The legal status of the international employee 400910080 )) (( 2011
ب
ج
د
ه ( ) - ) - - (
و 1 1 5 9 9 10 11 11 - - - - - - 11 -
ز 12 13 - - 15 15-16 - 22 24-24 - 32-39 - 39-43 - 45-46 - 53-56 - 61 -
ح 63 67-68 - 70-71 - 72-84 - 87-88 - 96-97 98 99 102 103 105 : : : : " : " -
ط 105 108 112 114 114 115 119 126 130 136 139 - - - - - - - 146 153 156 197 -
ي
ك The legal status of international employee Prepared by : Hiba Jamal Naser Abdullah Ali Supervised by : Abdul salaam Hamash ABSTRACT The world today witness a stage of overlapping between the interests of the countries, and the international organizations play an important role and extremely complicated where organizations become organize in all affairs of individual life And necessarily, the number of international organizations in increasing, as well as the number of international staff who works in these organizations And given the large number of such personnel the need the clearly show the presence of one legal system to control performance of these staff, Although the different between their works and their legal relationship to the international organization In this context, comes this study to shed light on the legal system of international employee to address the issue had to be back to study the evolution of concept of international employee
1 1 2 1949 11 " 121 (2005) ( 175 ( ) ( 1 2
2 " 3 -: -1-2 -3-4 -5 69 (1998) ( 3
3 " " 4 : (1986) ( 4 7
4 5 6 3 ( 6 32 ( 5
5 7 -: THE ORTICAL FRAME - -: - - - - - - - - - - - - ( 9 7
6 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
7 - - - - - - - : -: : : : " " : : : : : - :
8 : : : : : - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
9 - - STUDY ISSUE - Questions OF STUDY - : -1-2 -3
10-4 ( ) 5-6 -7-8 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY - -: - - -
11 - THE IMPORTANT OF THE STUDY - Limitations of the Study - Determinants of study -
12 TERMS OF THE STUDY - ( ) -: -1 8 -: -2 9 -: -3 ( ) 10 -: -4 11 25 1999 / ( 19 / ( 175 / ( 106 2000 / ( 8 9 10 11
13 " ( ) -: -5 12 PREVIOUS STUDIED - -: ) 2006-1 ( " " / ( 21 2006 12
14 : ) 1986-2 ( " " " "
15 " 1991-3 " -: - -: - -:
16 - -: - -( ) (2005) -1 ( ) (1999) -2 1 (2005-2004 ) -3 ( ) -4 (2007 ) -5 ( 1975 ) -6 ( 1974) -7 (2010 ) -8 " (2006 ) -9
17 " (2003) -10 (2004 ) -11, (2004) -12 ) (1991) -13 ( ) ( 2006) -14 2 ( ( 2000) 1-15 (1999) -16 (1998) -17 (1995) -18
18 (1990) -19 (1986) -20-21 : (2001 ) -22 " (2003 ) -23-24 (1963) -25 1963 " " -26 -( ) 1-Annual digest and reports of public international law cases 1946 2-international puplic,dallo2 2004 le edition Pirre-marie dapuy, droit 3- Sydneg D, Bdiley The Secretariat of the United Nations, 1964 -: -
