arxiv: v1 [math.nt] 26 Feb 2014

Transcription

1 FROBENIUS NUMBERS OF PYTHAGOREAN TRIPLES BYUNG KEON GIL, JI-WOO HAN, TAE HYUN KIM, RYUN HAN KOO, BON WOO LEE, JAEHOON LEE, KYEONG SIK NAM, HYEON WOO PARK, AND POO-SUNG PARK arxiv: v1 [ath.nt] 26 Feb 2014 Abstract. Giverelativelyprieitegersa 1,...,a, thefrobeiusuberg(a 1,...,a ) is defied as the largest iteger which caot be expressed as x 1a 1 + +x a with x i oegative itegers. I this article, we give the Frobeius uber of priitive Pythagorea triples. That is, g( 2 2,2, ) = ( 1)( 2 2 )+( 1)(2) ( ). 1. Itroductio Thehistroy of Frobeius ubersgoes back to J. J. Sylvester. He proposedaproble to fid the largest uber for two relatively prie itegers a ad b which caot be expressed as ax+by with x ad y oegative itegers [6]. His aswer was ab a b. F. G. Frobeius ephasized this proble ad asked to study such a uber for ore tha two itegers. That is, give relatively prie itegers a 1,a 2,...,a, he asked to fid the largest iteger N = g(a 1,a 2,...,a ) for which a 1 x 1 + a 2 x a x = N has o oegative iteger solutios. The uber heceforth has bee called Frobeius uber. May atheaticias have studied Frobeius ubers ad foud soe algoriths to copute the, evertheless o oe foud a geeral exact forula. I actual, ulike Sylvester s elegat forula, there are o polyoial solutios for ore tha two itegers [1]. I geeral, it is NP-hard to fid the Frobeius ubers for the uber of give itegers [4]. So, lots of the studies have focused o specific sets of itegers. For exaple, forulas for arithetic progressios ad geoetric progressios were foud [5], [3]. The forula for Fiboacci ubers F i,f i+2,f i+k was foud [2]. I the preset article, we give a forula for priitive Pythagorea triples. This research was perfored as a progra of Istitute of the Gifted Educatio i Sciece of Kyuga uiversity. Correspodig author. This research was supported by Basic Sciece Research Progra through the Natioal Research Foudatio of Korea(NRF) fuded by the Miistry of Educatio(NRF-2013R1A1A ). This research was partially supported by Istitute of the Gifted Educatio i Sciece of Kyuga Uiversity. 1

2 2 GIL, HAN, KIM, KOO, LEE, LEE, NAM, PARK, AND PARK 2. Mai result We have that ( 2 2,2, ) is a priitive Pythagorea triple if two itegers > are realtively prie ad have opposite parity. Theore. The Frobeius uber for a Pythagorea triple is For coveiece, let g( 2 2,2, ) = ( 1)( 2 2 )+( 1)(2) ( ). A = ( 1)( 2 2 )+( 1)(2) ( ) = ( ). First, we prove that g( 2 2,2, ) A. To do this, we show that A caot be expresssed by 2 2, 2, ad Suppose that there exist oegative itegers x, y, ad z satisfyig (*) x( 2 2 )+y(2)+z( ) = A. Dividig both sides by, we obtai that ( x+z) 2 0 (od ). Sice ad are relatively prie, we ca set z = x+k. Plug it ito the above expressio ad divide by. The k 2 +2x+2y+k 2 = k( )+2(x+y) = ( 2 2 )+2( ) ad we ca coclude that k is odd sice ad 2 2 are both odd. Settig k = 2l+1, we obtai If l 0, the l 2 +l 2 +x+y+ 2 =. (l+x)+(l+y +) =, but this is absurd because g(,) = by Sylvester. It follows that l 1. Set l = l 1 0. Chagig roles of x ad z, pluggig x = z k ito the above expressio (*) yields k( 2 2 )+y(2)+z(2 2 ) = ( ). Divide both sides by ad rearrage. k( 2 2 )+y(2)+z(2) = Usig k = 2l+1 = 2( l 1)+1 = 2l 1, we ca write l (+)( )+y+z = ( l ( )+z ) + ( l ( )+y ) =.

3 FROBENIUS NUMBERS OF PYTHAGOREAN TRIPLES 3 This is also absurd. So it was proved that g( 2 2,2, ) ( 1)( 2 2 )+( 1)(2) ( ). Now, we prove that g( 2 2,2, ) A. That is, we show that every iteger greater tha A is expressed as x( 2 2 )+y(2)+z( ) with x,y,z 0. To do this, we eed a lea. Lea. For a fixed [ positive ] iteger b, we defie y to be the sallest positive iteger such that the iterval b+y, y cotais a iteger, ad we also defie x to be the sallest iteger cotaied. The, the iequality holds. (y+x)( 2 2 ) A+( 2 2 )+b(2) Proof. The existece of y is guarateed fro < 1 <. Fro the coditio, if y = 0, the x ad b also vaish. Thus the iequlity holds for y = 0 trivially. Let us cosider whe y 1. We have that x 1 < b+y fro the iiality of x. Also, b+(y 1) = b+y > b+y 1 > x 2. We divide two cases accordig to copariso of x 1 ad b+(y 1). Case 1: x 1 < b+(y 1) < x. Note that (1-1) (x 1)+1 = x +1 b+(y 1) = b+y. If x (y 1) (y 1) < x or, the b+(y 1) < x (y 1) ad it cotradicts the iiality of y. Thus, (1-2) (y 1)+1 = y +1 x. Cobiig the above two iequalities (1-1) ad (1-2), we obtai (x +1+ b) y (x+ 1). This iequality yields a ew boud for x. That is, (1-3) x 2 +b 2 2.

