Chiral dynamics and NN potential
|
|
- Shavonne Haynes
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Chiral dynamics and NN potential Department of Physics University of Bologna Bologna (Italy) Otranto Summer School
2 1935 Yukawa: Meson Theory The Pion Theories 1950 s One-Pion Exchange: o.k. Multi-Pion Exchange: disaster Many pions multi-pion resonances: 1960 s σ, ρ, ω,... The One-Boson-Exchange Model: success Refined meson models, including 1970 s sophisticated 2π exchange contributions (Stony Brook, Paris, Bonn) Nuclear physicists discover 1980 s QCD (Quark Cluster Models) Nuclear physicists discover EFT 1990 s Weinberg, van Kolck and beyond Back to Pion Theory! but constrained by Chiral Symmetry: success! [From R. Machleidt arxiv: v1 nucl-th]
3 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) EFTs are low-energy approximations to (more) fundamental theories. Instead of solving the underlying theory, the low-energy physics is described with a set of variables (effective degrees of freedom) that is suited for the particular energy region you are interested in.
4 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) EFTs are low-energy approximations to (more) fundamental theories. Instead of solving the underlying theory, the low-energy physics is described with a set of variables (effective degrees of freedom) that is suited for the particular energy region you are interested in.
5 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) EFTs are low-energy approximations to (more) fundamental theories. Instead of solving the underlying theory, the low-energy physics is described with a set of variables (effective degrees of freedom) that is suited for the particular energy region you are interested in. [Adapted from R. J. Furnstahl]
6 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) EFTs are low-energy approximations to (more) fundamental theories. Instead of solving the underlying theory, the low-energy physics is described with a set of variables (effective degrees of freedom) that is suited for the particular energy region you are interested in. [Adapted from R. J. Furnstahl]
7 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) There exists a regime where both fundamental and effective theories yeld the same results. How to make sure EFT is not just a phenomenology? EFT must observe all relevant symmetries of the underlying theory. EFTs are based on the the most general Lagrangian which includes all terms that are compatible with the symmetries of the underlying theory. Infinite number of terms and each term is accompanied by a low-energy coupling constant (LEC).
8 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) There exists a regime where both fundamental and effective theories yeld the same results. How to make sure EFT is not just a phenomenology? EFT must observe all relevant symmetries of the underlying theory. EFTs are based on the the most general Lagrangian which includes all terms that are compatible with the symmetries of the underlying theory. Infinite number of terms and each term is accompanied by a low-energy coupling constant (LEC).
9 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) There exists a regime where both fundamental and effective theories yeld the same results. How to make sure EFT is not just a phenomenology? EFT must observe all relevant symmetries of the underlying theory. EFTs are based on the the most general Lagrangian which includes all terms that are compatible with the symmetries of the underlying theory. Infinite number of terms and each term is accompanied by a low-energy coupling constant (LEC).
10 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) There exists a regime where both fundamental and effective theories yeld the same results. How to make sure EFT is not just a phenomenology? EFT must observe all relevant symmetries of the underlying theory. EFTs are based on the the most general Lagrangian which includes all terms that are compatible with the symmetries of the underlying theory. Infinite number of terms and each term is accompanied by a low-energy coupling constant (LEC).
11 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) With an infinite number of terms I need a computational scheme: Weinberg s power counting. Physical quantities are calculated in terms of an expansion in p/λ where p stands for momenta or masses that are smaller than a certain momentum scale Λ. In practical calculations only a finite number of terms in the expansion in p/λ has to be considered Predictions. Effective field theories are non-renormalizable in the traditional sense. However, as long as one considers all terms that are allowed by the symmetries, divergencies that occur in calculations up to any given order of p/λ can be renormalized by redefining fields and parameters (LEC) of the EFT Lagrangian.
12 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) With an infinite number of terms I need a computational scheme: Weinberg s power counting. Physical quantities are calculated in terms of an expansion in p/λ where p stands for momenta or masses that are smaller than a certain momentum scale Λ. In practical calculations only a finite number of terms in the expansion in p/λ has to be considered Predictions. Effective field theories are non-renormalizable in the traditional sense. However, as long as one considers all terms that are allowed by the symmetries, divergencies that occur in calculations up to any given order of p/λ can be renormalized by redefining fields and parameters (LEC) of the EFT Lagrangian.
13 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) With an infinite number of terms I need a computational scheme: Weinberg s power counting. Physical quantities are calculated in terms of an expansion in p/λ where p stands for momenta or masses that are smaller than a certain momentum scale Λ. In practical calculations only a finite number of terms in the expansion in p/λ has to be considered Predictions. Effective field theories are non-renormalizable in the traditional sense. However, as long as one considers all terms that are allowed by the symmetries, divergencies that occur in calculations up to any given order of p/λ can be renormalized by redefining fields and parameters (LEC) of the EFT Lagrangian.
14 Definition of Effective Field Theories (EFT) With an infinite number of terms I need a computational scheme: Weinberg s power counting. Physical quantities are calculated in terms of an expansion in p/λ where p stands for momenta or masses that are smaller than a certain momentum scale Λ. In practical calculations only a finite number of terms in the expansion in p/λ has to be considered Predictions. Effective field theories are non-renormalizable in the traditional sense. However, as long as one considers all terms that are allowed by the symmetries, divergencies that occur in calculations up to any given order of p/λ can be renormalized by redefining fields and parameters (LEC) of the EFT Lagrangian.
15 EFT: the most important constrains Symmetry exploited in EFT all the symmetries of QCD (not just the Lorentz one) are accounted for Renormalizability relaxed completely in EFT infinite # of parameters not an issue, if only finite # relevant in the range of validity
16 EFT: non-renormalizable non-feasible Effective Field Theory needs some organizing principle L eff = n L (n) for any n the higher is the n non-renormalization L (n) should contain finite # of terms the less important should L (n) be may require higher and higher n...but they will be less and less important
17 Weinberg theorem If one writes down the most general possible Lagrangian, including all terms consistent with assumed symmetry principles, and then calculates matrix elements with this Lagrangian to any given order of perturbation theory, the result will simply be the most general possible S-matrix consistent with analyticity, perturbative unitarity, cluster decomposition and the assumed symmetry principles. [S. Weinberg, Physica A 96 (1979) 327]
18 Weinberg theorem If one writes down the most general possible Lagrangian, including all terms consistent with assumed symmetry principles, and then calculates matrix elements with this Lagrangian to any given order of perturbation theory, the result will simply be the most general possible S-matrix consistent with analyticity, perturbative unitarity, cluster decomposition and the assumed symmetry principles. [S. Weinberg, Physica A 96 (1979) 327] causality [Zuber and Itzykson, Quantum Field Theory, sec ]
19 Weinberg theorem If one writes down the most general possible Lagrangian, including all terms consistent with assumed symmetry principles, and then calculates matrix elements with this Lagrangian to any given order of perturbation theory, the result will simply be the most general possible S-matrix consistent with analyticity, perturbative unitarity, cluster decomposition and the assumed symmetry principles. [S. Weinberg, Physica A 96 (1979) 327] the sum over the probabilities of the final states must yeld: f S i 2 = 1 f
20 Weinberg theorem If one writes down the most general possible Lagrangian, including all terms consistent with assumed symmetry principles, and then calculates matrix elements with this Lagrangian to any given order of perturbation theory, the result will simply be the most general possible S-matrix consistent with analyticity, perturbative unitarity, cluster decomposition and the assumed symmetry principles. [S. Weinberg, Physica A 96 (1979) 327] distant experiments must yeld uncorrelated results: S γ+δ α+β S δ β S γ α
21 Weinberg theorem If one writes down the most general possible Lagrangian, including all terms consistent with assumed symmetry principles, and then calculates matrix elements with this Lagrangian to any given order of perturbation theory, the result will simply be the most general possible S-matrix consistent with analyticity, perturbative unitarity, cluster decomposition and the assumed symmetry principles. [S. Weinberg, Physica A 96 (1979) 327] Everything: Poincaré, discrete (CPT) and internal (isospin and chiral) symmetries. The possibility of a spontaneous symmetry breakdown must be included.
22 EFT step by step for nuclear physicists Identify the degrees of freedom relevant at the resolution scale of (low-energy) nuclear physics: nucleons and pions.
23 EFT step by step for nuclear physicists Identify the degrees of freedom relevant at the resolution scale of (low-energy) nuclear physics: nucleons and pions.