19-1 -2 " (1964 ) -3 " -: - -1-2 -3-4 -5-6 -7-8 -: - -1
20 http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/unjs/ ( ) -2 2010 http://unesdocunescoorg/images/0018/001874/187429apdf " " --3 http://wwwjusticelawhomecom/vb/attachmentphp?attachmentid=3399&d=1288177767-4 1991-1948 http://wwwicj-cijorg/homepage/ar/files/sum_1948-1991pdf -5 http://dhabiyamaktoobblogcom/1595843/%d9%85-6 http://wwwunorg/arabic/geninfo/ir/ch6/ch6htm -: - (2006) -1
21 " " (1991) -2 : (1986) -3
22 "Martin luther king" said -: no mater what profession you choose in life, you should make a career of humanity, whether you are a teacher,doctor, or lawer you should dedicate some 13 time to bulding a more human and peaceful world for your self -: ( ) ( 13
23 " " 14 15 " " 73 ( 32 ( 14 15
24 -: ( ) ( ) ( ) -: -: - 16 ( 16
25 17 -: -: - " ( ) 18 " 1919 1815 19 ( (2005-2004 ) -: 72-71 32 ( 338 ( 1974) ( 17 18 19
26 20 -: - - - ( ) 1871 1867 78 ( 20
27 -: - 21-1 -2-3 ( ) : -1-2 28-27 ( 21
28 22 ) ( 1865 17 ) (1890 14 ) (1874 ) (1890 5 ) (1905 7) (1902 5 20 ) (1886 9 ) (1907 9 ) (1875 81 ( 22
29 23 " " " " " " 24 (24) 1919 222 ( Kazanky : " " 53 ( les fonctionnaires 1959 " " internatioaux 23 24
30 25 26 2 ( : 1921 " " 54 ( 25 26
31 " 1905 " 27 1889 ( ) ( ( ) 38 1815 ) (1874 1856 (1990) -: 3 27
32 28 -: - 29 " " (1964 ) ( 91 16 ( 28 29
33 -: - 30 : ( 1934 ) 31 32 " " 33 1919 28 ( 29-28 ( 34 ( "Eric Drummond " ( 30 31 32 33
34 34! 35 ( ) 36 " " (2006 ) ( 298 40 ( 54-53 ( 34 35 36
35 37 38 39 -: - 247 ( 67 ( 43 ( 37 38 39
36 - ) ( -: -
37 40 41 -: 42 - ( 43 ) 5 ( 293 ( " (97) ( " 493 ( 40 41 42 43
38 )1965 ( 11 44 -: - 45 ( ) ) ( 46 295 ( -1992 ( 1995 552 298 ( 44 45 46
39 ) ( 47 - -: 7 ( 47
40 48 49 50 " 51 52 ( 97 ( 56 ( 319 ( 48 49 50 51
41 Agent international " " standard functional 52 53 54 1949 6 (1995) ( 57-56 75 ( 2 ( 52 53 54
42 55 " " " 56 57 ( ) d'une : 295 1945 : ( paul Reuter, les organs subsidiaires des organizations internationals,hommages Génération de jurists au president basdevant, Paris,1960p4,5 et SS 148 (1986) ( 57 ( 55 56 57
43 ( ) 58 -: - ( ) -: ( organique ) - 176 ( 58
44 59 ( temporel relatif ) - local 6/101 60 ( Normatif combine ) - 61 42 ( ( 333 CIJ"Avis de 27mai 1987 la reformation du jugement NO333 du tribunal Administratif des Nations unies 61 16 ( 59 60
45 62 " " " 63 " -: - -: - TANA,Jug NO19,Kaplan clonu,21aout 1953 ( 17 ( 62 63
46 64-65 66 67 (2004 ) ( 64 47 160 ( ) ( ( 6 7 ( (2006 ) ( 65 66 67 33
47 101 68 69 101 70 (1) 1 (4) ( (1) (4) ( 110 ( 68 69 70
48 100 71 (12) 72 (1) (4) ( (2) (1) (4) ( : - 20 - - - 71 72
49 73 74 75 : : -1 : -2 1946 1952 160 ( 99 ( 36 ( 73 74 75
50 76 77 179420 -: - (4) (5) 78 75 ( 72-29 ( 76 77 192 11 70 78 76 ( 78
