A Re-Evaluation of Schrodinger s Cat Paradox

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "A Re-Evaluation of Schrodinger s Cat Paradox"

Transcription

1 A Re-Evaluation of Schrodinger s Cat Paradox Wells Lucas Santo 5 December 2012 PL2293 Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics Professor Jonathan Bain 1

2 1 Introduction This paper is a re-examination of the famous Cat Paradox proposed by Erwin Schrodinger in Today, Schrodinger s Cat is discussed almost synonymously with the Measurement Problem of Quantum Mechanics. However, I posit that Schrodinger s Cat also proposes an equally important challenge of the literal interpretation of Quantum Mechanics by offering a mystifying view of Quantum Superposition. In order to show this, I will trace the discussion of Schrodinger s Cat from its inception to the present over the course of this paper. In Section 2, I will take an etiological move back to Schrodinger s paper, The Present Situation in Quantum Mechanics, where the Cat Paradox was originally proposed, and re-examine his original intentions associated with introducing the Cat Paradox. In conjunction with looking at Schrodinger s paper, I will also look at the 1935 EPR Argument, which Schrodinger admits to be a key motivator for his own work. In Section 3, I describe the Measurement Problem that arises as a result of the Cat Paradox and discuss how later interpretations of Quantum Mechanics, such as Wigner s Friend, have tried to solve the Measurement Problem in relationship with Schrodinger s Cat. In Section 4, I will then put Schrodinger s Cat in conversation with the Many Worlds Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. In Section 5, I introduce a potential solution to Schrodinger s Cat offered earlier this year by Professor Art Hobson of the University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, who molds his discussion around the phenomenon of Quantum Decoherence. Finally, in Section 6, I conclude this paper with a quick discussion on what a complete resolution of Schrodinger s Cat promises. 2 The Cat Paradox -By-Itself 2.1 Historical Context When Erwin Schrodinger imagined the Cat Paradox in 1935, one of the most hotly debated topics of the day was whether Quantum Mechanics (QM) could be taken as a successful ontologically literal physical theory. Earlier that year, Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) contended that in order for a physical theory to be successful, or satisfactory, it had to be both correct and complete (1935, pg. 777). While the 2

3 correctness of Quantum Mechanics can simply be tested by comparing the result of an a priori model with the a posteriori empirical result, EPR believed that completeness could only be fulfilled when every element of the physical reality must have a counterpart in the physical theory (1935, pg. 777). From here, EPR argued quite famously that the wave function (otherwise written as ψ-function) was incomplete: if it were actually complete, it would allow for non-locality, which they could not bear to accept. It is this that motivated Schrodinger to posit the Cat Paradox, in an attempt to make an argument for the incompleteness of QM without having to invoke the ideas of locality and we now refer to as entanglement (1935, pg. 163). For Schrodinger, the ψ-function is defined to be complete in the sense that it does not at all lack precision, but rather adds precision to our efforts at describing the world. With the ψ-function, we can calculate with certainty a fully determined statistical distribution to every variable, thus outlining exactly what outcomes are probable, and excluding all other outcomes that are not at all possible (1935, pg. 154). Even then, definite values of properties cannot be predicted by the ψ-function, and can only be obtained through direct measurements of the system. This is what deeply disturbs Schrodinger. How can we assume QM to be complete and take it ontologically seriously when the ψ-function merely describes a system as an ensemble of states in superposition (1935, pg. 155)? Without resolving this issue, the dynamics of the ψ-function cannot properly describe our reality by itself. Schrodinger thus devises the famous Cat Paradox in order to add weight this troubling issue of both measurement and superposition. 2.2 Coins Versus Cats In his thought experiment, Schrodinger describes a cat that is locked in a steel chamber with a Geiger counter that measures a radioactive substance, whose atoms have a chance of decaying after a certain period of time. If an atom decays, the Geiger counter releases a hammer that breaks a vial of hydrocyanic acid and kills the cat (1935, pg. 157). The question then becomes, if we leave this cat alone for a period of time, how do we know if it is alive or dead? The obvious answer would be to open the steel chamber and simply check that is, to make a measurement. But before we make such a measurement, can we know and say which state that the cat is in? 3

4 In order to better explain the spookiness of the Cat Paradox, I would like to relate it to the flipping of an ideal and fair coin. Let us say that I flip a fair coin and immediately cup my hand over it such that I do not observe which side it has landed on. Because I have not yet measured the outcome of the flip, I am epistemically uncertain whether the coin has landed heads or tails. Like with the aliveness of Schrodinger s Cat, there is a chance that either event has occurred. When I take my hand off the coin, I am then able to see which of the two outcomes has actually happened. However, with the flipping of the coin, I can be certain that the coin definitely landed on either heads or tails before I looked at it. In this case, my measurement did not cause the coin to become either heads or tails. With a literal QM interpretation, I cannot be so certain that this holds true for the aliveness of Schrodinger s Cat, for the state of the cat is in a superposition an ontological uncertainty. It seems to me that it is the issue of superposition, or more specifically the literal interpretation of it, that primarily distinguishes the quantum weirdness of Schrodinger s Cat with the uncertainty of a simple coin toss. 2.3 The Blurriness What is so spooky about superposition is that I cannot adopt any of the four classically logical descriptions of the cat s aliveness. In superposition, the cat is not dead, not alive, not both alive and dead, and not neither alive nor dead. So what can I say of the cat s state before I make a measurement? If the literal interpretation of superposition is to be taken seriously, Schrodinger asks, Have [systems in superposition] then no reality, perhaps a blurred reality? (1935, pg. 155) For things at the atomic level, this blurriness does not seem to pose a great challenge for physicists. However, when extended to the macroscopic scale, as with Schrodinger s Cat, it seems nonsensical and unacceptable to allow for a blurring of reality. For anyone who wishes to adopt any sort of ontologically, or ontic, literal interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, I propose that they must first be able to more adequately explain what occurs when a system is in a superposition of states. Of course, this is not what most physicists and philosophers find about Schrodinger s Cat that is most troubling rather, for them, the trouble comes from the Measurement Problem. 3 The Measurement Problem 4

