arxiv:hep-ph/ v1 8 Jul 2003

Transcription

1 KAS-P03053 March 12, 2008: hep-ph/ The Pion Velocity in Dense Skyrmion Matter arxiv:hep-ph/ v1 8 Jul 2003 Hee-Jung Lee a,b, Byung-Yoon Park a,b, Mannque Rho a,c and Vicente Vento a,d (a) School of Physics, Korea nstitute for Advanced Study, Seoul , Korea (b) Department of Physics, Chungnam National University, Daejon , Korea ( hjlee@phya.snu.ac.kr, bypark@chaosphys.cnu.ac.kr) (c) Service de Physique Théorique, CE Saclay Gif-sur-Yvette, France ( rho@spht.saclay.cea.fr) (d) Departament de Fisica Teòrica and nstitut de Física Corpuscular Universitat de València and Consejo Superior de nvestigaciones Científicas E Burjassot (València), Spain ( Vicente.Vento@uv.es) Abstract We have developed a field theory formalism to calculate in-medium properties of hadrons within a unified approach that exploits a single Lagrangian to describe simultaneously both matter and meson fluctuations. n this paper, we study the pion velocity v π, which controls through a dispersion relation, the pion propagation in the medium. The v π is defined in terms of parameters related to the expectation value in matter of the axial-vector current, i.e., the in-medium pion decay constants, f t and f s. These quantities change dramatically with density vanishing at chiral restoration, while the pion velocity does not. We analyze two scenarios, as a function of the dilaton mass, and find that in both cases, the pion velocity decreases at most 10% over the whole density range studied. Pacs: x, Hb, q, 14.70Dj Keywords: pion velocity, pion decay constants, dense matter Present address : Department of Physics, Pusan National University, Pusan , Korea

2 1 1 ntroduction The initial motivation for building high energy heavy ion colliders was the quest for the quark gluon plasma. However, the data and the theoretical developments have shown that the phase diagram of the hadronic matter is far richer and more interesting than initially thought. At high temperature and/or density, hadrons are expected to possess properties that are very different from those at normal conditions. Chiral symmetry, which under normal conditions is spontaneously broken, is believed to be restored under extreme conditions. The value of the quark condensate qq of QCD is an order parameter of this symmetry, and is expected to drop as the temperature and/or density of hadronic matter is increased. Since the pion is the litmus indicator for spontaneously broken chiral symmetry, the various patterns in which the symmetry is realized in QCD, will be directly reflected in the properties of the pions in medium. The most fundamental quantities governing the dynamics of the pion are its mass m π and its decay decay constant f π. These quantities have been the subject of previous studies in the formalism adopted here [1, 2]. The property we are interested in is encoded in the pion dispersion relation in medium, which involves, besides the mass, the so-called pion velocity in medium, v π. This allows us to gain more insight into the real time properties of the system under extreme conditions and enable us to analyze how the phase transition from normal matter to deconfined QCD phase takes place bottom-up from the hadronic side. At nonzero temperature and/or density, we have to take into account that the Lorentz symmetry is broken by the medium. n the dispersion relation for the pion modes (in the chiral limit) p 2 0 = v 2 π p 2, (1) the velocity v π which is 1 in free-space must depart from 1. This may be studied reliably at least at low temperatures and at low densities via chiral perturbation theory [3]. The in-medium pion velocity is evaluated by studying the time component of the pion decay constant, fπ t and the space component, fπ, s 0 A 0 a π b (p) in-medium = ifπδ t ab p 0, 0 A i a π b (p) in-medium = ifπδ s ab p i (2). The conservation of the axial vector current leads to the dispersion relation (1) with the pion velocity given by v 2 π = f s π/f t π. (3) Other authors [4, 5] define two decay constants, f t and f s, different from those of eq. (2)), through the effective Lagrangian, L eff = f2 t 4 Tr( 0U 0 U) f2 s 4 Tr( iu i U) +, (4) where U is an SU(2) valued chiral field whose phase describes the in-medium pion. n terms of these constants, the pion velocity is defined by v π = f s /f t. (5) What we are interested in is the pion velocity in dense medium as one approaches chiral restoration. Before entering into this matter, we briefly review the status of v π at high temperature. There are two basically different predictions depending upon what degrees of freedom are taken into account, namely at T = T c, v π = 0 in one version and v π 1 in another version. This stark difference is the motivation for our investigation of dense matter.

