Transmission capacity allocation in zonal electricity markets
|
|
- Alisha Flynn
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Transmission capacity allocation in zonal electricity markets Anthony Papavasiliou (UC Louvain) Collaborators: Ignacio Aravena (LLNL), Yves Smeers (UC Louvain) Workshop on Flexible Operation and Advanced Control for Energy Systems, Isaac Newton Institute for Mathematical Sciences, University of Cambridge. January 7 th -11 th, INI Workshop
2 Outline 1. Introduction 2. Day-ahead zonal electricity market models 3. Policy analysis using 4-node, 3-zone network 4. Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead zonal electricity markets 5. Simulation results for the Central Western European network 6. Conclusions INI Workshop
3 Introduction Day-ahead electricity market models Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead electricity markets Simulation results for the Central Western European network Conclusions Introduction Appendix INI Workshop
4 Zonal electricity markets European electricity market organized as a zonal market, EC 714/2009 Two types of export/import limits: Limits on the bilateral exchange between neighbouring zones, Available-Transfer-Capacity Market Coupling (ATCMC) Limits on the net position configuration of zones, Flow-Based Market Coupling (FBMC) Both methodologies should be N-1 robust (Critical Branches/Critical Outages), Amprion et al. (2017) FBMC used to clear day-ahead electricity market at the Central Western European system since May 2015 Other markets might implement FBMC in the near future (e.g. Nord Pool, Energinet et al. (2017)) INI Workshop
5 Flow-Based Market Coupling (FBMC) Preferred methodology for electricity market operations of the EC, EU 2015/1222:... a method that takes into account that electricity can flow via different paths and optimizes the available capacity in highly interdependent grids... Increases in day-ahead market welfare of 95Me/year with respect to ATCMC, Amprion et al. (2013) Congestion management and balancing costs not included in studies. They amounted to 945Me in 2015, ENTSO-E (2015). Questions: Do FBMC or ATCMC correctly account for physical flows? Why do they/do they not? Does FBMC significantly improve the overall welfare of the market with respect to ATCMC? INI Workshop
6 Literature Jensen et al. (2017), and many references therein, study ATCMC and conclude that its performance is significantly worse than that of a nodal market Waniek et al. (2009), Waniek et al. (2010) study the accuracy of the approximation of flows in FBMC at cross-border lines Marien et al. (2013) study how discretionary aggregation parameters (for export/import limits) affect the outcome of FBMC Van den Bergh et al. (2015) summarize the concepts and methodology used for FBMC at the Central Western European system Dierstein (2017) analyzes the impacts of discretionary aggregation parameters on welfare, exchanges, prices and counter-trading costs INI Workshop
7 Contributions 1. We propose a new framework for modelling ATCMC and FBMC in which we derive export/import limitations directly from the physics of the real network. (the proposed models do not depend on discretionary aggregation parameters) 2. We present cutting-plane algorithms to systematically account for the N-1 security criterion on day-ahead markets. 3. We perform numerical simulations using an industrial-scale instance of the Central Western European system considering 100 years of operating conditions. Vast similarities between ATCMC and FBMC in all aspects. Zonal market designs fail at allocating transmission capacity and are outperformed by a nodal market. INI Workshop
8 Introduction Day-ahead electricity market models Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead electricity markets Simulation results for the Central Western European network Day-ahead electricity market models Conclusions Appendix INI Workshop
9 Assumptions 1. All energy trades take place at the day-ahead auction 2. Bids are price-quantity pairs, associated with a node/zone 3. Participants bid truthfully 4. System operator knows: Topology of the network Susceptance and thermal limits of lines Installed production capacity at each node 5. Consumers have an infinite valuation (only for simplicity) INI Workshop
10 Nodal electricity market min bids, flows production cost s.t. fractional bids net production = outgoing flows, at each node line thermal limits n 2 l 12 n 1 l 23 l 41 B n 3 l 34 n 4 power-angle constraints INI Workshop
11 Nodal electricity market min v,f,θ g G P g Q g v g s.t. 0 v g 1 g G Q g v g Q n = g G(n) l L(n, ) f l l L(,n) F l f l F l l L f l n N [ρ n ] f l = B l ( θm(l) θ n(l) ) l L n 2 l 12 n 1 l 23 l 41 B G = {1,2,3,4}, G(n 1 ) = {1},... N = {n 1,n 2,n 3,n 4 } n 3 l 34 n 4 P,Q: price and quantity F l,b l : capacity and susceptance line l L = {l 12,l 23,l 34,l 41 }, L(n 1,n 2 ) = {l 12 },... INI Workshop
12 Zonal network organization B n 3 l 23 n 2 l 12 l 34 n 1 A l 41 C n 4 G = {1,2,3,4}, G(A) = {1,2},... N = {n 1,n 2,n 3,n 4 }, N(A) = {n 1,n 2 },... INI Workshop
13 Flow-Based Market Coupling with Approximation (FBMC-A) 1. Select a base case (p 0,f 0 ) (net positions, flows on branches) p B p 0 B f 0 l 23 f 0 l 12 f 0 l 34 f 0 l 41 p 0 A p A p 0 C p C INI Workshop
14 Flow-Based Market Coupling with Approximation (FBMC-A) 1. Select a base case (p 0,f 0 ) (net positions, flows on branches) 2. Compute zone-to-line Power- Transfer-Distribution-Factors, PTDF l,z, so that f l z Z PTDF l,z p z f 0 l 12 f l12 f 0 l 23 f l23 f fl 0 l34 34 f l34 p B p 0 B f 0 l 41 p 0 A p A p 0 C p C INI Workshop
15 Flow-Based Market Coupling with Approximation (FBMC-A) 1. Select a base case (p 0,f 0 ) (net positions, flows on branches) p B p 0 B 2. Compute zone-to-line Power- Transfer-Distribution-Factors, PTDF l,z, so that f 0 l 12 f l12 f 0 l 23 f l23 f fl 0 l34 34 f l z ZPTDF l,z p z f l34 3. Define flow-based { domain: P FB A := p R Z p z = 0, z Z p 0 A p A f 0 l 41 p 0 C p C F l z ZPTDF } l,z (p z p 0 z)+fl 0 F l l L INI Workshop
16 Flow-Based Market Coupling with Approximation (FBMC-A) 4. Clear day-ahead market by solving: min v,p g G P g Q g v g s.t. 0 v g 1 g G Q g v g g G(z) p z = 0 z Z n N(z) Q n = p z z Z [ρ z ] F l z ZPTDF l,z (p z p 0 z)+f 0 l F l l L Circular definitions: base case (p 0,f 0 ), market clearing point Discretionary parameters: zone-to-line PTDF (among others) INI Workshop
17 Zonal electricity market min v,p g G P g Q g v g s.t. 0 v g 1 g G Q g v g g G(z) n N(z) p z z Z [ρ z ] p P Q n = P should include all feasible cross-border trades, EC 714/2009, Annex I, Art. 1.1 P should not include configurations that can harm security, EC 714/2009, Annex I, Art. 1.7 n 2 l 12 n 1 A l 23 l 41 B C G = {1,2,3,4}, G(A) = {1,2},... N = {n 1,n 2,n 3,n 4 }, N(A) = {n 1,n 2 },... n 3 l 34 n 4 INI Workshop