5 After describing the Cat Paradox, Schrodinger continues by explaining that the macroscopic indeterminacy can then be resolved by direct observation, or in other words, by measurement (1935, pg. 157). This then brings about the core of the Measurement Problem what exactly does a measurement entail? More importantly, when does a measurement occur? And finally, is measurement the only thing that can cause a superposition to collapse? For Schrodinger s Cat, it would be quite odd to say that if we never look inside the steel chamber, the cat will forever be in a blurred reality. However, if a theory were to propose that the state of the cat does collapse to either being alive or dead before measurement, it would still need to describe when and how that collapse occurs. Many interpretations of quantum mechanics since 1935 have sought to resolve the paradox of Schrodinger s Cat. Wigner s Friend, for example, leads to the idea that there are two fundamentally different sorts of physical systems in the world, and introduces the philosophical notion of Cartesian mind-body dualism into mainstream physics (Albert 1994, pg. 82). In his interpretation, Wigner believes that collapse only occurs when a conscious being observes a system in superposition. The cat becomes either alive or dead when the first conscious being observes the state of the cat. However, this requires of Wigner a great undertaking to discuss what exactly consciousness is defined as, and whether it can actually be said to exist or not. 1 As a result, it seems that most contemporary philosophers and physicists adopt the Many Worlds interpretation, as it offers them a seemingly clever solution to the Cat Paradox. 4 Many Worlds and Many New Cats In the Many Worlds interpretation, which was originally proposed by Hugh Everett in 1957 and expanded on by Bryce DeWitt in 1970, each term in a superposition given by the ψ-function corresponds literally to a different physical world (Albert 1994, pg. 113). For instance, if an electron in the state black > is sent through a Hardness measuring box, the resulting superposition of hard > and soft > terms would correspond to two wholly different worlds: one where the electron is found to be hard, and the other where the electron is found to be soft. 1 The materialist Daniel Dennett would surely propose, then, that collapse never occurs, while the panpsychist Galen Strawson would argue that collapse always occurs. 5

6 An advocate of the Many Worlds interpretation would thus say that in performing the Schrodinger s Cat experiment, our world would split into two separate, non-interacting worlds, where the cat is alive in one world and dead in the other. It seems at first glance that this interpretation of QM successfully avoids the sort of blurriness that bothers Schrodinger, but as Albert points out, the Many Worlds interpretation still leads to many new problems. For instance, what does it mean for there to be a 50% chance of Schrodinger s Cat being alive or dead, if both cases necessarily will occur in different worlds (Albert 1994, pg. 115)? Furthermore, Hughes (1992, pg. 293) points out that experimentally, the Many Worlds interpretation still leads to the same predictions as a literal interpretation of QM. For when a measurement occurs, we cannot perceive the phenomenon of world splitting, and as a result, the wave packet has collapsed no less mysteriously (Hughes 1992, pg. 293). Though Schrodinger s Cat may not suffer from any blurring of reality due to world splitting, we still do not know whether the cat is alive or dead until we open the steel chamber and look inside. In addition, I must ask when exactly this phenomenon of world splitting occurs. If we believe that world splitting semantically replaces the phenomenon of a measurement, then we still run into all of the same problems as before. For instance, at which point in time during the Schrodinger s Cat experiment does the world split? Splitting cannot occur right when we close the steel chamber with the cat inside, for we could simply open the chamber back up and save the cat before any radioactive atoms have the chance to decay. Similarly, splitting cannot only occur when we open up the steel chamber to check on the cat, because that would still leave the cat in a blurred reality prior to checking on the cat just as the Measurement Problem did. In conclusion, it seems that trying to pinpoint the time when a world splits is quite similar a task as trying to define when a measurement occurs, and perhaps the Many Worlds interpretation as commonly understood is not enough to address the Cat Paradox. 5 Hobson and Decoherence In an article published earlier this year, Art Hobson argues for a solution to Schrodinger s Cat that utilizes both entanglement and Quantum Decoherence. First, Hobson makes the claim that the common description of Schrodinger s Cat as being in the state cat> = a life> + b death> is incorrect, and instead, the cat 6

7 state must be written cat> = a live cat> undecayed nucleus> + b dead cat> decayed nucleus> in order to express an entanglement between the cat and the radioactive atom (2013, pg. 4). This description of the Cat Paradox in terms of entangled states seems to be wholly valid if we perform the thought experiment with some slight modifications. Let us imagine that our steel chamber is technologically advanced, and allows us to separate the chamber in half, while keeping the contents of the two halves hidden. If we run the Schrodinger experiment for a certain period of time, we can then separate the chambers and bring them a great distance apart from one another, before opening either of the chambers and looking inside. If we look inside the chamber with the radioactive atom and see that the nucleus has decayed, then we know that the cat is no longer alive. Conversely, if we see that the nucleus has not decayed, then we know that the cat is still alive. Following a conventional explanation of entanglement, we can say that both the cat and the nucleus are in superposition states until a measurement is made on either one of the two. It is only at this point that collapse occurs. However, Hobson does not stop here. By operating on the idea that an entangled system necessarily interacts with its environment, Hobson claims that environmental interactions cause the entangled system to decohere, which for him, is equivalent to superposition collapse (2013, pg. 1). He believes, then, that we do not need to wait until a measurement is performed in order for an entangled system to collapse. In fact, Hobson boldly states that looking at the outcome changes nothing, beyond informing the observer of what has already happened (2013, pg. 4). Given that his interpretation of Quantum Decoherence is accurate, Hobson s solution to Schrodinger s Cat Paradox would essentially escape the Measurement Problem and the issue of blurriness by reducing the ontic uncertainty of all entangled states to mere epistemic uncertainty. Not knowing whether the cat is alive or dead would be no more mysterious or distressing than whether a coin landed heads-up or tails-up. But can we accept Hobson s interpretation of Quantum Decoherence? For all practical purposes, it may be acceptable to say that Decoherence and collapse are equivalent, but for Hobson to unequivocally equate the two seems to be too bold of an assertion, especially considering that it may be ideally possible to distinguish between a decohered and a collapsed state. Furthermore, if Decoherence does equate to collapse, we must still ask when Decoherence exactly occurs, and whether the 7

