Bayesian Fitting in Effective Field Theory
|
|
- Avice Dean
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Bayesian Fitting in Effective Field Theory Department of Physics Ohio State University February, 26 Collaborators: D. Phillips (Ohio U.), U. van Kolck (Arizona), R.G.E. Timmermans (Groningen, Nijmegen)
2 Outline Overview Method Request What Does The Typical Physicist Know About Bayesian Statistics? Nothing! But there are exceptions: Experimentalists searching for weak signatures of particles Some Beyond the Standard Model theorists Some lattice gauge theorists doing constrained curve fitting Even where applied, Bayesian methods are controversial Not applied as yet in EFT or nuclear structure calculations The problem described here is just one (simple) example where Bayesian methods might be useful
3 Outline Overview Method Request Constrained Curve Fitting Example (hep-lat/11175) Monte Carlo estimates of a meson correlator G(t) are generated at 24 time steps, t =, 1,, 23. Theory says the exact correlator has the form: G th (t; A n, E n ) = A n e Ent n=1 Challenge: Fit an infinite number of amplitudes A n and energies E n using only 24 G(t) s. Standard procedure: Keep only first few terms in G th Fit using only Monte Carlo data from t t min But choosing t min is ad hoc
4 Outline Overview Method Request Results From Standard Fits 2 2 Energy 1 E 2 E 1 Energy 1 E 2 E t min Number of Terms 8 Left: 2-term fit to n=1 A ne Ent for t t min Competition between large systematic errors for small t min and large statistical errors for large t max Right: Fit values for lowest two energies vs. # of terms
5 Outline Overview Method Request Unconstrained vs. Constrained Fits Goal: Fit all data using as many terms as we wish Plan: Add priors for reasonable A n s and E n s in n A ne Ent 2 2 Energy 1 E 2 E 1 Energy 1 E 2 E Number of Terms Number of Terms 8 Left: unconstrained. Right: constrained.
6 Outline Outline Overview Method Request Overview: Problem(s) to Be Solved Method: Effective Field Theory (EFT) Request: Advice on Applying Bayesian Methods
7 Outline Outline Overview Method Request Goal Overview: Problem(s) to Be Solved Method: Effective Field Theory (EFT) Request: Advice on Applying Bayesian Methods
8 Figure 1: From QCD vacuum to heavy nuclei: the intellectual Bayesian connection Fitting inbetween EFT the hadronic many-body Outline Overview Method Request Goal The Islands of Strong Interaction Physics RHIC CEBAF quarks gluons few nucleons RIA heavy nuclei vacuum quark-gluon plasma QCD nucleon QCD few-body systems free NN force many-body systems effective NN force
9 Outline Overview Method Request Goal The Big Picture (adapted from
10 Outline Overview Method Request Goal Table of the Nuclides Stable nuclei 126 Known nuclei 82 r-process Protons 2 28 rp-process Terra incognita Neutron stars Neutrons Figure The nuclear landscape, defining the territory of nuclear physics research. On this chart of the nuclides, black squares represent stable nuclei and nuclei with half-lives comparable to or longer than the age of the Earth. These nuclei define the valley of stability. Dick By Furnstahl adding either protons Bayesian or neutrons, Fitting inone EFTmoves away from the valley of
11 Outline Overview Method Request Goal Problems with Extrapolations Mass formulas and energy functionals do well where there is data, but elsewhere... two-neutron separation energies S 2n (MeV) Sn data exist Experiment HFB-SLy4 HFB-SkP HFB-D1S SkX RHB-NL3 LEDF Mass Formulae Neutron Number data do not exist Neutron Number Neutron Number exp FRDM CKZ JM MJ T+ Figure 6: Predicted two-neutron separation energies Bayesian for the even-even FittingSn inisotopes EFT using several
12 Outline Overview Method Request Goal Input to Many-Body Problem: Internucleon Force Reproduce data from scattering protons from neutrons, etc. Difficult problem with long history M.L. Goldberger, at the Midwestern Conference on Theoretical Physics, Purdue University, 196: There are few problems in nuclear theoretical physics which have attracted more attention than that of trying to determine the fundamental interaction between two nucleons. It is also true that scarcely ever has the world of physics owed so little to so many.... It is hard to believe that many of the authors are talking about the same problem or, in fact, that they know what the problem is.
13 Outline Overview Method Request Goal Successful Fits to Phase Shift Data Achieved Fit energies from to 35 MeV, with goal of χ 2 /dof 1 Account only for measurement errors Table from Argonne v 18 paper: No theoretical errors, all data treated equally
14 Outline Outline Overview Method Request EFT Chiral Analogs Overview: Problem(s) to Be Solved Method: Effective Field Theory (EFT) Request: Advice on Applying Bayesian Methods
15 Resolution and the Pointillists George Seurat painted using closely spaced small dots (.4 mm wide) of pure pigment Why do the dots blend together?
16 Resolution and the Pointillists George Seurat painted using closely spaced small dots (.4 mm wide) of pure pigment Why do the dots blend together?