18 Deriving P directly from physics: an example Physics: n 2 r 1 +r 2 +r 3 = r r r f 12 = 1/3r 1 1/3r 2 25 n 1 A B l 12 l 31 l 23 n 3 Zonal net positions: p A = r 1 p B = r 2 +r 3 G = {1,2,3} Q 1 = 200, Q 2 = 200, Q 3 = 50 N = {n 1,n 2,n 3 } L = {l 12,l 23,l 31 }, F 12 = MW demand per node INI Workshop
19 Deriving P directly from physics: an example Physics: r 1 +r 2 +r 3 = r r r f 12 = 1/3r 1 1/3r 2 25 Are these zonal net positions feasible? p A = 0 p B = 0 p A = 200 p B = 200 p A = 100 p B = 100 p A = 50 p B = 50 Zonal net positions: p A = r 1 p B = r 2 +r 3 INI Workshop
20 Deriving P directly from physics: an example Physics: r 1 +r 2 +r 3 = r r r f 12 = 1/3r 1 1/3r 2 25 Are these zonal net positions feasible? p A = 0 p B = 0 Yes p A = 200 p B = 200 p A = 100 p B = 100 p A = 50 p B = 50 Zonal net positions: p A = r 1 p B = r 2 +r 3 INI Workshop
21 Deriving P directly from physics: an example Physics: r 1 +r 2 +r 3 = r r r f 12 = 1/3r 1 1/3r 2 25 Are these zonal net positions feasible? p A = 0 p B = 0 Yes p A = 200 p B = 200 No p A = 100 p B = 100 p A = 50 p B = 50 Zonal net positions: p A = r 1 p B = r 2 +r 3 INI Workshop
22 Deriving P directly from physics: an example Physics: r 1 +r 2 +r 3 = r r r f 12 = 1/3r 1 1/3r 2 25 Are these zonal net positions feasible? p A = 0 p B = 0 Yes p A = 200 p B = 200 No p A = 100 p B = 100 p A = 50 p B = 50 No Zonal net positions: p A = r 1 p B = r 2 +r 3 INI Workshop
23 Deriving P directly from physics: an example Physics: r 1 +r 2 +r 3 = r r r f 12 = 1/3r 1 1/3r 2 25 Are these zonal net positions feasible? p A = 0 p B = 0 Yes p A = 200 p B = 200 No p A = 100 p B = 100 No p A = 50 p B = 50 Yes Zonal net positions: p A = r 1 p B = r 2 +r 3 INI Workshop
24 Deriving P directly from physics: an example Physics: r 1 +r 2 +r 3 = r r r f 12 = 1/3r 1 1/3r 2 25 Are these zonal net positions feasible? p A = 0 p B = 0 Yes p A = 200 p B = 200 No p A = 100 p B = 100 No p A = 50 p B = 50 Yes Zonal net positions: p A = r 1 p B = r 2 +r 3 True net position feasible set P: p A +p B = p A 87.5 INI Workshop
25 Flow-Based Market Coupling with Exact Projection (FBMC-EP) space of nodal injections space of zonal net positions R := { r R N r is feasible for the real network } 4-node, 3-zone network: p A = r 1 +r 2, p B = r 3, p C = r 4 INI Workshop
26 Flow-Based Market Coupling with Exact Projection (FBMC-EP) space of nodal injections space of zonal net positions R := { r R N r is feasible for the real network } P FB EP := { p R Z r R : p z = r n z Z } n N(z) 4-node, 3-zone network: p A = r 1 +r 2, p B = r 3, p C = r 4 INI Workshop
27 Flow-Based Market Coupling with Exact Projection (FBMC-EP) P FB EP = { p R Z ( v,f,θ) [0,1] G R L R N : g G(z) g G(n) Q g v g p z = Q g v g l L(n, ) n N(z) Q n z Z, f l + l L(,n) f l = Q n n N, F l f l F l, f l = B l ( θm(l) θ n(l) ) l L } P FB EP allows for all trades that are feasible with respect to the real network and bans only trades that can be proven to be infeasible for the real network P FB A provides no guarantees: might ban feasible trades and, also, allow infeasible trades INI Workshop
28 Available-Transfer-Capacity Market Coupling (ATCMC) net positions of zones Z l 23 B n 3 flow on interconnectors between zones T t AB B n 2 l 12 l 34 t BC n 1 A l 41 C n 4 A t CA C ATCMC clears day-ahead market over the network G(Z, T) Available-transfer-capacities (ATCs): ATC t e t ATC + t How to compute ATCs? INI Workshop
29 Available-Transfer-Capacity Market Coupling (ATCMC) space of zonal net positions space of exchanges P FB EP INI Workshop
30 Available-Transfer-Capacity Market Coupling (ATCMC) space of zonal net positions space of exchanges P FB EP { E := e R T l L(t) p P : p z = t T(z, ) F l e t e t l L(t) t T(,z) F l t T, } e t z Z INI Workshop
31 Maximum-volume Available-Transfer-Capacities (ATCs) ATC limits, ATC t e t ATC + t t T, are a box in the space of exchanges Compute ATCs as a maximum volume box inside E, max ATC (ATCt +ATC t + ) t T s.t. [ ATC,ATC + ] E E ATC := [ ATC,,ATC +, ] allows for the largest subset of bilateral exchanges that can be accommodated using a box and it bans all trades that would result in infeasible zonal net positions Implemented methodology for computing ATCs provides no guarantees INI Workshop
32 Maximum-volume Available-Transfer-Capacities (ATCs) space of zonal net positions space of exchanges P E INI Workshop
33 Maximum-volume Available-Transfer-Capacities (ATCs) space of zonal net positions space of exchanges P E, E ATC = [ ATC,,ATC +, ] INI Workshop
34 Maximum-volume Available-Transfer-Capacities (ATCs) space of zonal net positions space of exchanges P { P ATC := p R Z e E ATC : p z = e t } e t z Z t T(z, ) t T(,z) E, E ATC = [ ATC,,ATC +, ] INI Workshop
35 Introduction Day-ahead electricity market models Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead electricity markets Simulation results for the Central Western European network Conclusions Policy analysis using 4-node, 3-zone network Appendix INI Workshop
36 Recap: 4 policies LMP: Minimizes cost over nodal model FBMC-A: Minimizes cost over zonal model with P = P FB A FBMC-EP: Minimizes cost over zonal model with P = P FB EP ATCMC: Minimizes cost over zonal model with P = P ATC INI Workshop
37 Inter-zonal congestion case study n 2 l 12 l 23 B n 3 l 34 Generators Q g P g g n(g) [MW] [$/MWh] 1 n n n n n 1 A l 41 C B l = 1pu l L n 4 Consumers Q n n [MW] n n F l41 = 100MW,F l = + l L\{l 41 } INI Workshop
38 Inter-zonal congestion: results Summary of clearing quantities and prices for a case of inter-zonal congestion (l 41 limited to 100MW) Policy Total Abs. error Overload ρ [$/MWh] cost [$] flow approx. [MW] l 41 [MW] LMP (8, 45, 82, 119) 0 0 FBMC-A (8, 18, 200) FBMC-EP (8, 18, 23) ATCMC (8, 18, 200) 50 Cleared quantities on all zonal markets overload line l 41 : failure to account for inter-zonal congestion Flow approximation error and overload larger in FBMC-A than in FBMC-EP Cost of ATCMC larger than cost of LMP, ATCMC clears at an infeasible point INI Workshop
39 Inter-zonal congestion: space of zonal net positions Limited flow on inter zonal line l 41 Net position zone B [MW] LMP FBMC A FBMC EP ATCMC Net position zone A [MW] Vertically shaded area: P FB A P FB EP Horizontally shaded area: P FB EP P FB A INI Workshop
40 Intra-zonal congestion case study n 2 l 12 l 23 B n 3 l 34 Generators Q g P g g n(g) [MW] [$/MWh] 1 n n n n n 1 A l 41 C B l = 1pu l L n 4 Consumers Q n n [MW] n n F l12 = 100MW,F l = + l L\{l 12 } INI Workshop
41 Intra-zonal congestion: results Summary of clearing quantities and prices for a case of intra-zonal congestion (l 12 limited to 100MW) Policy Total Abs. error Overload ρ [$/MWh] cost [$] flow approx. [MW] l 12 [MW] LMP (8, 45, 32.7, 20.3) 0 0 FBMC-A (18, 18, 200) FBMC-EP (18, 18, 18) ATCMC (8, 18, 200) 108 Cleared quantities on all zonal markets overload line l 12 : failure to account for intra-zonal congestion Flow approximation error larger in FBMC-A than in FBMC-EP INI Workshop