8 system will still suffer from blurriness at any point in time. Nonetheless, Hobson s attempt at solving Schrodinger s Cat and escaping the Measurement Problem can be learned from, especially in considering the cat state as an entanglement of states, rather than a mere superposition. If we choose to do this, however, we will be forced to abandon Schrodinger s original goal of challenging the literal interpretation of Quantum Mechanics without having to deal with entanglement, as EPR did. 6 Conclusion: What A Complete Resolution Promises In conclusion, we can trace the origin of Schrodinger s Cat Paradox as an attempt to question the literal, ontic interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. By proposing a sort of reductio ad absurdum argument, Schrodinger showed how quantum superpositions could be amplified from a microscopic to macroscopic scale, and that a literal interpretation of QM would lead to an unacceptable blurriness of reality. What exactly does this blurriness mean, and what does it entail for those experiencing it? In addition, the Cat Paradox raises the question of when a measurement occurs and what exactly a measurement is defined as. Therefore, in order for an interpretation of QM to be seriously considered, it must first answer the questions posed by Schrodinger s Cat for both the Measurement Problem and the Superposition Problem. While looking at different proposed solutions to the Cat Paradox, we may also consider whether that interpretation is complete as defined by EPR. While both the Wigner s Friend and Many Worlds interpretations seem to explain current problems of physical reality quite well, the mind-body duality of Wigner s Friend and the phenomena of world-splitting in Many Worlds seem to introduce more unanswered problems that do not necessarily solve Schrodinger s Cat. Finally, as Hobson shows, considering Schrodinger s Cat as a question of entanglement seems to slightly aid our task of escaping the Cat Paradox, but we must be very careful when adopting certain theories such as Decoherence. Perhaps, once we understand more about Decoherence can we move closer to addressing both the Superposition and the Measurement Problems. 8

9 References Albert, D.Z. (1994). Quantum Mechanics and Experience. Harvard University Press. Einstein, A., Podolsky, B., & Rosen N. (1935). Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete? Physical Review, 47, pp Hobson, A. (2013) Two-photon interferometry illuminates quantum state collapse. Physical Review A, 88, Hughes, R.I.G. (1992). The Structure and Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. Harvard University Press. 9

Measurement: still a problem in standard quantum theory

Measurement: still a problem in standard quantum theory Measurement: still a problem in standard quantum theory R. E. Kastner August 20, 2013 - xarqiv Abstract It is argued that recent claims by A. Hobson that there is no measurement problem are based on taking

More information

Quantum Entanglement. Chapter Introduction. 8.2 Entangled Two-Particle States

Quantum Entanglement. Chapter Introduction. 8.2 Entangled Two-Particle States Chapter 8 Quantum Entanglement 8.1 Introduction In our final chapter on quantum mechanics we introduce the concept of entanglement. This is a feature of two-particle states (or multi-particle states) in

More information

226 My God, He Plays Dice! Entanglement. Chapter This chapter on the web informationphilosopher.com/problems/entanglement

226 My God, He Plays Dice! Entanglement. Chapter This chapter on the web informationphilosopher.com/problems/entanglement 226 My God, He Plays Dice! Entanglement Chapter 29 20 This chapter on the web informationphilosopher.com/problems/entanglement Entanglement 227 Entanglement Entanglement is a mysterious quantum phenomenon

More information

228 My God - He Plays Dice! Schrödinger s Cat. Chapter 28. This chapter on the web informationphilosopher.com/problems/scrodingerscat

228 My God - He Plays Dice! Schrödinger s Cat. Chapter 28. This chapter on the web informationphilosopher.com/problems/scrodingerscat 228 My God - He Plays Dice! Schrödinger s Cat This chapter on the web informationphilosopher.com/problems/scrodingerscat Schrödinger s Cat Schrödinger s Cat Erwin Schrödinger s goal for his infamous cat-killing

More information

How does it work? QM describes the microscopic world in a way analogous to how classical mechanics (CM) describes the macroscopic world.

How does it work? QM describes the microscopic world in a way analogous to how classical mechanics (CM) describes the macroscopic world. Today Quantum Mechanics (QM) is used in the university and beyond on a regular basis: Chemical bonds NMR spectroscopy The laser (blue beam in Blue-ray player; red beam in a DVD player for example) The

More information

Introduction to Bell s theorem: the theory that solidified quantum mechanics

Introduction to Bell s theorem: the theory that solidified quantum mechanics Introduction to Bells theorem: the theory that solidified quantum mechanics Jia Wang Department of Chemistry, University of Michigan, 930 N. University Ave., Ann Arbor, MI 48109 (Received November 30,

More information

Quantum Mechanics: Interpretation and Philosophy

Quantum Mechanics: Interpretation and Philosophy Quantum Mechanics: Interpretation and Philosophy Significant content from: Quantum Mechanics and Experience by David Z. Albert, Harvard University Press (1992). Main Concepts: -- complementarity -- the

More information

4.1 Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Paradox

4.1 Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Paradox Chapter 4 Quantum Spookiness As we have seen in the previous chapters, many aspects of quantum mechanics run counter to our physical intuition, which is formed from our experience living in the classical

More information

COPENHAGEN INTERPRETATION:

COPENHAGEN INTERPRETATION: QUANTUM PHILOSOPHY PCES 4.41 Perhaps the most difficult things to understand about QM are (i) how to reconcile our common sense ideas about physical reality with phenomena such as entanglement, & (ii)

More information

ELEC4705 Fall Tom Smy. LECTURE 3 Fundamentals of Quantum Theory

ELEC4705 Fall Tom Smy. LECTURE 3 Fundamentals of Quantum Theory ELEC4705 Fall 2009 Tom Smy LECTURE 3 Fundamentals of Quantum Theory 1 Contents ELEC4705 Fall 2009 1 Lecture 3. Fundamentals of Quantum Theory 1 3.1. History of Quantum/Wave Mechanics 4 3.2. Wave-like

