To Lambda or not to Lambda?
|
|
- Bonnie Snow
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 To Lambda or not to Lambda? Supratik Pal Indian Statistical Institute Kolkata October 17, 2015
2 Conclusion We don t know :)
3 Partly based on my works with Dhiraj Hazra, Subha Majumdar, Sudhakar Panda, Anjan Sen, Debabrata Adak, Debasish Majumdar
4 Partly based on my works with Dhiraj Hazra, Subha Majumdar, Sudhakar Panda, Anjan Sen, Debabrata Adak, Debasish Majumdar Thirty Meter Telescope s Science Report 2015 together with Planck 2015 paper [ ]
5 Some random questions What do we know about Dark Energy? Are the results observation dependent? Are they parametrization (theoretical prior) dependent? So, what next?
6 A bit of history
7 Universe is accelerating at present
8 Governing equations Universe is accelerating at present ( ȧ ) 2 a = 8πG 3 ρ k a 2 ä a = 4πG 3 (ρ + 3p) Ordinary matter satisfying Strong Energy Condition (ρ + 3p) 0 cannot supply the effective anti-gravity required for acceleration Who governs this expansion history?
9 Cosmological Constant ( ȧ ) 2 a = 8πG 3 ρ + Λ 3 k a 2 ä a = 4πG 3 (ρ + 3p) + Λ 3 M = 4 3 πa3 (ρ + 3p) = ä = GM + Λ a 2 3 a Effective mass Attraction Repulsion a(t) [ ] 2/3 sinh( 3 Λ 2 3 t) Fine-tuning problem Cosmic coincidence problem...
10 Dynamical models: Dark Energy ( ȧ ) 2 a = 8πG 3 ä a = 4πG 3 i ρ i k a 2 i (ρ i + 3p i ) p i < ρ i /3 w i < 1/3 leads to acceleration violates SEC
11 Dynamical models: Dark Energy ( ȧ ) 2 a = 8πG 3 ä a = 4πG 3 i ρ i k a 2 i (ρ i + 3p i ) p i < ρ i /3 w i < 1/3 leads to acceleration violates SEC Scalar field models EM tensor components ρ φ = 1 2 φ 2 + V (φ) ; p φ = 1 2 φ 2 V (φ) Quintessence: scalar field minimally coupled to gravity K-essence: Kinetic energy driven Tachyonic: Non-canonical Phantom: Opposite sign in kinetic term Dilatonic (Generalized) Chaplygin gas Too many candidates
12 Modified gravity models Einstein s theory is not directly tested in cosmological scales. Modify the gravity sector rather than the matter sector. Brans-Dicke theory: G as a VEV of a geometric field, need vastly different values for solar system and cosmic scales f(r) gravity: R in the action replaced by f(r), [e.g. R µ R ], no unique choice DGP model: Extra dimensional effects at large scale, fails to produce small scale results No unique candidate
13 Dark energy parametrizations Observationally we probe two parameters of dark energy: Density parameter (Ω DE ) (by probing Ω M ) Equation of State (EOS) parameter (w DE ) Proposal Instead of proposing individual models, can we parametrize dark energy and constrain models from observations by constraining those parameters?
14 Parametrization of Hubble parameter r(x) = H2 (x) H 2 0 = Ω 0 mx 3 + A 0 + A 1 x + A 2 x 2 with x = 1 + z ; Ω 0 m + A 0 + A 1 + A 2 = 1 ; ρ 0 c = 3H0 2 ρ = ρ 0 ( c A0 + A 1 x + A 2 x 2) For A 0 0, A 1 = 0 = A 2 = ΛCDM Either A 1 0 or A 2 0 = Dynamical dark energy
15 Parametrization of EOS CPL Parametrization Fits a wide range of scalar field dark energy models including the supergravity-inspired SUGRA dark energy models. w(a) = w 0 + w a (1 a) = w 0 + w a z 1 + z ρ DE a 3(1+w 0+w a) e 3wa(1 a) Two parameter description: w 0 = EOS at present, w a = its variation w.r.t. scale factor (or redshift). For w 0 1, w a > 0 : dark energy is non-phantom throughout Otherwise, may show phantom behavior at some point
16 SS Parametrization Useful for slow-roll thawing class of scalar field models having a canonical kinetic energy term. Motivation : to look for a unique dark energy evolution for scalar field models that are constrained to evolve close to Λ. w(a) = (1 + w 0 ) [ 1 + (Ω 1 DE 1)a 3 (Ω 1 DE 1)a 3 tanh (Ω 1 [ ( ) 1 ΩDE 1 Ω DE 1 tanh 1 ] 2 Ω DE 1 DE 1)a 3 ] 2 One model parameter: w 0 = EOS at present Rest is taken care of by the general cosmological parameter Ω DE = dark energy density today.