42 Intra-zonal congestion: space of zonal net positions Limited flow on intra zonal line l 12 Net position zone B [MW] LMP FBMC A FBMC EP ATCMC Net position zone A [MW] Vertically shaded area: P FB A P FB EP INI Workshop
43 Discussion FBMC-A, FBMC-EP, ATCMC led to clearing quantities that would overload the transmission system FBMC-A can be cleared with infeasible net positions and can prevent feasible trades from being accepted In direct conflict with EC 714/2009, Annex I, Art. 1.1 and 1.7 All zonal market designs suffer the same problem for interand intra-zonal transmission capacity allocation: losing track of nodal injections leads to inaccurate physical flow estimations Given these results, in what follows, we only use FBMC-EP for modelling flow-based market coupling INI Workshop
44 Introduction Day-ahead electricity market models Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead electricity markets Simulation results for the Central Western European network Conclusions Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead electricity markets Appendix INI Workshop
45 Nodal N-1 security criterion Nodal net injections, r n = g G(n) Q gv g Q n, should be feasible even if a single transmission element is not available n 2 l 12 n 1 A l 23 l 41 B C n 3 l 34 n 4 Generators Q g P g g n(g) [MW] [$/MWh] 1 n n n n INI Workshop
46 Nodal N-1 security criterion Nodal net injections, r n = g G(n) Q gv g Q n, should be feasible even if a single transmission element is not available n 2 n 1 A l 23 l 41 B C n 3 l 34 n 4 Generators Q g P g g n(g) [MW] [$/MWh] 1 n n n n INI Workshop
47 Nodal N-1 security criterion Nodal net injections, r n = g G(n) Q gv g Q n, should be feasible even if a single transmission element is not available n 2 n 1 n 3 l 12 l 34 A l 41 B C n 4 Generators Q g P g g n(g) [MW] [$/MWh] 1 n n n n INI Workshop
48 Nodal day-ahead market clearing problem with N-1 security min v,r g G P g Q g v g s.t. 0 v g 1 g G Q g v g Q n = r n n N [ρ n ] g G(n) r R N 1 where R N 1 = u {0,1} L R(u) and R(u) = u 1 1 { r R N (f,θ) R L R N : r n = l L(n, ) f l l L(,n) f l n N, F l f l F l, f l = B l (1 u l ) ( θ m(l) θ n(l) ) l L } INI Workshop
49 Cutting-plane algorithm for FBMC under N-1 security R N 1 is a convex polytope we can describe it as Vr W, for certain V R M N and W R N M CO(V, W) (Market Clearing Oracle): Clears day-ahead nodal market using Vr W as a description of R N 1 IO(r) (Injection Oracle): Checks if r R N 1, returning a separating hyperplane v r w if r / R N 1 1: Initialize V := 0 1, N,W := 0, inclusion := FALSE 2: while!inclusion do 3: Call MCO(V,W) r 4: Call IO(r) inclusion, (v, w) 5: V := [V v], W := [W w] 6: end while 7: Terminate: inner model of MCO(V,W) gives the optimal clearing. INI Workshop
50 Injection oracle (IO) Recall R N 1 = u {0,1} L u 1 1 R(u) Generating Benders cuts independently for every u {0,1} L, u 1 1 can be very expensive A better approach: use a distance function d between the query point r and the set R N 1 d(r,r N 1 ) := max u {0,1} L u 1 1 min r R(u) r r 1 which can be evaluated by solving a single-level MILP Cutting-plane algorithm converges finitely Algorithm inspired by original work by Street et al. (2014) on security constrained unit commitment INI Workshop
51 Zonal day-ahead market clearing problem with N-1 security Zonal net positions should be feasible even if a single transmission element is not available min v,p P g Q g v g g G s.t. 0 v g 1 g G Q g v g g G(z) p P n N(z) Q n = p z z Z [ρ z ] FBMC: P P FB EP N 1 := {p R Z there exists a feasible ( v, f, θ) for each single-element unavailability scenario} ATCMC: P projection of ATC box, computed as maximum-volume box inside E N 1 (defined in an analogous fashion to E) INI Workshop
52 Set of feasible net positions under N-1 security Define P FB EP N 1 P FB EP (u) = := u {0,1} L u 1 1 P FB EP (u), where { p R Z ( v,f,θ) [0,1] G R N R L : g G(z) i G(n) Q g v g n N(z) Q g v g Q n = Q n = p z z Z, l L(n, ) f l l L(,n) f l n N, F l f l F l, f l = B l (1 u l ) ( θ m(l) θ n(l) ) l L } is a convex polytope we can clear FBMC using an analogous cutting-plane approach to that used for LMP P FB EP N 1 Computing max-volume ATCs: similar approach, but separating hyperplanes guarantee box inclusion instead of point inclusion INI Workshop
53 Introduction Day-ahead electricity market models Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead electricity markets Simulation results for the Central Western European network Conclusions Simulation results for the Central Western European network Appendix INI Workshop
54 Two-settlement system forecast renewable energy infeed renewable energy infeed generation and transmission outages Day-ahead electricity market day-ahead commitment day-ahead net positions day-ahead cleared energy quantities Real-time electricity market day-ahead energy prices day-ahead cleared energy quantities day-ahead congestion rent reserve prices cleared reserve quantities real-time cleared energy quantities real-time energy prices real-time congestion rent real-time redispatch and congestion management cost Commitment refers to {0, 1} (on-off) decisions European rules for integer pricing, Madani and Van Vyve (2015) INI Workshop
55 Central Western European network Netherlands * Belgium Germany Netherlands France Austria Belgium Germany Austria Luxembourg France 632 buses, 945 branches (3 491 individual circuits), 346 slow thermal generators (154GW), 301 fast thermal generators (89GW) and renewable generators (149GW) 768 typical snapshots random uncertainty realizations 100 years of operation INI Workshop
56 Implementation and deployment on HPC infrastructure Implementation in Julia/JuMP, using Gurobi, Ipopt compiled with HSL and Xpress as mathematical programming solvers High-performance computing (HPC) deployment using Julia s built-in parallel computing capabilities Total simulation time: CPU-hours Cab Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory Lemaitre3 Consortium des Équipements de Calcul Intensif INI Workshop
57 CWE results: total cost performance Total costs and efficiency of different policies Policy Day-ahead Real-time Total Efficiency [Me/year] [Me/year] [Me/year] losses PF % LMP FBMC % ATCMC % PF: Perfect Foresight benchmark LMP schedules out-of-merit production to meet N-1 security, leading to inefficiencies with respect to PF Efficiency losses of zonal markets with respect to LMP amount to about 5.1% of total costs, 600Me/year FBMC and ATCMC do not present a significant difference INI Workshop
58 CWE results: costs composition Day-ahead costs Real-time costs LMP LMP FBMC FBMC ATCMC ATCMC Cost [10 9 e/year] Cost [10 9 e/year] Production slow Production fast CO2 emissions Curtailment Day-ahead costs larger for LMP, real-time costs much larger for FBMC and ATCMC than LMP Zonal policies: re-dispatching slow (cheap) generators down and re-dispatching fast (expensive) generators up in real time INI Workshop
