Type: Corresponding Author: Holomorphic approximation

More information

Some Sharp L 2 Inequalities for Dirac Type Operators

Some Sharp L 2 Inequalities for Dirac Type Operators ymmetry, Integrability and Geometry: Methods and Applications IGMA 3 007), 4, 0 pages ome harp L Inequalities for Dirac Type Operators Alexander BALINKY and John RYAN Cardif f chool of Mathematics, Cardif

More information

Fischer decomposition by inframonogenic functions

Fischer decomposition by inframonogenic functions CUBO A Mathematical Journal Vol.12, N ō 02, 189 197. June 2010 Fischer decomposition by inframonogenic functions Helmuth R. Malonek 1, Dixan Peña Peña 2 Department of Mathematics, Aveiro University, 3810-193

More information

Motivation towards Clifford Analysis: The classical Cauchy s Integral Theorem from a Clifford perspective

Motivation towards Clifford Analysis: The classical Cauchy s Integral Theorem from a Clifford perspective Motivation towards Clifford Analysis: The classical Cauchy s Integral Theorem from a Clifford perspective Lashi Bandara November 26, 29 Abstract Clifford Algebras generalise complex variables algebraically

More information

A CAUCHY-KOWALEVSKI THEOREM FOR INFRAMONOGENIC FUNCTIONS

A CAUCHY-KOWALEVSKI THEOREM FOR INFRAMONOGENIC FUNCTIONS Math. J. Okayama Univ. 53 (2011, 167 172 A CAUCHY-KOWALEVSKI THEOREM FOR INFRAMONOGENIC FUNCTIONS Helmuth R. MALONEK, Dian PEÑA PEÑA and Frank SOMMEN Abstract. In this paper we prove a Cauchy-Kowalevski

More information

Recent results in discrete Clifford analysis

Recent results in discrete Clifford analysis Recent results in discrete Clifford analysis Hilde De Ridder joint work with F. Sommen Department of Mathematical Analysis, Ghent University Mathematical Optics, Image Modelling and Algorithms 2016 0 /

More information

The Fueter Theorem and Dirac symmetries

The Fueter Theorem and Dirac symmetries The Fueter Theorem and Dirac symmetries David Eelbode Departement of Mathematics and Computer Science University of Antwerp (partially joint work with V. Souček and P. Van Lancker) General overview of

More information

The Cauchy Kovalevskaya Extension Theorem in Hermitean Clifford Analysis

The Cauchy Kovalevskaya Extension Theorem in Hermitean Clifford Analysis The Cauchy Kovalevskaya Extension Theorem in Hermitean Clifford Analysis F Brackx, H De Schepper, R Lávička & V Souček Clifford Research Group, Faculty of Engineering, Ghent University Building S22, Galglaan

More information

Master Algèbre géométrie et théorie des nombres Final exam of differential geometry Lecture notes allowed

Master Algèbre géométrie et théorie des nombres Final exam of differential geometry Lecture notes allowed Université de Bordeaux U.F. Mathématiques et Interactions Master Algèbre géométrie et théorie des nombres Final exam of differential geometry 2018-2019 Lecture notes allowed Exercise 1 We call H (like

More information

Clifford Algebras and Spin Groups

Clifford Algebras and Spin Groups Clifford Algebras and Spin Groups Math G4344, Spring 2012 We ll now turn from the general theory to examine a specific class class of groups: the orthogonal groups. Recall that O(n, R) is the group of

More information

Algebra I Fall 2007

Algebra I Fall 2007 MIT OpenCourseWare http://ocw.mit.edu 18.701 Algebra I Fall 007 For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use, visit: http://ocw.mit.edu/terms. 18.701 007 Geometry of the Special Unitary

More information

arxiv: v1 [math.ca] 9 Jan 2019

arxiv: v1 [math.ca] 9 Jan 2019 On Structure of Octonion Regular Functions arxiv:1901.02718v1 [math.ca] 9 Jan 2019 Janne Kauhanen Mathematics Tampere University FI-33014 Tampere University Finland janne.kauhanen@tuni.fi January 10, 2019

More information

THE LEGENDRE FORMULA IN CLIFFORD ANALYSIS. Guy Laville, Ivan Ramadanoff

THE LEGENDRE FORMULA IN CLIFFORD ANALYSIS. Guy Laville, Ivan Ramadanoff Serdica Math. J. 35 (2009), 61 74 THE LEGENDRE FORMULA IN CLIFFORD ANALYSIS Guy Laville, Ivan Ramadanoff Communicated by P. Pflug Abstract. Let R 0,2m+1 be the Clifford algebra of the antieuclidean 2m+1