17 GCG Parametrization p = c ρ α A w(a) = ; A = c A+(1 A)a 3(1+α) ρ 1+α GCG Two model parameters e.g A and α, with w(0) = A For (1 + α) > 0, w(a) behaves like a dust in the past and evolves towards negative values and becomes w = 1 in the asymptotic future. = tracker/freezer behavior For (1 + α) < 0, w(a) is frozen to w = 1 in the past and it slowly evolves towards higher values and eventually behaves like a dust in the future. = thawing behavior Restricted to 0 < A < 1 only since for A > 1 singularity appears at finite past = non-phantom only
18 Dark Energy a la observations Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data Shift parameter (position of peaks) Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect (low-l)
19 Shift Parameter DE Shift in position of peaks by Ω m D D= Angular diameter distance (to LSS) Shift Parameter R = Ωmh 2 Ω k h 2 χ(y) χ(y) = sin y(k < 0) ; = y(k = 0) ; = sinh y(k > 0) y = Ω k z dec o dz Ω m(1+z) 3 +Ω k (1+z) 2 +Ω X (1+z) 3(1+ω X ) χ 2 CMB (ω X, Ω m, H 0 ) = [ ] 2 R(zdec,ω X,Ω m,h 0 ) R σ R
20 Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect Some CMB anisotropies may be induced by passing through a time varying gravitational potential linear regime: integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect non-linear regime: Rees-Sciama effect Poisson equation : 2 Φ = 4πGa 2 ρδ Φ constant during matter domination time-varying when dark energy comes to dominate (at large scales l 20) T ISW l C l = dk k P R(k)Tl 2 (k) (k) = 2 dη exp τ dφ dη j l(k(η η 0 ) But cosmic variance!
21 Supernova Type Ia Data Probe Luminosity distance: D L (z) = H 0 d L (z) via distance modulus µ(z) = 5 log 10 (D L (z)) + µ 0 χ 2 SN (w 0 X, Ω0 m, H 0 ) = i [ ] µobs (z i ) µ(z i ;wx 0,Ω0 m,h 0 ) 2 σ i Marginalizing over the nuisance parameter µ 0, B = i A = i χ 2 SN (w 0 X, Ω0 m) = A B 2 /C [ ] µobs (z i ) µ(z i ;wx 0,Ω0 m,µ 2 0=0) σ i [ ] µobs (z i ) µ(z i ;wx 0,Ω0 m,µ 0 =0) σ i ; C = i 1 σ 2 i Union 2.1 compilation of 580 Supernovae at z = , considered as standard candles
22 Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) data Used to measure H(z) and angular diameter distance D A (z) via a combination [ ] 1/3 D V (z) = (1 + z) 2 DA 2 cz (z) H(z) Confront models via a distance ratio d z = rs(z drag) D V (z) r s (z drag ) = comoving sound horizon at a redshift where baryon-drag optical depth is unity Give 6 data points: WiggleZ : z = 0.44, 0.6, 0.73 SDSS DR7 : z = 0.35 SDSS DR9 : z = DF : z = Hence calculate χ 2 BAO
23 Hubble Space Telescope Data (HST) Use nearby Type-Ia Supernova data with Cepheid calibrations to constrain the value of H 0 directly. Combine and calculate χ 2 for the analysis of HST data χ 2 HST (w 0 X, Ω0 m, H 0 ) = i [ ] Hobs (z i ) H(z i ;wx 0,Ω0 m,h 2 0) σ i Two methods of analysis Riess et. al. (2011) Efstathiou (2014)
24 Some more probes Weak lensing Galaxy clusters Gamma ray bursts X-ray observations Growth factor... Dark Energy Perturbations Can be important at horizon scales. Need to cross-correlate large scale CMB with large scale structures. But cosmic variance! Incorporated through sound speed squared c 2 s. For canonical scalar, c 2 s = 1
25 Dark energy from different datasets Used all three parametrizations = Analysis is robust Data ΛCDM CPL SS GCG Planck (low-l + high-l) WMAP-9 low-l polarization BAO : SDSS DR BAO : SDSS DR BAO : 6DF BAO : WiggleZ SN : Union HST Total Best fit χ 2 eff obtained in different model upon comparing against CMB + non-cmb datasets using the Powell s BOBYQA method of iterative minimization.
26 Likelihood functions for CPL parametrization 1 CPL model 1 CPL model Planck+WP Planck+WP non-cmb non-cmb Planck+WP+non-CMB Planck+WP+non-CMB Likelihood 0.5 Likelihood w w a
27 Concordance with Planck 2015 paper: CPL
28 Likelihood functions for different parameters of EOS CPL model CPL model SS model Planck+WP Planck+WP Planck+WP non-cmb non-cmb non-cmb Planck+WP+non-CMB Planck+WP+non-CMB Planck+WP+non-CMB Likelihood 0.5 Likelihood 0.5 Likelihood w w a w GCG model Planck+WP 1 GCG model Planck+WP non-cmb non-cmb Planck+WP+non-CMB Planck+WP+non-CMB Likelihood 0.5 Likelihood A (w 0 ) α
29 Mean value and 1σ range for CMB+non-CMB
30 Analysis: value of H 0 76 CPL model 76 GCG model SS model H 0 70 H 0 70 H Ω m Ω m Ω m H CPL model w 0 H GCG model w 0 H SS model w 0
31 If phantom is forbidden by theoretical prior (GCG): The parameters stay close to the values obtained in ΛCDM model analysis. H 0 is not that degenerate with dark energy equation of state for CMB.
32 If phantom is forbidden by theoretical prior (GCG): The parameters stay close to the values obtained in ΛCDM model analysis. H 0 is not that degenerate with dark energy equation of state for CMB. If phantom is NOT forbidden by theoretical prior (CPL+SS): Better fit to the CMB data comes with a large value of H 0 agrees better with the HST data (better total χ 2 ) But background cosmological parameter space (e.g., Ω m H 0 ) is dragged s.t. best-fit base model and that from Planck becomes 2σ away. H 0 becomes highly degenerate with dark energy EOS for CMB only measurements.
33 Comparison with Planck 2015 Difference in analysis of HST data : Riess vs Efstathiou
34 Analysis: Equation of State w a CPL model 1 Always non-phantom α -2 GCG model Freezing/tracking Thawing w A (w 0 )
35 w z w 1.2 w z z Top: CPL, Bottom left: SS, Bottom right: GCG
36 If phantom is forbidden by theoretical prior (GCG): Show consistency between CMB and non-cmb data But they have marginally worse likelihood than other parametrizations. CMB and non-cmb observations are separately sensitive to the two model parameters but the joint constraint is consistent with w = 1.