3 2 Consider the scenario described by two-flavor linear sigma model where the relevant degrees of freedom in heat bath are the pions π and a scalar σ. n this model, as the temperature approaches the critical temperature T c, chiral symmetry becomes restored, the pions and the scalar join in an O(4) multiplet, the phase transition belonging to the O(4) universality class. This is the standard scenario largely accepted by the community in the field. t has been shown [4, 5] that this scenario predicts that at T = T c, the pion velocity must vanish. The argument is simple. Elevating the isovector axial chemical potential µ A to an U(1) gauge field a powerful trick, it follows from the low-energy effective action of QCD that the isovector axial susceptibility (ASUS) χ A is proportional to f 2 t that figures in eq.(4) where f t is the time component of the fully renormalized pion decay constant in heat bath. While one cannot reliably compute f t at low orders, one can use the information that the ASUS must equal the isovector vector susceptibility (VSUS) χ V at the phase transition. Now one knows that χ V T=Tc 0 from lattice measurements which implies that f t T=Tc 0 and that f s T=Tc = 0 from a general consideration. Thus we have at T = T c v π = f s /f t = 0. (6) This is an unequivocal prediction of the standard linear sigma model prediction. The situation is markedly different when other light degrees of freedom are present. t has been shown [6] that when light vector mesons are in the picture as predicted by the hidden local symmetry theory with the vector manifestation à la Harada and Yamawaki [7] (referred to as HLS/VM), the pion velocity is close to 1 at all temperatures near T c. The crucial element that leads to this result is that the HLS theory with the vector mesons ρ and the pions coupled gauge invariantly and matched to QCD at the matching scale Λ M has the vector manifestation fixed point at which the parametric mass of the vector meson M ρ and gauge coupling g vanish. To this fixed point flows the system as one approaches the criticality (in temperature, in density or in the number of flavors). To one-loop order in a generalized chiral perturbation theory in the presence of light vectors expected to be a good approximation near the critical point, the VM assures that χ A = χ V at T = T c, (f t π,fs π ) (0,0) (with f π s defined in (2)) as T T c. As a consequence 1 v π 1. (7) We now turn to the main objective of this paper, which is to see whether there is a similar dramatic dependence of the pion velocity on the degrees of freedom also in dense matter. At present, although it has been established that hadronic matter at high density flows to the VM fixed point [9], describing dense matter in HLS/VM is found not to be easy because of coupled renormalization group equations in the renormalization scale and in density. Up to date, no conclusive result on physical variables (e.g., f π, susceptibilities etc) has been obtained. We need therefore to resort to other formalisms. At low density, the standard chiral perturbation theory without vector degrees of freedom should be applicable. The in-medium pion decay constants have been computed to first order in the baryon number density ρ [11]. The results are f t π = f π(1 0.26ρ/ρ 0 ) and f s π = f π(1 1.23ρ/ρ 0 ), where ρ 0 is normal nuclear matter density. Note that the space component is highly suppressed with respect to the time one. Therefore the in-medium pion velocity scales as v 2 π = fs π /ft π 1 ρ/ρ 0. (8) 1 The pion velocity in this scenario is not exactly equal to 1. There is a small deviation from 1 due to the fact that the heat bath violates Lorentz invariance by a small amount at the matching point Λ M. This has been computed and will be reported in a future publication [8].