17 Wavelength and Resolution
18 Wavelength and Resolution
19 Wavelength and Resolution
20 Wavelength and Resolution
21 Wavelength and Resolution
22 Wavelength and Resolution
23 Wavelength and Resolution
24 Wavelength and Resolution
25 Wavelength and Resolution
26 Principles of Effective Low-Energy Theories
27 Principles of Effective Low-Energy Theories If system is probed at low energies, fine details not resolved
28 Principles of Effective Low-Energy Theories If system is probed at low energies, fine details not resolved use low-energy variables for low-energy processes short-distance structure can be replaced by something simpler without distorting low-energy observables
29 Effective Field Theory Ingredients From Crossing the Border [nucl-th/864] 1 Use the most general L with low-energy dof s consistent with the global and local symmetries of the underlying theory 2 Declaration of regularization and renormalization scheme 3 Well-defined power counting = expansion parameters
30 Effective Field Theory Ingredients: Chiral NN From Crossing the Border [nucl-th/864] 1 Use the most general L with low-energy dof s consistent with the global and local symmetries of the underlying theory L eft = L ππ + L πn + L NN chiral symmetry = systematic long-distance pion physics 2 Declaration of regularization and renormalization scheme momentum cutoff and Weinberg counting use cutoff sensitivity as measure of uncertainties! 3 Well-defined power counting = expansion parameters use the separation of scales = {p, m π} with Λ Λ χ 1 GeV χ chiral symmetry = V NN = ν=ν min c ν Q ν with ν naturalness: parameters are O(1) in appropriate units
31 Chiral Lagrangian Unified description of ππ, πn, and NN N Lowest orders: L () = 1 2 µπ µ π 1 2 M2 π 2 + N [ i + g A 2F τ σ π 1 4F 1 2 C S(N N)(N N) 1 2 C T (N σn)(n σn) +..., [ L (1) = N 4c 1 M 2 2c 1 F 2 M2 π 2 + c 2 F 2 π2 + c 3 F 2 ( µπ µ π) c ] 4 2F 2 ɛ ijk ɛ abc σ i τ a ( j π b )( k π c ) N ] τ (π π) N 2 D 4F (N N)(N στ N) π 1 2 E (N N)(N τ N) (N τ N) +... Infinite # of unknown parameters in hierarchy
32 Chiral Effective Field Theory for Two Nucleons Epelbaum, Meißner, et al. Also Entem, Machleidt L πn + match at low energy Q ν 1π 2π 4N 1S 3S P 1D D3 3G
33 Chiral Effective Field Theory for Two Nucleons Epelbaum, Meißner, et al. Also Entem, Machleidt L πn + match at low energy Q ν 1π 2π 4N Q 1S 3S P 1D D3 3G
34 Chiral Effective Field Theory for Two Nucleons Epelbaum, Meißner, et al. Also Entem, Machleidt L πn + match at low energy Q ν 1π 2π 4N Q Q 1 1S 3S P 1D D3 3G
35 Chiral Effective Field Theory for Two Nucleons Epelbaum, Meißner, et al. Also Entem, Machleidt L πn + match at low energy Q ν 1π 2π 4N Q Q 1 Q 2 1S 3S P 1D D3 3G
36 Chiral Effective Field Theory for Two Nucleons Epelbaum, Meißner, et al. Also Entem, Machleidt L πn + match at low energy Q ν 1π 2π 4N Q Q 1 Q 2 Q 3 1S 3S P 1D D3 3G
37 Chiral Effective Field Theory for Two Nucleons Epelbaum, Meißner, et al. Also Entem, Machleidt L πn + match at low energy Q ν 1π 2π 4N Q Q 1 Q 2 Q 3 Q 4 many many 4 (15) 1S 3S P 1D D3 3G
38 Motivation For Applying Effective Field Theory Systematic calculations with theoretical error estimates Reliable, model independent extrapolation Analogy between EFT and basic numerical analysis naive error analysis: pick a method and reduce the mesh size (e.g., increase grid points) until the error is acceptable sophisticated error analysis: understand scaling and sources of error (e.g., algorithm vs. round-off errors) = Does it work as well as it should? representation dependence = not all are equally effective! extrapolation: completeness of an expansion basis
39 Error Plots in Numerical Analysis relative error Numerical Derivatives f (x) = [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h + O(h) mesh size h
40 Error Plots in Numerical Analysis relative error Numerical Derivatives f (x) = [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h + O(h) f (x) = [f(x+h/2)-f(x-h/2)]/h + O(h 2 ) mesh size h
41 Error Plots in Numerical Analysis relative error Numerical Derivatives f (x) = [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h + O(h) f (x) = [f(x+h/2)-f(x-h/2)]/h + O(h 2 ) Richardson extrapolation O(h 4 ) mesh size h
42 Error Plots in Numerical Analysis relative error h n to h n Numerical Integration trapezoid rule O(h 2 ) mesh size h
43 Error Plots in Numerical Analysis Numerical Integration relative error h n to h n trapezoid rule O(h 2 ) Simpson s rule O(h 4 ) mesh size h
44 Error Plots in Numerical Analysis Numerical Integration relative error h n to h n trapezoid rule O(h 2 ) Simpson s rule O(h 4 ) Milne s rule O(h 6 ) mesh size h
45 The Representation Can Make A Difference! E.g., elliptic integral: 1 (1 x 2 )(2 x) dx
46 The Representation Can Make A Difference! E.g., elliptic integral: 1 (1 x 2 )(2 x) dx How do the numerical errors behave? relative error h n to h n trapezoid rule O(h 2 ) Simpson s rule O(h 4 ) Milne s rule O(h 6 ) before Numerical Integration mesh size h
47 The Representation Can Make A Difference! E.g., elliptic integral: 1 (1 x 2 )(2 x) dx How do the numerical errors behave? After transformation: π/2 sin 2 y 2 cos y dy relative error h n to h n trapezoid rule O(h 2 ) Simpson s rule O(h 4 ) Milne s rule O(h 6 ) before Numerical Integration after mesh size h
48 The Representation Can Make A Difference! E.g., elliptic integral: 1 (1 x 2 )(2 x) dx How do the numerical errors behave? After transformation: π/2 sin 2 y 2 cos y dy relative error h n to h n trapezoid rule O(h 2 ) Simpson s rule O(h 4 ) Milne s rule O(h 6 ) before Numerical Integration after mesh size h
49 The Representation Can Make A Difference! E.g., elliptic integral: 1 (1 x 2 )(2 x) dx How do the numerical errors behave? After transformation: π/2 sin 2 y 2 cos y dy relative error h n to h n trapezoid rule O(h 2 ) Simpson s rule O(h 4 ) Milne s rule O(h 6 ) before Numerical Integration after mesh size h
50 Error Plots in Effective Field Theory G. P. Lepage, How to Renormalize the Schrödinger Equation! "$# % % & Errors in the 1 S phase shifts versus energy through orders Λ 2 and Λ 4. Fit using data at low energy only.
