arxiv: v1 [math.dg] 17 Jan 2019

Transcription

1 RECTANGULAR CONSTRAINED WILLMORE MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE arxiv: v1 [math.dg] 17 Jan 019 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE Abstract. We show that the well-known family of -lobed Delaunay tori f b in S 3, parametrized by b R 1, uniquely minimizes the Willmore energy among all immersions from tori into 3-space of conformal class (a, b). As a corollary we obtain an alternate proof of the Willmore conjecture in 3-space. This new strategy can be generalized to arbitrary codimensions provided a classification of isothermic constrained Willmore tori is possible and all f b remain stable in all codimensions. Contents 1. Introduction 1. Proof of the main theorem 5 3. Isothermic constrained Willmore tori in 3-space 9 4. Constrained Willmore stability of the -lobe family 18 Appendix A. Non-minimal Babich-Bobenko tori 8 References 9 1. Introduction We study conformal immersions f : M S 3 from a Riemann surface M into the 3-sphere minimizing the Willmore energy Z W(f ) = (H + 1)dA, M where H is the mean curvature and da is the induced area form. Geometrically speaking W measures the roundness of a surface, physically the degree of bending, Date: January 18,

2 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE and in biology W appears as a special instance of the Helfrich energy for cell membranes. In mathematics the functional was introduced by Willmore in the 1960s who showed that the absolute minimum of W is attained at round spheres. Willmore then also conjectured that the minimum over tori is attained at the Clifford torus. This famous conjecture remained open for almost 50 years and was proven by Marques and Neves [9] in 01. In fact, they have shown a stronger statement: the minimum of the Willmore energy for all immersed compact surfaces in 3-space of positive genus is attained at the Clifford torus. It is expected that the Willmore conjecture remains valid in arbitrary codimensions though the Min-Max approach used in [9] cannot be generalized. Already in 004 Martin Schmidt [41] proposed a completely different approach towards the Willmore conjecture using Integrable Systems techniques. Though the paper is not confirmed through the peer review process, the work has been extremely influential and had a lasting impact on the field. It was soon noticed that the Willmore energy W is invariant under Möbius transformations of the target space in fact, it is invariant (when defined appropriately) under conformal changes of the metric in the target space. Thus, it makes no difference for the study of the Willmore functional which constant curvature target space is chosen. Prominent examples of Willmore surfaces are minimal surfaces in space forms. In fact, for topological spheres all critical points of the Willmore functional arise as a Möbius transformation of minimal surfaces in R 3 with planar ends as Bryant proved in [10]. The first examples of Willmore surfaces, not Möbius equivalent to minimal surfaces in any space form, were found by Pinkall [33] via lifting elastic curves on the -sphere, the critical points for the elastic energy (κ + 1)ds, under the Hopf fibration to Willmore tori in the 3-sphere. Later Ferus and Pedit [16] classified all Willmore tori equivariant under a Möbius S 1 -action on the 3-sphere. The Euler-Lagrange equation for the Willmore functional δw = H + H(H + 1 K) = 0, where K denotes the Gauss curvature of the surface f : M S 3, is a 4th order elliptic PDE for f since the mean curvature H is the normal part of f. Its analytic properties are prototypical for non-linear bi-laplace equations. Regularity and existence of a minimizer for the Willmore functional W on the space of immersions from -tori into 3-space was shown by Simon [4]. Kuwert and Bauer [4] generalized this result to higher genus surfaces. After a number of partial results, e.g. [8, 39], Marques and Neves [9], using Almgren-Pitts min-max theory for minimal surfaces, gave a proof of the Willmore conjecture in early 01. It had already been known by Weiner [44] that the the second Variation of the Willmore functional at Clifford torus is strictly positive (up to invariance of the functional) and thus the Clifford torus is a local minimum. A more refined, and also richer, picture emerges when considering minimizers of the Willmore energy under further constraints. A mathematically natural constraint is to restrict the Willmore functional to the subspace of immersions f : M S 3 inducing a given conformal structure on M. The critical points of this constrained

3 RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 3 problem are called (conformally) constrained Willmore surfaces. The conformal constraint augments the Euler-Lagrange equation by a holomorphic quadratic differential ω H 0 (KM ) paired with the trace-free second fundamental form Å of the immersion H + H(H + 1 K) = < ω, Å >, see [8]. Subtleties arise when the critical surface is isothermic: the holomorphic quadratic differential is no longer uniquely determined by the immersion leading to a singularity of the moduli space. Since there are no holomorphic quadratic differentials on a genus zero Riemann surface, constrained Willmore spheres are the same as Willmore spheres. For higher genus surfaces this is no longer the case: constant mean curvature (CMC) surfaces (and their Möbius transforms) are constrained Willmore, as one can see by choosing ω = Å to be the holomorphic Hopf differential, but not Willmore unless totally umbilic. In the case of M = T being a torus Bohle [5], partially motivated by the manuscript of Schmidt [41], showed that all constrained Willmore tori arise from linear flows on Jacobians of finite genus spectral curves. The link to the quaternionic surface theory [11] and the more general finite gap theory of conformal immersions [6] making the Willmore energy estimates of [15] available for constrained Willmore tori. Moreover, it is theoretically possible to parametrize all constrained Willmore tori in terms of algebro-geometric data. The main challenge in constructing these surfaces is to ensure closing, i.e., the problem that the immersion is well defined on the compact surface M rather than on its universal covering. The simplest examples, where the spectral curves are of genus zero, are the tori of revolution in R 3 with circular profiles. Those are stereographic images of products of circles of varying radii ratios in the 3-sphere and thus have constant mean curvature as surfaces in the 3-sphere. Starting at the Clifford torus, which has mean curvature H = 0 and a square conformal structure, these surfaces in the 3-sphere limit with monotone and unbounded mean curvature to a circle and thereby sweeping out all rectangular conformal structures. Less trivial examples come from the Delaunay tori of various lobe counts in the 3-sphere whose spectral curves have genus 1 (see Figure 1). By the solution of the Lawson and the Pinkall-Sterling conjecture, due to Brendle [9] and Andrews & Li [] using Brendle s approach, those are the only embedded CMC tori in the 3-sphere. Existence and regularity of a minimizer f : T S 3 in a given conformal class for any genus was shown by Kuwert and Schätzle [6] under the provision that the infimum Willmore energy W(f) is below 8π. This restriction is used to rule out minimizers with branch points. Similar results were proven by Riviere [38] using the divergence form of the Euler-Lagrange equation. Parallel to the solution of the Willmore conjecture Ndiaye and Schätzle [3, 31] showed that for rectangular conformal classes (0, b) in a neighborhood of the square conformal class (0, 1) the homogenous tori fh b (whose spectral curves have genus 0) are the unique minimizers for the constrained Willmore problem. In a recent preprint [0] minimizers of the Willmore energy with conformal class lying in a suitable neighborhood (of the Teichmüller space) of the square class have been identified to be equivariant. As a corollary we obtain the real analyticity of the minimal Willmore energy ω(a, b) for b 1, b 1 and a 0 +. Furthermore, at the rectangular conformal classes the minimal energy is