24 EFT step by step for nuclear physicists Identify the degrees of freedom relevant at the resolution scale of (low-energy) nuclear physics: nucleons and pions. Identify the relevant symmetries of low-energy QCD and investigate if and how they are broken (chiral symmetry). Construct the most general Lagrangian consistent with those symmetries and the symmetry breaking (L χ ). Design an organizational scheme that can distinguish between more and less important contributions: a low-momentum expansion (Weinberg s power counting). Guided by the expansion, calculate Feynman diagrams to the the desired accuracy for the problem under consideration. [From R. Machleidt arxiv: v1 nucl-th]
25 EFT step by step for nuclear physicists Identify the degrees of freedom relevant at the resolution scale of (low-energy) nuclear physics: nucleons and pions. Identify the relevant symmetries of low-energy QCD and investigate if and how they are broken (chiral symmetry). Construct the most general Lagrangian consistent with those symmetries and the symmetry breaking (L χ ). Design an organizational scheme that can distinguish between more and less important contributions: a low-momentum expansion (Weinberg s power counting). Guided by the expansion, calculate Feynman diagrams to the the desired accuracy for the problem under consideration. [From R. Machleidt arxiv: v1 nucl-th]
26 EFT step by step for nuclear physicists Identify the degrees of freedom relevant at the resolution scale of (low-energy) nuclear physics: nucleons and pions. Identify the relevant symmetries of low-energy QCD and investigate if and how they are broken (chiral symmetry). Construct the most general Lagrangian consistent with those symmetries and the symmetry breaking (L χ ). Design an organizational scheme that can distinguish between more and less important contributions: a low-momentum expansion (Weinberg s power counting). Guided by the expansion, calculate Feynman diagrams to the the desired accuracy for the problem under consideration. [From R. Machleidt arxiv: v1 nucl-th]
27 EFT step by step for nuclear physicists Identify the degrees of freedom relevant at the resolution scale of (low-energy) nuclear physics: nucleons and pions. Identify the relevant symmetries of low-energy QCD and investigate if and how they are broken (chiral symmetry). Construct the most general Lagrangian consistent with those symmetries and the symmetry breaking (L χ ). Design an organizational scheme that can distinguish between more and less important contributions: a low-momentum expansion (Weinberg s power counting). Guided by the expansion, calculate Feynman diagrams to the the desired accuracy for the problem under consideration. [From R. Machleidt arxiv: v1 nucl-th]
28 Bibliography S. Weinberg, The quantum theory of fields, Vol. II. V. Bernard, N. Kaiser and U.-G. Meissner [hep-ph/ ] E. Epelbaum, [nucl-th/ ] S. Scherer and M. R. Schindler [hep-ph/ ]
29 Chiral Symmetry What is chirality? The structural characteristic of a finite system (molecule, atom, particle) that makes it impossible to superimpose it on its mirror image. Any object that is different from its reflection is said to be chiral. Your left hand and your right hand are distinct chiral objects.
30 Notes on chiral symmetry Starting point L QCD = q(iγ µ D µ M)q 1 4 G µν,ag µν a considering m u = m d = 0 L QCD = L heavy (s,c,b,t) + L u,d defining right- and left-handed quark fields q R = P R q, q L = P L q, with P R = 1 2 (1 + γ 5), P L = 1 2 (1 γ 5), right- and left-handed components are decoupled L u,d = L ur,d R + L ul,d L
31 Notes on chiral symmetry defining right- and left-handed quark fields q R = P R q, q L = P L q, with P R = 1 2 (1 + γ 5), P L = 1 2 (1 γ 5), right- and left-handed components are decoupled L u,d = L ur,d R + L ul,d L
32 Notes on chiral symmetry (continues..) in fact L QCD = q R iγ µ D µ q R + q L iγ µ D µ q L 1 4 G µν,ag µν a. L QCD is now invariant under q L q L = exp( i τ j 2 Θj L )q L {j = 1, 3} q R q R = exp( i τ j 2 Θj R )q R where τ j are Pauli matrices (generators of the SU(2) group) and Θ j R,L arbitrary parameters. SU(2) R SU(2) L symmetry is called Chiral Symmetry. [see Volker Koch, nucl-th/ , pags. 8-9]
33 Noether theorem To each element j of a continuos symmetry a current J µ j is conserved µ J µ j = 0 and a charge Q j = d 3 x J 0 j (t, x) is a constant of motion, i.e. is time independent in case of SU(2) R SU(2) L we have 6 conserved 4-currents: 6 charges R 0 i, L0 i R µ j = q R γ µ τ j 2 q R j = 1, 3 L µ j = q L γ µ τ j 2 q L constants of motion. [see Scherer, hep-ph/ , pags.11-18, Gell-Mann and Lévy, Nuovo Cim. 16 (1960) 705]
34 ...some manipulations 3 vector currents V µ i 3 axial vector currents = R µ i + Lµ i = qγµ τ i 2 q µv µ i = 0 A µ i = Rµ i Lµ i = qγµ γ 5 τ i 2 q µa µ i = 0, now the symmetry group is SU(2) V SU(2) A. q q = exp( i τ j q q = exp( i τ j 2 Θj V 2 γ 5Θ j A )q )q {j = 1, 3} SU(2) V mixes states with different isospin (u and d flavor) SU(2) A mixes states with different parity [see Scherer, hep-ph/ , pags.19,20]
35 with an explicit chiral symmetry breaking term... the mass term qm q breaks chiral symmetry M = ( mu 0 0 m d = 1 2 (m u + m d ) ) ( = 1 2 (m u + m d ) I (m u m d ) τ 3. ) + 1 ( (m u m d ) 0 1 )
36 with an explicit chiral symmetry breaking term... the mass term qmq breaks chiral symmetry M = ( mu 0 0 m d = 1 2 (m u + m d ) ) ( = 1 2 (m u + m d ) I (m u m d ) τ 3. ) + 1 ( (m u m d ) 0 1 )
37 with an explicit chiral symmetry breaking term... the mass term qmq breaks chiral symmetry M = ( mu 0 0 m d = 1 2 (m u + m d ) ) ( = 1 2 (m u + m d ) I (m u m d ) τ 3. ) + 1 ( (m u m d ) 0 1 ) The first term in the last equation in invariant under SU(2) V (isospin symmetry)
38 with an explicit chiral symmetry breaking term... the mass term qmq breaks chiral symmetry M = ( mu 0 0 m d = 1 2 (m u + m d ) ) ( = 1 2 (m u + m d ) I (m u m d ) τ 3. ) + 1 ( (m u m d ) 0 1 ) The first term in the last equation in invariant under SU(2) V (isospin symmetry) and the second term vanishes for m u = m d. Thus, isospin is an exact symmetry if m u = m d.
39 with an explicit chiral symmetry breaking term... the mass term qmq breaks chiral symmetry M = ( mu 0 0 m d = 1 2 (m u + m d ) ) ( = 1 2 (m u + m d ) I (m u m d ) τ 3. ) + 1 ( (m u m d ) 0 1 ) The first term in the last equation in invariant under SU(2) V (isospin symmetry) and the second term vanishes for m u = m d. Thus, isospin is an exact symmetry if m u = m d. However, both terms break SU(2) A. Since the up and down quark masses are small the explicit chiral symmetry breaking is very small.
40 ...but [H, Q] = 0 H 0 = 0 Q V 0 = Q A 0 = 0 isospin-multiplets and parity-multiplets are degenerate Å Å Î ¾¼¼¼ ½ ¼¼ ½ ¼¼ ½ ¼¼ ½ ¼¼ ½ ¼¼ ½ ¼¼ ½ ¼¼ ½¾¼¼ ½½¼¼ ½¼¼¼ ¼¼ ½ ¾ ½ ¾ ¾ Æ ¾ ¾ ¾ ½ ¾ ½ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ [From Cohen and Glozman: the low lying N and experimental spectra] ¾ ¾ chiral symmetry breaking is not small SU(2) R SU(2) L is broken at the level of the ground-state.
41 Vector and axial vector mesons Isospin symmetry SU(2) V is respected (π +, π, π 0 have approximately the same mass) If axial symmetry is respected ρ ρ + Θ a 1 isovector dipole and axial dipole excitations must have the same mass [M.Barate et al. (ALEPH): Eur. Phys. J. C4 (1998) 409; ) K. Ackerstaff et al. (OPAL): Eur. Phys. J. C7 (1999) 571; sum rule analysis: E. Marco et al. : Phys. Lett. B 482 (2000) 87 ]
42 Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking (SSB) O(3) Model Having in mind the smallness of the u- and d- quark masses, one naturally expects that an approximate chiral symmetry manifests itself in the observable properties of hadrons...but it does not happen! (...only the isospin symmetry SU(2) V is respected) Any solution? When a Lagrangian density L is invariant with respect to a set of transformations (SU(2) V SU(2) A in our case), two situations can occur: Wigner-Weyl mode, where ground-state has the same symmetry of L Nambu-Goldstone mode, where the ground-state does not respect the symmetry of the system
43 Goldstone Theorem To each generator that does not annihilate the ground state exists a massless boson degree of freedom. [J. Goldstone, A. Salam and S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. 127 (1962) 965] H 0 QCD is invariant under SU(2) L SU(2) R φ 0 is invariant under SU(2) V 3 massless Goldstone bosons. If Q A 0 0, then there must be a set of physical states φ A = Q A 0 which are energetically degenerate H φ A = HQ A 0 = Q A H 0 since Q A represents axial charges, the states φ A must represent a triplet of pseudoscalar mesons Guess: Pions (π +, π 0, π )?