More information

The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics (Handout Eight) between the microphysical and the macrophysical. The macrophysical world could be understood

The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics (Handout Eight) between the microphysical and the macrophysical. The macrophysical world could be understood The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics (Handout Eight) 1. The Copenhagen Interpretation Bohr interpreted quantum theory as showing that there is a fundamental partition in nature, between the microphysical

More information

The nature of Reality: Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Argument in QM

The nature of Reality: Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Argument in QM The nature of Reality: Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Argument in QM Michele Caponigro ISHTAR, Bergamo University Abstract From conceptual point of view, we argue about the nature of reality inferred from EPR

More information

Superposition - World of Color and Hardness

Superposition - World of Color and Hardness Superposition - World of Color and Hardness We start our formal discussion of quantum mechanics with a story about something that can happen to various particles in the microworld, which we generically

More information

Lecture 2: Introduction to Quantum Mechanics

Lecture 2: Introduction to Quantum Mechanics CMSC 49: Introduction to Quantum Computation Fall 5, Virginia Commonwealth University Sevag Gharibian Lecture : Introduction to Quantum Mechanics...the paradox is only a conflict between reality and your

More information

On the role of Decoherence in Bohmian Mechanics

On the role of Decoherence in Bohmian Mechanics On the role of Decoherence in Bohmian Mechanics Mathematisches Institut LMU München June 8, 2009 My talk is based on my new book on Bohmian mechanics and on a new book coming out next year Sheldon Goldstein,

More information

The Measurement Problem of Quantum Mechanics Click to edit Master title style. Wells Wulsin SASS 24 September 2008

The Measurement Problem of Quantum Mechanics Click to edit Master title style. Wells Wulsin SASS 24 September 2008 The Measurement Problem of Quantum Mechanics Click to edit Master title style Wells Wulsin SASS 24 September 2008 Outline Invitation Stern-Gerlach experiment What is the measurement problem? Decoherence

More information

Does the ψ-epistemic view really solve the measurement problem?

Does the ψ-epistemic view really solve the measurement problem? Does the ψ-epistemic view really solve the measurement problem? Shan Gao Institute for the History of Natural Sciences, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China. E-mail: gaoshan@ihns.ac.cn. September

More information

Schrödinger in Nature and the Greeks

Schrödinger in Nature and the Greeks Schrödinger in Nature and the Greeks [... ] the scientist subconsciously, almost inadvertently, simplifies his problem of understanding Nature by disregarding or cutting out of the picture to be constructed

More information

Hugh Everett III s Many Worlds

Hugh Everett III s Many Worlds 236 My God, He Plays Dice! Hugh Everett III s Many Worlds Many Worlds 237 Hugh Everett III s Many Worlds Hugh Everett III was one of John Wheeler s most famous graduate students. Others included Richard

More information

Cosmology Lecture 2 Mr. Kiledjian

Cosmology Lecture 2 Mr. Kiledjian Cosmology Lecture 2 Mr. Kiledjian Lecture 2: Quantum Mechanics & Its Different Views and Interpretations a) The story of quantum mechanics begins in the 19 th century as the physicists of that day were

More information

Looking at Scripture with New Eyes: A Chance Conversation Between Faith and Science

Looking at Scripture with New Eyes: A Chance Conversation Between Faith and Science 1 Looking at Scripture with New Eyes: A Chance Conversation Between Faith and Science William K. Lewis Fairmont Presbyterian Church College Ministry Team One of the things I really enjoy about education

More information

The Collapse of the Wave Function

The Collapse of the Wave Function Chapter 7 The Collapse of the Wave Function At this point, it s worth taking a step back and reviewing where we are. We started with some observations about how electron spins function, and how it s very

More information

ON THE FAITHFUL INTERPRETATION OF PURE WAVE MECHANICS

ON THE FAITHFUL INTERPRETATION OF PURE WAVE MECHANICS ON THE FAITHFUL INTERPRETATION OF PURE WAVE MECHANICS JEFFREY A. BARRETT In the long version of his Ph.D. thesis, Hugh Everett III developed pure wave mechanics as a way of solving the quantum measurement

More information

Coins and Counterfactuals

Coins and Counterfactuals Chapter 19 Coins and Counterfactuals 19.1 Quantum Paradoxes The next few chapters are devoted to resolving a number of quantum paradoxes in the sense of giving a reasonable explanation of a seemingly paradoxical

More information

Closing the Debates on Quantum Locality and Reality: EPR Theorem, Bell's Theorem, and Quantum Information from the Brown-Twiss Vantage

Closing the Debates on Quantum Locality and Reality: EPR Theorem, Bell's Theorem, and Quantum Information from the Brown-Twiss Vantage Closing the Debates on Quantum Locality and Reality: EPR Theorem, Bell's Theorem, and Quantum Information from the Brown-Twiss Vantage C. S. Unnikrishnan Fundamental Interactions Laboratory Tata Institute

More information

Quantum Mechanics as Reality or Potentiality from A Psycho-Biological Perspective

Quantum Mechanics as Reality or Potentiality from A Psycho-Biological Perspective Quantum Mechanics as Reality or Potentiality from A Psycho-Biological Perspective F. K. Jansen 1 Abstract Quantum mechanics are generally interpreted as physical reality with superposition of wave functions,

More information

Q8 Lecture. State of Quantum Mechanics EPR Paradox Bell s Thm. Physics 201: Lecture 1, Pg 1

Q8 Lecture. State of Quantum Mechanics EPR Paradox Bell s Thm. Physics 201: Lecture 1, Pg 1 Physics 56: Lecture Q8 Lecture State of Quantum Mechanics EPR Paradox Bell s Thm Physics 01: Lecture 1, Pg 1 Question Richard Feynman said, [the double-slit experiment] has in it the heart of quantum mechanics;