59 Cross CWE results: production schedules and line overloading Production schedule Line overloading day-ahead schedule Line overloading day-ahead schedule comparison FBMC ATCMC L1 difference on nodal production [GW] Total line overload [GW] Total line overload [GW] LMP vs FBMC LMP vs ATCMC FBMC vs ATCMC DE/AT/LX BE/FR/NL border DE/AT/LX BE/FR/NL Cross border Large differences between day-ahead schedules of nodal and zonal policies, small differences between FBMC and ATCMC Zonal policies lead to decisions overloading inter- and intra-zonal transmission lines INI Workshop
60 CWE results: difference on commitment decisions Price change in FBMC at nodes where UC FBMC UC LMP Estimated density [-] Exclusive LMP Exclusive FBMC FBMC real-time ρ - day-ahead ρ [ /MWh] Exclusive LMP : weighted average change ρ RT n ρ DA z(n) over all nodes where LMP committed slow units and FBMC did not commit units. Exclusive FBMC series computed analogously. LMP commits capacity where it is needed. FBMC suffers from suboptimal commitment. INI Workshop
61 Introduction Day-ahead electricity market models Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead electricity markets Simulation results for the Central Western European network Conclusions Appendix Conclusions INI Workshop
62 Conclusions New framework for modelling zonal electricity markets: Projecting network constraints onto space of exports/imports Free from discretionary parameters (base case, flow approximation, etc.) ATCMC and FBMC fail at allocating inter- and intra-zonal transmission capacity CWE: ATCMC and FBMC do not present significant performance differences CWE: Nodal design outperforms ATCMC and FBMC by 600Me/year INI Workshop
63 Thank you Contact: Anthony Papavasiliou, Ignacio Aravena, Yves Smeers, INI Workshop
64 Introduction Day-ahead electricity market models Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead electricity markets Simulation results for the Central Western European network Conclusions Appendix Appendix INI Workshop
65 Future extensions Application of the developed framework to answer policy questions in European electricty markets via simulation Extensions of the proposed framework: Pricing AC power flow constraints implicitly on active power TSO-DSO coordination INI Workshop
66 Introduction Day-ahead electricity market models Cutting-plane algorithms for robust day-ahead electricity markets Simulation results for the Central Western European network Conclusions Electricity markets 101 Appendix INI Workshop
67 Transportation networks r n2 r n1 n 2 l 23 f l12 l 12 n 1 f l23 l 41 f l41 n 3 l 34 f l34 n 4 r n3 r n4 Paths are decision variables Must respect nodal balance constraints ( n N) r n = f l l L(n, ) l L(,n) Must respect capacities of branches ( l L): F l f l F l Note: n N r n = 0 f l INI Workshop
68 Transportation networks Paths are decision variables n 2 n 1 l 12 1 l 23 l 41 0 n 3 l 34 0 n Must respect nodal balance constraints ( n N) r n = f l l L(n, ) l L(,n) Must respect capacities of branches ( l L): F l f l F l f l Note: n N r n = 0 INI Workshop
69 Transportation networks Paths are decision variables n 2 n 1 l 12 0 l 23 l 41-1 n 3 l 34-1 n Must respect nodal balance constraints ( n N) r n = f l l L(n, ) l L(,n) Must respect capacities of branches ( l L): F l f l F l f l Note: n N r n = 0 INI Workshop
70 Electrical networks r n2 r n1 θ n2 n 2 l 23 f l12 l 12 n 1 θ n1 f l23 l 41 f l41 θ n3 n 3 l 34 f l34 n 4 θ n4 r n3 r n4 Flow paths are implied by injections Must respect nodal balance constraints ( n N) r n = f l l L(n, ) l L(,n) Must respect capacities of branches ( l L): F l f l F l f l Must respect power-angle constraints ( l L, branch l from m(l) to n(l)): f l = B l ( θm(l) θ n(l) ) INI Workshop
71 Electrical networks 1 n n 1 2 l l 23 l n 3 l n B l12 = B l23 = B l34 = B l41 = Flow paths are implied by injections Must respect nodal balance constraints ( n N) r n = f l l L(n, ) l L(,n) Must respect capacities of branches ( l L): F l f l F l f l Must respect power-angle constraints ( l L, branch l from m(l) to n(l)): f l = B l ( θm(l) θ n(l) ) INI Workshop
72 Nodal markets: trading power over an electrical network n 2 l 12 n 1 l 23 l 41 B n 3 l 34 n 4 Participants can trade freely when located at the same node Participants in different nodes can trade up to congestion of lines Congestion: power flow equations, thermal limits of transmission lines, among others (physics) INI Workshop
73 Zonal markets: trading power over an aggregated network n 2 l 12 n 1 A l 23 l 41 B C n 3 l 34 n 4 Participants trade freely within each bidding zone Participants in different zones can trade up to certain export/import limits Limits: aggregation of power flow equations and others INI Workshop
Status of the CWE Flow Based Market Coupling Project
Commissie voor de Regulering van de Elektriciteit en het Gas Commission pour la Régulation de l Electricité et du Gaz Status of the CWE Flow Based Market Coupling Project Joint NordREG / Nordic TSO workshop
More informationThe DC Optimal Power Flow
1 / 20 The DC Optimal Power Flow Quantitative Energy Economics Anthony Papavasiliou The DC Optimal Power Flow 2 / 20 1 The OPF Using PTDFs 2 The OPF Using Reactance 3 / 20 Transmission Constraints Lines
More informationEUROPEAN EXPERIENCE: Large-scale cross-country forecasting with the help of Ensemble Forecasts
WEPROG Weather & wind Energy PROGnoses EUROPEAN EXPERIENCE: Large-scale cross-country forecasting with the help of Ensemble Forecasts Session 6: Integrating forecasting into market operation, the EMS and
More informationChapter 5. Transmission networks and electricity markets
Chapter 5. Transmission networks and electricity markets 1 Introduction In most of the regions of the world: assumptions that electrical energy can be traded as if all generators were connected to the
More informationMulti-Area Stochastic Unit Commitment for High Wind Penetration
Multi-Area Stochastic Unit Commitment for High Wind Penetration Workshop on Optimization in an Uncertain Environment Anthony Papavasiliou, UC Berkeley Shmuel S. Oren, UC Berkeley March 25th, 2011 Outline
More informationA three-level MILP model for generation and transmission expansion planning
A three-level MILP model for generation and transmission expansion planning David Pozo Cámara (UCLM) Enzo E. Sauma Santís (PUC) Javier Contreras Sanz (UCLM) Contents 1. Introduction 2. Aims and contributions
More informationValue of Forecasts in Unit Commitment Problems
Tim Schulze, Andreas Grothery and School of Mathematics Agenda Motivation Unit Commitemnt Problem British Test System Forecasts and Scenarios Rolling Horizon Evaluation Comparisons Conclusion Our Motivation
More informationMulti-Area Stochastic Unit Commitment for High Wind Penetration in a Transmission Constrained Network
Multi-Area Stochastic Unit Commitment for High Wind Penetration in a Transmission Constrained Network Anthony Papavasiliou Center for Operations Research and Econometrics Université catholique de Louvain,
More informationCorrective Control to Handle Forecast Uncertainty: A Chance Constrained Optimal Power Flow
1 Corrective Control to Handle Forecast Uncertainty: A Chance Constrained Optimal Power Flow Line Roald, Sidhant Misra, Thilo Krause, and Göran Andersson arxiv:169.2194v1 [math.oc] 7 Sep 216 Abstract Higher
More informationA Unified Framework for Defining and Measuring Flexibility in Power System
J A N 1 1, 2 0 1 6, A Unified Framework for Defining and Measuring Flexibility in Power System Optimization and Equilibrium in Energy Economics Workshop Jinye Zhao, Tongxin Zheng, Eugene Litvinov Outline
More information2010/53. Market coupling and the organization of counter-trading: separating energy and transmission again? Giorgia Oggioni and Yves Smeers
2010/53 Market coupling and the organization of counter-trading: separating energy and transmission again? Giorgia Oggioni and Yves Smeers DISCUSSION PAPER Center for Operations Research and Econometrics
More informationModelling wind power in unit commitment models
Modelling wind power in unit commitment models Grid integration session IEA Wind Task 25 Methodologies to estimate wind power impacts to power systems Juha Kiviluoma, Hannele Holttinen, VTT Technical Research
More informationPublic data underlying the figures of Annual Report on the Results of Monitoring the Internal Electricity and Natural Gas Markets in 2015
Public data underlying the figures of Annual Report on the Results of Monitoring the Internal Electricity and Natural Gas Markets in 2015 Electricity Wholesale Market Volume January 2017 Legal notice This
More informationPerfect and Imperfect Competition in Electricity Markets
Perfect and Imperfect Competition in Electricity Marets DTU CEE Summer School 2018 June 25-29, 2018 Contact: Vladimir Dvorin (vladvo@eletro.dtu.d) Jalal Kazempour (seyaz@eletro.dtu.d) Deadline: August
More informationEnergy System Modelling Summer Semester 2018, Lecture 7
Energy System Modelling Summer Semester 2018, Lecture 7 Dr. Tom Brown, tom.brown@kit.edu, https://nworbmot.org/ Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Institute for Automation and Applied Informatics
More informationA new primal-dual framework for European day-ahead electricity auctions
A new primal-dual framework for European day-ahead electricity auctions Mehdi Madani*, Mathieu Van Vyve** *Louvain School of management, ** CORE Catholic University of Louvain Mathematical Models and Methods
More informationThe Nordic Capacity Calculation Methodology (CCM) project. CCM Stakeholder Forum Stockholm 8 February
The Nordic Capacity Calculation Methodology (CCM) project CCM Stakeholder Forum Stockholm 8 February - 2017 Agenda 1. Coffee (9.00 9.30) 2. Welcome, objective and agenda (9.30-9.45), Trond Jensen (Statnett)
More informationInternational Workshop on Wind Energy Development Cairo, Egypt. ERCOT Wind Experience
International Workshop on Wind Energy Development Cairo, Egypt ERCOT Wind Experience March 22, 21 Joel Mickey Direcr of Grid Operations Electric Reliability Council of Texas jmickey@ercot.com ERCOT 2 2
More informationSoftware Tools: Congestion Management
Software Tools: Congestion Management Tom Qi Zhang, PhD CompuSharp Inc. (408) 910-3698 Email: zhangqi@ieee.org October 16, 2004 IEEE PES-SF Workshop on Congestion Management Contents Congestion Management
More informationelgian energ imports are managed using forecasting software to increase overall network e 칁 cienc.
Elia linemen install Ampacimon real time sensors that will communicate with the dynamic thermal ratings software to control energy import levels over this transmission line. OV RH AD TRAN MI ION D namic
More informationOn Clearing Coupled Day-Ahead Electricity Markets
On Clearing Coupled Day-Ahead Electricity Markets Johannes C. Müller Johannes.Mueller@math.uni-erlangen.de joint work with Alexander Martin Sebastian Pokutta Oct 2010 Johannes C. Müller Clearing Coupled
More informationStochastic Unit Commitment with Topology Control Recourse for Renewables Integration
1 Stochastic Unit Commitment with Topology Control Recourse for Renewables Integration Jiaying Shi and Shmuel Oren University of California, Berkeley IPAM, January 2016 33% RPS - Cumulative expected VERs
More informationInverse Optimization for the Recovery of Market Structure from Market Outcomes
Inverse Optimization for the Recovery of Market Structure from Market Outcomes John Birge, University of Chicago Ali Hortaçsu, University of Chicago Michael Pavlin, Wilfrid Laurier University April 9,
More informationBilevel Programming-Based Unit Commitment for Locational Marginal Price Computation
Bilevel Programming-Based Unit Commitment for Locational Marginal Price Computation Presentation at 50 th North American Power Symposium Abdullah Alassaf Department of Electrical Engineering University
More informationA new stochastic program to facilitate intermittent renewable generation
A new stochastic program to facilitate intermittent renewable generation Golbon Zakeri Geoff Pritchard, Mette Bjorndal, Endre Bjorndal EPOC UoA and Bergen, IPAM 2016 Premise for our model Growing need
More informationFlow- based Market Coupling: Implementa9on of the CWE FB Project. Andrew Claxton APX Co- Chair, CWE Steering Commi5ee
Flow- based Market Coupling: Implementa9on of the CWE FB Project Andrew Claxton APX Co- Chair, CWE Steering Commi5ee 1 Themes! Introduction to Flow-based idea! Update on progress: the Parallel Run! Key
More informationCourse notes for EE394V Restructured Electricity Markets: Locational Marginal Pricing
Course notes for EE394V Restructured Electricity Markets: Locational Marginal Pricing Ross Baldick Copyright c 2013 Ross Baldick www.ece.utexas.edu/ baldick/classes/394v/ee394v.html Title Page 1 of 132
More informationBringing Renewables to the Grid. John Dumas Director Wholesale Market Operations ERCOT
Bringing Renewables to the Grid John Dumas Director Wholesale Market Operations ERCOT 2011 Summer Seminar August 2, 2011 Quick Overview of ERCOT The ERCOT Market covers ~85% of Texas overall power usage
More informationThe Nordic Capacity Calculation Methodology (CCM) project Stakeholder Forum. Arlanda Stockholm Airport 11 December 2018
The Nordic Capacity Calculation Methodology (CCM) project Stakeholder Forum Arlanda Skycity @ Stockholm Airport 11 December 2018 Table of Contents 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Status update of the CCM project, DA/ID
More informationWind power and management of the electric system. EWEA Wind Power Forecasting 2015 Leuven, BELGIUM - 02/10/2015
Wind power and management of the electric system EWEA Wind Power Forecasting 2015 Leuven, BELGIUM - 02/10/2015 HOW WIND ENERGY IS TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT WHEN MANAGING ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION SYSTEM IN FRANCE?
More informationThe Analysis of Electricity Storage Location Sites in the Electric Transmission Grid
Proceedings o the 2010 Industrial Engineering Research Conerence A. Johnson and J. Miller, eds. The Analysis o Electricity Storage Location Sites in the Electric Transmission Grid Thomas F. Brady College
More informationProper Security Criteria Determination in a Power System with High Penetration of Renewable Resources
Proper Security Criteria Determination in a Power System with High Penetration of Renewable Resources Mojgan Hedayati, Kory Hedman, and Junshan Zhang School of Electrical, Computer, and Energy Engineering
More informationApplying High Performance Computing to Multi-Area Stochastic Unit Commitment
Applying High Performance Computing to Multi-Area Stochastic Unit Commitment IBM Research Anthony Papavasiliou, Department of Mathematical Engineering, CORE, UCL Shmuel Oren, IEOR Department, UC Berkeley
More informationOptimal Locating and Sizing of TCPST for Congestion Management in Deregulated Electricity Markets
Optimal Locating and Sizing of TCPST for Congestion Management in Deregulated Electricity Markets M. Joorabian Shahid Chamran University, Ahwaz, Iran mjoorabian@yahoo.com M. Saniei Shahid Chamran University,
More informationJoint procurement of natural gas for grid operation
Joint procurement of natural gas for grid operation Slide www.aggm.at 1 Joint procurement of natural gas for grid operation AGGM 19. November 2014 1. General information 2. Procurement Slide 2 Joint procurement
More information+/- $50 Bid Cap and Node Limitations on Up-To Congestion Transactions APRIL 10 SPECIAL SESSION MIC NOHA SIDHOM- INERTIA POWER
+/- $50 Bid Cap and Node Limitations on Up-To Congestion Transactions APRIL 10 SPECIAL SESSION MIC NOHA SIDHOM- INERTIA POWER Limitations Addressed in Problem Statement Section 1.10 of Attachment K of
More informationJavier Contreras Sanz- Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha Jesús María López Lezama- Universidad de Antioquia Antonio Padilha-Feltrin- Universidade
Javier Contreras Sanz- Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha Jesús María López Lezama- Universidad de Antioquia Antonio Padilha-Feltrin- Universidade Estadual Paulista Jose Ignacio Muñoz-Universidad de Castilla-La
More informationAppendix A Solving Systems of Nonlinear Equations
Appendix A Solving Systems of Nonlinear Equations Chapter 4 of this book describes and analyzes the power flow problem. In its ac version, this problem is a system of nonlinear equations. This appendix
More informationComplex Renewable Energy Networks: Power flows and markets
Complex Renewable Energy Networks: Power flows and markets Mirko Schäfer 14th June 2016 Frankfurt Institute of Advanced Studies (FIAS), Goethe-Universität Frankfurt FIAS Renewable Energy System and Network
More informationManaging Uncertainty and Security in Power System Operations: Chance-Constrained Optimal Power Flow
Managing Uncertainty and Security in Power System Operations: Chance-Constrained Optimal Power Flow Line Roald, November 4 th 2016 Line Roald 09.11.2016 1 Outline Introduction Chance-Constrained Optimal
More informationSimulation and Evaluation of Zonal Electricity Market Designs. Mohammad Reza Hesamzadeh, Pär Holmberg and Mahir Sarfati
IFN Working Paper No. 1211, 2018 Simulation and Evaluation of Zonal Electricity Market Designs Mohammad Reza Hesamzadeh, Pär Holmberg and Mahir Sarfati Research Institute of Industrial Economics P.O. Box
More informationBaltic regional gas market study Final Report. 8 th April 2016
Baltic regional gas market study Final Report 8 th April 2016 Table of contents Executive summary Introduction Regional model development Approach to market design development Market design requirements
More informationPOWER system operations increasingly rely on the AC
i Convex Relaxations and Approximations of Chance-Constrained AC-OF roblems Lejla Halilbašić, Student Member, IEEE, ierre inson, Senior Member, IEEE, and Spyros Chatzivasileiadis, Senior Member, IEEE arxiv:1804.05754v3
More informationCAISO Participating Intermittent Resource Program for Wind Generation
CAISO Participating Intermittent Resource Program for Wind Generation Jim Blatchford CAISO Account Manager Agenda CAISO Market Concepts Wind Availability in California How State Supports Intermittent Resources
More information2015 IEEE. Digital Object Identifier: /PTC
2015 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained for all other users, including reprinting/ republishing this material for advertising or promotional purposes,
More informationPower System Seminar Presentation Wind Forecasting and Dispatch 7 th July, Wind Power Forecasting tools and methodologies
Power System Seminar Presentation Wind Forecasting and Dispatch 7 th July, 2011 Wind Power Forecasting tools and methodologies Amanda Kelly Principal Engineer Power System Operational Planning Operations
More informationCoupled Optimization Models for Planning and Operation of Power Systems on Multiple Scales
Coupled Optimization Models for Planning and Operation of Power Systems on Multiple Scales Michael C. Ferris University of Wisconsin, Madison Computational Needs for the Next Generation Electric Grid,
More informationA possible notion of short-term value-based reliability
Energy Laboratory MIT EL 1-13 WP Massachusetts Institute of Technology A possible notion of short-term value-based reliability August 21 A possible notion of short-term value-based reliability Yong TYoon,
More informationA Model for a Zonal Operating Reserve Demand Curve
A Model for a Zonal Operating Reserve Demand Curve Yen-Yu Lee Electrical and Computer Engineering University of Texas at Austin March 5, Outline What is operating reserves? Why do we need elastic reserves
More informationOperations Report. Tag B. Short, Director South Region Operations. Entergy Regional State Committee (ERSC) February 14, 2018
Operations Report Tag B. Short, Director South Region Operations Entergy Regional State Committee (ERSC) February 14, 2018 1 Winter Operations Highlights South Region Max Gen Event Regional Dispatch Transfer
More informationEconomic analysis of the N-1 reliable unit commitment and transmission switching problem using duality concepts
Energy Syst DOI 10.1007/s12667-009-0005-6 ORIGINAL PAPER Economic analysis of the N-1 reliable unit commitment and transmission switching problem using duality concepts Richard P. O Neill Kory W. Hedman
More informationInformation Document Calculation of Pool Price and Transmission Constraint Rebalancing Costs During a Constraint Event ID # R
Information Documents are not authoritative. Information Documents are for information purposes only and are intended to provide guidance. In the event of any discrepancy between an Information Document
More informationA stochastic integer programming approach to the optimal thermal and wind generator scheduling problem
A stochastic integer programming approach to the optimal thermal and wind generator scheduling problem Presented by Michael Chen York University Industrial Optimization Seminar Fields Institute for Research
More informationDIMACS, Rutgers U January 21, 2013 Michael Caramanis
Power Market Participation of Flexible Loads and Reactive Power Providers: Real Power, Reactive Power, and Regulation Reserve Capacity Pricing at T&D Networks DIMACS, Rutgers U January 21, 2013 Michael