4 4 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE Figure 1. The vertical stalk represents the family of homogenous tori, starting with the Clifford torus at the bottom. Along this stalk are bifurcation points at which the embedded Delaunay tori appear along the horizontal lines. The rectangles indicate the conformal types. Images by Nicholas Schmitt. C 0 but not C 1. In particular, using the same arguments as in [3] together with [30, Corollary 6], the homogenous tori fh b with b 1 uniquely minimizes the penalized Willmore energy W α := W απ 1 among immersions of conformal class (a, b), with a 1, if α > 0 is small enough. The homogeneous tori of revolution eventually have to fail to be minimizing since their Willmore energy can be made arbitrarily large. Calculating the nd variation of the Willmore energy W along tori of revolution with circular profiles Kuwert and Lorenz [5] showed that negative eigenvalues appear at those conformal classes (0, b k ) whose rectangles have side length ratio k 1 for k. These are exactly the rectangular conformal classes from which the k-lobed Delaunay tori (of spectral genus 1) bifurcate and the corresponding homogenous torus is of Index (k ). Any of the families fk b starting from the Clifford torus, following homogenous tori to the k-th bifurcation point, and branching to the Delaunay tori which limit to a neckless of spheres, sweep out all rectangular conformal classes (see Figure 1). The Willmore energy varies strictly monotonically along the family between π W < 4πk as b varies from 1 to, see [3, ]. For k = we obtain an immersion with Willmore energy below 8π for every rectangular conformal class satisfying the energy bound in [6] showing the existence of an embedded minimizer in all these conformal classes. Thus it is conjectured that f b minimizes the Willmore energy for rectangular conformal classes (0, b) in all codimensions. In this paper we will apply the results and techniques developed in [3] and [0] to confirm the -lobe conjecture in 3-space. Our main theorem is the following

5 RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 5 Theorem 1. For every b R 1 the -lobed Delaunay torus f b of conformal class (0, b) uniquely attains the minimum of the following minimization problem Min b := {W(f) f : T S 3 immersion, Π (f) = b}. In particular, the Clifford torus minimizes the Willmore energy among all immersions from a torus T into S 3. Remark 1. Since the Willmore energy of f b is monotonically increasing in b, the above theorem shows that the Clifford torus minimize the Willmore energy for all tori of conformal class (a, b) with b 1. Immersed tori with b < 1 and 1 b < a < 1 have larger Willmore energy than the Clifford torus by [30] using the conformal volume. The paper is organized as follows. We first give a proof the -lobe conjecture, Theorem 1, under the provision that Theorem (classification of isothermic constrained Willmore tori in 3-space) and Theorem 3 (constrained Willmore stability of f b ) holds. The sections three and four are then devoted to the proof of these Theorems. It is worth noting that the arguments in the second section remain valid in arbitrary codimension and the codimension 1 assumption is only used in the proofs of the Theorems and 3. The idea of the proof of Theorem 1 is very short and simple. In order to keep the paper the same way, we only included new computations and new insights here and cite the well-known arguments and facts rather than reproducing them. Acknowledgements. We would like to thank Franz Pedit and Reiner Schätzle for helpful discussions, and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) for former support within the SFB TR 71, where our joint work on this topic started. We would also like to thank Nicholas Schmitt for producing the images in the paper and for conducting useful computer experiments that shaped our geometric intuition. The first author is supported by the DFG within the SPP Geometry at Infinity, and the second author is supported by RTG 1670 Mathematics inspired by string theory and quantum field theory funded by the DFG.. Proof of the main theorem In this section we want to name and put together the key ingredients to prove Theorem 1. We identify the Teichmüller space of tori with the upper half plane with coordinates (a, b) such that the standard Clifford torus f 1 has conformal type (0, 1). The candidate family f b is the family of CMC tori in S 3 parametrized by its rectangular conformal class (0, b) for b R 1 starting at the Clifford torus at b = 1 following the homogenous tori for b [1, b 0 ], b 0 = 3, bifurcate to the family of -lobed Delaunay tori for b > b 0 and converge to the branched double cover of a geodesic -sphere in S 3 for b. To facilitate the notations we will call the whole candidate family the family of -lobed Delaunay tori in the following, The value b 0 is characterized by the fact that it is the maximum conformal class such that the