4 4 GIL, HAN, KIM, KOO, LEE, LEE, NAM, PARK, AND PARK Now, we ca coclude that (y+x)( 2 2 ) (x+ 1+x)( 2 2 ) by (1-2) ( ) 2 2 +b ( 2 2 ) by (1-3) = b(2)+( 2 2 )+( 1)(2) ( ) = A+( 2 2 )+b(2). Case 2: x 2 < b+(y 1) < x 1. We already verified that x 1 < b+y at the start of the proof. Thus, (2-1) x +1 b+y. If x 1 (y 1), the b+(y 1) x 1 (y 1) < x 1 or Thus (y 1) ad it cotradict the iiality of y. (2-2) (y 1)+1 = y +1 (x 1) = x. Fro the above two iequalities (2-1) ad (2-2), ad thus (x +1 b) y (x + 1) (2-3) x 1+ +b 2 2. The, (y+x)( 2 2 ) (x+ 1+x)( 2 2 ) by (2-2) ( 2 +b ) ( 2 2 ) by (2-3) = b(2)+( 2 2 )+( 1)(2) ( ) = A+( 2 2 )+b(2). Hece, the proof of Lea was copleted. Let us resue the proof of Theore. Let k be a arbitrary positive iteger. We ca choose two positive itegers a ad b such that If a is chose to be egative, cosider for sufficietly large t. a( 2 2 ) b(2) = A+k. (a+2t)( 2 2 ) ( b+( 2 2 )t ) (2) = A+k

5 FROBENIUS NUMBERS OF PYTHAGOREAN TRIPLES 5 Recall x ad y i Lea. Fro b+y x y, If a+1 y+x, the b+x y 0 ad y x 0. 1 k = a( 2 2 ) b(2) A (y+x 1)( 2 2 ) b(2) A = (y+x)( 2 2 ) ( 2 2 ) b(2) A A+( 2 2 )+b(2) ( 2 2 ) b(2) A = 0. by Lea This cotradictio yields y+x a. Theferefore, A+k = a( 2 2 )+( b)(2) = (a y x)( 2 2 ) +( b+x y)(2) +(y x)( ) ad a y x 0, b+x y 0, y x 0. We coclude that g( 2 2,2, ) = A. Ackowledgeet The authors would like to thak professor Byugcha Ki for readig this article ad for his helpful coets. Refereces [1] F. Curtis, O forulas for the Frobeius uber of a uerical seigroup, Math. Scad. 67 (1990), o. 2, [2] J.M. Marí, J. L. Raíres Alfosí, M.P. Revuelta, O the Frobeius uber of Fiboacci uerical seigroups, Itegers 7(1) (2007) o. A14, 1 7. [3] D. C. Og ad V. Pooareko, The Frobeius Nuber of Geoetric Sequeces, Itegers 8 (2008) o. A33, 1 3. [4] J. L. Raírez Alfosí, Coplexity of the Frobeius proble, Cobiatorica 16 (1996), o. 1, [5] J. B. Roberts, Note o liear fors, Proc. Aer. Math. Soc. 7 (1956), [6] J. J. Sylvester, Proble 7382, Educatioal Ties, 37, 1884, 26; reprited i Matheatical questios with their solutio, with additioal papers ad solutios, Educatioal Ties, 41, 1884, 21.

6 6 GIL, HAN, KIM, KOO, LEE, LEE, NAM, PARK, AND PARK (Byug Keo Gil) Naedog Middle School, Republic of Korea E-ail address: (Ji-woo Ha) Gyeoggi Sciece High School for the Gifted, Republic of Korea E-ail address: (Tae Hyu Ki) Dog Middle School, Republic of Korea E-ail address: (Ryu Ha Koo) Uga Middle School, Republic of Korea E-ail address: (Bo Woo Lee) Daegu Sciece High School, Republic of Korea E-ail address: (Jaehoo Lee) Departet of Matheatics, Uiversity of Califoria, Los Ageles, Uited States of Aerica E-ail address: (Kyeog Sik Na) Departet of Matheatics, Seoul Natioal Uiversity, Republic of Korea E-ail address: (Hyeo Woo Park) Daebag Middle School, Republic of Korea E-ail address: (Poo-Sug Park) Departet of Matheatics Educatio, Kyuga Uiversity, Republic of Korea E-ail address, Correspodig author: