Yusuke Tomita (Shibaura Inst. of Tech.) Yukitoshi Motome (Univ. Tokyo) PRL 107, (2011) arxiv: (proceedings of LT26)

Transcription

1 Yusuke Tomita (Shibaura Inst. of Tech.) Yukitoshi Motome (Univ. Tokyo) PRL 107, (2011) arxiv: (proceedings of LT26)

2 Spin glass (SG) in frustrated magnets SG is widely observed in geometrically frustrated materials. SrCr9pGa12-9pO19 (SCGO, pyrochlore slab), R2Mo2O7 (pyrochlore), etc. What is the role of frustration and randomness? How is it different from the conventional SG behavior? Classical Heisenberg antiferromagnet on a pyrochlore lattice H = J i,j S i S j Nearest neighbor AF exchange interaction = J 2 Classical spin liquid with continuous macroscopic degeneracy S α 2 const. Sα = α Sum rule for the ground state: For every tetrahedron,! i tetra(α) Freezing temperature Spin glass S i T. E. Saunders and J. T. Chalker (2007) A. Andreanov et al. (2010) randomness in exchange interaction

3 Susceptibility Inverse susceptibility Y2Mo2O7 S=1 pyrochlore AF magnet!cw = -200 K No uniform lattice distortion Freezing temperature 14 Puzzle #1: Tf does NOT strongly depend on the strength of disorder and the Curie-Weiss temperature!cw. (LaxY1-x)2Mo2O7 x=0!cw = -60 K x -w m 12 i %+_ "+ + \ ++ " " "~+,+ + "+~ x=0.5!cw = 41 K 03 Temperature (K) TEMPERATURE (K) I I I I I I I I TEMPERATURE (K. ) Temperature (K) M. Sato et al., (1987) N.B.!CW depends on the temperature range. Puzzle #2: high Tf theoretical estimate for Y2Mo2O7 Tf ~ 0.5 K Tf/! = T. E. Saunders and J. T. Chalker (2007); A. Andreanov et al. (2010)!/J ~ 5% C. H. Booth et al. (2000)

4 Peculiar SG behaviors in pyrochlore-based magnets Temperature [K] R2Mo2O7 (d) R 2 Mo 2 O 7 Eu 1-x La x, Eu 1-x Y x Sm 1-x Ho x Nd Sm Tf does not depend on R. 40 Dy Tb Gd Eu FM 20 SGI SGM R 3+ ionic radius [Å] T. Katsufuji et al. (2000), S. Iguchi et al. (2009) (Zn1-xCdx)Cr2O4 S=3/2 pyrochlore AF magnet Spin-lattice order for ZnCr2O4 Néel order + uniform lattice distortion W. Ratcliff II et al. (2002) Tf ~ const. Spin glass Importance of coupling to local lattice distortions has been pointed out for Y2Mo2O7 by local probes (NMR, etc.). C. Booth et al. (2000), A. Keren et al. (2001), E. Sagi et al. (2005), J. E. Greedan et al. (2009), O. Ofer et al., (2010) Cd substitution (disorder) How does spin-lattice coupling affect SG behaviors?

5 Model Classical Heisenberg model coupled with local lattice distortions change in bond length Exchange randomness integrating out lattice degrees of freedom Nearest-neighbor biquadratic interaction Contribution from independent local distortions Cooperative coupling of phonons Spatial correlations of "ij We take b=0.2. b=0.1 for CdCr2O4 and HgCr2O4 Y. Motome et al. (2006) " Spin-lattice order D. L. Bergman et al. (2006) O. Tchernyshyov et al. (2002)

6 Model! two-up two-down spin collinear configuration within each tetrahedron??????! cf. Absence of spinlattice coupling! Spin quadruple (nematic) order below Tc NO magnetic order Spin-ice type macroscopic degeneracy q=0 AF order below TN J. N. Reimers et al. (1991); G-W. Chern et al., (2008) How does SG appear when! > 0?!"#$%&'()) Classical Monte Carlo simulation using an extended version of the loop algorithm for the spin-ice problem HS and Y. Motome, PRB 82, (2010); HS and Y. Tomita and Y. Motome, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 320, (2011).

7 Calculated phase diagram Plateau behavior of Tf for! > b Remarkable enhancement of Tf for! < b T f T f (b = 0) 5 Bond disorder

8 Origin of peculiar SG behaviors Energy Biquadratic coupling b( S i S j ) 2 favors spin collinearity.! Modification of the structure of degenerate manifold from continuous to semi-discrete (multi-valley)! Suppression of thermal fluctuations! Enhancement of Tf Ice-rule configurations Phase space T T c ~ b nematic b Schematic phase diagram paramagnetic spin glass (concomitant with nematic order) Tf for b=0 The enhancement of Tf by spin collinearity does not work above Tc.! Tf is saturated at Tc ~ b.! disorder

9 Plateau regime: specific heat Concomitant transition seems to be continuous. Total # of spins = 16L 3 Broad peak of the specific heat at Tf Consistent with experiment for Y2Mo2O7 cf. no clear singularity at Tf for conventional SG N. P. Raju et al. (1992)

10 Plateau regime: Curie-Weiss temperature!cw Tf stays almost constant despite the change in!cw. cf. (LaxY1-x)2Mo2O7 M. Sato et al. (1987) Inverse magnetic susceptibility Curie-Weiss temperature Tf !CW

11 Effects of cooperative lattice distortions (Zn1-xCdx)Cr2O4 Spin glass Bond disorder x Cd substitution Robust plateau behavior of Tf at high T The competing phase diagram and Tf ~ const. in (Zn,Cd)Cr2O4 are well reproduced.

12 Summary Unconventional spin-glass behaviors induced by spinlattice coupling High Tf Robust plateau behavior of Tf A comprehensive understanding of peculiar spin-glass behaviors in frustrated magnets, such as R2Mo2O7 and ACr2O4. Hiroshi Shinaoka, Yusuke Tomita, and Yukitoshi Motome PRL 107, (2011) arxiv: (proceedings of LT26)