THE ROLE OF CELL WALL PEROXIDASE IN THE INHIBITION OF LEAF AND FRUIT GROWTH

Similar documents
Hormonal and other chemical effects on plant growth and functioning. Bill Davies Lancaster Environment Centre, UK

Macro- and Microscopic Aspects of Fruit Water Relations Influencing Growth and Quality in Tomato

Kinematic analysis of leaf growth in grasses a comment on "Spatial and Temporal

Major Nutrients Trends and some Statistics

Differential effects of salinity on leaf elongation kinetics of three grass species

plant physiology and energy conversion to plant systems. identify the components and the functions of plant describe the processes of

Relationship between Leaf Water Potential and Photosynthesis in Rice Plants

Chap 5. Differentiation and Development. 1. General Information 2. Plant Growth Hormones 3. Vegetative Physiology 4. Reproductive Physiology

Plant Responses. NOTE: plant responses involve growth and changes in growth. Their movement is much slower than that of animals.

GENETIC ANALYSES OF ROOT SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT IN THE TOMATO CROP MODEL

Non-hydraulic regulation of fruit growth in tomato plants (Lycopersicon esculentum cv. Solairo) growing in drying soil

LEAF WATER POTENTIAL AND STOMATAL CONDUCTANCE OF RUBBER (Hevea brasiliensis) AS INFLUENCED BY SOIL MOISTURE AND LEAF AGE LALANI SAMARAPPULI ABSTRACT

can affect division, elongation, & differentiation of cells to another region of plant where they have an effect

Effect of 1-MCP on Water Relations Parameters of Well-Watered and Water-Stressed Cotton Plants

10/4/2017. Chapter 39

Mlchio KANECHI, Naotsugu UCHIDA, Takeshl YASUDA and Tadashi YAMAGUCHI Graduate School of Science and Technology, Kobe University, Rokko, Kobe 657

Control of Plant Height and Branching in Ornamentals. Ep Heuvelink. Horticulture and Product Physiology group, Wageningen University, the Netherlands

CBSE Quick Revision Notes (Class-11 Biology) CHAPTER-15 PLANT GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT

Class XI Chapter 15 Plant Growth and Development Biology

Class XI Chapter 15 Plant Growth and Development Biology

Is that artificial turf or real grass? Its thicker than Bermuda!

Common Effects of Abiotic Stress Factors on Plants

POTASSIUM IN PLANT GROWTH AND YIELD. by Ismail Cakmak Sabanci University Istanbul, Turkey

Plant Structure, Growth, and Development

Tropical Agricultural Research & Extension 16(4): 2014

Chapter 25 Plant Processes. Biology II

THE IRON-CHLOROPHYLL RELATEONSHIP IN YOUNG HASS AVOCADO LEAVES

The Science of Plants in Agriculture Pl.Sci 102. Getting to Know Plants

CRITICAL PETIOLE POTASSIUM LEVELS AS RELATED TO PHYSIOLOGICAL RESPONSES OF CHAMBER- GROWN COTTON TO POTASSIUM DEFICIENCY

Nutrient status of potatoes grown on compost amended soils as determined by sap nitrate levels.

Peroxidase Assay Kit. Catalog Number KA assays Version: 02. Intended for research use only.

Leaf Growth in Dactylis glomerata following Defoliation J. L. DAVIDSON' AND F. L. MILTHORPE

Environmental Plant Physiology Photosynthesis - Aging. Department of Plant and Soil Sciences

Photosynthesis - Aging Leaf Level. Environmental Plant Physiology Photosynthesis - Aging. Department of Plant and Soil Sciences

Chapter 39. Plant Reactions. Plant Hormones 2/25/2013. Plants Response. What mechanisms causes this response? Signal Transduction Pathway model

STOLLER ENTERPRISES, INC. World leader in crop nutrition

PLANT STRUCTURE: PARTS (ORGANS) Roots Leaves Stems

TRANSPIRATION. An important regulator of transpiration is the stomatal complex composed of the opening or

LEAF APPEARANCE RATE IN Brachiaria decumbens GROWN IN NITROGEN AND POTASSIUM RATES. Abstract

TREES. Functions, structure, physiology

COMPARATIVE STUDY OF VIABILITY MEASUREMENT METHODS IN CROP PLANTS

Cytokinin. Fig Cytokinin needed for growth of shoot apical meristem. F Cytokinin stimulates chloroplast development in the dark

ABSORPTION OF WATER MODE OF WATER ABSORPTION ACTIVE AND PASSIVE ABSORPTION AND FACTORS AFFECTING ABSORPTION.