51 Error Plots in Effective Field Theory G. P. Lepage, How to Renormalize the Schrödinger Equation!#"%$ & & '(' & ) & Errors in the 1 S phase shifts versus energy for different values of the cutoff Λ.
52 Best Calculation: Theoretical Error A Posteriori Phase Shift [deg] Phase Shift [deg] Phase Shift [deg] Phase Shift [deg] ε 1 3 D2 1 S 3 P Lab. Energy [MeV] D2 3 D3 3 S1 3 P P1 3 P2 3 D Lab. Energy [MeV] Lab. Energy [MeV] ε 2
53 Naturalness of Coefficients (Epelbaum et al.) Georgi-Manohar naive dimensional analysis (NDA): ( N ) l ( ) m ( ( )N π µ ) n, m π L χ eft = c lmn fπλ 2 f χ f π Λ πλ 2 2 χ χ f π 1 MeV and Λ χ 1 MeV check NLO, NNLO constants from L NN (cutoff MeV): fπ 2 C S fπ 2 C T fπ 2 Λ 2 χ C fπ 2 Λ 2 χ C f 2 π Λ 2 χ C f 2 π Λ 2 χ C f 2 π Λ 2 χ C f 2 π Λ 2 χ C f 2 π Λ 2 χ C /3 c lmn 3 = natural! = truncation error estimates f 2 π C T unnaturally small = SU(4) spin-isospin symmetry
54 Outline Outline Overview Method Request Overview: Problem(s) to Be Solved Method: Effective Field Theory (EFT) Request: Advice on Applying Bayesian Methods
55 Outline Overview Method Request Summary of (Some of the) Questions How can we incorporate the expected behavior of the theoretical error based on naturalness and the EFT hierarchy? Frequently Asked Question: How much of the scattering data should be fit (i.e., up to what energy)? Traditionalist says: fit all data up to 35 MeV with χ 2 /dof 1 EFT practitioner says: only use the low-energy data How do we use all the data, accounting for the expected better description at low energy? How do we calculate uncertainties in our best-fit parameters? This is particularly important when using the fit to calculate elsewhere (e.g., nuclei)
Effective Field Theory for Many-Body Systems
Outline Systems EFT Dilute DFT Future Effective Field Theory for Many-Body Systems Department of Physics Ohio State University February 19, 2004 Outline Systems EFT Dilute DFT Future Principles of Effective
More informationRenormalization group methods in nuclear few- and many-body problems
Renormalization group methods in nuclear few- and many-body problems Lecture 2 S.K. Bogner (NSCL/MSU) 2011 National Nuclear Physics Summer School University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Lecture 2 outline
More informationEvgeny Epelbaum. Forschungszentrum Jülich & Universität Bonn
Evgeny Epelbaum KHuK Jahrestagung, GSI, 25.10.2007 Evgeny Epelbaum Forschungszentrum Jülich & Universität Bonn Outline Motivation & Introduction Few nucleons in chiral EFT: where do we stand Work in progress:
More informationAtomic Nuclei at Low Resolution
Atomic Department of Physics Ohio State University November, 29 Collaborators: E. Anderson, S. Bogner, S. Glazek, E. Jurgenson, R. Perry, S. Ramanan, A. Schwenk + UNEDF collaboration Overview DOFs EFT
More informationDense Matter for Dummies (Non-Experts)
for Dummies (Non-Experts) Department of Physics Ohio State University July, 26 Pictures have been freely borrowed from online sources; I apologize in advance for any omitted citations. Also, inclusion
More informationModern Theory of Nuclear Forces
Evgeny Epelbaum, FZ Jülich & University Bonn Lacanau, 28.09.2009 Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces Lecture 1: Lecture 2: Introduction & first look into ChPT EFTs for two nucleons Chiral Perturbation Theory
More informationRenormalization and power counting of chiral nuclear forces. 龙炳蔚 (Bingwei Long) in collaboration with Chieh-Jen Jerry Yang (U.
Renormalization and power counting of chiral nuclear forces 龙炳蔚 (Bingwei Long) in collaboration with Chieh-Jen Jerry Yang (U. Arizona) What are we really doing? Correcting Weinberg's scheme about NN contact
More informationPOWER COUNTING WHAT? WHERE?