More information

Bell s Theorem 1964 Local realism is in conflict with quantum mechanics

Bell s Theorem 1964 Local realism is in conflict with quantum mechanics Bell s Theorem 1964 Local realism is in conflict with quantum mechanics the most profound discovery in science in the last half of the twentieth century. For a technical presentation search Youtube.com

More information

Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox and Bell s inequalities

Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox and Bell s inequalities Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox and Bell s inequalities Jan Schütz November 27, 2005 Abstract Considering the Gedankenexperiment of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen as example the nonlocal character of quantum

More information

Max Planck, Nobel Prize in Physics and inventor of Quantum Mechanics said:

Max Planck, Nobel Prize in Physics and inventor of Quantum Mechanics said: Max Planck, Nobel Prize in Physics and inventor of Quantum Mechanics said: As a man who has devoted his whole life to the most clear-headed science, to the study of matter, I can tell you as a result of

More information

Quantum Mechanics: Stranger than we can imagine?

Quantum Mechanics: Stranger than we can imagine? Quantum Mechanics: Stranger than we can imagine? 1900: Kelvin announced that physics was basically solved except for two little clouds on the horizon. One cloud led to relativity, the other to quantum

More information

Enter Heisenberg, Exit Common Sense

Enter Heisenberg, Exit Common Sense Enter Heisenberg, Exit Common Sense W. Blaine Dowler July 10, 2010 1 Unanswered Questions The questions raised to date which still have not been answered are as follows: 1. The basic building blocks of

More information

PBR theorem and Einstein's quantum hole argument. Galina Weinstein

PBR theorem and Einstein's quantum hole argument. Galina Weinstein PBR theorem and Einstein's quantum hole argument Galina Weinstein Upon reading Einstein's views on quantum incompleteness in publications or in his correspondence after 1935 (the EPR paradox), one gets

More information

Quantum Mechanics: Observer and von Neumann Chain

Quantum Mechanics: Observer and von Neumann Chain Quantum Mechanics: Observer and von Neumann Chain Michele Caponigro ISHTAR, Bergamo University Abstract In this brief paper, we argue about the conceptual relationship between the role of observer in quantum

More information

Lecture 4. QUANTUM MECHANICS FOR MULTIPLE QUBIT SYSTEMS

Lecture 4. QUANTUM MECHANICS FOR MULTIPLE QUBIT SYSTEMS Lecture 4. QUANTUM MECHANICS FOR MULTIPLE QUBIT SYSTEMS 4.1 Multiple Qubits Next we consider a system of two qubits. If these were two classical bits, then there would be four possible states,, 1, 1, and

More information

Singlet State Correlations

Singlet State Correlations Chapter 23 Singlet State Correlations 23.1 Introduction This and the following chapter can be thought of as a single unit devoted to discussing various issues raised by a famous paper published by Einstein,

More information

Week 11: April 9, The Enigma of Measurement: Detecting the Quantum World

Week 11: April 9, The Enigma of Measurement: Detecting the Quantum World Week 11: April 9, 2018 Quantum Measurement The Enigma of Measurement: Detecting the Quantum World Two examples: (2) Measuring the state of electron in H-atom Electron can be in n = 1, 2, 3... state. In

More information

Lecture 13B: Supplementary Notes on Advanced Topics. 1 Inner Products and Outer Products for Single Particle States

Lecture 13B: Supplementary Notes on Advanced Topics. 1 Inner Products and Outer Products for Single Particle States Lecture 13B: Supplementary Notes on Advanced Topics Outer Products, Operators, Density Matrices In order to explore the complexity of many particle systems a different way to represent multiparticle states

More information

A Crucial Mistake in the Free Will Debate

A Crucial Mistake in the Free Will Debate A Crucial Mistake in the Free Will Debate Richard Johns Department of Philosophy University of British Columbia johns@interchange.ubc.ca January 19, 2005 There are usually considered to be three main views

More information

Quantum Physics & Reality

Quantum Physics & Reality Quantum Physics & Reality Todd Duncan Science Integration Institute (www.scienceintegration.org) & PSU Center for Science Education Anyone who is not shocked by quantum theory has not understood it. -

More information

Hardy s Paradox. Chapter Introduction

Hardy s Paradox. Chapter Introduction Chapter 25 Hardy s Paradox 25.1 Introduction Hardy s paradox resembles the Bohm version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox, discussed in Chs. 23 and 24, in that it involves two correlated particles,

More information

T he Science of. What exactly is quantum physics? Until the end of the nineteenth century, scientists thought

T he Science of. What exactly is quantum physics? Until the end of the nineteenth century, scientists thought T he Science of From radioactive bananas to cats that are both dead and alive at the same time, here s more about the real- life science in The Many Worlds of Albie Bright. Wait a minute, are bananas really

More information

The Mysteries of Quantum Mechanics

The Mysteries of Quantum Mechanics The Mysteries of Quantum Mechanics Class 5: Quantum Behavior and Interpreta=ons Steve Bryson www.stevepur.com/quantum Ques=ons? The Quantum Wave Quantum Mechanics says: A par=cle s behavior is described

More information

Card Appendix Quantum Concepts

Card Appendix Quantum Concepts 1 Physics 310 Card Appendix Quantum Concepts Table of Contents 0. Blackbody Radiation 2 3. Normalize 2 4. Angular Momentum 3 4. Hydrogen 4 5. Wavefunction 4 6. Photoelectric Effect 5 7. Lowering Operator

More information

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought experiment and Bell s theorem

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought experiment and Bell s theorem PHYS419 Lecture 0 The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought experiment and Bell s theorem 1 The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought experiment and Bell s theorem As first shown by Bell (1964), the force of the arguments

More information

Why the Difference Between Quantum and Classical Physics is Irrelevant to the Mind/Body Problem

Why the Difference Between Quantum and Classical Physics is Irrelevant to the Mind/Body Problem Why the Difference Between Quantum and Classical Physics is Irrelevant to the Mind/Body Problem Kirk Ludwig Department of Philosophy University of Florida Gainesville, FL 32611-8545 U.S.A. kludwig@phil.ufl.edu

More information

What does it feel like to be in a quantum superposition?

