Colorimetric Study on the Application of Some Fluorescent Naphthalimide Derivatives

Similar documents
PHOTO STABILIZERS FOR POLYMERS - NEW TRENDS (Review)

Rhodamine B pentyl ester and its methyl, ethyl, propyl, and butyl homologues

PHOTOCATALYTIC DEGRADATION STUDIES OF POLYANILINE BASED ZnO-Al 2 O 3 NANOCOMPOSITE

DYEING BEHAVIOR PREDICTION OF COTTON FABRICS IN SUPERCRITICAL CO 2

Annals of West University of Timisoara

Supporting information

UV-VIS SPECTROSCOPIC STUDY OF NATURAL DYES WITH ALUM AS A MORDANT

Standard Practice for Calculating Yellowness and Whiteness Indices from Instrumentally Measured Color Coordinates 1

Reactive fluorescent dye functionalized cotton fabric as a Magic Cloth for selective sensing and reversible separation of Cd 2+ in water

Alternative analysis of 6-Nitro BIPS behaviour based on factorial design

Introduction to Colorimetry

SYNTHESIS AND INVESTIGATION OF SOME ACID AZO DYES FOR WOOL Polya M. Miladinova 1, Reny K. Vaseva 1, Varbina R. Lukanova 2

World Journal of Pharmaceutical and Life Sciences WJPLS

ph-responsive Quantum Dots (RQDs) that Combine a Fluorescent Nanoparticle with a ph-sensitive Dye

J- vs. H-type assembly: pentamethine cyanine (Cy5) as near IR chiroptical. reporter

ATTO 565 and ATTO 590

SUPPORTING INFORMATION. A Sensitive and Selective Ratiometric Near IR Fluorescent Probe for Zinc Ions Based on Distyryl-Bodipy Fluorophore

Terms used in UV / Visible Spectroscopy

Supporting Information. Self-assembled nanofibers from Leucine Derived Amphiphiles as Nanoreactors for Growth of ZnO Nanoparticles

COLOR SCIENCE. Concepts and Methods, Quantitative Data and Formulae, 2nd Edition. John Wiley & Sons New York Chichester Brisbane Toronto Singapore

SUPPORTING INFORMATION

Spectroscopy. Page 1 of 8 L.Pillay (2012)

Protein quantification and detection methods

Supporting Information. for. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Z Wiley-VCH 2004

Effect of ultraviolet and x-ray radiation on optical properties of epoxy polymers dyed with organic phosphors

Research Article. A r t i c l e I n f o. Received 11/5/2016. Accepted 5/10/2016

Quantum chemical studies on the structures of some heterocyclic azo disperse dyes

EXPERIMENT 14. ACID DISSOCIATION CONSTANT OF METHYL RED 1

The Spectrophotometer and Atomic Spectra of Hydrogen Physics 246

Application of IR Raman Spectroscopy

Experiment 24: Spectroscopy

Fluorescence Workshop UMN Physics June 8-10, 2006 Basic Spectroscopic Principles Joachim Mueller

LM-79 Report TEST REPORT NO. L523A

BROMAMINE ACID DERIVATED DYES

APPLICATION OF SILVER NANOPARTICLES AS METAL MORDANT AND ANTIBACTERIAL AGENT IN WOOL NATURAL DYEING PROCESS Hossein Barani 1, Majid Nasiri Boroumand 2

Rational design of light-directed dynamic spheres

Effect of Addition Au Nanoparticles on Emission Spectra of Laser Dye

Proposed Mechanism of Photo-Induced Reactions. of Chiral Threonine Schiff Base Cu(II) Complexes. with Imidazole by TiO 2

D DAVID PUBLISHING. Simulation of Accelerated Ageing of UV-Radiation for Photodegradable Geotextiles/Geomembranes. 1. Introduction

UV-VIS Spectroscopy and Fluorescence Spectroscopy (Part 2 of 2)

Synthesis of Dihydroquinoline Based Merocyanines as Naked Eye and Fluorogenic sensors for Hydrazine Hydrate in Aqueous Medium

Module: 7. Lecture: 36

DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION

EVOLUTION OF STARS HERTZSPRUNG-RUSSELL DIAGRAM

Electronic Supplementary Information For. Facile fabrication of glycopolymer-based iron oxide nanoparticles

A near-infrared colorimetric fluorescent chemodosimeter for the detection of glutathione in living cells

Detection of toxic mercury ions using a ratiometric CdSe/ZnS nanocrystal sensor

A.Thakur. et. al./ 2(4) pp December-2014

LM-79 Report TEST REPORT NO.M037D

2. Discrete means unique, that other states don t overlap it. 3. Electrons in the outer electron shells have greater potential energy.