More information

On primitives and conjugate harmonic pairs in Hermitean Clifford analysis

On primitives and conjugate harmonic pairs in Hermitean Clifford analysis On primitives and conjugate harmonic pairs in Hermitean Clifford analysis F. Brackx, H. De Schepper, R. Lávička & V. Souček Clifford Research Group, Department of Mathematical Analysis, Faculty of Engineering

More information

Conjugate Harmonic Functions and Clifford Algebras

Conjugate Harmonic Functions and Clifford Algebras Conjugate Harmonic Functions and Clifford Algebras Craig A. Nolder Department of Mathematics Florida State University Tallahassee, FL 32306-450, USA nolder@math.fsu.edu Abstract We generalize a Hardy-Littlewood

More information

Representation Theory

Representation Theory Representation Theory Representations Let G be a group and V a vector space over a field k. A representation of G on V is a group homomorphism ρ : G Aut(V ). The degree (or dimension) of ρ is just dim

More information

Rarita Schwinger Type Operators in Clifford Analysis

Rarita Schwinger Type Operators in Clifford Analysis Journal of Functional Analysis 85, 45 455 (00) doi:0.006/jfan.00.378, available online at http://www.idealibrary.com on Rarita Schwinger Type Operators in Clifford Analysis J. Bureš Mathematical Institute,

More information

Polynomial solutions for arbitrary higher spin Dirac operators

Polynomial solutions for arbitrary higher spin Dirac operators Polynomial solutions for arbitrary higher spin Dirac operators D Eelbode T Raeymaekers Abstract In a series of recent papers, we have introduced higher spin Dirac operators, which are far-reaching generalisations

More information

REPRODUCING KERNELS OF SPACES OF VECTOR VALUED MONOGENICS

REPRODUCING KERNELS OF SPACES OF VECTOR VALUED MONOGENICS REPRODUCING KERNELS OF SPACES OF VECTOR VALUED MONOGENICS J. Cnops RUG, Galglaan 2, B-9 Gent, Belgium Abstract. An important class of monogenic functions is that of vector valued monogenic functions, i.e.

More information

Hendrik De Bie. Hong Kong, March 2011

Hendrik De Bie. Hong Kong, March 2011 A Ghent University (joint work with B. Ørsted, P. Somberg and V. Soucek) Hong Kong, March 2011 A Classical FT New realizations of sl 2 in harmonic analysis A Outline Classical FT New realizations of sl

More information

The Monogenic Fischer Decomposition: Two Vector Variables

The Monogenic Fischer Decomposition: Two Vector Variables The Monogenic Fischer Decomposition: Two Vector Variables P. Van Lancker May 8, 2011 Abstract In this paper we will present two proofs of the monogenic Fischer decomposition in two vector variables. The

More information

AN INTEGRAL FORMULA OF HYPERBOLIC TYPE FOR SOLUTIONS OF THE DIRAC EQUATION ON MINKOWSKI SPACE WITH INITIAL CONDITIONS ON A HYPERBOLOID.

AN INTEGRAL FORMULA OF HYPERBOLIC TYPE FOR SOLUTIONS OF THE DIRAC EQUATION ON MINKOWSKI SPACE WITH INITIAL CONDITIONS ON A HYPERBOLOID. ARCHIVUM MATHEMATICUM BRNO) Tomus 46 010), 363 376 AN INTEGRAL FORMULA OF HYPERBOLIC TYPE FOR SOLUTIONS OF THE DIRAC EQUATION ON MINKOWSKI SPACE WITH INITIAL CONDITIONS ON A HYPERBOLOID Martin Sikora Abstract.

More information

APPENDIX A. Background Mathematics. A.1 Linear Algebra. Vector algebra. Let x denote the n-dimensional column vector with components x 1 x 2.