What does it feel like to be in a quantum superposition? What does it feel like to be in a quantum superposition? Shan Gao Institute for the History of Natural Sciences, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China. E-mail: gaoshan@ihns.ac.cn. December

More information

What Does Quantum Mechanics Suggest About Our Perceptions of Reality?

What Does Quantum Mechanics Suggest About Our Perceptions of Reality? What Does Quantum Mechanics Suggest About Our Perceptions of Reality? Quantum mechanics suggests that we perceive at most a tiny sliver of reality. Of course we already knew that! We knew that the visible

More information

Quantum reality. Syksy Räsänen University of Helsinki, Department of Physics and Helsinki Institute of Physics

Quantum reality. Syksy Räsänen University of Helsinki, Department of Physics and Helsinki Institute of Physics Quantum reality Syksy Räsänen University of Helsinki, Department of Physics and Helsinki Institute of Physics www.helsinki.fi/yliopisto 1 Quantum century Quantum mechanics (and quantum field theory) is

More information

The Relativistic Quantum World

The Relativistic Quantum World The Relativistic Quantum World A lecture series on Relativity Theory and Quantum Mechanics Marcel Merk University of Maastricht, Sept 24 Oct 15, 2014 Relativity Quantum Mechanics The Relativistic Quantum

More information

Honors 225 Physics Study Guide/Chapter Summaries for Final Exam; Roots Chapters 15-18

Honors 225 Physics Study Guide/Chapter Summaries for Final Exam; Roots Chapters 15-18 Honors 225 Physics Study Guide/Chapter Summaries for Final Exam; Roots Chapters 15-18 Chapter 15 Collapsing the Wave If a particle is in a quantum superposition state (that is, a superposition of eigenfunctions

More information

David Bohm s Hidden Variables

David Bohm s Hidden Variables ccxxii My God, He Plays Dice! David Bohm s Hidden Variables Hidden Variablesccxxiii David Bohm s Hidden Variables David Bohm is perhaps best known for new experimental methods to test Einstein s supposed

More information

On the origin of probability in quantum mechanics

On the origin of probability in quantum mechanics On the origin of probability in quantum mechanics Steve Hsu Benasque, September 2010 Outline 1. No Collapse quantum mechanics 2. Does the Born rule (probabilities) emerge? 3. Possible resolutions R. Buniy,

More information

Introduction to the strange world of Quantum Physics

Introduction to the strange world of Quantum Physics Introduction to the strange world of Quantum Physics Terminology Note: Quantum physics, quantum theory, quantum mechanics and wave mechanics all refer to the same field of study in physics. Quantum physics

More information

What is it like to be a quantum observer? And what does it imply about the nature of consciousness?

What is it like to be a quantum observer? And what does it imply about the nature of consciousness? What is it like to be a quantum observer? And what does it imply about the nature of consciousness? Shan Gao Research Center for Philosophy of Science and Technology, Shanxi University, Taiyuan 030006,

More information

Modern Physics notes Spring 2007 Paul Fendley Lecture 27

Modern Physics notes Spring 2007 Paul Fendley Lecture 27 Modern Physics notes Spring 2007 Paul Fendley fendley@virginia.edu Lecture 27 Angular momentum and positronium decay The EPR paradox Feynman, 8.3,.4 Blanton, http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/quantum/bells

More information

Delayed Choice Paradox

Delayed Choice Paradox Chapter 20 Delayed Choice Paradox 20.1 Statement of the Paradox Consider the Mach-Zehnder interferometer shown in Fig. 20.1. The second beam splitter can either be at its regular position B in where the

More information

3/10/11. Which interpreta/on sounds most reasonable to you? PH300 Modern Physics SP11

3/10/11. Which interpreta/on sounds most reasonable to you? PH300 Modern Physics SP11 3// PH3 Modern Physics SP The problems of language here are really serious. We wish to speak in some way about the structure of the atoms. But we cannot speak about atoms in ordinary language. Recently:.

More information

J = L + S. to this ket and normalize it. In this way we get expressions for all the kets

J = L + S. to this ket and normalize it. In this way we get expressions for all the kets Lecture 3 Relevant sections in text: 3.7, 3.9 Total Angular Momentum Eigenvectors How are the total angular momentum eigenvectors related to the original product eigenvectors (eigenvectors of L z and S

More information

DEEP METAPHYSICAL INDETERMINACY

DEEP METAPHYSICAL INDETERMINACY The Philosophical Quarterly June 2010 doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9213.2010.672.x The Scots Philosophical Association and the University of St Andrews DEEP METAPHYSICAL INDETERMINACY BY BRADFORD SKOW A recent

More information

The Foundations of Quantum Mechanics and The Limitations of Human Being

The Foundations of Quantum Mechanics and The Limitations of Human Being The Foundations of Quantum Mechanics and The Limitations of Human Beings Department of Mathematics 21 February 2011 Supported by NSF Quantum mechanics is very successful in computing quantities than can

More information

The paradox of knowability, the knower, and the believer

The paradox of knowability, the knower, and the believer The paradox of knowability, the knower, and the believer Last time, when discussing the surprise exam paradox, we discussed the possibility that some claims could be true, but not knowable by certain individuals

More information

Has CHSH-inequality any relation to EPR-argument?

