By: John M. Drake & Andrew M. Kramer (Odum School of Ecology, University of Georgia, Athens) 2011 Nature Education

of 8 http://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/allee-effects-19699394 2014/05/29 12:49 PM Allee Effects By: John M. Drake & Andrew M. Kramer (Odum School of Ecology, University of Georgia, Athens) 2011 Nature Education Citation: Drake, J. M. & Kramer, A. M. (2011) Allee Effects. Nature Education Knowledge 3(10):2 Creative Commons Eistreter via Wikimedia Commons Some rights reserved. History and Definition Allee effects occur in small or sparse populations and, although rarely detected, are widely believed to be common in nature. Population growth of populations subject to Allee effects is reduced at low density. The originator and namesake of the phenomenon was Warder Clyde Allee (1885 1955), a University of Chicago zoologist and animal ecologist, whose special interest was group behavior in animals. Charles Darwin observed that large population size is an important hedge against extinction in the presence of predators or other natural enemies (Darwin 1872, quoted in Stephens et al. 1999). Nevertheless, early twentieth century biologists typically accepted as given both the Malthusian principle that intra-specific competition does not decrease with population size and its mathematical expression in the logistic model for population growth (Gause 1934). Allee, an astute observer of animal behavior, noticed that in many species it was undercrowding, not competition, that limited population growth. He observed, for instance, that aggregation had positive effects on the survival of land isopods, which were subject to rapid desiccation when isolated (Allee 1927). His empirical examples of the benefits of aggregation seemed to contradict both the Malthusian paradigm and the logistic model. Much of Allee's early work focused on documenting this phenomenon in animal populations (Allee 1931). In modern biology, Allee effects are considered to have two manifestations: 1. 2. component Allee effects are exhibited by a population in which there is a positive association between some fitness component (e.g., viability, juvenile survivorship, fecundity; Orr 2009) and population size; demographic Allee effects that occur when these component Allee effects produce a positive association between per capita population growth and population size. Keeping in mind that competition, for instance for resources or space, will limit a population's size, and noting that per capita growth rate of a population at small size equals average absolute individual fitness (Lande et al. 2003), both kinds of Allee effects may be captured by the following general definition. An Allee effect is a positive association between absolute average individual fitness and population size over some finite interval. Such a positive association may (but does not necessarily) give rise to a critical population size below which the population cannot persist (Stephens et al. 1999). Allee effects that cause critical population sizes are called strong, while Allee effects that do not result in critical sizes are called weak. Other names for the Allee effect

2 of 8 2014/05/29 12:49 PM are positive density dependence (in contrast to classical negative density dependence) and depensatory dynamics (in contrast to classical compensatory dynamics). Mechanisms That Cause Allee Effects A positive relationship between fitness and population size can be caused by a variety of mechanisms that affect reproduction and survival. A well established example, mate limitation, may result in undercrowding in species that reproduce sexually, because sexual reproduction requires contact between male and female gametes. Mate limitation reduces reproduction when plants or animals release gametes into the environment or when males and females have difficulty locating each other. When behaviors such as breeding, feeding, and defense are cooperative, they become more efficient or successful in larger social groups, resulting in increased reproductive success or survivorship (Courchamp et al. 1999). Although cooperative behaviors are most obvious in social vertebrates, such as prairie dogs, ungulates or birds, Allee effects resulting from group feeding or defense can also arise in insects, such as bark beetles, and aquatic organisms, such as cichlid fish (Friedenberg et al. 2007, Balshine et al. 2001). Other mechanisms do not require cooperation in the behavioral sense, but merely the presence of conspecific individuals. For example, the per capita risk of predation is smaller in large prey populations than small prey populations (Dennis 1989, Gascoigne and Lipcius 2004). It is also known that the presence of multiple individuals can alter environmental or biotic conditions in favorable ways. Examples of such niche construction include reducing physical damage in intertidal zones (Bertness and Grosholz 1985) or exclusion of competitors via allelopathy (Cappuccino 2004). Finally, demographic and genetic mechanisms may give rise to Allee effects. In animals, active dispersal away from low-density populations can result in decreased rates of population growth (Bonte et al. 2004). For many organisms, when population size is small, inbreeding depression can cause an Allee effect by reducing average fitness as population size declines (Fischer et al. 2003). While these phenomena differ in form, in the way they affect fitness, and in which species are affected, they all result in the same general pattern: small populations suffer from reduced average individual fitness. Evidence of Allee Effects Evidence for Component Allee Effects There is evidence from natural populations for component Allee effects due to all of these mechanisms (see references above, Courchamp et al 2008, Kramer et al. 2009; Figure 1). The most commonly observed mechanism is mate limitation, which causes Allee effects in both animals and plants (in the form of pollen limitation). Positive density dependence in survivorship due to either cooperative defense or predator satiation is also found across taxonomic groups. Indeed, because the tendency of predators to become satiated and stop increasing consumption depends on the predator rather than the prey, predator satiation has the potential to affect any population fed upon by a predator that does not numerically track the abundance of the small prey population, such as when a generalist predator feeds on multiple species (Kramer & Drake 2010). Evidence for the other mechanisms described above is less abundant, but each has been found in multiple taxonomic groups, and some studies have detected positive density dependence in reproduction or survival without identifying the mechanism (Kramer et al. 2009), making it likely that there are other mechanisms that lead to component Allee effects. The population level impacts of these mechanisms are less clear.