Level 2 Plant Growth and Development Part I Toby Day MSU Extension Horticulture Associate Specialist

A. Stimulus Response:

Biology 213 Exam 3 Practice Key

Plant Development. Chapter 31 Part 1

RESPONSE OF TOMATO PLANTS UNDER ALUMINUM STRESS

CONTROL SYSTEMS IN PLANTS

Major Plant Hormones 1.Auxins 2.Cytokinins 3.Gibberelins 4.Ethylene 5.Abscisic acid

Increasing Processing Tomato Fruit Soluble Solids

Plant Stimuli pp Topic 3: Plant Behaviour Ch. 39. Plant Behavioural Responses. Plant Hormones. Plant Hormones pp

Chapter 23 Notes Roots Stems Leaves

Factors which influence plant growth

MY BACKGROUND. Saeid since 1998

Topic 14. The Root System. II. Anatomy of an Actively Growing Root Tip

Growth Regulator Effects on Flowering in Maize

Effect of 1-MCP on Ethylene Synthesis and Development of Cotton Flowers under Normal and High Temperature

The plant body has a hierarchy of organs, tissues, and cells. Plants, like multicellular animals:

Why Calcium is So Important

Abiotic Stress in Crop Plants

Title Allantoin by Inosine in Nutrient So. Author(s) Toshihiro; Yokoi, Daisuke; Osaki, M

Plant Structure and Function. Roots, Stems, and Leaves

High nitrogen conditions enhance the cooling damage to pollen in rice plants : proteome analysis of mature anthers

Modification of Leaf Apoplastic ph in Relation to Stomatal Sensitivity to Root-Sourced Abscisic Acid Signals 1

Plant Growth & Development. By: Johnny M. Jessup Agriculture Teacher/FFA Advisor

AGRONOMIC POTENTIAL AND LIMITATIONS OF USING PRECIPITATED CALCIUM CARBONATE IN THE HIGH PLAINS

Plant Anatomy and Physiology. What are the parts of the plant, and how do they work?

Embryo Development. Embryo Development. Embryo Development. Embryo Development (Cont.) Vegetative Plant Development

Transport in Plants Question Paper 3

EFFECTS OF DROUGHT STRESS ON GROWTH RESPONSE IN CORN, SUDAN GRASS, AND BIG BLUESTEM TO GLOMUS ETUNICA TUM*

Understanding how vines deal with heat and water deficit

'H NMR Techniques in Studies of Transport of Paramagnetic Ions in Multicellular Systems

Reproduction, Seeds and Propagation

Biological and Agricultural Engineering Department UC Davis One Shields Ave. Davis, CA (530)

Secondary Cell Wall Deposition Causes Radial Growth of Fibre Cells in the Maturation Zone of Elongating Tall Fescue Leaf Blades

Plant Gene and Trait, 2013, Vol.4, No.8,

Principles of QTL Mapping. M.Imtiaz

Useful Propagation Terms. Propagation The application of specific biological principles and concepts in the multiplication of plants.

Plant Growth and Development

PLANT GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT

Plant Water Stress Frequency and Periodicity in Western North Dakota

Effects of Rising Atmospheric Concentrations of Carbon Dioxide on Plants

MORPHOLOGICAL, CULTURAL AND PATHOGENIC CHARACTERISTICS OF MACROPHOMINA PHASEOLINA ISOLATES FROM SUGAR BEET

Topic Covered. Name of the College/Institute: S K N College of Agriculture (SKNAU) Jobner

Growth Stages of Wheat: Identification and Understanding Improve Crop Management

Roots and Soil Chapter 5

BIO1PS 2012 Plant Science Lecture 4 Hormones Pt. I

Modelling the relationships between growth and assimilates partitioning from the organ to the whole plant

Figure 1. Identification of UGT74E2 as an IBA glycosyltransferase. (A) Relative conversion rates of different plant hormones to their glucosylated

(17) CYCLANILIDE: MECHANISM OF ACTION AND USES AS A PLANT GROWTH REGULATOR IN COTTON

XEROPHYTES, HYDROPHYTES AND CULTIVATED PLANTS

From smallest to largest plants

NOTES: CH 35 - Plant Structure & Growth

By the end of this lesson, you should be able to

Water Potential. The physical property predicting the direction in which water will flow. Pressure

The three principal organs of seed plants are roots, stems, and leaves.