6 6 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE homogenous tori are stable, see [5]. For b 1 the -lobed Delaunay tori f b minimize the Willmore energy among all immersions from a torus into S 3 under the constraint Π (f) = b by [3]. Using the generalization of [3] in [0] together with the Montiel-Ros [30] estimate of the Willmore energy in terms of its conformal type, we can further conclude that f b also attains the minimum Min α b := inf{(w απ 1 )(f) f : T S 3 immersion, Π (f) = b} for b 1 and all α < α b for some α b > 0. It is important to notice the application of Montiel-Ros [30] requires a 0, which can be assumed without loss of generality due to the independence of the Willmore energy of the orientation of the surface. The key geometric observation of this paper is that a minimizer of this stronger minimization problem is necessarily a degenerated point of the moduli space, i.e, an isothermic constrained Willmore torus. Proposition 1 (Key Observation). Let ɛ > 0 and b R 1 such that the family of -lobed Delaunay tori f b attains Min α b for all b [1, b) and for all α [0, ɛ). Then every immersion attaining Min ᾱ for all α [0, ɛ] must be isothermic. b Proof. By continuity of the minimal Willmore energy ω(a, b), [40], the corresponding candidate torus f b also minimizes the penalized Willmore energy W α for all α [0, ɛ). Assume that there exists a non-isothermic f b attaining Min ᾱ for all α [0, ɛ), in b particular, δπ 1 ( f b) 0. Hence W α (f b) = W α ( f b) for all α [0, ɛ) from which we obtain Π 1 ( f b) = 0. Further, both immersions f b and f b satisfies the same type Euler-Lagrange equation δw(f) + β(f)δπ (f) = 0 for some β(f) R. Due to the non-degeneracy of f b this implies the corresponding Π 1 -Lagrange multiplier α( f b) = 0. Moreover, there exist normal variations V 1 and V with δπ i f b(v j ) = δ ij and we can consider the smooth family of immersions f (a,b) = exp f b(t(a, b)v 1 + s(a, b)v ) of conformal class (a, b) together with its energy function ω(a, b) := W( f (a,b) ). Since α( f (0,b) ) = α( f b) = 0 we have a ω(a, b) = 0 and thus W α ( f (a, b) ) = ω(a, b) αa < ω(0, b) = W α ( f b)

7 RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 7 for every positive α and a 0 contradicting the fact that f b minimizes W α for all immersions with Π (f) = b. To prove the -lobe conjecture we consider the sequence ( b n ) n N with bn := sup{b f b is the unique minimizer of W α for all α [0, 1 n ]}. The sequence ( b n ) n N is monotonically increasing and thus has a limit b ]1, ]. The -lobe conjecture would then follow from showing b =. Moreover, the Willmore conjecture follows from the -lobe conjecture together with the Montiel and Ros estimate of the Willmore energy depending on the conformal type (for b < 1) [30]. Combining the arguments in [3, 0] we have that there exist a n 0 N such that bn > 1 for all n n 0. Assume b <. Then a contradiction is obtained by combining Proposition 1 and the following two theorems. Theorem. Isothermic constrained Willmore tori with Willmore energy below 8π are CMC in S 3. Remark. The solution of the Lawson and Pinkall-Sterling conjectures by Brendle [9], and Andrews and Li [], together with the classification of CMC tori of revolution in [3] yield that the family of -lobed Delaunay tori f b uniquely minimize the Willmore energy among isothermic (constrained Willmore) tori in their respective conformal classes. Since any minimizer of W α for all α [0, 1 ] with n > n n 0 satisfying the constraint Π (f) = b n is isothermic by Proposition 1, f b n is the unique constrained Willmore minimizer. Theorem 3. The family of -lobed Delaunay tori f b are W-stable for all b R 1. Moreover, the kernel dimension of the stability operator is at most 1 (up to invariance) for b > b 0 and reduces to a variation ϕ of the underlying curve. In particular, δ Π 1 (f b )(ϕ, ϕ) = 0. Remark 3. This theorem guarantees that variants of the implicit function theorem, as carried out in [3] and [0], can be applied to classify all solutions of the Euler- Lagrange equation W 4, -close to f b n for some n N large. Proof of Theorem 1: Assume ( b n ) n N is a bounded sequence in R 1. Applying the arguments of [3] and [0] we obtain a contradiction by showing to that b n can be extended for large n. We deal with the following three cases separately. (1) b n < b 0 for all n N () b n = b 0 for some n N large (3) b n > b 0 for all large n N bn < b 0 for all n N. The functional W at the candidate surfaces f b is known to be strictly stable for b < b 0. Moreover, at b = b 0 any kernel element ϕ of the second variation of W satisfies δ Π 1 (f b 0 )(ϕ, ϕ) = 0, as computed in [5]. Therefore, there exists a n 1 such

8 8 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE that for all n > n 1 the functional W α is strictly stable at f b for all b < b 0 and all α [0, 1 n ]. Thus choose n > n 1 and assume b n < b 0. In this case the surface f b n is homogenous and uniquely minimizes the penalized Willmore energy W α for all α [0, 1 ] among n immersions f satisfying Π (f) = b n by Proposition 1 and Theorem. Applying the arguments of [3] it can be shown that for b b n the minimizers of W α with Π (f) = b are W 4, -close to f b n for all α [0, 1 ]. n Moreover, due to the strict stability of W α for all α [0, 1 ] we can apply the implicit n function theorem developed in [3]. Thus there exists a ɛ > 0 such that the candidate family f b for b [ b n, b n + ɛ), with b n + ɛ < b 0 are the only solutions to the Euler- Lagrange equation that are W 4, -close to f b n. Thus for all b [ b n, b n + ɛ) and all α [0, 1 ] the minimum of the penalized Willmore functional W n α under the constraint Π (f) = b is attained at the respective candidate surface f b giving a contradiction. Therefore, b n b 0 for n > n 1. bn = b 0 for large n N. As in the previous case we have by Proposition 1 and Theorem that f b 0 is the unique immersion attaining Min α b 0. Hence using the arguments of [3] we obtain for b b 0 that the constrained minimizers of W α are W 4, -close to f b 0. At b n = b 0 the second variation of W(f b 0 ) has a non-trivial -dimensional kernel determined by [5]. Since a normal variation ϕ Ker(δ W β b 0 δ Π )(f b 0 ) reduces to a variation of the profile curve only, i.e., the surfaces remain surfaces of revolution, which are of rectangular conformal type, it can be computed that δ Π 1 (f b 0 )(ϕ, ϕ) = 0. Therefore there exist n N such that for all n > n n 1 the functional W α remains stable for all α [0, 1 n ]. Therefore we can apply the bifurcation arguments of [0] together with the properties of f b, or rather the properties of its Lagrange-multipliers computed in [], to show the existence two branches of solutions close to f b the homogenous tori and the -lobe Delaunay tori out of which the -lobes have smaller Willmore energy for every b b 0, and b > b 0. Thus there exist a ɛ > 0 such that f b minimizes W α for immersions with Π 1 (f) = b for all b [ b n, b n + ɛ) and all α [0, 1 ] which is again a n contradiction. Hence we obtain b n > b 0 for all n > n. bn > b 0 for all large n N. It remains to show that the sequence ( b n ) n N is unbounded. Assume that there exists a B R >b0 with b n B for all n N. Due to the spectral properties of the second variation of W at f b 0 and Theorem 3 there exist a n 3 N such that for n > n 3 n n 1 the functional W α is stable (but not necessarily strict stable) for all b 0 < b B and all α [0, 1 ]. The kernel of the stability operator remains at most one-dimensional n up to invariance of the Euler-Lagrange equation. For n > n 3 we again have that f b n

