arxiv:gr-qc/ v3 17 Jul 2003

Transcription

1 REGULAR INFLATIONARY COSMOLOGY AND GAUGE THEORIES OF GRAVITATION A. V. Minkevich 1 Department of Theoretical Physics, Belarussian State University, av. F. Skoriny 4, 0050, Minsk, Belarus, phone: , fax: arxiv:gr-qc/030706v3 17 Jul 003 Department of Physics and Computer Methods, Warmia and Mazury University in Olsztyn, Poland MinkAV@bsu.by; awm@matman.uwm.edu.pl Abstract. Cosmological equations for homogeneous isotropic models filled by scalar fields and ultrarelativistic matter are investigated in the framework of gauge theories of gravity. Regular inflationary cosmological models of flat, closed and open type with dominating ultrarelativistic matter at a bounce are discussed. It is shown that generic feature of flat inflationary cosmological models is their bouncing character. PACS numbers: 040J, 0450, 1115, 9880 KEYWORDS: Cosmological singularity, bounce, inflation, gauge theories of gravity 1 Introduction It is known that inflationary scenario plays the important role in the early Universe theory and allows to resolve a number of problems of standard Friedmann cosmology [1, ]. Most inflationary models built in the frame of general relativity theory GR are singular and limited in the time in the past. In the case of flat and open models such situation is 1

2 inevitable [3], and the quantum gravity era cannot be avoided in the past 1. At the same time regular inflationary bouncing solutions exist in GR for closed models filled by massive or nonlinear scalar fields and usual matter [5-1]. Because limiting maximum energy density and limiting temperature at a bounce in such models can be essentially less than the Planckian ones, classical description of gravitational field in these models is possible and quantum gravitational effects are negligible. Note that regular inflationary solutions for closed models in GR are unstable at compression stage, and small variations of gravitational and scalar fields at compression lead to singularity because of the divergence of the time derivative of scalar field φ. As result the energy density ρ φ = 1 φ + V φ and the pressure p = 1 φ V φ V is a scalar field potential of scalar field at compression stage near singularity are connected in the following way p φ ρ φ [7]. In the case of regular bouncing solutions the scalar field potential has to be dominating at a bounce, so in the case of models including scalar field φ and ultrarelativistic matter with the energy density ρ r the following condition at a bounce must be valid V φ ρ r > Recently the Pre-Big Bang Scenario in String Cosmology was discussed. See [4] and Refs. given therein Eternally inflating regular closed model of an Emergent Universe with asymptotically Einstein static state was discussed in Ref. [13].

3 The relation 1 means that the greatest part of energy density at the end of cosmological compression has to be determined by scalar fields 3. Because there are not physical reasons ensuring the realization of condition 1, regular inflationary solutions in GR cannot be considered as a base to build regular inflationary cosmology. Different situation takes place in gauge theories of gravitation GTG - Poincare GTG, metric-affine GTG. Note that GTG are natural generalization of GR by applying the local gauge invariance principle to gravitational interaction see review [14]. As it was shown in a number of our papers [15-0,1], the GTG possess important regularizing properties. By satisfying the correspondence principle with GR in the case of usual gravitating systems with rather small energy densities and pressures, GTG can lead to essentially different physical conclusions in the case of gravitating systems at extreme conditions with extremely high energy densities and pressures [15, 17]. In particular, gravitating vacuum with sufficiently high energy density ρ v > 0 and pressure p v = ρ v can lead to the vacuum gravitational repulsion effect and to a bounce in closed, open and flat models, that allows to build regular inflationary cosmological models [16, 10, 1]. Some particular regular inflationary cosmological solutions for closed models with scalar fields were discussed in Refs.[1, 11, 1]. The present paper is devoted to study the problem whether the GTG can be a base to build the regular inflationary cosmology. 3 Note that classical solutions of cosmological Friedmann equations of GR for models including scalar fields can be used only for limited time intervals because of the processes of mutual transformations of elementary particles and scalar fields in the early Universe. 3