POWER COUNTING WHAT? WHERE? U. van Kolck Institut de Physique Nucléaire d Orsay and University of Arizona Supported by CNRS and US DOE 1 Outline Meeting the elephant What? Where? Walking out of McDonald
More informationNuclear Forces - Lecture 1 -
Physics Department, Tohoku University, June 30 July 2, 2014 Nuclear Forces - Lecture 1 - Historical Perspective R. Machleidt University of Idaho 1 Nuclear Forces - Overview of all lectures - Lecture 1:
More informationThe theory of nuclear forces: Is the never-ending ending story coming to an end? R. Machleidt University of Idaho
The theory of nuclear forces: Is the never-ending ending story coming to an end? University of Idaho What s left to say? Put the recent progress into a wider perspective. Fill in some missing details.
More informationModern Theory of Nuclear Forces
Evgeny Epelbaum, FZ Jülich & University Bonn Lacanau, 29.09.2009 Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces Lecture 1: Lecture 2: Lecture 3: Introduction & first look into ChPT EFTs for two nucleons Nuclear forces
More informationChiral effective field theory on the lattice: Ab initio calculations of nuclei
Chiral effective field theory on the lattice: Ab initio calculations of nuclei Nuclear Lattice EFT Collaboration Evgeny Epelbaum (Bochum) Hermann Krebs (Bochum) Timo Lähde (Jülich) Dean Lee (NC State)
More informationNuclear Physics from Lattice Effective Field Theory
Nuclear Physics from Lattice Effective Field Theory Dean Lee (NCSU/Bonn) work done in collaboration with Evgeny Epelbaum (Bochum) Hermann Krebs (Bochum) Ulf-G. Meißner (Bonn/Jülich) Buḡra Borasoy (now
More informationPhysics 795 Nuclear Theory at OSU
Physics 795 Nuclear Theory at OSU Department of Physics Ohio State University October, 2006 Nuclear Theory Group Bunny Clark Ulrich Heinz Sabine Jeschonnek Yuri Kovchegov Robert Perry Current Students/Postdocs
More informationPion-nucleon scattering around the delta-isobar resonance
Pion-nucleon scattering around the delta-isobar resonance Bingwei Long (ECT*) In collaboration with U. van Kolck (U. Arizona) What do we really do Fettes & Meissner 2001... Standard ChPT Isospin 3/2 What
More informationNeutron matter from chiral effective field theory interactions
Neutron matter from chiral effective field theory interactions Ingo Tews, In collaboration with K. Hebeler, T. Krüger, A. Schwenk, JINA Neutron Stars, May 26, 2016, Athens, OH Chiral effective field theory
More informationTHE THREE NUCLEON SYSTEM AT LEADING ORDER OF CHIRAL EFFECTIVE THEORY
THE THREE NUCLEON SYSTEM AT LEADING ORDER OF CHIRAL EFFECTIVE THEORY Young-Ho Song(RISP, Institute for Basic Science) Collaboration with R. Lazauskas( IPHC, IN2P3-CNRS) U. van Kolck (Orsay, IPN & Arizona
More informationEffective Field Theory for Nuclear Physics! Akshay Vaghani! Mississippi State University!
Effective Field Theory for Nuclear Physics! Akshay Vaghani! Mississippi State University! Overview! Introduction! Basic ideas of EFT! Basic Examples of EFT! Algorithm of EFT! Review NN scattering! NN scattering
More informationRG & EFT for nuclear forces
RG & EFT for nuclear forces Andreas Nogga, Forschungszentrum Jülich ECT* school, Feb/March 2006 Low momentum interactions: Using the RG to simplify the nuclear force for many-body calculations. Application
More informationOverview of low energy NN interaction and few nucleon systems
1 Overview of low energy NN interaction and few nucleon systems Renato Higa Theory Group, Jefferson Lab Cebaf Center, A3 (ext6363) higa@jlaborg Lecture II Basics on chiral EFT π EFT Chiral effective field
More informationBayesian methods for effective field theories
Bayesian methods for effective field theories Sarah Wesolowski The Ohio State University INT Bayes Workshop 2016 a1! Prior! Posterior! True value! Dick Furnstahl (OSU) Daniel Phillips (OU) 0! a0! BUQEYE
More informationNuclear Forces - Lecture 1 - R. Machleidt University of Idaho
CNS Summer School, Univ. of Tokyo, at Wako campus of RIKEN, Aug. 18-23, 2005 Nuclear Forces - Lecture 1 - R. Machleidt University of Idaho 1 Nuclear Forces - Overview of all lectures - Lecture 1: History,
More informationAb Initio Nuclear Structure Theory
Ab Initio Nuclear Structure Theory Lecture 1: Hamiltonian Robert Roth Overview Lecture 1: Hamiltonian Prelude Many-Body Quantum Mechanics Nuclear Hamiltonian Matrix Elements Lecture 2: Correlations Two-Body
More informationLattice Simulations with Chiral Nuclear Forces
Lattice Simulations with Chiral Nuclear Forces Hermann Krebs FZ Jülich & Universität Bonn July 23, 2008, XQCD 2008, NCSU In collaboration with B. Borasoy, E. Epelbaum, D. Lee, U. Meißner Outline EFT and
More informationhg: Chiral Structure of Few-Nucleon Systems
Chiral Structure of Few-Nucleon Systems H. W. Grießhammer Center for Nuclear Studies, The George Washington University, Washington DC, USA D. R. Phillips: Chiral Dynamics with πs, Ns and s Done. hg: Chiral
More informationNuclear Structure and Neutron-Rich Matter
Nuclear Structure and Neutron-Rich Matter Dick Furnstahl Department of Physics Ohio State University August, 28 Pictures have been freely borrowed from online sources; I apologize in advance for any omitted
More informationNuclear structure I: Introduction and nuclear interactions
Nuclear structure I: Introduction and nuclear interactions Stefano Gandolfi Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) National Nuclear Physics Summer School Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) July