44 Pions Pions are degenerate but not massless (m π 135 MeV) because the up and down quark masses are not exactly zero either (explicit symmetry breaking) δl = ψmψ ψψ = ψ R ψ L + ψ L ψ R Pions reflect spontaneous as well as explicit symmetry breaking
45 Chiral Lagrangian The relevant degrees of freedom are pions (Goldstone bosons) and nucleons. Interactions of Goldstone bosons must vanish at zero momentum transfer and in the chiral limit (m π 0) the low-energy expansion of the Lagrangian is arranged in powers of derivatives and pion masses. with L eff = L ππ + L πn + L NN L ππ = L (2) ππ + L (4) ππ +... L πn = L (1) πn + L(2) πn + L(3) πn +... L NN = L (2) NN + L(4) NN +... [S. Coleman, J. Wess, and B. Zumino, Phys. Rev. 177 (1969) 2239 and 2247]
46 Chiral Lagrangian L ππ Pions are represented by a 2 2 SU(2) matrix field U(x) U(x) = exp[iτ a φ a (x)] φ a = π a /f with the pion decay constant f in the chiral limit as normalisation. Write an effective Lagrangian for the field U(x) and its derivatives L QCD L eff (U, U, 2 U,...) Goldstone bosons can only interact when they carry momentum low-energy expansion in powers of µ U Lorentz invariance only an even numbers of derivatives
47 Chiral Lagrangian L ππ Transformation behaviour under SU(2) L SU(2) R for the U field U RUL U LU R and for its derivatives µ U µ U µ (RUL ) = µ RUL +R µ UL +RU µ L = R µ UL µ U L µ U R The most general chirally invariant L with the minimal number of derivatives is L (2) ππ = f 2 4 T r[ µu µ U ] [see Scherer, hep-ph/ , pags.63...and also V. Koch, nucl-th/ ]
48 Chiral Lagrangian L ππ in fact L (2) ππ f 2 4 T r[r µul L µ U R ] = f 2 4 T r[r R µ U µ U ] = L (2) ππ The symmetry breaking mass term is small, so that it can be handled perturbatively. The leading contribution in the quark mass matrix M is: where L (2) = f 2 4 T r[ µu µ U] + f 2 ( ) mu 0 M = 0 m d ; 2 B 0 T r[mu + M U]. { M RML M LM R
49 Chiral Lagrangian L ππ Expanding L (2) ππ L (2) ππ = (m u +m d )f 2 B µπ a µ π a 1 2 (m u +m d )B 0 π 2 a +...
50 Chiral Lagrangian L ππ Expanding L (2) ππ L (2) ππ = (m u +m d )f 2 B µπ a µ π a 1 2 (m u +m d )B 0 π 2 a +... The first (constant) term corresponds to the shift of the vacuum energy density by the non-zero quark masses (m u ūu + m d dd ) = (m u + m d )f 2 B 0 where ūu = dd = f 2 B 0 in the chiral limit V(σ, π=0) V(σ, π=0) f π σ fπ σ [From V. Koch (Potential of linear sigma model without (left) and with (right) explicit symmetry breaking)]
51 Chiral Lagrangian L ππ Expanding L (2) ππ L (2) ππ = (m u +m d )f 2 B µπ a µ π a 1 2 (m u +m d )B 0 π 2 a +... The first (constant) term corresponds to the shift of the vacuum energy density by the non-zero quark masses (m u ūu + m d dd ) = (m u + m d )f 2 B 0 where ūu = dd = f 2 B 0 in the chiral limit The pion mass term is m 2 π = (m u + m d )B 0 from which we have the GOR relation m 2 π f 2 π = (m u + m d ) qq + O(m 2 u,d ) [M. Gell-Mann, R. Oakes and B. Renner, Phys. Rev. 122 (1968) 2195]
52 Chiral Lagrangian L πn At leading order where L (1) πn = ψ ( ) i /D M (0) N + g 2 γµ γ 5 u µ ψ }{{} axial coupling /D = µ + Γ µ Γ µ = (u µ u + u µ u )/2 = iτ (π µ π)/4f 2 }{{} +O(π4 ) W einberg T omozawa u µ = i(u µ u u µ u ) = τ µ π/f + O(π 3 ) u = U = 1 + iτ π/2 + O(π 2 ) with g πnn = (M N /f)g = 13.1
53 Chiral Lagrangian L πn At leading order where L (1) πn = ψ ( ) i /D M (0) N + g 2 γµ γ 5 u µ ψ }{{} axial coupling /D = µ + Γ µ Γ µ = (u µ u + u µ u )/2 = iτ (π µ π)/4f 2 }{{} +O(π4 ) W einberg T omozawa u µ = i(u µ u u µ u ) = τ µ π/f + O(π 3 ) u = U = 1 + iτ π/2 + O(π 2 ) with g πnn = (M N /f)g = 13.1
54 Chiral Lagrangian L πn Invariance under SU(2) L SU(2) R very lengthy [see J. Gasser, M. E. Sainio and A. Švarc, Nucl. Phys. B 307 (1988) 779] The nucleon mass M N in the chiral limit does not vanish a dimensional scale to be taken in account. A solution (not the only one): Heavy Baryon expansion where the Lagrangian is expanded in powers of 1/M N [ L (1) πn = N i 0 1 4fπ 2 τ (π 0 π) g ] A τ ( σ 2f )π N+... π [E. Jenkins and A. V. Manohar, Phys. Lett. B 255 (1991) 558] At next-to-leading order the symmetry breaking term enters M N = M (0) N + σ N L (2) πn =... + σ N ψψπ 2 2fπ 2
55 Chiral Lagrangian L πn In general the Lagrangians must contain all terms consistent with chiral symmetry and Lorentz invariance. The parameters c i are the low-energy constants (LECs). 2 nd order L (2) πn = 4 i=1 (2) c i ΨO i Ψ 4 c i parameters to be determined from fits to πn data 3 rd order L (3) 23 πn = (3) d i ΨO i Ψ i=1 23 d i parameters to be determined (not all relevant for the NN potential) [Operators: Fettes et al., Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 283 (2000) 283; 288 (2001) 249; Nucl. Phys. A 640 (1998) 199]
56 Chiral Lagrangian L NN Nucleon contact interactions consist of four nucleon fields to renormalize loop integrals to make results reasonably independent of regulators to parametrize the unresolved short-distance contributions Because of parity only even numbers of derivatives L NN = L (0) NN + L(2) NN + L(4) NN +... L (0) NN = 1 2 C S NN NN 1 2 C T L (2) 14 NN = C i NÕ (2) i N i=1 N σn N σn where LECs are determined by a fit to the NN data.
57 Power counting contributions in terms of powers of (Q/Λ χ ) ν, Power counting: the power ν at which a given diagram contributes for an irreducible NN diagram (A = 2) ν = 2L + i i where L is the number of loops and i = d i + n i 2 2 ν is bounded from below; e.g., for A = 2, ν 0. [see for the general case R. Machleidt arxiv: v1 nucl-th]
58 Power counting for an irreducible NN diagram (A = 2) ν = 2L + i i where L is the number of loops and i = d i + n i 2 2 At leading order [LO, O(Q 0 ), ν = 0]: 2 contact terms the static 1π exchange no contributions at order O(Q 1 )
59 Power counting for an irreducible NN diagram (A = 2) ν = 2L + i i where L is the number of loops and i = d i + n i 2 2 At leading order [LO, O(Q 0 ), ν = 0]: 2 contact terms the static 1π exchange no contributions at order O(Q 1 )
60 Power counting for an irreducible NN diagram (A = 2) ν = 2L + i i where L is the number of loops and i = d i + n i 2 2 The first graph with four nucleon legs and a solid square represent the seven contact terms of O(Q 2 ). All 2π exchange diagrams.
61 Nuclear Force hyerarchy Q 0 LO Q 2 NLO 2N Force 3N Force 4N Force generation of many body forces estimates of missing terms Q 3 NNLO Q 4 3 N LO For high precision potentials (χ 2 1) go to N 3 LO
62 Nuclear Force hyerarchy Q 0 LO Q 2 NLO 2N Force 3N Force 4N Force generation of many body forces estimates of missing terms Q 3 NNLO Q 4 3 N LO For high precision potentials (χ 2 1) go to N 3 LO
63 Nuclear Force hyerarchy Q 0 LO Q 2 NLO 2N Force 3N Force 4N Force generation of many body forces estimates of missing terms Q 3 NNLO Q 4 3 N LO For high precision potentials (χ 2 1) go to N 3 LO
64 Nuclear Force hyerarchy Q 0 LO Q 2 NLO 2N Force 3N Force 4N Force generation of many body forces estimates of missing terms Q 3 NNLO Q 4 3 N LO For high precision potentials (χ 2 1) go to N 3 LO
65 Strategy Following Weinberg: use perturbation theory to calculate the N N potential and to apply this potential in a scattering equation to obtain the NN amplitude [S. Weinberg, Phys. Lett. B 251 (1990) 288; 295 (1992) 114; Nucl. Phys. B 363 (1991) 3] Derive the N N potential perturbatively pion-exchange contribution contact terms contribution T-matrix derivation Partial wave analysis
66 π-exchange contributions Momentum-space N N potential in the center-of-mass system V ( p, p) = V C + τ 1 τ 2 W C + [ V S + τ 1 τ 2 W S ] σ 1 σ 2 ( + [ V LS + τ 1 τ 2 W LS ] is ( q ) k) + [ V T + τ 1 τ 2 W T ] σ 1 q σ 2 q + [ V σl + τ 1 τ 2 W σl ] σ 1 ( q k ) σ 2 ( q k ),
67 π-exchange contributions Momentum-space N N potential in the center-of-mass system V ( p, p) = V C + τ 1 τ 2 W C + [ V S + τ 1 τ 2 W S ] σ 1 σ 2 ( + [ V LS + τ 1 τ 2 W LS ] is ( q ) k) + [ V T + τ 1 τ 2 W T ] σ 1 q σ 2 q + [ V σl + τ 1 τ 2 W σl ] σ 1 ( q k ) σ 2 ( q k ), V i represents isoscalar contributions
68 π-exchange contributions Momentum-space N N potential in the center-of-mass system V ( p, p) = V C + τ 1 τ 2 W C + [ V S + τ 1 τ 2 W S ] σ 1 σ 2 ( + [ V LS + τ 1 τ 2 W LS ] is ( q ) k) + [ V T + τ 1 τ 2 W T ] σ 1 q σ 2 q + [ V σl + τ 1 τ 2 W σl ] σ 1 ( q k ) σ 2 ( q k ), V i represents isoscalar contributions W i represents isovector contributions
69 π-exchange contributions Momentum-space N N potential in the center-of-mass system V ( p, p) = V C + τ 1 τ 2 W C + [ V S + τ 1 τ 2 W S ] σ 1 σ 2 ( + [ V LS + τ 1 τ 2 W LS ] is ( q ) k) + [ V T + τ 1 τ 2 W T ] σ 1 q σ 2 q + [ V σl + τ 1 τ 2 W σl ] σ 1 ( q k ) σ 2 ( q k ), q p p is the momentum transfer k 1 2 ( p + p) is the average momentum S 1 2 ( σ 1 + σ 2 ) is the total spin
70 π-exchange contributions Momentum-space N N potential in the center-of-mass system V ( p, p) = V C + τ 1 τ 2 W C + [ V S + τ 1 τ 2 W S ] σ 1 σ 2 ( + [ V LS + τ 1 τ 2 W LS ] is ( q ) k) + [ V T + τ 1 τ 2 W T ] σ 1 q σ 2 q + [ V σl + τ 1 τ 2 W σl ] σ 1 ( q k ) σ 2 ( q k ), Dimensional regularization typically generates also polynomial and nonpolynomial terms. The polynomials will be absorbed by the contact interactions.