APPENDIX A. Background Mathematics. A.1 Linear Algebra. Vector algebra. Let x denote the n-dimensional column vector with components x 1 x 2. APPENDIX A Background Mathematics A. Linear Algebra A.. Vector algebra Let x denote the n-dimensional column vector with components 0 x x 2 B C @. A x n Definition 6 (scalar product). The scalar product

More information

Conformally invariant differential operators

Conformally invariant differential operators Spring Lecture Two at the University of Arkansas p. 1/15 Conformal differential geometry and its interaction with representation theory Conformally invariant differential operators Michael Eastwood Australian

More information

THE HOWE DUALITY FOR HODGE SYSTEMS

THE HOWE DUALITY FOR HODGE SYSTEMS 18 th International Conference on the Application of Computer Science and Mathematics in Architecture and Civil Engineering K. Gürlebeck and C. Könke (eds.) Weimar, Germany, 07 09 July 009 THE HOWE DUALITY

More information

Quantum Computing Lecture 2. Review of Linear Algebra

Quantum Computing Lecture 2. Review of Linear Algebra Quantum Computing Lecture 2 Review of Linear Algebra Maris Ozols Linear algebra States of a quantum system form a vector space and their transformations are described by linear operators Vector spaces

More information

Algebraic structures I

Algebraic structures I MTH5100 Assignment 1-10 Algebraic structures I For handing in on various dates January March 2011 1 FUNCTIONS. Say which of the following rules successfully define functions, giving reasons. For each one

More information

Vectors in Function Spaces

Vectors in Function Spaces Jim Lambers MAT 66 Spring Semester 15-16 Lecture 18 Notes These notes correspond to Section 6.3 in the text. Vectors in Function Spaces We begin with some necessary terminology. A vector space V, also

More information

Totally quasi-umbilic timelike surfaces in R 1,2

Totally quasi-umbilic timelike surfaces in R 1,2 Totally quasi-umbilic timelike surfaces in R 1,2 Jeanne N. Clelland, University of Colorado AMS Central Section Meeting Macalester College April 11, 2010 Definition: Three-dimensional Minkowski space R

More information

The Spinor Representation

The Spinor Representation The Spinor Representation Math G4344, Spring 2012 As we have seen, the groups Spin(n) have a representation on R n given by identifying v R n as an element of the Clifford algebra C(n) and having g Spin(n)

More information

Clifford Analysis on Super-Space

Clifford Analysis on Super-Space 18 Clifford Analysis on Super-Space This is page 291 Printer: Opaque this F. Sommen University of Gent, Department of Mathematical Analysis Galglaan 2, B-9000 Gent, Belgium ABSTRACT In this paper we further

More information

The Cylindrical Fourier Transform

The Cylindrical Fourier Transform The Cylindrical Fourier Transform Fred Brackx, Nele De Schepper, and Frank Sommen Abstract In this paper we devise a so-called cylindrical Fourier transform within the Clifford analysis context. The idea

More information

Math 225B: Differential Geometry, Final

Math 225B: Differential Geometry, Final Math 225B: Differential Geometry, Final Ian Coley March 5, 204 Problem Spring 20,. Show that if X is a smooth vector field on a (smooth) manifold of dimension n and if X p is nonzero for some point of

More information

Lecture 14 Conformal Mapping. 1 Conformality. 1.1 Preservation of angle. 1.2 Length and area. MATH-GA Complex Variables

Lecture 14 Conformal Mapping. 1 Conformality. 1.1 Preservation of angle. 1.2 Length and area. MATH-GA Complex Variables Lecture 14 Conformal Mapping MATH-GA 2451.001 Complex Variables 1 Conformality 1.1 Preservation of angle The open mapping theorem tells us that an analytic function such that f (z 0 ) 0 maps a small neighborhood

More information

Models for Irreducible Representations of Spin(m)

Models for Irreducible Representations of Spin(m) 17 Models for Irreducible Representations of Spin(m) This is page 271 Printer: Opaque this P. Van Lancker, F. Sommen and D. Constales ABSTRACT In this paper we consider harmonic and monogenic polynomials

More information

Qualifying Exams I, 2014 Spring

Qualifying Exams I, 2014 Spring Qualifying Exams I, 2014 Spring 1. (Algebra) Let k = F q be a finite field with q elements. Count the number of monic irreducible polynomials of degree 12 over k. 2. (Algebraic Geometry) (a) Show that

More information

Linear Algebra and Dirac Notation, Pt. 3

Linear Algebra and Dirac Notation, Pt. 3 Linear Algebra and Dirac Notation, Pt. 3 PHYS 500 - Southern Illinois University February 1, 2017 PHYS 500 - Southern Illinois University Linear Algebra and Dirac Notation, Pt. 3 February 1, 2017 1 / 16

More information

Math 201C Homework. Edward Burkard. g 1 (u) v + f 2(u) g 2 (u) v2 + + f n(u) a 2,k u k v a 1,k u k v + k=0. k=0 d

Math 201C Homework. Edward Burkard. g 1 (u) v + f 2(u) g 2 (u) v2 + + f n(u) a 2,k u k v a 1,k u k v + k=0. k=0 d Math 201C Homework Edward Burkard 5.1. Field Extensions. 5. Fields and Galois Theory Exercise 5.1.7. If v is algebraic over K(u) for some u F and v is transcendental over K, then u is algebraic over K(v).