More informationLocal chiral NN potentials and the structure of light nuclei
Local chiral NN potentials and the structure of light nuclei Maria Piarulli @ELBA XIV WORKSHOP June 7-July 1 16, Marciana Marina, Isola d Elba PHYSICAL REVIEW C 91, 43(15) Minimally nonlocal nucleon-nucleon
More informationQuantum Monte Carlo calculations of two neutrons in finite volume
Quantum Monte Carlo calculations of two neutrons in finite volume Philipp Klos with J. E. Lynn, I. Tews, S. Gandolfi, A. Gezerlis, H.-W. Hammer, M. Hoferichter, and A. Schwenk Nuclear Physics from Lattice
More informationNuclear Structure and Reactions using Lattice Effective Field Theory
Nuclear Structure and Reactions using Lattice Effective Field Theory Dean Lee North Carolina State University Nuclear Lattice EFT Collaboration Frontiers of Nuclear Physics Kavli Institute for Theoretical
More informationNucleon-nucleon interaction in covariant chiral effective field theory
Guilin, China The Seventh Asia-Pacific Conference on Few-Body Problems in Physics Nucleon-nucleon interaction in covariant chiral effective field theory Xiu-Lei Ren School of Physics, Peking University
More informationQuantum Monte Carlo calculations with chiral Effective Field Theory Interactions
Quantum Monte Carlo calculations with chiral Effective Field Theory Interactions Alexandros Gezerlis East Lansing, MI 3rd International Symposium on Nuclear Symmetry Energy July 25, 2013 Motivation for
More informationNuclei as Bound States
Nuclei as Bound States Lecture 1: Hamiltonian Robert Roth Overview Lecture 1: Hamiltonian Prelude Nuclear Hamiltonian Matrix Elements Two-Body Problem Correlations & Unitary Transformations Lecture 2:
More informationNuclear forces and their impact on structure, reactions and astrophysics
Nuclear forces and their impact on structure, reactions and astrophysics Lectures for Week 2 Dick Furnstahl Ohio State University July, 213 M. Chiral EFT 1 (as); χ-symmetry in NN scattering, QCD 2 (rjf)
More informationFew Body Methods in Nuclear Physics - Lecture I
Few Body Methods in Nuclear Physics - Lecture I Nir Barnea The Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel Sept. 2010 Course Outline 1 Introduction - Few-Body Nuclear Physics 2 Gaussian Expansion - The Stochastic
More informationHadronic parity-violation in pionless effective field theory
Hadronic parity-violation in pionless effective field theory Matthias R. Schindler Ohio University PAVI9 June 25, 29 In collaboration with D. R. Phillips and R. P. Springer Introduction Effective Field
More informationNeutrino processes in supernovae from chiral EFT
Neutrino processes in supernovae from chiral EFT Achim Schwenk CANADA S NATIONAL LABORATORY FOR PARTICLE AND NUCLEAR PHYSICS Owned and operated as a joint venture by a consortium of Canadian universities
More informationEffective Field Theories in Nuclear and Hadron Physics
Effective Field Theories in Nuclear and Hadron Physics Vadim Lensky Theoretical Physics Group, The University of Manchester January 11, 2013 V. Lensky EFTs in Hadron and Nuclear Physics 1 Outline Introduction
More informationMicroscopically Based Energy Functionals. S.K. Bogner (NSCL/MSU)
Microscopically Based Energy Functionals S.K. Bogner (NSCL/MSU) Dream Scenario: From QCD to Nuclei 2 SciDAC 2 Project Building a Universal Nuclear Energy Density Functional See http://undef.org for details
More informationEFFECTIVE FIELD THEORY FOR LATTICE NUCLEI
EFFECTIVE FIELD THEORY FOR LATTICE NUCLEI Francesco Pederiva Physics Deparment Unversity of Trento INFN-TIFPA, Trento Institue for Fundamental Physics and Applications LISC, Interdisciplinary Laboratory
More informationQuantum Monte Carlo calculations of neutron and nuclear matter
Quantum Monte Carlo calculations of neutron and nuclear matter Stefano Gandolfi Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) Advances and perspectives in computational nuclear physics, Hilton Waikoloa Village,
More informationThree-nucleon forces and neutron-rich nuclei
Three-nucleon forces and neutron-rich nuclei Achim Schwenk Facets of Strong Interaction Physics Hirschegg 40 + Bengt 60, Jan. 18, 2012 Happy Birthday Bengt! Outline Understanding three-nucleon forces Three-body
More informationThe nucleon-nucleon system in chiral effective theory
The nucleon-nucleon system in chiral effective theory Daniel Phillips Ohio University Research supported by the US Department of Energy Plan χet for nuclear forces: the proposal Leading order for S waves
More informationQuantum Monte Carlo calculations of medium mass nuclei
Quantum Monte Carlo calculations of medium mass nuclei Diego Lonardoni FRIB Theory Fellow In collaboration with: J. Carlson, LANL S. Gandolfi, LANL X. Wang, Huzhou University, China A. Lovato, ANL & UniTN
More informationRenormalization group methods in nuclear few- and many-body problems
Renormalization group methods in nuclear few- and many-body problems Lecture 1 S.K. Bogner (NSCL/MSU) 2011 National Nuclear Physics Summer School University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Useful readings
More informationEFT as the bridge between Lattice QCD and Nuclear Physics
EFT as the bridge between Lattice QCD and Nuclear Physics David B. Kaplan QCHSVII Ponta Delgada, Açores, September 2006 National Institute for Nuclear Theory Nuclear physics from lattice QCD? Not yet,
More informationPion production in nucleon-nucleon collisions near threshold: complete NNLO calculation in chiral EFT