71 π-exchange contributions At leading order [O(Q 0 )] the static one-pion exchange V 1π ( p, p) = g2 A σ 1 q σ 2 q 4fπ 2 τ 1 τ 2 q 2 + m 2. 1π exchange π At second order (ν = 2, NLO) 1π iterated (no iterative contributions) W C = L(q) [ 4m 2 384π 2 fπ 4 π (5gA 4 4gA 2 1) + q 2 (23gA 4 10gA 2 1) ] + 48g4 A m4 π w 2, V T = 1 q 2 V S = 3g4 A L(q) 64π 2 f 4 π where L(q) w q ln w+q 2m π and w 4m 2 π + q 2,
72 π-exchange contributions insertions from L (2) πn rel. 1/M N corrections [D. R. Entem and R. Machleidt, Phys. Rev. C 68 (2003) ] 3-pion exchange rel. 1/M N corrections rel. (1/M N ) 2 corrections
73 N N contact contributions Short distance part of the nuclear force Contact terms pick up infinities from regularization and remove scale dependence I (ν) +1 L = Q ν P L (cos θ)d cos θ = 1 +1 where P L is a Legendre polynomial. Due to the orthogonality of the P L, 1 I (ν) L = 0 for L > ν 2. order zero contribute only in S-waves order-two contribute up to P -waves order-four contribute up to D-waves... f ν 2 (cos θ)p L(cos θ)d cos θ,
74 N N contact contributions Short distance part of the nuclear force Contact terms pick up infinities from regularization and remove scale dependence I (ν) +1 L = Q ν P L (cos θ)d cos θ = 1 +1 where P L is a Legendre polynomial. Due to the orthogonality of the P L, 1 I (ν) L = 0 for L > ν 2. order zero contribute only in S-waves order-two contribute up to P -waves order-four contribute up to D-waves... f ν 2 (cos θ)p L(cos θ)d cos θ,
75 N N contact contributions Short distance part of the nuclear force Contact terms pick up infinities from regularization and remove scale dependence I (ν) +1 L = Q ν P L (cos θ)d cos θ = 1 +1 where P L is a Legendre polynomial. Due to the orthogonality of the P L, 1 I (ν) L = 0 for L > ν 2. order zero contribute only in S-waves order-two contribute up to P -waves order-four contribute up to D-waves... f ν 2 (cos θ)p L(cos θ)d cos θ,
76 N N contact contributions Order zero Order two Order four V (0) ( p, p) = C S + C T σ 1 σ 2 V (2) ( p, p) = C 1 q 2 + C 2 k 2 + ( C 3 q 2 + C 4 k 2) σ 1 σ 2 + C 5 ( i S ( q ) k) + C 6 ( σ 1 q) ( σ 2 q) + C 7 ( σ 1 k) ( σ 2 k) V (4) ( p, p) = D 1 q 4 + D 2 k 4 + D 3 q 2 k 2 + D 4 ( q k) 2 + D 5 q 4 + D 6 k 4 + D 7 q 2 k 2 + D 8 ( q k) 2 σ 1 σ 2 + D 9 q 2 + D 10 k 2 is ( q k) + D 11 q 2 + D 12 k 2 ( σ 1 q) ( σ 2 q) + D 13 q 2 + D 14 k 2 ( σ 1 k) ( σ 2 k) + D 15 σ 1 ( q k) σ 2 ( q k)
77 Constructing the T matrix Nonrelativistic Lippmann-Schwinger (LS) equation T ( p, p) = V ( p, p)+ d 3 p V ( p, p M ) T ( p, p) p 2 p 2 + iɛ V and T satisfy the Blankenbecler and Sugar equation [Excellent introduction: M. Hjorth-Jensen, ] No manifest covariance. Relativity is accounted for in terms of a Q/Λ expansion up to given order Iteration of V requires cutting V off for high momenta to avoid infinities cutoff V ( p, p) V ( p, p) e (p /Λ) 2n e (p/λ)2n { [ (p ) ] } V ( p 2n ( p ) 2n, p) Λ Λ
78 Constructing the T matrix For large n, the regulator introduces contributions that are beyond the given order or removed by contact terms What cutoff? A too small Λ will remove the truly long-distance physics and reduce any predictive power. On the other hand with large cutoffs high-momentum states are included that are sensitive to short-distance dynamics Entem and Machleidt: 500 MeV [R. Machleidt arxiv: v1 nucl-th]] Epelbaum, Meissner,...: MeV (systematic investigations) [Epelbaum, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 57 (2006) 654] More on cutoffs
79 Phase shifts with L 3 and T lab 300 MeV At order four in small momenta no contributions from contact interactions f π = 92.4 and g A = 1.29 LEC NN potential πn at N 3 LO empirical c ± 0.15 a c ± 0.23 b c ± 1.34 a c ± 0.04 a d 1 + d ± 0.21 b d ± 0.73 b d ± 0.42 b d 14 d ± 0.41 b Phase Shift (deg) F 3 N2LO LO N3LO NLO Phase Shift (deg) F 2 N3LO N2LO LO NLO Phase Shift (deg) F 3 Bonn OPE N3LO Phase Shift (deg) F 2 N3LO Bonn OPE Lab. Energy (MeV) Lab. Energy (MeV) Lab. Energy (MeV) Lab. Energy (MeV) 3 F F 4 3 F F 4 Phase Shift (deg) N3LO N2LO NLO LO Phase Shift (deg) N3LO N2LO NLO LO Phase Shift (deg) N3LO Bonn OPE Phase Shift (deg) N3LO Bonn OPE Lab. Energy (MeV) Lab. Energy (MeV) Lab. Energy (MeV) Lab. Energy (MeV)
80 Phase shifts Nijmegen CD-Bonn Contact Potentials partial-wave high-precision Q 0 Q 2 Q 4 analysis potential LO NLO/NNLO N 3 LO 1 S S S1-3 D P P P P P2-3 F D D D D D3-3 G F F F F Total
81 Phase shifts (np scattering with Λ = 500 MeV) NLO: dotted line NNLO: dashed line N 3 LO: solid line [From R. Machleidt arxiv: v1 nucl-th]
82 Phase shifts np database T lab bin Idaho Argonne (MeV) N 3 LO V 18 ( ) pp database T lab bin Idaho Argonne (MeV) N 3 LO V 18 ( ) Deuteron properties Idaho N 3 LO CD-Bonn AV18 Empirical (500) B d (MeV) (9) A S (fm 1/2 ) (9) η (4) r d (fm) (85) Q (fm 2 ) (3) P D (%)
83 Phase shifts by Epelbaum Spectral Function regularization [Epelbaum et al. Eur. Phys. J. A 19 (2004) 125] NLO: dashed bands NNLO: light shaded bands N 3 LO: dark shaded bands Phase Shift [deg] Phase Shift [deg] Phase Shift [deg] Phase Shift [deg] ε 1 3 D2 1 S0 3 P Lab. Energy [MeV] D2 3 D3 3 S1 3 P Lab. Energy [MeV] [Epelbaum, nucl-th/ ] P1 3 P2 3 D1 ε Lab. Energy [MeV]
84 Many-body forces Do we need 3body forces? Some evidence from few-body observables p + d p + d [Witala et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 (1998) 1183; Machleidt, talk at FB18]
85 Many-body forces EFT approaches create two- and many-nucleon forces at the same time Old approaches based on phenomenology [Pieper, Pandharipande, Wiringa and Carlson, Phys. Rev. C 64 (2001) ]
86 Many-body forces [From Epelbaum, Talk (2006)] Calculations performed at NNLO; N 3 LO under construction
87 O(3) Model Considering a system of spins, located on the sites of an infinite dimensional lattice. X H = S i S j near.neighbours Back is invariant under rotations g O(3) in 3-dimensional space S i g S i disordered system (O(3) conserved) ordered system (O(3) broken into O(2)) Ferromagnet Low-energy QCD H symmetry O(3) SU(2) V SU(2) A Vacuum symmetry O(2) SU(2) V Collective modes spin waves (massless) Goldstone bosons Explicit breaking external magnetic field (small) quark masses
88 1π-exchange pseudovector coupling two-body amplitude L pv = f π m π ψγ5 γ µ ψ µ φ π Vpv π = f π 2 ū(p 1 )γ 5γ µ (p 1 p 1 )µ u(p 1 )ū(p 2 )γ 5γ ν (p 2 p 2 )ν u(p 2 ) m 2 π (p 1 p 1 )2 m 2 π the Dirac spinors obey γ µ p µ u(p) = mu(p) ū(p)γ µ p µ = mū(p)
89 1π-exchange using these relations, together with {γ 5, γ µ } = 0, we find ū(p 1)γ 5 γ µ (p 1 p 1) µ u(p 1 ) = 2mū(p 1)γ 5 u(p 1 ) ū(p 2)γ 5 γ µ (p 2 p 2 ) µ u(p 2 ) = 2mū(p 2)γ 5 u(p 2 ) we get Vpv π = f π 2 m 2 4m 2 ū(p 1 )γ 5u(p 1 )ū(p 2 )γ 5u(p 2 ) π (p 1 p 1 )2 m 2 π by inserting expressions for the Dirac spinors ( ) ū(p (E 1 1)γ 5 u(p 1 ) = + m)(e 1 + m) σ 1 p 1 4m 2 E 1 + m σ 1 p 1 E 1 + m and similarly for ū(p 2 )γ 5u(p 2 )