More information

arxiv:math/ v1 [math.ag] 18 Oct 2003

arxiv:math/ v1 [math.ag] 18 Oct 2003 Proc. Indian Acad. Sci. (Math. Sci.) Vol. 113, No. 2, May 2003, pp. 139 152. Printed in India The Jacobian of a nonorientable Klein surface arxiv:math/0310288v1 [math.ag] 18 Oct 2003 PABLO ARÉS-GASTESI

More information

Physics 342 Lecture 2. Linear Algebra I. Lecture 2. Physics 342 Quantum Mechanics I

Physics 342 Lecture 2. Linear Algebra I. Lecture 2. Physics 342 Quantum Mechanics I Physics 342 Lecture 2 Linear Algebra I Lecture 2 Physics 342 Quantum Mechanics I Wednesday, January 27th, 21 From separation of variables, we move to linear algebra Roughly speaking, this is the study

More information

LECTURE 16: LIE GROUPS AND THEIR LIE ALGEBRAS. 1. Lie groups

LECTURE 16: LIE GROUPS AND THEIR LIE ALGEBRAS. 1. Lie groups LECTURE 16: LIE GROUPS AND THEIR LIE ALGEBRAS 1. Lie groups A Lie group is a special smooth manifold on which there is a group structure, and moreover, the two structures are compatible. Lie groups are

More information

arxiv: v2 [math.cv] 2 Nov 2017

arxiv: v2 [math.cv] 2 Nov 2017 Segal-Bargmann-Fock modules of monogenic functions arxiv:608.06790v [math.cv] Nov 07 Dixan Peña Peña Dipartimento di Matematica Politecnico di Milano Via E. Bonardi 9 033 Milano, Italy e-mail: dixanpena@gmail.com

More information

On higher order Cauchy-Pompeiu formula in Clifford analysis and its applications

On higher order Cauchy-Pompeiu formula in Clifford analysis and its applications General Mathematics Vol. 11, No. 3 4 (2003), 5 26 On higher order Cauchy-Pompeiu formula in Clifford analysis and its applications Heinrich Begehr, Du Jinyuan, Zhang Zhongxiang Abstract In this paper,

More information

ALGEBRAIC ANALYSIS OF THE RARITA SCHWINGER SYSTEM IN REAL DIMENSION THREE

ALGEBRAIC ANALYSIS OF THE RARITA SCHWINGER SYSTEM IN REAL DIMENSION THREE ARCHIVUM MATHEMATICUM (BRNO) Tomus 42 (2006), Supplement, 197 211 ALGEBRAIC ANALYSIS OF THE RARITA SCHWINGER SYSTEM IN REAL DIMENSION THREE ALBERTO DAMIANO Abstract. In this paper we use the explicit description

More information

10. Smooth Varieties. 82 Andreas Gathmann

10. Smooth Varieties. 82 Andreas Gathmann 82 Andreas Gathmann 10. Smooth Varieties Let a be a point on a variety X. In the last chapter we have introduced the tangent cone C a X as a way to study X locally around a (see Construction 9.20). It

More information

Tensor Product of modules. MA499 Project II

Tensor Product of modules. MA499 Project II Tensor Product of modules A Project Report Submitted for the Course MA499 Project II by Subhash Atal (Roll No. 07012321) to the DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY GUWAHATI GUWAHATI

More information

Representation Theory

Representation Theory Part II Year 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2018 Paper 1, Section II 19I 93 (a) Define the derived subgroup, G, of a finite group G. Show that if χ is a linear character

More information

Topics in Representation Theory: Fourier Analysis and the Peter Weyl Theorem

Topics in Representation Theory: Fourier Analysis and the Peter Weyl Theorem Topics in Representation Theory: Fourier Analysis and the Peter Weyl Theorem 1 Fourier Analysis, a review We ll begin with a short review of simple facts about Fourier analysis, before going on to interpret