9 RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 9 is the unique constrained minimizer of W α for α [0, 1 ]. Further, as in case (1) and n (), any constrained minimizer for b b n of W α is W 4, -close to f b n. The W α -stability properties of f b makes techniques in [0] applicable and we can classify all solutions of the Euler-Lagrange equation W 4, -close to f b n using bifurcation theory. Assume there are no solution to the bifurcation equation of the Euler-Lagrange equation W 4, -close to f b n. Then b n can be extended as in the previous cases to obtain a contradiction. Then sequence ( b n ) n N would then be unbounded and b =. Thus assume that there is a bifurcation f b f b of the Euler-Lagrange equation at f b n for b b n. Due to Theorem 3 the kernel element ϕ reduces to a variation of the profile curve and the solution of the auxiliary equation is unique see [0, Equation 5.15]. Thus the solution f b of the Euler-Lagrange equation W 4, -close to f b n is given by f b = f b + tϕ + V (t, β) and V only depends on the curve parameter (when using appropriate coordinates of the target as in Section 4). Any bifurcation of the Euler-Lagrange equation at f b n in direction of ϕ therefore reduces to a bifurcation of the elastic curve equation at its profile curve, i.e., the surface f b is rotational symmetric. This is a contradiction, since every rotational symmetric surface is isothermic and therefore f b is CMC in a space form by [37]. Moreover, the Willmore energy of f b would be below 8π (because they are W 4, - close to f b 1 ). Thus we would obtain by Theorem that f b coincide with -lobed Delaunay tori f b. 3. Isothermic constrained Willmore tori in 3-space Surfaces providing a conformal curvature line parametrization are called isothermic. At isothermic surfaces the projection from the space of immersions to the Teichmüller space is not submersive, i.e, the conformal constraint is degenerated. The simplest examples of isothermic surfaces are given by rotating a curve in the upper half plane around the x-axis. The corresponding conformal curvature line parametrization is obtained using the arc length parametrization of its profile curve with respect to the hyperbolic metric of the upper half plane. Richter [37] shows that isothermic constrained Willmore tori in 3-space are locally of constant mean curvature in a 3-dimensional space form. The solution of the Lawson and Pinkall-Sterling conjectures by Brendle [9] and Andrews-Li [] further gives that embedded CMC tori in the 3-sphere are rotationally symmetric and thus consist only of the families of k-lobed Delaunay tori [3]. Moreover, the Willmore energy along every embedded family is monotonically increasing in the conformal class b. Thus since for k 3 the k-lobes bifurcates from the homogenous tori with Willmore energy above 8π, the -lobed family is the family with minimal Willmore energy in their respective conformal classes. The aim of this section is to prove Theorem, by which we show that the -lobe family f b minimize the penalized Willmore energy W α for

10 10 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE small α > 0 in its respective conformal class among all isothermic immersions. In other words, the aim is to exclude the existence of constrained Willmore surfaces of constant mean curvature in R 3 or hyperbolic 3-space H 3 that can be compactified to a torus in S 3 with Willmore energy below 8π. Further, the Li and Yau estimate [8] shows the embeddedness of surfaces with Willmore energy below 8π. Proof of Theorem : By Alexandrov [1] and Li-Yau, there are no compact CMC tori with Willmore energy below 8π in R 3 or H 3. The only non-closed CMC surfaces in R 3 that can be compactified to conformal embeddings in S 3 are minimal surfaces with planar ends (H 0 is excluded by local analysis [4]), which have quantized energy 4πk, with k being the number of ends. Thus, those surfaces have Willmore energy 8π. Similar arguments work for constant mean curvature surfaces in H 3 with mean curvature H = 1 giving quantized Willmore energy W = 4πk, where k N denotes the number of ends see [7]. A one-punctured CMC 1 torus in H 3 does not exist (compare with [35]). To prove Theorem it is thus sufficient to show that isothermic constrained Willmore tori in S 3, whose intersection with H 3 S 3 is of constant mean curvature, cannot have Willmore energy below 8π. Those surfaces intersect the infinity boundary of H 3 S 3 a round -sphere with an angle α satisfying cos(α) = H. In particular, H < 1 or the surface is entirely contained in H 3, and cannot be embedded by maximum principle. We can therefore restrict to the case H < 1 and the theorem follows from Theorem 5 proven below. We will call isothermic constrained Willmore tori into S 3 which are CMC in H 3 with H < 1 on the intersection with the two hyperbolic balls Babich-Bobenko tori in the following. The first examples have been constructed by Babich and Bobenko [3] in the case of H = 0. In order to show that all Babich-Bobenko tori have Willmore energy above 8π we apply the Plücker estimate for the Willmore energy [15]. Thus we first have to recall some constructions of the Integrable Systems Theory for constrained Willmore tori. The spectral curve theory for conformal immersions f from a -torus T into the conformal S 4 has been developed in [11], where S 4 is considered as the quaternionic projective space HP 1. To every conformal immersion f the quaternionic holomorphic line bundle L = f T T H given by the pull-back of the tautological bundle T of HP 1 is associated. Another quaternionic holomorphic line bundle associated to f is V/L, where V = T H. On V/L there exists a natural quaternionic holomorphic structure D (see [11, 5] for a definition) by demanding the projections of the constant sections (0, 1) and (1, 0) of V to be holomorphic. The immersion is then recovered (up to conformal transformations) by [0, 1] = [1, 0]f. The (multiplier) spectral curve Σ of a conformally immersed torus f is the normalization of the Riemann surface parametrizing all holomorphic sections of V/L with (complex) monodromy, i.e, every point of the spectral curve corresponds to a holomorphic section with monodromy. Therefore, we can define maps from Σ to C