4 Generalized cosmological Friedmann equations in GTG Homogeneous isotropic models in GTG are described by the following generalized cosmological Friedmann equations GCFE { k d [ R + dt ln R ] } 1 β ρ 3p = 8π 3Mp ρ β ρ 3p 4 1 β ρ 3p, [Ṙ + R ln ] 1 β ρ 3p R = 4π 3M p ρ + 3p + β ρ 3p, 3 1 β ρ 3p where Rt is the scale factor of Robertson-Walker metrics, k = +1, 0, 1 for closed, flat, open models respectively, ρ is energy density, p is pressure, β is indefinite parameter with inverse dimension of energy density, M p is Planckian mass. The system of units with = c = 1 is used. At first the GCFE were deduced in Poincare GTG [15], and later it was shown that Eqs.-3 take place also in metric-affine GTG [, 3]. From Eqs. -3 follows the conservation law in usual form ρ + 3H ρ + p = 0, 4 where H = Ṙ R is the Hubble parameter. Besides cosmological equations -3 gravitational equations of GTG lead to the following relation for torsion function S and nonmetricity function Q S 1 4 Q = 1 4 d ln 1 βρ 3p. 5 dt In Poincare GTG Q = 0 and Eq. 5 determines the torsion function. In metric-affine GTG there are three kinds of models [3]: in the Riemann-Cartan space-time Q = 0, in the 4

5 Weyl space-time S = 0, in the Weyl-Cartan space-time S 0, Q 0, the function S is proportional to the function Q. The value of β 1 determines the scale of extremely high energy densities. The GCFE -3 coincide practically with Friedmann cosmological equations of GR if the energy density is small βρ 3p 1. The difference between GR and GTG can be essential at extremely high energy densities βρ 3p 1. 4 In the case of gravitating vacuum with constant energy density ρ v = const > 0 the GCFE 3 are reduced to Friedmann cosmological equations of GR and S = Q = 0, this means that de Sitter solutions for metrics with vanishing torsion and nonmetricity are exact solutions of GTG [4, 5] and hence inflationary models can be built in the frame of GTG. In order to analyze inflationary cosmological models in GTG let us consider systems including scalar field minimally coupled with gravitation and usual matter in the form of ultrarelativistic matter. This assumption is available by analysis of the hot Universe models in the beginning of cosmological expansion. In the case of other form of gravitating matter our consideration would be more complicated. If the interaction between scalar field and ultrarelativistic matter is negligible, the energy density ρ and pressure p take the form ρ = 1 φ + V φ + ρ r, p = 1 φ V φ ρ r, 6 and the conservation law 4 leads to the scalar field equation φ + 3H φ = V V = dv dφ 4 Ultrarelativistic matter with equation of state p = 1 3ρ is exceptional system because Eqs. 3 are identical to Friedmann cosmological equations of GR in this case independently on values of energy density. 7 5

6 and the conservation law for matter, which in our case has the following integral ρ r R 4 = const. By using Eqs. 6-7 the GCFE -3 can be written in the following form k { [ + H 1 βv + R φ ] Z Ḣ = 8π 3M p } 3βV φ [ 1 βv + φ ] {[ Z + H 1 4βV 4 φ + 1βH φv [1 βv + φ ] = 8π 3M p [ρ r + 1 φ + V 14 β 4V φ ] Z, 8 ] } Z 18β φ4 3β [V φ V Z + 6β φ ] V [V φ ρ r 14 ] β4v φ Z, 9 where Z = 1 β4v φ, V = dv dφ, V = d V. Relation 5 takes the form dφ S 1 4 Q = 3β H φ + V φ 1 β 4V φ. 10 Unlike GR the cosmological equation 8 leads to essential restrictions on admissible values of scalar field and permits to exclude the divergence of derivative φ for any finite value of φ, if β < 0. Imposing β < 0, we obtain from Eq. 8 in the case k = 0, +1. Z 0 or φ 4V + β Inequality 11 is valid also for open models discussed in Sec. 3. The region Σ of admissible values of scalar field on the plane P with the axis φ, φ determined by 11 is limited by two bounds L ± φ = ± 4V + β From Eq. 8 the Hubble parameter on the bounds L ± is equal to H = 3βV φ 1 βv + φ. 13 6

7 We see the value of H is negative on the bound L + and it is positive on the bound L. According to 13 the right-hand part of Eq. 10 is equal to 1 H on the bounds L ±. This means that the torsion nonmetricity will be regular, if the Hubble parameter and scalar field are regular. In connection with this our main attention in Sec. 3 will be turned to study properties of solutions of GCFE 8-9. In accordance with 11 energy density ρ φ and pressure p φ of scalar field satisfy the condition p φ 1 ρ 3 φ + β 1. Unlike GR the equation of state for scalar field p φ ρ φ is not valid at any stage of models evolution in GTG. 3 Regular inflationary models in GTG Let us consider the most important general properties of cosmological solutions of GCFE 8-9. At first of all the behaviour of cosmological models in the beginning of cosmological expansion will be studied. Let us analyze extreme points for the scale factor Rt: R 0 = R0, H 0 = H0 = 0. Denoting values of quantities at t = 0 by means of index 0, we obtain from 8-9: k Z R β V φ 0 0 = 8π [ ρ 3Mp r0 + 1 φ 0 + V0 1 4V 4 β 0 φ ] 0 Z 0, 14 { 8π Ḣ 0 = [V 0 φ 0 ρ r0 14 ] β4v 0 φ 0 Z 0 3M p [ + 3β V φ 0 0 V 0Z 0 + 6β φ ]}[ 0V 0 1 βv 0 + φ ] 1 0 Z 1 0, 15 where Z 0 = 1 β4v 0 φ 0. A bounce point is described by Eq. 14, if the value of H 0 is positive. By giving concrete form of potential V and choosing values of R 0, φ 0, φ0 and ρ r0 7

8 at a bounce, we can obtain numerically particular bouncing solutions of GCFE for various values of parameter β. The analysis of GCFE shows, that the properties of cosmological solutions depend essentially on the parameter β, i.e. on the scale of extremely high energy densities. From physical point of view interesting results can be obtained, if the value of β 1 is much less than the Planckian energy density [1], i.e. in the case of large in module values of parameter β by imposing M p = 1. In order to investigate cosmological models at the beginning of cosmological expansion in this case, let us consider the GCFE by supposing that β 4V φ 1, ρr + 1 φ + V β 4V φ. 16 Note that the second condition 16 does not exclude that ultrarelativistic matter energy density can dominate at a bounce ρ r V + 1 φ [1]. We obtain: k R + [ H V + φ 4V φ ] + 3V φ = π 3M p 4V φ, 17 Ḣ V + φ 4V φ + H 8V 34V φ φ 4 1HV φ V + φ + 3 V φ V 4V φ 9V φ = π 3M p 4V φ Eqs do not include radiation energy density, which does not have influence on the dynamics of inflationary models in the case under consideration although, as it was noted above, the contribution of ultrarelativistic matter to energy density can be essentially greater in comparison with scalar field, moreover Eqs do not contain the parameter β. According to Eq. 17 extreme points of the scale factor are determined by the following 8

9 condition k R V 0 φ 0 4V 0 φ 0 = π 3M p 4V 0 φ From Eq. 18 the time derivative of the Hubble parameter at extreme points is [ π Ḣ 0 = 3M p 4V 0 φ V 0 V 0 φ 0 + 9V 0 φ 0 4V 0 φ ] 1 0 V 0 + φ 1 0, 0 Obviously Eq correspond to in considered approximation. Now let us consider flat models, for which Eq. 17 can be written in the following form M 4V 0 φ 1 0 = 3 p π V 0 3 φ 0 1 Solutions of Eq. 1 are in physical region Σ on the plane P determined in considered approximation according to 11 by the following inequality 4V 0 φ 0 > 0 the neighbourhood of origin of coordinates on the plane P is not considered in our approximation. Eq.1 has as solutions two curves B ± on the plane P, which are situated near bounds L ±. Because of 1 the bounce condition H 0 > 0 can be written in the form π 3M p 4V 0 φ V 0 V 0 φ π 3 0 > 0 or 6 V 4M φ 4 3 p V 0 V 0 φ 0 > 0. If the condition is satisfied on the curves B ±, the bounce takes place in points of these curves, which can be called bounce curves. Note that bounce curves exist in the case of various scalar field potentials applying in inflationary cosmology. In the case of power potentials V = αφ n α and n are positive constants the second inequality takes the form 1 π 3 6 n V Mp φ0 + n V 0 φ 0 φ n 1 n φ 0 V 0 > 0 3