Pion production in nucleon-nucleon collisions near threshold: complete NNLO calculation in chiral EFT a, V. Baru ab, E. Epelbaum a, C. Hanhart c, H. Krebs a, and F. Myhrer d a Institut für Theoretische
More informationRecent results in lattice EFT for nuclei
Recent results in lattice EFT for nuclei Dean Lee (NC State) Nuclear Lattice EFT Collaboration Centro de Ciencias de Benasque Pedro Pascua Bound states and resonances in EFT and Lattice QCD calculations
More informationNuclear few- and many-body systems in a discrete variable representation basis
Nuclear few- and many-body systems in a discrete variable representation basis Jeremy W. Holt* Department of Physics University of Washington *with A. Bulgac, M. M. Forbes L. Coraggio, N. Itaco, R. Machleidt,
More informationN and (1232) masses and the γn transition. Marc Vanderhaeghen College of William & Mary / Jefferson Lab
N and (1232) masses and the γn transition Marc Vanderhaeghen College of William & Mary / Jefferson Lab Hadron Structure using lattice QCD, INT, April 4, 2006 Outline 1) N and masses : relativistic chiral
More informationINTRODUCTION TO EFFECTIVE FIELD THEORIES OF QCD
INTRODUCTION TO EFFECTIVE FIELD THEORIES OF QCD U. van Kolck Institut de Physique Nucléaire d Orsay and University of Arizona Supported in part by CNRS, Université Paris Sud, and US DOE Outline Effective
More informationHadronic Weak Interactions
1 / 44 Hadronic Weak Interactions Matthias R. Schindler Fundamental Neutron Physics Summer School 2015 Some slides courtesy of N. Fomin 2 / 44 Weak interactions - One of fundamental interactions - Component
More informationIntroduction to Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD)
Introduction to Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) Jianwei Qiu Theory Center, Jefferson Lab May 29 June 15, 2018 Lecture One The plan for my four lectures q The Goal: To understand the strong interaction dynamics
More informationNuclear Forces - Lecture 6 -
Physics Department, Tohoku University, June 30 July 2, 2014 Nuclear Forces - Lecture 6 - Nuclear many-body forces from chiral EFT R. Machleidt University of Idaho 1 Nuclear Forces - Overview of all lectures
More informationAbstract. 1 r 2n+m (1)
MENU 27 11th International Conference on Meson-Nucleon Physics and the Structure of the Nucleon September1-14, 27 IKP, Forschungzentrum Jülich, Germany RENORMALIZING THE SCHRÖDINGER EQUATION FOR NN SCATTERING
More informationApplications of Renormalization Group Methods in Nuclear Physics 2
Applications of Renormalization Group Methods in Nuclear Physics 2 Dick Furnstahl Department of Physics Ohio State University HUGS 2014 Outline: Lecture 2 Lecture 2: SRG in practice Recap from lecture
More informationCarbon-12 in Nuclear Lattice EFT
Carbon-12 in Nuclear Lattice EFT Nuclear Lattice EFT Collaboration Evgeny Epelbaum (Bochum) Hermann Krebs (Bochum) Timo A. Lähde (Jülich) Dean Lee (NC State) Thomas Luu (Jülich) Ulf-G. Meißner (Bonn/Jülich)
More informationAb initio lattice EFT from light to medium mass nuclei Nuclear Lattice EFT Collaboration
Ab initio lattice EFT from light to medium mass nuclei Nuclear Lattice EFT Collaboration Evgeny Epelbaum (Bochum) Hermann Krebs (Bochum) Timo Lähde (Jülich) Dean Lee (NC State) Thomas Luu (Jülich/Bonn)
More informationAlex Gezerlis. New Ideas in Constraining Nuclear Forces ECT*, Trento, Italy June 5, 2018
Quantum Monte Carlo interactions with From microscopic to effective Chiral Effective Field Theory Interactions using Quantum Monte Carlo Alex Gezerlis New Ideas in Constraining Nuclear Forces ECT*, Trento,
More informationDepartment of Physics, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID 83844, USA; Tel.:
S S symmetry Article Chiral Symmetry and the Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction Ruprecht Machleidt Department of Physics, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID 83844, USA; machleid@uidaho.edu; Tel.: +1-28-885-638 Academic
More informationarxiv: v1 [nucl-th] 31 Oct 2013
Renormalization Group Invariance in the Subtractive Renormalization Approach to the NN Interactions S. Szpigel and V. S. Timóteo arxiv:1311.61v1 [nucl-th] 31 Oct 13 Faculdade de Computação e Informática,
More informationNUCLEAR FORCES. Historical perspective
NUCLEAR FORCES Figure 1: The atomic nucleus made up from protons (yellow) and neutrons (blue) and held together by nuclear forces. Nuclear forces (also known as nuclear interactions or strong forces) are
More informationSome new developments in relativistic point-coupling models
Some new developments in relativistic point-coupling models T. J. Buervenich 1, D. G. Madland 1, J. A. Maruhn 2, and P.-G. Reinhard 3 1 Los Alamos National Laboratory 2 University of Frankfurt 3 University
More informationMeson Baryon Scattering
Meson Baryon Scattering Aaron Torok Department of Physics, Indiana University May 31, 2010 Meson Baryon Scattering in Lattice QCD Calculation of the π + Σ +, and π + Ξ 0 scattering lengths Aaron Torok
More informationUltracold atoms and neutron-rich matter in nuclei and astrophysics
Ultracold atoms and neutron-rich matter in nuclei and astrophysics Achim Schwenk NORDITA program Pushing the boundaries with cold atoms Stockholm, Jan. 23, 2013 Outline Advances in nuclear forces 3N forces
More informationLight hypernuclei based on chiral and phenomenological interactions
Mitglied der Helmholtz-Gemeinschaft Light hypernuclei based on chiral and phenomenological interactions Andreas Nogga, Forschungszentrum Jülich International Conference on Hypernuclear and Strange Particle