37 If phantom is forbidden by theoretical prior (GCG): Show consistency between CMB and non-cmb data But they have marginally worse likelihood than other parametrizations. CMB and non-cmb observations are separately sensitive to the two model parameters but the joint constraint is consistent with w = 1. If phantom is NOT forbidden by theoretical prior (CPL+SS): CMB data: the non-phantom equation of states stays at the edge of 2σ region. Non-CMB data: non-phantom behavior favored for every parametrization considered.
38 Combined CMB + non-cmb data Mean w and error bar depends on the parametrization. SS and GCG parametrization: the nature of dark energy is best constrained at high redshifts CPL parametrization: the best constraints come in the redshift range of Just as aside... Similar results by Novosyadlyj et.al. (JCAP): for dataset Planck+HST+BAO+SNLS3 ΛCDM is outside 2σ confidence regime, for dataset WMAP-9+HST+BAO+SNLS3 ΛCDM is 1σ away from best fit. PAN-STARRS1 shows tension with ΛCDM at 2.4σ with a constant EOS (Rest et.al., )
39 Conclusion Constraints on w and hence the nature of dark energy that we infer from cosmological observation depends crucially on the choice of the underlying parametrization of the EOS.
40 Conclusion Constraints on w and hence the nature of dark energy that we infer from cosmological observation depends crucially on the choice of the underlying parametrization of the EOS. Can the apparent tension between CMB and non-cmb data be attributed to unknown systematics? Unlikely!
41 Conclusion Constraints on w and hence the nature of dark energy that we infer from cosmological observation depends crucially on the choice of the underlying parametrization of the EOS. Can the apparent tension between CMB and non-cmb data be attributed to unknown systematics? Unlikely! Can it be due to different analysis of HST data (Riess vs Efsthathiou)? Maybe
42 Conclusion Constraints on w and hence the nature of dark energy that we infer from cosmological observation depends crucially on the choice of the underlying parametrization of the EOS. Can the apparent tension between CMB and non-cmb data be attributed to unknown systematics? Unlikely! Can it be due to different analysis of HST data (Riess vs Efsthathiou)? Maybe Can it be due to lack of a better theory/parametrization of the dark energy equation of state? Most likely yes
43 Conclusion Constraints on w and hence the nature of dark energy that we infer from cosmological observation depends crucially on the choice of the underlying parametrization of the EOS. Can the apparent tension between CMB and non-cmb data be attributed to unknown systematics? Unlikely! Can it be due to different analysis of HST data (Riess vs Efsthathiou)? Maybe Can it be due to lack of a better theory/parametrization of the dark energy equation of state? Most likely yes Can a non-parametric reconstruction of w for the total dataset help to infer about the correct nature of dark energy (or, Λ) without any priors on the form of w?
44 Conclusion We don t know :)
45
Detecting Dark Energy Perturbations
H. K. Jassal IISER Mohali Ftag 2013, IIT Gandhinagar Outline 1 Overview Present day Observations Constraints on cosmological parameters 2 Theoretical Issues Clustering dark energy Integrated Sachs Wolfe
More informationA theorist s take-home message from CMB Supratik Pal
A theorist s take-home message from CMB Supratik Pal Indian Statistical Institute Kolkata Outline CMB à la WMAP and Planck Inflation Dark energy New horizons 1 A cosmologist s wishlist To explain... 2
More informationDark Energy. RESCEU APcosPA Summer School on Cosmology and Particle Astrophysics Matsumoto city, Nagano. July 31 - August
RESCEU APcosPA Summer School on Cosmology and Particle Astrophysics Matsumoto city, Nagano LCC, Université Montpellier 2 July 31 - August 4 2014 More : Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) universes:
More informationCosmological Constraints on Dark Energy via Bulk Viscosity from Decaying Dark Matter
Cosmological Constraints on Dark Energy via Bulk Viscosity from Decaying Dark Matter Nguyen Quynh Lan Hanoi National University of Education, Vietnam (University of Notre Dame, USA) Rencontres du Vietnam:
More informationChapter - 3. Analytical solutions of the evolution of mass of black holes and. worm holes immersed in a Generalized Chaplygin Gas model
Chapter - 3 Analytical solutions of the evolution of mass of black holes and worm holes immersed in a Generalized Chaplygin Gas model (Published in International Journal of Pure and Applied Sciences and
More informationN-body Simulations and Dark energy
N-Body Simulations and models of Dark Energy Elise Jennings Supported by a Marie Curie Early Stage Training Fellowship N-body Simulations and Dark energy elise jennings Introduction N-Body simulations
More informationThe Nature of Dark Energy and its Implications for Particle Physics and Cosmology
The Nature of Dark Energy and its Implications for Particle Physics and Cosmology May 3, 27@ University of Tokyo Tomo Takahashi Department of Physics, Saga University 1. Introduction Current cosmological
More informationModified gravity as an alternative to dark energy. Lecture 3. Observational tests of MG models
Modified gravity as an alternative to dark energy Lecture 3. Observational tests of MG models Observational tests Assume that we manage to construct a model How well can we test the model and distinguish
More informationUnication models of dark matter and dark energy