3 of 8 2014/05/29 12:49 PM Figure 1: The number of studies which attributed the Allee effect in a species to a given mechanism, according to taxonomy Taxonomic groups for which there is evidence of Allee effects are terrestrial arthropods, aquatic invertebrates, mammals, birds, fish, and plants. Species were included if the mechanism was detected empirically in natural populations. Single studies can be represented by multiple evidence types and mechanisms. The area of the circle represents the relative number of species exhibiting each mechanism (smallest circle = 1 species, largest = 20 species). Question marks indicate combinations where evidence is currently lacking. 2011 Nature Education Modified from Kramer et al. 2009 All rights reserved. Evidence for Demographic Allee Effects Demographic Allee effects have been harder to demonstrate. Two reasons for this include: 1. Allee effects in one component of fitness may be offset at low density by increases in other components of fitness, such as decreased competition for resources; 2. Natural populations at low density are often difficult to detect and the high variance that results from small sample sizes obscures statistical analysis. For these reasons, unusual cases of population growth are important to the ongoing study of Allee effects. In particular, monitoring data from invasive species provides an opportunity for improving understanding of Allee effects. Some likely effects of positive density dependence are easier to observe, extinction, for instance, but it is difficult to confirm that an Allee effect was to blame. Dynamics of Populations with Allee Effects The most dramatic consequences of Allee effects are associated with strong Allee effects, although weak Allee effects are also predicted to give rise to measurable dynamical differences. The difference between Allee effects and the classical (Malthusian) logistic theory is seen most clearly in the correlation between per capita

4 of 8 2014/05/29 12:49 PM growth rate and population size. This correlation can be generated using : where x is the population size, a is the critical point, and k represents the force of competition and is known as the carrying capacity (Figure 2a). Figure 2: Allee effects are distinguished from other forms of density dependence by a positive association between average absolute individual fitness and population size over a finite interval. When Allee effects are strong, a critical size occurs where the growth function dx/dt=f(x) intersects the horizontal line at zero (panel a, red arrow). This is an unstable equilibrium. Populations with abundance greater than this value will increase to carrying capacity (panel a, black arrow). Populations with abundance less than this value will decline to extinction. While carrying capacity is a stable equilibrium for both strong and weak Allee effects, and for logistic growth, extinction is stable only for strong Allee effects and unstable for weak Allee effects and logistic growth. Both kinds of Allee effects may be diagnosed by the positive association between per capita population growth rate and small population sizes, shown here to reach an intermediate maximum for weak Allee effects and for strong Allee effects (panel b). Strong and weak Allee effects may be distinguished by whether the y-intercept of the per capita growth rate is less than zero (indicating strong Allee effect, red arrow in panel b) or greater than zero (indicating weak Allee effect, blue arrow in panel b). Trajectories of populations with weak Allee effects are delayed compared with logistic growth, but qualitatively similar: populations initialized at any size will grow smoothly to carrying capacity (panel c). By contrast, the bistability of strong Allee effects means that eventual limit population size is determined by the initial condition (panel c). In panel c, the dashed lines for each population are for trajectories with initial size N =21 and the solid lines for trajectories with initial size N =19. From this plot, it is evident that the effects of small changes in 0 0 initial population size are virtually indistinguishable for populations with logistic growth or weak Allee effects, but may be crucial for populations with strong Allee effects. Further, the delay between the trajectories for populations with weak Allee effects or logistic growth and the dashed red line for a population with a strong Allee effect initialized just greater than the critical population size at N =21, shows the very slow population takeoff caused by strong Allee effects, even when growth is positive. 0 2011 Nature Education All rights reserved. Dividing both sides by the population size (x) yields the per capita population growth rate: The classical logistic theory predicts that per capita growth rate will not increase with population size (Figure