51 ( ) 79 : - : - : - : - (2) (3) (4) ( 79
52 80 : 13/104 : - : - : - ( ) ) 104 ( 80
53 ( 81 -: - 82 (6 ) (8 ) (16 )( ) (39 ) : ( (1) 82 78 60 ( 81 82
54 83 84 85 ) 86 ( " " (2001 ) ( 83 362-316 (2003) -( ) ( 317 85 182 ( 84 325 ( 86
55 87 41 89 ( 87
56-88 89 -: - ( http://wwwuniv-biskradz/fac/droit/revues/revumofakir/sommaire/r3/mf3a15pdf 324 ( 88 89
57 90 91 92 -: - : - -: -1 159 ( 338 ( 160 ( 90 91 92
58 2/105 1953 9 " 22 4/2 93 94 -: -2 1946 1947 95 131 ( 172 ( 328 ( 93 94 95
59 96 -: -3 -: - -: : -1 ( : 165 96
60 97 1945 1993 : -2 98 99 " (19) ( - ( http://wwwuniv-biskradz/fac/droit/revues/revumofakir/sommaire/r3/mf3a15pdf 99 319 ( ) ( 97 98
61-3 100-101 102 18 16 ( 319 ( 183 ( 100 101 102
62 103 - ( ) 104 105 512 (2010 ) ( 325 ( 70 ( 103 104 105
63 fonctionnaire les internationaux 106 " : Droit international puplic,dallo2 2004 le8 edition page 199 Pirre-marie dapuy( 106
64 107 108 1958 74 109 43 ( 114 ( 74-73 ( 107 108 109
65 ( ) ) ( ) ( ( ) ) ( ) ( 110 ( ) ( ), ( 1948 20 1945,, ( ) 1948 110
66 ( ) 111 -: -1-2 -3 69 ( 111
67 ( ) - ) ( : - 112 30 ( 112
68 113 114 -: : : -1 : - 115 25-24 ( 243-241 (2003) ( ( 113 114 115
69 116 : HOURANI - 117-22 ( 130 ( 116 117
70 -: - 2 1956 / 23 118 -: - 25 ( 118
71 119 : - 120-121 90 (1999 ) ( 242 ( " " (1991) ( 119 120 121 41
72 122 -: - -: - 2/100 123 : -: 331 ( 130 ( 122 123
73 124 125 ) ( 126-127 ( ) (1) " " ( 124 157 133 ( 183 ( 62 15 ( 125 126 127 19
74 128 1975/9/6 3307 129 130 1965 http://wwwunorg/arabic/geninfo/ir/ch6/ch6htm ( 134 ( 64 20 63 ( 128 129 130
75 131-132 133 -: - 134 51 ( 134 ( 4/103 8/103 ( 140 ( 131 132 133 134
76 11/103 11/103 " " " 7/103 " 11/103 -: - 135 2/15 ( 57 : 135
77 : 136-137 14/104 138 : - ١ 138 ( : ( 136 137 56 ( 6 ) ( 138
78-٢ - ٣ ( ) (10/1 ) 139 1975 /4/26 ٣٢٧٨ 1/105 5/503 105 (2) (5) ( 139
79 (٤٤ ) ( ٢٠ ( ٤٥ ) 140 ( ) 141 -: 142 346 ( 58 ( 148 ( 140 141 142
80 143 -: - 144 183 352 ( 143 158 338 ( 144
81 145 146 : - 105-14 - -: -1 147 183 ( 101 ( 338 ( 145 146 147
82 148-2 -3-4 -5 149-6 15 ( 338 ( 148 149
83-7 150-8 151 -: 160-159 ( ( 150 151
84 70 152 153-56-55 ( 340 ( 152 153
85 -: - 154 " " (3) " " - 1948 155 14 (2003 ) ( 13 ( 154 155
86 156 -: 157 /20 " " -: - 42 ( 130 ( 156 157
87 158 " " 159-160 183 ( 18 ( 43 ( 158 159 160
88 161 162 163 : -: - 330 ( 17 ( 184 ( 161 162 163
89 164 ( ) 165 -: ": 4/1 ( ( ) 6/151 : ": ( ) / - " : ( ) 4/151 - " " 2/212 - " 87 54 11 159 / : (2) TANUle 6/4/1973,Dupuy,174 ( 164 165 69
90 4/1 166 1/2 54 16 87 167 159 ( -1 : ( 15 : Sydneg D, Bdiley The Secretariat of the United Nations, 1964, P 29 166 167
91 -: - " 168 " 169 2/1 Union de Europ Occidental (UEO) 170 2/1 ( /19 ( 71 -: ( 168 169 170