Unication models of dark matter and dark energy Neven ƒaplar March 14, 2012 Neven ƒaplar () Unication models March 14, 2012 1 / 25 Index of topics Some basic cosmology Unication models Chaplygin gas Generalized
More informationDark Energy in Light of the CMB. (or why H 0 is the Dark Energy) Wayne Hu. February 2006, NRAO, VA
Dark Energy in Light of the CMB (or why H 0 is the Dark Energy) Wayne Hu February 2006, NRAO, VA If its not dark, it doesn't matter! Cosmic matter-energy budget: Dark Energy Dark Matter Dark Baryons Visible
More informationPhysical Cosmology 4/4/2016. Docente: Alessandro Melchiorri
Physical Cosmology 4/4/2016 Docente: Alessandro Melchiorri alessandro.melchiorri@roma1.infn.it Suggested textbooks Barbara Ryden, Introduction to Cosmology http://www.astro.caltech.edu/~george/ay21/readings/ryden_introcosmo.pdf
More informationNonparametric Inference and the Dark Energy Equation of State
Nonparametric Inference and the Dark Energy Equation of State Christopher R. Genovese Peter E. Freeman Larry Wasserman Department of Statistics Carnegie Mellon University http://www.stat.cmu.edu/ ~ genovese/
More informationComplementarity in Dark Energy measurements. Complementarity of optical data in constraining dark energy. Licia Verde. University of Pennsylvania
Complementarity in Dark Energy measurements Complementarity of optical data in constraining dark energy Licia Verde University of Pennsylvania www.physics.upenn.edu/~lverde The situation: SN 1A (Riess
More informationMapping the Dark Energy Equation of State
**TITLE** ASP Conference Series, Vol. **VOLUME***, **YEAR OF PUBLICATION** **NAMES OF EDITORS** Mapping the Dark Energy Equation of State Eric V. Linder Berkeley Lab, 1 Cyclotron Road, M/S 50R5008, Berkeley,
More informationWhat do we really know about Dark Energy?
What do we really know about Dark Energy? Ruth Durrer Département de Physique Théorique & Center of Astroparticle Physics (CAP) ESTEC, February 3, 2012 Ruth Durrer (Université de Genève ) Dark Energy ESTEC
More informationVasiliki A. Mitsou. IFIC Valencia TAUP International Conference on Topics in Astroparticle and Underground Physics
Vasiliki A. Mitsou IFIC Valencia TAUP 2009 International Conference on Topics in Astroparticle and Underground Physics Rome, Italy, 1-5 July 2009 Dark energy models CDM Super-horizon CDM (SHCDM) [Kolb,
More informationProbing alternative theories of gravity with Planck
Probing alternative theories of gravity with Planck Andrea Marchini Sapienza - University of Rome based on Updated constraints from the Planck experiment on modified gravity:prd88,027502 In collaboration
More informationCosmology II: The thermal history of the Universe
.. Cosmology II: The thermal history of the Universe Ruth Durrer Département de Physique Théorique et CAP Université de Genève Suisse August 6, 2014 Ruth Durrer (Université de Genève) Cosmology II August
More informationCosmology. Jörn Wilms Department of Physics University of Warwick.
Cosmology Jörn Wilms Department of Physics University of Warwick http://astro.uni-tuebingen.de/~wilms/teach/cosmo Contents 2 Old Cosmology Space and Time Friedmann Equations World Models Modern Cosmology
More informationGalaxies 626. Lecture 3: From the CMBR to the first star
Galaxies 626 Lecture 3: From the CMBR to the first star Galaxies 626 Firstly, some very brief cosmology for background and notation: Summary: Foundations of Cosmology 1. Universe is homogenous and isotropic
More informationCMB Anisotropies and Fundamental Physics. Lecture II. Alessandro Melchiorri University of Rome «La Sapienza»
CMB Anisotropies and Fundamental Physics Lecture II Alessandro Melchiorri University of Rome «La Sapienza» Lecture II CMB & PARAMETERS (Mostly Dark Energy) Things we learned from lecture I Theory of CMB
More informationThe early and late time acceleration of the Universe
The early and late time acceleration of the Universe Tomo Takahashi (Saga University) March 7, 2016 New Generation Quantum Theory -Particle Physics, Cosmology, and Chemistry- @Kyoto University The early
More informationTheoretical Explanations for Cosmic Acceleration
Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Acceleration Eanna Flanagan, Cornell Physics Colloquium, University of Guelph, 17 October 2006 Outline Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe is
More informationEffective Field Theory approach for Dark Energy/ Modified Gravity. Bin HU BNU
Effective Field Theory approach for Dark Energy/ Modified Gravity Bin HU BNU NAOC Nov. 2016 Outline 1. Evidence of late-time cosmic acceleration 2. Effective Field Theory approach for DE/MG 3. The structure
More informationTESTING GRAVITY WITH COSMOLOGY
21 IV. TESTING GRAVITY WITH COSMOLOGY We now turn to the different ways with which cosmological observations can constrain modified gravity models. We have already seen that Solar System tests provide
More informationwith Matter and Radiation By: Michael Solway
Interactions of Dark Energy with Matter and Radiation By: Michael Solway Advisor: Professor Mike Berger What is Dark Energy? Dark energy is the energy needed to explain the observed accelerated expansion
More informationThe Power. of the Galaxy Power Spectrum. Eric Linder 13 February 2012 WFIRST Meeting, Pasadena
The Power of the Galaxy Power Spectrum Eric Linder 13 February 2012 WFIRST Meeting, Pasadena UC Berkeley & Berkeley Lab Institute for the Early Universe, Korea 11 Baryon Acoustic Oscillations In the beginning...