5 of 8 2014/05/29 12:49 PM 2b). By the definition above, a population with an Allee effect will exhibit an increase over some interval of population size (Figure 2b). This distinction between Allee and non-allee populations is the same regardless of whether the y-axis depicts per capita intrinsic rate of increase, the reproductive multiplier, λ, or lifetime reproductive output. Strong and weak Allee effects are distinguished according to whether the y-intercept falls below or above the replacement value (1/x dx/dt = 0 or λ = 1), respectively (Figure 2b). These plots do not distinguish whether the Allee effect is endogenous to the dynamics of the population, such as result from mate limitation, or due to interactions with other species, such as the predator-induced Allee effect exhibited by the crown-of-thorns starfish Acanthaster planci (Dulvy et al. 2004; Figure. 3). Figure 3: The relationship between per capita growth rate and starfish density show that the crown-of-thorns starfish (Acanthaster planci) is subject to a strong Allee effect. In this case, the Allee effect is due to escape from fish predation at Other dynamical consequences of strong Allee effects high density. include: 2011 Nature Education Adapted from Dulvy et al. 2004 1. A sigmoidal relationship between the probability All rights reserved. of rapid extinction and the initial population size (Dennis 1989), a pattern which contrasts with the concave shape predicted by the classical logistic theory (Dennis 2002) (Figure 4a); 2. A critical area that the population must occupy for it to persist (Lewis & Kareiva 1993, Vercken et al. 2011) (Figure 4b); 3. A bimodal stationary distribution of population size (Dennis 1989, Drake & Lodge 2006) (Figure 4c). Figure 4: Three signatures of the Allee effect A sigmoidal probability of rapid extinction results from an inflection point corresponding to the critical population size (panel a). A critical area (panel b) results from the race between population growth at the center of a patch (where the population density exceeds the critical value) and dispersal at the periphery (where population density is below the replacement level). The critical area may be characterized by a radius r that the population must exceed for the patch to persist. The solid line in panel b c illustrates the critical area. The dashed (dotted) lines represent the areas subsequently occupied by populations that initially occupy the area just larger (smaller) than the critical area. The critical point in the growth dynamics also gives rise to a trough in the stationary distribution of population sizes once they have equilibrated (panel c). This trough causes the density to be bimodal with a lower mode in the vicinity of extinction and an upper mode at carrying capacity. 2011 Nature Education All rights reserved. Evolution

6 of 8 2014/05/29 12:49 PM The negative effects of low density, such as difficulty finding mates or increased vulnerability to predators, is expected to often result in strong selection for traits that reduce the influence of these mechanisms. For instance, rare species, which are typically at low density, often have adaptations that allow positive growth at low density, or they will become extinct. However, aggregation and sociality are not adaptations that eliminate Allee effects per se. Rather, they increase population densities so that the densities at which Allee effects are manifest are avoided (Stephens and Sutherland 1999). Other traits may be the result of selection on low-density populations. For example, displays, calls, and pheromones all widen the area over which males and females perceive mates, thus reducing mate limitation. These adaptations can also increase fitness in other ways, however, such as signaling mate quality, so it is difficult to assign causality (Courchamp et al. 2008). Similarly, sperm storage, hermaphroditism, and parthenogenesis are all favored when chances of encountering mates are low, but may provide fitness benefits in other contexts as well, such as accelerated local adaptation (Cousyn et al. 2001). It is reasonable to conclude that species most likely to suffer Allee effects are those that usually have large populations but have suffered a recent reduction in size, such as due to habitat fragmentation or catastrophic natural events. Such populations will be more likely to suffer from mechanisms that reduce fitness at low density, especially if traits conferring fitness at low density incur a cost at high density. Finding such a trade-off may provide the best indication that a trait is an evolutionary response to persistence at low density (Courchamp et al. 2008). Environmental applications When the size of populations subject to strong Allee effects is low, then these populations tend towards extinction. This fact argues for a thorough understanding of Allee effects and their mechanisms in order to develop sound management practices for a number of environmental issues. An obvious case is the conservation of rare species. It has been shown, for instance, that small patches of the flowering herb Clarkia concinna concinna attract pollinating insects in fewer numbers than do large patches. As a result, small patches are more prone to extinction (Groom 1998). In general, persistence of species subject to strong Allee effects requires that a minimum population size specific to each population be distributed over a population-specific minimal area. This conclusion also applies to efforts to restore extirpated populations through captive breeding and reintroduction. Another environmental issue that involves the Allee effect is the management of invasive species. Population biologists have long wondered why only a small fraction of introduced species ultimately persist in their introduced locations (Williamson & Fitter 1996). A partial answer to this question is that many introductions are below the critical size associated with Allee effects (Grevstad 1999). It follows that risk management for invasive species could be improved by a better understanding of the comparative biology of Allee effects (i.e., the relative frequency and strength of Allee effects across species) (Drake et al. 2004), coupled with a quantitative understanding of the rates at which introductions occur, a concept referred to as propagule pressure (Leung et al. 2004, Lockwood et al. 2005). Even populations with weak Allee effects may require consideration of Allee effects for effective management. For instance, the invasive smooth cordgrass, Spartina alterniflora, is known to exhibit Allee effects due to pollination limitation. As a result, new patches of cordgrass initially grow quite slowly. An observer of such an invasion might wrongly conclude that this species' potential for spread is low. However, once the incipient colony grows to a certain size its potential to spread increases dramatically (Taylor 2004). Conclusion Allee effects are a small population phenomenon in which population growth rate is reduced by undercrowding. Although Allee effects are widely believed to be common and are important to environmental management, clear documentation of demographic Allee effects in nature has mostly proved elusive. References and Recommended Reading Allee, W. C. Animal aggregations. The Quarterly Review of Biology 2, 367 398 (1927).