90 1π-exchange In the CM system p 2 = p 1, p 2 = p 1 and so E2 = E 1 and E2 = E 1 Vpv,CM π = f π 2 m 2 4m 2 1 (E 1 + m)(e 1 + m) π (p 1 p 1 )2 m 2 π 4m 2 ( ) ( ) σ 1 p 1 E 1 + m σ 1 p 1 σ 2 p 1 E 1 + m E 1 + m σ 2 p 1 E 1 + m in the non-relativistic limit E 1 = p m2 m E 1 and then (p 1 p 1 )2 = k 2 Vpv,CM π = f π 2 m 2 4m 2 1 σ 1 π k 2 + m 2 2m (p 1 p 1) σ 2 2m (p 1 p 1) = f 2 π m 2 π (σ 1 k)(σ 2 k) k 2 + m 2 τ 1 τ 2 π
91 1π-exchange in coordinate space Back V π (r) = d 3 k 2π 3 eikr V π (k) we obtain V π (r) = f π 2 ( e m πr ) m 2 τ 1 τ 2 σ 1 σ 2 π r carrying out the differentiation V π (r) = 1 f 2 { π e m πr } 3 m 2 4πδ 3 (r) σ 1 σ 2 τ 1 τ 2 π r + 1 f 2 { π m π r + 3 } e m πr m 2 πr 2 S 12 (ˆr)τ 1 τ 2 r m 2 π [T. Ericson and W. Weise, Pions and nuclei, Oxford Press]
92 1π iterated Back The iterative 2PE contribution has to be subtracted from the covariant box diagram, order by order V 2π,it ( p, p) = M 2 N E p d 3 p (2π) 3 V 1π ( p, p ) V 1π ( p, p) p 2 p 2 + iɛ [N. Kaiser, R. Brockmann, and W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A 625 (1997) 758]
93 More about cutoffs Back Doesn t a finite cutoff introduce a model dependence? A finite Λ reduce the range of applicability to the momentum region Q < Λ. Taking Λ Λ breakdown will not introduce any ambiguity/model dependence [Donoghue, Holstein and Borasoy, Phys. Rev. D 59 (1999)] What about breaking of chiral invariance? Chiral symmetry is preserved. [Dijukanovic et al., hep-ph/ ] What about if I take Λ? Infinite number of counterterms.
94 N N-force: some phenomenology V C (r) [MeV] S0 3 S1 OPEP r [fm] [Lattice calculations from Ishii et al., nucl-th ] The extracted potential has a strong repulsive core of a few hundred MeV at short distances (r 0.5 fm) surrounded by a relatively weak attraction at medium and long distances
95 N N-force: some phenomenology V III II I N N π π π π N N N N π N π N r [µ 1 ] Strong short range repulsion (core) Intermediate attraction Long-range: 1π-exchange [Figure from W. Weise, arxiv: v1 (nucl-th)]
96 N N-force: some phenomenology V III II I N N π π π π N N N N π N π N r [µ 1 ] Strong short range repulsion (core) Intermediate attraction Long-range: 1π-exchange [Figure from W. Weise, arxiv: v1 (nucl-th)]
97 N N-force: some phenomenology V III II I N N π π π π N N N N π N π N r [µ 1 ] Strong short range repulsion (core) Intermediate attraction Long-range: 1π-exchange [Figure from W. Weise, arxiv: v1 (nucl-th)]
98 N N-force: some phenomenology V III II I N N π π π π N N N N π N π N r [µ 1 ] Strong short range repulsion (core) Intermediate attraction Long-range: 1π-exchange [Figure from W. Weise, arxiv: v1 (nucl-th)]
99 N N-force: some phenomenology Relevant aspects Deuteron (J π = 1 + ) as a shallow bound state Spin-dependent force Spin-orbit force Non central force tensor force Charge symmetry breaking (CSB) and Charge indipendence breaking (CIB) app = 17.3 ± 0.4 fm a nn = 18.8 ± 0.5 fm (with some disagreements...) a pn = ± 0.02 fm
100 N N-force: some phenomenology Symmetries Translation invariance Galilean invariance Rotation invariance Space reflection invariance Time reversal invariance Invariance under the interchange of particle 1 and 2 Almost isospin symmetry [For a general two-body non-relativistic model see Okubo and Marshak, Ann. Phys. (NY) 4, 166 (1958); in general see R. Machleidt, Adv. Nucl. Phys. 19 (1989) 189]
Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces
Evgeny Epelbaum, FZ Jülich & University Bonn Lacanau, 28.09.2009 Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces Lecture 1: Lecture 2: Introduction & first look into ChPT EFTs for two nucleons Chiral Perturbation Theory
More informationOverview of low energy NN interaction and few nucleon systems
1 Overview of low energy NN interaction and few nucleon systems Renato Higa Theory Group, Jefferson Lab Cebaf Center, A3 (ext6363) higa@jlaborg Lecture II Basics on chiral EFT π EFT Chiral effective field
More informationThe theory of nuclear forces: Is the never-ending ending story coming to an end? R. Machleidt University of Idaho
The theory of nuclear forces: Is the never-ending ending story coming to an end? University of Idaho What s left to say? Put the recent progress into a wider perspective. Fill in some missing details.
More informationRenormalization group methods in nuclear few- and many-body problems
Renormalization group methods in nuclear few- and many-body problems Lecture 2 S.K. Bogner (NSCL/MSU) 2011 National Nuclear Physics Summer School University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Lecture 2 outline
More informationNuclear Forces - Lecture 1 - R. Machleidt University of Idaho
CNS Summer School, Univ. of Tokyo, at Wako campus of RIKEN, Aug. 18-23, 2005 Nuclear Forces - Lecture 1 - R. Machleidt University of Idaho 1 Nuclear Forces - Overview of all lectures - Lecture 1: History,
More informationPion-nucleon scattering around the delta-isobar resonance
Pion-nucleon scattering around the delta-isobar resonance Bingwei Long (ECT*) In collaboration with U. van Kolck (U. Arizona) What do we really do Fettes & Meissner 2001... Standard ChPT Isospin 3/2 What
More informationDepartment of Physics, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID 83844, USA; Tel.:
S S symmetry Article Chiral Symmetry and the Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction Ruprecht Machleidt Department of Physics, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID 83844, USA; machleid@uidaho.edu; Tel.: +1-28-885-638 Academic
More informationModern Theory of Nuclear Forces
Evgeny Epelbaum, FZ Jülich & University Bonn Lacanau, 29.09.2009 Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces Lecture 1: Lecture 2: Lecture 3: Introduction & first look into ChPT EFTs for two nucleons Nuclear forces
More informationLectures on Chiral Perturbation Theory
Lectures on Chiral Perturbation Theory I. Foundations II. Lattice Applications III. Baryons IV. Convergence Brian Tiburzi RIKEN BNL Research Center Chiral Perturbation Theory I. Foundations Low-energy
More informationPions are Special Contents Chiral Symmetry and Its Breaking Symmetries and Conservation Laws Goldstone Theorem The Potential Linear Sigma Model Wigner
Lecture 3 Pions as Goldstone Bosons of Chiral Symmetry Breaking Adnan Bashir, IFM, UMSNH, Mexico August 2013 Hermosillo Sonora Pions are Special Contents Chiral Symmetry and Its Breaking Symmetries and
More informationTheory toolbox. Chapter Chiral effective field theories
Chapter 3 Theory toolbox 3.1 Chiral effective field theories The near chiral symmetry of the QCD Lagrangian and its spontaneous breaking can be exploited to construct low-energy effective theories of QCD
More informationThe Nuclear Force Problem: Is the Never-Ending Story Coming to an End?