More informationBAO & RSD. Nikhil Padmanabhan Essential Cosmology for the Next Generation VII December 2017
BAO & RSD Nikhil Padmanabhan Essential Cosmology for the Next Generation VII December 2017 Overview Introduction Standard rulers, a spherical collapse picture of BAO, the Kaiser formula, measuring distance
More informationPlanck constraints on neutrinos. Massimiliano Lattanzi Università di Ferrara on behalf of the Planck Collaboration
Planck constraints on neutrinos Massimiliano Lattanzi Università di Ferrara on behalf of the Planck Collaboration The Cosmic Neutrino Background (CnB) The presence of a background of relic neutrinos is
More informationDARK ENERGY, DARK MATTER AND THE CHAPLYGIN GAS
DARK ENERGY, DARK MATTER AND THE CHAPLYGIN GAS R.Colistete Jr. 1,J. C. Fabris 2, S.V.B. Gonçalves 3 and P.E. de Souza 4 Departamento de Física, Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo, CEP296-9, Vitória,
More informationDark energy. P. Binétruy AstroParticule et Cosmologie, Paris. Zakopane, 15 June 2007
Dark energy P. Binétruy AstroParticule et Cosmologie, Paris Zakopane, 15 June 2007 Context : the twentieth century legacy Two very successful theories : General relativity A single equation, Einstein s
More informationCan kinetic Sunyaev-Zel dovich effect be used to detect the interaction between DE and DM? Bin Wang Shanghai Jiao Tong University
Can kinetic Sunyaev-Zel dovich effect be used to detect the interaction between DE and DM? Bin Wang Shanghai Jiao Tong University Outline: The interaction model between DE&DM The ISW effect as a probe
More informationThe Principal Components of. Falsifying Cosmological Paradigms. Wayne Hu FRS, Chicago May 2011
The Principal Components of Falsifying Cosmological Paradigms Wayne Hu FRS, Chicago May 2011 The Standard Cosmological Model Standard ΛCDM cosmological model is an exceedingly successful phenomenological
More informationCONSTRAINTS AND TENSIONS IN MG CFHTLENS AND OTHER DATA SETS PARAMETERS FROM PLANCK, INCLUDING INTRINSIC ALIGNMENTS SYSTEMATICS.
CONSTRAINTS AND TENSIONS IN MG PARAMETERS FROM PLANCK, CFHTLENS AND OTHER DATA SETS INCLUDING INTRINSIC ALIGNMENTS SYSTEMATICS 1 Mustapha Ishak The University of Texas at Dallas Jason Dossett INAF Osservatorio
More informationUn-natural aspects of standard cosmology. John Peacock Oxford anthropics workshop 5 Dec 2013
Un-natural aspects of standard cosmology John Peacock Oxford anthropics workshop 5 Dec 2013 Outline Defining natural-ness PPT viewpoint Bayesian framework List of cosmological problems Strange parameter
More informationIntroduction. How did the universe evolve to what it is today?
Cosmology 8 1 Introduction 8 2 Cosmology: science of the universe as a whole How did the universe evolve to what it is today? Based on four basic facts: The universe expands, is isotropic, and is homogeneous.
More informationEl Universo en Expansion. Juan García-Bellido Inst. Física Teórica UAM Benasque, 12 Julio 2004
El Universo en Expansion Juan García-Bellido Inst. Física Teórica UAM Benasque, 12 Julio 2004 5 billion years (you are here) Space is Homogeneous and Isotropic General Relativity An Expanding Universe
More informationStructure in the CMB
Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropies = structure in the CMB Structure in the CMB Boomerang balloon flight. Mapped Cosmic Background Radiation with far higher angular resolution than previously available.
More informationThe ultimate measurement of the CMB temperature anisotropy field UNVEILING THE CMB SKY
The ultimate measurement of the CMB temperature anisotropy field UNVEILING THE CMB SKY PARAMETRIC MODEL 16 spectra in total C(θ) = CMB theoretical spectra plus physically motivated templates for the
More informationThe Early Universe John Peacock ESA Cosmic Vision Paris, Sept 2004
The Early Universe John Peacock ESA Cosmic Vision Paris, Sept 2004 The history of modern cosmology 1917 Static via cosmological constant? (Einstein) 1917 Expansion (Slipher) 1952 Big Bang criticism (Hoyle)
More informationNarrowing down the possible explanations of cosmic acceleration with geometric probes
Prepared for submission to JCAP arxiv:1705.05768v1 [astro-ph.co] 16 May 2017 Narrowing down the possible explanations of cosmic acceleration with geometric probes Suhail Dhawan, a Ariel Goobar, a Edvard
More informationModern Cosmology Final Examination Solutions 60 Pts
Modern Cosmology Final Examination Solutions 6 Pts Name:... Matr. Nr.:... February,. Observable Universe [4 Pts] 6 Pt: Complete the plot of Redshift vs Luminosity distance in the range < z < and plot (i)
More informationBeyond ΛCDM: Dark energy vs Modified Gravity
Beyond ΛCDM: Dark energy vs Modified Gravity Bhuvnesh Jain University of Pennsylvania References BJ et al, arxiv:1309.5389 (Snowmass) Joyce, BJ, Khoury, Trodden, arxiv:1407.0059 (Review) Cosmology probes:
More informationModified gravity. Kazuya Koyama ICG, University of Portsmouth
Modified gravity Kazuya Koyama ICG, University of Portsmouth Cosmic acceleration Cosmic acceleration Big surprise in cosmology Simplest best fit model LCDM 4D general relativity + cosmological const. H
More informationPlanck results (1 st release)
General Introduction Planck results (1 st release) From Planck Collaboration.XVI. 2014 Standard cosmological model in good agreement with data but Valentina Salvatelli Interacting Dark Energy in light
More informationThe Dark Sector ALAN HEAVENS
The Dark Sector ALAN HEAVENS INSTITUTE FOR ASTRONOMY UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH AFH@ROE.AC.UK THIRD TRR33 WINTER SCHOOL PASSO DEL TONALE (ITALY) 6-11 DECEMBER 2009 Outline Dark Matter Dark Energy Dark Gravity