More information

Inequalities of Babuška-Aziz and Friedrichs-Velte for differential forms

Inequalities of Babuška-Aziz and Friedrichs-Velte for differential forms Inequalities of Babuška-Aziz and Friedrichs-Velte for differential forms Martin Costabel Abstract. For sufficiently smooth bounded plane domains, the equivalence between the inequalities of Babuška Aziz

More information

The spectral action for Dirac operators with torsion

The spectral action for Dirac operators with torsion The spectral action for Dirac operators with torsion Christoph A. Stephan joint work with Florian Hanisch & Frank Pfäffle Institut für athematik Universität Potsdam Tours, ai 2011 1 Torsion Geometry, Einstein-Cartan-Theory

More information

Mapping problems and harmonic univalent mappings

Mapping problems and harmonic univalent mappings Mapping problems and harmonic univalent mappings Antti Rasila Helsinki University of Technology antti.rasila@tkk.fi (Mainly based on P. Duren s book Harmonic mappings in the plane) Helsinki Analysis Seminar,

More information

Linear Algebra using Dirac Notation: Pt. 2

Linear Algebra using Dirac Notation: Pt. 2 Linear Algebra using Dirac Notation: Pt. 2 PHYS 476Q - Southern Illinois University February 6, 2018 PHYS 476Q - Southern Illinois University Linear Algebra using Dirac Notation: Pt. 2 February 6, 2018

More information

Fix(g). Orb(x) i=1. O i G. i=1. O i. i=1 x O i. = n G

Fix(g). Orb(x) i=1. O i G. i=1. O i. i=1 x O i. = n G Math 761 Fall 2015 Homework 4 Drew Armstrong Problem 1 Burnside s Lemma Let X be a G-set and for all g G define the set Fix(g : {x X : g(x x} X (a If G and X are finite, prove that Fix(g Stab(x g G x X

More information

FREMLIN TENSOR PRODUCTS OF CONCAVIFICATIONS OF BANACH LATTICES

FREMLIN TENSOR PRODUCTS OF CONCAVIFICATIONS OF BANACH LATTICES FREMLIN TENSOR PRODUCTS OF CONCAVIFICATIONS OF BANACH LATTICES VLADIMIR G. TROITSKY AND OMID ZABETI Abstract. Suppose that E is a uniformly complete vector lattice and p 1,..., p n are positive reals.

More information

Symmetries, Fields and Particles 2013 Solutions

Symmetries, Fields and Particles 2013 Solutions Symmetries, Fields and Particles 013 Solutions Yichen Shi Easter 014 1. (a) Define the groups SU() and SO(3), and find their Lie algebras. Show that these Lie algebras, including their bracket structure,

More information

Parallel and Killing Spinors on Spin c Manifolds. 1 Introduction. Andrei Moroianu 1

Parallel and Killing Spinors on Spin c Manifolds. 1 Introduction. Andrei Moroianu 1 Parallel and Killing Spinors on Spin c Manifolds Andrei Moroianu Institut für reine Mathematik, Ziegelstr. 3a, 0099 Berlin, Germany E-mail: moroianu@mathematik.hu-berlin.de Abstract: We describe all simply

More information

which is a group homomorphism, such that if W V U, then

which is a group homomorphism, such that if W V U, then 4. Sheaves Definition 4.1. Let X be a topological space. A presheaf of groups F on X is a a function which assigns to every open set U X a group F(U) and to every inclusion V U a restriction map, ρ UV

More information

Physics 342 Lecture 2. Linear Algebra I. Lecture 2. Physics 342 Quantum Mechanics I

Physics 342 Lecture 2. Linear Algebra I. Lecture 2. Physics 342 Quantum Mechanics I Physics 342 Lecture 2 Linear Algebra I Lecture 2 Physics 342 Quantum Mechanics I Wednesday, January 3th, 28 From separation of variables, we move to linear algebra Roughly speaking, this is the study of

More information

SYMPLECTIC GEOMETRY: LECTURE 1

SYMPLECTIC GEOMETRY: LECTURE 1 SYMPLECTIC GEOMETRY: LECTURE 1 LIAT KESSLER 1. Symplectic Linear Algebra Symplectic vector spaces. Let V be a finite dimensional real vector space and ω 2 V, i.e., ω is a bilinear antisymmetric 2-form:

More information

Linear Algebra in Hilbert Space

Linear Algebra in Hilbert Space Physics 342 Lecture 16 Linear Algebra in Hilbert Space Lecture 16 Physics 342 Quantum Mechanics I Monday, March 1st, 2010 We have seen the importance of the plane wave solutions to the potentialfree Schrödinger