More informationShort-Term Demand Forecasting Methodology for Scheduling and Dispatch
Short-Term Demand Forecasting Methodology for Scheduling and Dispatch V1.0 March 2018 Table of Contents 1 Introduction... 3 2 Historical Jurisdictional Demand Data... 3 3 EMS Demand Forecast... 4 3.1 Manual
More informationTopology control algorithms in power systems
Boston University OpenBU Theses & Dissertations http://open.bu.edu Boston University Theses & Dissertations 2015 Topology control algorithms in power systems Goldis, Evgeniy https://hdl.handle.net/2144/16306
More informationECG 740 GENERATION SCHEDULING (UNIT COMMITMENT)
1 ECG 740 GENERATION SCHEDULING (UNIT COMMITMENT) 2 Unit Commitment Given a load profile, e.g., values of the load for each hour of a day. Given set of units available, When should each unit be started,
More informationFirming Renewable Power with Demand Response: An End-to-end Aggregator Business Model
Firming Renewable Power with Demand Response: An End-to-end Aggregator Business Model Clay Campaigne joint work with Shmuel Oren November 5, 2015 1 / 16 Motivation Problem: Expansion of renewables increases
More informationRobust Corrective Topology Control for System Reliability and Renewable Integration. Akshay Shashikumar Korad
Robust Corrective Topology Control for System Reliability and Renewable Integration by Akshay Shashikumar Korad A Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor
More informationTutorial 2: Modelling Transmission
Tutorial 2: Modelling Transmission In our previous example the load and generation were at the same bus. In this tutorial we will see how to model the transmission of power from one bus to another. The
More informationAccelerating the Convergence of MIP-based Unit Commitment Problems
Accelerating the Convergence of MIP-based Unit Commitment Problems The Impact of High Quality MIP Formulations ermán Morales-España, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands Optimization
More informationMISO September 15 Maximum Generation Event Overview. October 11, 2018
MISO September 15 Maximum Generation Event Overview October 11, 2018 Purpose & Key Takeaways Purpose: Summarize operations during the September 15 South Region Maximum Generation Event Key Takeaways: MISO
More informationR O B U S T E N E R G Y M AN AG E M E N T S Y S T E M F O R I S O L AT E D M I C R O G R I D S
ROBUST ENERGY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR ISOLATED MICROGRIDS Jose Daniel La r a Claudio Cañizares Ka nka r Bhattacharya D e p a r t m e n t o f E l e c t r i c a l a n d C o m p u t e r E n g i n e e r i n
More informationWIND INTEGRATION IN ELECTRICITY GRIDS WORK PACKAGE 3: SIMULATION USING HISTORICAL WIND DATA
WIND INTEGRATION IN ELECTRICITY GRIDS WORK PACKAGE 3: SIMULATION USING PREPARED BY: Strategy and Economics DATE: 18 January 2012 FINAL Australian Energy Market Operator Ltd ABN 94 072 010 327 www.aemo.com.au
More informationSpatially-Explicit Prediction of Wholesale Electricity Prices
Spatially-Explicit Prediction of Wholesale Electricity Prices J. Wesley Burnett and Xueting Zhao Intern l Assoc for Energy Economics, NYC 2014 West Virginia University Wednesday, June 18, 2014 Outline
More informationCongestion and Price Prediction in Locational Marginal Pricing Markets Considering Load Variation and Uncertainty
The Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science Congestion and Price Prediction in Locational Marginal Pricing Markets Considering Load Variation and Uncertainty Dissertation Defense Rui
More informationEnergy Forecasting Customers: Analysing end users requirements Dec 3rd, 2013 Carlos Alberto Castaño, PhD Head of R&D
IT Solutions for Renewables Energy Forecasting Customers: Analysing end users requirements Dec 3rd, 2013 Carlos Alberto Castaño, PhD Head of R&D carlos.castano@gnarum.com I. Who we are II. Customers Profiles
More informationSINGLE OBJECTIVE RISK- BASED TRANSMISSION EXPANSION
Vol.2, Issue.1, Jan-Feb 2012 pp-424-430 ISSN: 2249-6645 SINGLE OBJECTIVE RISK- BASED TRANSMISSION EXPANSION V.Sumadeepthi 1, K.Sarada 2 1 (Student, Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering,
More informationComputing risk averse equilibrium in incomplete market. Henri Gerard Andy Philpott, Vincent Leclère
Computing risk averse equilibrium in incomplete market Henri Gerard Andy Philpott, Vincent Leclère YEQT XI: Winterschool on Energy Systems Netherlands, December, 2017 CERMICS - EPOC 1/43 Uncertainty on
More informationOptimal Demand Response
Optimal Demand Response Libin Jiang Steven Low Computing + Math Sciences Electrical Engineering Caltech Oct 2011 Outline Caltech smart grid research Optimal demand response Global trends 1 Exploding renewables
More informationMid-term Adequacy Forecast 2018
Appendix 1: Methodology and Detailed Results 2018 edition Table of Contents 1 Methodology and assumptions... 3 1.1 Methodology advanced tools for probabilistic market modelling...4 Adequacy Indices...7
More informationProbabilistic Reliability Management Approach and Criteria for Power System Short-term Operational Planning
Probabilistic Reliability Management Approach and Criteria for Power System Short-term Operational Planning Efthymios Karangelos and Louis Wehenkel Department of Electrical Engineering & Computer Science
More informationEdinburgh Research Explorer
Edinburgh Research Explorer Decentralized Multi-Period Economic Dispatch for Real-Time Flexible Demand Management Citation for published version: Loukarakis, E, Dent, C & Bialek, J 216, 'Decentralized
More informationUniqueness and Multiplicity of Market Equilibria on DC Power Flow Networks
Uniqueness and Multiplicity of Market Equilibria on DC Power Flow Networks Vanessa Krebs, Lars Schewe, Martin Schmidt Abstract. We consider uniqueness and multiplicity of market equilibria in a short-run
More informationDerogation Criteria for the Requirements for Generators Network Code
Derogation Criteria for the Requirements for Generators Network Code Decision Paper Reference: CER/17/084 Date Published: 13/04/2017 Closing Date: 0 Executive Summary Commission Regulation (EU) 2016/631
More informationSHORT-TERM hydropower planning under uncertainty is
Proceedings of the International MultiConference of Engineers and Computer Scientists 015 Vol II, IMECS 015, March 18-0, 015, Hong Kong Hydropower Producer Day-ahead Market Strategic Offering Using Stochastic
More informationMulti-Area Interchange Scheduling under Uncertainty
1 Multi-Area Interchange Scheduling under Uncertainty Yuting Ji, Student Member, IEEE, and Lang Tong, Fellow, IEEE arxiv:1611.05012v1 [math.oc] 15 Nov 2016 Abstract The problem of multi-area interchange
More informationDual decomposition approach for dynamic spatial equilibrium models
Dual decomposition approach for dynamic spatial equilibrium models E. Allevi (1), A. Gnudi (2), I.V. Konnov (3), G. Oggioni (1) (1) University of Brescia, Italy (2) University of Bergamo, Italy (3) Kazan
More informationApplication of Monte Carlo Simulation to Multi-Area Reliability Calculations. The NARP Model
Application of Monte Carlo Simulation to Multi-Area Reliability Calculations The NARP Model Any power system reliability model using Monte Carlo simulation consists of at least the following steps: 1.