4 3 QCD sum rules have also been applied to calculating the in-medium pion decay constants [13, 12]. n the pseudoscalar axial-vector correlation function used, the dimension-5 condensate in the nucleon is found to play the most important role in splitting the time and space components of the pion decay constant. Unfortunately little is known whether in free space or in medium of the dimension-5 operators, so one cannot make quantitative estimates. For instance, a positive value of the condensate yields fπ s/ft π > 1 and a tachyonic pion mass [13], clearly at odds with causality. n ref. [12], the problem was turned around: taking the in-medium pion mass as an input parameter, the authors of [12] obtained a negative condensate. t turns out that the contribution of the intermediate states is important in getting the sensible result. Using the input values for the in-medium mass in the range 139MeV < m π < 159 MeV, they obtain fπ/f s π = and fπ/f t π = and as a consequence the in-medium pion velocity is in the range of 1/3 < v π < 1. (9) n this paper, we study the in-medium pion velocity in the systematic field theory scheme developed in our recent works [1, 2]. There, the Skyrme picture is adopted to describe in a unified way both the pions and dense baryonic matter. A contact with HLS/VM theory of Harada and Yamawaki was suggested there. A static soliton solution having an FCC crystal structure [18] is found to describe dense baryonic matter. The pion is incorporated as fluctuating fields on top of this dense skyrmion matter. The interactions between the pions and matter modify the pion effective mass and decay constant. The background skyrmion matter breaks Lorentz invariance and thus the resulting space and time components of the pion decay constant become different. n the following section, we describe the Skyrme model approach used for investigating the properties of the pions in dense matter. n Sec. 3, we study the in-medium pion velocity by taking into account the background matter effect up to the second order in the interactions. We make a brief conclusion in Sec Model Lagrangian The aim of our series of investigations has been to develop the full dynamics of dense matter from a unique Lagrangian, which we have taken for simplicity of Skyrme type. Here, we use a modified Skyrme model Lagrangian [14, 15, 16], which incorporates in an effective way the scale anomaly of QCD in terms of a scalar dilaton field: L = f2 π 4 ( χ f χ ) 2 Tr( µ U µ U) µχ µ χ m2 χ f2 ( ) χ (χ/f χ ) 4 (ln(χ/f χ ) ) (10) where U = exp(i τ π/f π ) SU(2) and χ is the scalar field. The parameters in eq. (10) are related to physical properties, f π is the pion decay constant in free space, f χ the corresponding quantity for the scalar field and m χ its mass. For simplicity we will work with massless pions. The Lagrangian (10) in the B = 0 sector describes only mesons and yields the following pion and scalar field solutions in the vacuum, The fluctuations about this vacuum can be described by U = 1, χ = f χ. (11) U π = exp(i τ ϕ/f π ), and χ = f χ + χ. (12)

5 4 Up to the second order in ϕ and χ, we obtain L = 1 2 µϕ a µ ϕ a µ χ µ χ 1 2 m2 χ χ 2 +. (13) This Lagrangian can also describe, à la Skyrme [17], baryons, i.e., the skyrmions, as topological solitons if a proper stabilizing term, e.g., the Skyrme term L sk = 1 32e 2Tr ( [U µ U,U ν U] 2) (14) is added. The winding number associated with the homotopy of the static solution U 0 ( r) is taken as the baryon number, B = 1 24π 2εijk d 3 rtr(u 0 i U 0 U 0 j U 0 U 0 k U 0 ). (15) Two skyrmions are most attractive when they are relatively rotated by an angle π about an axis perpendicular to the line joining their centers. Thus the lowest energy configuration of skyrmions for a given number density is in crystal phase with all the neighboring skyrmions in the most attractive orientations. Moreover, the ground state of the scalar field χ is shifted from the constant value f χ to a static field configuration χ 0 ( r) in order to reduce the energy of the whole skyrmion-scalar system. (See ref. [2] for the details.) The pion and scalar in dense medium can be described by fluctuations on skyrmion matter through the Ansätze U = U π U 0 ( r) U π, and χ = χ 0 ( r) + χ. (16) Expanding up to the second order in the fluctuating fields, we obtain L = 1 2 Gab ( r) µ ϕ a µ ϕ b + ǫ abc ϕ a i ϕ b V i c ( r) µ χ µ χ 1 2 M( r) χ2 + P i a( r) χ i ϕ a. (17) This Lagrangian describes single particles moving under local background potentials provided by the static field configurations U 0 ( r) and χ 0 ( r). We have shortened the lengthy expressions for the local potentials introducing G ab ( r), Vc i ( r), M( r), Pa( r). i Their explicit forms are shown in ref. [2]. Assuming background matter to be known, eq. (17) shows, when compared with eq. (13), that a direct ϕ-χ (not only ϕ 2 -χ) coupling might appear, which is absent in free space. Hereafter, we will drop the tildes for the fluctuating scalar field. n refs. [1, 2], by replacing the local potentials with their averages over space, we obtained L eff = 1 2 Gaa µ ϕ a µ ϕ a µχ µ χ 1 2 M χ2 +. (18) We interpret this result as an effective Lagrangian for the in-medium pions and scalar with intrinsic parameters G aa and M, which correspond to the in-medium pion decay constant and the effective mass for the scalar respectively. n this naive approximation, Lorentz symmetry is still preserved. Thus, the pion velocity is 1 at this level. However, static local potentials will definitely break the Lorentz symmetry. n this work, we are going to evaluate the deviation of the pion velocity from 1 due to this background. Our strategy to perform the calculation is based on the following result. When local interactions with background matter are taken into account they lead to an effective Lagrangian for pion dynamics in the form of eq. (4) which defines the quantities necessary for the calculation.