11 RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 11 so-called monodromy maps ν i by assigning to every point in Σ the monodromy of the underlying holomorphic section along generators γ i of the fundamental group π 1 (T ). The genus g of the associated spectral curve is called the spectral genus of the immersion f. In general, for conformally immersed tori which are not constrained Willmore, the spectral genus is not finite. Bohle [5] gives an alternative approach to the spectral curve for constrained Willmore tori. He showed that the flatness of a C -family µ of SL(4, C)-connections defined on the trivial bundle V, considered as a C 4 -bundle, is equivalent to f being constrained Willmore. The (holonomy) spectral curve is then given by the Riemann surface parametrizing the eigenlines of the holonomy of µ. Bohle [5] showed that the (holonomy) spectral curve is always of finite genus and that both approaches to the spectral curve coincide. To be more precise, Bohle showed that µ -parallel sections with monodromy are the unique prolongations of the holomorphic sections with monodromy of (V/L, D) to V. In the case of f mapping into 3-space S 3 S 4, the spectral curve Σ admits an additional involution σ, see [19, Lemma 1]. As a consequence of our arguments below, we obtain that the quotient Σ/σ is biholomorphic to CP 1 for Babich-Bobenko tori. Note that the same is true for CMC surfaces in R 3, S 3. Another involution ρ on Σ arises from the quaternionic construction, i.e., by an appropriate multiplication by j. There are two cases to distinguish depending on whether the real involution ρ σ has fix points or not. In the first case the surface is of constant mean curvature in R 3, S 3 or H 3 with mean curvature H > 1. If ρ σ has no fixed points then the corresponding immersion is of Babich-Bobenko type The link between the CMC and CW spectral curves for Babich- Bobenko type tori. For constrained Willmore surfaces f : M S 3 S 4 Bohle [5] defined the following C -family of flat SL(4, C)-connections µ = d + (µ 1)A 1,0 + (µ 1 1)A 0,1. Here d is the trivial connection on the trivial H -bundle considered as a C 4 -bundle, A = A + η where A is the Hopf field of the conformal immersion and η is the Lagrange-multiplier of the constrained Willmore Euler-Lagrange equation (which is not unique for isothermic surfaces). The aim of this section is to show that the holonomy spectral curve of a Babich-Bobenko torus defined by µ has the same properties as the Cosh-Gordon spectral curve used in [3] by taking the Lagrange multiplier η corresponding to q as in [36, page 130]. We first study the structure of the spectral curve for the case of H = 0, which is equivalent to η = 0. The case 0 < H < 1 is morally the same, though the details are slightly different, see the Appendix 4.4. The application of the Plücker estimate in Section 3. below works totally analogous in both cases. We use the light cone model approach as developed in [1] and [13]. Details of the computations can also be found in the thesis of Quintino [36].

12 1 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE Proposition. For a Babich-Bobenko torus f : M S 3 with H = 0, the associated constrained Willmore family of flat connections µ is gauge equivalent to a C -family of flat SL(4, C)-connections λ with µ = λ of the form ( ) ω(λ) 0 λ = d + 0 ω( λ 1 ) through a λ-dependent family of complex gauge transformations, where (3.1) ω(λ) = λ 1 ω 1 + ω 0 + λω 1 Ω 1 (M, sl(, C)) with ω ±1 = ±iω ±1. Moreover, d + ω( λ) and d + ω( λ 1 ) are gauge equivalent for all λ C, and the monodromies of d + ω( λ) along nontrivial elements of the first fundamental group have neither unimodular nor real eigenvalues for generic λ S 1. Proof. Consider the family λ = d λ q,s as defined in [36, page 161] (with q = 0 as we consider the H = 0 case). Because the Babich-Bobenko surface is contained in the 3-sphere S 3 S 4, we can deduce from [36, Lemma 8.33] that after a suitable conformal transformation of S 4 the (real and space-like) -vectors v := e 1 e + e 3 e 4, w = ie 1 e ie 3 e 4 are parallel with respect to the induced connection Λ λ for all λ C, with e 1, e, e 3 = e 1 j, e 4 = e j being the standard basis of C 4. Thus, a short (multi-)linear algebra computation shows that λ has the form ( ) ω(λ) 0 λ = d +, 0 ω( λ 1 ) with ω(λ) as stated in (3.1). By [36, Lemma 9.14] and [5, Equation (.11)], λ is gauge equivalent to µ (with µ = λ ). If the monodromies of d + ω( λ) along non-trivial elements γ i of π 1 (T ) would have either unimodular or real eigenvalues for generic λ S 1 then [5, Proposition 3.] shows that the eigenvalues of µ must be all equal to 1 for all µ C and therefore this case can be excluded by [5, Theorem 5.1]. It remains to prove that d+ω( λ) and d+ω( λ 1 ) are gauge equivalent for all λ C. Because λ and λ are gauge equivalent (as both are gauge equivalent to µ=λ ) we only need to exclude the case that d + ω( λ) is gauge equivalent to d + ω(λ) for all λ C. This can be seen by first using the local form of Λ λ with respect to a (λ-independent) adapted frame of the minimal surface in H 3 to obtain det(ω 1 ) = 0 and then performing a short analysis analogously to [1, Proposition 3.10]. As an immediate corollary the spectral curve Σ has the same properties as a coshgordon spectral curve.