More informationCapacity Scarcity Condition Monday, September 3, 2018 Two primary factors led to the implementation of OP 4 event Significant generation outages and r
S E P T E M B E R 1 2, 2 0 1 8 September 3 OP-4 Event and Capacity Scarcity Condition Vamsi Chadalavada E X E C U T I V E V I C E P R E S I D E N T A N D C H I E F O P E R A T I N G O F F I C E R Capacity
More informationFORECASTING OF WIND GENERATION The wind power of tomorrow on your screen today!
FORECASTING OF WIND GENERATION The wind power of tomorrow on your screen today! Pierre Pinson 1, Gregor Giebel 2 and Henrik Madsen 1 1 Technical University of Denmark, Denmark Dpt. of Informatics and Mathematical
More informationThe L-Shaped Method. Operations Research. Anthony Papavasiliou 1 / 38
1 / 38 The L-Shaped Method Operations Research Anthony Papavasiliou Contents 2 / 38 1 The L-Shaped Method 2 Example: Capacity Expansion Planning 3 Examples with Optimality Cuts [ 5.1a of BL] 4 Examples
More informationA Progressive Hedging Approach to Multistage Stochastic Generation and Transmission Investment Planning
A Progressive Hedging Approach to Multistage Stochastic Generation and Transmission Investment Planning Yixian Liu Ramteen Sioshansi Integrated Systems Engineering Department The Ohio State University
More informationSUBMITTED TO IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS, AUGUST
SUBMITTED TO IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS, AUGUST 2014 1 Adaptive Robust Optimization with Dynamic Uncertainty Sets for Multi-Period Economic Dispatch under Significant Wind Álvaro Lorca, Student
More informationRisk Consideration in Electricity Generation Unit Commitment under Supply and Demand Uncertainty
Graduate Theses and Dissertations Iowa State University Capstones, Theses and Dissertations 2016 Risk Consideration in Electricity Generation Unit Commitment under Supply and Demand Uncertainty Narges
More informationA Bound Strengthening Method for Optimal Transmission Switching in Power Systems
1 A Bound Strengthening Method for Optimal Transmission Switching in Power Systems Salar Fattahi, Javad Lavaei,+, and Alper Atamtürk Industrial Engineering and Operations Research, University of California,
More informationCoordinated Multilateral Trades for Electric Power Networks: Theory and Implementation. Felix F. Wu and Pravin Varaiya
PWP-031 Coordinated Multilateral Trades for Electric Power Networks: Theory and Implementation Felix F. Wu and Pravin Varaiya June 1995 This paper is part of the working papers series of the Program on
More informationChapter 6 Impact of Stochastic Renewable Energy Generation on Market Quantities 6.1 Introduction
Chapter 6 Impact of Stochastic Renewable Energy Generation on Market Quantities 6.1 Introduction One of the most traditional systems for the commercial exchange of electricity production from stochastic
More informationGame theory and market power
Game theory and market power Josh Taylor Section 6.1.3, 6.3 in Convex Optimization of Power Systems. 1 Market weaknesses Recall Optimal power flow: minimize p,θ subject to λ i : χ ij 0 : f i (p i ) i p
More informationAnalysis of Adaptive Certainty-Equivalent Techniques for the Stochastic Unit Commitment Problem
power systems eehlaboratory José Sebastián Espejo-Uribe Analysis of Adaptive Certainty-Equivalent Techniques for the Stochastic Unit Commitment Problem Master Thesis PSL177 EEH Power Systems Laboratory
More informationI. Why power? II. Model definition III. Model uses IV. The basics. A. Supply Dispatch B. Demand Bidding. D. Transmission
Electric Power Markets: Why is Electricity Different? Dumb Grids, the Ultimate Just-in in-time Problem, & Polar Bears Benjamin F. Hobbs & Daniel Ralph Whiting School of Engineering The Johns Hopkins University
More informationA Robust Optimization Approach to the Self-scheduling Problem Using Semidefinite Programming
A Robust Optimization Approach to the Self-scheduling Problem Using Semidefinite Programming by Jason Conrad Landry A thesis presented to the University of Waterloo in fulfillment of the thesis requirement
More informationCOORDINATING CONGESTION RELIEF ACROSS MULTIPLE REGIONS
COORDINATING CONGESTION RELIEF ACROSS MULTILE REGIONS MICHAEL D. CADWALADER* SCOTT M. HARVEY** WILLIAM W. HOGAN*** SUSAN L. OE** *HB Hagler Bailly, Inc., Cambridge, MA 02142 **Navigant Consulting, Inc.,
More informationSensitivity-Based Line Outage Angle Factors
Sensitivity-Based Line Outage Angle Factors Kai E. Van Horn, Alejandro D. Domínguez-García, and Peter W. Sauer Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
More informationPowerApps Optimal Power Flow Formulation
PowerApps Optimal Power Flow Formulation Page1 Table of Contents 1 OPF Problem Statement... 3 1.1 Vector u... 3 1.1.1 Costs Associated with Vector [u] for Economic Dispatch... 4 1.1.2 Costs Associated
More informationA Merchant Mechanism for Electricity Transmission Expansion
A Merchant Mechanism for Electricity Transmission Expansion Tarjei Kristiansen, Norwegian University of Science and Technology. Tarjei.Kristiansen@elkraft.ntnu.no Juan Rosellon, Harvard University/CIDE.
More informationIEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS, VOL. 24, NO. 3, AUGUST
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS, VOL. 24, NO. 3, AUGUST 2009 1435 DCOPF-Based Marginal Loss Pricing With Enhanced Power Flow Accuracy by Using Matrix Loss Distribution V. Sarkar, Student Member, IEEE,
More informationMixed Integer Linear Programming Formulation for Chance Constrained Mathematical Programs with Equilibrium Constraints
Mixed Integer Linear Programming Formulation for Chance Constrained Mathematical Programs with Equilibrium Constraints ayed A. adat and Lingling Fan University of outh Florida, email: linglingfan@usf.edu
More informationTight and Compact MILP Formulation for the Thermal Unit Commitment Problem
Online Companion for Tight and Compact MILP Formulation for the Thermal Unit Commitment Problem Germán Morales-España, Jesus M. Latorre, and Andres Ramos Universidad Pontificia Comillas, Spain Institute
More informationSolving the economic power dispatch and related problems more efficiently (and reliably)
Solving the economic power dispatch and related problems more efficiently (and reliably) Richard P O'Neill FERC With Mary Cain, Anya Castillo, Clay Campaigne, Paula A. Lipka, Mehrdad Pirnia, Shmuel Oren
More information