Bio 100 Guide 27.

Biology 102 Environmental Biology Plants/Agriculture Unit Page 1 of 5

Height Variability Obtained From a New Dwarf Avocado Tree Population

Transcription:

264 BULG. J. PLANT PHYSIOL., SPECIAL ISSUE 2003, 264 272 THE ROLE OF CELL WALL PEROXIDASE IN THE INHIBITION OF LEAF AND FRUIT GROWTH T. Djaković 1, Z. Jovanović 2 1 Maize Research Institute, Slobodana Bajića 1, 11000 Belgrade, Serbia 2 Faculty of Agriculture, University of Belgrade, Nemanjina 6, 11081 Belgrade, Serbia Summary. The aim of the work presented was to investigate the role of cell wall bound peroxidase in the inhibition of leaf and fruit growth during unfavorable environmental conditions. In the first experiment, plants of two maize genotypes, differing in drought resistance and growth dynamics, were subjected to drought in order to observe leaf growth parameters (LER and SER) in parallel with bulk and segmental peroxidase activity in the growth zone. The results obtained indicated that drought significantly reduced LER, length of elongation zone and local growth rates within it in both genotypes. Bulk peroxidase activity was increased in both genotypes to different degrees (143% in low-ler and susceptible genotype and 238% in high-ler and resistant genotype) while segmental peroxidase activity also increased in almost every segment of the elongation zone with notable peaks in some regions. In the second experiment the same maize genotypes were subjected to nitrogen deficiency, where growth parameters and peroxidase activity were observed in the division and elongation zone separately. Nitrogen deficiency also caused a reduction of LER, cell division and elongation rate and shortening of the growth zone. This was followed by a significant increase in peroxidase activity in both regions of growth zones: in the low LER genotype this increase was expressed most in division zone, while in all other regions investigated the values were almost the same. The third experiment includes the effect of a partial root drying (PRD) treatment on tomato fruit growth and peroxidase activity in cell walls of fruit epidermis. Results obtained in all experiments allowed us to confirm that under stress conditions cell wall associated peroxidase plays an important role in biochemical inhibition of leaf and fruit growth. * Corresponding author, e-mail:

Cell wall peroxidase activity in biochemical control of leaf and fruit growth 265 Key words: growth, maize, tomato, leaf, fruit, LER, SER, cell wall, peroxidase activity Abbreviations: LER leaf elongation rate, SER segmental elongation rate Introduction Several studies have confirmed the role of cell wall bound peroxidase (EC 1.11.1.7) in biochemical regulation of leaf growth (MacAdam et al., 1992, Bacon et al., 1997, desouza and MacAdam, 1998 etc). Recent results indicate that reduction in leaf growth rate and cessation of cell expansion under drought conditions may be associated with changes in cell wall bound peroxidase activity (Bacon et al, 1997) while no results about biochemical regulation by cell-wall peroxidase activity under nitrogen deficiency have been reported as yet. According to current investigations, several cell wall enzymes, including peroxidase, mediate cell expansion of fruit in the same manner as in other plant organs. The role of cell-wall peroxidase in the biochemical regulation of tomato fruit growth was investigated by Thompson et al. (1998) during development, while Andrews et al. (2000) investigated peroxidase isoforms during the same period. They were concentrated on fruit epidermis since this tissue is considered as the growth controlling part. Our work was also focused on the activity in this tissue during fruit development and during partial root drying in order to investigate the role of this enzyme in biochemical control of tomato fruit growth in unfavorable growth conditions. Materials and Methods Plant material and growth conditions Two maize (Zea mays L.) genotypes, provided by Maize Research Institute Zemun Polje (Belgrade, Yugoslavia) and differing in growth dynamics and drought susceptibility were chosen for experiments. Line F-2 was characterized as a slow growing (low-ler) and drought susceptible genotype and hybrid ZPSC-677 as a fast growing (high-ler) and drought resistant genotype. After seed germination, plants were potted in a mixture made of soil, peat and sand and grown in a phytotrone chamber (t = 23/18ºC, RH=70%, photoperiod 14 h, PPFD of 200 µmol.m 2.s 1 ). Plants were irrigated daily until the appearance of the third leaf when randomly selected plants were exposed to drought by withholding water through the whole growth period of the experimental leaf. Plants for the nitrogen deficiency experiment were grown in perlite as a substrate and were irrigated with two types of nutrient solutions: 100% NO 3 -N and 0% NO 3 - N (Hewitt, 1966).