13 RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 13 Corollary 1. The spectral curve Σ of a Babich-Bobenko torus (with H = 0) considered as a Willmore torus, i.e, as the Riemann surface parametrizing the eigenlines of µ, is given by a double covering of λ : Σ CP 1 with λ = µ satisfying: λ is branched over λ = 0 and λ = there exist two holomorphic functions the monodromy maps ν 1, ν : Σ \ {0, } C such that the hyper-elliptic involution σ satisfies σ ν i = 1 ν i, for i = 1, Σ has a anti-holomorphic involution ρ covering λ λ 1 with ρ ν i = ν i, for i = 1, µ : Σ CP 1 is a for four-fold covering, i.e., for generic µ C the connection µ has 4 distinct eigenvalues along the generators γ k k = 1, given by the four elements of the set {ν k (ξ) ξ Σ : µ = (λ(ξ)) }. Proof. By the previous proposition, the spectral curve Σ is given by the holonomy spectral curve of the family of flat connections ˆ λ = d + ω(λ). Since ˆ λ is SL(, C), the hyper-elliptic involution σ maps an eigenvalue of the monodromy to its inverse. The other involution ρ is induced by the quaternionic multiplication j, which covers λ λ 1 and (complex) conjugates the eigenvalues of the monodromy. Moreover, the parameter covering µ = λ is unbranched over C. Thus the quotient Σ/σ is biholomorphic to CP Plücker estimates. We show that all isothermic constrained Willmore tori of Babich-Bobenko type have Willmore energy above 8π. The following Plücker estimate is relating the dimension of the holomorphic sections of V/L (without monodromy) to the Willmore energy of the corresponding immersion. Theorem 4 ([15], Theorem 4.1). Let f : T S 3 be a conformal immersion and (V/L, D) be the quaternionic holomorphic line bundle associated to it. Let k N be the dimension of H 0 (T, V/L) (with trivial monodromy). Then a lower bound for the Willmore energy of f is given by { πk k even W (f) π(k 1) k odd Remark 4. For every immersion into S 3 the sections [1, 0] and [0, 1] are holomorphic sections without monodromy. Thus H 0 (V/L) is at least -dimensional. The most relevant cases in the following are: if there exist a third quaternionic linearly independent holomorphic section, then the Willmore energy of f is at least 8π, if there exist a fourth quaternionic linearly independent holomorphic section, the lower bound is 16π.

14 14 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE Remark 5. We show in Section 3.1 (respectively in Appendix 4.4 for H 0) that the associated family of flat connections µ of a Babich-Bobenko torus has four distinct eigenvalues for generic µ C. Thus by Bohle [5] ˆL =KerA is a non-constant quaternionic line subbundle of V. Lemma 1. Let f : T S 3 be a Babich-Bobenko torus with Willmore energy below 8π. Then every branch point of the spectral curve λ: Σ Σ/σ = CP 1 except those over λ = 0 and λ = corresponds to a non-constant holomorphic section of V/L with Z -monodromy. Proof. The spectral curve Σ is the surface parametrizing the eigenlines of µ the constrained Willmore associated family of flat connections. It admits two involutions: σ and ρ. While the involution ρ corresponds to the quaternionic multiplication by j and is fixpoint free, the involution σ maps a holomorphic section ψ with monodromy h to a holomorphic section with monodromy h 1. Therefore the branch points of Σ correspond to those µ -parallel sections ψ of V with Z -monodromy, i.e., prolongations of holomorphic sections of V/L with Z -monodromy. It is thus crucial to show that these ψ are non-constant sections of V, which clearly holds whenever the monodromy of the section ψ is non-trivial. Thus we restrict to the case where ψ has trivial monodromy. Let λ 0 be a branch point of Σ and ψ 0 be the µ 0 -parallel section of V without monodromy associated to λ 0 where µ 0 = λ 0. If µ 0 1 then ψ must be non-constant, since ψ being constant would imply that ψ Γ(KerA ) and then ˆL =KerA would be constant in contradiction to [5, Theorem 5.3]. It remains to show that also for the case µ 0 = λ 0 = 1 there exists a non-constant section ψ, given by a prolongation of a holomorphic section of V/L, with trivial monodromy. Let µ be the CW associated family, and µ 0 = 1 be a branch point of the spectral curve Σ. Because of the ρ-symmetry (interchanging the two points over µ 0 = 1) Σ is not totally branched at µ 0, i.e., we can use a local coordinate ξ on Σ with ξ = µ 1. Assume that the Willmore energy is below 8π. By [6, Theorem 4.3 (iii)] there is a smooth family of µ(ξ) -parallel sections ψ ξ parametrized on an open subset of Σ around ξ = 0 depending smoothly on ξ, i.e., we have µ(ξ) ψ ξ = 0. Differentiating this equation with respect to ξ (denoted by () ) at ξ = 0 (and therefore µ = 1) gives 0 = ( µ(x) ) ψ + dψ = ( dµ(ξ) A 1,0 + dµ 1 (ξ) ) A 0,1 ψ + dψ = dψ, dξ ξ=0 dξ ξ=0 where ψ = ψ ξ=0 is constant in z T (as µ=1 = d). Differentiating once more and evaluating at ξ = 0 thus gives 0 = ( µ(x) ) ψ + ( µ(x) ) ψ + dψ = ( A 1,0 + A 0,1 )ψ + dψ.

15 RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 15 Since ( A 1,0 + A 0,1 )ψ is contained in L = f T = Im (A ), dψ is contained in L as well showing that ψ is the prolongation of a (locally) holomorphic section of V/L. Since the monodromy takes the value 1 with at least second order (because the monodromy is trivial at the branch point µ = 1), ψ has also trivial monodromy. If ψ would be constant then 0 = ( A 1,0 + A 0,1 )ψ, which yields that KerA is constant giving a contradiction. Lemma. Two holomorphic sections of V/L with non-trivial Z -monodromy corresponding to different branch points of λ: Σ Σ/σ = CP 1 not lying over 0 or, which are not interchanged by the involution ρ, are quaternionic linear independent. Proof. Let ψ 1 and ψ be two holomorphic sections of V/L with Z -monodromy. If these sections have different Z -monodromies, then they are clearly quaternionic linear independent. Thus let the ψ i have the same non-trivial Z -monodromy in the following. Due to [5, Section.5] and the fact that their monodromy is non-trivial on T, it is enough to prove that their prolongations ψ 1 and ψ, which are parallel sections with respect to µ 1 and µ (corresponding to the branch points λ 1 and λ of Σ Σ/σ), are linear independent. If µ 1 = µ it follows from Proposition that ψ 1 and ψ are (quaternionic) linear independent since ξ 1 ξ and ξ 1 ρ(ξ ). If µ 1 µ we obtain that ψ 1 and ψ are complex linear independent. Assume that they are not independent as quaternionic sections, then we would have w.l.o.g. for some a, b C. Moreover, from we obtain (3.) ψ 1 = a ψ + b ψ j µ 1 ψ1 = 0; µ ψ = 0 µ 1 ψ j = 0 0 =(µ 1 1 µ 1 )A 1,0 a ψ +(µ 1 1 µ )A 1,0 a ψ j +(µ 1 µ )A 0,1 a ψ +(µ 1 µ 1 )A 1,0 a ψ j. By type decomposition (see [15, Section.1]) we obtain A ψ = 0. Since ψ is µ -parallel this implies ψ being constant, which is a contradiction by [5, Theorem 5.3] Lemma 3. Let f : T S 3 be a constrained Willmore torus of Babich-Bobenko type with spectral genus g 3. Then, either one of the branch points of the spectral curve over the unit disc D C corresponds to the trivial monodromy or at least two of the branch points of the spectral curve on the punctured unit disc D correspond to the same (non-trivial) Z -monodromy.