More informationEffective Field Theory for Density Functional Theory I
Effective Field Theory for Density Functional Theory I Department of Physics Ohio State University February, 26 I. Overview of EFT, RG, DFT for fermion many-body systems II. EFT/DFT for dilute Fermi systems
More informationNeutron-rich matter and neutrino-matter interactions based on chiral effective field theory
Neutron-rich matter and neutrino-matter interactions based on chiral effective field theory Achim Schwenk Astrophysical Transients: Multi-Messenger Probes of Nuclear Physics INT, July 29, 2011 Outline
More informationChiral dynamics and NN potential
Chiral dynamics and NN potential Department of Physics University of Bologna 40126 Bologna (Italy) paolo.finelli@bo.infn.it Otranto Summer School 1935 Yukawa: Meson Theory The Pion Theories 1950 s One-Pion
More informationEffective Field Theory
Effective Field Theory Iain Stewart MIT The 19 th Taiwan Spring School on Particles and Fields April, 2006 Physics compartmentalized Quantum Field Theory String Theory? General Relativity short distance
More informationCurrent status and challenges of ab-initio computations of nuclei
Current status and challenges of ab-initio computations of nuclei Gaute Hagen Oak Ridge National Laboratory INT workshop on Nuclear Physics from Lattice QCD INT, May 5th, 2016 Computing real nuclei from
More informationNuclear structure Anatoli Afanasjev Mississippi State University
Nuclear structure Anatoli Afanasjev Mississippi State University 1. Nuclear theory selection of starting point 2. What can be done exactly (ab-initio calculations) and why we cannot do that systematically?
More informationElectroweak Probes of Three-Nucleon Systems
Stetson University July 3, 08 Brief Outline Form factors of three-nucleon systems Hadronic parity-violation in three-nucleon systems Pionless Effective Field Theory Ideally suited for momenta p < m π since
More informationThree-nucleon potentials in nuclear matter. Alessandro Lovato
Three-nucleon potentials in nuclear matter Alessandro Lovato PRC 83, 054003 (2011) arxiv:1109.5489 Outline Ab initio many body method Nuclear Hamiltonian: 2- and 3- body potentials Density dependent potential
More informationThe Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction
Brazilian Journal of Physics, vol. 34, no. 3A, September, 2004 845 The Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction J. Haidenbauer Forschungszentrum Jülich, Institut für Kernphysik, D-52425 Jülich, Germany Received on
More informationThe non-perturbative N/D method and the 1 S 0 NN partial wave
HADRONet p. 1 The non-perturbative N/D method and the 1 S NN partial wave 2nd Spanish Hadron Network Days Madrid, September 216 D.R. Entem, J.A. Oller University of Salamanca HADRONet p. 2 Summary The
More informationarxiv:nucl-th/ v1 28 Aug 2001
A meson exchange model for the Y N interaction J. Haidenbauer, W. Melnitchouk and J. Speth arxiv:nucl-th/1862 v1 28 Aug 1 Forschungszentrum Jülich, IKP, D-52425 Jülich, Germany Jefferson Lab, 1 Jefferson
More informationModern Theory of Nuclear Forces
Evgeny Epelbaum PAX Meeting, Stockholm, 15.06.2010 Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces Evgeny Epelbaum, Ruhr-Universität Bochum Outline Chiral EFT for nuclear forces Some hot topics (work in progress) Deuteron
More informationFROM QCD TO NUCLEI: ASPECTS OF NUCLEAR THEORY IN FRANCE
FROM QCD TO NUCLEI: ASPECTS OF NUCLEAR THEORY IN FRANCE Ubirajara van Kolck Institut de Physique Nucléaire 1 Outline Hadronic theory in France Nuclear forces from QCD Low-energy nuclear theory in France
More informationThree-nucleon forces and shell structure of neutron-rich Ca isotopes
Three-nucleon forces and shell structure of neutron-rich Ca isotopes Javier Menéndez Institut für Kernphysik (TU Darmstadt) and ExtreMe Matter Institute (EMMI) NUSTAR Week 3, Helsinki, 9 October 13 Outline
More informationU. van Kolck. Institut de Physique Nucléaire d Orsay. and University of Arizona. Supported in part by CNRS, Université Paris Sud, and US DOE
THE NON-PC STORY A SERMON OF ABOUT CHIRAL PC EFT U. van Kolck Institut de Physique Nucléaire d Orsay and University of Arizona Supported in part by CNRS, Université Paris Sud, and US DOE 1 Why? Chiral
More informationNuclear structure from chiral-perturbation-theory two- plus three-nucleon interactions
Nuclear structure from chiral-perturbation-theory two- plus three-nucleon interactions Petr Navratil Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory* Collaborators: W. E. Ormand (LLNL), J. P. Vary (ISU), E. Caurier
More informationChiral EFT for nuclear forces with Delta isobar degrees of freedom
with Delta isobar degrees of freedom Helmholtz-Institut für Strahlen- und Kernphysik (Theorie) and Bethe Center for Theoretical Physics, Universität Bonn, Nußallee 4-6, D-535 Bonn, Germany E-mail: hkrebs@itkp.uni-bonn.de
More informationHyperon-Nucleon Scattering
Hyperon-Nucleon Scattering In A Covariant Chiral Effective Field Theory Approach Kai-Wen Li In collaboration with Xiu-Lei Ren, Bing-Wei Long and Li-Sheng Geng @INPC, Adelaide September, 2016 School of
More informationThe Phases of QCD. Thomas Schaefer. North Carolina State University
The Phases of QCD Thomas Schaefer North Carolina State University 1 Motivation Different phases of QCD occur in the universe Neutron Stars, Big Bang Exploring the phase diagram is important to understanding
More informationThe Nuclear Force Problem: Is the Never-Ending Story Coming to an End?
