arxiv: v1 [math.fa] 30 Oct 2011

Transcription

1 AROUND OPERATOR MONOTONE FUNCTIONS MOHAMMAD SAL MOSLEHIAN AND HAMED NAJAFI arxiv: v1 [math.fa] 3 Oct 11 Abstract. We show that the symmetrized product AB + BA of two positive operators A and B is positive if and only if f(a+b f(a+f(b for all non-negative operator monotone functions f on [, and deduce an operator inequality. We also give a necessary and sufficient condition for that the composition f g of an operator convex function f on [, and a non-negative operator monotone function g on an interval (a, b is operator monotone and give some applications. 1. Introduction Let B(H denote the algebra of all bounded linear operators on a complex Hilbert space(h,,. AnoperatorA B(H iscalledpositive if Ax,x holdsforevery x H and then we write A. The set of all positive operators on H is denoted by B(H +. For self-adjoint operators A,B B(H, we say A B if B A. The symmetrized product of two operators A,B B(H is defined by S(A,B = AB + BA. In general, the symmetrized ( product of two ( operators A,B B(H + is not positive. For example, if A = and B =, then AB+BA is not 1 1 a positive operator. The operator 1 S(A,B is called the Jordan product of A and B. Nicholson [11] and Strang [1] introduced some sufficient conditions for that the Jordan product of two positive matrices A and B is positive. Also Gustafson [7] showed that if m A M and n B N, then mn (M m(n n 8 1 S(A,B. (1 Throughout the paper we assume all functions to be continuous. Let f be a real-valued function defined on an interval J. If for each self-adjoint operators A,B B(H with spectra in J, A B implies f(a f(b, then f is called operator monotone; 1 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 47A63; Secondary 47B1, 47A3. Key words and phrases. Operator monotone function; Jordan product; operator convex function; subadditivity; composition of functions. 1

2 M.S. MOSLEHIAN AND H. NAJAFI f(λa+(1 λb λf(a+(1 λf(b for all λ [,1], then f is said to be operator convex; f(a+b f(a+f(b, then f is called subadditive. If f is an operator monotone function on [,, then f can be represented as f(t = f(+βt+ λt λ+t dµ(λ, where β and µ is a positive measure on [, and if f is an operator convex function on [,, then f can be represented as f(t = f(+βt+γt + λt λ+t dµ(λ, where γ, β = f + ( = lim t f(t f( + and µ is a positive measure on [, ; t see [5, Chapter V]. If f is a non-negative operator monotone function on [,, then the subadditivity of f does not hold in general. Aujla and Bourin [] showed that if A,B are matrices and f : [, [, is a concave function, i.e. f is convex, then there exist unitaries U,V such that f(a+b Uf(AU +Vf(BV. Regarding the subadditivity property, Ando and Zhan [1] proved that f(a + B f(a+f(b for all non-negative operator monotone functions f, all unitarily invariant norms and all matrices A,B ; see also [3]. Recall that a norm on the algebra of all n n matrices is unitarily invariant if X = UXV for all unitaries U and V and all matrices X. Throughout this paper M(H denotes the set of all (A,B B(H + B(H + for which f(a+b f(a+f(b for all non-negative operator monotone functions f on [,. We shall show that M(H = {(A,B B(H + B(H + AB +BA }. We apply this result to present an operator inequality involving operator monotone functions analogue to that of Hansen [9]. We also give a necessary and sufficient conditionforthecompositionf g ofanoperatorconvexfunctionf on[, andanonnegative operator monotone function g on an interval (a, b to be operator monotone and deduce some operator inequalities.. The results We start this section with one of our main results.

3 AROUND OPERATOR MONOTONE FUNCTIONS 3 Theorem.1. Let A,B B(H +. Then AB+BA is positive if and onlyif f(a+b f(a+f(b for all non-negative operator monotone functions f on [,. Proof. Suppose that f(a+b f(a+f(b for all non-negative operator monotone functions f on [,. Let λ (,. The function f λ (t = λt λ+t on [,. Hence is operator monotone (A+B(λ+A+B 1 A(λ+A 1 +B(λ+B 1. ( Put X λ = A(A+λ 1 and Y λ = B(B +λ 1. Inequality ( is equivalent to (λ+a+b(a+b (λ+a+bx λ (λ+a+b +(λ+a+by λ (λ+a+b = λ X λ +λax λ +λbx λ +λx λ B +AX λ A+AX λ B +BX λ A+BX λ B +λ Y λ +λby λ +λay λ +λy λ A+BY λ B +BY λ A+AY λ B +AY λ A. Since BY λ = Y λ B = B λy λ and AX λ = X λ A = A λx λ the above inequality is, in turn, equivalent to λ(a+b+a +B +AB +BA λ(a+b+a +B +(AB +BA+BX λ B +AY λ A or AB +BA+BX λ B +AY λ A. (3 Letting λ we get BX λ B +AY λ A, whence AB +BA. Conversely, assume that AB +BA. Since inequality (3 holds for each λ R +, we obtain f λ (A+B f λ (A+f λ (B. Now, if f be a non-negative operator monotone function on [,, then f can be represented on [, by f(t = f(+βt+ f λ (t dµ(λ,