16 16 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE Proof. For g > 3 we have at least 5 branch points over the punctured unit disc D := {λ C 0 < λ 1}. The claim follows from the fact that there exist only 3 different non trivial spin structures of the torus. It remains to show the Lemma in the case of g = 3, where we have 4 branch points over the unit disc (that are not interchanged by ρ). Assume that none of the 4 branch points on the unit disc corresponds to the trivial spin structure and moreover, for µ 0 the other 3 branch points correspond to different spin structures. Then the spin structure at µ = 0 must coincide with the one at P k for a k {1,, 3}, since there exist only 3 different non-trivial spin structures of a torus. Without loss of generality we can assume k = 1. We want to show that the spin structures corresponding to P and P 3 must then coincide. In this case, the closed non-trivial curve, the green curve in Figure, through the branch points P and P 3 denoted by γ 3, is homologous to the difference of the closed (red) curve γ S through the Sym-points S 1 and S and the closed (blue) curve γ 01 connecting 0 and P 1. Let θ i = d log ν i (i = 1, ) be the logarithmic differentials of the monodromy maps ν i and consider integrals of θ i along these curves. Using the hyper-elliptic symmetry we want to show that P3 P θ i = θ i 4πiZ γ 3 Since 0 and P 1 correspond to the same spin structure by assumption we first show that γ 01 θ k 4πiZ for k = 1,. As θ k has trivial residue, we can interpret the above integral as the integral of θ k along any curve homotopic to γ 01 which does not pass through 0 Σ. In order to analyze the integral, we apply a renormalization: For k = 1, there exist a closed 1-form η k on Σ \ {0} with support in a small neighborhood of 0 which satisfies σ η k = η k and such that θ k + η k extends smoothly through 0, compare with the limiting analysis of [1, Proposition 3.10]. Note that γ 01 η k = 0. Using an analogous computation as in [1, Proposition 3.10] again, we can associate to 0 Σ renormalized eigenvalues ν 1 and ν which take values in {±1} and encode the spin structure of the surface. The sign is encoded in the parity of the constant part of the expansion in [1, Proposition 3.10]. Then, we obtain θ k = θ k + η k = θ k + η k 4πiZ, γ 01 γ 01 γ + 01 where γ 01 + is given by a part of γ 01 which goes from 0 to P 1, and the last equality follows from the fact that the values ν k (0) and ν k (P 1 ) coincide as 0 and P 1 correspond to the same spin structure.

17 RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 17 P γ 01 γ 0 P 3 γ 1 S S P 3 1 S Figure. A spectral curve of genus 3, with branch points and certain cycles. Thus it remains to prove that the integral of θ i along the red curve γ S satisfies γ S θ k 4πiZ. This follows from the ρ-symmetry of the spectral data: the integral of θ k along the red curve γ S is twice the integral along the curve γ which is defined to be the part of γ S from the point S 1 lying over the Sym point µ 1 to the point S lying over µ 1 1, i.e., θ k = θ k + θ k = θ k θ k = θ k, γ S γ σ ρ( γ) γ γ γ where the last equality uses the fact that the integral takes imaginary values. The well-definedness of f then gives γ θ k πiz proving the claim. Theorem 5. A constrained Willmore torus f : T S 3 of Babich-Bobenko type has Willmore energy at least 8π. Proof. Since the spectral curve Σ admits an involution ρ covering λ λ 1, it must be of odd genus g, or λ is unbranched. For g {0, 1} the surface f is equivariant, see [18]. For g = 0 the surface must be homogenous. This case cannot appear, since it would be a surface entirely contained in hyperbolic 3-space. For g = 1 the surface is rotational symmetric and obtained by rotating a closed wavelike elastic curve in the hyperbolic plane H around the infinity boundary of H. The only periodic solution in this class is the family of elastic figure-8 curves in H. These surfaces are nonembedded, see for example [17] or [43], and therefore they have Willmore energy above 8π by [8].

18 18 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE Let g 3. By Lemma 1 we can associate to every branch point of Σ a holomorphic section ψ with Z -monodromy of V/L. There exist exactly 4 possible Z - monodromies for ψ arising from the 4 different spin structures of T. To be more concrete, the two monodromy maps ν i of ψ satisfies: (ν 1 (ψ), ν (ψ)) {(1, 1), (1, 1), ( 1, 1), ( 1, 1)}. Every ψ with ±1 monodromy gives rise to a proper holomorphic section of V/L considered as a bundle over a suitable double cover T of T. Thus the theorem follows from the previous Lemma by applying the Plücker estimate (Theorem 4). If the trivial monodromy arises over λ = 0, the immersion f has trivial spin structure and by [34] the surface cannot be embedded and hence it has Willmore energy above 8π. 4. Constrained Willmore stability of the -lobe family In this section we show that the candidate surfaces f b (b b 0 ) are stable as constrained Willmore surfaces. For b < b 0 the surface f b is strictly stable [5]. At b = b 0 the stability operator has a -dimensional kernel spanned by (4.1) ϕ = cos(x) n b 0 and ϕ = sin(x) n b 0, where x is the parameter of the profile curve. Thus in order to prove Theorem 3, it suffices to show the stability of the second variation of W at f b for b > b 0 (up to invariance). For b > b 0 the candidate surface f b arises by rotating its profile curve an arc length parametrized elastic curve γ b in the upper half plane H given by H = {(u, v) R v > 0} considered as the hyperbolic plane around the u-axis. The arc length parametrized closed curve γ b is given by with L = πb being its length. It satisfies γ b : x R/πbZ (u(x), v(x)), u (x) + v (x) = v(x). The oriented unit normal in H is given by n g = v (x) u + u (x) v. Instead of the Euclidean 3-space R 3, we consider f b mapping into the subspace H S 1 R 3 S 3 with conformally equivalent metric g = 1 v (du du + dv dv) + dϕ dϕ,