NEW MEASURES OF WHITENESS THAT CORRELATE WITH PERCEIVED COLOR APPEARANCE

CHAPTER 7 SUMMARY OF THE PRESENT WORK AND SUGGESTIONS FOR FUTURE WORK

Construction of Absorption Filter for colorimetry and its performance characteristics

DETERMINATION OF RELATIVE FLUORESCENCE QUANTUM YIELD USING THE AGILENT CARY ECLIPSE

One polymer for all: Benzotriazole Containing Donor-Acceptor Type Polymer as a Multi-Purpose Material

Thermodynamic Properties of Water in Amorphous Carbohydrates: Physical and Chemical Considerations

A Fluorescence Turn-On Sensor for the Detection of Palladium Ions that Operates Through In-Situ Generation of Palladium Nanoparticles

Module 1. Illumination Engineering Basics. Version 2 EE IIT, Kharagpur 1

Blending conjugated polymers without phase separation for fluorescent colour tuning of polymeric materials through FRET

Supporting Information for. A Fluorescence Ratiometric Sensor for Trace Vapor Detection of. Hydrogen Peroxide

EFFECT OF CO 2 LASER RADIATION ON SURFACE PROPERTIES OF SYNTHETIC FIBRES F. Esteves, H. Alonso ABSTRACT

Module: 7. Lecture: 36

Chapter 17: Fundamentals of Spectrophotometry

TECHNICAL INFORMATION. Quantum Dot

Infrared Spectroscopy

Supporting Informations for. 1,8-Naphthyridine-based molecular clips for off-on fluorescence sensing

Application Note: Ocean Optics in the Teaching and Research Laboratories Susquehanna University Department of Chemistry July 2014

Separation and Identification of Plant Pigments Dr. Gergens - SD Mesa College

PAPER No.12 :Organic Spectroscopy MODULE No.29: Combined problem on UV, IR, 1 H NMR, 13 C NMR and Mass - Part I

Spectroscopy of Atoms and Molecules

Multi-step Synthesis: Preparation of Organic Dyes *

ON THE SYNTHESIS AND APPLICATION OF SOME MONO- AND DIS-AZO ACID DYES

A Simple Fluorescein Derived Colorimetric and Fluorescent off - on Sensor For The Detection of Hypochlorite

Kristen Fox Chem 213 Synthetic #2 FFR. Green Synthesis of Fluorescein Dye

Supplementary Material (ESI) for CrystEngComm. An ideal metal-organic rhombic dodecahedron for highly efficient

International Journal of Pure and Applied Sciences and Technology

Figure S1 - Enzymatic titration of HNE and GS-HNE.

EXPERIMENT 12 UV/VIS Spectroscopy and Spectrophotometry: Spectrophotometric Analysis of a Commercial Aspirin Tablet

Theory of colour measurement Contemporary wool dyeing and finishing

MOLEBIO LAB #4: Using a Spectrophotometer

IRDye 800CW Protein Labeling Kit Low MW

Effects of -Ray Irradiation on Colour and Fluorescence of Pearls

Supplementary Figure 1. Cross-section SEM image of the polymer scaffold perovskite film using MAI:PbI 2 =1:1 in DMF solvent on the FTO/glass

A colorimetric and fluorescent turn-on sensor for pyrophosphate. anion based on dicyanomethylene-4h-chromene framework

Correlation of High Pressure Density Behaviors for Fluid Mixtures made of Carbon Dioxide with Solvent at K

Characterize NOM in typical china s water using HPLC-SEC with continuous wavelength UV absorbance detector

Introducing a photo switchable azo-functionality inside Cr-MIL-101-NH 2 by covalent post-synthetic modification

Supporting Information. Shining New Light on the Spiropyran Photoswitch: A Photocage Decides between cis-trans or Spiro-Merocyanine Isomerization.