Has CHSH-inequality any relation to EPR-argument? arxiv:1808.03762v1 [quant-ph] 11 Aug 2018 Has CHSH-inequality any relation to EPR-argument? Andrei Khrennikov International Center for Mathematical Modeling in Physics, Engineering, Economics, and Cognitive

More information

ReleQuant Improving teaching and learning in modern physics in upper secondary school Budapest 2015

ReleQuant Improving teaching and learning in modern physics in upper secondary school Budapest 2015 ReleQuant Improving teaching and learning in modern physics in upper secondary school Budapest 2015 Carl Angell Professor of physics education ReleQuant - Improving teaching and learning in quantum physics

More information

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought-experiment and Bell s theorem

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought-experiment and Bell s theorem PHYS419 Lecture 0 The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought-experiment and Bell s theorem 1 The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought-experiment and Bell s theorem As first shown by Bell (1964), the force of the arguments

More information

11/26/2018 Photons, Quasars and the Possibility of Free Will - Scientific American Blog Network. Observations

11/26/2018 Photons, Quasars and the Possibility of Free Will - Scientific American Blog Network. Observations Observations Photons, Quasars and the Possibility of Free Will Flickers of light from the edge of the cosmos help physicists advance the idea that the future is not predetermined By Brian Koberlein on

More information

Quantum theory appendix 4: Three options for the future on quantum theory

Quantum theory appendix 4: Three options for the future on quantum theory Quantum theory appendix 4: Three options for the future on quantum theory As we described earlier, to apply the method of physics in a box, we have to identify a subsystem of the world and consider it

More information

On The Mysterious Aspects of Quantum Mechanics

On The Mysterious Aspects of Quantum Mechanics On The Mysterious Aspects of Quantum Mechanics Noson S. Yanofsky 1 There are many aspects of quantum mechanics that are very different than the classical world. This paper looks at some of the most important

More information

ψ x=0,t =ψ x=l,t =0 ψ x,t = X x T t X x t t =X x 2 Something more about. Standing Waves Standing Waves Wave Function Differential Wave Equation X=L

ψ x=0,t =ψ x=l,t =0 ψ x,t = X x T t X x t t =X x 2 Something more about. Standing Waves Standing Waves Wave Function Differential Wave Equation X=L Something more about. Standing Waves Wave Function Differential Wave Equation Standing Waves Boundary Conditions: ψ x=0,t =ψ x=l,t =0 Separation of variables: X=0 sin(πx/l) sin(πx/l) sin(3πx/l) X=L Y Axis

More information

EPR Paradox and Bell Inequalities

EPR Paradox and Bell Inequalities Chapter 24 EPR Paradox and Bell Inequalities 24.1 Bohm Version of the EPR Paradox Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) were concerned with the following issue. Given two spatially separated quantum systems

More information

6.896 Quantum Complexity Theory September 9, Lecture 2

6.896 Quantum Complexity Theory September 9, Lecture 2 6.96 Quantum Complexity Theory September 9, 00 Lecturer: Scott Aaronson Lecture Quick Recap The central object of study in our class is BQP, which stands for Bounded error, Quantum, Polynomial time. Informally

More information

Quantum mechanics is an exquisitely well-verified theory of how our physical world operates

Quantum mechanics is an exquisitely well-verified theory of how our physical world operates A Unified Explanation of Quantum Phenomena? The Case for the Peer-to-Peer Simulation Hypothesis as an Interdisciplinary Research Program Marcus Arvan University of Tampa Abstract: In my 2013 article, A

More information

Instant Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Instant Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Instant Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Huy Khanh Hoang E-mail: hoang.huy.khanh@gmail.com We suggest a new interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, in which the system state vectors are identified with

More information

about Quantum Physics Bill Poirier MVJS Mini-Conference Lawrence Hall of Science July 9, 2015

about Quantum Physics Bill Poirier MVJS Mini-Conference Lawrence Hall of Science July 9, 2015 about Quantum Physics Bill Poirier MVJS Mini-Conference Lawrence Hall of Science July 9, 2015 Some Notable Quotes If we knew what we were doing, it wouldn't be called 'research Albert Einstein The paradox

More information

Odd Things about Quantum Mechanics: Abandoning Determinism In Newtonian physics, Maxwell theory, Einstein's special or general relativity, if an initi

Odd Things about Quantum Mechanics: Abandoning Determinism In Newtonian physics, Maxwell theory, Einstein's special or general relativity, if an initi Odd Things about Quantum Mechanics: Abandoning Determinism In Newtonian physics, Maxwell theory, Einstein's special or general relativity, if an initial state is completely known, the future can be predicted.

More information

Deep Metaphysical Indeterminacy

Deep Metaphysical Indeterminacy Deep Metaphysical Indeterminacy Bradford Skow Abstract A recent theory of metaphysical indeterminacy says that metaphysical indeterminacy is multiple actuality. That is, we have a case of metaphysical

More information

EPR Paradox Solved by Special Theory of Relativity

EPR Paradox Solved by Special Theory of Relativity EPR Paradox Solved by Special Theory of Relativity Justin Lee June 20 th, 2013 Abstract This paper uses the special theory of relativity (SR) to introduce a novel solution to Einstein- Podolsky-Rosen (EPR)

More information

The hybrid-epistemic model of quantum mechanics and the solution to the measurement problem

The hybrid-epistemic model of quantum mechanics and the solution to the measurement problem The hybrid-epistemic model of quantum mechanics and the solution to the measurement problem Jiří Souček Charles University in Prague, Faculty of Arts U Kříže 8, Prague 5, 158 00, Czech Republic jiri.soucek@ff.cuni.cz

More information

We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them.!

We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them.! PuNng Local Realism to the Test We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them.! - Albert Einstein! Day 39: Ques1ons? Revisit EPR-Argument Tes1ng Local Realism

More information

Entanglement swapping and retrocausation

Entanglement swapping and retrocausation Entanglement swapping and retrocausation Juliusz Doboszewski UJ, Cracow 25.09.2012 Foundations of Quantum Mechanics and Relativistic Spacetime, Athens jdoboszewski@gmail.com Juliusz Doboszewski (UJ, Cracow)

More information

Decoherence and The Collapse of Quantum Mechanics. A Modern View

Decoherence and The Collapse of Quantum Mechanics. A Modern View Decoherence and The Collapse of Quantum Mechanics A Modern View It s time to make decoherence mainstream QM is ~90 years old But it is still taught like the 1930s Modern textbooks still ignore measurement

More information

QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT AND ITS ASPECTS. Dileep Dhakal Masters of Science in Nanomolecular Sciences

QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT AND ITS ASPECTS. Dileep Dhakal Masters of Science in Nanomolecular Sciences QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT AND ITS ASPECTS Dileep Dhakal Masters of Science in Nanomolecular Sciences Jacobs University Bremen 26 th Nov 2010 Table of Contents: Quantum Superposition Schrödinger s Cat Pure vs.