6 5 Let us be more specific. As far as the single pion is concerned, to lowest order in the fields, eq. (4) with U = exp(i τ ϕ/f π ) becomes 2 L eff = 1 2 ( ft f π ) 2 0 ϕ a 0 ϕ a 1 2 ( fs f π ) 2 i ϕ a i ϕ a +. (19) Thus the procedure consists in calculating the propagators for the pion and the scalar fields from (17) by solving for the background potentials. Then, matching these propagators with those obtained from the effective Lagrangian (19), we have for the pion 1 Zt 1 p 2 0 (20) Z 1 s p 2 where Zt,s 1 = (f t,s /f π ) 2. Before we proceed to the calculation, we digress to obtain relations between the parameters, f t,s and fπ t,s, defined in ntroduction. The effective Lagrangian (4) yields the following axial vector current components ) ( 0 UU τa A a 0 = if2 t 4 Tr A a i = if2 t 4 Tr 2 0U U τa = (ft 2 2 /f π) 0 ϕ, ) = (fs 2 /f π) i ϕ, ( i UU τa 2 iu U τa 2 where the last equality is obtained by substituting the value of U = exp(i τ ϕ/f π ). When the expectation value of these axial vector current components is taken as in eq. (2), we obtain relations between the various parameters, f t = fπ t, and f s = fπ sft π. (22) Similar relations are derived in ref. [6] for the real part of the complex pion decay constants. n what follows, the results will be given in terms of f t and f s. 3 n-medium Pion Velocity n order to obtain nontrivial results for the pion velocity in the medium we need to take into account the higher order effects of the background potentials. We shall proceed here in a perturbative scheme. To do so we decompose the Lagrangian into an unperturbed part, L 0, and an interaction part, L. The simplest way to do so is to take the free Lagrangian (13) as L 0 and the rest as L, explicitly, (21) L = 1 2 (Gab ( r) δ ab ) µ ϕ a µ ϕ b + ǫ abc ϕ a i ϕ b V i c ( r) 1 2 (M( r) m2 χ) χ 2 + P i a( r) χ i ϕ a. (23) The presence of the local interaction potential G ab ( r) in the pion kinetic energy term makes the quantization process of the fluctuating pions nontrivial. The conjugate momenta of the pion fields ϕ a are given by Π a L 0 ϕ a = ϕ a. (24) 2 f one substituted U = exp(i τ ϕ /f t) with renormalized pion fields ϕ a, one would have L eff = 1 2 ( 0ϕ a 0ϕ a v 2 π iϕ a iϕ a) +.