The Nuclear Force Problem: Is the Never-Ending Story Coming to an End? R. Machleidt Department of Physics, University of Idaho, Moscow, Idaho, USA Abstract. The attempts to find the right (underlying)
More informationBaroion CHIRAL DYNAMICS
Baroion CHIRAL DYNAMICS Baryons 2002 @ JLab Thomas Becher, SLAC Feb. 2002 Overview Chiral dynamics with nucleons Higher, faster, stronger, Formulation of the effective Theory Full one loop results: O(q
More informationNational Nuclear Physics Summer School Lectures on Effective Field Theory. Brian Tiburzi. RIKEN BNL Research Center
2014 National Nuclear Physics Summer School Lectures on Effective Field Theory I. Removing heavy particles II. Removing large scales III. Describing Goldstone bosons IV. Interacting with Goldstone bosons
More informationFew Body Methods in Nuclear Physics - Lecture I
Few Body Methods in Nuclear Physics - Lecture I Nir Barnea The Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel Sept. 2010 Course Outline 1 Introduction - Few-Body Nuclear Physics 2 Gaussian Expansion - The Stochastic
More informationEvgeny Epelbaum. Forschungszentrum Jülich & Universität Bonn
Evgeny Epelbaum KHuK Jahrestagung, GSI, 25.10.2007 Evgeny Epelbaum Forschungszentrum Jülich & Universität Bonn Outline Motivation & Introduction Few nucleons in chiral EFT: where do we stand Work in progress:
More informationLocal chiral NN potentials and the structure of light nuclei
Local chiral NN potentials and the structure of light nuclei Maria Piarulli @ELBA XIV WORKSHOP June 7-July 1 16, Marciana Marina, Isola d Elba PHYSICAL REVIEW C 91, 43(15) Minimally nonlocal nucleon-nucleon
More informationQuantum Field Theory. and the Standard Model. !H Cambridge UNIVERSITY PRESS MATTHEW D. SCHWARTZ. Harvard University
Quantum Field Theory and the Standard Model MATTHEW D. Harvard University SCHWARTZ!H Cambridge UNIVERSITY PRESS t Contents v Preface page xv Part I Field theory 1 1 Microscopic theory of radiation 3 1.1
More informationGoldstone Bosons and Chiral Symmetry Breaking in QCD
Goldstone Bosons and Chiral Symmetry Breaking in QCD Michael Dine Department of Physics University of California, Santa Cruz May 2011 Before reading this handout, carefully read Peskin and Schroeder s
More informationThe Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction
Brazilian Journal of Physics, vol. 34, no. 3A, September, 2004 845 The Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction J. Haidenbauer Forschungszentrum Jülich, Institut für Kernphysik, D-52425 Jülich, Germany Received on
More informationarxiv: v1 [nucl-th] 31 Oct 2013
Renormalization Group Invariance in the Subtractive Renormalization Approach to the NN Interactions S. Szpigel and V. S. Timóteo arxiv:1311.61v1 [nucl-th] 31 Oct 13 Faculdade de Computação e Informática,
More informationLight hypernuclei based on chiral and phenomenological interactions
Mitglied der Helmholtz-Gemeinschaft Light hypernuclei based on chiral and phenomenological interactions Andreas Nogga, Forschungszentrum Jülich International Conference on Hypernuclear and Strange Particle
More informationChiral EFT for nuclear forces with Delta isobar degrees of freedom
with Delta isobar degrees of freedom Helmholtz-Institut für Strahlen- und Kernphysik (Theorie) and Bethe Center for Theoretical Physics, Universität Bonn, Nußallee 4-6, D-535 Bonn, Germany E-mail: hkrebs@itkp.uni-bonn.de
More informationQCD in the light quark (up & down) sector (QCD-light) has two mass scales M(GeV)
QCD in the light quark (up & down) sector (QCD-light) has two mass scales M(GeV) 1 m N m ρ Λ QCD 0 m π m u,d In a generic physical system, there are often many scales involved. However, for a specific
More informationBayesian Fitting in Effective Field Theory
Bayesian Fitting in Effective Field Theory Department of Physics Ohio State University February, 26 Collaborators: D. Phillips (Ohio U.), U. van Kolck (Arizona), R.G.E. Timmermans (Groningen, Nijmegen)
More informationLEADING LOGARITHMS FOR THE NUCLEON MASS
/9 LEADING LOGARITHMS FOR THE NUCLEON MASS O(N + ) Lund University bijnens@thep.lu.se http://thep.lu.se/ bijnens http://thep.lu.se/ bijnens/chpt/ QNP5 - Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María UTFSMXI
More informationIntroduction to chiral perturbation theory II Higher orders, loops, applications
Introduction to chiral perturbation theory II Higher orders, loops, applications Gilberto Colangelo Zuoz 18. July 06 Outline Introduction Why loops? Loops and unitarity Renormalization of loops Applications
More informationCHIRAL SYMMETRY AT HIGH ENERGIES: HARD PION CHIRAL PERTURBATION THEORY
CHIRAL SYMMETRY AT HIGH ENERGIES: HARD PION CHIRAL PERTURBATION THEORY Johan Bijnens Lund University bijnens@thep.lu.se http://www.thep.lu.se/ bijnens Various ChPT: http://www.thep.lu.se/ bijnens/chpt.html
More informationThree-nucleon potentials in nuclear matter. Alessandro Lovato
Three-nucleon potentials in nuclear matter Alessandro Lovato PRC 83, 054003 (2011) arxiv:1109.5489 Outline Ab initio many body method Nuclear Hamiltonian: 2- and 3- body potentials Density dependent potential
More informationarxiv:hep-ph/ v2 24 Sep 1996
NUC MINN 96/11 T A New Approach to Chiral Perturbation Theory with Matter Fields Hua-Bin Tang arxiv:hep-ph/9607436v 4 Sep 1996 School of Physics and Astronomy University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55455
More informationPion-nucleon sigma-term - a review
Pion-nucleon sigma-term - a review M.E. Sainio Helsinki Institute of Physics, and Department of Physics, University of Helsinki, P.O. Box 64, 00014 Helsinki, Finland (Received: December 5, 2001) A brief
More informationarxiv:nucl-th/ v1 22 Sep 2000
1 arxiv:nucl-th/967v1 22 Sep 2 Chiral Dynamics in Few Nucleon Systems E. Epelbaum a, H. Kamada a,b, A. Nogga b, H. Wita la c, W. Glöckle b, and Ulf-G. Meißner a a Forschungszentrum Jülich, Institut für
More informationGell-Mann - Oakes - Renner relation in a magnetic field at finite temperature.
Gell-Mann - Oakes - Renner relation in a magnetic field at finite temperature. N.O. Agasian and I.A. Shushpanov Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics 117218 Moscow, Russia Abstract In the first
More informationEffective Field Theories for lattice QCD
Effective Field Theories for lattice QCD Stephen R. Sharpe University of Washington S. Sharpe, EFT for LQCD: Lecture 1 3/21/12 @ New horizons in lattice field theory, Natal, Brazil 1 Outline of Lectures
More informationNucleon-nucleon interaction in covariant chiral effective field theory
Guilin, China The Seventh Asia-Pacific Conference on Few-Body Problems in Physics Nucleon-nucleon interaction in covariant chiral effective field theory Xiu-Lei Ren School of Physics, Peking University
More informationNUCLEAR FORCES. Historical perspective
NUCLEAR FORCES Figure 1: The atomic nucleus made up from protons (yellow) and neutrons (blue) and held together by nuclear forces. Nuclear forces (also known as nuclear interactions or strong forces) are
More informationElastic and Inelastic Pion Reactions on Few Nucleon Systems
Elastic and Inelastic Pion Reactions on Few Nucleon Systems Dissertation zur Erlangung des Doktorgrades (Dr. rer. nat.) der Mathematisch Naturwissenschaftlichen Fakultät des Rheinischen Friedrich-Wilhelms
More informationNuclear forces from chiral effective field theory
FZJ-IKP-TH-2010-2 HISKP-TH-10/4 Nuclear forces from chiral effective field theory a primer arxiv:1001.3229v1 [nucl-th] 19 Jan 2010 Evgeny Epelbaum Forschungszentrum Jülich, Institut für Kernphysik (Theorie)
More informationWeakly-Bound Systems in Atomic and Nuclear Physics March 2010
Electroweak properties of Weakly- Bound Light Nuclei Weakly-Bound Systems in Atomic and Nuclear Physics March 2010 INSTITUTE FOR NUCLEAR THEORY Collaborators Sonia Bacca Winfried Leidemann, Giuseppina
More informationNucleon mass, sigma term, and lattice QCD
PHYSICL REVIEW D 69, 3455 4 Nucleon mass, sigma term, and lattice QCD Massimiliano Procura* Physik-Department, Theoretische Physik, Technische Universität München, D-85747 Garching, Germany and ECT, Villa
More informationNucleon Nucleon Forces and Mesons
Canada s ational Laboratory for Particle and uclear Physics Laboratoire national canadien pour la recherche en physique nucléaire et en physique des particules ucleon ucleon Forces and Mesons Sonia Bacca
More informationNuclear structure I: Introduction and nuclear interactions
Nuclear structure I: Introduction and nuclear interactions Stefano Gandolfi Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) National Nuclear Physics Summer School Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) July
More informationNuclear Forces - Lecture 2 - R. Machleidt University of Idaho
CNS Summer School, Univ. of Tokyo, at Wako campus of RIKEN, Aug. 18-3, 005 Nuclear Forces - Lecture - R. Machleidt University of Idaho 1 Lecture : The Meson Theory of Nuclear Forces Yukawa s historic idea
More informationRenormalization and power counting of chiral nuclear forces. 龙炳蔚 (Bingwei Long) in collaboration with Chieh-Jen Jerry Yang (U.