4 4 M.S. MOSLEHIAN AND H. NAJAFI where β and µ is a positive measure on [,. Since f(, without loss of generality, we can assume that f(t = f λ (tdµ(λ. Therefore f(a+b = = f λ (A+Bdµ(λ (f λ (A+f λ (Bdµ(λ f λ (Adµ(λ+ = f(a+f(b. f λ (Bdµ(λ If A,B B(H + commute, then AB = (A 1/ B 1/. The above theorem therefore shows that f(a+b f(a+f(b for any non-negative operator monotone function f on [,. In particular, for each n N we have f(na nf(a. Corollary.. Let m A M, n B N and f be a non-negative operator monotone function on [,. If (M m(n n 8mn, then f(a+b f(a+f(b. Proof. Use inequality (1. Corollary.3. Let p 1 and f be a non-negative operator monotone function on [,. Then for positive operators A and B with A B it holds that ( ( B f (B p p +A p B p A p f +f. Proof. Assume that S 1 = 1 (Bp +A p and S = 1 (Bp A p. Clearly S 1 and due to f(t = t p is operator monotone [6, Theorem 1.8], S. We have (S 1 S +S S 1 = (S 1 +S (S 1 S = B p A p, since f(t = t p is also operator monotone. Therefore ( ( B f (B p p +A p B p A p = f(s 1 +S f(s 1 +f(s = f +f. Let m M ( + 1m. If m A,B M, then inequality (1 ensures that AB + BA is positive. From this we can introduce an inequality for non-negative operator monotone functions. We should notice that Hansen[9] proved that an operator monotone function f on [, satisfies the inequality C f(ac f(c AC for all

5 AROUND OPERATOR MONOTONE FUNCTIONS 5 positive operators A and all contractions C, i.e. operators of norm less than or equal to one. Theorem.4. Let f be a non-negative operator monotone function on [,. Let A and A i (1 i n be positive operators with spectra in [λ,(1 + λ] for some λ R +. Then (i For every isometry C B(H, f(c AC C f ( A C. (ii For operators C i (i = 1,,n with n C i C i = I, ( n n ( A f Ci A ic i Ci f C i. ( ( A Proof. (i Put X =, D = (I CC C D, 1 V = and U = A C ( C D. It is easy to see that U and V are unitary operators. So sp(u XU = C sp(v XV = sp(x [λ,(1+ λ], where sp stands for spectrum. Thus ( ( f(c AC C AC = f f(dad+cac DAD +CAC ( U XU +V XV = f f (U X U +f (V X V = U f ( = ( X U +V f ( X V C f ( A C Df ( ( A D +Cf A C, whence f(c AC C f ( A C. (ii Set C = C 1. C n, Ã = A 1 A.... A n

6 6 M.S. MOSLEHIAN AND H. NAJAFI Thus ( n f Ci A ic i = f( C Ã C C f (Ã C = n ( A Ci f C i. Corollary.5. Let λ R + and w i [λ,(1 + λ] (i = 1,,n. Let f be a non-negative operator monotone function on [, and A i be positive operators such that n A i = I. Then f( n w i A i n f( w i A i. Proof. Put C i = A 1 i in part (ii of Theorem.4. Theorem.6. Let A,B B(H +. Then B A if and only if for each operator convex function f on [, with f + ( it holds that f(b f(a Proof. Let A,B B(H +. Suppose that for each operator convex function f on [, with f + ( we have f(b f(a. Due to f(t = t is operator convex on [, and f +(, we get B A. Next we show the converse. First assume that A and B are invertible positive operators such that B A. Then λa + A 1 λb + B 1. This inequality is equivalent to (λb + B 1 1 (λa + A 1 1 and this is, in turn, equivalent to B (B + λ 1 A (A + λ 1. On the other hand f λ (t = λt λ+t [,, so f λ (B f λ (A. is operator convex on If A and B are positive and (A B,A+B M(H, then for each ǫ let us set A ǫ = A+ǫ and B ǫ = B +ǫ. Then (A ǫ B ǫ,a ǫ +B ǫ M(H. Hence Letting ǫ we get f λ (B f λ (A. f λ (B +ǫ f λ (A+ǫ. Now suppose that f is an operator convex function on [, with f +(. It is known that f can be represented on [, by f(t = f(+βt+γt + f λ (t dµ(λ, (4 where γ, β = f + ( and µ is a positive measure on [, ; see [5, Chapter V]. If f(t = f λ (t dµ(λ,