266 T. Djaković and Z. Jovanović Seeds of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) were germinated in commercial compost in a growth cabinet until the appearance of the fifth leaf. The plants were then removed from their pots and the root system of each plant was divided and repotted into two separate 3.0 l. plastic bags containing the same compost. These two separate compartments were irrigated alternately for 10 days to the end of experiment. Determination of growth parameters Leaf elongation rate the length of the third leaf was measured daily through the whole growth period and according to these data leaf elongation rate (LER) was calculated in mm.h 1. Segmental elongation rate (SER) on the day of leaf maximal elongation rate (LER max ) in the elongation zone of the third leaf the spatial distribution of local growth rates (SER) was determined and calculated in mm mm 1.h 1 (Schnyder et al., 1987). In the nitrogen deficiency experiment measurements of epidermal cell length along the growth zone were performed and, on the basis of these data, lengths of the division and the elongation zone were determined. Dynamics of fruit growth. This parameter was determined by measuring fruit diameter every five days from the immature phase until the end of ripening. Peroxidase assay Peroxidase activity in maize leaves in both experiments was determined during the day of maximal growth rate (LER max ). In the drought experiment it was determined both in the whole elongation zone (bulk peroxidase activity) and in 2 mm-long sections of the growth zone (segmental peroxidase activity). In the nitrogen deficiency experiment, the growth zone was divided into division and elongation zone so activity was measured in those parts separately. Samples were taken by excising the whole growth zone of the third leaf (bulk peroxidase activity), 2 mm long segments of the zone growth zone (segmental peroxidase activity) or division and elongation zone separately using razor blades. Samples of tomato epidermis were taken from fruits by peeling frozen fruits collected at different periods of PRD treatment: 55 days at the stage of developing fruits (early green stage), 80 days from mature but non-ripened fruits (mature green stage) and 95 days from ripened fruits. Samples were taken from fruits of five randomly selected plants in both PRD and control treatment. The strips of epidermis were cut and peeled from the equatorial region using razor blades. All samples were collected on ice and, after determination of fresh weight, were stored in the freezer at 20ºC. The method for cell wall extraction and isolation of peroxidase activity is precisely described by Bacon et al. (1997).

Cell wall peroxidase activity in biochemical control of leaf and fruit growth 267 Peroxidase activity was determined sprectrophotometrically at a wavelength of 470 nm in reaction mixture containing 10 µl of enzyme extract, 1ml of guiacol solution (276 µl of guiacol per 50 ml of 20 mmol phosphate buffer, ph 5.5) and 0.06% hydrogen peroxide. Activity in maize leaves was expressed in horseradish peroxidase units (HRPEU) per mg of leaf fresh weight while activity in tomato fruit was expressed in nmol per hour and mg of fresh weight. Results I Drought experiment LER max and bulk peroxidase activity According to results from table 1 maximal leaf elongation rate (LER max ) and cell wall bound peroxidase activity of the genotypes investigated significantly differed in both experimental conditions: LER max was higher in ZPSC-677 (high-ler genotype) and was followed by lower peroxidase activity compared to F-2 (low-ler genotype). SER and segmental peroxidase activity The profiles of segmental elongation rates (SER) (Fig.1.A) showed both distribution of growth rates through the zone and length of the elongation zone of the third leaf. Profile of local growth rates is showing differences between lengths of the growth zone and maximal values at the middle of elongation zone in both experimental conditions. Drought affects reductions in SER values and shortening of the elongation zone in both genotypes with more expressed influence in low-ler and drought susceptible genotype. The profile of peroxidase activity in the elongation zone (segmental activity) of the genotypes observed, presented in figure 1B, indicates different activities through the leaf elongation zone and pointed to the appearance of peaks in some regions of the elongation zone. Drought caused an increase in activity in almost all segments of the elongation zone. II Nitrogen deficiency experiment Results for maximal leaf elongation rate (LER max ) presented in Table 2 show that nitrogen deficiency caused a reduction in this parameter being, more expressed in the high-ler genotye. Data from Fig. 2 also confirmed different lengths of the growth zone in the genotypes investigated and the effect of nitrogen deficiency, which affected the division zone more than the elongation zone. Peroxidase activity didn t differ significantly between genotypes but nitrogen deficiency caused a significant increase in both regions of the growth zone (Fig. 3). It is also notable that peroxidase activity reached almost the same values in division and elongation zones.