More information

Critical Notice: Bas van Fraassen, Scientific Representation: Paradoxes of Perspective Oxford University Press, 2008, xiv pages

Critical Notice: Bas van Fraassen, Scientific Representation: Paradoxes of Perspective Oxford University Press, 2008, xiv pages Critical Notice: Bas van Fraassen, Scientific Representation: Paradoxes of Perspective Oxford University Press, 2008, xiv + 408 pages by Bradley Monton June 24, 2009 It probably goes without saying that

More information

Objective probability-like things with and without objective indeterminism

Objective probability-like things with and without objective indeterminism Journal reference: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 38 (2007) 626 Objective probability-like things with and without objective indeterminism László E. Szabó Theoretical Physics Research

More information

Laboratory 1: Entanglement & Bell s Inequalities

Laboratory 1: Entanglement & Bell s Inequalities Laboratory 1: Entanglement & Bell s Inequalities Jose Alejandro Graniel Institute of Optics University of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14627, U.S.A Abstract This experiment purpose was to study the violation

More information

Disjunctive facts and superposition of states

Disjunctive facts and superposition of states Disjunctive facts and superposition of states Berislav Žarnić Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences University of Split x y Φ&Φ 2014 7 8 July 2014, Split Overview 1 Motto 2 Methodological introduction:

More information

Unknowable Reality. Science, Mathematics and Mystery. Aleksandar I. Zecevic Dept. of Electrical Engineering Santa Clara University

Unknowable Reality. Science, Mathematics and Mystery. Aleksandar I. Zecevic Dept. of Electrical Engineering Santa Clara University Unknowable Reality Science, Mathematics and Mystery Aleksandar I. Zecevic Dept. of Electrical Engineering Santa Clara University The Unknowable and the Counterintuitive A fundamental question in the debate

More information

Paradoxes of special relativity

Paradoxes of special relativity Paradoxes of special relativity Today we are turning from metaphysics to physics. As we ll see, certain paradoxes about the nature of space and time result not from philosophical speculation, but from

More information

Chapter 24: A Brief Introduction to Quantum Theory

Chapter 24: A Brief Introduction to Quantum Theory Worldviews, by Richard Dewitt Chapter 24: A Brief Introduction to Quantum Theory Special and General Relativity fundamentally undermined Newtonian intuitions about space and time, but it fundamentally

More information

viii My God, He Plays Dice! Preface Preface

viii My God, He Plays Dice! Preface Preface viii The primary goal of this book is to revise and correct the history of Albert Einstein s contributions to quantum mechanics, which have been distorted for decades by the unfortunately biased accounts

More information

Physicists' Epistemologies of Quantum Mechanics

Physicists' Epistemologies of Quantum Mechanics Physicists' Epistemologies of Quantum Mechanics Raymond A. Hodges Physics Education Research Group University of Maryland College Park AAPT Summer Meeting Madison, Wisconsin August 4, 2003 Supported in

More information

146 Philosophy of Physics: Quantum Mechanics

146 Philosophy of Physics: Quantum Mechanics Superposition http://philosophy.ucsd.edu/faculty/wuthrich/ 146 Philosophy of Physics: Quantum Mechanics Quantum superposition: Setting things up David Z Albert, Quantum Mechanics and Experience, Harvard

More information

Alan Mortimer PhD. Ideas of Modern Physics

Alan Mortimer PhD. Ideas of Modern Physics Alan Mortimer PhD Ideas of Modern Physics Electromagnetic Waves Last Week Special Relativity General Relativity The Quantum World Index Planck s Law Atomic Structure and emission lines Matter waves Uncertainty

More information

A possible quantum basis of panpsychism

A possible quantum basis of panpsychism A possible quantum basis of panpsychism Gao Shan The Scientists Work Team of Electro-Magnetic Wave Velocity, Chinese Institute of Electronics -, NO. Building,YueTan XiJie DongLi, XiCheng District Beijing

More information

Lecture 12: Arguments for the absolutist and relationist views of space

Lecture 12: Arguments for the absolutist and relationist views of space 12.1 432018 PHILOSOPHY OF PHYSICS (Spring 2002) Lecture 12: Arguments for the absolutist and relationist views of space Preliminary reading: Sklar, pp. 19-25. Now that we have seen Newton s and Leibniz

More information

On the Present Status of Quantum Mechanics

On the Present Status of Quantum Mechanics Department of Mathematics UNAM, Mexico City, 24 September 2015 What does the cat example mean? It s often called a paradox, but that is too weak that sounds like get used to it. Basically, it s an argument:

More information

Counterfactuals in Quantum Mechanics

Counterfactuals in Quantum Mechanics 132 Counterfactuals in Quantum Mechanics Counterfactuals in Quantum Mechanics Lev Vaidman Counterfactuals in quantum mechanics appear in discussions of (a) nonlocality, (b) pre- and post-selected systems,

More information

EPR Paradox and Bell s Inequality

EPR Paradox and Bell s Inequality EPR Paradox and Bell s Inequality James Cross 2018-08-18 1 Introduction The field of quantum mechanics is practically synonymous with modern physics. The basics of quantum theory are taught in every introductory

More information

Quantum mechanics and reality

Quantum mechanics and reality Quantum mechanics and reality Margaret Reid Centre for Atom Optics and Ultrafast Spectroscopy Swinburne University of Technology Melbourne, Australia Thank you! Outline Non-locality, reality and quantum

More information

Unitary evolution: this axiom governs how the state of the quantum system evolves in time.

Unitary evolution: this axiom governs how the state of the quantum system evolves in time. CS 94- Introduction Axioms Bell Inequalities /7/7 Spring 7 Lecture Why Quantum Computation? Quantum computers are the only model of computation that escape the limitations on computation imposed by the

More information