Renormalization and power counting of chiral nuclear forces 龙炳蔚 (Bingwei Long) in collaboration with Chieh-Jen Jerry Yang (U. Arizona) What are we really doing? Correcting Weinberg's scheme about NN contact
More informationModern Theory of Nuclear Forces
Evgeny Epelbaum PAX Meeting, Stockholm, 15.06.2010 Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces Evgeny Epelbaum, Ruhr-Universität Bochum Outline Chiral EFT for nuclear forces Some hot topics (work in progress) Deuteron
More informationQuantum Monte Carlo calculations with chiral Effective Field Theory Interactions
Quantum Monte Carlo calculations with chiral Effective Field Theory Interactions Alexandros Gezerlis East Lansing, MI 3rd International Symposium on Nuclear Symmetry Energy July 25, 2013 Motivation for
More informationη π 0 γγ decay in the three-flavor Nambu Jona-Lasinio model
TIT/HEP-38/NP INS-Rep.-3 η π 0 γγ decay in the three-flavor Nambu Jona-Lasinio model arxiv:hep-ph/96053v 8 Feb 996 Y.Nemoto, M.Oka Department of Physics, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Meguro, Tokyo 5,
More informationLow-energy aspects of amplitude analysis: chiral perturbation theory and dispersion relations
Low-energy aspects of amplitude analysis: chiral perturbation theory and dispersion relations Bastian Kubis Helmholtz-Institut für Strahlen- und Kernphysik (Theorie) Bethe Center for Theoretical Physics
More informationLattice Simulations with Chiral Nuclear Forces
Lattice Simulations with Chiral Nuclear Forces Hermann Krebs FZ Jülich & Universität Bonn July 23, 2008, XQCD 2008, NCSU In collaboration with B. Borasoy, E. Epelbaum, D. Lee, U. Meißner Outline EFT and
More informationHadronic Weak Interactions
1 / 44 Hadronic Weak Interactions Matthias R. Schindler Fundamental Neutron Physics Summer School 2015 Some slides courtesy of N. Fomin 2 / 44 Weak interactions - One of fundamental interactions - Component
More informationTHE THREE NUCLEON SYSTEM AT LEADING ORDER OF CHIRAL EFFECTIVE THEORY
THE THREE NUCLEON SYSTEM AT LEADING ORDER OF CHIRAL EFFECTIVE THEORY Young-Ho Song(RISP, Institute for Basic Science) Collaboration with R. Lazauskas( IPHC, IN2P3-CNRS) U. van Kolck (Orsay, IPN & Arizona
More informationAnomaly. Kenichi KONISHI University of Pisa. College de France, 14 February 2006
Anomaly Kenichi KONISHI University of Pisa College de France, 14 February 2006 Abstract Symmetry and quantization U A (1) anomaly and π 0 decay Origin of anomalies Chiral and nonabelian anomaly Anomally
More informationNuclear Forces - Lecture 1 -
Physics Department, Tohoku University, June 30 July 2, 2014 Nuclear Forces - Lecture 1 - Historical Perspective R. Machleidt University of Idaho 1 Nuclear Forces - Overview of all lectures - Lecture 1:
More informationThe Hadronic Decay Ratios of η 5π at NLO in χpt
EJTP 11, No. 1 (2014) 11 140 Electronic Journal of Theoretical Physics The Hadronic Decay Ratios of η 5π at NLO in χpt M. Goodarzi and H. Sadeghi Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, Arak University,
More informationA high-accuracy extraction of the isoscalar πn scattering length from pionic deuterium data
A high-accuracy extraction of the isoscalar πn scattering length from pionic deuterium data Daniel Phillips Ohio University and Universität Bonn with V. Baru, C. Hanhart, M. Hoferichter, B. Kubis, A. Nogga
More informationPoS(QNP2012)138. The weak S = 1 ΛN interaction with effective field theory
The weak S = 1 interaction with effective field theory Departament d Estructura i Constituents de la Matèria, Institut de Ciències del Cosmos (ICC), Universitat de Barcelona, Martí i Franquès 1, E 0808,
More informationThe NN system: why and how we iterate
The NN system: why and how we iterate Daniel Phillips Ohio University Research supported by the US department of energy Plan Why we iterate I: contact interactions Why we iterate II: pion exchange How
More informationπn scattering in relativistic BChPT revisited
πn scattering in relativistic BChPT revisited Jose Manuel Alarcón jmas1@um.es Universidad de Murcia In colaboration with J. Martin Camalich, J. A. Oller and L. Alvarez-Ruso arxiv:1102.1537 [nucl-th] To
More informationHadronic parity-violation in pionless effective field theory
Hadronic parity-violation in pionless effective field theory Matthias R. Schindler Ohio University PAVI9 June 25, 29 In collaboration with D. R. Phillips and R. P. Springer Introduction Effective Field
More informationEffective Field Theories in Nuclear and Hadron Physics
Effective Field Theories in Nuclear and Hadron Physics Vadim Lensky Theoretical Physics Group, The University of Manchester January 11, 2013 V. Lensky EFTs in Hadron and Nuclear Physics 1 Outline Introduction
More informationNucleon mass, sigma term and lattice QCD 1
TUM-T39-03-17 Nucleon mass, sigma term and lattice QCD 1 arxiv:hep-lat/030900v 5 Apr 004 Massimiliano Procura a,b, Thomas R. Hemmert a and Wolfram Weise a,b a Physik-Department, Theoretische Physik Technische
More informationThe Phases of QCD. Thomas Schaefer. North Carolina State University
The Phases of QCD Thomas Schaefer North Carolina State University 1 Motivation Different phases of QCD occur in the universe Neutron Stars, Big Bang Exploring the phase diagram is important to understanding
More informationOctet Baryon Charge Radii, Chiral Symmetry and Decuplet Intermediate States. Abstract
Octet Baryon Charge Radii, Chiral Symmetry and Decuplet Intermediate States S.J. Puglia a M.J. Ramsey-Musolf a,b Shi-Lin Zhu a a Department of Physics, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269 USA b
More informationDonoghue, Golowich, Holstein Chapter 4, 6
1 Week 7: Non linear sigma models and pion lagrangians Reading material from the books Burgess-Moore, Chapter 9.3 Donoghue, Golowich, Holstein Chapter 4, 6 Weinberg, Chap. 19 1 Goldstone boson lagrangians
More informationarxiv: v1 [nucl-th] 23 Feb 2016
September 12, 2018 Threshold pion production in proton-proton collisions at NNLO in chiral EFT arxiv:1602.07333v1 [nucl-th] 23 Feb 2016 V. Baru, 1, 2 E. Epelbaum, 1 A. A. Filin, 1 C. Hanhart, 3 H. Krebs,
More informationarxiv: v1 [hep-ph] 13 Nov 2013
euniversityofmanchester November 14, 2013 arxiv:1311.3203v1 [hep-ph] 13 Nov 2013 Odd- and even-parity charmed mesons revisited in heavy hadron chiral perturbation theory Mohammad Alhakami 1 School of Physics
More informationChiral Nuclear Effective Field Theory
Chiral uclear Effective Field Theory U. van Kolck University of Arizona Supported in part by US DOE and Sloan Foundation Background by S. Hossenfelder In emoriam Vijay Pandharipande See talks by Carlson,
More informationStefan Scherer Institut für Kernphysik, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität, D Mainz, Germany
Institut für Kernphysik, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität, D-55099 Mainz, Germany E-mail: scherer@kph.uni-mainz.de We provide an introduction to the power-counting issue in baryon chiral perturbation theory
More informationElectromagnetic currents from chiral EFT
ab a Forschungszentrum Jülich, Institut für Kernphysik (IKP-3) and Jülich Center for Hadron Physics, D-545 Jülich, Germany b Helmholtz-Institut für Strahlen- und Kernphysik (Theorie) and Bethe Center for
More informationPOWER COUNTING WHAT? WHERE?