10 By taking into account that the value of φ 0 is close to 4V 0 we obtain from 3 approximate estimation for lower bound of admissible values of scalar field φ 0 > n 4 n 1 3 M p 1 n 1 6π, which in the case of power potentials with n = and n = 4 is more strong than corresponding restriction on scalar field for inflation in GR [1, 1]. By compression stage by increasing of φ of cosmological model scalar field can not reach the bounds L ± undergoing a bounce in a point of a bounce curve. The existence of a bounce curves leads to important physical conclusion: cosmological solutions for flat models in GTG have the bouncing character, their properties near a bounce are determined by scalar fields and do not depend on the presence of ultrarelativistic matter. Independently on stability properties of bouncing solutions the existence of a bounce curves ensures their regular character. In general case, when approximation 16 is not valid, a bounce curves of flat cosmological models determined by Eq.14 with k = 0 depend on parameter β. By certain value of β we have 1-parametric family of bounce curves with parameter ρ r0. Then the bounce condition H 0 > 0 leads to the following relation due to 14-15: 8π 3M p [V ρ r0 14 β 4V 0 φ ] 0 β V 0 V 0 φ 0 > 0 4 We see from 4,unlike GR the presence of ultrarelativistic matter does not prevent from the bounce realization compare with 1 by reaching certain bounce curve 5. In the case of closed and open models Eq. 19 determines 1-parametric family of a bounce curves with parameter R 0. A bounce curves of closed models are situated on the plane P in region between two bounce curves B + and B of flat models, and in the case of 5 The analysis of bounce curves corresponding to various scalar field potentials will be given in Ref.[6]. 10

11 open models a bounce curves are situated in two regions between the curves: L + and B +, L and B. In general case we have -parametric families of bounce curves for closed and open models with parameters R 0 and ρ r0 determined by Eq.14. The bouncing character of inflationary cosmological solutions for closed and open models as well as solutions properties at direct proximity to the bounds L ± and near the origin of coordinates on the plane P will be discussed apart [6]. As illustration of obtained results we will consider particular cosmological inflationary solution for flat model by using the scalar field potential in the form V = 1 m φ m = 10 6 M p. The solution was obtained by numerical integration of Eqs. 7, 9 and by choosing in accordance with Eq.14 or 1 the following values of scalar field at a bounce: V 0 = 10 6 M 4 p, φ 0 = V 0 β = Mp 4. A bouncing solution includes: quasi-de-sitter stage of compression, the stage of transition from compression to expansion, quasi-de-sitter inflationary stage, stage after inflation. The dynamics of the Hubble parameter and scalar field is presented for different stages of obtained bouncing solution in Figures 1-3 by choosing M p = 1. The transition stage from compression to expansion Fig. 1 is essentially 10 3 H t φ t 1.8 Figure 1: The stage of transition from compression to expansion. 11

12 10 3 H φ t t Figure : Quasi-de-Sitter stage of compression and inflationary stage H 10 φ t t -4 Figure 3: The stage after inflation. asymmetric with respect to the point t = 0 because of φ0 0. Similar asymmetry is inevitable property of bouncing solutions for flat and open models. In course of transition stage the Hubble parameter changes from maximum in module negative value at the end of compression stage to maximum positive value at the beginning of expansion stage. The scalar field changes linearly at transition stage, the derivative φ grows at first from positive value φ to maximum value φ φ 0 and then decreases to negative value φ Quasi-de-Sitter inflationary stage and quasi-de-sitter compression stage are presented in Fig.. Although the GCFE 8-9 and their approximation have different structure from cosmological Friedmann equations of GR, like GR the time dependence 1