. Animal Aggregations. A Study in General Sociology. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1931. Balshine, S. et al. Correlates of group size in a cooperatively breeding cichlid fish (Neolamprologus pulcher). Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 50 134 140 (2001). Bertness, M. D. & Grosholz, E. Population dynamics of the ribbed mussel, Geukensia demissa: The costs and benefits of an aggregated distribution. Oecologia 62, 192 204 (1985). Bonte, D., Lens, L., & Maelfait, J. Lack of homeward orientation and increased mobility result in high emigration rates from low-quality fragments in a dune wolf spider. Journal of Animal Ecology 73, 643 650 (2004). Cappucino, N. Allee effect in an invasive alien plant, pale swallow-wort Vicentoxicum rossicum (Asclepiadaceae). Oikos 106, 3 8 (2004). Courchamp, F., Berec, L., & Gascoigne, J. Allee Effects in Ecology and Conservation. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2008. Courchamp, F., Clutton-Brock, T., & Grenfell, B. Inverse density dependence and the Allee effect. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 14, 405 410 (1999). Cousyn, C. et al. Rapid, local adaptation of zooplankton behavior to changes in predation pressure in the absence of neutral genetic changes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 98, 6256 6260 (2001). Dennis, B. Allee effects: Population growth, critical density, and the chance of extinction. Natural Resource Modeling 3, 481 538 (1989).. Allee effects in stochastic populations. Oikos 96, 389 401 (2002). Davis, H. G. et al. Pollen limitation causes an Allee effect in a wind pollinated invasive grass (Spartina alterniflora). Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 101, 13804 13807 (2004). Drake, J. M. & Lodge, D. M. Allee effects, propagule pressure and the probability of establishment: Risk analysis for biological invasions. Biological Invasions 8, 365 375 (2006). Dulvy, N. K., Freckleton, R. P., & Polunin, V. N. V. C. Coral reef cascades and the indirect effects of predator removal by exploitation. Ecology Letters 7, 410 416 (2004). Fischer, M., Hock, M., & Paschke, M. Low genetic variation reduces cross-compatibility and offspring fitness in populations of a narrow endemic plant with a self-incompatibility system. Conservation Genetics 4, 325 336 (2008). Friedenberg, N. A., Powell, J. A., & Ayres, M. P. Synchrony's double edge: Transient dynamics and the Allee effect in stage structured populations. Ecology Letters 10, 564 573 (2007). Gascoigne, J. C. & Lipcius, R. N. Allee effects driven by predation. Journal of Applied Ecology 41, 801 810 (2004). Gause, G. F. The Struggle for Existence. Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins, 1934. Johnson, D. M. et al. Allee effects and pulsed invasion by the gypsy moth. Nature 444, 361 363 (2006). Kramer, A. M. & Drake, J. Experimental demonstration of population extinction due to a predator-driven Allee effect. Journal of Animal Ecology 79, 633 639 (2010). Kramer, A. M. et al. The evidence for Allee effects. Population Ecology 51, 341 354 (2009). Leung, B., Drake, J. M., & Lodge, D. M. Predicting invasions: Propagule pressure and the gravity of Allee effects. Ecology 85, 1651 1660 (2004). Lewis, M. A. & Kareiva, P. Allee dynamics and the spread of invading organisms. Theoretical Population Biology 43, 141 158 (1993). Lockwood, J. L., Cassey, P. & Blackburn, T. The role of propagule pressure in explaining invasions. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 20, 223 228 (2005). Orr, H. A. Fitness and its role in evolutionary genetics. Nature Reviews Genetics 10, 531 539 (2009). Stephens, P. A. & Sutherland, W. J. Consequences of the Allee effect for behaviour, ecology and conservation. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 14, 401 405 (1999). Taylor, C. M. et al. Consequences of an Allee effect on the invasion of a Pacific estuary by Spartina alterniflora. Ecology 85, 3254 3266 (2004). 7 of 8 2014/05/29 12:49 PM

8 of 8 2014/05/29 12:49 PM Veit, R. R. & Lewis, M. A. Dispersal, population growth, and the Allee effect dynamics of the house finch invasion of eastern North America. The American Naturalist 148, 255 274 (1996). Vercken, E. et al. Critical patch size generated by Allee effect in gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar (L.). Ecology Letters 14, 179 186 (2011).