19 RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 19 with singularities for v = 0. In these coordinates the corresponding conformally parametrized torus of revolution has a particularly simple form f b : M = R/πbZ R/πZ H S 1 ; (x, y) (u(x), v(x), y) with v(x) > 0 for all x. This defines a conformal immersion into R 3 S 3. With respect to g the fiber direction of the surface, i.e., the curves given by y f(x 0, y) for a fixed x 0 R/πb, are geodesics with respect to g. The Willmore functional as specified in [14] is given by W(f) = (H G)dA M where H is the mean curvature, G is the determinant of the second fundamental form (both with respect to the induced metric), and da is the induced area form. With this definition W is invariant under conformal changes of the ambient metric. We use g to compute the Willmore functional and its derivatives. Since f b is an isometric immersion and the fibers are geodesics we obtain H = κ, G = 0, and da = dx dy, with κ = κ(x) being the geodesic curvature of γ b in the hyperbolic plane. Thus the conformal invariance of the Willmore functional gives: W(f b ) = ( 1 4 H R 3)dA R 3 = 1π 4 T πb and E is the elastic energy functional of curves in H. 0 κ ds = 1 4 πe(γ), 4.1. Variation of the profile curve. Consider normal variations Φ(x, y) = ϕ(x, y) n g (x, y). For every fixed y 0 we have that γ b y 0 = f b (x, y 0 ) is an arc length parametrized elastic curve in H, and Φ(x, y 0 ) is a normal variation of the curve γ b y 0. Since the Willmore functional of the candidate surface W(f b ) is the energy functional E of the curve γy b 0 and the conformal constraint corresponds to the length constraint on curves [33], we have that the second variation satisfies for every y 0 R/πZ (4.) δ W β b(f b )(ϕ(x, y 0 ) n g (x, y)) = δ E(γ y0 )(Φ(x, y 0 )) β b δ L(γ b )(Φ(x, y 0 )) =: δ E β b(γ y0 )(Φ(x, y 0 )), where L is the length functional of curves in H. Lemma 4. Let f b be the candidate surface with conformal class (0, b) and γ b the corresponding elastic curve in H. Then δ E β b(γ y0 )(Φ(x, y 0 ), Φ(x, y 0 )) 0

20 0 LYNN HELLER, SEBASTIAN HELLER, AND CHEIKH BIRAHIM NDIAYE for normal variations Φ preserving the length constraint. Moreover, for b > b 0 the kernel of δ E β b is at most 1-dimensional modulo the isometries of H. Proof. For L = πb > 0 fixed, consider the minimization problem inf {E(γ) γ is a closed curve in H with length L }. The minimum is attained by an elastic curve γ min [7] for which δ E β b(γ min )(Φ(x, y 0 ), Φ(x, y 0 )) 0. Rotating γ min we obtain an embedded and isothermic constrained Willmore torus f min in S 3. The Willmore energy of f min must be below 8π, by using the candidate surfaces/curves as competitor. Thus by Theorem and [37], f min is CMC in S 3. The classification of embedded CMC tori [9, ] and [3] shows that f min = f b for the respective b > 1 up to invariance. Therefore, we have γ min = γ b up to isometry. Since δ E β b 0, kernel elements consists of eigenvectors with respect to eigenvalue 0 of δ E β b. This gives rise to a 4th order linear ODE, see [7], which has at most 4- dimension worth of solutions, three of which corresponds to the 3-dimensional space of isometries of H. Thus up to invariance of the equation the kernel is at most one-dimensional. Remark 6. The Willmore energy of the candidate surfaces is shown to be monotonically increasing [3]. The Lagrange multiplier of f b (which corresponds to its constant mean curvature in S 3 ) on the other hand, is shown to be strictly increasing for b < b 0 and strictly decreasing for b > b 0 [3]. 4.. General variations. In order to compute the full second variation δ W β b, we first explicitly parametrize a normal variation Ft b of f b, compute the first and second fundamental form and then determine the Taylor expansion of the Willmore energy at t = 0 to the second order. The second order term is then ( ) d t=0w(ft b ) = D W(f b )( t Ft b, t Ft b ) + DW( tt Ft b ). dt A short computation shows that the following holds for a variation Ft b of a constrained Willmore torus: DW ( tt F b t ) = β b D Π ( t F b t t F b t ) + β b ( d dt A constrained Willmore torus is stable for W, if ) t=0(π (F b t )). ( ) d t=0w(ft b ) 0 dt

21 for all variations F b t RECTANGULAR MINIMIZERS AND THE WILLMORE CONJECTURE 1 preserving the conformal type. In this case ( ) d t=0(π (Ft b )) 0, dt i.e., to determine whether a surface is stable we have to show that (4.3) ( ) ( ) d d t=0w(ft b ) β b t=0(π (Ft b )) 0 dt dt for all variations F b t. The similar arguments as in Section 4.1 show that δ W β b decomposed into = δ W + β b δ Π can be δ W β b(f b ) = δ E β b + Q, where δ E β b we have is tensorial in y, i.e., for normal variations of the form Φ(x, y) = p(x)q(y) n g δ E β b(f b )(Φ(x, y), Φ(x, y)) = δ E β b(f b )(p(x) n g, p(x) n g )q (y). The term Q in this decomposition has no 0th order term in y. We want to show that Q is strictly positive unless the normal variation given by ϕ is a Möbius variation. Together with Lemma 4 this implies Theorem 3. We can further split Q with respect to (4.3) Q = Q 1 + Q where Q 1 corresponds to ( ) d t=0 W(F b dt t ) and Q corresponds to ( d dt ) t=0 (Π (F b t )) Explicit formulas. For the -lobed Delaunay torus f b consider normal variations determined by Φ(x, y) = ϕ(x, y) n g, for a function ϕ: T R, i.e., F b t t F b t : T H S 1 ; (x, y) (u(x) tv (x)ϕ(x, y), v(x) + tu (x)ϕ(x, y), y). is an immersion for every t 0, although F b t is generally not conformal for t 0. For t 0 the induced family of metrics g t of F b t are given by: T b on the torus = R/(πbZ) R/(πZ) g t = dx dy+dy dy+t(αdx dx)+t (βdx dx+γ(dx dy+dy dx)+δdy dy)+...,