7 6 ϕ a (p 0, p) δ ab p 2 0 p2 ϕ b χ (p 0, p) 1 p 2 0 p2 m 2 χ χ ϕ a H ϕϕ ϕ b ( l) (p 0, p) (q 0, q) (p 2 0 p q)(gab ( l) δ ab ) +iǫ abc p V c ( l) χ H ϕχ ( l) ϕ a (p 0, p) (q 0, q) i q P a ( l) χ H χχ ( l) χ (p 0, p) (q 0, q) M( l) m 2 χ Figure 1: Free propagators and interactions for the pion and the scalar fields in the presence of background skyrmion matter. The energy-momentum conservation delta functions are not shown. We obtain where and H = H 0 + H, (25) H 0 = 1 2 ( ϕa ϕ a + i ϕ a i ϕ a ) ( χ χ + iχ i χ + m 2 χ χ2 ), (25a) H = L. (25b) Note that the interaction Hamiltonian H is simply L. The free propagators defined by H 0 and the interaction potentials appearing due to H are summarized in Fig. 1. n Fig. 1, G ab ( l), for example, is the Fourier transformed of the local potential G ab ( r): G ab ( l) = 1 d 3 re i l r G ab ( r), (26) V box box where the integration is over a unit box of the crystal and V box is its volume. Due to the periodic structure of the crystal only discrete momentum values are possible. We show in Fig. 2 the diagrams used to evaluate the self-energy. Only the diagrams for Σ ϕaϕ b appear. The symmetry structure of the skyrmion matter allows a nonvanishing self-energy only for a = b, One easily gets the corresponding diagrams for Σ ϕaχ or Σ χχ. To first order, Σ (1) is nothing but H ( l = 0). Since H ϕχ ( 0) = 0, no mixing between the fluctuating pions and the fluctuating scalar occurs. Thus, the pion propagator for ϕ a can be expressed as 1 p 2 0 p2 Σ (1) (p 0, p) = 1 G aa ( 0)(p 2 0 p2 ). (27) where we have used that the self energy to this order is Σ (1) ϕ aϕ a (p 0, p) = p 2 (G aa ( 0) 1). The superscript (1) means that the quantities are evaluated to first order. Comparing these results with the propagator (20), we obtain f t = f s = f π G aa ( 0). Since G aa ( 0) is nothing but the average of G aa ( r) over the space, our calculation thus far reproduces the results of ref. [2]. To

8 7 ϕ a ϕ a ϕ a ϕ a Σ (p (1) = H ϕϕ ( 0) 0, p) (p 0, p) (p 0, p) (p 0, p) ϕ a ϕ a ϕ a Σ (p (2) = H ϕϕ ( 0, p) (p 0, p) l) (p 0, p) (p 0, p + H ϕϕ ( l) l) (p 0, p) ϕ b ϕ b ϕ a ϕ a + H ϕχ ( l) χ χ (p 0, p) (p 0, p + H χϕ ( ϕ a l) l) (p 0, p) Figure 2: Diagrams used to evaluate the self-energy of the ϕ a propagation up to second order in the interaction. Here, b runs over 1,2,3 and the intermediate states run over all l 0. the same order, the self-energy of the scalar field is Σ (1) χχ = M( 0) m 2 χ. Since it is constant, this self-energy modifies just the scalar mass from the free value m χ to M( 0). Now, let us evaluate the second order diagrams shown in Fig. 2. Again, the symmetry of the background skyrmion matter does not allow nonvanishing off diagonal components such as Σ (2) ϕ aϕ b (a b) and Σ (2) χϕ a. We obtain Σ (2) ϕ aϕ b (p 0, p) = δ ab Σ (2) l 0 { (p 2 0 p ( p + l))g ab ( l) + ǫ abc p V c ( l) 2 p 2 0 ( p + l) 2 p + P a ( } l) 2 p 2 0 ( p +, (28) l) 2 m 2 χ ϕ aχ(p 0, p) = 0, (29) Σ (2) χχ (p 0, p) = { p Pa ( l) 2 l 0 p 2 0 ( p + l) + M( } l) 2 2 p 2 0 ( p +, (30) l) 2 m 2 χ Again, in spite of the ϕ χ coupling term in the interaction Lagrangian (23), Σ (2) χϕ a vanishes so that the pion propagator and the scalar propagator can be simply written as 1 p 2 0 p2 Σ (1+2), ϕ b ϕ a 1 p 2 0 p2 m 2 χ Σ(1+2) χχ, (31) respectively. The p 0 and p dependence of Σ (2) is not so simple as that of Σ (1). Let s consider the small energy-momentum region. f we expand the self-energy Σ ϕaϕ b in powers of p 0 and p, then the coefficients to second order in p 0 and p 2 lead to ( ft f π ) 2 = ( fs f π ) 2 = Σ (1+2) ϕ aϕ a p Σ (1+2) ϕ aϕ a p 2 i = G aa ( 0), (32) 0, 0 = G aa ( 0) { V i c 2 + l 2 i Gab ( l) 2 + P a( i } l) 2. (33) 0, 0 l 0 l 2 l 2 + m 2 χ