7 AROUND OPERATOR MONOTONE FUNCTIONS 7 then due to f λ (B f λ (A for each λ R + we have f(b f(a. Since γ,β and B A the validity of f(b f(a is deduced in the general case when f is given by (4. Remark.7. It follows from the identity (A B(A+B+(A+B(A B = (A B that B A if and only if (A B,A+B M(H. We need the Löwner Theorem for establishing our next main result. Theorem.8. [1, Löwner Theorem] A function g defined on (a,b is operator monotone if and only if it is analytic in (a,b, can analytically be continued to the whole upper half-plane {z C : Im(z > } and represents there an analytic function whose imaginary part is non-negative. Theorem.9. Let g be a non-negative operator monotone function on an interval (a,b. Let g(z = u(z + iv(z be its analytic continuation to the upper half-plane. Then for each operator convex function f on [, with f +(, f g is operator monotone on (a,b if and only if u(z on the upper half-plane. Proof. Assume that u(z. By the Löwner Theorem.8, v(z on the upper halfplane. One then sees that g maps the upper half-plane into the first quadrant of plane. Hence g maps the upper half-plane into itself. Utilizing again the Löwner Theorem we conclude that g isoperatormonotone. Assume that AandB areself-adjoint operators with spectra in (a,b and B A. It follows from (g(a g(b(g(a+g(b+(g(a+ g(b(g(a g(b = (g(a g(b that (g(a g(b,g(a+g(b M(H. Now Theorem.6 implies that for each operator convex function f on [, with f +( the function f g is operator monotone on (a,b. Conversely, assume that there would be a complex number z with Imz > such that u(z <. Because g is operator monotone, v(z. Hence π < Arg(g(z < π. Therefore π < Arg(g (z < π. So that Im g (z <. Using the Löwner Theorem.8, g is not operator monotone on (a,b, which is a contradiction, since f(x = x is operator convex on (,. Remark.1. If a non-negative operator monotone function g on an interval (a, b is not a zero constant function and u(z on the domain of g, then u(z > on this domain. To see this note that:

8 8 M.S. MOSLEHIAN AND H. NAJAFI (i If for some t (a,b we have g(t =, then there exists R > such that g can be represented as g(t = g (n (t n=1 (t t n! n for all t (t R,t +R [4, p. 63]. Since g is a non-negative monotone function, g(t = for all t t. Hence g (n (t = for all n, so g is zero on the neighborhood (t R,t +R of t. Thus {t : g(t = } is clopen. Hence g is zero on (a,b contradicting the assumption above. Thus g(t > on (a,b. (ii If g is a constant function, then clearly u(z >. (iii If g is not a constant function, then by the open mapping theorem for non-constant analytic functions, u maps the upper half-plane into {z : Imz > & u(z > }. Corollary.11. Let p 1 with f + (. If B A, then and let f be an operator convex function on [, f(b p f(a p. Proof. Since for p 1 the function g(t = tp is non-negative operator monotone and g takes the upper half-plane into the first quarter of plane, by Theorem.9 we get f g is operator monotone on [,. Corollary.1. Let p 1 and f be a non-negative operator monotone function on [,. Then for positive operators A and B with B A, (i B p f(b p A p f(a p ; (ii If f is strictly positive on (, and A,B are invertible, then A p 1 f(a p B p 1 f(b p. Proof. (i Due to f is operator monotone on [,, by [8, Theorem.4], the function g(t = tf(t is operator convex on [,, hence g +( = f(. Corollary.11 then yields B p f(b p A p f(a p. (ii By part (i, h(t = t p f(t p is operator monotone on (,. By [8, Corollary.6], th(t 1 is operator monotone, hence B 1 p f(b p 1 A 1 p f(a p 1. Therefore A p 1 f(a p B p 1 f(b p. Acknowledgment. The authors would like to sincerely thank the anonymous referee for useful comments and suggestions.

9 AROUND OPERATOR MONOTONE FUNCTIONS 9 References 1. T. Ando and X. Zhan, Norm inequalities related to operator monotone functions, Math. Ann. 315 (1999, J.S. Aujla and J.C. Bourin, Eigenvalue inequalities for convex and log-convex functions, Linear Algebr Appl. 44 ( J.S. Aujla and F. Silva, Weak majorization inequalities and convex functions, Linear Algebra Appl. 369 (3, J. Bendat and S. Sherman, Monotone and convex operator functions, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 79 (1955, R. Bhatia, Matrix Analysis, Springer, New York, T. Furuta, J. Mićić Hot, J. Pečarić and Y. Seo, Mond Pečarić Method in Operator Inequalities, Element, Zagreb, K. Gustafson, Interaction antieigenvalues, J. Math. Anal. Appl. 99 (4, no. 1, F. Hansen and G. Pedersen, Jensen s inequality for operators and Löwner s theorem, Math. Ann. 58 (1981/8, no. 3, F. Hansen, An operator inequality, Math. Ann. 46 (1979/8, no. 3, K. Löwner, Uber monotone matrix funktionen, Math. Z. 38 (1934, D.W. Nicholson, Eigenvalue bounds for AB + BA, with A, B positive definite matrices, Linear Algebra Appl. 4 (1979, W.G. Strang, Eigenvalues of Jordan products, Amer. Math. Monthly. 63 (196, Department of Pure Mathematics, Center of Excellence in Analysis on Algebraic Structures (CEAAS, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, P.O. Box 1159, Mashhad 91775, Iran address: moslehian@ferdowsi.um.ac.ir and moslehian@member.ams.org Department of Pure Mathematics, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, P.O. Box 1159, Mashhad 91775, Iran address: hamednajafi@gmail.com