More information

NOTES ON NEWLANDER-NIRENBERG THEOREM XU WANG

NOTES ON NEWLANDER-NIRENBERG THEOREM XU WANG NOTES ON NEWLANDER-NIRENBERG THEOREM XU WANG Abstract. In this short note we shall recall the classical Newler-Nirenberg theorem its vector bundle version. We shall also recall an L 2 -Hörmer-proof given

More information

Lecture notes on Quantum Computing. Chapter 1 Mathematical Background

Lecture notes on Quantum Computing. Chapter 1 Mathematical Background Lecture notes on Quantum Computing Chapter 1 Mathematical Background Vector states of a quantum system with n physical states are represented by unique vectors in C n, the set of n 1 column vectors 1 For

More information

Problems in Linear Algebra and Representation Theory

Problems in Linear Algebra and Representation Theory Problems in Linear Algebra and Representation Theory (Most of these were provided by Victor Ginzburg) The problems appearing below have varying level of difficulty. They are not listed in any specific

More information

MP463 QUANTUM MECHANICS

MP463 QUANTUM MECHANICS MP463 QUANTUM MECHANICS Introduction Quantum theory of angular momentum Quantum theory of a particle in a central potential - Hydrogen atom - Three-dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillator (a model of

More information

Group theory - QMII 2017

Group theory - QMII 2017 Group theory - QMII 7 Daniel Aloni References. Lecture notes - Gilad Perez. Lie algebra in particle physics - H. Georgi. Google... Motivation As a warm up let us motivate the need for Group theory in physics.

More information

The Schrodinger Wave Equation (Engel 2.4) In QM, the behavior of a particle is described by its wave function Ψ(x,t) which we get by solving:

The Schrodinger Wave Equation (Engel 2.4) In QM, the behavior of a particle is described by its wave function Ψ(x,t) which we get by solving: When do we use Quantum Mechanics? (Engel 2.1) Basically, when λ is close in magnitude to the dimensions of the problem, and to the degree that the system has a discrete energy spectrum The Schrodinger

More information

Dunkl operators and Clifford algebras II

Dunkl operators and Clifford algebras II Translation operator for the Clifford Research Group Department of Mathematical Analysis Ghent University Hong Kong, March, 2011 Translation operator for the Hermite polynomials Translation operator for

More information

Properties of Transformations

Properties of Transformations 6. - 6.4 Properties of Transformations P. Danziger Transformations from R n R m. General Transformations A general transformation maps vectors in R n to vectors in R m. We write T : R n R m to indicate

More information

Hilbert Space Problems

Hilbert Space Problems Hilbert Space Problems Prescribed books for problems. ) Hilbert Spaces, Wavelets, Generalized Functions and Modern Quantum Mechanics by Willi-Hans Steeb Kluwer Academic Publishers, 998 ISBN -7923-523-9

More information

Phase Derivative of Monogenic Signals in Higher Dimensional Spaces

Phase Derivative of Monogenic Signals in Higher Dimensional Spaces Phase Derivative of Monogenic Signals in Higher Dimensional Spaces Yan Yang, Tao Qian, Frank Sommen School of Mathematics and Computational Science, Sun Yat-Sen University, Department of Mathematics, Faculty

More information

NOTES IN COMMUTATIVE ALGEBRA: PART 2

NOTES IN COMMUTATIVE ALGEBRA: PART 2 NOTES IN COMMUTATIVE ALGEBRA: PART 2 KELLER VANDEBOGERT 1. Completion of a Ring/Module Here we shall consider two seemingly different constructions for the completion of a module and show that indeed they

More information

ARCS IN FINITE PROJECTIVE SPACES. Basic objects and definitions

ARCS IN FINITE PROJECTIVE SPACES. Basic objects and definitions ARCS IN FINITE PROJECTIVE SPACES SIMEON BALL Abstract. These notes are an outline of a course on arcs given at the Finite Geometry Summer School, University of Sussex, June 26-30, 2017. Let K denote an

More information

Linear Ordinary Differential Equations

Linear Ordinary Differential Equations MTH.B402; Sect. 1 20180703) 2 Linear Ordinary Differential Equations Preliminaries: Matrix Norms. Denote by M n R) the set of n n matrix with real components, which can be identified the vector space R

More information

THE EULER CHARACTERISTIC OF A LIE GROUP

THE EULER CHARACTERISTIC OF A LIE GROUP THE EULER CHARACTERISTIC OF A LIE GROUP JAY TAYLOR 1 Examples of Lie Groups The following is adapted from [2] We begin with the basic definition and some core examples Definition A Lie group is a smooth