Natural Exposure Testing VS Accelerated Weathering... The Right Choice.

Chapter 17: Fundamentals of Spectrophotometry

Two-dimensional homologous perovskites as light absorbing materials for solar cell applications

Linear bases for representation of natural and artificial illuminants

Electronic Supplementary Material

Synthesis of Bis (2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-piperidinyl) Maleate

Reference literature. (See: CHEM 2470 notes, Module 8 Textbook 6th ed., Chapters )

Weathering of Artificial Grass Yarn CEN TC 217 WG 11, 18/10/2016 Daniel Müller (BASF) & Jeroen Wassenaar (TOTAL)

Chapter 18. Fundamentals of Spectrophotometry. Properties of Light

E. Simeonov, V. Koleva, Ch. Chilev

A BODIPY-based fluorescent probe for the differential

Mengying Li.

Transcription:

22 The Open Textile Journal, 2010 3, 22-26 Open Access Colorimetric Study on the Application of Some Fluorescent Naphthalimide Derivatives P. Miladinova and T. Konstantinova * Organic Synthesis Department, University of Chemical Technology and Metallurgy, 8 Ohridski str., Sofia 1756, Bulgaria Abstract: Coloration of polyamide fabrics with five dyes naphthalimide derivatives was investigated. Three compounds, containing a tetramethylpiperidine (TMP) fragment were applied as fluorescent whitening agents (FWA). Materials with a bright color or whiteness and an intense fluorescence were obtained. The color characteristics using a Tristimulous colorimetry were recorded. The photo stability of the compounds in solution and on the polyamide fabrics was studied. It was found that among the dyes the compound 5 had the best photo stability. The FWA compounds, containing a stabilizer fragment in their molecule, had excellent stability in solution and very good stability on polyamide material. Keywords: Naphthalimide dyes, fluorescent whitening agents, dyeing and whitening of polyamide, photo stability. 1. INTRODUCTION Among various classical dyes, luminophores, due to their bright color and intense fluorescence, are of special interest. They were successfully applied for coloration of natural and synthetic materials [1, 2]. Recently, they have been widely applied in high technology such as solar energy sells, liquidcrystal displays, lasers, sensors and others [2, 3]. The fluorescent whitening agents (FWA) are also of special interest and have been applied not only for whitening of different materials but in high technology as well [3, 4]. The 1, 8-naphthalimide derivatives due to their bright color and intense fluorescence are well known as dyes for coloration of different materials, markers in biomaterials, sensors and others [3]. The stability of dyes and FWA was also of importance for their application. In the last years different approaches have been developed and different functional compounds have been synthesized [5, 6]. The possibility for one-step coloration and stabilization of polymers that we reported in the past few years was of special interest. In our papers we reported the synthesis of different dyes, including 1,8-naphthalimide derivatives, and their application for coloration of polymers [5-10]. It was of interest to study the color characteristics of the compounds synthesized and the possibility for their application for dyeing or whitening of textile materials. Some of the compounds under this present study contained a stabilizer (tetramethylpiperidine -TMP) fragment in their molecule, so it was of interest to investigate their photo stability and to compare it to the stability of the others. Therefore, this was the objective of the present study. 2. MATERIALS AND METHODS 2.1. Materials The compounds under study were synthesized according to the method described before [11, 12]; polyamide fabrics *Address correspondence to this author at the Organic Synthesis department, University of Chemical Technology &Metallurgy, 8 Ohridski str., Sofia 1756, Bulgaria; Tel/Fax: +3592-8163208; E mail: konst@uctm.edu, temekonstantinova@abv.bg (Polyamide 6) were a Bulgarian product (Agrochim, St. Zagora). All solvents were products of Merck (pro analysis or analytical grade). 2.2. Equipment and Methods UV/Vis absorption spectra of the compounds were recorded in dimethyformamide (DMF; concentration 4x10-4 g.ml -1 ) on a Hewlett-Packard 8452A UV/Vis spectrophotometer (2-nm resolution). Fluorescent spectra were measured on a Varian Eclipse fluorescent spectrophotometer in DMF (4x10-4 g.ml -1 ). The photo stability of the compounds was studied by irradiation of their DMF solutions in a Suntest equipment ( Heraeus, Germany), fitted with an air-cooled Xenon lamp (Hanau, 1.1 kw, 765 W/m 2 ). The process of their photo degradation was monitored colorimetrically (the standard calibration curve method), following the dependence of the compound s concentration on the time of irradiation, where the initial concentration of the compounds was accepted to be 100 %. Polyamide fabrics were dyed with the compounds 1-5 at concentration of 1 % on weight of fabric (o.w.f.) following the standard procedure [2, 13]. Materials with the compounds 6-8 at two concentrations 0.5 % and 1 % (o.w.f.) were treated [14]. The color characteristics of the dyed materials applying a Tristimulus Colorimetry (Data color technique) at three different illuminant light sources (a daylight - D65, a fluorescent light - CWF and an artificial light source with red-hot filament - A) were determined. The dyed or whitened fabrics thus obtained, were subjected to irradiation by UV light (wavelength λ max = 290 nm) in a Suntest equipment. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The compounds are presented by general formula I and II, where the meanings of R and R 1 are given. The compounds 1-5 are yellow-orange in color with an intense greenish fluorescence in solution. The compounds 6-8 are colorless with an intense bluish fluorescence in solution under UV light. 1876-5203/10 2010 Bentham Open