92 171 -: - 172 ": 1/1 " 3/19 ( -taoit le 21-10-1974,Riley243 -taoit le 9-5-1967terrain 109 172 499 ( 171
93 ( ) 173 174 1920 19 1945 184, 155 ( 120-113 " ( 173 174
94 175 - " 176 " -: - 2/194 177 6/4 10 9/1 ( 7/101 1949 11 ( 128 ( 175 176 177
95 " 178 ( ) 2/8 ( ) 179 -: 180 5/1 ( 17 ( 331 ( 178 179 180
96 181 - - 182 -: 183 -: - 77 ( 50-49 ( 122 ( 181 182 183
97 6/101 7/1 184 185-17 131 ( 123 ( 184 185
98 186 -: - 6/1 11 ( ) 1/8 ( ) 4/101 187-348 ( 129 ( 186 187
99 188 189 ) -: -: " " 190-84, (2004) ( 189 102-101 ( 85 ( 188 190 62
100 191 102 ( 191
101 192 : 193 194 86 : ( it is not possible,by a strained use of the concept of allegrance,to assimi-late the legal bond which " exists,under article 100of the charter between the organization on the one hand,and the secretary general and the staff on the other" 194 345 ( ( 192 193
102 195 -: 196 " " 87 ( 105 ( 195 196
103 197 " " -: 198 " " 105 88 ( 197 411 1958 Howrani Vthe SG of UN 1951/8/25 /103 Ruth Forma 1955/10/29 VUNESCO 1/1/9 Official Bulletin (ILO),1955,P295 198 84 ( 1975 ) ( "
104 199 200 201 159-158 ( 21 ( 90 ( 199 200 201
105 202 203 - -: 108 ( 7 ( 202 203
106 -: - " 204 72 ( 204
107 205 ( ) - - 206 207 -: - 41 ( 320 1 ( 2000) ( 41-40 ( 205 206 207
108 208 -: - 209 24 ( 33 ( 208 209
109 : -: - 210 -: - 211 30 (2007 ) ( 86-85 ( 210 211
110 212 ( ) 213 -: - ( ) 214 56 ( 178 ( 256-255 1963 (1963) ( 212 213 214 177
111 215 -: - ( ) 216 -: - 217 30 ( 325-324 ( (1)76 ( 7-5 317 ( ) 215 216 217
112 218 -: 219 318-317 ( 1949 ( 218 219
113
114 220 -: ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) - 99 ( 220
115 221 - : - : 1926 ( 221
116 222 -: - 223 198 : ( 188 ( 222 223
117 224 K 225 ١٩٤٨ " " ١٩٤٩ ( ) 226 189 ( 71 ( 225 226
118 227 : 183 ( 227
119 ( ) ( / 50 ) 40 228 6 229 -: _1-2 ( Annual digest and reports of public international law cases 1946, No 77, PP 168 229 2010 ( ) ( http://unesdocunescoorg/images/0018/001874/187429apdf 228
120-3 -4-5 -: -
121 230 231 ( 1920 17 : " " ( 230 http://wwwjusticelawhomecom/vb/attachmentphp?attachmentid=3399&d=1288177767 231
122 : (232) -: - 233 214 ( " " ( http://wwwjustice-lawhomecom/vb/attachmentphp?attachmentid=3399&d=1288177767 232 233
123 -: -: - 2/8 ( 2/108) 234 235 -: - - - - 245-244 ( 111 ( 234 235
124 -: - (50) 236 -: - - - 237-245 ( 113 ( 236 237
125 238 -: - 239 ) " ( 240 102 ( ( 238 239 304-303 ( 240
126 241 242! ),,, (, ( ), : ( ) : ( 253-252 ( 241 242
127 243 -: - 244 ( ) : ( http://dhabiyamaktoobblogcom/1595843/%d9%85 244 229 ( 243
128 245 246 112 ( " " ( http://wwwjustice-lawhomecom/vb/attachmentphp?attachmentid=3399&d=1288177767 245 246
129 ) 247 ( 248 249 267 ( 167 ( 212 211 ( 247 248 249
130 250 1954 / 13 251 268 ( 1991-1948 ( 250 251 39