268 T. Djaković and Z. Jovanović Fig. 1.The spatial distribution of SER (A) and cell wall peroxidase activity (B) through the growing zone of the 3 rd leaf in control (closed symbols) and drought conditions (open symbols). Each point is the mean of 10 plants ± S.E. of the 3 rd leaf. Fig. 2. The length of the division zone (white bars) and elongation zone (gray bars) of plants well supplied with nitrogen and subjected to nitrogen deficiency. Fig. 3. Peroxidase activity of the division zone (white bars) and elongation zone (gray bars) of plants well supplied with nitrogen or subjected to nitrogen deficiency. III Dynamics of fruit growth and peroxidase activity at different developmental stages Changes of tomato fruit diameter and peroxidase activity at different developmental stages in both experimental conditions are presented in Fig. 4. The profile of changes

Cell wall peroxidase activity in biochemical control of leaf and fruit growth 269 Fig. 4. Peroxidase activity in fruit epidermis at different developmental stages. Inset: fruit diameter during investigated period. in fruit diameter (inset in Fig. 4) showed a characteristic sigmoid shape with maximal velocities in immature developmental stages and decreasing rates towards maturity. PRD treatment, as indicated, didn t significantly affect growth dynamics or final size of fruit due to slightly higher growth rates although fruit growth stopped earlier than in controls. Peroxidase activity was rose during fruit development showing significant changes at the cessation of growth (between the immature and green mature phases) in both treatments, while a significant change was also recorded in treated plants between green and complete maturity. Treatment caused significant changes in peroxidase activity only at the stage of complete maturity.

270 T. Djaković and Z. Jovanović Discussion Effect of drought on leaf growth and peroxidase activity Data from Table 1 shows that higher values for LER max in ZPSC-677 are followed by lower peroxidase activity in both experimental conditions. Drought caused significant and almost the same reduction in maximal leaf growth rate of the third leaf in both genotypes while the increase in peroxidase activity was recorded in both genotypes but with different ranges (Table 1) which may point to the differential responses of susceptible and tolerant genotypes to drought. Table 1. Maximal growth rates (LER max ) and bulk peroxidase activity under controlled and drought conditions. * Indicates significance at the 0.1% level. LER max (mm/mm/h) bulk peroxidase activity (HRPEU x 10 4 mg 1 FW) genotype Reduc- Increase in control drought tion (% of control drought activity (% control) of control) F-2 1.17±0.06 0.60±0.03 * 49 4.9648±0.4839 12.0470±1.4743 * 143 ZPSC-677 2.60±0.13 1.38±0.06 * 47 0.6634±0.0776 2.2436±0.3298 * 238 The profile of segmental elongation rates (SER) in the growth zone showed that drought shortened the elongation zone and also reduced local growth rates while peroxidase activity showed several peaks of activity in the zone. The first peak was noticed in the division zone, the second in the region of maximal growth rates, while the third was recorded at the end of the elongation zone. This effect was also recorded by Bacon et al (1997). According to these authors, the physiological role of the first peak of activity is not yet understood but may be explained by the high density of cell walls and very fragile tissue; the second peak may be responsible for growth deceleration while cessation of growth can be ascribed to the third peak at the end of the elongation zone. Our results suggest that reduction of leaf growth rate in drought conditions is a consequence of both reduced cell division and cell elongation rate. Since cell-wall peroxidase activity takes part in cross-linking of cell-wall polymers Table 2. Maximal leaf elongation rate (LER max ) on the day of maximal growth rate. *Indicates significance at the 0.1% level. genotype LER max (mm/h) +N -N Reduction (% of control) F-2 0.8917 ± 0.0299 0.6833 ± 0.0293 * 23 ZPSC-677 1.2625 ± 0.0847 0.9333 ± 0.0374 * 26