Colorimetric Study on the Application of Some Fluorescent Naphthalimide Derivatives The Open Textile Journal, 2010, Volume 3 23 Formula I Formula II 3.2. Color Assessment The polyamide samples with the compounds 1-5 were dyed and the color characteristics of the dyed materials applying a Tristimulus Colorimetry (Datacolor technique) at three different illuminant light sources were studied. Their reflectance spectra thus recorded are shown in Fig. (1). 1) R=-CH 3; R 1= -NHNH 2; 2) R=-CH 2CH=CH 2 ; R 1=-NHNH 2; 3) R=-CH 2CH=CH 2 ; R 1=-NHCH 2CH 2NH 2; 4) R=-CH 3 ; R 1=-NHNHCOCH 2Cl; 5) R=-CH 2CH=CH 2 ; R 1= -NHNHCOCH 2Cl 6) A= -CH 3; 7) A= -CH 2CH=CH 2; 8) A= -CH 2CH 2OCOC(CH) 3=CH 2; 3.1. Spectrophotometric Measurements Firstly, it was of interest to study some of the spectral characteristics of the compounds, important for their application. The absorption UV/Vis and fluorescent spectra of the compounds in solution were recorded and the data obtained are presented in Table 1. Table 1. Spectrophotometric Data for the Compounds 1-8 * Compound N λ max abs nm log ε λ max fl nm 1 444 3.4 543 2 458 3.3 560 3 442 3.5 535 Fig. (1). Reflectance spectra of the dyed materials. * numbers of the curves correspond to the numbers of compounds; std: untreated polyamide fabric. One can see that the most intensive color with the compound 3 (-NHCH 2 CH 2 NH 2 group in the fourth position) was obtained. The acylation of the amino group in the hydrazine residue (compound 4) affected (increasing) the hue of the dye compared to the compound 1, but for the compound 5 (in comparison to compound 2), neither increasing nor decreasing of the hue was observed. Similar measurements with polyamide materials treated with the compounds 6-8 were performed and the reflectance spectra of the whitened materials (Tristimulus Colorimetry-Data color technique) were recorded. In Fig. (2) the reflectance spectra of the compound 6 are presented. (The reflectance spectra for the compounds 7 and 8 were quite similar so we did not present them). 4 412 3.6 513 5 404 3.5 507 6 342 (356) 3.6 413 7 342 (356) 3.0 410 8 342 (356) 3.2 407 *DMF solutions with a concentration 4.10-4 g.ml -1 One can see from these data that when the amino group in the hydrazine residue was acylated (compounds 4 and 5), a hypso chromic shift in their absorption (46-38 nm) and fluorescence λ max (47-28 nm) was observed. Nevertheless their absorption maxima remained in the visible region (they had a color). When in the fourth position of the naphthalimide ring an alcohol residue (methyl, allyl or HEMA) was involved (compounds 6-8), the λ max of their absorption moved to the near UV region (342-356 nm). Their fluorescence was in the near visible one (407-413 nm), that was very important for their application as FWA. Fig. (2). Reflectance spectra of the polyamide materials. * 1- untreated polyamide; 2 - polyamide material treated with 0.5 % of compound 6; 3- polyamide treated with 1% of compound 6.