13 of functions Ht and φt at compression and inflationary stages is linear. The amplitude and frequency of oscillating scalar field after inflation Fig. 3 are different than that of GR, this means that approximation of small energy densities β 4V φ 1 at the beginning of this stage is not valid; however, the approximation is not valid also because of dependence on parameter β of oscillations characteristics, namely, amplitude and frequency of scalar field oscillations decrease by increasing of β [1]. The behaviour of the Hubble parameter after inflation is also noneinsteinian, at first the Hubble parameter oscillates near the value H = 0, and later the Hubble parameter becomes positive and decreases with the time like in GR. Before quasi-de-sitter compression stage there are also oscillations of the Hubble parameter and scalar field not presented in Figures 1 3. As it was noted above 3, solutions similar to obtained one can be used only for limited time intervals. Ultrarelativistic matter, which could dominate at a bounce, has negligible small energy density at quasi-de Sitter stages. At the same time the gravitating matter could be at compression stage in more realistic bouncing models, and scalar fields could appear only at certain stage of cosmological compression. The only fact is important in the frame of considered theory the presence of scalar fields at the end of cosmological compression of the hot Universe, that leads to the realization of a bounce and ensures regular transition to cosmological expansion. 4 Conclusion As it is shown in the present paper, regular inflationary cosmological solutions for flat, closed and open models obtained in the frame of GTG possess some interesting physical properties, 13

14 if the scale of extremely high energy densities β 1 is much less than the Plackian one. The dynamics of cosmological models at a bounce is determined by scalar fields and Newton s gravitational constant; ultrarelativistic matter, which can dominate at a bounce, does not have influence on their dynamics. The generic feature of flat inflationary cosmological models is their bouncing character, that permits to build the regular inflationary cosmology in the frame of GTG. Acknowledgements I am grateful to Alexander Garkun and Andrey Minkevich for help by preparation of this paper. References [1] A. D. Linde, Physics of Elementary Particles and Inflationary Cosmology. Nauka, Moscow, [] E. W. Kolb and M. S. Turner, The Early Universe Addison-Wesley, [3] A. Borde, A. H. Guth and A. Vilenkin, gr-qc/ [4] M.Gasperini, G.Veneziano, Phys. Rep. 373, 1 003; hep-th/ [5] L. Parker and S. A. Fulling, Phys. Rev. D7, [6] A. A. Starobinsky. Pis ma Astron. Zhurn. 4, ; Sov. Astron. Lett. 4,

15 [7] V. A. Belinsky, L. P. Grishchuk, Ya. B. Zeldovich,I. M. Khalatnikov, Zhurn. Exp. Teor. Fiz. 89, ; Sov. Phys. JETP 6, ; Phys. Lett. B155, [8] A. V. Toporensky, Gravitation & Cosmology 5, ; gr-qc/ [9] C. Molina-Paris and M. Visser, Phys. Lett. B455, ; gr-qc/ [10] A. V. Minkevich, in Nonlinear Phenomena in Complex Systems. Proceedings of the Tenth Annual Intern. Seminar NPCS-001, Minsk, 001, pp [11] A. V. Minkevich, Intern. J. Mod. Phys. A, 17, [1] A. V. Minkevich, gr-qc/ [13] G. Ellis, R. Maartens, gr-qc/ [14] F. W. Hehl, G. D. McCrea, E. W. Mielke, Yu. Ne eman, Phys. Rep. 58, [15] A. V. Minkevich, Vestsi Akad. Nauk BSSR. Ser. fiz.-mat., no., ; Phys. Lett. A80, [16] A. V. Minkevich, Dokl. Akad. Nauk BSSR. 9, [17] A. V. Minkevich, Vestsi Akad. Nauk Belarus. Ser. fiz.-mat., no. 5, ; in Proc. of the Third Alexander Friedmann Intern. Seminar on Gravitation and Cosmology, St.- Petersburg, July 4 1, 1995, p. 1. [18] A. V. Minkevich, Acta Phys. Polon. B9,

16 [19] A. V. Minkevich, I. M. Nemenman, Class. Quantum Grav. 1, [0] A. V. Minkevich, A. S. Garkun, Gravitation & Cosmology. 5, [1] A. V. Minkevich, G. V. Vereshchagin, in Nonlinear Phenomena in Complex Systems. Proceedings of the Tenth Annual Intern. Seminar NPCS-001, Minsk, 001, p [] A. V. Minkevich, Dokl. Akad. Nauk Belarus. 37, [3] A. V. Minkevich and A. S. Garkun, Class. Quantum Grav. 17, [4] A. V. Minkevich, Phys. Lett. 95A, [5] A. V. Minkevich, Dokl. Akad. Nauk BSSR. 30, [6] A. V. Minkevich, in preparation