More information

Exercises in Geometry II University of Bonn, Summer semester 2015 Professor: Prof. Christian Blohmann Assistant: Saskia Voss Sheet 1

Exercises in Geometry II University of Bonn, Summer semester 2015 Professor: Prof. Christian Blohmann Assistant: Saskia Voss Sheet 1 Assistant: Saskia Voss Sheet 1 1. Conformal change of Riemannian metrics [3 points] Let (M, g) be a Riemannian manifold. A conformal change is a nonnegative function λ : M (0, ). Such a function defines

More information

Risi Kondor, The University of Chicago

Risi Kondor, The University of Chicago Risi Kondor, The University of Chicago Data: {(x 1, y 1 ),, (x m, y m )} algorithm Hypothesis: f : x y 2 2/53 {(x 1, y 1 ),, (x m, y m )} {(ϕ(x 1 ), y 1 ),, (ϕ(x m ), y m )} algorithm Hypothesis: f : ϕ(x)

More information

On generalized Helmholtz type equations in concentric annular domains in R 3

On generalized Helmholtz type equations in concentric annular domains in R 3 On generalied Helmholt type equations in concentric annular domains in R 3 Denis Constales Dennis Grob Rolf Sören Kraußhar October 30, 2008 Abstract In this paper we consider inhomogeneous generalied Helmholt

More information

A Mean-Value Theorem for Some Eigenfunctions of the Laplace- Beltrami Operator on the Upper-Half Space

A Mean-Value Theorem for Some Eigenfunctions of the Laplace- Beltrami Operator on the Upper-Half Space Tampereen teknillinen yliopisto. Matematiikan laitos. Tutkimusraportti 97 Tampere University of Technology. Department of Mathematics. Research Report 97 Sirkka-Liisa Eriksson & Heikki Orelma A Mean-Value

More information

DIFFERENTIAL GEOMETRY HW 12

DIFFERENTIAL GEOMETRY HW 12 DIFFERENTIAL GEOMETRY HW 1 CLAY SHONKWILER 3 Find the Lie algebra so(n) of the special orthogonal group SO(n), and the explicit formula for the Lie bracket there. Proof. Since SO(n) is a subgroup of GL(n),

More information

Finite-dimensional spaces. C n is the space of n-tuples x = (x 1,..., x n ) of complex numbers. It is a Hilbert space with the inner product

Finite-dimensional spaces. C n is the space of n-tuples x = (x 1,..., x n ) of complex numbers. It is a Hilbert space with the inner product Chapter 4 Hilbert Spaces 4.1 Inner Product Spaces Inner Product Space. A complex vector space E is called an inner product space (or a pre-hilbert space, or a unitary space) if there is a mapping (, )

More information

TWISTOR AND KILLING FORMS IN RIEMANNIAN GEOMETRY

TWISTOR AND KILLING FORMS IN RIEMANNIAN GEOMETRY TWISTOR AND KILLING FORMS IN RIEMANNIAN GEOMETRY Andrei Moroianu CNRS - Ecole Polytechnique Palaiseau Prague, September 1 st, 2004 joint work with Uwe Semmelmann Plan of the talk Algebraic preliminaries

More information

9. The Lie group Lie algebra correspondence

9. The Lie group Lie algebra correspondence 9. The Lie group Lie algebra correspondence 9.1. The functor Lie. The fundamental theorems of Lie concern the correspondence G Lie(G). The work of Lie was essentially local and led to the following fundamental

More information

Since G is a compact Lie group, we can apply Schur orthogonality to see that G χ π (g) 2 dg =

Since G is a compact Lie group, we can apply Schur orthogonality to see that G χ π (g) 2 dg = Problem 1 Show that if π is an irreducible representation of a compact lie group G then π is also irreducible. Give an example of a G and π such that π = π, and another for which π π. Is this true for

More information

MATH 4030 Differential Geometry Lecture Notes Part 4 last revised on December 4, Elementary tensor calculus

MATH 4030 Differential Geometry Lecture Notes Part 4 last revised on December 4, Elementary tensor calculus MATH 4030 Differential Geometry Lecture Notes Part 4 last revised on December 4, 205 Elementary tensor calculus We will study in this section some basic multilinear algebra and operations on tensors. Let

More information

LECTURE Itineraries We start with a simple example of a dynamical system obtained by iterating the quadratic polynomial