131 : - - 1952 ( ) 1927 1931 252 1931 ( ) " " ( http://wwwjustice-lawhomecom/vb/attachmentphp?attachmentid=3399&d=1288177767 252
132 253 : - " " 254 271-270 ( 233 ( 253 254
133 -: - 1949 24 351 255 : - 212 ( 255
134 256 257 ( ) 258 301 ( 223 ( 302 ( 256 257 258
135 ) ( 259 260 -: ( double scrutiny ( 3 ) (4) 225 ( 259 260
136 261 ( ) 262 236 ( ( 261 262
137 263 ( 3/10 ) 264 265 1997 4/13 1954 13 1954 / 13-1948 -: 39 1991 246 ( ( 263 264 265
138 266-267 ( 245 ( 306 266 267
139 268 269 96 20 (11) 1982 270 12 271 1/11 ( -: (96) ( ( ) ( ) -: ( 268 269 270 157 1991-1948 -: ( 5/110-271
140 272 -: 2007 " " 361 ( 272
141 273 2009 / 1 -: -: - -: - (2009 / 1 ) 274 /http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/unjs -: ( /http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/dispute ( 273 274
142 275 -: " " " " ) ( http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/dispute/organizationshtml ( 275
143 276 277 - " " - " " 278 2-2 ( ) 2009 / ( ( ) 2010 / http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/dispute/organizationshtml 277 ( http://daccess-dds-nyunorg/doc/undoc/gen/n08/485/95/pdf/n0848595pdf#page=10 278 http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/dispute/decisionsshtml ( 276
144 ( 3 1) 279 -: - " " " " - ( 8 2) - - ( ) : ( 8 ) - 2 - ( 279
145 - - 280 -: - - ( ) /http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/appeals ( 280
146 281 ( ) - : (1 (2 (3 (4 (5 http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/appeals/jurisdictionshtml( 281
147 : (1 (2 (3 : - 282 1964/3/31 (1) " 283 " 1965 ( 226 ( 282 283
148 : - : - - -
149 -: -2 284 : -3 285 327 ( 284 115 ( 285
150 ( ) 286 167 ( 286
151 : - (166/٥٢) 287 ( ٢) - 288 289 - http://wwwisaorgjm/files/documents/ar/16sess/council/isba-16c-4pdf ( ( http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/unjs/stepbystepshtml 60 ( 287 288 289
152 - ( 90) - 90 290 - - : - (45 ) ) ( ( http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/unjs/stepbystepshtml 290
153 291 -: : - -1 ب -2 : - -1-2 -3 - - ٧ ٩٠ http://wwwisaorgjm/files/documents/ar/16sess/council/isba-16c-4pdf( 291
154 ) ( ) ( ) (
155 " " (2009 / 1 )
156
157 - - - (F A O)
158 - ( ) 8 98 99 100
159 " " 1 2 101 " " 1 2 3 102 " " " " 1 2 103 " " 104
160 105 " " 2 1 1 2 3-97 1 101
161 1-1 ( ) ( ) : " ( ) ( )
162 ( ) 105 ( ) 2-1 ( ) ( )
163 ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
164 ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
165 1- ( ) ( ) 2-1 : ( ) ( ) 1 2 3
166 ( ) ( ) 3-1 ( ) ( )
167 1-1 ( ) ( ) 1-1 ( ) 1-1 ( ) 2-1 ( ) ( ) ( )
168 ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
169 ( ) ( ) ( )