24 The Open Textile Journal, 2010, Volume 3 Miladinova and Konstantinova Table 2. Tristimulous Data for the Compounds 1-8 on Polyamide Fabrics a Compound- concentration WL Purity (%) x b y b L* c a* c b* c 1-1 % 574 75.35 0.4570 0.4553 72.5 7.3 66.6 2-1 % 572 77.88 0.4533 0.4680 79.2 2.9 75.7 3-1 % 567 70.85 0.4179 0.4785 90.1-12.4 75.7 4-1 % 575 84.20 0.4796 0.4635 76.3 11.7 82.0 5-1 % 570 65.08 0.4231 0.4527 81.5-2.0 61.5 6-0.5 % - - 0.3149 0.3306 91.1 0.7 0.1 6-1% - - 0.3158 0.3324 90.9 0.3 0.9 7-0.5 % - - 0.3302 0.3509 90.3-1.1 9.9 7-1% - - 0.3331 0.3530 90.6-0.7 11.2 8-0.5 % - - 0.3292 0.3511 90.4-1.7 9.8 8-1% - - 0.3277 0.3482 90.5-1.1 8.5 PA standard 571 5.68 0.3235 0.3412 90.3 0.03 5.4 a illuminant D 65, b - x and y chromaticity characteristics; c -L* (luminance), a* and b* - CIE coordinates. These results showed that the application of the compound 6 (in both concentrations 0.5 and 1 %) led to a significant increasing of the light absorption value and from economical point of view, we considered that the concentration 0.5 % had to be recommended. Applying the Tristimulous Colorimetry (Data color technique), some color characteristics of the materials treated with the compounds 1-8 were recorded. The results are presented in Table 2. One can see that the luminance L * of the compounds was good. The color obtained with the compounds 1, 2 and 4 had a reddish nuance (positive values of a * and b * ), while that with the compounds 3 and 5 (positive b * value and negative a * value) had a greenish one. 3.3. Photo Stability of the Compounds 3.3.1. Photo Stability of the Compounds in Solution In order to determine the photo stability of the compounds, their DMF solutions were irradiated by UV light in a Suntest equipment. As during the irradiation no change in their absorption (λ max ) was registered, the kinetics of photo degradation was monitored colorimetrically using the method of the standard calibration curve. The data obtained after 60 min of irradiation are presented in Table 3. These results showed that the compounds, containing a TMP fragment in their molecule (6-8) had the highest photo stability. The stability of the others was also good (50-60 % after 60 min of irradiation). 3.3.2. Photo Stability of the Compounds on Polyamide Fabrics In order to determine the photo stability of the compounds on polyamide fabrics the materials dyed with the compounds 1-5 at a concentration of 1 % depth. (o.w.f.) or whitened with the compounds 6-8 at two concentrations 0.5 % and 1 % depth. (o.w.f.) were subjected to irradiation by UV light (wavelength λ max = 290 nm) in a Suntest equipment. It was found that no change in the absorption maxima (λ max ) of the compounds during the irradiation was observed. They Table 3. Concentration of the Compounds 1-8 During Irradiation* Compound N Concentration of the compound ** (%) after irradiation 15 min Concentration of the compound** (%) after irradiation 30 min Concentration of the compound** (%) after irradiation 60 min 1 75 70 65 2 68 64 60 3 62 59 56 4 70 65 60 5 72 65 62 6 100 99 98 7 99 99 98 8 99 99 98 *DMF solutions with concentration 4.10-4 g.ml -1 ; **the concentration of each compound before irradiation was accepted 100 %.