9 8 We have used to obtain this result that the off diagonal components of 2 Σ (1+2) / p i p j 0, 0 (i j) vanish. Note that the second order correction terms contribute only to f s /f π and since they are all negative the pion velocity becomes v π < 1. n a similar way, the scalar mass gets a second order correction given by m 2 χ = m 2 χ + Σ (1+2) χχ (0, 0) = M( 0) M( l) 2 l 2 + m 2. (34) χ l 0 Shown in Fig. 3 are the decay constants f t and f s in units of f π. The inset figure is their ratio, i.e. the in-medium pion velocity v π. We have used f π = 93 MeV, e = 4.75, f χ = 240 MeV and m χ = 720 MeV 3. To second order the contribution to f s /f π turns out to be small, and thus the pion velocity stays v π 1. The lowest value is about 0.9. Furthermore, for the pions at higher matter densities, the internal propagator provides an extra suppression because l scales as ρ 1/3. Once we pass the density at which the pion velocity has its minimum, the pion velocity increases with density and approaches 1. When the background matter is in the half-skyrmion phase, χ 0 ( r) vanishes identically and so do all the local potentials. Thus, both f t and f s vanish. Moreover, their difference is proportional to the square of the potentials and vanishes faster. This fact explains the asymptotic behavior v π 1 in Fig. 3. This result is very similar to that of ref. [6] found in heat bath, where the pion velocity approaches to 1 while both the spatial and temporal pion decay constants vanish at T = T c. Although we believe that the scalar that enters in our consideration is the scalar associated with the soft glue, it is interesting to see what happens if we take a massive scalar. Clearly the massive scalar will decouple from the pions as one approaches the chiral transition. ts effect on the pion dynamics will of course become small. n this case, we expect to recover the naive Skyrme model with only pion degrees of freedom. This is indeed what happens numerically. n Fig. 4 we show the results obtained with m χ = 5 GeV. We can see that f t stays at a constant value 2/3 as in our previous work [1]. n this limit when the scalar decouples as the density increases, the two components of the pion decay constant and the pion velocity converge to fixed values. 4 Conclusion We have developed a formalism to calculate in-medium properties within a unified approach which describes within the same Lagrangian both matter and meson fluctuations. n this paper, we have studied the pion velocity, which controls through a dispersion relation, the pion propagation in the medium. For simplicity, we have chosen massless pions and therefore the propagation is entirely controlled by the velocity. Both f t and f s are found to drop dramatically with density, whereas the pion velocity remains little changed from the vacuum value, decreasing at most by 10%. We have analyzed two different limits according to the scalar mass which incorporates the scale anomaly into the model. For a massive scalar with a mass much greater than the chiral 3 This is the free-space mass of the scalar relevant to our situation. n [2], we have considered a range of masses, including higher masses. However as stressed there, what we are concerned with is the mode associated with soft glue that is locked with chiral symmetry and it is the lower mass scalar that figures there. There is a compelling evidence [19] for this in the structure of temperature-driven chiral restoration transition where one observes that only about 50% of the QCD trace anomaly disappears across T c, leaving the other half in the form of epoxy glue. The part that melts at the phase transition is found to be encoded in the scalar field of mass 700 MeV. This suggests that our description here as well as in [2] is consistent with the picture arrived at in [19]. See also [20].