Cell wall peroxidase activity in biochemical control of leaf and fruit growth 271 (Fry, 1986) making it less extensible, it may be supposed that the increase in activity of this enzyme is responsible for maize leaf growth reduction under drought stress condition. Effect of nitrogen deficiency on leaf growth and peroxidase activity Nitrogen deficiency is another limiting factor for leaf growth. Volonec and Nelson (1983) have found that optimal quantities of nitrogen increased the number of adult cells per day for 90% in Tall Fescue leaves. MacAdam et al. (1989) in Tall Fescue leaf blades and Palmer et al. (1996) in maize leaves obtained similar results. Our results showed that nitrogen deficiency affected shortening of the division zone in both genotypes, while the elongation zone remains the same. Peroxidase activity rose significantly in both regions of the elongation zone but there were no genotypic differences. This increase in the division zone, as in the drought experiment, has no valid physiological explanation yet, while the increase in the elongation zone may cause a reduction of cell elongation rates. This led us to the conclusion that cell wall ionically bound peroxidase activity is also taking part in the biochemical inhibition of leaf growth subjected to these unfavorable environmental conditions. Fruit growth and peroxidase activity during development and partial root drying Recent investigations have shown that cell wall peroxidase activity changes during fruit development reaching maximal values at the time of growth cessation (Thompson et al., 1998). Our data confirmed the previous study and revealed that significant changes in the activity in well-watered plants are only correlated with growth cessation and not with ripening. However, in treated plants we have recorded significant changes between all stages investigated, which may point to a special physiological role for this activity under stress conditions irrespective of fruit growth. We didn t record significant changes in activity between treatments during fruit ontogeny, as was expected due to lack of growth reduction, confirming the role of this enzyme in growth control. Changes in activity in mature fruits may be due to the appearance of new isoforms and further investigations in this field may provide some explanations. References Andrews, J., Malone, M., Thompson, D.J., Ho, L.C., Burton, K.S., 2000. Peroxidase isozyme patterns in skin of maturing tomato fruit. Plant, Cell and Environment 23, 415 422. Bacon M.A., Thompson D.S., Davies W.J., 1997. Can cell wall peroxidase activity explain the leaf growth response of Lolium temulentum during drought? J. Exp. Botany 48, 2075 2085 Chance B., Maehly A.C., 1955. Assay of catalases and peroxidases. In: Methods in Enzymology vol. II. Eds. Colowick Sp, Kaplan N.O. Academic Press Publishers, New York. 764 775

272 T. Djaković and Z. Jovanović Fry S.C., 1986. Cross-linking of matrix polymers in the growing cell walls of Angiosperms. Annual Review of Plant Physiol., 37, 165 86 Hewitt E.J., 1966. Sand and water culture methods used in the study of plant nutrition. Comm. Agri. Bur. Farn. Bucks, UK. MacAdam J.W., Volonec J.J., Nelson C., 1989. Effects of nitrogen on mesophyll cell division and epidermal cell elongation in Tall Fescue leaf blades. Plant Physiol., 89, 549 556 MacAdam J.W., Nelson C.J., Sharp R., 1992. Peroxidase activity in the leaf elongation zone of Tall fescue (I), Plant Physiol., 99, 872 878 Palmer S.J. and Davies W.J., 1996. An analysis of relative elemental growth rate, epidermal cell size and XET activity through the growing zone of aging maize leaves. J. Exp. Botany 47, 1 9 Schnyder H., Nelson C.J. and Coutts J.H., 1987. Assessment of spatial distribution of growth in the elongation zone of grass leaf blades, Plant Physiol., 85, 290 293 De Souza I.R.P., MacAdam J.W., 1998. A transient increase in apoplastic peroxidase activity precedes decrease in elongation rate of B73 (Zea mays) leaf blades. Physiol. Plant., 104, 556 62 Thompson D.S., Davies W.J., Ho L.C., 1998. Regulation of tomato fruit growth by epidermal cell wall enzymes. Plant, Cell and Environment 21, 589 599 Volonec J.J., Nelson., 1983. Responses of Tall Fescue leaf meristems to N fertilization and harvest frequency, Crop Science 23, 720 24