Colorimetric Study on the Application of Some Fluorescent Naphthalimide Derivatives The Open Textile Journal, 2010, Volume 3 25 Fig. (3). Strength of color (%) as a function of time of irradiation (min) * numbers on the curves correspond to the numbers of the compounds. were tested using the Tristimulous Colorimetry (Data color technique). The data for the compounds 1-5 obtained are presented in Fig. (3). One can see from the figure that photo stability of the compound 5 is the highest (50 % degradation at 240 th min). The stability of others was also good ( 50 % degradation after 120 min). The similar experiments with the materials treated with the compounds 6-8 were performed. Materials with a bright whiteness and an intense bluish fluorescence were subjected to irradiation and then tested by Tristimulous Colorimetry (Data color technique). The data received are presented in Fig. (4). We can see that the compound 6 had the highest photo stability at 0.5% concentration. This compound at 1 % and the compounds 7 and 8 at both concentrations (0.5 and 1%) degraded 50 % after 60 min. We consider that more detailed investigations in the future will enable us to determine the most suitable concentrations for application and their influence on the photo degradation process. 4. CONCLUSIONS Based on the results of this study we can summarize that among the dyes (compounds 1-5), the compound 5 can be recommended for coloration of polyamide fabrics, having good color characteristics and photo stability. The FWA (the compounds 6-8) containing a TMP fragment in their molecule had very good photo stability and among them, the compound 6, when was applied with 0.5 % concentration, can be recommended for whitening of polyamide materials. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Authors would like to thank the Science & Research Program of the University of Chemical Technology & Metallurgy, Sofia for the financial support. Fig. (4). Emission (%) as a function of time of irradiation (min) * numbers on the curves correspond to the numbers of the compounds.

26 The Open Textile Journal, 2010, Volume 3 Miladinova and Konstantinova REFERENCES [1] H. Zollinger, Color Chemistry, VNC: Zurich, 1989. [2] D.R. Warning and G. Hallas, Eds., The Chemistry and Application of Dyes, Plenum Press: London, 1990. [3] P. Gregory, High Technology Application of Organic Colorants, Plenum Press: New York, 1991. [4] R. Anliker and G. Müler, Eds., Fluorescent Whitening Agents, Georg Thieme Verlag: Stuttgart, 1975, pp. 51-52. [5] T.N. Konstantinova and P.P. Miladinova, Dyes and pigments with ecologically more tolerant application, In: Dyes and Pigments- New Research, A.R. Lang, Ed., Nova Science Publishers: New York, 2009, pp. 383-402. [6] V.V. Bojinov, Synergistic efficiency of combined HALS-UV absorber polymerizable stabilizers, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., vol. 102, pp. 2408-2415, March 2006. [7] V.V. Bojinov and T.N. Konstantinova, On the possibility of onestep coloration and stabilization of polystyrene, Polym. Degrad. Stab. vol. 68, pp. 295-298, April 2000. [8] V.V. Bojinov and T.N. Konstantinova, Synthesis of polymerizable 1, 8-naphthalimide dyes containing hindered amine fragment, Dyes Pigm., vol. 54, pp. 239-245, September 2002. [9] T.N. Konstantinova, R.D. Lazarova and V.V. Bojinov, On the photo stability of some naphthalimide dyes and their copolymers with methyl methacrylate, Polym. Degrad. Stab., vol. 82, pp. 115-118, January 2003. [10] P.P. Miladinova and T.N. Konstantinova, On the synthesis of some reactive triazine azodyes containing tetramethylpiperidine fragment, Dyes Pigm., vol. 67, pp. 63-69, October 2005. [11] T.N. Konstantinova and P.P. Miladinova, Synthesis and properties of some fluorescent 1,8- naphthalimide derivatives and their copolymers with methylmethacrylate, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., vol. 111, pp. 1991-1998, February 2009. [12] T.N. Konstantinova, A.B. Spirieva and T.I. Petkova, The synthesis, properties and application of some 1,8-naphthalimide dyes, Dyes Pigm., vol. 45 pp. 125-129, May 2000. [13] R.I. Betcheva, T.N. Konstantinova and A.B. Spirieva, Colorimertic study on the textile application of some benzanthrone dyes, Fibres Text. East. Eur., N 2, pp. 41-44, July- September 2001. [14] T.N. Konstantinova and I.K. Grabchev, "Aufhellen von Textilien mit neuen optischen Aufhellen", Melliand Textilberichte, vol. 75, pp. 125-127, February 1994. Received: June 19, 2009 Revised: October 30, 2009 Accepted: March 03, 2010 Miladinova and Konstantinova; Licensee Bentham Open. This is an open access article licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/bync/3.0/), which permits unrestricted, non-commercial use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the work is properly cited.