10 9 Figure 3: f t and f s as a function of skyrmion matter density for the chiral limit, m π = 0 and m χ = 720 MeV. The in medium pion velocity appears as function of matter density in the small box. Figure 4: f t and f s as function of skyrmion matter density in the heavy scalar mass limit (we used m χ = 5 GeV).

11 10 scale 1 GeV, the pion velocity tends to a constant as the density increases. However for a scalar mass commensurate with the soft glue locked to chiral symmetry as observed in temperature-driven chiral restoration, the pion velocity decreases in the intermediate region but tends towards 1 at higher densities, a feature that supports the HLS/VM scenario in heat bath [6] and is at variance with that given by linear sigma model in the O(4) universality class [4]. We must note that our calculation was made in perturbation theory to second order which we believe is justified at low densities but we do not have at present a control of this approximation for larger densities. Work is in progress to improve on this scheme. Acknowledgements Hee-Jung Lee, Byung-Yoon Park and Vicente Vento are grateful for the hospitality extended to them by KAS, where this work was initiated. This work was partially supported by grants MCyT-BFM and GV01-26 (VV), KOSEF Grant R (BYP), M (HJL)

12 11 References [1] H.-J. Lee, B.-Y. Park, D.-P. Min, M. Rho and V. Vento, A unified approach to high density: Pion fluctuations in skyrmion matter, hep-ph/ , Nucl. Phys. A723 (2003) 427. [2] H.-J. Lee, B.-Y. Park, M. Rho and V. Vento, Sliding vacua in dense skyrmion matter, Nucl. Phys. A, in press, hep-ph/ [3] R. D. Pisarski and M. Tytgat, Phys. Rev. D54 (1996) R2989. [4] D. T. Son and Stephanov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 (2002) [5] D. T. Son and Stephanov, Phys. Rev. D66 (2002) [6] M. Harada, Y. Kim, M. Rho and C. Sasaki, Effective degrees of freedom at chiral restoration and the vector manifestation in HLS theory, Nucl. Phys. A, in press, hep-ph/ [7] M. Harada and K. Yamawaki, Phys. Rep., to appear, hep-ph/ [8] M. Harada, Y. Kim, M. Rho and C. Sasaki, in preparation. [9] M. Harada, Y. Kim and M. Rho, Phys. Rev. D66 (2002) [10] On the contrary, in ref. [5], the hot-medium pion velocity is evaluated explicitly in the linear sigma model as v 2 π = (1+T 2 /3 σ 2 ) 1 with the temperature-dependent vacuum expectation value of σ, σ. This formula works only in the range of T σ m σ. f we substitute T σ, we have v π 0.87 only! [11] Ulf-G. Meissner, J. A. Oller, and A. Wirzba, Ann. Phys. 297 (2002) 27. [12] H. Kim and M. Oka, hep-ph/ [13] H. Kim, Phys. Rev. C65 (2002) [14] J. Ellis and J. Lanik, Phys. Lett. B150 (1985) 289. [15] V.A. Novikov, M.A. Shifman, A.. Vainshtein, V.. Zakharov, Nucl.Phys. B165 (1980) 67. [16] G.E. Brown and M. Rho, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66 (1991) [17] T.H.R. Skyrme, Nucl. Phys. 31 (1962) 556. [18] For example, see M. Kugler and S. Shtrikman, Phys. Lett. B208 (1988) 491; Phys. Rev. D40 (1989) [19] G.E. Brown, L. Grandchamp, C.-H. Lee and M. Rho, Nature of the chiral restoration transition in QCD, to appear. [20] Y. Hatta and K. Fukushima, Linking the chiral and deconfinement phase transitions, hep-ph/