Swiss Contributions to a Better Understanding of the Space Debris Environment T. Schildknecht Astronomical Institute, University of Bern (), Switzerland 47 th Session of UNCOPUOS Scientific and Technical Subcommittee, Vienna, 8-19 February 2010
Outline 1. Why a Better Understanding 2. History of Swiss Space Debris Research 3. Scientific Highlights 4. International Collaboration 5. Summary Slide 2
Why do we Need a Better Understanding? Knowledge regarding the space debris environment required to Assess threads (e.g. risk to spacecraft) Design protection measures (e.g. shields) Devise efficient space debris mitigation measures enabling sustainable outer space activities Space debris research provides information on environment through Extending the catalogues of known space objects towards smaller sizes (deterministic population) enable active collision avoidance (safety of operations) Slide 3
Why do we Need a Better Understanding? Space debris research provides information on environment through (cont.) Acquiring statistical orbit information on small-size objects in support of statistical environment models statistical risk analysis (e.g. mission analysis, shielding, etc.) input data for long-term evolution models identification of debris sources progenitors of debris clouds (breakup events) disintegrations of spacecraft due to aging processes Long-term monitoring of environment identification of new sources verification of evolution models Slide 4
History of Swiss Space Debris Research Observation of artificial satellites at 's Zimmerwald observatory since 45 years Essential contribution to the ESA space debris observation program trough software development for the ESA space debris telescope planning, data acquisition, processing, 1992- observations programs (on behalf of ESA) Geostationary Orbit Objects Survey, 1998-2005 Geostationary Transfer Orbit Survey, 1997-2004 Extension of Optical Observation Capabilities of the Zeiss 1m Telescope / Space Debris Optical Observations, 2001-2008 MEO Surveys, 2008- Spectroscopic Measurements of GEO objects, 2008- Space debris cataloguing and characterization with 's sensors in Zimmerwald Slide 5
Surveys at the ESA 1-m Telescope, Tenerife Continuous program since since 1999 1999 10-12 10-12 nights/month operated by by Slide 6
Key Scientific Results (several firsts ) Longest and most sensitive observations of the GEO/GTO regime Discovery of small-sized (dm) debris only sensor with significant contribution for objects < 0.4m in IADC GEO campaigns 10 years of continuous monitoring clusters of debris in orbital element space discovered, evolution studied Input data for ESA MASTER environment model: introduction of "artificial" breakup events in order to model the observed clusters of debris in the 0.2 to 1m size range Discovery of "new" (i.e. previously unknown) population of high areato-mass (AMR) ratio objects First (and so far only) spectra of high area-to-mass (AMR) ratio objects Slide 7
Small-Sized Fragments in GEO (example 2008 surveys) Frequency 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 correlated Detections (Jan 2008 - Dec 2008) correlated uncorrelated Sensitivity 99 60 cm 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 Magnitude 40 cm uncorrelated 15 cm 10 cm 2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Sensitivity Slide 8
Contributing Swiss Sensors Used Used for: for: Faint Faint objects, light light curves, color color photometry 1 m ZIMLAT () Used Used for: for: Orbit Orbit maintenance (bright (bright obj.), obj.), object object searches Slide 9
Routine, Continuous Operation Observation Nights 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 1.10.02 30.09.03 1.10.03 30.09.04 1.10.04 30.09.05 1.10.05 30.09.06 Years ZIMLAT Observations / Objects 1.10.06 30.09.07 Objects 1.10.07 30.09.08 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 1.10.02 30.09.03 1.10.08 30.09.09 Objects Observations 1.10.03 30.09.04 1.10.04 30.09.05 ZIMLAT Observation Nights Nights 1.10.05 30.09.06 Years 1.10.06 30.09.07 1.10.07 30.09.08 1.10.08 30.09.09 20'000 15'000 10'000 5'000 0 Observations (tracklets) Slide 10
Catalogue of Small-Size Space Debris Build-up and maintenance of orbit catalogue of decimeter-sized debris in GEO () Why? Density/collision risk lower than in LEO BUT: No sinks population constantly grows Mitigation of debris is important Need to know nature and sources of debris Requires: Orbit catalogue Constant monitoring due to perturbations by non-gravitational forces Slide 11
Networking is Essential Discover new objects: Obs. From Tenerife (OGS, ) Secure orbits: obs. from OGS, Zimmerwald () Maintain orbits: obs. from OGS, Zimmerwald, international partners, International Scientific Optical observation Network (ISON),... Daily orbit maintenance at and Keldysh Institute of Applied Mathematics of the Russian Academy of Sciences (KIAM) Orbit catalogue of high-altitude space debris Provide predictions: To other partners (CNES, JAXA, NASA, Roscosmos...) to investigate physical properties of objects Slide 12
Discovery of High AMR Objects Unexpected, not modeled class of objects 100 90 80 Mean motion suggests release in GEO Eccentricity/inclination builds up (solar radiation pressure) Source & process of generation unknown Difficult orbit maintenance in catalogue of orbits shows need of continuous monitoring, frequent follow-ups, and data exchange Frequency 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 52 56 Area to Mass Ratio [m 2 /kg] Max. 73 m 2 /kg MLI?, solar cells? break-up event? aging effects? Slide 13
Characterization of Space Debris Light Light curves curves ZIMLAT; small small GEO GEO high high AMR AMR debris debris Magnitude 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 Seconds past 20080324 0:41:19 Spectrometry OGS OGS (); (); small small GEO GEO high high AMR AMR debris debris Spectra HST HST solar solar cell cell 4.5 4.0 Scaled Reflectance 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 Wavelength [nm] Slide 14
International Collaboration Active participation in the Inter-Agency Space Coordination Committee (IADC) by exchanging information on space debris research organizing cooperative observation campaigns providing measurements providing orbit predictions author is WG-1 measurements deputy chair Fostering international collaboration trough bi- and multilateral scientific cooperation partner of Int. Scientific Optical Network ISON scientific collaboration with Keldysh Institute of Applied Mathematics of the Russian Academy of Sciences (KIAM) cooperative observations with ESA, BNSC, NASA, JAXA and other space agencies operational support for ESA Slide 15
Summary 20 years of Space Debris Research in Switzerland Optical survey techniques Algorithms (detection, survey scenarios) Software suite Observations 10 years of space debris surveys at OGS for ESA Operational, continuous, highly automated observation programs using the Zimmerwald sensors Orbit Catalogues Orbit determination techniques/software Build-up and maintenance of space debris catalogue (GEO/GTO) International collaboration Physical Characterization area-to-mass ratio from orbital evolution sizes from photometry shapes from light curves materials from color photometry, spectra Slide 16
Thank you for your attention! Thomas Schildknecht Astronomical Institute University of Bern () Switzerland thomas.schildknecht@aiub.unibe.ch Slide 17