POWER COUNTING WHAT? WHERE? U. van Kolck Institut de Physique Nucléaire d Orsay and University of Arizona Supported by CNRS and US DOE 1 Outline Meeting the elephant What? Where? Walking out of McDonald
More informationThe nucleon-nucleon system in chiral effective theory
The nucleon-nucleon system in chiral effective theory Daniel Phillips Ohio University Research supported by the US Department of Energy Plan χet for nuclear forces: the proposal Leading order for S waves
More informationEffective Field Theory for Cold Atoms I
Effective Field Theory for Cold Atoms I H.-W. Hammer Institut für Kernphysik, TU Darmstadt and Extreme Matter Institute EMMI School on Effective Field Theory across Length Scales, ICTP-SAIFR, Sao Paulo,
More informationAt the end of Section 4, a summary of basic principles for low-energy effective theories was given, which we recap here.
Nuclear Forces 2 (last revised: September 30, 2014) 6 1 6. Nuclear Forces 2 a. Recap: Principles of low-energy effective theories Figure 1: Left: high-resolution, with wavelength of probe short compared
More informationLOW-ENERGY QCD and STRANGENESS in the NUCLEON
PAVI 09 Bar Harbor, Maine, June 009 LOW-ENERGY QCD and STRANGENESS in the NUCLEON Wolfram Weise Strategies in Low-Energy QCD: Lattice QCD and Chiral Effective Field Theory Scalar Sector: Nucleon Mass and
More informationNuclear forces and their impact on structure, reactions and astrophysics
Nuclear forces and their impact on structure, reactions and astrophysics Lectures for Week 2 Dick Furnstahl Ohio State University July, 213 M. Chiral EFT 1 (as); χ-symmetry in NN scattering, QCD 2 (rjf)
More informationEDMs from the QCD θ term
ACFI EDM School November 2016 EDMs from the QCD θ term Vincenzo Cirigliano Los Alamos National Laboratory 1 Lecture II outline The QCD θ term Toolbox: chiral symmetries and their breaking Estimate of the
More informationChiral and angular momentum content of rho and rho mesons from dynamical lattice calculations
Chiral and angular momentum content of rho and rho mesons from dynamical lattice calculations L. Ya. Glozman Institut für Physik, FB Theoretische Physik, Universität Graz With Christian Lang and Markus
More informationCoupling of Angular Momenta Isospin Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction
Lecture 5 Coupling of Angular Momenta Isospin Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction WS0/3: Introduction to Nuclear and Particle Physics,, Part I I. Angular Momentum Operator Rotation R(θ): in polar coordinates the
More informationAnomalies and discrete chiral symmetries
Anomalies and discrete chiral symmetries Michael Creutz BNL & U. Mainz Three sources of chiral symmetry breaking in QCD spontaneous breaking ψψ 0 explains lightness of pions implicit breaking of U(1) by
More informationRG & EFT for nuclear forces
RG & EFT for nuclear forces Andreas Nogga, Forschungszentrum Jülich ECT* school, Feb/March 2006 Low momentum interactions: Using the RG to simplify the nuclear force for many-body calculations. Application
More informationΛ QCD and Light Quarks Contents Symmetries of the QCD Lagrangian Chiral Symmetry and Its Breaking Parity and Handedness Parity Doubling Explicit Chira
Lecture 5 QCD Symmetries & Their Breaking From Quarks to Hadrons Adnan Bashir, IFM, UMSNH, Mexico August 2013 Hermosillo Sonora Λ QCD and Light Quarks Contents Symmetries of the QCD Lagrangian Chiral Symmetry
More informationarxiv:hep-ph/ v1 1 Jun 1995
CHIRAL PREDICTION FOR THE πn S WAVE SCATTERING LENGTH a TO ORDER O(M 4 π ) V. Bernard a#1#2, N. Kaiser b#3, Ulf-G. Meißner c#4 arxiv:hep-ph/9506204v1 1 Jun 1995 a Centre de Recherches Nucléaires, Physique
More informationChiral expansion of the π 0 γγ decay width
arxiv:1109.1467v1 [hep-ph] 7 Sep 2011 Chiral expansion of the π 0 γγ decay width Bing An Li Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Kentucky Lexington, KY 40506, USA Abstract A chiral field
More information8 September Dear Paul...
EXA 2011 Vienna PK Symposium 8 September 2011 Dear Paul... DEEPLY BOUND STATES of PIONIC ATOMS Experiment (GSI): K. Suzuki et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92 (2004) 072302 Theory: Energy Dependent Pion-Nucleus
More informationHow nucleon gets its mass
Fiz-Tech, Dec 05, 2006 How nucleon gets its mass Dmitri Diakonov Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute 1. Quantum Chromodynamics: the theory of strong interactions 2. Chiral symmetry of strong interactions
More informationSpin-Orbit Interactions in Nuclei and Hypernuclei
Ab-Initio Nuclear Structure Bad Honnef July 29, 2008 Spin-Orbit Interactions in Nuclei and Hypernuclei Wolfram Weise Phenomenology Aspects of Chiral Dynamics and Spin-Orbit Forces Nuclei vs. -Hypernuclei:
More informationHARD PION CHIRAL PERTURBATION THEORY
HARD PION CHIRAL PERTURBATION THEORY Johan Bijnens Lund University bijnens@thep.lu.se http://www.thep.lu.se/ bijnens Various ChPT: http://www.thep.lu.se/ bijnens/chpt.html Bonn 11/10/2011 Hard Pion Chiral
More informationU. van Kolck. Institut de Physique Nucléaire d Orsay. and University of Arizona. Supported in part by CNRS, Université Paris Sud, and US DOE
THE NON-PC STORY A SERMON OF ABOUT CHIRAL PC EFT U. van Kolck Institut de Physique Nucléaire d Orsay and University of Arizona Supported in part by CNRS, Université Paris Sud, and US DOE 1 Why? Chiral
More informationOne-loop corrections as the origin of spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking in the massless chiral sigma model
One-loop corrections as the origin of spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking in the massless chiral sigma model a S. Tamenaga, a H. Toki, a, b A. Haga, and a Y. Ogawa a RCNP, Osaka University b Nagoya Institute
More informationQuantum Monte Carlo calculations of medium mass nuclei
Quantum Monte Carlo calculations of medium mass nuclei Diego Lonardoni FRIB Theory Fellow In collaboration with: J. Carlson, LANL S. Gandolfi, LANL X. Wang, Huzhou University, China A. Lovato, ANL & UniTN
More informationElectric Dipole Moments and the strong CP problem
Electric Dipole Moments and the strong CP problem We finally understand CP viola3on.. QCD theta term Jordy de Vries, Nikhef, Amsterdam Topical Lectures on electric dipole moments, Dec. 14-16 Introductory
More informationRG & EFT for nuclear forces
RG & EFT for nuclear forces Andreas Nogga, Forschungszentrum Jülich ECT* school, Feb/March 2006 Low momentum interactions: Using the RG to simplify the nuclear force for many-body calculations. Application
More informationSUNY Stony Brook August 16, Wolfram Weise. with. Thomas Hell Simon Rössner Claudia Ratti
SUNY Stony Brook August 16, 27 PHASES of QCD POLYAKOV LOOP and QUASIPARTICLES Wolfram Weise with Thomas Hell Simon Rössner Claudia Ratti C. Ratti, M. Thaler, W. Weise: Phys. Rev. D 73 (26) 1419 C. Ratti,
More informationPredictions of chiral perturbation theory for Compton scattering off protons
Predictions of chiral perturbation theory for Compton scattering off protons ECT* Trento E-mail: lensky@ect.it Vladimir PASCALUTSA Institut für Kernphysik, Johannes Gutenberg Universität, Mainz D-5599,
More informationThe Gauge Principle Contents Quantum Electrodynamics SU(N) Gauge Theory Global Gauge Transformations Local Gauge Transformations Dynamics of Field Ten
Lecture 4 QCD as a Gauge Theory Adnan Bashir, IFM, UMSNH, Mexico August 2013 Hermosillo Sonora The Gauge Principle Contents Quantum Electrodynamics SU(N) Gauge Theory Global Gauge Transformations Local
More informationThe chiral anomaly and the eta-prime in vacuum and at low temperatures
The chiral anomaly and the eta-prime in vacuum and at low temperatures Stefan Leupold, Carl Niblaeus, Bruno Strandberg Department of Physics and Astronomy Uppsala University St. Goar, March 2013 1 Table
More informationCitation PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS (2000), 84( RightCopyright 2000 American Physical So
Title Chiral-symmetry realization resonances for eve Author(s) Jido, D; Hatsuda, T; Kunihiro, T Citation PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS (000), 84( Issue Date 000-04-0 URL http://hdl.handle.net/433/5059 RightCopyright
More informationEffective Field Theory for Nuclear Physics! Akshay Vaghani! Mississippi State University!
Effective Field Theory for Nuclear Physics! Akshay Vaghani! Mississippi State University! Overview! Introduction! Basic ideas of EFT! Basic Examples of EFT! Algorithm of EFT! Review NN scattering! NN scattering
More informationEffective Field Theory
Effective Field Theory Iain Stewart MIT The 19 th Taiwan Spring School on Particles and Fields April, 2006 Physics compartmentalized Quantum Field Theory String Theory? General Relativity short distance
More informationPion production in nucleon-nucleon collisions near threshold: complete NNLO calculation in chiral EFT
Pion production in nucleon-nucleon collisions near threshold: complete NNLO calculation in chiral EFT a, V. Baru ab, E. Epelbaum a, C. Hanhart c, H. Krebs a, and F. Myhrer d a Institut für Theoretische
More information