More informationPhysical Cosmology 6/6/2016
Physical Cosmology 6/6/2016 Alessandro Melchiorri alessandro.melchiorri@roma1.infn.it slides can be found here: oberon.roma1.infn.it/alessandro/cosmo2016 CMB anisotropies The temperature fluctuation in
More informationPhysics 463, Spring 07. Formation and Evolution of Structure: Growth of Inhomogenieties & the Linear Power Spectrum
Physics 463, Spring 07 Lecture 3 Formation and Evolution of Structure: Growth of Inhomogenieties & the Linear Power Spectrum last time: how fluctuations are generated and how the smooth Universe grows
More informationHighlights from Planck 2013 cosmological results Paolo Natoli Università di Ferrara and ASI/ASDC DSU2013, Sissa, 17 October 2013
Highlights from Planck 2013 cosmological results Paolo Natoli Università di Ferrara and ASI/ASDC DSU2013, Sissa, 17 October 2013 On behalf of the Planck collaboration Fluctuation and GW generator Fluctuation
More informationCosmology with the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Supernova Search. David Cinabro
Cosmology with the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Supernova Search David Cinabro Cosmology Background The study of the origin and evolution of the Universe. First real effort by Einstein in 1916 Gravity is all
More informationCosmology Dark Energy Models ASTR 2120 Sarazin
Cosmology Dark Energy Models ASTR 2120 Sarazin Late Homeworks Last day Wednesday, May 1 My mail box in ASTR 204 Maximum credit 50% unless excused (but, better than nothing) Final Exam Thursday, May 2,
More informationCONSTRAINTS AND TENSIONS IN MG CFHTLENS AND OTHER DATA SETS PARAMETERS FROM PLANCK, INCLUDING INTRINSIC ALIGNMENTS SYSTEMATICS. arxiv:1501.
CONSTRAINTS AND TENSIONS IN MG PARAMETERS FROM PLANCK, CFHTLENS AND OTHER DATA SETS INCLUDING INTRINSIC ALIGNMENTS SYSTEMATICS arxiv:1501.03119 1 Mustapha Ishak The University of Texas at Dallas Jason
More informationConstraining Modified Gravity and Coupled Dark Energy with Future Observations Matteo Martinelli
Coupled Dark University of Rome La Sapienza Roma, October 28th 2011 Outline 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 Accelerated Expansion Cosmological data agree with an accelerated expansion of the Universe d L [Mpc] 16000
More informationA glimpse on Cosmology: Mathematics meets the Data
Naples 09 Seminar A glimpse on Cosmology: Mathematics meets the Data by 10 November 2009 Monica Capone 1 Toward a unified epistemology of Sciences...As we know, There are known knowns. There are things
More informationThe State of Tension Between the CMB and LSS
The State of Tension Between the CMB and LSS Tom Charnock 1 in collaboration with Adam Moss 1 and Richard Battye 2 Phys.Rev. D91 (2015) 10, 103508 1 Particle Theory Group University of Nottingham 2 Jodrell
More informationDark Matter and Dark Energy
Dark Matter and Dark Energy Sean Carroll, University of Chicago Our universe, as inventoried over the last ten years: 5% Ordinary Matter 25% D ark M atter 70% Dark Energy Dark Energy Dark Matter Ordinary
More informationLecture 09. The Cosmic Microwave Background. Part II Features of the Angular Power Spectrum
The Cosmic Microwave Background Part II Features of the Angular Power Spectrum Angular Power Spectrum Recall the angular power spectrum Peak at l=200 corresponds to 1o structure Exactly the horizon distance
More informationA5682: Introduction to Cosmology Course Notes. 11. CMB Anisotropy
Reading: Chapter 8, sections 8.4 and 8.5 11. CMB Anisotropy Gravitational instability and structure formation Today s universe shows structure on scales from individual galaxies to galaxy groups and clusters
More informationCOSMIC MICROWAVE BACKGROUND ANISOTROPIES
COSMIC MICROWAVE BACKGROUND ANISOTROPIES Anthony Challinor Institute of Astronomy & Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics University of Cambridge, U.K. a.d.challinor@ast.cam.ac.uk 26
More informationDark Universe II. Prof. Lynn Cominsky Dept. of Physics and Astronomy Sonoma State University
Dark Universe II Prof. Lynn Cominsky Dept. of Physics and Astronomy Sonoma State University Dark Universe Part II Is the universe "open" or "closed? How does dark energy change our view of the history
More informationImprint of Scalar Dark Energy on CMB polarization
Imprint of Scalar Dark Energy on CMB polarization Kin-Wang Ng ( 吳建宏 ) Institute of Physics & Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Academia Sinica, Taiwan Cosmology and Gravity Pre-workshop NTHU, Apr
More informationGalileon Cosmology ASTR448 final project. Yin Li December 2012
Galileon Cosmology ASTR448 final project Yin Li December 2012 Outline Theory Why modified gravity? Ostrogradski, Horndeski and scalar-tensor gravity; Galileon gravity as generalized DGP; Galileon in Minkowski
More informationFluctuations of cosmic parameters in the local universe
Fluctuations of cosmic parameters in the local universe Alexander Wiegand Dominik Schwarz Fakultät für Physik Universität Bielefeld 6. Kosmologietag, Bielefeld 2011 A. Wiegand (Universität Bielefeld) Fluctuations
More informationConcordance Cosmology and Particle Physics. Richard Easther (Yale University)
Concordance Cosmology and Particle Physics Richard Easther (Yale University) Concordance Cosmology The standard model for cosmology Simplest model that fits the data Smallest number of free parameters
More informationLecture 19. Dark Energy
Dark Energy ΛCDM Recall the lectures on cosmology The universe is flat Total energy density is 1 We know matter and baryon density So far, we called the rest Dark Energy We treated DE in the Friedmann
More informationModified Gravity (MOG) and Dark Matter: Can Dark Matter be Detected in the Present Universe?
Modified Gravity (MOG) and Dark Matter: Can Dark Matter be Detected in the Present Universe? John Moffat Perimeter Institute, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada Talk given at the Miami 2014 topical conference on
More informationDark Energy vs. Dark Matter: Towards a unifying scalar field?
Dark Energy vs. Dark Matter: Towards a unifying scalar field? Alexandre ARBEY Centre de Recherche Astrophysique de Lyon Institut de Physique Nucléaire de Lyon, March 2nd, 2007. Introduction The Dark Stuff
More informationThe large scale structure of the universe
The large scale structure of the universe Part 1: Deciphering the large scale structure (LSS) With statistics and physics Part 2: Tracers of LSS Broadband power spectrum, BAO, redshift distortion, weak
More informationBaryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 Galaxy Sample
Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 Galaxy Sample BOMEE LEE 1. Brief Introduction about BAO In our previous class we learned what is the Baryon Acoustic Oscillations(BAO).
More informationExamining the Viability of Phantom Dark Energy
Examining the Viability of Phantom Dark Energy Kevin J. Ludwick LaGrange College 12/20/15 (11:00-11:30) Kevin J. Ludwick (LaGrange College) Examining the Viability of Phantom Dark Energy 12/20/15 (11:00-11:30)
More informationThe Outtakes. Back to Talk. Foregrounds Doppler Peaks? SNIa Complementarity Polarization Primer Gamma Approximation ISW Effect
The Outtakes CMB Transfer Function Testing Inflation Weighing Neutrinos Decaying Neutrinos Testing Λ Testing Quintessence Polarization Sensitivity SDSS Complementarity Secondary Anisotropies Doppler Effect
More informationExploring dark energy in the universe through baryon acoustic oscillation
Exploring dark energy in the universe through baryon acoustic oscillation WMAP CMB power spectrum SDSS galaxy correlation Yasushi Suto Department of Physics, University of Tokyo KEK Annual Theory Meeting
More informationModern Cosmology / Scott Dodelson Contents
Modern Cosmology / Scott Dodelson Contents The Standard Model and Beyond p. 1 The Expanding Universe p. 1 The Hubble Diagram p. 7 Big Bang Nucleosynthesis p. 9 The Cosmic Microwave Background p. 13 Beyond
More informationCosmology with Peculiar Velocity Surveys
Cosmology with Peculiar Velocity Surveys Simulations Fest, Sydney 2011 Morag I Scrimgeour Supervisors: Lister Staveley-Smith, Tamara Davis, Peter Quinn Collaborators: Chris Blake, Brian Schmidt What are
More informationLecture 3. The inflation-building toolkit
Lecture 3 The inflation-building toolkit Types of inflationary research Fundamental physics modelling of inflation. Building inflation models within the context of M-theory/braneworld/ supergravity/etc
More informationObservational evidence for Dark energy
Observational evidence for Dark energy ICSW-07 (Jun 2-9, 2007) Tarun Souradeep I.U.C.A.A, Pune, India Email: tarun@iucaa.ernet.in Observational evidence for DE poses a major challenge for theoretical cosmology.
More informationForthcoming CMB experiments and expectations for dark energy. Carlo Baccigalupi
Forthcoming CMB experiments and expectations for dark energy Carlo Baccigalupi Outline Classic dark energy effects on CMB Modern CMB relevance for dark energy: the promise of lensing Lensing (B modes)
More informationA Unified Description of Screened Modified Gravity
A Unified Description of Screened Modified Gravity Philippe Brax IPhT Saclay P.B,C. van de Bruck, A.C. Davis, B. Li, H. Winther, G. Zhao etc «Microscope» workshop, ONERA January 2013 Outline 1) Dark energy
More informationAn accurate determination of the Hubble constant from baryon acoustic oscillation datasets
. Article. SCIENCE CHINA Physics, Mechanics & Astronomy September 2015 Vol. 58 No. 9: 599801 doi: 10.1007/s11433-015-5684-5 An accurate determination of the Hubble constant from baryon acoustic oscillation
More informationUnderstanding the Properties of Dark Energy in the Universe p.1/37
Understanding the Properties of Dark Energy in the Universe Dragan Huterer Case Western Reserve University Understanding the Properties of Dark Energy in the Universe p.1/37 The Cosmic Food Pyramid?? Radiation
More informationProbing dark energy beyond z=2 with CODEX
Probing dark energy beyond z=2 with CODEX Pauline Eva Vielzeuf Centro de Astrofísica da Universidade do Porto February 26, 2013 Based on: P.E. Vielzeuf and C. J. A. P. Martins, Phys. Rev. D85, 087301 (2012)
More informationReally, really, what universe do we live in?
Really, really, what universe do we live in? Fluctuations in cosmic microwave background Origin Amplitude Spectrum Cosmic variance CMB observations and cosmological parameters COBE, balloons WMAP Parameters
More informationPlanck 2015 parameter constraints
Planck 2015 parameter constraints Antony Lewis On behalf of the Planck Collaboration http://cosmologist.info/ CMB temperature End of inflation Last scattering surface gravity+ pressure+ diffusion Observed
More informationSample variance in the local measurements of H 0. Heidi Wu (Caltech OSU) with Dragan Huterer (U. Michigan) arxiv: , MNRAS accepted
Sample variance in the al measurements of H 0 Heidi Wu (Caltech OSU) with Dragan Huterer (U. Michigan) arxiv:1706.09723, MNRAS accepted 1 Tension in H 0 measurements Beaton (2016); Freedman (2017) 2 H
More informationIntroduction to CosmoMC
Introduction to CosmoMC Part I: Motivation & Basic concepts Institut de Ciències del Cosmos - Universitat de Barcelona Dept. de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Universidad de Granada, 1-3 Marzo 2016 What
More informationDark Universe II. The shape of the Universe. The fate of the Universe. Old view: Density of the Universe determines its destiny
Dark Universe II Prof. Lynn Cominsky Dept. of Physics and Astronomy Sonoma State University Modifications by H. Geller November 2007 11/27/2007 Prof. Lynn Cominsky 2 Dark Energy and the Shape of the Universe
More informationNewtonian Gravity and Cosmology
Chapter 30 Newtonian Gravity and Cosmology The Universe is mostly empty space, which might suggest that a Newtonian description of gravity (which is valid in the weak gravity limit) is adequate for describing
More informationA FIGURE OF MERIT ANALYSIS OF CURRENT CONSTRAINTS ON TESTING GENERAL RELATIVITY USING THE LATEST COSMOLOGICAL DATA SETS.
A FIGURE OF MERIT ANALYSIS OF CURRENT CONSTRAINTS ON TESTING GENERAL RELATIVITY USING THE LATEST COSMOLOGICAL DATA SETS. Jason Dossett OUTLINE Motivations Ways to Test Gravity Growth Equations Modified
More informationCosmology: An Introduction. Eung Jin Chun
Cosmology: An Introduction Eung Jin Chun Cosmology Hot Big Bang + Inflation. Theory of the evolution of the Universe described by General relativity (spacetime) Thermodynamics, Particle/nuclear physics
More informationThe AfterMap Wayne Hu EFI, February 2003
The AfterMap Wayne Hu EFI, February 2003 Connections to the Past Outline What does MAP alone add to the cosmology? What role do other anisotropy experiments still have to play? How do you use the MAP analysis
More informationTesting Gravity Cosmologically
Testing Gravity Cosmologically Philippe Brax IPhT Saclay Asphon Toulouse March 2013 The Big Puzzle How do we know? measuring distances! Absolute luminosity. Received flux: what we see in the telescope
More informationMeasuring Neutrino Masses and Dark Energy
Huitzu Tu UC Irvine June 7, 2007 Dark Side of the Universe, Minnesota, June 5-10 2007 In collaboration with: Steen Hannestad, Yvonne Wong, Julien Lesgourgues, Laurence Perotto, Ariel Goobar, Edvard Mörtsell
More informationCosmology with the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Supernova Search. David Cinabro
Cosmology with the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Supernova Search David Cinabro Cosmology Background The study of the origin and evolution of the Universe. First real effort by Einstein in 1916 Gravity is all
More informationA5682: Introduction to Cosmology Course Notes. 11. CMB Anisotropy
Reading: Chapter 9, sections 9.4 and 9.5 11. CMB Anisotropy Gravitational instability and structure formation Today s universe shows structure on scales from individual galaxies to galaxy groups and clusters
More informationThe Hunt for Dark Energy
The Hunt for Dark Energy Peter Garnavich University of Notre Dame as imagination bodies forth astronomer s The forms of things unknown, the poet's pen Turns them to shapes and gives to airy nothing A local
More informationTesting gravity on cosmological scales with the observed abundance of massive clusters
Testing gravity on cosmological scales with the observed abundance of massive clusters David Rapetti, KIPAC (Stanford/SLAC) In collaboration with Steve Allen (KIPAC), Adam Mantz (KIPAC), Harald Ebeling
More informationEnergy and Matter in the Universe
Chapter 17 Energy and Matter in the Universe The history and fate of the Universe ultimately turn on how much matter, energy, and pressure it contains: 1. These components of the stress energy tensor all
More informationFirst Cosmology Results from Planck. Alessandro Melchiorri University of Rome La Sapienza On behalf of the Planck collaboration
First Cosmology Results from Planck Alessandro Melchiorri University of Rome La Sapienza On behalf of the Planck collaboration Planck Collaboration 300+ names Planck Core-Team (a fraction of it) Planck
More informationH 0 is Undervalued BAO CMB. Wayne Hu STSCI, April 2014 BICEP2? Maser Lensing Cepheids. SNIa TRGB SBF. dark energy. curvature. neutrinos. inflation?
H 0 is Undervalued BICEP2? 74 Maser Lensing Cepheids Eclipsing Binaries TRGB SBF SNIa dark energy curvature CMB BAO neutrinos inflation? Wayne Hu STSCI, April 2014 67 The 1% H 0 =New Physics H 0 : an end
More informationBaryon Acoustic Oscillations and Beyond: Galaxy Clustering as Dark Energy Probe
Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and Beyond: Galaxy Clustering as Dark Energy Probe Yun Wang Univ. of Oklahoma II Jayme Tiomno School of Cosmology August 6-10, 2012 Plan of the Lectures Lecture I: Overview
More information