The Nuclear Force Problem: Is the Never-Ending Story Coming to an End? R. Machleidt Department of Physics, University of Idaho, Moscow, Idaho, USA Abstract. The attempts to find the right (underlying)
More informationRole of Spin in NN NNπ
Spin Physics (SPIN2014) International Journal of Modern Physics: Conference Series Vol. 40 (2016) 1660061 (6 pages) c The Author(s) DOI: 10.1142/S2010194516600612 Role of Spin in NN NNπ Vadim Baru Institut
More informationConstraints on neutron stars from nuclear forces
Constraints on neutron stars from nuclear forces Achim Schwenk Workshop on the formation and evolution of neutron stars Bonn, Feb. 27, 2012 Main points Advances in nuclear forces and nuclear matter theory
More informationThe symmetries of QCD (and consequences)
The symmetries of QCD (and consequences) Sinéad M. Ryan Trinity College Dublin Quantum Universe Symposium, Groningen, March 2018 Understand nature in terms of fundamental building blocks The Rumsfeld
More informationThe Nuclear Many-Body Problem
The Nuclear Many-Body Problem relativistic heavy ions vacuum electron scattering quarks gluons radioactive beams heavy few nuclei body quark-gluon soup QCD nucleon QCD few body systems many body systems
More informationRenormalization group methods in nuclear few- and many-body problems
Renormalization group methods in nuclear few- and many-body problems Lecture 1 S.K. Bogner (NSCL/MSU) 2011 National Nuclear Physics Summer School University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Useful readings
More informationThe NN system: why and how we iterate
The NN system: why and how we iterate Daniel Phillips Ohio University Research supported by the US department of energy Plan Why we iterate I: contact interactions Why we iterate II: pion exchange How
More informationCoupled-cluster theory for nuclei
Coupled-cluster theory for nuclei Thomas Papenbrock and G. Hagen D. J. Dean M. Hjorth-Jensen B. Velamur Asokan INT workshop Weakly-bound systems in atomic and nuclear physics Seattle, March 8-12, 2010
More informationFlavor Asymmetry of the Nucleon Sea and W-Boson Production*
Flavor Asymmetry of the Nucleon Sea and W-Boson Production* Department of Physics University of Illinois 7 December 2012 *R. Yang, J.C. Peng, M. Grosse-Perdekamp, Phys. Lett. B 680 (2009) 231-234 What
More informationWeakly-Bound Systems in Atomic and Nuclear Physics March 2010
Electroweak properties of Weakly- Bound Light Nuclei Weakly-Bound Systems in Atomic and Nuclear Physics March 2010 INSTITUTE FOR NUCLEAR THEORY Collaborators Sonia Bacca Winfried Leidemann, Giuseppina
More informationPoS(Confinement8)147. Universality in QCD and Halo Nuclei
Helmholtz-Institut für Strahlen- und Kernphysik (Theorie) and Bethe Center for Theoretical Physics, University of Bonn, Germany E-mail: hammer@itkp.uni-bonn.de Effective Field Theory (EFT) provides a powerful
More informationNational Nuclear Physics Summer School Lectures on Effective Field Theory. Brian Tiburzi. RIKEN BNL Research Center
2014 National Nuclear Physics Summer School Lectures on Effective Field Theory I. Removing heavy particles II. Removing large scales III. Describing Goldstone bosons IV. Interacting with Goldstone bosons
More informationarxiv: v2 [nucl-th] 9 Jan 2013
Reduced regulator dependence of neutron-matter predictions with perturbative chiral interactions arxiv:9.5537v [nucl-th] 9 Jan 3 L. Coraggio, J. W. Holt,, 3 N. Itaco,, R. Machleidt, 5 and F. Sammarruca
More informationarxiv:nucl-th/ v1 18 Feb 1999
FZJ-IKP(TH)-1999-04 arxiv:nucl-th/9902042v1 18 Feb 1999 Charge independence breaking and charge symmetry breaking in the nucleon nucleon interaction from effective field theory E. Epelbaum, a,b#1 Ulf-G.
More informationHadronic Interactions and Nuclear Physics
Williamsburg,VA LATT2008 7/2008 p. 1/35 Hadronic Interactions and Nuclear Physics Silas Beane University of New Hampshire Williamsburg,VA LATT2008 7/2008 p. 2/35 Outline Motivation Signal/Noise Estimates
More information