170 ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) 2-1 ( ) ( ) ( )
171 : ( ) 1 2 3 4 ( ) 2-1 ( ) 2-1 ( ) 2-1 ( ) ( )
172 ( ) 10-7 ( ) 3-1 ( ) ( ) ( )
173 4-1 ( ) ( ) ( ) 5-1 ( )
174 ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) 6-1 ( )
175 ( ) ( ) 7-1 8-1 13 (1- ) 22 1946 /
176 9-1 1-2 1-2 ( )
177 : ( ) 1-3 2-3 75 ( )
178 100 100 ( ) ) ( ) ( )
179 3-3 ( ) 3 1 : 1 ( )
180 ( ) ( ) 11 20 000 18 25 30 40 000 20 001 60 000 40 001 60 001 (2006 / 1 )
181 : - ( ) ( ) 19 50 000 28 50 000 32 50 000 35-6 : 2 ( ) ( ) 19 20 000
182 ( ) ( ) 23 40 000 20 001 26 60 000 40 001 31 60 001 2 1 5 3 4 (10 ) 973 ( ) ( ) ( )
183 : ( ) 1 2 3 4 4-3 3 1 : ( ) 1
184 3-3 1 ( ) 3-3 1 ( ) 1 2 1 ( ) 3 ( ) 1 ( ) 2 3 ( ) ( ) ( )
185 6 5 ( ) (F A O) - 1 1-301 1-1-301 2-1-301 21-1 - 22-1 -
186 3-1-301 4-1-301 5-1-301 6-1-301 21-1-301 2-1-301 7-1-301 8-1-301 -
187 : 9-1-301 ( ) " " 91 2-1 - 2-301 - - 1-2-301 3 3-301 1-3-301 11-3 -
188 2-3-301 21-3- : (3) 1 730 - - (1) (3) 3 460 1 730 619 : (2) (3) (4) - 22-3- 11-3-301 (1) 21-3-301 (4) 21-3-301 23-3-
189 24-3- 3-3-301 31-3- : ( ) ( ) ( )
190 ( ) 31-3-301 32-3- ( ) 31-3-301 ( ) 31-3-301 33-3- ( ) 31-3-301 34-3- 25 28 : 35-3- (1) (2) (1) (3) ( ) 31-3-301
191 4-3-301 / 4 4-301 7 1-4-301 (1) 39 2-4-301 3-4-301 (2) 39 4-4-301
192 5-4-301 18 6-4-301 7-4-301 5 5-301 1-5-301 2-5-301 3-5-301
193 6 6-301 1-6-301 2-6-301 7 7-301 1-7-301-2-7-301 3-7-301
194 8 8-301 1-8-301 11-8- - - 12-8- " " 13-8- - 2-8-301 :
195 (1) (2) - - 3-8-301 9 9-301 (1) 1-9-301 (2) (3) - - 11-9- 12-9- 1-9-301 13-9- 12-9-301 1-9-301
196 14-9- - - 2-9-301 3-9-301 4-9-301 5-9-301 - - - 1990/1/1 10 10-301 1-10-301 2-10-301
197 3-10-301 11 11-301 1-11-301 - - - - 2-11-301 ) ( 3-11-301
198 3-11-301 1-6-301 12 12-301 1952/7/1 1-12-301 2-12-301 (3) 39
199 - ( ) -( ) (2005) -27 ( ) (1999) -28 1 (2005-2004 ) -29 ( ) -30 (2007 ) -31 ( 1975 ) -32 ( 1974) -33 (2010 ) -34 " (2006 ) -35
200 " (2003) -36 (2004 ) -37 (2004) -38 ( ) (1991) -39 ) ( 2006) -40 2 ( 1 ( 2000) -41 (1999) -42 (1998) -43 (1995) -44 (1990) -45
201 (1986) -46-47 : (2001 ) -48 " (2003 ) -49 (1963) -50-51 1963 " " -52 -( ) 1-Annual digest and reports of public international law cases 1946 2-international puplic,dallo2 2004 le edition Pirre-marie dapuy, droit 3- Sydneg D, Bdiley The Secretariat of the United Nations, 1964 - -1-2 " (1964 ) -3 "
202 - -1-2 -3-4 -5-6 -7-8
203 - -1 http://wwwunorg/ar/oaj/unjs/ ( ) -2 2010 http://unesdocunescoorg/images/0018/001874/187429apdf " " --3 http://wwwjusticelawhomecom/vb/attachmentphp?attachmentid=3399&d=1288177767-4 1991-1948 http://wwwicj-cijorg/homepage/ar/files/sum_1948-1991pdf -5 http://dhabiyamaktoobblogcom/1595843/%d9%85-6
204 http://wwwunorg/arabic/geninfo/ir/ch6/ch6htm