LECTURE Itineraries We start with a simple example of a dynamical system obtained by iterating the quadratic polynomial LECTURE. Itineraries We start with a simple example of a dynamical system obtained by iterating the quadratic polynomial f λ : R R x λx( x), where λ [, 4). Starting with the critical point x 0 := /2, we

More information

Chapter 7: Bounded Operators in Hilbert Spaces

Chapter 7: Bounded Operators in Hilbert Spaces Chapter 7: Bounded Operators in Hilbert Spaces I-Liang Chern Department of Applied Mathematics National Chiao Tung University and Department of Mathematics National Taiwan University Fall, 2013 1 / 84

More information

Week 2 Notes, Math 865, Tanveer

Week 2 Notes, Math 865, Tanveer Week 2 Notes, Math 865, Tanveer 1. Incompressible constant density equations in different forms Recall we derived the Navier-Stokes equation for incompressible constant density, i.e. homogeneous flows:

More information

MATH 590: Meshfree Methods

MATH 590: Meshfree Methods MATH 590: Meshfree Methods Chapter 14: The Power Function and Native Space Error Estimates Greg Fasshauer Department of Applied Mathematics Illinois Institute of Technology Fall 2010 fasshauer@iit.edu

More information

Analysis in weighted spaces : preliminary version

Analysis in weighted spaces : preliminary version Analysis in weighted spaces : preliminary version Frank Pacard To cite this version: Frank Pacard. Analysis in weighted spaces : preliminary version. 3rd cycle. Téhéran (Iran, 2006, pp.75.

More information

QUATERNIONS AND ROTATIONS

QUATERNIONS AND ROTATIONS QUATERNIONS AND ROTATIONS SVANTE JANSON 1. Introduction The purpose of this note is to show some well-known relations between quaternions and the Lie groups SO(3) and SO(4) (rotations in R 3 and R 4 )

More information

Introduction to Modern Quantum Field Theory

Introduction to Modern Quantum Field Theory Department of Mathematics University of Texas at Arlington Arlington, TX USA Febuary, 2016 Recall Einstein s famous equation, E 2 = (Mc 2 ) 2 + (c p) 2, where c is the speed of light, M is the classical

More information

A Tilt at TILFs. Rod Nillsen University of Wollongong. This talk is dedicated to Gary H. Meisters

A Tilt at TILFs. Rod Nillsen University of Wollongong. This talk is dedicated to Gary H. Meisters A Tilt at TILFs Rod Nillsen University of Wollongong This talk is dedicated to Gary H. Meisters Abstract In this talk I will endeavour to give an overview of some aspects of the theory of Translation Invariant

More information

Math113: Linear Algebra. Beifang Chen

Math113: Linear Algebra. Beifang Chen Math3: Linear Algebra Beifang Chen Spring 26 Contents Systems of Linear Equations 3 Systems of Linear Equations 3 Linear Systems 3 2 Geometric Interpretation 3 3 Matrices of Linear Systems 4 4 Elementary

More information

Decomposition of a recursive family of polynomials

Decomposition of a recursive family of polynomials Decomposition of a recursive family of polynomials Andrej Dujella and Ivica Gusić Abstract We describe decomposition of polynomials f n := f n,b,a defined by f 0 := B, f 1 (x := x, f n+1 (x = xf n (x af

More information

Generalized nonparametric tests for one-sample location problem based on sub-samples

Generalized nonparametric tests for one-sample location problem based on sub-samples ProbStat Forum, Volume 5, October 212, Pages 112 123 ISSN 974-3235 ProbStat Forum is an e-journal. For details please visit www.probstat.org.in Generalized nonparametric tests for one-sample location problem

More information

MULTISECTION METHOD AND FURTHER FORMULAE FOR π. De-Yin Zheng

MULTISECTION METHOD AND FURTHER FORMULAE FOR π. De-Yin Zheng Indian J. pure appl. Math., 39(: 37-55, April 008 c Printed in India. MULTISECTION METHOD AND FURTHER FORMULAE FOR π De-Yin Zheng Department of Mathematics, Hangzhou Normal University, Hangzhou 30036,

More information

ν(u, v) = N(u, v) G(r(u, v)) E r(u,v) 3.

ν(u, v) = N(u, v) G(r(u, v)) E r(u,v) 3. 5. The Gauss Curvature Beyond doubt, the notion of Gauss curvature is of paramount importance in differential geometry. Recall two lessons we have learned so far about this notion: first, the presence

More information